Content Type: Article

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 22

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 22

    May, 2005

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. Annual Report by the US Trade Representative on Foreign IP Protection

    Section 301 of the US Trade Act of 1974 instructs the US Trade Representative (USTR) to identify territories where the rights of the US under any trade agreement are being violated. Where trading privileges exist with another territory ‘Special 301’ reviews are made of those trading partners lacking sufficient intellectual property protection such that they present a potential threat to US trade interests. Famously, the first bilateral stand off raised by the USTR on the issue of intellectual property was Indonesia. Because of raising the profile of Intellectual Property Rights as a political issue, negotiations at the World Trade Organisation resulted in the Trade Relating to Intellectual Property Rights agreement. Despite growing hostility to the use of IPRs as a political weapon, the USTR continues to target trading partners on a bilateral basis.

    2. UK Labour Party’s Intellectual Property Manifesto for the Digital Age

    The Labour Party have published their manifesto for the digital age.

    3. Spanish Authorities to Fight Piracy: Criminal Code Reform and Successes of Police Actions

    A widespread reform of the Spanish criminal code was initiated last October, which facilitated the prosecution of individuals committing criminal offences against intellectual property. The reform has been welcomed by SGAE (Sociedad General de Autores y Editores), and produced an increase in the actions by the Police to fight pirates belonging to criminal organisations. Last month Spain further strengthened its anti-piracy policies by approving a Comprehensive Intellectual Property Defence Plan.

    Copyright

    4. France: A Step Backwards for Digital Rights Management Implementation

    In the continuous battle between exclusive rights and exceptions to copyright infringement, the French Court d’Appel de Paris found against Universal Pictures Video France, who had adopted technological measures designed to impede copying from DVD to VHS format.

    5. BBC Creative Licence on Archive Copyright

    An online initiative by British broadcasters that will allow people to download, manipulate and share film, TV and radio archives has been launched.

    6. Dutch Industry Anxious Over Proposed MP3 Tax

    A proposed tax on MP3 players could become law in the Netherlands with possibly grave implications for the Dutch music industry and international copyright law.

    Patents(click the header at left to view all of the Patent case notes)

    7. Regulatory Data Protection for Medicinal Products: R (on the Application of Merck Sharp & Dohme Ltd) v the Licensing Authority

    This case is another round of battle between the innovators who seek strong protection for regulatory data submitted for marketing authorisation of their products that are developed through years of research, development and clinical trials, and generic companies who wish to market a product by relying on such clinical trials. In this decision, the High Court had rejected an attempt by Merck to give a restricted meaning to Article 10 (1) (a) (iii) of Directive 2001/83/EC or to refer the matter to ECJ for further clarification.

    8. When is a Non-EEA Marketing Authorisation an EEA Marketing Authorisation?

    In recent joined cases, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) considered a lacuna in the law in respect of Supplementary Protection Certificates (SPC). SPCs are granted based on the first marketing authorisation in a European Economic Area (EEA) state. Switzerland is not a member of the EEA, therefore technically marketing authorisations granted there should not be recognised. However, questions arose due to the fact that Lichtenstein, which is a member of the EEA, recognised Swiss marketing authorisations.

    Trademarks

    9. WIPO Member States Agree Basic Text for Revised Trade Mark Law Treaty

    There has been significant progress in updating the Trademark Law Treaty which aims to streamline the administrative procedures for national and regional trade mark applications and the maintenance of trade mark registrations. The World Intellectual Property Organisation Standing Committee has agreed on a text to be proposed for the Revised Trademark Law Treaty.

    10. Final Rulings Adopted in WTO Geographical Indications Dispute

    On 20 April 2005, the Dispute Settlement Body of the WTO adopted the Panel report on the European Communities’ protection of trade marks and geographical indications for agricultural products and foodstuffs.

    11. Adidas v Marca at the Court of Appeal in The Netherlands

    On 29 March 2005, a Dutch Court of Appeal delivered its judgment in Adidas v Marca. The case centres around Marca’s use of a two-stripe design on clothing, which, Adidas claims, allegedly infringes its own three-stripe emblem trade mark.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Angela Adrian, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Tina Loverdou, Maria Mercedes, James Mitchiner, Lois Muraguri, Rajesh Sagar, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 21

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 21

    April, 2005

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. New WIPO Information Tool on UDRP Designs

    On 23 March 2005, the World Intellectual Property Organisation announced that its Arbitration and Mediation Center has created and made available a new information tool providing an overview of trends in decisions taken under the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy.

    2. Annual Enforcement Report Released

    On 31 March 2005, the UK Patent Office released its 2004 IP Crime Strategy Annual Enforcement Report.

    Copyright

    3. Google in AFP Copyright Dispute

    The French news agency AFP has sued Google for including links to AFP’s story leads, headlines and graphics on the “Google News” site without permission. Google are now in the process of removing all AFP content from Google News.

    4. Russian MP3 Site ‘Legal’

    A Russian website accused of dealing in unauthorised digital copies of recorded music will not face the courts, as Russian copyright law does not cover digital files.

    5. BPI Victory Against File Sharers

    The British Phonographic Industry has recorded a fresh victory against illegal music downloads with its recent conclusion of 23 settlements. This and other similar initiatives have been pursued to deter file sharers as well as encourage the use of legitimate forms of music distribution over the Internet.

    Patents

    6. EU Ministers Endorse Proposal For a Directive on Computer-Implemented Inventions

    On 7 March 2005, EU ministers endorsed the proposal for a Computer- Implemented Inventions Directive. The adoption of the draft Directive was highly controversial, especially after the EU Commission rejected requests from European MPs to amend it. In his statement to the European Parliament, the European Commissioner for Internal Market and Services remarked that any substantial change to the proposal should now be agreed during the second reading of the text.

    7. Best Before’ Entitlement to Patents

    The Court of Appeal recently delivered a decision on entitlement to patents or parts of patents, that is, the right to apply for a patent. Within the specific context of employees’ inventions, the extent to which one can have a claim of entitlement to someone else’s patent was considered.

    Trademarks

    8. O2 Holdings V Hutchinson 3G

    The High Court declined to refer a number of questions raised by the Claimant to the European Court of Justice.

    9. Gillette: Spare Parts and the Consumer Trade Mark

    The issue of whether disposable razors are made up of spare parts resulted in the clearest confirmation yet of the role of trade mark law in consumer protection. In a system of undistorted competition benefiting the consumer, trade mark owners must look to their consumers to justify protecting the integrity of their marks. This extends protection beyond the classic test of confusion but the level of protection is likely to vary from industry to industry, with greater uncertainty for the owner.

    10. L’0real V OHIM

    On 16 March 2005, the Court of First Instance delivered its judgment in L’Oreal SA v OHIM (Case T-112/03). The Court dismissed an appeal against the Fourth Board of Appeal’s decision in L’Oreal’s FLEXI AIR application. The Court held that the Board of Appeal was entitled to adopt a decision that rejected the request for proof of genuine use. It re-affirmed that the word signs FLEX and FLEXI AIR were similar at visual, phonetic and conceptual levels and stated that national laws of Member States governing likelihood of confusion between a trade mark applied for and an earlier national mark were fully harmonised.

    11. Shark’ Is Not ‘HAI’: Trade Mark Registration for Linguistic Equivalents

    The Court of First Instance ruled that an earlier trade mark registration does not per se operate as a bar for refusal of subsequent application for trade mark registration or its linguistic equivalent. The conceptual similarity between marks arising from the same meaning could be ignored if, on global assessment of aural, visual and conceptual features, the translated word does not create any likelihood of confusion in the mind of relevant public. This test is more easily satisfied in cases where the relevant public could see and pronounce the names of the marks at the time of purchasing the branded products.

    12. Nike Wins Spanish Trade Mark Battle

    After litigation lasting ten years, the Civil Division of the Spanish Supreme Court has ruled in favour of Nike against Cidesport, the former proprietors of a Spanish trade mark consisting of the word NIKE and a depiction of the goddess Samothracia.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Claudio Chiarolla, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Florian Leverve, Tina Loverdou, Maria Mercedes, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 20

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 20

    March, 2005

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. Norway Proposes New Digital Copyright Law

    The proposed new digital law will make it illegal for anyone to circumvent or overcome security codes on DVD and CDs or provide software to do so. However, in the case of private use, the owners will be allowed to circumvent the codes if they are making copies to be used in the same medium.

    2. The Game Group PLC V Garth Sumpter

    Nominet UK’s Dispute Resolution Service has given its decision in relation to the domain name dispute concerning the domain name Game.co.uk. The issue for determination was whether a change of use by the Defendant of the domain name Game.co.uk had become an abusive registration because it was being used in a manner which took unfair advantage of, or was unfairly detrimental to, the Complainant’s rights.

    Copyright

    3. Harry Potter in the US Army

    Representatives of Harry Potter author, JK Rowling, are investigating a Harry Potter look-alike comic published by the US Army, featuring characters similar to those in the Harry Potter books and films.

    4. Italian DJ Receives Record Fine for MP3 Piracy

    Italy imposed a record fine on a DJ found in possession of a large number of unauthorised copies of records, mp3 and video clips. The material was used in a well-known nightclub in Rieti, near Rome.

    5. New DVD Anti-Piracy Measures

    In continuing the crack down on DVD piracy, new anti-piracy measures have been devised by Macrovision, the copy protection company, to make it more difficult for DVDs to be copied.

    Designs

    6. Dyson Vacuums Up the Secondary

    The vacuum cleaner company Dyson has successfully defended various design rights in spare parts for its machines against the defendant Qualtex. This case demonstrates the power of the unique unregistered design right in affecting access to a secondary market in practice.

    Patents

    7. Mayne Pharma V Pharmacia Italia

    This case concerned the construction of patent claims following the recent House of Lords’ judgment in Kirin Amgen.

    8. Obvious to Try? Think Again!

    This is the message the Court of Appeal gave in the case of Saint Gobain PAM SA v Fusion Provida Limited & others, when it held that in order for an obviousness attack to succeed, the prior art should provide more than a mere possibility of inclusion of something within the research programme of a person skilled in the art. It should be more-or-less self-evident from the prior art that what is being tested ought to work; and to assess such a scenario, historical considerations cannot be omitted and will form an integral part of this evaluation process.

    9. Consultation on Compulsory Licensing of Pharmaceutical Patents for Export to Countries with Public Health Problems

    A consultation paper has been issued by the UK Patent Office regarding the Commission’s Regulation proposal allowing European drug manufacturers to produce generic versions of patented drugs for export to WTO Members in need of essential medicines. The purpose of this consultation is to enable the views of perspective users of the compulsory licensing system and all other interested parties to be taken into account in the Community legislative process.

    Trademarks

    10. Feta Cheese Protection Reaches ECJ

    The Danish and German governments have appealed against the European Commission’s decision to grant protected designation of origin status to feta cheese. If the Commission’s decision is allowed to stand, from 2007 onwards, cheese producers outside Greece, including Britain’s only feta cheese producer, will no longer be able to describe their cheeses as feta.

    11. UK Trade Mark Decision-Appeal on Registering Famous Names on Posters

    The appeal focused on the question of registration of the names of celebrities on goods such as posters. Sections 3(1)(b) and (c) of the Trade Marks Act 1994 were considered. The appeal was dismissed on the ground that that the mark in question designated the characteristics of the goods concerned and should be excluded from registration.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott, Will & Emery UK LLP would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Angela Adrian, Professor Michael Blakeney, Claudio Chiarolla, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Florian Leverve, Tina Loverdou, Maria Mercedes, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • International News: Focus on Intellectual Property

    ARTICLE

    International News: Focus on Intellectual Property

    February 1, 2005

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Summary

    In This Issue
    International Practice Head David Ryder addresses current issues affecting businesses.

    An International Approach to International Dispute Resolution
    By John Reynolds

    As the global nature of commerce increases, the means to resolve the disputes that inevitably arise must change.

    New Rules Address Due Diligence Required for Export Transactions
    By David J. Levine

    U.S. exporters must exercise due diligence.

    Changing Directors’ Liabilities Under the New Italian Company Law
    By Oreste Marchini

    The new Italian Company Law has been introduced in response to recent financial scandals. It makes company directors more responsible in performing their assigned duties.

    Akzo/Akcros Update

    Private Equity Opportunities in Italy
    By Andrea De Pieri and Olimpio Stucchi

    The structure and climate of the Italian economy are providing valuable new opportunities for private equity investors.

    Public-Private Partnership Programs in Brazil—Will They Trigger a New Wave of Investments?
    By René Gelman and Adriano Chaves with contributions by Stuart Berkson

    PPP programs have become a top priority for the federal government and a new law establishing rules of implementation was passed at the end of last year.

    Employers—Use Your Plan Deficit to Your Advantage
    By Steven Hull

    An employer that does not seek to negotiate with its pension plan trustees and its employees is wasting a huge opportunity.

    Spain Reforms Its Insolvency Legislation
    By Xavier Ruiz

    The new legislation came into force in September 2004 and constitutes a sweeping change of the previous

    FOCUS ON: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

    Employees’ Invention Rights in Europe and the U.S.
    By Dr. Boris Uphoff, Rohan Massey, Clare Sellars, Margherita Barié, Cathryn Campbell and Kathrin Tauber

    When employees produce inventions, questions arise regarding ownership of rights. The legal situation varies from country to country and your business may be exposing itself to risk.

    Trademarks Go Global
    By Dr. Thomas Hauss and Dr. Jonas Ewert

    Over the last 18 months, three major events have changed the legal environment for trademark owners. What is significant about these events and how can they benefit trademark owners?

    Patent Infringement as an Unfair Trade Practice: Section 337 Proceedings before the U.S. International Trade Commission
    By Shamita D. Etienne and Jack Q. Lever

    There is clear evidence that some companies importing goods into the United States are utilizing unfair trade practices. What can a patent holder do?

    Shielding IP License Agreements from the Sword of European Antitrust Litigation
    By Duncan Curley

    Challenges to your IP license agreement may result in the agreement being rendered void and unenforceable and there may also be a financial penalty.

    Tax and IP in the UK—Maximizing Use of IP Rights to Obtain Fiscal Advantages
    By Laurence Cohen

    For the first time, the UK has become an attractive place from which to exploit IP Rights.

    VoIP: How to Regulate a Transformative Communications Technology
    By Dr. Andreas Boos, Shirley S. Fujimoto, David D. Rines and Dr. Ralf Weisser

    The telecoms sector is being transformed by a new technology—Voice over Internet Protocol which supplies low-cost voice communications.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    David J. Levine

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Dr. Thomas Hauss

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 18

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 18

    January, 2005

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. The ECJ Interprets the Database Sui Generis Right

    The ECJ handed down its first decisions interpreting the sui generis database right as provided in the Database Directive 1996/9/EC. The decisions provide important clarification of the law, specifically, the definition of database, the scope of the sui generis right and the test for infringement.

    Copyright

    2. IIPA Recommends That Poland Remains on Special 301 Watch List

    In November, the International Intellectual Property Alliance (IIPA) responded to the Section 301 Committee’s request for comments regarding Poland’s review in the 2004 Special 301 process which recommended that Poland remain on the Special 301 Watch List. IIPA stressed the need for Poland to properly implement the new Optical Disc decree and improve enforcement against hard goods piracy and internet piracy.

    3. Belgium, Finland and Sweden Fail to Implement Copyright Directive

    At the beginning of 2004 the Commission referred eight Member States to the European Court of Justice for non-communication of the national implementing measures regarding the 2001 Copyright Directive (2001/29/EU). The Court has now given the first three decisions against Belgium, Finland and Sweden. Six more cases are pending.

    Patents

    4. EU Software Patents Directive Hangs in Balance After Poland Withdraws Support

    The Polish government announced that it would not support the current draft directive on software patents rendering uncertain the directive’s future.

    5. A Proposal On Leave To Leave To Perform Certain Experiments In Patent Litigation

    The Court of Appeal commented on the design of experiments aimed at supporting an obviousness attack. The Court criticised the approach taken and made recommendations for the future control over experiments which could have a significant effect over the management of future litigation.

    6. Human Rights and Patents ITP V Coflexip Stena Offshore

    This decision of the First Division, Inner House, Court of Session of Scotland has shed light on the relationship between human rights and patents. In doing so the Court had held that the European Convention on Human Rights cannot trump the decision of the Board of Appeal under the European Patent Convention even though the same is alleged to have been given in violation of the human rights of a patent holder.

    Trade Marks

    7. Peak Holding AB V Axilon-Elinor AB

    The case deals with the interpretation of Article 7(1) of the First Council Directive 89/104/EEC of 21 December 1988, specifically the exhaustion of rights conferred by a trade mark within the European Economic Area (EEA) in circumstances whereby the goods are offered for sale within the EEA and later withdrawn.

    8. Lowden v Lowden Guitar Co Ltd

    On 17 November 2004, the Chancery Division of the High Court of Justice delivered a judgment in Lowden v Lowden Guitar Company Limited, an appeal against a trade mark revocation decision of the Registrar.

    9. Denial of Domain Name Transfer: BAA Loses Request For gatwick.com

    WIPO Panel reached a decision on the issue raised by BAA against Mr Larkin, owner of the disputed domain name gatwick.com. The dismissal of this claim represents a review of the registration of geographical names, as well as leaving room for discussion of “reverse domain name hijacking” and passing off.

    10. Anheuser-Busch v Budejovicky Budvar

    The case concerns the conflict between a registered trade mark and an unregistered trade name. Under certain conditions, a trade name may be used in spite of being identical with a registered trade mark, and be regarded as a prior right in spite of being unregistered.

    11. Distinctiveness in Registering 3d ctm: Frischpack v Ohim

    The case concerns the conflict between a registered trade mark and an unregistered trade name. Under certain conditions, a trade name may be used in spite of being identical with a registered trade mark, and be regarded as a prior right in spite of being unregistered.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney (Supervisor), Estelle Derclaye, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley (Coordinator), Tina Loverdou, Maria Mercedes, James Mitchiner, Lois Muraguri, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 17

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 17

    November, 2004

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. The House of Lords Wakes Up: Kirin Amgen v Hoechst

    The House of Lords has given a detailed explanation of the relationship between the European Patent Convention and national laws and the applicability of the doctrine of equivalents, as well as product-by-process claims.

    2. Sabaf SpA v MFI: Ascertaining Inventiveness in case of Aggregation of Inventions

    The House of Lords laid down the test to be followed for ascertaining the inventive step, in case of an aggregation or juxtaposition of inventions within a single patent. It was also held that the seller of goods situated outside UK, who sells goods to a party in UK and makes arrangements for its importation to UK, cannot be held to be liable as an importer for infringement of the patent.

    Copyright

    3. First Victory in Unprecedented Legal Battle Against Music Files Uploaders in the UK

    The British Phonographic Industry Limited has been granted a court order forcing internet service providers to disclose the names and addresses of 28 music files-swappers, in an unprecedented case in the UK. This represents the commencement of a litigation programme against the major uploaders of music files in this country.

    4. Moscow Court Dismisses Copyright Lawsuit Filed by Authors Opposing Free Online Library

    This judgment in favour of the digital library once again highlights the issue of the liability of online service providers for the publication of digital copyright works. The defendants were hosts and were found not to be liable for the actions of the online libraries. The authors should have filed the suit against the author of the digital library.

    5. “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire” – Vulnerable to Plagiarism?

    The issue in this case is whether the format of the television show “Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?” infringes the copyright in pre-existing works by three individuals. The High Court’s ruling, dismissing two applications for summary judgment issued by the show’s producers, effectively paves the way for two of the writers to challenge the show’s format by seeking to prove copyright infringement in their own works.

    6. S.A.. EMI Music France v Association CLCV

    On 30 September 2004, the Court of Appeal of Versailles confirmed an earlier decision of the Court of Nanterre which found that EMI Music France had to inform consumers, by means of labelling, that there could be limitations to their ability to listen to CDs or make copies of them.

    Patents

    7. Celltech v Medimmune: Interpreting Jurisdiction Clause in IP Licencing Agreements

    The present Court of Appeal judgment is relevant to the interpretation of jurisdiction clauses incorporated into intellectual property licensing agreements. It demonstrates that the courts will interpret jurisdiction clauses broadly with reference to the commercial objectives of the parties.

    8. Pharmacia Italia v German Patent Office: Better Treating People Before Animals

    This judgment addressed the way the duration of a Supplementary Protection Certificate is to be calculated within the Community. More specifically, the meaning of the term ‘medicinal product’ in determining the first marketing authorisation was debated. The question was whether ‘medicinal product’ referred only to human use or whether veterinary purpose was also included.

    Trade Marks

    9. KWS Saat v OHIM

    This case considered the registration of a single colour as a trade mark.

    10. Distinctive Character: Absolute Ground of Refusal for Advertising Slogans as Community Trade Mark? ECJ in OHIM v Erpo Möbelwerk

    The Court of Justice held that the OHIM Third Board of Appeal applied incorrect criteria in its judgment regarding distinctive character within the meaning of Article 7(1)(b) of Regulation No 40/94, namely the absence of an additional element of imagination or an additional element of originality.

    11. ECJ Sheds Light on Shape Trade Marks

    In Mag Instrument Inc v OHIM, the European Court of Justice has provided more precise guidance on the requirements shape marks must meet in order to be registered as trade marks.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney (Supervisor), Sofia Casimiro, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley (Coordinator), Florian Leverve, Tina Loverdou, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The House of Lords Wakes Up

    ARTICLE

    The House of Lords Wakes Up

    October 27, 2004

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Summary

    After a decade of refusing to take any patent cases, the House of Lords took 2; Kirin Amgen v Hoechst Marion Rousell and SABAF v MFI. Judgment was handed down respectively on 21 October and 14 October 2004. The former is more important than the latter. In each case the judgment was unanimous, and the leading judgment was given by Lord Hoffman who was formerly a Patents Court Judge and has been involved as a barrister in IP cases, and is still actively involved in IP professional issues.

    In Depth

    There Is No European Doctrine of Equivalents

    The Court reviewed the decisions and writings of the leading judges in Germany and the Netherlands, and concluded that there is no room in the European Patent Convention and conformed national laws for a doctrine of equivalents. The message is quite clear; the claim means what is says and you cannot construe into the claim what is not there. The claim states what the patentee claims as his monopoly, and what is not claimed is disclaimed.

    It is not permissible, and the Court observed this to be the normal position in the UK, Germany and the Netherlands, to look at the prosecution file, or to second guess what was in the mind of the draughtsman in his negotiations with the patent office.

    The decision then set out the basis on which claims are to be construed having regard to Section 69 EPC and its Protocol. It held first how they are not to be construed; that is by taking the old English common law approach of narrow or forensic construction, or by taking the old continental European approach of the claims in which the claims were construed as point of departure in determining the inventive achievement disclosed by the specification as a whole.

    Instead the Court said that claims are to be construed by reference to the words used, giving them the widest meaning they are reasonably capable of having, but no wider. They are to be given a purposive construction in accordance with the construction of all documents including statutes and contracts. Construction of a claim has to be viewed through the eyes
    of the skilled address. The question to be asked is what the claims mean to the skilled addressee.

    Normally the answer will come back; exactly what they say, but there occasions, often but not exclusively where numerical or geometrical limits are used, where the claim means an approximation to those limits to the skilled reader. In the classic English case of Catnic Componentswhich was about the interpretation of the vertical in a claim to the construction of a steel lintel for reinforcing door and window openings, that word was to be construed through the eyes of a builder or constructor and not through the eyes of a mathematician. The Court observed that most of the cases where strict language of the claims has not been observed relate to quasi mathematical limits, where the word “about” can be interpolated when construing how a man skilled in the art would construe the word or phrase.

    Product by Process Claims

    Under Article 64(2) EPC, embodied in English law as section 60(3) Patents Act 1977, it is an infringement to import a product made directly by the process claimed. The House of Lords said that product by process claims are unnecessary. If they claim only the product when made by the claimed process they add nothing to the process claim. If they seek to claim more widely than the process then the claim has to be examined for sufficiency to see if it is enabled by the specification. Product by process claims are only acceptable where the process makes a new product because it is some material way different from what was previously known. But where that is so the product is new and can and should be claimed as such.

    A new process for a known product does not make the product as such new, only the process, and any product by process claim which is dressed up to claim the product as such will be bad for lack of novelty.

    What Are the Lessons?

    The Kirin Amgen case puts a premium on good patent drafting. It is better to have fewer patents of good width than more patents of narrow width. It is worth having some wide claims which might be held invalid but where the litigation process and the existence of the claims might be a deterrent to competition. Where the pendulum has swung is that claim drafting should now concentrate on two series of claims; a narrow series to the strict invention and a wider series, which might not survive protracted litigation to exploring the boundaries of litigation. What is clear across Europe is that the patentee which has drafted his or her claims too narrowly can no longer rely on the court coming to his rescue with the doctrine of equivalents, however dressed up.

    This issue is particularly applicable to the pharmaceutical and biotech industries, where monopolies are sought to be extended by new processes of manufacture. If the product of the process is not new, then the process should be claimed widely as well as narrowly, and if the product is new, it should be claimed as such.

    It is worth pointing out that only two claims were in issue in Kirin-Amgen; 19 and 26, and although they were both found invalid and not infringed, the rest of the patent (the narrow claims) survived. The effect of the litigation appears to have been to keep the defendant off the market until about two months before the patent expired, so even though invalid and not infringed, the wide claims had real practical commercial utility.

    Mere Collection

    The House of Lords also pronounced in SABAF on the issue of mere collocation. It held that where a claim contains integers which are themselves known and used for the purpose for which they are known and there is no claimed synergy from the combination, the claim will be invalid as being obvious. In the claim in that case, it was to a domestic stove burner with three known features which were put together for the first time. Each feature was performing the function for which it was known, and there was no synergy claimed between the features. This was held to be a mere collocation, and unpatentable.

    Infringement by Importation

    The House of Lords also examined the question as to when a person is an importer for the purpose of the statutes on infringement, Patents Act 1977 section 60(1). It held that this work has its common sense meaning; that is to say the person who brings the goods into the UK. It is a question of title and legal possession. The person who makes the arrangements to ship the goods is not the importer unless he or she also retains title when the goods enter the UK.

    After a 10 year drought of cases from the English House of Lords on patent issues, there have been two important cases; the Kirin-Amgencase affects patenting strategy and litigation strategy, and needs to be considered as a seminal case. SABAF warns that if known integers are put together without some synergistic advantage, the patent is unlikely to survive
    an obviousness attack.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 16

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 16

    October, 2004

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Thomas Hauss

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 15

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 15

    September, 2004

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. UK Launches National Intellectual Property Crime Stratety

    Piracy and counterfeiting costs the economy billions of pounds and undermines the success of many companies. In the UK, the estimated loss to the economy has doubled over the last five years. On 10 August 2004, Industry Minister, Jacqui Smith, launched a blueprint to crackdown on the trade in fake goods as she unveiled the first National Intellectual Property Crime Strategy.

    2. Protection of Geographical Indications and Designations of Origin In The European Union

    Geographical Indications and Designations of Origin are protected at both Community and international level. Patricia Müller Chosco, an intern in McDermott Will & Emery’s Munich office outlines the framework of protection and considers the development of the law.

    Copyright

    3. Sony Playstation Copy Protection Upheld: Extra-Territorial Arguments Rejected

    The UK’s Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 was amended in 2003 to provide stronger protection against circumvention of the ‘technological measures’ used by copyright owners to prevent unauthorised copying. Mr Justice Laddie considered the provisions in a case brought by Sony.

    4. Lambretta Clothing Company v Teddy Smith

    The infringement of copyright in a design document and the interpretation of s.51 Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA) which provides defences to infringement of design documents and models, are addressed in this recent decision of the Court of Appeal.

    5. EU Commission Launches Consultation To Harmonise Copyright and Related Rights Legislation

    The European Commission announced that it has launched consultations to review EU legislation on copyright and related rights in order to improve the operation of copyright law and to safeguard the functioning of the Internal Market.

    Patents

    6. The First Anit-Suite Injunction In a Patent Case Before the Dutch Court of the Hague

    The President of the Dutch Court of the Hague granted an injunction, the first of its kind, against Mendinol, effectively preventing them from bringing any further actions for patent infringement against Cordis. Various summary requests for interim injunctions had been brought by Mendinol against Cordis in relation to its family of patents.

    7. Sandoz GMBH V Roche Diagnostic GMBH

    The main issue in this case related to the determination of inventiveness. It addressed the definition of the person skilled in the art and his relation to prior art.

    8. Patent and Design Rights In Ultraframe V Eurocell: One and One Makes Eleven

    This case presents a perfect example whereby a party failing to win its battle for patent infringement claim, secured a ruling in its favour for infringement of its design rights. Apart from emphasising the strategic importance of using two IP rights for litigation, this case also encapsulates interpretation of various concepts of design rights and related exceptions.

    9. Patents Act Receives Royal Assent

    The UK Patents Act 2004 has received Royal Assent. The 2004 Act updates the Patents Act 1977, bringing the UK patents system in line with the revised European Patent Convention. It also introduces measures designed to assist in the enforcement of patent disputes between patent proprietors and third parties.

    Trade Marks

    10. Coffee Visits CFI In Consumer Interest

    Through this preliminary ruling the Court of First Instance gave a harmonious interpretation of Article 28 of EC and Article 2 of Directive 1999/4/EC relating to coffee extracts and chicory extracts, and of Article 18 of Directive 2000/13/EC on the approximation of the laws of the Member States relating to the labelling, presentation and advertising of foodstuffs.

    11. ECJ Allows Substituion Of Opponent In CTM Dispute

    In Gerolsteiner Brunnen GmbH & Co v OHIM – Kerry Spring the Court of First Instance considered whether the new owner of a trade mark, which is subject to a Community trade mark opposition, may be substituted as a party to the opposition once the trade mark has changed hands.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Alison Firth, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, YunJoo Lee, Florian Leverve, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 14

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 14

    June, 2004

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

    1. In The UK New Legislation Extends The Right To Opt-Out Of Telephone Marketing To Corporate Subscribers

    The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) (Amendment) Regulations 2004 come into force on 25 June 2004. They extend The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 and enable corporate subscribers to register their desire not to receive unsolicited telephone calls for direct marketing purposes.

    2. The IP Value of Business Plans: Protection for the Entrepreneur

    A business plan is rarely thought of as being valuable because of the protectable IP rights contained and embodied in it. While it is usually treated as confidential and disclosed through a non disclosure agreement, it is usually considered as the vehicle to get money and not intrinsically valuable in its own right. However, the issue of value was recently shown in the English case of Ball v Druces and Attlee (a firm).

    3. Hungarian IP Law: Beyond National Frontiers After EU Accession

    Harmonisation of intellectual property rights in new member countries has been a hotly debated and eagerly awaited consequence of EU enlargement. Hungary has recently updated its law relating to Trademark and Design in line with its commitment to the treaty of accession. Other new member states like Lithuania are also undertaking statutory revisions to fulfil their treaty obligations.

    4. Griggs v Evans: Are Foreign IPRs Subject To Equities Recognised By The English Courts?

    For the first time, the High Court has addressed an important point of private international law concerning its jurisdiction to order the assignment of foreign copyrights that are subject to equities under English law. This case serves as a reminder that intellectual property rights are creatures of national law, and should be treated as such in the course of commercial negotiations. Nevertheless, by holding that the court has jurisdiction to order the assignment of all foreign copyrights subject to equities, this decision will come as a relief to those commissioning copyright works in the UK.


    COPYRIGHT

    5. Collective Society Of Music In The Information Society

    The European Commission has warned collecting societies that their so-called Santiago Agreement, which aims at simplifying the licensing of music to be used online by allowing them to grant “one-stop shop” copyright licenses, may be in breach of European Union competition rules.

    6. Irish Copyright Act Amended To Prevent Infringement Action Against National Library

    Ireland recently amended its copyright legislation to clarify that literary and artistic works may be displayed in public without infringing the author’s copyright. The change came in response to threats by James Joyce’s estate that it was considering bringing an infringement action against the National Library of Ireland if the library went ahead with a display of various manuscripts written by Joyce as part of celebrations to mark the centenary of Bloomsday.


    PATENTS

    7. EPO Revokes Myriad Breast Cancer Patent

    The opposition division of the European Patent Office has decided to revoke a patent, which had been granted to Myriad Genetics in 2001, relating to a method for diagnosing a predisposition for breast and ovarian cancer on the grounds that it did not meet the requirements of the European Patent Convention.

    8. Commission Welcomes Council Agreement On Directive On Computer-Implemented Inventions

    The Council of Ministers of the European Union has agreed a compromise over the Directive on computer-implemented inventions. However, important differences remain between the positions of the Council and European Parliament.

    9. Celltech v Medimmune: ‘Infringement’ In German Patent Law Defined by English Courts

    This case explains and formulates the precise scope of the test that a Court would adopt in determining the issue of patent infringement under the German law, if applicable in English proceedings. The Court, assisted by expert witnesses, accepted the “test of infringement” as laid down by German Supreme Court in the case of Formstein and Custodial II.

    10. The End Of The Italian Torpedo

    The Supreme Court of Italy has rejected the so-called Italian Torpedo as a way to tie-up cross-border patent infringement litigious with the Italians courts.

    11. Kambly SA Spécialités de Bisuits Suisses v Intersnack Knabber-Gebäck GmbH & Co KG

    This case, which started with a trade mark application in 1989 for the mark Goldfish, in English and German, and which went under opposition in about 1998, is an example of a case where nothing went right for the opponent to the registration of the mark.


    TRADE MARKS

    12. Violin-Maker’s Descendant Wins Case To Protect Stradivari Name

    In a test case, a descendant of the violin-maker Antonio Stradivari has persuaded an Italian court to order an estate agent to stop using the name Stradivari. She is now threatening similar legal action against anybody who uses the Stradivari name.

    13. Coco De Mer v Chanel

    In a trade mark dispute over bottled perfume, Coco de Mer, named after an exotic Seychelles palm tree, failed in their appeal against the refusal of the Registrar of Trade Marks in the UK to register the mark COCO DE MER in a number of classes of goods, including class 3 (perfumery, essential oils, cosmetics).


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Angel Adrian, Lucas Arrivillaga, John Cahir, Malcolm Langley, YunJoo Lee, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights