Content Type: Article

  • Texas Court Blocks New Federal Overtime Rule

    Texas Court Blocks New Federal Overtime Rule

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Texas Court Blocks New Federal Overtime Rule

    November 23, 2016

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Nov. 22, 2016, Judge Amos L. Mazzant III of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas issued a preliminary injunction temporarily preventing the U.S. Department of Labor (“DOL”) from implementing and enforcing the DOL’s final rule increasing the minimum salary level necessary to qualify for the executive, administrative and professional exemptions under the Fair Labor Standards Act. The injunction prevents the new rule — which was set to take effect on Dec. 1, 2016 — from taking effect.

    As we discussed in a previous Alert, on May 18, 2016, the DOL issued a final rule that increased the salary level for the executive, administrative and professional exemptions from $455 per week ($23,660 per year) to $913 per week ($47,476 per year) and the minimum salary level for the exemption for “highly compensated employees” from $100,000 to $134,004 per year. The final rule did not change the duties tests for the executive, administrative and professional exemptions or the minimal duties test for “highly compensated employees.” Judge Mazzant found that the new rule’s “significant increase to the salary level creates essentially a de facto salary-only test” which “supplants the duties test” for the executive, administrative and professional exemptions. Judge Mazzant therefore held that the DOL exceeded its authority in issuing the new rule because it was contrary to congressional intent. As a result, Judge Mazzant issued an injunction blocking the new rule from taking effect nationwide.

    Commentators have opined that a successful appeal of Judge Mazzant’s ruling by the DOL prior to Jan. 20, 2017, is unlikely. Absent such an appeal, the Trump administration could instruct the DOL to cease defending the rule in any legal actions.

    Effect on New York Employers

    For New York employers, the injunction means that, for the time being, the minimum salary necessary to qualify for the “highly compensated employee” exemption will remain at $100,000 and at $455 per week for the professional exemption.

    New York, however, has always required a higher minimum salary threshold for employers that use the executive and administrative exemptions. Currently, the minimum salary threshold for these exemptions is $675 per week ($35,100 per year). In conjunction with New York’s minimum wage increase that will take effect on Dec. 31, 2016, the New York State Department of Labor recently proposed increasing the minimum salary thresholds for such exemptions. Similar to the minimum wage increases, the salary thresholds will depend on employer size and location. The proposed salary thresholds for New York City employers, which are expected to be adopted next month, are:

    • Large employers in New York City (11 or more employees):
      • $825 per week ($42,900 per year) on and after Dec. 31, 2016
      • $975 per week ($50,700 per year) on and after Dec. 31, 2017
      • $1,125 per week ($58,500 per year) on and after Dec. 31, 2018
    • Small employers in New York City (10 or fewer employees):
      • $787.50 per week ($40,950 per year) on and after Dec. 31, 2016
      • $900 per week ($46,800 per year) on and after Dec. 31, 2017
      • $1,012.50 per week ($52,650 per year) on and after Dec. 31, 2018
      • $1,125 per week ($58,500 per year) on and after Dec. 31, 2019

    Employers should review employees’ salaries in December of each year to ensure that that no adjustments are needed to maintain the exemptions. Note that, in addition to being paid the requisite salary level, employees must still perform the duties required for the executive and administrative exemptions to apply.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Holly H. Weiss, Scott A. Gold and Adam B. Gartner.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Holly H. Weiss

    Retired Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam B. Gartner

    Special Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • A Walk Around Trump’s, GOP’s Tax Plans For HNW Individuals

    ARTICLE

    A Walk Around Trump’s, GOP’s Tax Plans For HNW Individuals

    November 18, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Carol Harrington, Ellen Harrison and Carlyn McCaffrey wrote this bylined article on tax moves possible under the new President and Congress. Noting that “tax reform is one of the central components of Donald Trump’s platform,” the authors wrote that “continued Republican control of [Congress] makes it likely that at least some combination of the Trump Tax Plan and the House Republicans’ Plan will become part of our tax law sometime next year,” affecting such issues as estate tax repeal and an itemized deductions cap.

    In depth
    Authors

    Carol A. Harrington

    Senior Counsel

    Chicago

    Ellen K. Harrison

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Carlyn S. McCaffrey

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Revised Uniform Unclaimed Property Act Finalized for State Enactment—Legislative Drafting Notes and Interpretative Comments Added

    Revised Uniform Unclaimed Property Act Finalized for State Enactment—Legislative Drafting Notes and Interpretative Comments Added

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Revised Uniform Unclaimed Property Act Finalized for State Enactment—Legislative Drafting Notes and Interpretative Comments Added

    November 18, 2016

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The fourth iteration of a uniform unclaimed property act—entitled the Revised Uniform Unclaimed Property Act (RUUPA or Act)—has been finalized by the Uniform Law Commission for state enactment. The new Prefatory Note, Legislative Notes, and Comments components offer further explanatory guidance on the Act.

    In depth

    Years in development, with thousands of pages of comments submitted by interested parties, the fourth iteration of a uniform unclaimed property act—entitled the Revised Uniform Unclaimed Property Act (RUUPA or Act)—has been finalized by the Uniform Law Commission (ULC) for state enactment. The version now available includes a Prefatory Note, Legislative Notes, (Notes) and Comments (Comments) components. The Prefatory Note is an overview of the history of unclaimed property laws and the process and issues relating to this new act. Legislative Notes are directions to state legislatures as to how to conform elements of the Act to specific state requirements—such as when a provision is optional in the Act, or where a provision references a federal law and a state is prohibited from incorporating another law by reference. Comments explain the drafters’ interpretations and intent of the statutory language.

    Practice Note: These Notes are often considered legislative history or explanatory guidance by state agencies and courts tasked with interpreting the statutory language.

    Prefatory Note

    RUUPA’s Prefatory Note provides a history of unclaimed property concepts and the previous uniform acts, a summary of the current status of unclaimed property laws in the states, an account of relevant terms, an explanation of the goals of unclaimed property laws and a description the stakeholders. Oddly, the one stakeholder group not specifically mentioned is actual owners of the property. The Prefatory Note also explains the significant areas of dispute: look-back period for audits; estimation methods in audits; and application of the “derivative rights” doctrine. The Note addresses the lack of a “business-to-business” (B2B) exemption in the Act, despite rigorous advocacy by the holder community. The Note explains:

    “Achieving the proper balance between . . . competing interests has been difficult. B2B provisions have not been incorporated into this act. However, states that have a B2B exemption will be able to keep it if they want to, and those who do not have or want a B2B exemption, will be free to leave it out without offending the goal of achieving substantial uniformity.”

    Practice Note: The failure to include at least a placeholder for a B2B exemption in the Act is a significant disappointment to holders. Reference to this exemption in the Comments at least legitimizes the exclusion and provides support for its adoption by states.

    Highlights of RUUPA Section Comments

    • Definition of “Holder”

    One Comment provides an extensive discussion of whether there can be more than one Holder—an issue that continues to be controversial under current law. The Comment clears up some of this controversy by noting:

    “Where one party has a direct legal obligation to the owner of the property, and another party has possession of funds associated with the property and an obligation to hold it for the account of, or to pay or deliver it to, the owner solely by virtue of a contractual relationship with the party who is directly obligated to the owner, but who has not assumed direct liability to the owner, it is the party who is directly obligated to the owner who is the holder for purposes of the act.”

    (Emphasis added). An example is provided in the context of an issuer of stock or bonds and provides that it is the issuer not the transfer agent that is the holder. In contrast, the Comment explains that when “a corporation sells assets to another corporation and the acquiring corporation affirmatively assumes liability for obligations of the selling corporation for certain liabilities associated with the acquired assets, the acquiring corporations becomes the applicable ‘holder’ of the assumed obligations.”

    Practice Note: The use of the term “affirmatively” in the Comment is important in asset deals. Sometimes state administrators argue that if the purchaser acquired bank accounts or other assets as part of the deal, and such assets could hypothetically be tied to the seller’s unclaimed property liability, this is enough to shift the liability to the purchaser. This Comment suggests that the acquirer must “affirmatively” assume liability, which suggests something more than an inference from the transfer of related assets.

    • Loyalty Programs

    RUUPA provides an exemption for loyalty programs for which no consideration was exchanged. The Comment on the issue specifically addresses an issue raised by a commissioner from the floor at the final ULC meeting at which the Act was adopted, regarding programs that allow purchases of loyalty points. In response to this question, a Comment explains:

    “Some loyalty programs permit consumers to purchase additional rewards for direct monetary consideration. The burden would be on the issuer of cards under such programs to establish that unredeemed card balances for which exemption is claimed do not include balances for which the cardholder paid any direct monetary consideration.”

    Practice Note: This interpretation is a good result. There was some concern (fueled by comments from state representatives) that any ability to purchase loyalty points would taint an entire loyalty account and result in even points for which no consideration was paid being subject to classification as remittable abandoned property. The Comment does not provide how the burden of establishing which balances qualify for the exemption is satisfied by the issuer. Holders should consider their options for doing this, such as segregating points; adopting a policy that paid points are used first and a program for tracing such points; or considering mathematical models to estimate which points are paid and which are gratis.

    • Scope of Covered Property

    Another Comment notes that “unless specifically excluded, all intangible property is within the coverage of this Act.”

    Practice Note: This Comment could cause mischief in the future as new types of property are created through technology and other business model advances.

    • Merchandise credits and similar items

    Whether merchandise credits are property subject to the Act is an option specifically left up to the individual states. The Comment to the section addressing presumptions of abandonment addresses these credits and provides:

    “This section also covers consumer credits owed on consumer transactions such as returns of merchandise, cancellation of layaways, and various kinds of deposits. The existence and amounts of such credits will of course be dependent on the terms of the contract between the older and the consumer. However, in-store credits for returned merchandise are included, unless expressly excluded in the Act.”

    (Emphasis added).

    Practice Note: This Comment is confusing because it specifically provides for reliance on contract terms—which typically limits the use of the credit to purchasing merchandise or services and prohibits redemption for cash. Such credits may also include a period in which the credit is valid. However, the Comment goes on to say that such merchandise credits are property covered by the Act unless specifically excluded. It is not clear why the Comment would reference the importance of the contract terms and then in the next sentence apparently negate their relevance.

    • ERISA Pre-Emption

    Another Comment specifically addresses the issue of ERISA pre-emption of state unclaimed property laws. The Comment describes the various cases and US Department of Labor guidance on this issue. The Comment notes “there may be a valid distinction between assets held in a defined contribution plan where each participant’s portion is held separately and those held in defined benefit plan where the assets are held in a pool or fund out of which funds are withdrawn as needed, and excess funds may be returned to the plan sponsor.”

    Practice Note: The Comment does not mention a recent US Supreme Court case that could have significant repercussions on states’ rights to audit ERISA related assets. The Comment also is only in the Act’s section addressing tax-deferred retirement accounts, but there are other types of employee welfare plans with similar issues.

    • Securities

    Regarding the deemed abandonment of securities, a Comment clarifies some ambiguous language in the Act. The Act states that “[a]t and after the time property is presumed abandoned under this [act], any other property right or interest accrued or accruing from the property and not previously presumed abandoned is also presumed abandoned.” The Comment makes it clear that this provision is “not intended to mean that a security is presumed abandoned as a result of a dividend payment being presumed abandoned, nor does it mean that the underlying bond will be presumed abandoned merely because an interest payment with respect to the bond is presumed abandoned.”

    • Life Insurance

    Significant controversy has persisted over when life insurance proceeds become abandoned and the extent of the obligations of an insurer to determine whether benefits have become payable. A Comment addressing “knowledge of death” explains that a new Model Act being developed by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners may be substituted for the RUUPA life insurance provisions. The Comment also notes that several of the RUUPA provisions are consistent with another Model Act created by the National Conference of Insurance Legislatures.

    • Place of Transaction Priority Rule

    A Comment makes it abundantly clear that:

    “a newly added provision recognize[is] that, if property is specifically exempt as unclaimed property under the laws of the state of last known address of the owner, or that of the holder’s domicile, then the state in which the transaction giving rise to the property occurred must recognize the higher priority state’s affirmative exemption of the property and cannot take custody of the property because to do so would not give Full Faith and Credit to the laws of a state with a higher constitutional priority to claim the property.”

    Practice Note: This is a significant development. In states that adopt this provision, businesses like retailers that utilize gift card management companies can now rely on the rules in the management company’s state of incorporation rather than worrying that the state of transaction would apply a different rule (which was possible under the 1995 Act but subject to litigation).

    • Administrator’s Burden of Proof

    Another Comment notes that a section addressing a state administrator’s burden of proof to establish its right to custody of property is “an expansion of the concept of the administrator’s burden of proof . . . this Act acknowledges that the burden of proof as to all items of property is on the administrator.”

    Practice Note: It will be very interesting how this plays out in an audit!

    • Record Retention

    The record retention Comment explains that the provision “does not require the holder to obtain the address of the owner.” It specifically notes: “For example, a record of the address of the purchaser or donee of a gift certificate often is not obtained.”

    • Audit

    The Comment to the compliance examination section notes that “one of the dual purposes of this act is the collection of revenue.” As a result, the Comment finds that in determining the scope of an audit, reference may be to cases “holding that it is not an unreasonable search [under the Fourth Amendment] to require taxpayers to produce their books and records.”

    Practice Note: Reference merely to “books and records” can be problematic because this is such a broad term and allows auditors to go on extensive phishing expeditions. For example, most auditors assert the right to review all books and records, even those records that pertain to owners with addresses in states not participating in an audit. This can be particularly problematic when the records demanded include protected confidential information, such as information under HIPAA.

    • Holder’s Failure to Maintain Records

    Practice Note: Under the 1995 Act, use of estimation as a result of failure to maintain records was characterized as a “penalty” rather than merely an audit methodology. Some states took the position that if they were not the state of domicile, they could nevertheless impose a penalty for failure to keep records and measure that penalty by estimated unremitted abandoned property. RUUPA seems to say that only one state can use estimation. The Comment suggests that estimation is a penalty only in the sense that it may overstate the holder’s actual liability. The Comment also suggests that only the second priority state is entitled to estimated property. While citing to Temple-Inland, the Comment does not reconcile the suggestion in that case that addresses be extrapolated back as well as value.

    Conclusion

    The art of crafting the Revised Uniform Unclaimed Property Act has been a tremendous task. Thanks should be given to all of the drafting committee members and to the ULC Reporter, Charlie Trost. While we do not agree with all of the choices that were made in finalizing the Act, the commissioners put in tremendous unpaid hours and put up with a lot of forceful advocates from both sides of the fence. The result is an Act that addresses many of the modern unclaimed property issues.

    See everyone in 2036 for the next Revised Uniform Unclaimed Property Act drafting process!

    Authors

    Stephen P. Kranz

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Third Circuit Enforces Post-Acceleration Make-Whole Premium

    Third Circuit Enforces Post-Acceleration Make-Whole Premium

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Third Circuit Enforces Post-Acceleration Make-Whole Premium

    November 18, 2016

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit held on Nov. 17, 2016 that a debtor’s refinancing of its first and second lien notes during its Chapter 11 case triggered the obligation to satisfy the “make-whole” payments contemplated to be more than $431 million by at least one of the indentures. In re Energy Future Holdings Corp., No. 16-1351, 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 20601, at *3, 7 (3d Cir. Nov. 17, 2016) (“Energy Future”). Reversing the lower courts, the Third Circuit held that the debtors had effectuated optional redemptions entitling the lenders to receive their contractual make-whole payment despite the automatic acceleration of the notes upon the bankruptcy filing. Id. at *13-17. This decision may have a profound impact on Energy Future Holdings’ “E-side” reorganization plan because of the huge liability now imposed on the debtors.[1] The decision is also at odds with recent cases finding that so-called “make-whole premiums” are only due if the governing indenture clearly provides for them.[2]

    Facts

    The Energy Future debtors had entered into separate indentures, each governed by New York law, for their first-priority secured notes (“First Lien Notes”) and second-priority secured notes (“Second Lien Notes,” and collectively, the “Notes”). Id. at *4-5. The First Lien Indenture required the debtors to pay a redemption price of 100 percent of the outstanding principal balance plus the “Applicable Premium” (the make-whole) if the First Lien Notes were redeemed at the debtors’ option before Dec. 1, 2015. Id. at *3. The Second Lien Indenture similarly required a make-whole payment if the debtors made an optional redemption prior to May 15, 2016 or March 1, 2017 (depending on the maturity of the notes redeemed). Id. at *4. Each indenture provided for automatic acceleration of the debt upon the borrower’s bankruptcy filing. Id. at *4-5.

    Seeking to take advantages of lower interest rates, the debtors disclosed in an 8-K filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission their intention to file Chapter 11 petitions and refinance their outstanding notes “without paying any make-whole amount.” Id. at *5. Six months later, the debtors commenced their Chapter 11 cases in Delaware, and thereafter sought and obtained bankruptcy court approval to obtain post-petition financing to refinance the First Lien Notes and a portion of the Second Lien Notes without paying the make-whole premiums. Id. at *5-7. The indenture trustees for each of the First Lien Notes and Second Lien Notes sued, asserting an entitlement to the make-whole premiums.

    Lower Courts

    The bankruptcy court held that the debtors’ bankruptcy filing had automatically accelerated the Notes, so that the bankruptcy filing date became the new maturity date for the Notes. In re Energy Future Holdings Corp., 527 B.R. 178, 191-95 (Bankr. D. Del. 2015); In re Energy Future Holdings Corp., 539 B.R. 723, 729-733 (Bankr. D. Del. 2015). Relying on recent make-whole decisions from other circuits, the court found that the post-acceleration repayment of the Notes was not an “optional redemption” and that the indentures did not include “clear and unambiguous” language requiring payment of the make-whole following acceleration. Id. The district court affirmed. In re Energy Future Holdings Corp., No. CV 15-1011, 2016 WL 1451045 (D. Del. April 12, 2016).

    Decision

    Optional Redemption of Notes

    The Third Circuit first posed three specific questions regarding the First Lien Notes: (1) was there a redemption; (2) was it optional; and (3) if yes to both, did it occur before Dec. 1, 2015?[3] Energy Future, at *13.

    First, the court found that New York and federal law deem a “redemption” to include repayments of debt occurring both prior to or after maturity. Id. at *13-14. Thus, the refinancing of the First Lien Notes was a redemption. Id. at *14.

    Second, the refinancing was optional because the debtors had voluntarily sought Chapter 11 protection and could have chosen to reinstate the Notes rather than paying them off. Id. at *14-15. The court also noted the debtors’ statements in its SEC filings that outlined their intention to redeem the Notes despite being “under no obligation” to do so. Id. at *15. Further, the court said the debtors redeemed the Notes “over the Noteholders’ objection.” Id. at *16.

    Third, the repayment of the First Lien Notes had occurred prior to Dec. 1, 2015, the trigger date in the indenture. Id.

    The Third Circuit then rejected the debtors’ argument that the acceleration provision in the indenture conflicted with its optional redemption provisions. Id. at *16-19. According to the court, the two sections “simply address different things.” Id. at *16. Moreover, the holding of In re AMR Corp., 730 F.3d 88 (2d Cir. 2013) was inapplicable because the indenture in that case explicitly said that upon acceleration, the make-whole would not become due. Id. at *17. [4]

    Second Lien’s Entitlement to Make-Whole

    While the above reasoning also applied to the Second Lien Notes, the court reasoned that the Second Lien Indenture’s make-whole provision was even more “explicit” because the acceleration clause provided that “all principal of and premium, if any, … ” became immediately due and payable upon the bankruptcy filing.[5] Id. at *19-20. Relying on the Momentive decisions out of the Southern District of New York, [6] the debtors argued that the reference to “premium, if any,” was not “specific enough” to require payment of the make-whole upon acceleration, but the Third Circuit said there was no reason to “demand such exactness.”[7] Id. at *20.

    The burden was on the debtors, not the noteholders, to make the indenture language clearer, noted the court. Id. at *29. If the debtors wanted their “duty to pay the make-whole on optional redemption to terminate on acceleration of its debt,” they should have made it clear that the acceleration language primed the optional redemption provisions. Id.

    “Redemption” versus “Prepayment”

    The Third Circuit also rejected the debtors’ argument that “courts must close their eyes to make-whole provisions once a debt’s maturity has accelerated.” Id. at *21. Instead, it relied heavily on NML Capital v. Republic of Argentina, in which the New York Court of Appeals held that the borrower had to continue to make interest payments on its debt after acceleration and maturity. 952 N.E.2d 482, 492 (N.Y. 2011) (“NML Capital”). As the NML court explained, while “acceleration advances the maturity debt of the debt … [it was] unaware of any rule of New York law declaring that other terms of the contract not necessarily impacted by acceleration … automatically cease to be enforceable after acceleration.” NML Capital, at 492. Thus, reasoned the Third Circuit, the “optional redemption” provision applied “no less following acceleration of the Notes’ maturity than it would to a pre-acceleration redemption.” Energy Future, at *23-24.

    The Third Circuit differentiated between a “prepayment,” which “could not take effect after the debt’s maturity” and a “redemption,” which “would be unaffected by acceleration of a debt’s maturity.” Id. at *25. Thus, “if parties want a ‘prepayment’ premium to survive acceleration and maturity, they must clearly state it.” Id. at *27. Because nothing in the acceleration language of the indentures “negate[d] the premium … [b]y avoiding the word ‘prepayment’ and using the term ‘redemption’ … the make-whole would apply without regard to the Notes’ maturity.” Id.

    The Third Circuit rejected the debtors’ further argument that the make-whole was “in substance a prepayment premium,” instead giving effect to the “‘words and phrases’ the parties chose.” Id. The court also distinguished the Northwestern case[8] relied on by the debtors, for in that case, the lender had foreclosed on his collateral and sought a prepayment premium. In Energy Future, though, the Noteholders had not sought immediate payment. Energy Future, at *28.

    Criticism of Momentive

    The Third Circuit also criticized the Momentive decisions, finding them to be unpersuasive. Id. at *21. The indentures in the Momentive case had also required payment of a make-whole upon the occurrence of an optional redemption (not a prepayment) before a particular date. Id. at *26. The Momentive courts held that the words “premium, if any,” were not specific enough to require payment of a make-whole. Id. at *20. The Third Circuit disagreed, finding that “the result in Momentive conflicts with that indenture’s text and fails to honor the parties’ bargain.” Id. at *21. The Momentive decision is currently on appeal in the Second Circuit. In re MPM Silicones, L.L.C., No. 15-1682.

    Takeaways

    The Third Circuit gave a clear warning to borrowers who think Chapter 11 will help them avoid their obligations to pay make-whole premiums. As the court noted, a different outcome may result if the make-whole is characterized as a “prepayment” (as opposed to a “redemption”). Further, given lower court decisions like Momentive, drafting a clear right to a post-acceleration make-whole is still a lender’s best bet.

    Authored by Adam C. Harris, Lawrence V. Gelber, Michael L. Cook and Lucy F. Kweskin.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Energy Future Holdings’ “E-Side” plan of reorganization, whose confirmation hearing is scheduled to begin Dec. 1, 2016, requires the make-whole obligations be disallowed prior to the effective date. See No. 14-10979 (Bankr. D. Del.) [DKt. No. 9612].

    [2] See, e.g., In re MPM Silicones, LLC, No. 14-22503, 2014 WL 4436335, at *13 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Sept. 9, 2014), aff’d, 531 B.R. 321 (S.D.N.Y. 2015); In re Calpine Corp., 2010 WL 3835200, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 15, 2010) (breach of no-call provision was unenforceable after bankruptcy filing accelerated debt and plain language of debt instruments did not provide for payment of premiums after acceleration).

    [3] Like the lower courts, the Third Circuit presumed the debtors were solvent and did not “consider whether insolvency might have affected [the Debtors’] obligations.” Id. at *8-9.

    [4] The indenture trustees had also sought stay relief to rescind the acceleration of the debt, which the bankruptcy court denied. Id. at *6, 8,9. Because it had already held that the noteholders were entitled to the make-whole, the Third Circuit did not address rescission. Id. at *30.

    [5] In contrast, the First Lien Indenture provided that, upon the bankruptcy filing, “all outstanding Notes” would automatically become due and payable. Id. at *4.

    [6] In Momentive, the court denied payment of a make-whole premium upon a voluntary note redemption after the notes were automatically accelerated by virtue of the borrower’s bankruptcy filing. In re MPM Silicones, LLC, No. 14-22503, 2014 WL 4436335, at *13 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Sept. 9, 2014), aff’d, 531 B.R. 321 (S.D.N.Y. 2015). Absent clear and unambiguous language to the contrary, the acceleration had advanced the maturity date so that the debt repayment was not an elective redemption. Id. The decision is currently on appeal in the Second Circuit.

    [7] EFIH had argued the make-whole would only be payable post-acceleration if more specific language had been used such as “a premium owed under section 3.07” or a specific reference to the “Applicable Premium” and “Optional Redemption.” Id. at *20.

    [8] Nw. Mut. Life Ins. Co. v. Uniondale Realty Assocs., 816 N.Y.S.2d 831, 836 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 2006) (“Northwestern”).


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Adam C. Harris

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • McDermott International Legal Highlights November 2016

    ARTICLE

    McDermott International Legal Highlights November 2016

    November 2016

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • FDA Hosts Public Meeting on Off-Label Communications

    FDA Hosts Public Meeting on Off-Label Communications

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FDA Hosts Public Meeting on Off-Label Communications

    November 17, 2016

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently held a two-day public meeting on Manufacturer Communications Regarding Unapproved Uses of Approved or Cleared Medical Products (off-label communications), which offered insight into the areas on which FDA may focus forthcoming (and long-awaited) guidance on off-label communications.

    In depth

    The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently held a two-day public meeting on Manufacturer Communications Regarding Unapproved Uses of Approved or Cleared Medical Products (off-label communications), which offered insight into the areas on which FDA may focus forthcoming (and long-awaited) guidance on off-label communications.

    As discussed in our pre-meeting commentary, FDA convened the public meeting to obtain public input as it develops draft guidance on the communication of off-label information. A broad array of stakeholders, including manufacturers, trade organizations, payers, and consumer safety and patient advocates, offered comments at the meeting and responded to questions from the agency. As outlined below, several themes emerged from the meeting:

    Factors Influencing Standards for Off-Label Communications

    During the meeting, the FDA and various stakeholders identified and discussed several factors that may be relevant when assessing the extent to which manufacturers should be permitted to disseminate off-label information. In particular, FDA questioned whether the audience or recipient of information; the nature, quality and source quality of information; the nature of the disease or condition; and/or who evaluates communications should be considered when establishing standards for off-label communications.

    Audience or Recipient

    Payers, health care providers, and patients are all potential recipients of off-label information.

    Given the relative sophistication of the payer audience, increased payer access to off-label information seemed relatively non-controversial. To this end, the agency’s questions appeared to be aimed at articulating the boundaries of permissible communication—e.g., what types of data payers need to make decisions, and how far in advance payers need information before product roll-out—as opposed to whether such communication should occur.

    Section 114 of the Food and Drug Administration Modernization Act of 1997 (FDAMA) (Pub. Law No. 105-115), which amended Section 502(a) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA), permits manufacturers to provide payers and formularies health economic information directly relating to a drug’s approved indication for formulary decision making. While the Section 114 pathway has not been widely used, commenters expressed an interested in a revised safe harbor that would allow manufacturers to convey clinical information and health economic information regarding unapproved indications to payers and formularies to advance the same purposes, i.e., to allow population-level decision-making related to disease burden and overall cost.

    Considerably more discussion surrounded the parameters for disseminating such information to health care providers. Some commenters supported relaxed agency standards that would facilitate the dissemination of off-label information to trained medical professionals. Other commenters, however, questioned whether providers have the time and/or expertise required to digest and understand novel clinical data. Commenters further questioned whether manufacturer-driven communications were the correct vehicle to provide such information to providers, given the potential for manufacturers to focus solely on favorable information. Other commenters noted, however, that manufacturers may be able to more quickly identify patterns of successful off-label use of their medical products, allowing them to notify health care providers that they may consider the off-label use as a viable treatment option for a particular condition.

    Few commenters explicitly discussed the provision of off-label information to patients, and the provision of information to patients did not appear to be a priority for industry. Certain commenters noted, however, that the availability of truthful, non-misleading off-label information—particularly in patient populations for which all or virtually all treatments are used off-label (e.g., pediatric cancers)—could benefit the public health by, for the first time, giving patients an institutional resource to access such data.

    Nature, Quality and Source of Information

    Commenters and the FDA suggested that the nature, quality and source of scientific information may also be relevant considerations. For example, the agency and/or commenters explicitly considered:

    • Whether studies that are peer-reviewed should have different requirements for dissemination than those that are not
    • Whether peer-reviewed publications adequately disseminate clinically relevant data on off-label uses, or if there is a need for manufacturer participation to effectively disseminate such materials
    • Whether the peer-review process is a sufficient control on the quality of evidence available to payers, providers and patients
    • Whether data from clinical trials that constitute a higher level of evidence (e.g., randomized controlled trials) should be treated differently than information from lower-quality study designs (e.g., retrospective reviews, case reports)

    Several presenters remarked that limiting dissemination to published peer-reviewed studies limits access to quality clinical evidence that may, for whatever reason, not have been published in the clinical literature. While FDA expressed concerns regarding the transparency of clinical information that had not undergone the peer review process, it appears open to a regulation defining “valid scientific evidence” that parallels the device regulation, 21 C.F.R. § 860.7, potentially expanding communication of information even in the absence of well-controlled investigations.

    The agency asked several questions about criteria for judging “weak” or “incomplete” versus “complete” evidence in the absence of clinically significant results, i.e., objective or widely accepted thresholds for statistical or practical significance. The agency also asked how to distinguish and contextualize the differences between “evidence” that has clinical significance versus mere “information” or “data” that may not demonstrate the safety or effectiveness of a medical product, if any.

    FDA questioned the extent to which disclaimers describing limitations of information are effective and whether data supports the effectiveness of such disclaimers. Finally, the agency questioned whether looser restrictions on off-label communications will disincentivize manufacturers from generating data or continuing to generate more robust data, or whether it will disincentivize manufacturers from seeking FDA approval or clearance for new uses altogether.

    Nature of Disease or Condition

    FDA also entertained whether the nature of the clinical condition(s) addressed in the information should merit greater flexibility. For example, the risk-benefit analysis for the dissemination of off-label information regarding treatments for serious or life-threatening illnesses and rare diseases may weigh in favor of enhanced access to such information, particularly insofar as the affected provider and/or patient population may be more likely to understand such information.

    Evaluation of Communications

    FDA also considered the process for evaluating whether information meets potential standards for off-label communications. Specifically, issues on which the agency expressed interest in receiving comments included:

    • Who should decide whether information is “truthful and non-misleading”
    • Whether and when the FDA should review such communications before dissemination
    • Whether the source (e.g., manufacturer versus independent researcher) of the information affects whether a communication is “truthful and non-misleading”
    • Whether information omitted from a communication could cause patient harm

    Boundaries to “Scientific Exchange”

    FDA reaffirmed that its regulatory oversight is limited to promotion of medical products, and that it does not have the authority to regulate the practice of medicine. While neither “promotion” nor “scientific exchange” is defined, in its “Off-Label and Investigational Use Of Marketed Drugs, Biologics, and Medical Devices – Information Sheet” guidance, FDA states that physicians must be “well informed about [a] product” and “base [the product’s] use on scientific rationale and on sound medical evidence.” To that end, the agency appears willing to consider defining or establishing more concrete parameters around the concept of scientific exchange to distinguish it from promotion. Several stakeholders’ presentations and FDA questions focused on the distinction between “scientific exchange” and “promotion,” who may participate in “scientific exchange,” and whether scientific exchange is limited to communications between academics and health care providers or extends to communications to formularies and payers.

    Potential Revisions to Labeling

    A number of stakeholders argued that current labeling is largely outdated and not the primary mode through which information is transmitted and raised the possibility of updating labeling to include an off-label information section with appropriate context (e.g., study design, limitations, statistical analysis) and disclaimers.

    FDA also questioned what responsibilities manufacturers have to make sure audiences are given new or updated information, via periodically revised labeling or otherwise.

    ************************

    The public can submit comments, regardless of attendance at the meeting. The period for public comment has been extended to April 10, 2017.

    Authors

    Michael W. Ryan

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • New York Court Finds Implied Private Right of Action in Nonprofit Revitalization Act’s ‘Whistleblower Policy’

    New York Court Finds Implied Private Right of Action in Nonprofit Revitalization Act’s ‘Whistleblower Policy’

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York Court Finds Implied Private Right of Action in Nonprofit Revitalization Act’s ‘Whistleblower Policy’

    November 17, 2016

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Oct. 24, 2016, a New York court ruled that the state’s Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (“N-PCL”), as amended by the Nonprofit Revitalization Act of 2013 (the “Act”), contains an implied private right of action for failing to protect whistleblowers from retaliation. The Supreme Court, Kings County rejected the notion that the Act’s “Whistleblower Policy” requirement only permits the attorney general or the board of directors to file suit and ruled that the Act implies a private right of action.[1]

    Della Pietra v. Poly Prep

    While employed by Poly Prep Country Day School (“Poly Prep”), an employee, Lisa Della Pietra, reported to the school’s headmaster and several board members that her supervisor engaged in misconduct while on a school-funded vacation with students and alumni. The alleged misconduct involved sexual contact with prostitutes and alcohol consumption. Della Pietra alleged that the headmaster disclosed her identity and, as a result, she was “harassed, bullied, and intimidated” by her supervisor. Della Pietra claims she was subsequently terminated from Poly Prep shortly after reporting the retaliatory conduct to the headmaster. Della Pietra sued the school for mental anguish and humiliation due in part to Poly Prep’s failure to maintain and distribute a whistleblower protection policy.

    The court applied the three-part test set out by the New York Court of Appeals in Burns Jackson v. Lindner, 59 N.Y.2d 314 (1983), ruling that the legislature intended for the Act to encompass a private right of action. Under this test, a court considers: “(1) whether the plaintiff is one of the class for whose particular benefit the statute was enacted; (2) whether recognition of a private right of action would promote the legislative purpose; and (3) whether creation of such a right would be consistent with the legislative scheme.”[2] The Court rejected Poly Prep’s motion to dismiss, finding that Della Pietra was within the class of people the law was intended to help and permitting her suit would promote the legislative purpose of protecting whistleblowers. The Court granted the remainder of Poly Prep’s motion to dismiss, however, dismissing Della Pietra’s claims for breach of contract and defamation, and rejecting her argument of an implied contract of employment, finding that she could not rebut the presumption of an employment-at-will relationship.

    Nonprofit Revitalization Act

    As we have previously notified you,[3] New York’s legislature reformed the N-PCL in 2013, its first major modification in over 40 years. The Act requires not-for-profit organizations with 20 or more employees and an annual revenue of more than $1 million to adopt a policy protecting whistleblowers from retaliation. Section 715-b mandates that the “Whistleblower Policy” include: (1) procedures for reporting violations and suspected violations of laws or policies, including procedures for preserving the confidentiality of reported information; (2) a designated employee, officer or director tasked with administering the policy and reporting to the audit committee or other committee of independent directors or if no such committees exist, to the board; and (3) a requirement that copies of the policy be provided to employees, officers, directors and volunteers. The purpose of the “Whistleblower Policy” is to protect employees, who, in good faith, report misconduct, from adverse employment consequences.[4] In 2015, Governor Cuomo signed into law amendments to the Act. Section 715-b(b)(3) offers guidance and provides that the distribution requirement of the “Whistleblower Policy” may be satisfied by posting it on the organization’s website or at the organization’s office in a conspicuous location accessible to volunteers and employees.

    Recommended Actions

    All New York not-for-profit organizations, including nonprofit education institutions, should review the Act and its amendments in light of this new development. All not-for-profit organizations are encouraged to update their whistleblower protection policies and ensure that the policies are comprehensive and properly distributed. Additionally, this judicially recognized implied right of action might be extended to apply to other parts of the N-PCL which do not explicitly recognize a private right of action, such as the new conflict of interest requirements set forth by the Act.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Donna Lazarus and Aaron S. Farovitch. 

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Della Pietra v. Poly Prep, 506586/2015 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Oct. 24, 2016) (decision and order of the court granting in part and denying in part motion to dismiss).

    [2] Sheehy v. Big Flats Community Day, 73 NY.2d 629, 633 (1989).

    [3] See our previous Alerts: “The Nonprofit Revitalization Act of 2013” and “The Nonprofit Revitalization Act of 2013 Takes Effect on July 1, 2014.”

    [4] See N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §715-b(a).


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donna K. Lazarus

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Act Now To Preserve Your Section 1603 Grant

    Act Now To Preserve Your Section 1603 Grant

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Act Now To Preserve Your Section 1603 Grant

    November 15, 2016

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    We recently reported that on October 31, 2016, the US Court of Federal Claims issued its opinion in Alta Wind I Owner v. United States, in which the court determined that the value of the property eligible for the grant included the value of the power purchase agreements (PPA) associated with the facilities, and awarded an additional $206 million to the applicant.

    This case will likely have very important ramifications to taxpayers who have either: (1) applied for the Section 1603 grant and received less money than anticipated; or (2) did not seek the full amount of the grant based upon Treasury’s guidance. In either case, if you have applied for a Section 1603 grant, you should consider your options.

    What Should You Do Now?

    We do not know if the government will appeal its loss in Alta Wind. Moreover, the statute of limitations may be expiring on your ability to seek reimbursement under the reasoning in Alta Wind. Strategically, it may make sense to file suit immediately in the Court of Federal Claims to put your case in the most positive position for resolution. Or if you never claimed the full amount of the grant, you may need to amend your application to do so.

    Alta Wind is a significant decision, and is welcomed guidance to the renewable energy industry affirming its long-held view that the appropriate measure of cost basis in the context of the Section 1603 grant includes the value of a related PPA.

    Authors

    Philip Tingle

    Partner

    Miami

    More insights

  • Tax Planning for High-Net-Worth Individuals under a Trump Presidency

    Tax Planning for High-Net-Worth Individuals under a Trump Presidency

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Tax Planning for High-Net-Worth Individuals under a Trump Presidency

    November 14, 2016

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Tax reform is one of the central components of Donald Trump’s platform, and in many respects, his goals for tax reform are aligned with those described in the Tax Reform Task Force report issued by the House Republicans last summer. While we don’t yet have yet have a clear understanding of his proposals, or a prediction of what will actually be enacted, it is very likely that some combination of the Trump Tax Plan and the House Republicans’ Plan will become part of our tax law sometime next year.

    In depth

    Tax reform is one of the central components of Donald Trump’s platform. In many respects his goals for tax reform are aligned with those described in the Tax Reform Task Force report issued by the House Republicans last summer (the House Republicans’ Plan). We don’t yet have a clear understanding of the details of Trump’s tax proposals (the Trump Tax Plan) or a prediction as to which parts of his proposal will be enacted. But the continued Republican control of the House and the Senate make it likely that at least some combination of the Trump Tax Plan and the House Republicans’ Plan will become part of our tax law sometime next year. Because of a Senate procedural rule, it is possible that the tax changes that are adopted will be temporary, as the Bush tax cuts enacted in 2001 were.

    Here is a list of the provisions of both the Trump Tax Plan and the House Republicans’ Plan that, if enacted, will be likely to have the greatest impact on individual taxpayers.

    Repeal of the death tax: Trump has made it clear that he wants to repeal the estate tax. It is not clear whether he would also propose to repeal the gift and generation-skipping transfer tax. The House Republicans’ Plan eliminates the estate and generation-skipping transfer tax and says nothing about the gift tax. Until we know whether repeal will occur, and how broad that repeal will be, you may want to continue to implement estate planning strategies that do not have a significant risk of attracting a gift tax. Even if the estate tax is eliminated, if the gift tax remains, you may want a way to make funds available to your beneficiaries before your death.

    Because it is difficult to predict what form repeal would actually take, and whether, if enacted, it will last beyond the Trump presidency, it is important to build flexibility into your estate plan. You may want to give the individual who holds your power of attorney an expanded power to make certain changes to your estate plan in response to changes in the tax law. This power, for example, could be used to change an outright bequest to a spouse to a gift in trust if repeal occurs before your death and at a time when you no longer have the capacity to make changes. An outright gift to your surviving spouse will not increase your family’s estate tax burden under current law. But if your death occurs during a year in which there is no estate tax and the death of your spouse occurs after the estate tax has been restored, a gift to your spouse in trust rather than outright could save significant taxes for your family.

    Tax on unrealized appreciation at or after death: The Trump Tax Plan on unrealized appreciation at death is not spelled out clearly. As described on his website, his plan states that “capital gains held until death and valued over $10 million will be subject to tax. . . .” This statement does not tell us whether the tax will be imposed on the death of a decedent or at a later time when the decedent’s beneficiaries sell the appreciated property. The House Republicans’ Plan leaves the basis adjustment at death (commonly referred to as a basis “step-up”) in place.

    If the Trump Tax Plan taxes unrealized gain at death, lifetime transfers may be able to avoid that gain. If it does not tax unrealized gain at death, but merely requires that beneficiaries take a carryover basis, tax planning will be important to avoid burdening beneficiaries with capital gain taxes in excess of the value of their inheritance (for example, due to debt encumbering the inherited property).

    The elimination of basis step-up at death could result in the imposition of additional taxes on your estate if you have created grantor retained annuity trusts (GRATs) or have sold appreciated property to grantor trusts for notes. There are provisions that could be added to your current wills that, under current law, would eliminate this risk.

    Cap on itemized deductions: The Trump Tax Plan includes a provision limiting an individual’s itemized deductions to an annual $100,000 amount ($200,000 for joint returns). This limitation would impose a significant restriction on the use of the charitable deduction. The House Republicans’ proposal eliminates all itemized deductions other than the deduction for home mortgage interest and charitable gifts.

    To protect against the possibility that Trump’s proposal will prevail on this issue, individuals who plan to make large charitable donations over the next several years may want to consider accelerating those gifts into 2016.

    Contributions of appreciated assets to private foundations: Trump’s Tax Plan states that “contributions of appreciated assets into a private charity established by the decedent or the decedent’s relatives will be disallowed.” It is unclear what “disallowance” means and whether this disallowance will apply only on death, or whether it will also apply to lifetime transfers. If you are planning to make significant gifts of appreciated property to your private foundation in the near future, you may want to consider accelerating your gifts into 2016. If you are planning to make substantial gifts at death to a private foundation, you may want to consider adding a contingent alternative gift to a public charity in case you are not able to amend your estate plan if this aspect of Trump’s Tax Plan is enacted.

    Tax Rates: The investment and business income of individuals is now subject to a tax rate as high as 43.4 percent (23.8 percent in the case of long-term capital gains and qualified dividends), including the 3.8 percent tax on net investment income. The Trump Tax Plan would decrease that top tax rate to 33 percent (20 percent in the case of long-term capital gains and qualified dividends). At one time, the Trump Tax Plan called for a tax rate of 15 percent on the business income of individuals who earn this income from a flow through entity, such as a limited liability company or subchapter S corporation, but this proposal seems to have been withdrawn. The House Republicans’ Plan would also reduce the top rate to 33 percent. In addition, the House Republicans’ Plan would lower the effective top tax rate applicable to capital gains, interest and dividends to 16.5 percent, and the top rate applicable to the business income of individuals who earn this income directly or receive it from pass-through entities to 25 percent. Both proposals would also eliminate the alternative minimum tax.

    If you are contemplating a transaction that would result in the recognition of substantial income, such as the sale of appreciated assets, if feasible, you might want to consider deferring the transaction until 2017.

    Minority, Marketability Discounts: Many clients were considering transfers by year end or early in 2017 to capture marketability and minority discounts for interests in non-public partnerships and corporations. The impetus for the transfers was concern that controversial proposed regulations targeted at reducing those discounts could become effective shortly. A significant number of members of Congress had indicated strong opposition to the purpose of these proposed regulations, which we also believe are technically flawed. We now think it highly unlikely that adoption of final regulations in the nature of the proposed regulations would survive the next Congress. It is our view that it is unnecessary to immediately complete any transaction due to concern that the regulations will become effective in the near term, or remain in place if they were finalized.

    Authors

    Carol A. Harrington

    Senior Counsel

    Chicago

    Ellen K. Harrison

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Carlyn S. McCaffrey

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Briefing Points for the Board: The Election and the 2017 Health Policy Agenda

    Briefing Points for the Board: The Election and the 2017 Health Policy Agenda

    ARTICLE

    Briefing Points for the Board: The Election and the 2017 Health Policy Agenda

    November 14, 2016

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    It is vitally important for the health system board, as well as certain of its key committees, to receive an introductory briefing as soon as possible on the health policy implications of last week’s Presidential and Congressional elections, as they are currently understood.

    In depth

    It is vitally important for the health system board, as well as certain of its key committees, to receive an introductory briefing as soon as possible on the health policy implications of last week’s Presidential and Congressional elections, as they are currently understood.

    The board’s familiarity with such implications will help position it to exercise informed oversight and decision making, and to fully engage with management on health policy-prompted issues and opportunities.

    Such a briefing, which management can provide, could incorporate the following issues, among others:

    1. ACA Repeal – The President-elect and congressional Republicans campaigned clearly and vocally on repealing the Affordable Care Act (ACA), and since winning the election, both have renewed promises to advance repeal legislation early in 2017. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) was much more than just increasing insurance coverage for uninsured and underinsured individuals, so it is important to understand what ACA opponents mean when they say they intend to repeal the ACA. Generally speaking, Republicans’ first priority in repeal will be to eliminate the mandate that individuals purchase insurance and reduce or eliminate subsidies for that purchase. Although any repeal is likely to have a delayed effective date, if enacted, these changes could upset the insurance markets almost immediately and disrupt access to insurance for millions of Americans.

    Of course, Republican leaders likely will work to advance alternative policies that achieve comparable results through different means. What that replacement will ultimately look like is uncertain, and there are various procedural pathways in Congress that will need to be considered. Nonetheless, boards should be informed that current insurance markets may be disrupted and changes could impact the number of insured individuals and revenues to the health system. Paired with elimination of expanded coverage in Medicaid, this would be a real game-changer in payer mix and revenue sources.

    2. Medicaid Expansion and Reform – The ACA also expanded access to health insurance for low-income individuals by providing financial incentives to states to adopt expanded eligibility standards. If “repeal the ACA” means eliminating these financial incentives or reverting to pre-2014 eligibility standards, millions of Americans would no longer receive coverage through Medicaid, further increasing the number of uninsured.

    However, as with the ACA repeal discussion above, Republican leaders are likely to look for ways to minimize disruptions and to build in a transition period. Even so, potential changes may cause disruption and at least some dislocation. The President-elect also has promised to “block-grant Medicaid” and turn more authority over to states to design Medicaid programs.

    3. Medicare Reform – The President-elect has promised to “modernize Medicare.” What this means precisely is hard to predict at this juncture. However, inferences can be drawn from previous Republican proposals to reform Medicare.

    Republicans have previously and repeatedly called for Medicare to be converted to a premium support model, where beneficiaries would be given a credit or voucher to purchase insurance on the open market. Republicans also have called for increasing the Medicare age of eligibility from 65 to 67. Republicans also strongly favor the Medicare Advantage program, and could seek policy changes to buttress those options and incentivize seniors to enroll in managed care over traditional fee-for-service Medicare. Notably, Republicans have routinely called for these changes to be phased in over years, so it is unlikely that any disruptions for health systems caused by these changes would be felt immediately.

    4. Alternative Payment Models – The Obama Administration has also championed health system modernization by linking Medicare and Medicaid payments to various performance metrics and incentivizing risk-sharing models, like Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) and bundled payment models. Notably, these efforts have traditionally enjoyed bipartisan support, so it is less likely that Republican leaders would seek to entirely undo these programs.

    A new administration probably will maintain a commitment to advancing change to achieve more savings. Health systems will likely want to continue to ready themselves for the new programs rolled out by the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Innovation, including MACRA, but they also may want to re-examine physician alignment strategies and investments in ACOs, among other things, to align such strategies with potential changes.

    5. Medicare Fee-for-Service Payment – The new administration and congressional leaders also are likely to consider entitlement spending reductions to both fund other federal policy priorities, such as defense and infrastructure investment, and reduce the federal deficit. Health systems should brace for program payment cuts under traditional Medicare that could negatively impact revenues. Medicare fee-for-service payment changes are often replicated by commercial payers, so the implications could be felt beyond just Medicare.

    Authors

    Eric Zimmerman

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights