Content Type: Article

  • A Net-Neutral Decision for Health Care? What Providers Can Expect in the Wake of Net Neutrality Repeal

    A Net-Neutral Decision for Health Care? What Providers Can Expect in the Wake of Net Neutrality Repeal

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    A Net-Neutral Decision for Health Care? What Providers Can Expect in the Wake of Net Neutrality Repeal

    December 21, 2017

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    As the Federal Communications Commission repeals the Open Internet Order—more commonly known as the net-neutrality rules—health care consumers and providers have been left wondering how this change will affect their ability to receive and deliver health care using digital health tools. In this On the Subject, we outline how changes in internet access will affect digital health and what the regulatory landscape will look like in the coming months and years.

    In depth

    On December 14, 2017, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) voted 3–2 along party lines to repeal the Open Internet Order, more commonly known as the net-neutrality rules. The Open Internet Order was a 2015 FCC regulation designating private internet service providers (ISPs) as common carrier providers of a utility under Title II of the Communications Act of 1934. While the decision to repeal the Open Internet Order has drawn the scrutiny of the media, consumers and industry, health care consumers and providers have been left wondering how the repeal may affect their ability to receive and deliver health care using digital health tools such as telemedicine. The consequences of the FCC’s move to repeal the Open Internet Order and replace it with the Restoring Internet Freedom Order remain speculative, but the following sets forth the general legal impact of the Restoring Internet Freedom Order in the context of health care.

    What Is Net Neutrality and What Did Its Repeal Change?

    Net neutrality is the concept that every packet of data transmitted through the internet must be treated the same regardless of its content, size, and originating and end site. The Open Internet Order restricted ISPs from interfering with the capabilities of content providers disseminating their content utilizing the internet. More specifically, the Open Internet Order prohibited blocking access to websites, throttling (i.e., slowing) website download speeds and requiring payment for prioritization of internet traffic. Net neutrality became an administrative regulation under the Obama administration’s FCC in 2015, following years of litigation and failed legislation to create substantive law addressing the subject area. Additionally, the Open Internet Order required public disclosure regarding network management practices, performance and commercial terms of broadband access services sufficient for consumers to make informed choices regarding use of such services and for content, application, service and device providers to develop, market and maintain offerings.

    Upon repeal of the Open Internet Order, broadband internet access is reclassified as an “information service,” and ISPs are no longer common carriers subject to Title II of the Communications Act of 1934. The repeal moves internet service to a free market system pursuant to the FCC’s Restoring Internet Freedom Order, whereby ISPs must comply with new transparency requirements to disclose any throttling, blocking or paid prioritization arrangements, but will not be subject to any explicit restrictions on use of these mechanisms. The FCC argues that deregulation will facilitate increased investment into broadband internet infrastructure and generate competition amongst the ISPs.

    How Does the Repeal Affect Digital Health and Health Care Providers?

    The internet is central to both health care providers and consumers, as digital connectivity is a key component of numerous patient-practitioner encounters in the health care space. Telemedicine programs require strong internet connections and consume a considerable amount of data in streaming interactions. A number of electronic health record (EHR) systems are cloud based, and access to a cloud-based EHR requires a high-speed connection. Such cloud-based systems may be accessed by individuals across multiple states or even countries that will all be serviced by different ISPs. Further, remote monitoring of patients in home-health settings or in rural areas requires data to be transmitted on a real-time basis to central aggregating software or applications, and then forwarded on to providers in a number of instances. Internet of Things devices “talk” to one another using internet connectivity, facilitating data sharing on a real-time basis and enabling compilation of data to track an individual’s health trends.

    While the net neutrality rules were in place, the connectivity of each of these services and devices could not be restricted by the ISP operating the broadband network to which they connected. For example, one telemedicine provider could not pay to have faster connectivity speeds than another telemedicine provider. Now, ISPs could (within the confines of the antitrust and trade laws, as discussed subsequently herein) create tiered pricing structures that favor certain content providers over others. These tiered pricing structures could in turn create “fast lanes” that prioritize certain internet traffic and generally increase costs for providers. Thus, commentators have indicated that without net neutrality in place, there is potential for ISPs to control which content providers will be able to function at their highest capability to deliver their services. For example, if a telemedicine provider has the infrastructure to create a connection delivering high-quality image and sound, but access to the telemedicine provider’s web servers is throttled, the telemedicine provider will only be able to provide services with a lower-quality image and sound capability. This structure could raise the barrier to entry for new health care technologies and new telemedicine companies, causing rural providers or hospitals with less favorable revenues to cut innovative programs to increase access. Additionally, should an ISP have a related cloud-based services division or subsidiary, it could provide favorable connectivity to that cloud over other clouds, potentially affecting EHR access.

    The FCC has noted that removing restrictions on ISPs should facilitate greater investment in infrastructure, including that within rural communities. This investment should increase the ability of rural communities to gain access to high-speed internet connections, which in turn could be a boon for the telemedicine industry. Additionally, the FCC promised that by deregulating, ISPs will innovate and compete, providing improved options for consumers; what these new options may look like in relation to digital health tools remains to be seen.

    What Will the Regulatory Landscape Look Like?

    The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) will become responsible for monitoring and evaluating arrangements between ISPs and content providers to determine whether such arrangements are anti-competitive. The FCC and FTC released an outline of a memorandum of understanding to coordinate consumer protection under the Restoring Internet Freedom Order, granting the FTC review authority for complaints of blocking, throttling, paid prioritization and congestion management.

    It should be noted that the FTC attempted to regulate ISPs prior to the net neutrality rules but was stopped by the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in an appeal of an action taken against AT&T. The basis of the refusal to allow the FTC to enforce its 15 USC § 45 (Section 5) jurisdiction was that Section 5 does not grant the FTC jurisdiction over common carriers, even for non-common-carrier services provided by a common carrier. In light of the Open Internet Order, the Ninth Circuit concluded that AT&T is and was a common carrier, a determination made based on AT&T’s status, rather than its business activities. An en banc hearing is pending before the Ninth Circuit, and if AT&T’s internet activities are ruled as protected from the FTC’s jurisdiction resulting from AT&T’s general common carrier status post-Open Internet Order repeal, ISPs will be effectively unregulated under the current regulatory schematic.

    One question (of many) that remains unanswered is whether higher payment for access to a faster internet rate or exclusive access could be viewed as anti-competitive under Section 5. Additionally, given the FTC’s role in health care, advertising, data privacy, and mergers and acquisitions generally, there is some uncertainty whether the FTC has the resources and staffing to take on an additional oversight functions, and whether it will remain in this role.

    General Takeaways

    • ISPs could potentially grant preferential treatment to certain providers, particularly in the context of paid prioritization, but any such threat remains speculative at this stage.
    • If the FCC is correct in its assumptions that reduced regulation will facilitate additional investment, rural providers may ultimately benefit and have improved ability to access and grow telemedicine programs and digital health programs generally. The FCC concurrently voted to adopt proposed rulemaking that would grant additional funding to the Rural Health Care Program to continue modernization efforts of rural health care providers’ communication systems.
    • Given the public outcry over the repeal of net neutrality, it appears unlikely that ISPs will do anything to generate further controversy in the immediate future. It is a fair bet that health care will remain unaffected at least for now.

     

    Authors

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Cybersecurity Risks and Considerations for Plan Sponsors to Protect Employee Benefit Plans

    Cybersecurity Risks and Considerations for Plan Sponsors to Protect Employee Benefit Plans

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Cybersecurity Risks and Considerations for Plan Sponsors to Protect Employee Benefit Plans

    December 19, 2017

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Recent massive and highly publicized data breaches should cause employee benefit plan sponsors to reexamine their security protocols. A security breach could jeopardize employee benefit plan assets and information. Plan data, for example, may include personally identifiable information such as social security numbers, addresses, dates of birth, bank accounts and other financial information. Plan sponsors should be proactive and implement (or improve existing) cybersecurity measures to comply with their fiduciary responsibilities under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).

    Call to Action

    Plan sponsors should consider developing a cybersecurity risk management strategy and take into account the following steps:

    • Identify risks and assess current cybersecurity measures;
    • Establish enhanced written security policies and procedures (e.g., email/text alerts for account activity and multi-step authentication protocol and procedures to handle a data breach);
    • Communicate security tips to plan participants including use of strong and unique passwords;
    • Review service providers’ contracts to:
      • ensure adequacy of security protocols and use of best in class systems and software
      • negotiate indemnification provisions for losses incurred by the plan and its participants and beneficiaries
      • require reporting of cybersecurity breaches;
    • Document cybersecurity measures including any change due to a service provider’s recommendation;
    • Review fiduciary liability insurance coverage for data breach events;
    • Consider purchase of cybersecurity insurance; and
    • In the event of a breach, be active in the investigation, notice and response.

    As plan sponsors seek to maintain retirement plan compliance, they should make sure cybersecurity protection measures are in place to safeguard the personal information contained in qualified plan records.


    Authored by Mark E. Brossman , Holly H. Weiss, Susan E. Bernstein, and Aaron S. Farovitch.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your lawyer or the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Holly H. Weiss

    Retired Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Non-Infringement of a Patent Also Not an Antitrust Injury

    ARTICLE

    Non-Infringement of a Patent Also Not an Antitrust Injury

    December 19, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Stefan Meisner wrote this bylined article on Cascades Computer Innovation, LLC v. RPX Corp. and Samsung Electronics Co., in which the Ninth Circuit upheld dismissal of an antitrust suit where a jury verdict in a parallel case found no patent infringement. As a result, he wrote, “seeking an antitrust remedy where no patent infringement is found … doesn’t appear to be a winning strategy in private causes of action.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Preparing for Brexit | The Legal View

    ARTICLE

    Preparing for Brexit | The Legal View

    December 19, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Sharon Lamb gives a legal view on preparation for Brexit across the UK health care sector, as part of the Nuffield Trust’s series of guest blogs.

    In depth
    Authors

    Sharon Lamb

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • The Sales Factor Apportionment Method Brings Its Own Challenges

    ARTICLE

    The Sales Factor Apportionment Method Brings Its Own Challenges

    December 18, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Peter Faber wrote this bylined letter to the editor about states’ use of formulary apportionment to determine their shares of a multistate corporation’s income for income tax purposes. Advocating international use of this system as being easier to administer and as a way around expensive disputes about transfer pricing “has its own set of problems that may be as difficult to deal with as the ones that arise under the present system,” Mr. Faber wrote.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Manager Liability for Cartel Fines

    ARTICLE

    Manager Liability for Cartel Fines

    December 15, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    German courts have been disagreeing on whether companies can hold their managers liable for cartel fines. The highest German labour court now avoided taking a position by holding that only specialised antitrust courts can resolve that issue.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Recent SEC Enforcement Actions and Public Statement in the Blockchain Space

    Recent SEC Enforcement Actions and Public Statement in the Blockchain Space

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Recent SEC Enforcement Actions and Public Statement in the Blockchain Space

    December 14, 2017

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The SEC has recently taken significant public steps in the regulation of token sales (popularly known as initial coin offerings, or ICOs) relating to blockchain. While the SEC Guidance provides clarity for critical points and moves further in the direction of much-needed clarity on the SEC’s thinking about token sales—which should help the various constituencies participating in blockchain and ICOs—there are still several points that have not yet been directly addressed.

    In depth

    In recent weeks, the US Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken significant public steps in the regulation of token sales (popularly known as initial coin offerings, or ICOs) relating to blockchain. These steps followed the issuance by the SEC of the Decentralized Autonomous Organization Report on July 25, 2017 (the DAO Report). On December 4, 2017, and December 11, 2017, the SEC announced enforcement actions relating to the PlexCoin and Munchee token launches, respectively, (Enforcement Actions). On December 11, 2017, SEC Chairman Jay Clayton published a public statement entitled Cryptocurrencies and Initial Coin Offerings (the Public Statement, further referenced together with the Enforcement Actions as the Recent SEC Guidance). The SEC has made a concerted effort to monitor the ICO market and address—first through the DAO Report and now the SEC Guidance—transactions and behaviors it believes are both inconsistent with and in violation of US securities laws.

    The SEC Guidance moves further in the direction of much-needed clarity on the SEC’s thinking about token sales, which should help the various constituencies participating in blockchain and ICOs. Highlighted below are critical points that are addressed in the Recent SEC Guidance and several other points that have not yet been directly addressed.

    Points of Clarity about the SEC’s View:

    • Manner of Sale. While the Howey test (SEC v. W. J. Howey Co., 328 US 293 (1946)) provides the basis of the analysis as to whether a token is an investment contract, concepts from other Supreme Court precedent (cited in Munchee) inform the application of the factors described in Howey. For example, the manner in which a token is sold, including the defining characteristics of the target purchasers, can create an expectation of profit, as can statements about intended project improvements through the use of ICO proceeds, which can increase the likelihood that the token will be considered to be a security.
    • Touting. Any “touting” of the possibility of appreciation (return on investment) of a token’s value through anticipated platform development, additional functionality or an increase in secondary market price, whether on a cryptocurrency exchange or from peer-to-peer trading, can impact whether a token will be considered to be a security.
    • Token Liquidity – Secondary Market Trading. Engaging in activities that seek to ensure token liquidity might also form the basis for a view that purchasers have an expectation of profits from the efforts of others. In other words, engaging in these activities, even in respect of a token that could be considered to be a “utility” token, could cause the token to be considered by the SEC to be a security. These activities might include arranging for a cryptocurrency exchange to “list” the token, selling efforts geared exclusively to “investors” in tokens rather than users of the platform, and publicity aimed at creating interest among traders.
    • Other Market Participants. The Public Statement emphasizes that market participants, other than token issuers, should independently consider the Howey test and whether a token may be a security prior to promoting a token as an advisor, listing the tokens on an exchange or otherwise engaging in behavior that is regulated by the SEC in respect of securities offerings, sales and market-making. Operating as an unregistered broker-dealer or exchange is a separate violation of the securities laws.
    • Prior Bad Acts. In Plexcoin, the SEC emphasizes that prior bad acts by senior members of a token issuer, especially in the securities industry (in the United States or in other jurisdictions), will draw additional scrutiny by the SEC.

    Points for Which Additional Clarification is Needed:

    • Each Enforcement Action asserts that the token at issue is a security without considering an interpretation to the effect that the manner of sale created an investment contract with respect to the sale itself, rather than the underlying token. We consider this distinction important and in line with Howey, where the Supreme Court found that the contract concerning the profits from the sale of oranges was a security, not the oranges themselves. The blockchain ecosystem has developed several “investment contract” instruments for selling tokens in the initial sale that seek to maintain the utility nature of the underlying token. Utility tokens not subject to the securities laws seek to create the kind of network adoption that a project needs for their cryptoeconomy to succeed. SEC clarification of this point would be beneficial.
    • Clarification that a utility token that represents a digital good (e.g., cigars, coffee cups) or service (e.g., software as a service, storage, processing power) is not a security, would also be helpful. If someone selling such a token makes statements about appreciation, will the token be a security? We do not think so.
    • Additional guidance is needed about whether the stage of a platform’s development at the time of the token sale matters to the securities law analysis of the related token. This question poses significant issues because like any technology, blockchain projects will seek to make continuous improvements.
    • Further understanding on the touting prohibition would be helpful. If a market participant does the touting at the request of the token sponsor, that is the equivalent of the project itself touting its token. However, it remains uncertain whether the SEC will take into consideration the touting of a token by independent actors.

    We believe it is important to view blockchain as a technology usable in many industries. As a result, “contextual regulation” remains a cornerstone of our advice to clients; the industry in which the blockchain is adopted will tell us a lot about how it should be regulated. In the Recent SEC Guidance, the SEC has adopted a contextual approach that appears to focus on promissory statements and actions, as well as the history of those behind the blockchain project. In other words, if the project creates an investment-like context, the SEC will scrutinize the sale of the token very carefully to protect market participants from sales of securities without adherence to applicable laws and regulations.

    Authors

    David L. Taub

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • The Taylor Review Recommendations: What Happens Now?

    ARTICLE

    The Taylor Review Recommendations: What Happens Now?

    December 14, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Paul McGrath wrote this bylined article assessing the UK’s Taylor Report on how employment practices in the modern economy might need to change to keep pace with such modern business models as the gig economy. The report recommended a national strategy to deal with this issue, Mr. McGrath wrote, and he added that while “there is no immediate practical impact of the Taylor Review for business, this is certainly a space worth watching.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • GOP Tax Plan Keeps Green Energy, Electric Car Subsidies

    ARTICLE

    GOP Tax Plan Keeps Green Energy, Electric Car Subsidies

    December 14, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Heather Cooper, Martha Groves Pugh, Philip Tingle, Madeline Chiampou Tully and Bradford LaBonte wrote an MWE update, cited here, on how the Base Erosion Anti-Abuse Tax provision (BEAT) of the new tax bill could erode the value of tax credits for solar and wind energy projects.

    In depth
    Authors

    Heather Cooper

    Partner

    Miami

    Philip Tingle

    Partner

    Miami

    Bradford E. LaBonte

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Craft Beer and Marijuana

    ARTICLE

    Craft Beer and Marijuana

    November/December 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Marc Sorini and Vanessa Burrows wrote this bylined article on the legal issues facing craft brewers seeking to combine their brewing business with one or more aspects of the emerging marijuana business. “Marijuana currently operates in a very uncertain place in the US legal system” because of state legalization and continued federal restrictions, the authors wrote, so “brewers seeking to enter the marijuana business as investors or more face a host of questions and risks.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights