ARTICLE
Six Takeaways: How Utilities and IPPs Are Responding to COVID-19
May 1, 2020
Read time: 3 min
On Thursday, April 30, McDermott was joined by Brett Kerr, vice president of external affairs at Calpine, Drew Murphy, senior vice president of strategy and corporate development at Edison International, and Andrew Campbell, director of regulatory support and planning at NiSource who shared their perspectives on how investor-owned utilities and independent power producers are managing the COVID-19 crisis.
Below are six takeaways from this week’s webinar:
- As businesses go back to work, it is essential that they carefully plan for a new normal, including consideration of travel restrictions, acquisition of personal protective equipment, maintaining social distancing of employees and contractors, and compliance with new rules and regulations.
- Utilities have been and will continue to optimize their maintenance schedules to balance safety and reliability concerns considering the essential nature of electricity and risks potentially associated with deferred maintenance.
- Although it is too soon to see the permanent effects of COVID-19, there has been a five to seven percent reduction in weather-normalized demand: this includes both an increase in residential demand and a larger reduction in commercial and industrial demand.
- Utilities are watching cash flow more closely as more customers are either not paying or deferring payment, and as commercial and industrial customers reduce demand. In California, where revenues are decoupled from electricity demand, this should not affect total revenues, but may lead to reallocation of rates across customer classes.
- A number of large commercial and industrial corporate customers with renewable and sustainability commitments are talking about placing these commitments on hold or rethinking them as recessionary impacts become clearer.
- Drops in load and low natural gas prices could detrimentally impact the economics of new renewable projects seeking financing and prevent the projects from moving forward. However, as renewables often dominate interconnection queues, if some of these projects do not come online, prices could actually remain constant.
To begin receiving Energy updates, including invitations to the Renewables Roundtable and Q&A Webinar Series, please click here.
To access past webinars, please click here.

Businesses with up to 15,000 Employees or $5 Billion in Revenue: Federal Reserve Expands Scope and Eligibility for Main Street Lending Program
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Businesses with up to 15,000 Employees or $5 Billion in Revenue: Federal Reserve Expands Scope and Eligibility for Main Street Lending Program
May 1, 2020
Read time: 12 min
On April 30, 2020, after soliciting and receiving public feedback, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (“Federal Reserve”) announced that it is expanding the loan options and eligibility of the Main Street Lending Program.[1]
In connection with the Main Street Lending Program, the Department of the Treasury (“Treasury Department”) will make a $75-billion equity investment in a special purpose vehicle (“Main Street SPV”) using funds appropriated to the Exchanges Stabilization Fund under Section 4027 of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”).[2] The Main Street SPV will purchase up to $600 billion[3] of participations in eligible facilities under the Main Street Lending Program.
With the expansion, the Main Street Lending Program now consist of three facilities: (i) the Main Street New Loan Facility, (ii) the Main Street Expanded Loan Facility and (iii) the Main Street Priority Loan Facility (each, a “Facility” and together, the “Main Street Facilities”). Borrowers may only participate in one of the three Main Street Facilities.
This Alert provides a brief overview of the revised and expanded terms of the Main Street Lending Program and replaces our April 9, 2020 Alert.
Eligible Borrowers
The Main Street Lending Program will provide loans to small and mid-sized companies. In order to be eligible to borrow under the Main Street Lending Program, all borrowers must satisfy the following criteria in addition to the eligibility requirements set forth in the specific term sheet for the Facility they seek to access (as further described below):
- The borrower must have been incorporated prior to March 13, 2020.
- The borrower must not be an “Ineligible Business,” which, among others, includes banks, finance companies, life insurance companies, government funded companies, businesses primarily engaged in political or lobbying activities and businesses engaged in any illegal activity.[4]
- The borrower must either (a) have 15,000 or fewer employees or (b) have had annual revenue of $5 billion or less in 2019.
- The borrower must be created or organized in the United States or under the laws of the United States with significant operations in and a majority of their employees based in the United States.
- The borrower must not participate in the Primary Market Corporate Credit Facility[5] or have received specific support pursuant to Subtitle A of Title IV section 4003(b)(1)-(3) of the CARES Act.[6] (For the avoidance of doubt, businesses that have received Payroll Protection Program[7] loans are permitted to borrow under the Main Street Facilities.)
- The borrower must have been in sound financial condition prior to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Eligible borrowers will also be required to make certain attestations concerning eligibility and the use of loan proceeds, including that:
- The borrower will refrain from repaying the principal balance of, or paying any interest on, any debt until the eligible loan is repaid in full, unless the debt or interest payment is mandatory and due.[8]
- The borrower will not seek to cancel or reduce any of its committed lines of credit with the eligible lender or any other lender.
- The borrower has a reasonable basis to believe that, as of the date of origination of the eligible loan and after giving effect to such loan, it has the ability to meet its financial obligations for at least the next 90 days and does not expect to file for bankruptcy during that time period.
- The borrower will follow compensation, stock repurchase and capital distribution restrictions that apply to direct loan programs under section 4003(c)(3)(A)(ii) of the CARES Act, except that an S corporation or other tax pass-through entity that is an eligible borrower may make distributions to the extent reasonably required to cover its owners’ tax obligations in respect of the entity’s earnings.
- The borrower is eligible to participate in the Facility, and such participation will not violate the conflicts of interest prohibition in Section 4019(b) of the CARES Act.[9]
In addition, the borrower must commit to make commercially reasonable efforts to maintain its payroll and retain its employees during the time the eligible loan (or upsized tranche) is outstanding.
Main Street Loan Overview
In connection with the Main Street Lending Program, the Federal Reserve will issue four-year loans to these eligible companies, at an adjustable rate of LIBOR (one or three month) + 300 basis points, with principal and interest payments deferred for one year after the loan is disbursed (“Main Street Loans”). All of the Main Street Facilities allow for prepayment without penalty. Main Street Loans are full-recourse loans and the principal amount cannot be reduced through loan forgiveness.
Main Street New Loan Facility
- Loans will be made for a minimum of $500,000 and may not exceed either the lesser of (a) $25 million or (b) an amount that, when added to the eligible borrower’s existing outstanding and committed but undrawn debt, does not exceed four times the eligible borrower’s 2019 adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (“EBITDA”).
- No principal is paid in the first year. The loan will be amortized over the remaining term of the loan, with 33.33% of principal due at the end of the second year, 33.33% at the end of the third year, and 33.33% at maturity at the end of the fourth year.
- The loan is not, at the time of origination or at any time during the term of the Main Street New Loan, contractually subordinated in terms of priority to any of the borrower’s other loans or debt instruments.
- The Main Street SPV will purchase at par value a 95% participation in the loan. The Main Street SPV and the eligible lender will share risk in the loan on a pari passu The eligible lender must retain its 5% of the loan until it matures or the Main Street SPV sells all of its participation, whichever comes first.
Main Street Expanded Loan Facility
- Eligible lenders that have extended an existing term loan or revolving credit facility to an eligible borrower may increase (or “upsize”) that extension of credit, by adding a new increment (or “tranche”). At the time of upsizing and at all times the upsized tranche is outstanding, the upsized tranche is senior to or pari passu with, in terms of priority and security, the eligible borrower’s other loans or debt instruments, other than mortgage debt. The eligible lender must be one of the lenders that holds an interest in the underlying eligible loan at the date of upsizing.
- Loans will be made for a minimum of $10 million and may not exceed either the lesser of (a) $200 million; (b) 35% of the eligible borrower’s existing outstanding and committed but undrawn bank debt; or (c) an amount that, when added to the eligible borrower’s existing outstanding and committed but undrawn debt, does not exceed six times the eligible borrower’s 2019 adjusted EBITDA.
- No principal is paid in the first year. The loan will be amortized over the remaining term of the loan, with 15% of principal due at the end of the second year, 15% at the end of the third year, and a balloon payment of 70% at maturity at the end of the fourth year.
- The Main Street SPV will purchase at par value a 95% participation in the upsized tranche of the eligible loan, provided that it is upsized on or after April 24, 2020. The Main Street SPV and the eligible lender will share risk in the upsized tranche on a pari passu The eligible lender must retain its 5% portion of the upsized tranche of the eligible loan until the upsized tranche of the eligible loan matures or the Main Street SPV sells all of its 95% participation, whichever comes first. The eligible lender must also retain its interest in the underlying eligible loan until the underlying eligible loan matures, the upsized tranche of the eligible loan matures, or the Main Street SPV sells all of its 95% participation, whichever comes first.
Main Street Priority Loan Facility
- Loans will be made for a minimum of $10 million and may not exceed any of the following: (a) $200 million, (b) 35% of the eligible borrower’s existing outstanding and committed but undrawn bank debt, or (c) an amount that, when added to the eligible borrower’s existing outstanding and committed but undrawn debt, does not exceed six times the eligible borrower’s 2019 adjusted EBITDA.
- No principal is paid in the first year. The loan will be amortized over the remaining term of the loan, with 15% of principal due at the end of the second year, 15% at the end of the third year, and a balloon payment of 70% at maturity at the end of the fourth year.
- At the time of origination and at all times thereafter while the eligible loan is outstanding, the eligible loan is senior to or pari passu with, in terms of priority and security, the eligible borrower’s other loans or debt instruments, other than mortgage debt.
- The Main Street SPV will purchase at par value an 85% participation in the eligible loan. The Main Street SPV and the eligible lender will share risk in the eligible loan on a pari passu The eligible lender must retain its 15% of the eligible loan until it matures or the Main Street SPV sells all of its participation, whichever comes first.
Eligible Lenders
Eligible lenders are U.S. insured depository institutions, U.S. bank holding companies and U.S. savings and loan holding companies. Eligible lenders will be required to make certain certifications, including that:
- The eligible lender will not request that the eligible borrower repay debt extended by the eligible lender to the eligible borrower, or pay interest on such outstanding obligations, until the eligible loan (in the case of the Main Street Expanded Loan Facility, the upsized tranche) is repaid in full, unless the debt or interest payment is mandatory and due, or in the case of default and acceleration.
- The eligible lender will not cancel or reduce any existing lines of credit outstanding to the borrower, except in an event of default.
- The methodology used for calculating the eligible borrower’s adjusted 2019 EBITDA for the leverage requirement is the methodology it has previously used for adjusting EBITDA when extending credit to the eligible borrower or similarly situated borrowers (in the case of the Main Street Expanded Loan Facility, when originating or amending the existing extension of credit) on or before April 24, 2020.
- The eligible lender is eligible to participate in the Facility, and such participation will not violate the conflicts of interest prohibition in Section 4019(b) of the CARES Act.
Facility Termination
The Main Street Lending Program is authorized to purchase participations in the Main Street Facilities until Sept. 30, 2020. The Main Street SPV will cease purchasing loan participations on Sept. 30, 2020, unless the Main Street Lending Program and Main Street Facilities are extended by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve and the Treasury Department.[10]
For more information, please see the Main Street New Loan Facility term sheet here, the Main Street Expanded Loan Facility here or the Main Street Priority Loan Facility here. In addition, the Federal Reserve has created an FAQ page with more details, which it intends to further supplement as warranted.
Authored by Joseph P. Vitale, Kristen Q. Lin and Jessica Romano.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
[1] The Main Street Lending Program was created to support small and medium-sized businesses affected by the COVID-19 pandemic through the provision of credit in order to help them maintain their payroll and day-to-day operations.
[2] The CARES Act is a $2-trillion stimulus bill that was signed into law on March 27, 2020, with the goal of providing financial support to individuals and businesses that have been affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.
[3] The Federal Reserve and the Treasury Department will continue to assess the situation and needs of eligible borrowers and may adjust the Main Street Lending Program’s size in the future.
[4] For a full list of ineligible businesses, please refer to those listed in 13 CFR 120.110(b)-(j), (m)-(s), as modified and clarified by the Small Business Association.
[5] The Primary Market Corporate Credit Facility was created by the Federal Reserve to support large companies through the purchase of eligible corporate bonds from, and lending through syndicated loans to, large companies.
[6] Section 4003(b)(1)-(3) of the CARES Act authorizes up to $46 billion for direct Treasury support for passenger air carriers (and certain specified related businesses), cargo air carriers and businesses critical to maintaining national security.
[7] The Payroll Protection Program was established by the CARES Act and implemented by the Small Business Administration to support the payroll and operations of small businesses through the issuance of government-guaranteed loans that include a forgiveness feature for borrowers that satisfy the requirements of the Payroll Protection Program.
[8] For the Main Street Priority Loan Facility, the eligible borrower may, at the time of origination of the eligible loan, refinance existing debt owed by the eligible borrower to a lender that is not the eligible lender.
[9] Section 4019 of the CARES Act is intended to prohibit any business that is directly or indirectly owned by the president, vice president, the head of all executive branch departments (but not other federal agencies) and any member of congress, as well as their spouse, child (including adult children) or son- or daughter-in-law.
[10] The Federal Reserve Bank of Boston will continue to fund the Main Street SPV after such date until the Main Street SPV’s underlying assets mature or are sold.
This is a fast-moving topic and the information contained in this Alert is current as of the date it was published.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

Massachusetts Provides Flexibility for Ch. 180 Corporation Governance During COVID-19
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Massachusetts Provides Flexibility for Ch. 180 Corporation Governance During COVID-19
April 30, 2020
Read time: 6 min
In April 2020, Massachusetts enacted emergency legislation that eases certain corporate governance requirements for the duration of the Commonwealth’s state of emergency, declared by the Governor on March 10, 2020, and for 60 days thereafter. This article highlights key takeaways that affect Massachusetts Chapter 180 non-stock corporations.
Section 16 of the emergency legislation signed April 3, 2020 gives the board of directors of Chapter 180 corporations more flexibility in the following matters of corporate governance, so long as the entities’ articles of organization do not provide otherwise. While Massachusetts law generally grants corporations the flexibility to set forth in their bylaws many aspects of the manner and method of operation, this emergency legislation now permits Chapter 180 corporations to override specific requirements of the bylaws during this period without requiring such bylaws to be formally amended.
- Relaxed notice requirements
- Chapter 180 permits a non-stock corporation to establish in its bylaws what constitutes proper notice of meetings of the directors. Most corporate bylaws set forth a process of providing notice several days in advance by mail, email or phone communication to a director’s usual or last known place of business or address. This normal process may be challenging given remote work environments and social distancing, and it may be difficult for the corporation to track down where each director is on a given day and ensure that she receives the notice.
- Under the emergency legislation, the corporation only needs to provide notice to those directors who are “practicable” to reach. The corporation also has discretion to choose the method of notice based on practicality. Similarly, when cancelling a meeting of the members, the emergency legislation allows the flexibility to use any practical methods of notice as well.
- While the emergency legislation does not define “practicable,” this provision eases the notice burden that may be otherwise established in the bylaws. This flexibility could allow for methods of communication such as texts, social media messaging or chats.
- Greater latitude to facilitate meetings of the members
- While Chapter 180 allows non-stock corporations not to have members, many do have one or more classes of members that are set forth in the Articles. Chapter 180 also allows the method of meetings of the members to be established in the bylaws. In many cases, bylaws of corporations that have members only allow votes to be cast by members that are physically present at a meeting, either in person or by proxy.
- The emergency legislation allows some flexibility to override more stringent bylaw requirements in order to conduct meetings during the Coronavirus (COVID-19) crisis.
- The emergency legislation permits members to vote in person or by proxy, provided that members voting by proxy shall count for quorum.
- Unless prohibited in the articles of organization or bylaws, this is already permitted under Chapter 180 and generally in many corporate bylaws.
- Remote participation for a meeting of the members is also permitted under the emergency legislation, and shall count for quorum only if all of the following are true:
- First, reasonable measures must be implemented to verify that votes are cast by a member or proxyholder.
- For example, votes cast via chat, online polling or online surveys would require a method of verifying that they were in fact cast by the appropriate person.
- First, reasonable measures must be implemented to verify that votes are cast by a member or proxyholder.
- Second, reasonable measures must be implemented to provide members and proxyholders with a reasonable opportunity to participate in the meeting and to vote. These measures include opportunities to read or hear the proceedings of the meeting substantially concurrently with such proceedings and opportunities to pose questions and make comments, regardless of whether communication is simultaneous.
- The definition of “substantially concurrent” communications is not clear from the emergency legislation, but it does appear that meetings could be conducted virtually in a way that does not account for simultaneous, real-time participation. For example, comments/questions could be collected in advance of an online or recorded meeting (made available to members for a period of time), where votes would be taken through an online poll or survey by individuals who viewed the meeting live or through a subsequent recording.
- Third, the corporation must maintain a record of the votes and other actions taken in the meeting that involves virtual participation.
- For example, any votes taken via a webinar meeting would need to be recorded appropriately in the minutes.
- This flexibility for meetings of the members stands in contrast to how board meetings must be conducted, even under the emergency legislation. Boards can permit remote participation by directors, but only when all persons participating in the meeting can simultaneously communicate with each other at the meeting. This approach is generally included in most corporate bylaws already.
- While Chapter 180 allows non-stock corporations not to have members, many do have one or more classes of members that are set forth in the Articles. Chapter 180 also allows the method of meetings of the members to be established in the bylaws. In many cases, bylaws of corporations that have members only allow votes to be cast by members that are physically present at a meeting, either in person or by proxy.
- Flexible terms of office
- The emergency legislation permits a board to allow a director or officer to continue to serve during the state of emergency and until his successor is elected, appointed or designated, despite the expiration of the director’s or officer’s term. The board may also appoint successors to officers, directors, employees or agents.
- Most bylaws already provide for this, but the legislation allows for temporary flexibility for those that do not.
- The emergency legislation permits a board to allow a director or officer to continue to serve during the state of emergency and until his successor is elected, appointed or designated, despite the expiration of the director’s or officer’s term. The board may also appoint successors to officers, directors, employees or agents.
- Authority to relocate the principal office
- Boards are permitted to relocate the corporation’s principal office under the emergency legislation. Normally, the principal office is first established in the Articles of Organization, and most bylaws will permit the board to change the location effective upon filing a certificate with the secretary of the Commonwealth’s office. Changes can also be reported in the corporation’s annual report.
- It is unclear if the emergency legislation tolls the requirement to file the certificate with the secretary’s office during the emergency or the requirement that the corporate records be stored at the principal office.
- Boards are permitted to relocate the corporation’s principal office under the emergency legislation. Normally, the principal office is first established in the Articles of Organization, and most bylaws will permit the board to change the location effective upon filing a certificate with the secretary of the Commonwealth’s office. Changes can also be reported in the corporation’s annual report.
In a Chapter 180 corporation with members, the corporation must notify the members, as soon as reasonably practicable, of any action taken by the board of directors pursuant to the emergency legislation.
CMS Issues Explanatory Guidance on Nationwide Blanket Stark Law Waivers
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
CMS Issues Explanatory Guidance on Nationwide Blanket Stark Law Waivers
April 30, 2020
Read time: 11 min
On April 21, 2020, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) issued explanatory guidance on the scope and application of a series of nationwide Section 1135 waivers of the physician self-referral law (Stark Law) issued on March 30, 2020 in response to the novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. The waivers exempt healthcare entities from sanctions under section 1877(g) of the Social Security Act for noncompliance, provided certain conditions are met, and absent the government’s determination of fraud or abuse. CMS has structured the waivers to apply only to arrangements that meet one of the specified COVID-19-related purposes (a COVID-19 Purpose). We discussed and analyzed the nationwide blanket Stark Law waivers in detail in a previous article.
In response to questions and concerns raised by stakeholders, CMS has issued the explanatory guidance to clarify and elaborate on the scope and application of the blanket Stark Law waivers. CMS also took the opportunity to indicate that it will actively work with the US Department of Justice to address False Claims Act qui tam suits where a party believes, in good faith, that the arrangement in question satisfies a blanket Stark Law waiver.
Stark Law Waiver Scope Limitations
CMS confirmed that the waivers do not relieve entities that furnish designated health services (DHS) from compliance with the other elements of Stark Law exceptions that were not waived, such as the requirement that the arrangement not take into account the volume or value of referrals. Thus, financial relationships involving payments made by an entity that furnishes DHS (DHS Entity) to a physician or physician organization (PO) for the purchase of items or services, where the payments do not reflect fair market value (FMV), must still satisfy the other requirements of an applicable exception even though a blanket Stark Law waiver would protect the non-FMV payment aspect of relationships.
Amending Direct Compensation Arrangements
CMS explained that it has historically interpreted, and currently interprets, the Stark Law to permit parties to amend the terms of compensation arrangements multiple times over the course of the arrangement, even within the first year of the arrangement, provided the elements of a Stark Law exception are met. This interpretive statement from CMS provides parties welcome flexibility to amend arrangements where the overall arrangement will last at least a year following each amendment, regardless of whether the amendment itself lasts at least a year. Notwithstanding the difficulty in squaring this interpretive statement with CMS’s past commentary on the Stark Law’s “set in advance” and one-year duration requirements, the flexibility is welcome and means that parties do not necessarily need to wait a year after a first amendment to the compensation terms to make a second amendment to the compensation terms.
For example, suppose a hospital entered into a professional services agreement with a physician effective January 1, 2020. Although the agreement was entered into less than a year ago, the parties may amend the terms of the agreement during the national emergency period to reflect the changed needs of the parties, regardless of whether the parties are attempting to use a Stark Law waiver. The hospital may need the physician to perform different or more services than initially contemplated, including services that might involve greater risk of COVID-19 exposure. If the parties increase the compensation provided to a rate above FMV, the Stark Law compensation exception waivers would permit such above-FMV compensation. The agreement would need to meet all other, non-waived elements of a Stark Law compensation exception. Following the expiration of the emergency period, the compensation terms of the agreement could be again modified to meet the FMV element of the applicable exception, even within the first year of the amended arrangement. The parties must still evaluate whether an amendment furthers a specified COVID-19 Purpose, however. Reopening the compensation terms of an arrangement for the sole benefit of the physician or PO can itself confer a benefit on the physician or PO for which an exception is needed.
Read literally, the explanatory guidance requires that the arrangement last at least a year following an amendment. If an arrangement has served its commercially reasonable purposes before the first anniversary of the arrangement, key Stark Law compensation exceptions expressly permit termination of the compensation arrangement before the first year has expired so long as the parties do not enter into the same or a substantially similar arrangement until the anniversary of the original arrangement’s commencement date. This balances the parties’ need for flexibility to address changed circumstances warranting early termination with CMS’s interest in guarding against the use of replacement arrangements to reward or punish a physician for referrals during the course of the first year. By implication and analogy, amended compensation arrangements should be eligible for the same early termination option, albeit one tied to the first anniversary of the amendment instead of the first anniversary of the original commencement date. However, based on the literal text of the explanatory guidance, the industry cannot rely on this implication and analogy without risk based on current CMS guidance.
Indirect Compensation Arrangements
The blanket compensation waivers only pertain to direct compensation exceptions. In the explanatory guidance, CMS confirmed that it does not intend at this time to issue a blanket indirect compensation waiver. Parties may request an individual waiver from CMS for specific indirect compensation arrangements.
CMS observed, however, that the direct compensation analysis and waivers can be used for arrangements between a DHS Entity and a PO because all of a PO’s physicians are permitted to “stand in the shoes” of the PO.
Given the variety of arrangements between DHS Entities and non-POs that have physician ownership, it seems that CMS may not believe it has sufficient information to issue a blanket indirect compensation waiver at this time. But, these arrangements also likely have experienced changed circumstances in light of COVID-19’s impact on healthcare delivery. If the indirect compensation definition is met (i.e., the arrangement gives rise to an indirect compensation arrangement for Stark Law purposes), then the arrangement must meet the indirect compensation arrangement exception. The exception has a FMV requirement that may pose the same challenges that led to the need for the FMV waiver for direct compensation arrangements.
Loans and Other Debts
The Stark Law waivers contain two blanket waivers that address remuneration resulting from a loan between a DHS Entity and a physician, or a physician’s immediate family member, where the interest rate is below FMV or on terms that are unavailable from a bank or other commercial lender.
First, CMS clarified that no potentially applicable Stark Law exception would require cash payments to satisfy a borrower’s debt to a lender, and therefore a debtor could repay the loan with in-kind services or items. However, CMS noted that the Stark Law blanket waivers do not extend to forgiving repayment of the loan. Therefore, while a DHS Entity may permit a physician to repay a loan through in-kind payments, the value of the physician’s in-kind payments must be consistent with the amount of the loan balance. CMS acknowledged that the value of a physician agreeing to and in fact operating a medical practice in the community where a DHS Entity is located might be sufficient to constitute a physician’s in-kind repayment of a cash loan depending on each party’s unique facts and circumstances. CMS highlighted that the existing Stark Law exception for retention payments in underserved areas may also be available to protect certain retention payments to physicians in the DHS Entity’s geographic service area. CMS further noted that compensation arrangements involving in-kind payments must be commercially reasonable and may implicate the federal anti-kickback statute.
Second, CMS clarified that loan balance and interest payment terms agreed to in reliance on the blanket waivers may continue beyond the termination of the waivers. However, loan proceeds may not be dispersed and other remuneration may not be conveyed by parties after the termination of the blanket waivers without full compliance with an existing Stark Law exception. This clarification is helpful for providers concerned about the scope of protection for arrangements initiated, but arguably not completed, during the waiver period.
Restructuring of Physician Recruitment Agreements
The Stark Law and its implementing regulations contain both a statutory and regulatory exception permitting certain physician recruitment arrangements to induce a physician to relocate her practice to the geographic area served by a hospital in order to become a member of the hospital’s medical staff, provided the arrangement meets all of the elements of the exception. In a 2007 advisory opinion, CMS stated that parties to a recruitment arrangement are not permitted to amend the arrangement after it has commenced to provide for additional compensation to the recruited physician, because the additional compensation would not be for the purpose of inducing relocation and may directly or indirectly reflect the volume or value of the recruited physician’s actual or potential referrals.
In the guidance, CMS reiterated that an income guarantee may not be extended under an existing physician recruitment arrangement in light of interruption to the recruited physician’s medical practice due to the COVID-19 pandemic. However, a hospital may enter into other arrangements with a recruited physician to address COVID-19 disruption, which could be covered by the blanket Stark Law waivers as needed.
Key Takeaways and Outstanding Questions
The additional guidance provided by CMS clarifies a number of issues, including the applicability and scope of the blanket Stark Law waivers in relation to loans made in reliance on the waivers, and application of the waivers to indirect compensation arrangements. CMS’s commentary also appears to support the notion that the COVID-19 Purpose related to addressing medical practice or business interruption requires a close nexus between a DHS Entity providing financial support to a physician and that physician continuing to provide medical care in the community during the current pandemic.
A few questions still remain and additional commentary from CMS would be helpful. Specifically, additional guidance regarding the interplay between the non-monetary compensation limit (NMC) and the NMC blanket waiver would benefit the provider community. Typically, DHS entities can offer physicians remuneration in the form of NMC up to a specified annual limit ($413 for 2020) if certain other requirements are satisfied. CMS waived the NMC limit with a blanket waiver if the provision of the NMC is for a specified COVID-19 Purpose. Outstanding questions include the following:
- How will CMS analyze the applicability of the NMC limits if the emergency period ends in the middle of the calendar year?
- Will the published NMC limit spring back into effect at that time and, if so, what happens if a DHS entity has already exceeded the published limit for a particular physician in reliance on the waiver?
- Will the DHS entity no longer be able to use the NMC exception for this particular physician for the balance of the calendar year?
Similarly, CMS may wish to consider providing additional clarity regarding lifting the blanket waivers and any effects such lifting may have on healthcare entities’ reliance on the blanket waivers. For example, physician-owned hospitals that expanded their capacity to treat or respond to COVID-19, or ambulatory surgery centers that converted to hospitals, may be adversely affected by an abrupt lifting of the emergency period. Providers may need time after expiration of the national emergency period to unwind such expansion and/or hospital operations. A key question is whether CMS will provide a “grace period” for such physician-owned hospitals or ambulatory surgery centers to complete an unwinding of operations should the termination of the national emergency period come without sufficient advance notice. This unwinding scenario applies to compensation relationships as well. If the emergency declaration ends unexpectedly, and thus the waiver disappears, it will take some time to adjust all of the arrangements that have been entered into during the emergency, especially if care delivery has not returned to “normal.”
Best Practices
While notice to CMS before using a blanket Stark Law waiver is not required, it is advisable for providers to document that the arrangement meets a specified COVID-19 Purpose as well as the particular facts and circumstances for each arrangement where a Stark Law waiver applies. While CMS has provided some clarity on the status of arrangements entered into in reliance on a Stark Law waiver that continue after the emergency period ends, questions remain. Providers should include traditional “change of law/illegality” provisions in the event these clauses are necessary to modify or end an arrangement.
Mitigating Litigation Risk for Businesses Reopening in the Near-Term
ARTICLE
Mitigating Litigation Risk for Businesses Reopening in the Near-Term
April 30, 2020
Read time: 1 min
United Technologies/Raytheon Highlights Key Issues in Aerospace and Defense Industry Merger Review
ARTICLE
United Technologies/Raytheon Highlights Key Issues in Aerospace and Defense Industry Merger Review
April 30, 2020
Read time: 1 min
How to Manage Reputational Risks during Times of Crisis
ARTICLE
How to Manage Reputational Risks during Times of Crisis
April 30, 2020
Read time: 1 min
Open Letter to Chancellor Angela Merkel, Federal Minister for Economic Affairs Peter Altmeier and Federal Minister of Finance Olaf Scholz
ARTICLE
Open Letter to Chancellor Angela Merkel, Federal Minister for Economic Affairs Peter Altmeier and Federal Minister of Finance Olaf Scholz
April 30, 2020
Read time: 2 min
Proposal to support the economic management of the Coronavirus crisis by extending and facilitating tax loss carryback and loss carryforward and by payment of a lumpsum amount to companies in trouble in the amount of 30 % of the prospective annual loss of 2020 and 2021.
Bill Extends Medicare Telehealth Coverage for Therapy Providers
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Bill Extends Medicare Telehealth Coverage for Therapy Providers
April 29, 2020
Read time: 3 min
As part of the Coronavirus Preparedness and Response Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2020 and Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act, the federal government expanded Medicare reimbursement for telehealth services. In subsequent guidance and rulemaking, CMS provided expanded telehealth billing codes to allow for reimbursement of telehealth therapy services (e.g., physical therapy and occupational therapy) during the public health emergency. However, while reimbursement was expanded for telehealth therapy services, usage of the codes has not been possible because certain therapy providers are not identified as eligible distant site providers under Section 1834(m) of the Social Security Act. This absence has caused confusion amongst the patient and provider community regarding who can provide and bill for Medicare-covered therapy services during the public health emergency.
In an April 14, 2020, letter to Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, a group of bipartisan members of Congress sought further clarification on this issue and requested that physical therapists, occupational therapists, speech language pathologists and audiologists be reimbursed through Medicare for telehealth services.
On April 28, 2020, Rep. Cynthia Axne (IA-03), Rep. Troy Balderson (OH-12) and Rep. French Hill (AR-02) introduced bipartisan legislation, the Emergency COVID Telehealth Response Act, aimed at addressing this disconnect by including therapy providers in the definition of eligible distant site providers. Specifically, the proposed legislation provides that a practitioner described in section 1834(m) of the Social Security Act includes the following providers:
- Physical therapists
- Physical therapist assistants working under the supervision of a physical therapist
- Occupational therapists
- Occupational therapy assistants working under the supervision of an occupational therapist
- Speech-language pathologists
- Clinical social workers (as defined in section 1861(hh)(1) of the Social Security Act)
- Audiologists.
If passed, the Emergency COVID Telehealth Response Act will permit therapy providers to take advantage of Medicare’s more flexible telehealth reimbursement policies in response to Coronavirus (COVID-19) and allow Medicare beneficiaries to receive telehealth therapy services from the comfort of their home without risk of exposure. By introducing this bill, lawmakers continue to signal to CMS that it should prioritize expanding the types of providers eligible to furnish telehealth services for the duration of the COVID-19 public health emergency to include therapy providers.
This On the Subject was co-authored with Rachel Stauffer, Director at McDermott+Consulting.

SEC Examination Risk Update: Regulation BI and Form CRS
ARTICLE
SEC Examination Risk Update: Regulation BI and Form CRS
April 29, 2020
Read time: 1 min
