Content Type: Article

  • M&A Ordinary Course Covenants Amid Extraordinary Times

    M&A Ordinary Course Covenants Amid Extraordinary Times

    ARTICLE

    M&A Ordinary Course Covenants Amid Extraordinary Times

    May 7, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Andrew B. Kratenstein

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    M. Elias Berman

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • DOL Relaxes Deadlines for ERISA-Governed Group Health Plans

    DOL Relaxes Deadlines for ERISA-Governed Group Health Plans

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOL Relaxes Deadlines for ERISA-Governed Group Health Plans

    May 6, 2020

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Department of Labor, in conjunction with the Internal Revenue Service and US Department of the Treasury, issued guidance and deadline extensions applicable to ERISA-governed group health and welfare plans. The guidance provides relief for plan sponsors, plan administrators and plan participants that may be struggling to comply with applicable deadlines and requirements in the midst of the chaos related to the COVID-19 pandemic.

    In depth

    The US Department of Labor (DOL), in conjunction with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and US Department of the Treasury, has issued guidance and deadline extensions applicable to group health and welfare plans governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (ERISA) (collectively, COVID-19 guidance). This guidance includes a temporary expansion of plans’ ability to use forms of electronic disclosure, and also contains relief applicable to retirement plan sponsors and beneficiaries.

    To ease the impact of the Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act amended Section 518 of ERISA to expressly empower the DOL with discretion to extend any action required or permitted by ERISA for up to one year. The COVID-19 guidance is detailed in two documents providing relief to plan administrators and plan participants with respect to certain deadlines and notice requirements for health and welfare plans: EBSA Disaster Relief Notice 2020-01 and Department of Labor, Internal Revenue Service, and Treasury Department Joint Notice. The COVID-19 guidance modifies the timing requirements for certain health and welfare plan notices and actions to effectively disregard the outbreak period, which is defined as the period between March 1, 2020, (the beginning of the COVID-19 national emergency declared by the president) and 60 days after the announcement of the end of the COVID-19 national emergency (or such other date announced by the DOL in a future notice).

    Relief for Group Health Plans, Plan Participants, Beneficiaries, Qualified Beneficiaries and Claimants

    The COVID-19 guidance states that group health plans, disability plans and other employee welfare benefit plans must disregard the outbreak period in determining the following periods or dates:

    • The 30-day period (or 60-day period, if applicable) to request HIPAA special enrollment
    • The 60-day election period for COBRA continuation coverage
    • The date for making COBRA premium payments
    • The date for individuals to notify the plan of certain qualifying events (divorce, dependent child aging out of plan coverage) or determination of disability as it relates to COBRA coverage
    • The date within which individuals may file a benefit claim under a plan’s claims procedure
    • The date within which claimants may file an appeal of an adverse benefit determination under a plan’s claims procedure
    • The date within which claimants may file a request for an external review after receipt of an adverse benefit determination or final internal adverse benefit determination
    • The date within which a claimant may file information to perfect a request for external review upon an incomplete initial request
    • For group health plan sponsors and administrators, the date for providing a COBRA election notice (typically within 14 days after the plan receives notice of a qualifying event).

    Some of the relief outlined above may require revisions to participant notices and communications. For example, the COBRA election notice is required to include an explanation of how to elect COBRA coverage and the deadlines for making such election. The extended notice timing described above, which takes into account the outbreak period, would appear to affect this content requirement. More guidance on satisfying the content requirements applicable to all affected notices would be welcome, particularly as it may help protect plan sponsors against the ongoing threat of participant lawsuits alleging deficient notices.

    The COVID-19 guidance contains the following examples using April 30, 2020, as the assumed end date of the COVID-19 national emergency. Unfortunately, it is unknown when the COVID-19 national emergency will end, so plan sponsors should check with counsel before reverting back to shorter pre-pandemic timeframes.

    Special Enrollment: Emma previously declined coverage in her employer-sponsored group plan (for which she was otherwise eligible). Emma gave birth on March 31, 2020, and would like to enroll herself and her child in her employer’s plan, but open enrollment does not begin until November 15, 2020. Assuming the COVID-19 national emergency ends on April 30, 2020, Emma and her child qualify for special enrollment as of March 31, 2020, with Emma able to exercise her special enrollment rights until July 29, 2020 (30 days following the 60th day after the ending of the COVID-19 national emergency).

    COBRA Election Notice: John experiences a qualifying event for COBRA purposes as a result of a reduction of hours below the hours necessary to meet the group health plan’s eligibility requirements and has no other coverage. He is provided a COBRA notice on April 1, 2020. Assuming the COVID-19 national emergency ends on April 30, 2020, John has until August 28, 2020, to elect COBRA coverage (60 days following the 60th day after the ending of the COVID-19 national emergency).

    COBRA Payments: More than 45 days have passed since Sally elected COBRA continuation coverage, and monthly premium payments are due by the first of the month. Sally made a timely February payment for her COBRA coverage but did not make payments on March 1, 2020; April 1, 2020; May 1, 2020; or June 1, 2020. Sally’s plan does not permit qualified beneficiaries longer than the 30-day grace period for making premium payments. Assuming the COVID-19 national emergency ends on April 30, 2020, Sally has until July 29, 2020, to pay the March-June COBRA premiums payments (30 days following the 60th day after the ending of the COVID-19 national emergency). However, if she does not make the payments for the four missed months by July 29, 2020, the plan would not be obligated to cover benefits or services that occurred during such months.

    Filing a Benefit Claim: On March 1, 2020, Danielle received medical treatment for a condition covered under her employer’s group health plan. Under her plan, claims must be submitted within 365 days of the participant’s medical treatment. Assuming the COVID-19 national emergency ends on April 30, 2020, Danielle has until July 29, 2021, to submit her claim (365 days following the 60th day after the ending of the COVID-19 national emergency).

    Appealing an Adverse Benefit Determination: Leonard received a notification of an adverse benefit determination from his disability plan on January 28, 2020, noting that he has 180 days to file an appeal. Assuming the COVID-19 national emergency ends on April 30, 2020, Leonard has until November 24, 2020, to file an appeal (148 days after the 60th after the ending of the COVID-19 national emergency [180-32 days between January 28 and March 1, 2020]).

    The DOL also released additional FAQ guidance for participants and beneficiaries to address the new relief and other common health and retirement plan questions: COVID-19 FAQs for Participants and Beneficiaries.

    Form 5500 and M-1 Filing Relief

    Welfare plans subject to ERISA generally must file a Form 5500 with the DOL by the end of the seventh month after the end of the plan year (for calendar-year plans, July 31 of the following year). The COVID-19 guidance confirms previous relief providing an extension by which any Form 5500 filing that would otherwise be due between April 1 and July 15, 2020, is now automatically due by July 15, 2020, without the need to request an extension. Additionally, the regular two-and-one-half month extension is also available by filing a Form 5558, but this extension is still measured using the original due date instead of July 15. Finally, this automatic extension also applies if a sponsor previously filed an extension request using Form 5558 and that extension falls within the April 1 to July 15 relief period. For a calendar-year plan, the 2019 Form 5500 will be due by July 31, 2020, which is outside the relief period. M-1 filing relief extends for the same period of time as the Form 5500 relief.

    ERISA-Required Communications and Electronic Disclosure

    The COVID-19 guidance states that the Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) will not hold a benefit plan and/or plan fiduciary in violation of ERISA for failure to timely furnish any required notice, disclosure or document during the outbreak period, provided that the fiduciary acts in good faith and furnishes the communication as soon as practicable. For example, this relief would extend to the provision of summary plan descriptions, summaries of material modifications, and notices of adverse benefit determinations and appeals. EBSA states that “good faith acts” include use of alternative electronic means of communicating with participants and beneficiaries if the fiduciary reasonably believes they have effective access to those means, such as email, text messaging and continuous access websites.

    Next Steps

    The recent guidance issued by the DOL, IRS and the Treasury reflects the agencies’ acknowledgement that plan sponsors, plan administrators and plan participants may be struggling to comply with all applicable deadlines and requirements for health and welfare plans in the midst of the chaos related to the COVID-19 pandemic. Plan sponsors and administrators should consult with their third-party administrators, insurance providers and legal advisors to confirm that the COVID-19 guidance is incorporated into existing plan policies, procedures, participant notices and applicable plan documents.

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • When Insureds, Intermediaries and Business Partners File for Bankruptcy: Key Points for Insurers

    When Insureds, Intermediaries and Business Partners File for Bankruptcy: Key Points for Insurers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    When Insureds, Intermediaries and Business Partners File for Bankruptcy: Key Points for Insurers

    May 5, 2020

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    “Bankruptcy is about financial death and financial rebirth. Bankruptcy is the great American story rewritten. We’re a nation of debtors.” -Elizabeth Warren

    Amid the Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic and related economic turmoil, bankruptcy filings in the United States are on the rise. Insurers should review contractual arrangements with US insureds and brokers, and establish a plan to deal with bankruptcy filings across the United States in a consistent fashion.

    In depth

    As of May 1, 2020, US unemployment is above 20%; most businesses, churches and schools are still closed; and months more of economic and financial markets turmoil are in prospect. Against this backdrop, it is not unreasonable to expect a surge in business bankruptcy filings around the country. For the first three weeks of April 2020, the American Bankruptcy Institute reports 442 commercial filings, up 32.7% over the same period in 2019.

    Insurers will see more insureds filing for bankruptcy protection, and may well see a number of agents, brokers, “MGAs” and coverholders filing for bankruptcy as well.

    What should insurers know about the US bankruptcy system? What should insurers be paying attention to when insureds file? When business partners do so?

    Let’s start with the basics:

    • Federal versus State. Insurers that are in financial difficulty—unable to pay debts when due or whose liabilities exceed assets—will be dealing with state insurance regulators and state courts, rather than federal bankruptcy courts. Insolvent commercial entities (other than insurers) most likely will be handled in the federal bankruptcy system.
    • Chapter 7 versus Chapter 11. Some debtors can recover financial health, but others will not be able to do so. Chapter 7 bankruptcies result in the liquidation of the bankrupt company. Chapter 11 provides a mechanism for a company to be reorganized, recapitalized and relaunched as a solvent enterprise.
    • Automatic Stay. A bankruptcy filing prevents creditors from pursuing the debtor with respect to pre-filing or pre-petition debts; all litigation and all collection actions against the debtor are stayed.
    • Contracts. Contractual provisions that effectuate a forfeiture, modification or termination of the contract upon a bankruptcy filing are not enforceable after the filing of a bankruptcy petition.

    Practice Tips: Pay close attention to all notices received from bankruptcy courts. Within days of a bankruptcy filing, the debtor (in the case of a Chapter 11 filing) or the court-appointed trustee (in the case of a Chapter 7 filing) will notify all creditors by mail that a filing has occurred. Subsequent notices will advise creditors about (i) filing claims against the estate and of the “bar date” (the date by which such claims must be filed), and (ii) the statutorily mandated meeting of creditors, at which meeting a representative of the debtor will be examined under oath regarding the debtor’s reported assets and liabilities. Failure to assert a claim in accordance with the notice of the bar date will result in discharge of the claim.

    • “Preferences.” Subject to certain statutory defenses (including the defense that such payments were made “in the ordinary course”), payments by a debtor to a creditor during the 90 days prior to a bankruptcy filing may be clawed back by the bankrupt estate.
    • Offset/Setoff. The Bankruptcy Code recognizes the common law right of creditors to setoff amounts payable to debtors against amounts due from debtors. There are a multitude of issues arising and extensive case law to consider.

    Practice Tip: Consult a competent bankruptcy lawyer to evaluate available defenses in litigation brought to recover a payment received within the 90 days prior to a bankruptcy filing and/or rights to setoff in a particular case.

    • Official Committees. In larger Chapter 11 cases, an official committee of unsecured creditors will be appointed to participate in the proceedings. On request of a party in interest, the court also may order the appointment of additional committees of creditors or equity security holders. It may or may not be possible for you to become a committee member; in general, the larger the creditor, the more likely the creditor will want to be a member and will be selected as a member.

    Practice Tip: The Office of the US Trustee, the “bankruptcy watchdog” arm of the US Department of Justice, is tasked with appointing official committees. After a case is filed, the US Trustee will mail questionnaires to a debtor’s top 30 unsecured creditors to determine each creditor’s interest in serving on the official committee of unsecured creditors.

    Bankrupt Insureds

    • In general, insurers should be able to file claims along with all other general creditors for unpaid insurance premiums for coverage periods prior to a bankruptcy filing. Unpaid premium amounts may be more significant now than they would have been absent Coronavirus (COVID-19) orders from insurance regulators, given the many states that have imposed cancellation/nonrenewal moratoriums and/or premium payment deferrals for insureds affected by COVID-19 since early March 2020 (and that may extend and/or reimpose such moratoriums and deferrals).

    Practice Tips: Consider the following issues: Are you working with brokers to track insureds that are deferring premium payments? Particularly those with approaching anniversary/renewal dates? Do you have processes in place to negotiate and implement revised premium payment plans once moratoriums/deferral periods end? Can you offer renewal on a “premium fully earned at inception” basis? Can you offset pre-petition claims and/or return premium obligations against pre-petition premiums owed? When an insured is in bankruptcy, the automatic stay prohibits the cancellation of an insurance contract based solely upon the non-payment of pre-petition premiums owed.

    • In general, debtors continuing in business (Chapter 11 filers) will seek to confirm a variety of commercial contracts, including insurance contracts. If you are happy to continue to insure the debtor, premium payments for coverage periods after a bankruptcy filing generally should be protected during the Chapter 11 process (but if the debtor converts to a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, there is renewed exposure for pre-conversion premiums due).

    Practice Tips: Consider the following issues: Are you tracking or working with brokers to track bankruptcy filings by insureds? Have you put in place notification procedures with brokers so that you are aware of filings in the first place and going forward, so that you are aware of important dates during the bankruptcy process—e.g., “bar dates” for filing claims? Meetings of creditors? Formation of creditors’ committees?

    • Policy Buybacks. Essentially commutations, potentially useful in situations in which claims against the Chapter 7 (or equivalent) bankrupt debtor far exceed available policy limits (e.g., clergy, educational or sports-related sex abuse cases; batch claims arising from multiple medical malpractice incidents).

    Bankrupt Brokers/MGAs/Coverholders

    • Every US insurance intermediary is required to deposit premiums owed to insurers in a premium trust account. This segregated account should protect pipeline premiums.

    Practice Tips: Consider stepping up monitoring of coverholders’ financial health and perhaps the financial health of significant producers of open market business. Presumably your coverholder agreement requires the broker to submit annual audited financials, but you may wish to obtain unaudited financials on a quarterly basis. Is your premium held in a specific trust account or commingled with premiums due other insurers? Are you receiving regular periodic financial statements for all trust accounts or perhaps just those with an average balance in excess of an amount that you deem material? Does the coverholder also handle claims funds and/or have signing authority for a claims payment account? If so, you should review existing arrangements to ensure that you or a representative has access to those funds.

    Overriding Practice Issue: With the bankruptcy of a US-based “MGA” or coverholder, one key issue for a non-US insurer and the non-US broker that introduced the coverholder is to ensure that the portfolio of business is handled appropriately by a successor to the MGA or coverholder. Careful analysis of the MGA or coverholder agreement is necessary. Do you own the right to renewals in the event of MGA or coverholder bankruptcy? Do you have the right to approve or reject an assignment of contract rights? Can the bankruptcy court order the sale of assets/business of the coverholder to a third party? Should you bid on those assets if a sale is ordered? How much control do you have with respect to handling claims arising under your policies?

    Conclusion

    Regardless of the many factors unique to you and your commercial relationships with US insureds and brokers, particularly with brokers upon which you have conferred underwriting and/or claims-handling authorities, now would be an excellent time to review and consider those contractual arrangements, particularly as to handling of funds and rights available to non-US insurers and brokers upon a bankruptcy filing. Contracts drafted or signed during periods when softer market conditions prevailed should merit enhanced attention today in light of prevailing and expected economic and financial market conditions. Most importantly, have a plan in place to deal with bankruptcy filings nationwide in a consistent fashion, and consult US counsel that can provide you with coordinated bankruptcy, litigation and insurance advice when needed.

    Authors

    Thomas M. Dawson

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Andrea T. Best

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Stacy A. Lutkus

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • But Wait, There’s More! CMS Provides Additional Regulatory Relief Through Expanded Blanket Waivers

    But Wait, There’s More! CMS Provides Additional Regulatory Relief Through Expanded Blanket Waivers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    But Wait, There’s More! CMS Provides Additional Regulatory Relief Through Expanded Blanket Waivers

    May 5, 2020

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) issued blanket waivers under Section 1135 of the Social Security Act (Section 1135 waivers) on April 30, 2020. Fast on the heels of a more modest waiver announcement on April 22, 2020, the blanket waivers announced April 30 (the April 30 waivers) provides expanded flexibilities for almost all provider types, including long term care facilities, home health agencies and ambulatory surgery centers, and identify key relief related to telehealth made possible by the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act.

    For background on Section 1135 waivers previously issued, see our On the Subject, here.

    In depth

    Long Term Care Facilities

    During the Coronavirus (COVID-19) public health emergency (PHE), long term care facilities (LTCFs) may streamline their quality assurance and performance improvement (QAPI) plans to focus on adverse events and infection control. In addition, the response time in which an LTCF must provide records to requestors has been extended from two working days to 10 working days. The deadline for nurse aide in-service training, which normally requires 12 hours of training per year, has been postponed for the duration of the PHE and through the end of the first full quarter after the PHE ends. The April 30 waivers also provide a limited waiver of one component of LTCF discharge planning, to permit LTCFs to simplify the information provided to residents before discharge to a post-acute care provider.

    Home Health and Hospice

    Similar to the waivers applicable to LTCFs, home health agencies (HHAs) are permitted by the April 30 waivers to postpone the completion of home health aide training for the duration of the PHE and through the end of the first full quarter after the PHE ends. Discharge planning requirements are also similarly waived, such that HHAs need not provide detailed data on potential post-acute providers as part of the discharge planning process. Record requests may also be fulfilled in a longer time period, 10 days, rather than the usual four-day expected response time.

    Hospice providers may delay completion of certain annual skills and competency training for all individuals furnishing care as well as in-service training and education programs until the end of the first quarter after the PHE ends. Importantly, the April 30 waivers do not waive all training and competency requirements, and providers are cautioned to ensure that required training under 42 CFR Part 418 continues to the extent not waived.

    For HHAs and hospice providers, the requirement for home health aides to have an annual onsite supervisory visit by a registered nurse or other skilled professional has been relaxed, and such visits must now be completed no later than 60 days after the PHE has concluded. In addition, QAPI programs may be limited during the PHE to concentrate on infection control and adverse events.

    Ambulatory Surgery Centers

    Similar to previously announced Section 1135 waivers applicable to hospitals, the April 30 waivers provide that ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) may permit physicians whose privileges expire during the PHE to continue to practice without the completion of a reappraisal process, permitting ASCs access to a full workforce during the emergency.

    Community Mental Health Centers

    Community mental health centers (CMHCs) may operate under new flexibilities announced in the April 30 waivers. The April 30 waivers provide that CMHCs may provide certain services in individuals’ homes to further efforts to shelter in place as part of the community infection control measures taken in response to the pandemic. This waiver is linked to the recently released interim final rule (IFR) that permits billing for certain services rendered to individuals in their homes. Non-waived requirements must still be met, including the requirement of physician certification of need for partial hospitalization services, the required implementation and development of an active treatment plan for each individual served, and continued promotion of patient rights (including the rights to file a complaint).

    In addition, CMS has waived the “40% rule” which would otherwise require CMHCs to provide at least 40% of its items and services to individuals who are not Medicare beneficiaries, to expand the scope of available mental health services during the PHE. Finally, while CMHCs are expected to maintain a robust QAPI program, the detailed requirements related to the program’s organization and content are waived for the duration of the PHE to permit the program to adapt to the needs and circumstances that arise during the PHE, so long as the changes are consistent with the emergency preparedness or pandemic plan in the CMHC’s state of operation.

    Physical Environment Waiver

    The April 30 waivers include a common waiver of a physical environment requirement regarding inspection, testing and maintenance (ITM) of equipment that is otherwise applicable to hospitals (including critical access hospitals), inpatient hospice, skilled nursing facilities, nursing facilities and certain enrolled facilities for individuals with disabilities. The waiver permits ITM frequencies and activities to be adjusted due to the exigencies presented by the PHE.

    However, certain ITM are exempt from the waiver, meaning that they must continue to be completed in accordance with existing requirements. ITM not waived include sprinkler system testing, monthly fire extinguisher inspection, elevator/firefighter monthly testing, emergency generator and transfer switch testing, and egress inspection to ensure use of interim egress routes in case of emergency.

    Telehealth Flexibilities

    While granted as part of the CARES Act legislation that broadens the existing Section 1135 waiver process, CMS announced greater flexibilities related to telehealth and included them in public-facing materials regarding the April 30 waivers.

    The new waivers permit any Medicare-enrolled provider that is eligible to bill Medicare for professional services to also furnish and bill for Medicare telehealth services, dramatically expanding the availability of telehealth reimbursement to professionals, including physical and occupational therapists, speech language pathologists and others.

    CMS previously announced that Medicare would pay for certain telephone evaluation and management (E/M) services. In the interim final rule with comment period released in pre-publication form on April 30, 2020 (the IFC), CMS is increasing payments for these services consistent with payments for similar office/outpatient visits. The payment increases for these services are retroactive to March 1, 2020. CMS is also adding these services to the Medicare telehealth list. Because services on the Medicare telehealth list are otherwise required to be furnished using both audio and video, CMS is waiving requirements that these telephone E/M codes be provided using video. The IFC also expands flexibilities for opioid treatment programs (OTPs). Previously, CMS had allowed certain OTP therapy and counseling sessions to be furnished via audio-only telephone calls. Under the IFC, OTPs are also permitted to furnish periodic assessments using audio-only telephone calls rather than via two-way interactive audio-video communication technology.

    In conjunction with release of the IFC, CMS published an updated Medicare telehealth list, which reflects the addition of 46 services, bringing the total number of Medicare telehealth services to 239. Of these 239 services, 89 are also designated as requiring audio-only interaction. Many of the services designated as requiring audio-only interaction are behavioral health and patient education services.

    Key Takeaways

    The April 30 waivers continue to expand opportunities for a range of enrolled providers to operate as efficiently as possible during the PHE. As set forth in the waivers, and as detailed in the IFC, the government has taken the needs of providers into consideration as it continues to roll out these changes to participation and payment requirements. As CMS continues to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic with additional and expanded regulatory flexibilities, and as providers race to provide care under these flexibilities, keeping track of the waivers under which the provider elects to operate becomes increasingly important. The ability to recognize and document changes in operations, and to be prepared to scale them back once the emergency has concluded, will become more challenging as additional requirements are waived and providers get comfortable operating in a more flexible environment.

    Mara McDermott and Jessica Roth of McDermott+Consulting also contributed to this On the Subject.

    Authors

    Sandra M. DiVarco

    Partner

    Chicago

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Monica Wallace

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • The Pandemic, the Risk of Insolvency and Director Liability Protection

    ARTICLE

    The Pandemic, the Risk of Insolvency and Director Liability Protection

    May 5th, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Federal Circuit Confirms That Colour Marks of Certain “Character” Can Be Inherently

    ARTICLE

    Federal Circuit Confirms That Colour Marks of Certain “Character” Can Be Inherently

    May 5, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Sarah Bro

    Partner

    Orange County, Los Angeles

    More insights

  • COVID-19: FAQs on Employees Experiencing Symptoms and Employee Absences

    ARTICLE

    COVID-19: FAQs on Employees Experiencing Symptoms and Employee Absences

    May 5, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Litigating Lending Agreements During and in the Aftermath of a Pandemic

    Litigating Lending Agreements During and in the Aftermath of a Pandemic

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Litigating Lending Agreements During and in the Aftermath of a Pandemic

    May 4, 2020

    Read time: 12 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    As Coronavirus (COVID-19) continues to ravage the nation’s health and economy, in-progress deals are being reassessed by buyers, sellers and lenders. We review a number of issues that parties to financed transactions should consider in these uncertain times.

    In depth

    Coronavirus (COVID-19) continues to ravage the nation’s health and economy. In this challenging environment, deals struck prior to the crisis that have yet to close are being reassessed by all interested parties, including financiers. This article discusses various considerations that parties to a financed transaction face in these uncertain times.

    Satisfaction of Conditions Precedent

    To begin, most commercial lending agreements require the borrower to meet certain conditions precedent to the lender’s satisfaction in order for the lender to have an obligation to fund. For example, a borrower building a facility may have to demonstrate to the lender’s satisfaction that the borrower can obtain the parts and equipment necessary to build the facility or obtain the requisite governmental approvals by a certain date. Likewise, parties to a merger or asset acquisition often have a series of requirements to meet in order to close, such as obtaining various regulatory approvals. As supply chains across the world and regulatory timetables are interrupted by lockdowns caused by COVID-19, prospective borrowers’ ability to satisfy all of their conditions precedent may be impacted.

    That said, the lender’s discretion over what is “satisfactory” to the lender is not unfettered. Lenders must exercise their discretion in good faith, which means that neither party will do anything that would “have the effect of destroying or injuring the right of the other party to receive the fruits of the contract” and includes “a promise not to act arbitrarily or irrationally in exercising that discretion.” Dalton v. Educ. Testing Serv., 87 N.Y.2d 384, 389 (1995) (internal citation omitted).

    In addition, parties to any contract—including merger and acquisition agreements as well as loan and other financing agreements—cannot take action deliberately designed to sabotage or otherwise frustrate the performance of the contract. See, e.g., Thompson v. Advanced Armament Corp., LLC, 614 F. App’x 523, 525 (2d Cir. 2015); Hexion Specialty Chems., Inc. v. Huntsman Corp., 965 A.2d 715, 749 (Del. Ch. 2008). Accordingly, it is important for all parties to document their decision-making process both with their respective counterparties and internally to demonstrate that the party is acting in good faith and reasonably based on the agreements and prevailing market conditions.

    Force Majeure

    Most commercial loan agreements do not contain force majeure clauses that would excuse the parties from performing in the event of, for example, a pandemic such as COVID-19. Force majeure in commercial lending generally arises in connection with construction loans.

    Construction loan agreements typically contain covenants regarding the commencement, prosecution and final completion of whatever is to be constructed with the loan proceeds. Construction loan agreements may, however, recognize that certain events—such as those deemed to be a force majeure—are beyond the parties’ control and thus may excuse performance at least for a period of time. Philip Lane Bruner & Patrick J. O’Connor, 2A Bruner & O’Connor Construction Law § 7:229 (2020).

    The mere presence of a force majeure clause in an agreement is not conclusive as to whether performance will be excused. The party invoking such a provision must demonstrate that (i) the force majeure event was outside the party’s control, (ii) the force majeure event was not reasonably foreseeable by the parties, (iii) the force majeure event materially affects the party’s ability to perform their contractual obligations, and (iv) the party took all reasonable steps to avoid or mitigate the relevant event.

    The outcome of this analysis is heavily dependent on the specific context of the situation, including the unique terms of the governing contract and applicable law and facts. In addition, some courts construe force majeure clauses narrowly by, for example, excusing performance “only if the force majeure clause specifically includes the event that actually prevents a party’s performance” and confining catch-all phrases to the same types of events explicitly mentioned in the clause. Kel Kim Corp. v. Cent. Markets, Inc., 70 N.Y.2d 900, 902-03 (1987); David J. Ball, et al., Contractual Performance In The Age Of Coronavirus: Force Majeure, Impossibility And Other Considerations, The National Law Review (Mar. 18, 2020). Accordingly, it is important for parties to review both the language of any force majeure clause and the case law from the jurisdiction whose law governs the agreement.

    Injunctions and Specific Performance

    If a lender refuses to fund a loan, the parties may litigate not only whether there was a breach of the lending agreement, but if so, the appropriate remedy if a breach is found. A disappointed borrower will often seek an injunction and/or specific performance compelling the lender to fund. The borrower also typically seeks monetary damages as an alternate remedy in case an injunction or specific performance is not awarded.

    An injunction or award of specific performance compelling the lender to loan is appropriate where (i) there is a valid contract, (ii) plaintiff has substantially performed under the contract and is willing and able to perform its remaining obligations, (iii) defendant is able to perform its obligations and (iv) plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law. Goodman Mfg. Co. L.P. v. Raytheon Co., No. 98 Civ. 2774(LAP), 1999 WL 681382, at *10 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 31, 1999). A plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law when the damages are irreparable (i.e., cannot be fully compensated with monetary damages that can be measured to a reasonable degree of certainty). Lucente v. Int’l Bus. Mach. Corp., 310 F.3d 243, 262 (2d Cir. 2002); Burke v. Bowen, 40 N.Y.2d 264, 267 (1976). Accordingly, the general rule is that an agreement to lend money will not be specifically enforced unless “the breaching party is the only source of funds for the injured party to borrow” or “[w]here a tight money market makes it difficult for the plaintiff to obtain a substitute loan or makes the amount of damages speculative because of rapidly rising interest rates . . . .” Charles L. Knapp, Commercial Damages: A Guide to Remedies in Business Litigation ¶ 12.05 (1997).

    In the merger context, several courts have considered that the opportunity to acquire a business is unique, and therefore may warrant an award of specific performance because the buyer’s damages from being unable to consummate the acquisition are not fully compensable with money. BT Triple Crown Merger Co., Inc. v. Citigroup Global Market, Inc., 2008 WL 1970900, at *7-9 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. May 7, 2008); Triple-A Baseball Club Assocs. v. N.E. Baseball, Inc., 832 F.2d 214, 223-24 (1st Cir. 1987); In re IBP, Inc. S’holders Litig., 789 A.2d 14, 82 (Del. Ch. 2001); Allegheny Energy, Inc. v. DOE, Inc., 171 F.3d 153, 163-64 (3d Cir. 1999); Rand-Whitney Packaging Corp. v. Robertson Grp., Inc., 651 F. Supp. 520, 538 (D. Mass. 1986). For example, in BT Triple Crown, the court held that there were triable issues of fact as to whether (i) the target company was “unique,” (ii) alternate financing can be procured for the acquisition (which was the subject of expert testimony) and (iii) the buyer’s money damages can be proven with reasonable certainty. 2008 WL 1970900, at *7-9.

    In the non-merger context, courts are more likely to compel a lender to fund if the loan is tied to real estate in some way. For example, in Destiny USA Holdings, LLC v. Citigroup Global Markets Realty Corp., 69 A.D.3d 212 (4th Dep’t 2009), the court affirmed the grant of a preliminary injunction requiring a lender to fund a construction development. The court observed that cases involving construction mortgages are an exception to the general rule that agreements to lend cannot be specifically enforced:

    Since the law regards land as unique, an agreement to buy land can be specifically enforced even though the defendant’s sole obligation is to pay money. Although the question is close, it may not be too great a stretch to include advances under a construction mortgage. In such circumstances, the agreement is not a simple contract to lend money. It is an integral part of a contract to sell or develop real property.

    Destiny, 69 A.D.3d at 220-21 (internal quotation marks and citation omitted).

    Among other things, the court noted that the construction project at issue was both unique and relevant to public interest, in that it had a “revolutionary” financing model that was based on both private and public money, and furthered a “green” climate change-friendly mission. Id. at 214, 221. Given these unique qualities, some commentators have observed that Destiny USA‘s broader application to other types of financing agreements may be limited. See, e.g., Kenneth Jacobson, et al., Destiny v. Citigroup – What It Means for Lenders, Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP (Aug. 4, 2009); Janice Mac Avoy & David Charles Pollack, When Construction Lenders Stop Funding, New York Law Journal (June 21, 2010).

    Damages: Direct Versus Consequential

    If specific performance is not awarded, then the issue becomes what, if any, damages are recoverable and how to measure them. Notably, most loan agreements contain restrictions on recovering consequential, exemplary, special or punitive damages. Such restrictions are typically enforced. See, e.g., Mu Chapter Of Sigma Pi Fraternity Of U.S. Inc. v. Ne. Const. Servs. Inc., 273 A.D.2d 579, 581 (3rd Dep’t 2000); U.S. Bank Nat. Ass’n v. DLJ Mortg. Capital, Inc., Index No. 650369/2013, 2013 WL 6997183, at *4 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. Jan. 15, 2013), aff’d, 121 A.D.3d 535 (1st Dep’t 2014); Farm Family Mut. Ins. Co. v. Moore Bus. Forms, Inc., 164 Misc. 2d 656, 659 (Sup. Ct. Albany Co. 1995).

    There is often debate, however, over whether certain damages qualify as “direct” (also known as “general”) damages as opposed to “consequential” damages. As the New York State Court of Appeals has held, “[g]eneral damages are the natural and probable consequence of the breach of a contract. They include money that the breaching party agreed to pay under the contract. By contrast, consequential, or special, damages do not directly flow from the breach.” Biotronik A.G. v. Conor Medsys. Ireland, Ltd., 22 N.Y.3d 799, 805 (2014) (internal quotation marks and citations omitted).

    Typically, if alternate financing is available, courts will measure damages as the difference between the contracted for rate of interest and the rate of interest at the time of the breach over the term of the loan, discounted to present value and subject to a foreseeability requirement. Int’l Fid. Ins. Co. v. Cty. of Rockland, 98 F. Supp. 2d 400, 416 (S.D.N.Y. 2000); Teachers Ins. & Annuity Ass’n of Am. v. Butler, 626 F. Supp. 1229, 1236 (S.D.N.Y. 1986). If alternate financing is not available, then the borrower has a stronger case for specific performance.

    Amending the Agreements

    As the effects of COVID-19 continue to weigh down the economy, parties may seek to renegotiate their deal. Before amending an agreement as a result of the pandemic by, for example, extending the closing date, parties must consider that a delayed closing or other material changes may trigger a lender’s right to walk away from the transaction, or result in additional fees or otherwise more expensive debt. Accordingly, parties should consider the extent to which their agreement addresses their ability to renegotiate with the lender or obtain alternate financing.

    For instance, the purchaser in a merger or acquisition agreement may have included a clause relieving the buyer of any obligation to seek to compel the lender to lend or otherwise to obtain alternate financing. An example of such a clause reads:

    Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Agreement, in no event shall the efforts of the Purchaser be deemed or construed to require, the Purchaser to (i) bring any enforcement action against any financing source to enforce its rights under any lending agreement, (ii) seek equity financing in any amount in excess of that contemplated by the Purchaser’s equity commitment letter, (iii) seek or accept debt financing on terms less favorable than the terms and conditions described in the debt commitment letters as determined in the reasonable judgment of the Purchaser, or (iv) pay any fees in excess of those contemplated by the debt commitment letters (whether to secure waiver of any conditions contained therein or otherwise).

    Alternatively, the buyer may have agreed to keep the seller informed of financing changes and/or to not change materially the terms of financing.

    Of course, a buyer and a seller can always agree to amend their deal and alter such obligations. However, absent an agreement otherwise with the lender, the lender likely has no obligation to accept the changes if they materially affect the terms of the financing.

     

    Takeaways

    In view of the foregoing, parties to any financing that may be impacted by COVID-19 or otherwise should consider the following when assessing an actual or potential dispute over funding obligations:

    • Carefully review the force majeure clause in any of the transaction documents to determine whether any party’s performance may be delayed or excused, which, as detailed above, is a highly fact-specific and often strict inquiry depending on the governing law.
    • Carefully review any provisions in the transaction documents for clauses that speak to any obligation to obtain financing for the transaction, including alternate financing if the in-place financing falls through.
    • Carefully review all conditions precedent to performance and carefully document whether and when the conditions have been satisfied.
    • If the lender does not fund, document the availability of all efforts to obtain alternate financing available and on what terms. Line up one or more experts to opine on the issue and testify if necessary.
    • Identify the extent to which the non-breaching party cannot be fully compensated by an award of monetary damages, such as if the subject matter of the transaction is unique in some way or if any damages cannot be measured to a reasonable certainty for any other reason.
    • Itemize all potential damages and assess all damages limitation provisions, including the extent to which any damages were foreseeable by the parties at the time of contracting and can be measured to a reasonable degree of certainty. Again consider lining up one or more experts to assess these issues and testify if necessary.

    Following these steps will help best position a party for any dispute with its counterparties in these difficult times and maximize the likelihood of a positive outcome.

    Authors

    Andrew B. Kratenstein

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • President Trump’s Executive Order on US Bulk Power System Electric Equipment: Questions and Analysis

    President Trump’s Executive Order on US Bulk Power System Electric Equipment: Questions and Analysis

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    President Trump’s Executive Order on US Bulk Power System Electric Equipment: Questions and Analysis

    May 4, 2020

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    President Trump’s May 1, 2020, Executive Order prohibiting certain transactions involving bulk-power system electric equipment developed, manufactured or supplied by a foreign adversary could have far-reaching implications for both the renewable and conventional power industries. The breadth of the Executive Order raises key questions and concerns for sponsors and developers of energy projects, construction contractors and energy project investors.

    In depth

    On May 1, 2020, President Trump issued an Executive Order (EO) prohibiting certain transactions involving “bulk-power system electric equipment” developed, manufactured or supplied by a “foreign adversary” if the Secretary of Energy, in consultation with the heads of other agencies, determines that the transaction raises significant national security concerns. The EO is ostensibly aimed at addressing the threat that foreign adversaries could exploit vulnerabilities in the US electrical grid to malicious effect. However, the EO could have far-reaching implications for both the renewable and conventional power industries if the EO prevents the import of certain critical equipment for new power or existing power projects or, in certain circumstances, prevents the sale of any interests in those projects (including tax equity interests).

    Energy industry participants, including sponsors and developers of energy projects, construction contractors and energy project investors, are asking questions regarding the implications of the new EO on the US bulk power system and what the order means for their projects under development and construction (and existing energy projects). For stakeholders in the power sector, the breadth of the EO raises a number of key questions and concerns, which will hopefully be clarified in forthcoming guidance. Below are some of the initial issues raised by the EO.

    ANALYSIS OF ORDER:

    What countries are implicated by the EO?

    The EO applies to bulk-power system electric equipment “designed, developed, manufactured, or supplied, by persons owned by, controlled by, or subject to the jurisdiction or direction of a foreign adversary.” The term “foreign adversary” is not defined, and no particular country is specified in the EO. However, because Chinese companies are key suppliers of equipment to the US power sector, and the Trump administration has consistently targeted China as a trade adversary and threat to US national security, many observers believe the EO intends primarily to curtail Chinese access to, and Chinese industrial equipment sales serving, the US bulk power system. The new EO follows a series of Trump administration trade actions against China, including the imposition of tariffs on virtually all imports from China under Section 301 of the Trade Act, prosecution for trade violations of major Chinese companies including Huawei and ZTE, export restrictions thwarting involvement of those Chinese companies in the US telecom industry, and concerted focus by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) on US national security interests affected by Chinese investments in US businesses.

    To what equipment does the EO apply?

    While the EO specifically refers to “bulk-power system electrical equipment,” there are really two definitions at play here. The first is “bulk-power system,” which, as outlined below, is a system necessary to maintain interconnected transmission systems and maintain reliability. The definition of “bulk-power system electrical equipment” is electrical equipment necessary to maintain the “bulk-power system.” The examples of such equipment could appear to go beyond equipment merely needed to maintain the transmission system and ensure reliability, however.

    • For purposes of the EO, “bulk-power system” is defined as “(i) facilities and control systems necessary for operating an interconnected electric energy transmission network (or any portion thereof); and (ii) electric energy from generation facilities needed to maintain transmission reliability.” The definition includes transmission facilities rated 69 kV or higher, but excludes electric distribution facilities.
    • “Bulk-power system electric equipment” potentially subject to the EO includes “items used in bulk-power system substations, control rooms, or power generating stations, including reactors, capacitors, substation transformers, current coupling capacitors, large generators, backup generators, substation voltage regulators, shunt capacitor equipment, automatic circuit reclosers, instrument transformers, coupling capacity voltage transformers, protective relaying, metering equipment, high voltage circuit breakers, generation turbines, industrial control systems, distributed control systems, and safety instrumented systems.”
    • The EO’s definition of “bulk-power system” is substantively identical to the definition of that term under Section 215 of the Federal Power Act, which gives the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) jurisdiction over electric reliability matters affecting the bulk-power system. It is perhaps noteworthy that, notwithstanding FERC’s responsibilities in this area, FERC’s chairman is not identified as one of the agency heads to be included in the Task Force. Nor is FERC identified as an agency with which the Secretary must consult in implementing the EO.
    • The EO does not apply to distributed generation facilities (such as commercial or residential solar or storage projects).

    Does the EO apply to utility-scale wind, solar or battery storage projects?

    While distributed solar or wind is not covered by the order, the issue becomes whether the language is broad enough to include utility-scale wind or solar or large-scale energy storage projects. Nothing in the EO suggests that it applies to these projects. On a close reading of the definition, with the possible exception of substation equipment, neither wind equipment, solar equipment nor large-scale batteries should be included. However, the inclusion of the terms “generating power stations” and “generation turbines” creates some uncertainty. Further, the statement in the EO that it only applies to generation facilities that are necessary to “maintain transmission reliability” could be a vague reference to generation sources other than wind and solar (since those technologies have been challenged by coal and nuclear interests as “less reliable”). That said, it would be surprising that such a large proportion of new-build power projects in the United States would be categorically exempt from the EO.

    To what type of transactions does the EO apply?

    The EO applies to the “acquisition, importation, transfer, or installation” of any bulk-power system electric equipment designed, developed, manufactured or supplied by persons owned by, controlled by, or subject to the jurisdiction or direction of a by foreign adversary that threatens national security. In other words, the EO could apply broadly not only to equipment supply purchases directly from original equipment manufacturers, but also to any downstream purchases or incorporation of such equipment in power projects. It could even apply, for example, to transfers in connection with establishing a tax equity partnership for renewable power transactions.

    • Implementation of the EO will require inter-agency coordination, rulemaking and procedures. The EO directs the Energy Secretary to coordinate with the US Departments of Homeland Security, Commerce and Defense, among others, which may involve new requirements and focus on targeted imports (customs rules), exports and transfers (trade controls), and foreign investments in US bulk-power equipment businesses (CFIUS reviews).

    What considerations will the US Department of Energy use to determine whether equipment supply poses a threat to US national security?

    US “national security,” which also underlies the Trump administration tariff action on steel and aluminum under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act and all reviews by CFIUS, remains undefined. Instead, as in the CFIUS and Section 232 contexts, “national security” is framed as a series of factors to be considered. Thus, the EO directs the Secretary of Energy, in consultation with other department heads, to determine one of the following in order to impose the applicable prohibitions: the transaction must pose (1) “an undue risk of sabotage” to the operation or maintenance of the US bulk-power system, (2) an undue risk of “catastrophic effects” on the security or resiliency of US critical infrastructure or economy, or (3) an “unacceptable risk” to US national security. As in the CFIUS and Section 232 contexts, these factors allow significant discretion to the Department of Energy for imposing the prohibitions.

    What is the effective date of the EO?

    This is unclear. The EO states that it applies to “transaction[s] . . . initiated after the date of this order,” although another part of the EO states that it applies “notwithstanding any contract entered into or any license or permit granted prior to the date of this order.” This suggests, for example, that new purchase orders placed under master supply contracts that are already signed and downstream sales of projects incorporating prohibited equipment already installed could both be blocked.

    Will the EO just apply to new equipment orders?

    One troubling aspect of the EO is that it instructs the Energy Secretary to “develop recommendations on ways to identify, isolate, monitor, or replace” targeted equipment, meaning that, depending on the scope and nature of forthcoming regulations, projects that have incorporated target equipment could have to replace such equipment in the future. Parties would do well to think about these potential implications when negotiating contracts with counterparties to appropriately allocate risk of future replacement (and costs and delays associated with such replacement).

    NEXT STEPS TO BE TAKEN BY SECRETARY OF ENERGY:

    The Department of Energy provided an initial overview of the EO.

    The EO directs the Secretary of Energy, in consultation with other relevant department heads, to identify “as soon as practicable” bulk-power system electric equipment that would raise the national security risks mentioned in the EO.

    The Secretary of Energy, in consultation with the heads of other agencies, is also allowed to publish a list of pre-approved equipment vendors.

    The EO establishes a task force, headed by the Secretary of Energy or the Secretary’s designee, that will produce a set of energy infrastructure procurement policies for the US government and will produce an annual report summarizing its findings.

    The Secretary of Energy is directed to publish rules and regulations implementing the EO by September 28, 2020.

    WHAT NEXT?

    While the industry waits for the Secretary of Energy to publish rules and regulations implementing the EO, the industry must live under this cloud of uncertainty. It would seem difficult, but not impossible, to later challenge good faith attempts to comply with the EO. Therefore, in the meantime, we would expect that many developers and owners will stay the course on building and operating existing projects. On new projects or those where changes in equipment suppliers can be made, we would expect to see some international manufacturers avoided. We may also see extra diligence applied in purchase and sale transactions for projects that could include equipment that may be later determined to be prohibited by the EO. While the EO refers to new transactions, it is not completely clear that existing projects are exempt. Hopefully, the Secretary of Energy’s regulations will properly clarify this issue.

    The team at McDermott is monitoring these issues and addressing client-specific inquiries as well, including providing advice regarding structuring transactions and allocating risks associated with the EO. We will continue to provide updates on the implementation of the EO regulations as they are developed.

    Authors

    Joel A. Hugenberger

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Christopher Gladbach

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Edward Zaelke

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Neil L. Levy

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    David G. Tewksbury

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    David J. Levine

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Raymond Paretzky

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • What You Must Disclose on Cybersecurity

    ARTICLE

    What You Must Disclose on Cybersecurity

    May 4, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights