Content Type: Article

  • Benefit Plan Updates (COVID-19)

    Benefit Plan Updates (COVID-19)

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Benefit Plan Updates (COVID-19)

    May 19, 2020

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Department of Labor (“DOL”), in conjunction with the Department of the Treasury, the Internal Revenue Service and the Department of Health and Human Services (collectively, the “Agencies”), recently issued guidance that provides a host of relief to ERISA benefit plan sponsors, participants and beneficiaries extending the timeframe for certain deadlines that would otherwise arise during the period between March 1, 2020 through 60 days after the declared end of the COVID-19 pandemic (or a later date that may be declared by the Agencies) (“Outbreak Period”), including providing certain participant communications, submitting claims and appeals, rolling over certain eligible distributions, enrolling in COBRA, taking advantage of certain special enrollment rights in light of the COVID-19 pandemic as well as increasing flexibility with respect to elections under employer-sponsored health plans, health flexible spending accounts (“FSAs”) and dependent care assistance programs (“DCAPs”). The purpose of the relief is to ensure that sponsors of, and participants and beneficiaries in, qualified plans have the flexibility and necessary amount of time to make important decisions regarding their health and pension benefits.

    Deadlines Extended for Participants and Beneficiaries

    Health Plans. For ERISA-covered health plans, the Outbreak Period shall be disregarded when determining whether a participant timely:

    • Enrolls in the plan due to a special enrollment right (e.g., after the birth or adoption of a child, or losing coverage under another plan) (without this extension, the deadline for enrolling is generally 30 days after the event leading to the special enrollment right);
    • Notifies the plan of a COBRA-qualifying event, including a divorce, legal separation, a determination of a disability that could lead to extended COBRA coverage;
    • Elects COBRA coverage (without this extension, the deadline for electing COBRA coverage is generally 60 days after the participant receives his or her COBRA election notice or actually loses coverage under the plan, whichever is later);
    • Makes COBRA premium payments (without this extension, the deadline for the initial COBRA premium payment is generally 45 days after electing COBRA coverage, with premiums due monthly thereafter, subject to any grace period available under the terms of the plan);
    • Files a claim for health benefits, or appeals an adverse benefit decision, under the plan’s claims and appeals procedures; or
    • Files a request for an external review of an adverse benefit determination, or files additional information if such request was incomplete (applicable only to non-grandfathered health plans).

    Retirement Plans. For ERISA-covered qualified pension plans, the Outbreak Period shall be disregarded when determining whether a participant timely:

    • Files a claim for pension benefits, or appeals an adverse benefit decision, under the plan’s claims and appeals procedures.

    Participants in qualified pension plans that accept rollovers of eligible distributions can now roll over eligible distributions within 60 days of receipt of the distribution or July 15, 2020, whichever is later.

    Deadlines Extended for Plan Sponsors

    Plan sponsors of qualified pension plans can also take advantage of the Outbreak Period for the following:

    • Distributing certain participant communications (to the extent such communications had not already been sent at the time the guidance was issued). This includes annual funding notices, SPDs, SMMs, pension benefit statements, COBRA notices, claims and appeals notices, blackout notices and the multiemployer plan summary reports that are required under Section 104(d) of ERISA. Because the guidance requires plans to make good-faith efforts to provide the communications as soon as administratively feasible, plans should make best efforts to continue to provide participant communications on a timely basis. The DOL specified that good-faith acts include the use of electronic communications if the fiduciary reasonably believes the participant or beneficiary has effective access to such mode of communication, including email, text messages and continuous access websites.
    • Transmitting participant contributions or repayment of a participant loan within the prescribed timeframes (generally on the earliest date on which such amounts can reasonably be segregated from the employer’s general assets). Employers must act reasonably, prudently and in the interest of employees to comply as soon as administratively practicable under the circumstances.
    • Filing the Form 5500 Annual Return/Report.

    Health Plan Sponsor Considerations

    New Model COBRA Notice and COBRA Procedures

    In conjunction with this new guidance, the DOL has updated its model COBRA notice and election forms. These new forms now clarify for participants how COBRA and Medicare interact for purposes of enrolling in either (or both) for coverage, which coverage pays primary or secondary, and whether enrolling in Medicare can lead to an early termination of COBRA coverage. The new COBRA notices do not, however, address the temporary extensions described herein about the COBRA deadlines due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Plan sponsors, employers and third-party administrators may wish to review their current COBRA policies and practices to ensure they are issuing the appropriate COBRA notices on a timely basis to COBRA qualified beneficiaries, especially in light of the recent spate of class-action lawsuits against large companies alleging failure to timely provide such notices.

    Mid-Year Changes to Cafeteria Plans

    The IRS recently issued a notice that allows plan sponsors of cafeteria plans, including both self-insured and fully-insured group health plans, in their discretion, to permit employees to make prospective mid-year election changes under employer-sponsored group health plans, FSAs and DCAPs. For example, employers that sponsor group health plans can amend their plans prospectively to allow employees who make salary reduction contributions under the plan to:

    • Make a new election for coverage under a group health plan, even if the employee initially declined coverage during open enrollment and is not eligible for a special enrollment right (as discussed above);
    • Revoke an existing election for coverage under a group health plan and make a new election to enroll in a different plan sponsored by the employer (for example, by changing an election from single coverage to family coverage);
    • Completely revoke an existing election for coverage under a group health plan, but only if the employee attests in writing that he or she is enrolled, or immediately will enroll, in other health coverage not sponsored by the employer, and only if the employer does not have actual knowledge to the contrary;
    • Revoke an election, make a new election or decrease or increase an existing election regarding an FSA (including a limited purpose FSA that is provided in conjunction with a health savings account) and/or a DCAP on a prospective basis; and
    • Provide an extended period of time to apply unused amounts in a FSA or DCAP with a grace or carryover period for medical or dependent care expenses incurred through Dec. 31, 2020.

    Plan sponsors can choose to implement any or all of the above mid-year election changes as long as they are implemented prospectively and any changes do not cause the plan to run afoul of other applicable rules and regulations, including the nondiscrimination rules that apply to self-insured health plans. If implementing any of these newly-permissible mid-year election changes, plan sponsors will need to notify participants accordingly and timely amend their plan documents (no later than Dec. 31, 2021).

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ian. L. Levin, Ronald E. Richman, Susan E. Bernstein and Melissa J. Sandak.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, or wish to update your plan documents and participant communications to reflect these relief measures, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This is a fast-moving topic and the information contained in this Alert is current as of the date it was published.

    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ian L. Levin

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Importance of CCPA Compliance Highlighted by First Round of Private Actions

    Importance of CCPA Compliance Highlighted by First Round of Private Actions

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Importance of CCPA Compliance Highlighted by First Round of Private Actions

    May 18, 2020

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The first wave of California Consumer Privacy Act litigation has begun to roll in, and the complaints are already raising interesting questions about the scope of CCPA’s private right of action. The actions assert a variety of claims under numerous theories and present a broad range of potential risks to businesses subject to CCPA. In light of the many questions that surround CCPA’s private right of action, the extent of possible liability from private litigation is still largely unknown and potentially significant.

    In depth

    The first wave of private lawsuits filed under the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) has begun to roll in, and the complaints are already raising interesting questions about the scope of CCPA’s private right of action. The recent explosion in popularity of video conferencing and social media software in response to the COVID-19 pandemic—and the technical issues some of these products have experienced—has inspired its own wave of litigation, with several cases alleging violations of CCPA along with other laws. The flurry of litigation activity makes clear the importance of CCPA compliance, particularly in the current challenging business environment. Although it’s too early to tell how these lawsuits will play out, some themes are emerging.

    Refresher on CCPA Private Right of Action

    Businesses are now familiar with the long list of privacy obligations imposed by CCPA and enforceable by the California attorney general. Although CCPA contains a private right of action, that right is applicable only to CCPA’s sole data security provision. Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.150 authorizes consumers to institute a civil action against a business whose failure to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures resulted in the unauthorized access and exfiltration, theft or disclosure of the consumer’s nonencrypted and nonredacted personal information. The definition of “personal information” in the context of § 1798.150 is narrower than the expansive definition applicable to other CCPA provisions, applying only to an individual’s name together with an identifying data element, such as a Social Security number, driver’s license number or medical information. A plaintiff may seek injunctive or declaratory relief, actual damages or statutory damages in an amount not less than $100 and not greater than $750 per consumer, per incident. Before seeking statutory damages, however, the consumer must provide the business 30 days’ written notice to cure the alleged violation. The “notice and cure” provision is the subject of some controversy, because CCPA does not explain how a violation that resulted in a data breach can be “cured.” CCPA also explicitly prohibits consumers from using alleged violation of its provisions “to serve as the basis for a private right of action under any other law,” thus, in theory, prohibiting a plaintiff from alleging that a CCPA violation constitutes a violation of the California Unfair Competition Law, Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 17200, et seq. or other statutes. That hasn’t stopped plaintiffs from trying, as described below.

    Theme #1: Suits Brought as Class Actions

    Most, if not all, of the lawsuits brought under CCPA thus far have been brought as class actions. (Taylor v. Zoom Video Communications, Inc., No. 5:20-cv-02170 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 31, 2020) (Taylor); Hurvitz v. Zoom Video Communications, Inc. et al., No. 2:20-cv-03400 (C.D. Cal. Apr. 13, 2020) (Hurvitz); Sweeney v. Life on Air, Inc. et al., No. 3:20-cv-00742 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 17, 2020) (Sweeney)). This result was anticipated, as the damages element of the CCPA private right of action encourages class actions. Plaintiffs are able to obtain statutory damages, and they can obtain them on a per incident, per customer basis. Plaintiffs have, unsurprisingly, been enticed by the ability to obtain significant damages without proving actual harm.

    Theme #2: Complaints Not Limited to CCPA Claims

    Many of the actions brought so far contain claims under other statutes or common law. In Fuentes v. Sunshine Behavioral Health Group LLC, No. 8:20-cv-00487 (C.D. Cal. Mar. 10, 2020) (Fuentes), the plaintiffs brought 11 claims in addition to the CCPA claim, both statutory and common law, including claims of negligence, negligence per se, breach of contract and breach of implied contract. Likewise, in both the Taylor and Hurvitz class action complaints, the plaintiffs brought six claims in addition to asserted violations of CCPA. Though not unexpected, this pattern demonstrates that businesses must be prepared to defend a wide range of claims in addition to any alleged CCPA violations.

    Theme #3: Leveraging CCPA to Make Other Claims

    Rather than make claims under CCPA, several plaintiffs have used violations of CCPA as a springboard from which to make claims under other statutes. In Hurvitz, the plaintiffs allege that defendant Zoom Video Communications (Zoom) violated the provision of CCPA requiring a business to provide notice to consumers of the categories and uses of personal information it collects at or before the point of collection, and prohibiting the business from collecting additional categories of personal information or using personal information for additional purposes without providing additional notice. (See Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.100(b); Hurvitz Complaint, ¶ 213.) Because a literal reading of CCPA would prohibit private plaintiffs from enforcing these provisions, the Hurvitz plaintiffs instead allege that the violation constitutes an unlawful practice in violation of the California Unfair Competition Law, Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 17200, et seq. A complaint filed this past week uses CCPA in a similar manner. (See Saint Paulus Lutheran Church et al. v. Zoom Video Communications, Inc., No. 5:20-cv-03252 (N.D. Cal. May 13, 2020) (Saint Paulus Lutheran Church).)

    The Hurvitz and Saint Paulus Lutheran Church plaintiffs’ attempt to use CCPA to allege an unfair trade practices claim creates interesting questions for the courts to address. As noted above, CCPA prohibits private plaintiffs from using any of its provisions to serve as the basis for a private right of action under any other law. (See Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.150(c).) Therefore, it is not clear that claims such as those made by the Hurvitz and Saint Paulus Lutheran Church plaintiffs are authorized by CCPA. If such claims are upheld, they would create a functional back-door private right of action for the privacy provisions of CCPA.

    Theme #4: Actions Filed in Federal Court

    Most, if not all, of the CCPA actions to date have been filed in federal court. (See, e.g., Taylor, Hurvitz, Sweeney, Fuentes, Saint Paulus Lutheran Church, Barnes v. Hanna Andersson LLC, No. 3:20-cv-00812 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 9, 2020).) The jurisdictional basis for such actions is the Class Action Fairness Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1332(d), which provides for federal jurisdiction for class-action claims comprising a class of at least 100 members and alleging an amount in controversy of at least $5 million, provided that minimal diversity exists (i.e., at least one plaintiff must be domiciled in a different state than at least one defendant). The fact that these claims have been brought in federal court creates an interesting dynamic whereby the federal courts may have the opportunity to examine and adjudicate CCPA before California state courts do. This trend may incentivize the California attorney general to bring early enforcement actions to establish binding precedent in state courts before many cases are adjudicated by the federal courts.

    Theme #5: Claims Brought for Violations of CCPA Privacy Provisions

    Although CCPA’s private right of action is explicitly limited to allegations of injury suffered in the context of data breaches arising from the defendant’s failure to provide “reasonable security,” plaintiffs are nonetheless bringing claims for violations of the privacy provisions of CCPA. The Sweeney plaintiffs, for instance, alleged violations of (i) Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.100(b), requiring notice at or before the point at which personal information is collected and limiting additional uses of personal information; (ii) Cal. Civ. Code §1798.120(b), requiring a business to provide notice of the right to opt-out of sales of personal information; (iii) Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.135(a)(1), requiring a “Do Not Sell My Personal Information” link on a business’s homepage and (iv) Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.135(a)(6), requiring a business using information collected in connection with an opt-out request solely to comply with the opt-out request. (See Sweeney Complaint, ¶¶ 102-105.) Likewise, the Taylor plaintiffs alleged violations of Cal. Civ. Code §§ 1798.100(b) and 1798.120(b). (See Taylor Complaint, ¶¶ 131-132.) Although none of these claims appears to be sustainable under the plain text of CCPA, it remains for the courts to clarify the scope of the private right of action.

    Theme #6: Creative Applications of Private Right of Action

    Plaintiffs are also bringing claims that will force courts to confront some of the more ambiguous provisions of CCPA’s private right of action for data breaches. In Cullen v. Zoom Video Communications, Inc., No. 5:20-cv-02155 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 30, 2020) (Cullen), for instance, the complaint alleges that the defendant violated its duty to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices, resulting in the unauthorized disclosure of plaintiffs’ nonencrypted and nonredacted personal information. (See Cullen Complaint ¶ 34.) For a period of time, Zoom’s iOS app featured a digital advertising platform’s software development kit (SDK) that collected certain device identifiers, such as device carrier, device model and time zone. Several days after an article was published on the SDK, Zoom released a blog post stating that it had been unaware that the SDK was collecting the device identifiers, and had removed the SDK from the iOS client. The Cullen complaint appears to allege (i) that Zoom’s decision to remove the SDK demonstrates that the access to and disclosure of the device identifiers was unauthorized and (ii) Zoom’s ability to quickly remedy the problem demonstrates that Zoom failed to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices. (See Cullen Complaint ¶ 37.)

    The Cullen complaint may bring some clarity to the meaning of the terms “unauthorized access” and “reasonable security procedures and practices” in the CCPA’s private right of action. Although the private right of action is widely understood to protect only against data breaches, the Cullen plaintiffs make at least a colorable allegation that the right of action may apply to exchanges of information between business partners. The Cullen claim may fail on other grounds—it does not appear that the device identifiers at issue constitute “personal information,” and it’s not clear the plaintiffs provided the statutorily required 30 days’ notice to cure—but the case nonetheless raises important questions about the extent of the private right of action. If the Cullen or similar claims are successful, the scope of culpability under the private right of action could be expansive.

    Takeaways

    The first round of CCPA litigation drives home the point that CCPA is being enforced. The actions assert a variety of claims under numerous theories and present a broad range of potential risks to businesses subject to CCPA. In light of the many questions that surround CCPA’s private right of action, the extent of possible liability from private litigation is still largely unknown and potentially significant.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Hair of the Dog? Ninth Circuit Finds That Squeaker Toy Is Expressive Work

    ARTICLE

    Hair of the Dog? Ninth Circuit Finds That Squeaker Toy Is Expressive Work

    May 18, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Eleanor B. Atkins

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Litigating Lending Agreements During and After Pandemic

    Litigating Lending Agreements During and After Pandemic

    ARTICLE

    Litigating Lending Agreements During and After Pandemic

    May 18, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Andrew B. Kratenstein

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Chelsea Cosillos

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Further Tightening of Germany’s Foreign Investment Control Regime

    ARTICLE

    Further Tightening of Germany’s Foreign Investment Control Regime

    May 18, 2020

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On 8 April 2020, the German Federal Government adopted an amendment act of the German Foreign Trade and Payments Act (AWG) and thus opened the way for the parliamentary procedure. The legislative procedure is expected to be completed and the new act (Act) shall enter into effect in autumn 2020. The purpose of the draft Act is to adapt the German legal framework to the requirements of the European Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Screening Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2019/452 of 19 March 2019) and to further tighten the investigation and control regime for foreign investments in German target companies.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Back to the Future: Employer Considerations for Returning to the Workplace

    Back to the Future: Employer Considerations for Returning to the Workplace

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Back to the Future: Employer Considerations for Returning to the Workplace

    May 18, 2020

    Read time: 31 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    As government mandated stay-at-home orders are eased or lifted, employers will be presented with the decisions of if, when and how, to bring their employees back to the workplace. A return to the workplace from lockdown mode does not mean a return to how business was conducted prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. New laws, orders, directives and guidance from every level of government are being issued and have weaved a complex regulatory web for employers to navigate. Employers need to be cautious, engage in advanced planning and make numerous important decisions prior to reopening offices.

    Plethora of Guidance

    Guidance has been issued from all levels of government and is expected to continue to be issued in the coming weeks. The White House has issued nonbinding guidelines, which envision a slow, phased reopening over a period of weeks or months. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”) published a checklist for employers considering reopening workplaces, providing a list of recommended health and safety actions and ongoing monitoring plans employers should take before reopening.[1] State and local governments have also issued guidelines. In New York State, Governor Andrew M. Cuomo issued Regional Guidelines for Reopening New York, which provide that different types of businesses in 10 different regions of the state will be permitted to open in phases. The phases are based on the CDC’s recommendations. Prior to reopening, a region must experience a 14-day decline in hospitalizations and deaths over a three-day rolling average.[2] Governor Cuomo’s guidelines provide, inter alia, that to maintain the phased reopening, each region must have at least 30% total hospital beds and ICU beds available after elective surgeries resume, coupled with at least a 90-day stockpile of personal protective equipment (“PPE”).[3] The Governor also requires capacity for diagnostic testing regimen, a comprehensive tracing system and isolation facilities.[4] The Governor’s “shelter in-place” order for the State of New York was extended until May 28, 2020, provided that certain industries in certain parts of the state outside of the New York City metropolitan area may reopen as early as May 15, 2020.

    Should an Employer Reopen?

    The health and safety of the workforce should be the guiding principle behind all decisions concerning reopening. The general duty clause of the Occupational Safety and Health Act (“OSHA”) requires that each employer furnish to each of its employees a workplace that is free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm.[5] Absent a vaccine or treatment, reopening will be gradual as stay-at-home orders are lifted. Further, there is a concern that there will be a second wave of the COVID-19  with a much larger spread. When considering reopening, an employer should determine if its workplace is in a community no longer requiring significant mitigation and whether the employer has protective measures in place for employees, including those at high risk. All employers should familiarize themselves with OSHA’s Guidance on Preparing Workplaces for COVID-19 and closely follow guidance from other government agencies as the crisis evolves.

    Doing so should help address employer concerns related to potential litigation and COVID-19. The COVID-19 pandemic is already proving to be fertile breeding ground for litigation, which will likely continue, and infected employees (and plaintiffs’ counsel) may seek to hold employers liable. While it is not yet clear how workplace contractions of the COVID-19 will be treated, state workers’ compensation statutes may bar many employee tort claims. Proving causation will present another challenge to these types of claims. Furthermore, state and federal lawmakers are considering legislation that would immunize certain employers from these types of claims. Accordingly, to protect employees and help mitigate potential liability, before reopening their worksites, employers need to consider how best to reduce the risk of COVID-19 infection in their workplace.

    Preparing the Workplace

    Prior to reopening, employers should consider reconfiguring their physical workplaces and modifying floor plans. Alterations to workspaces and layouts should be considered to place employees further apart from one another so that coworkers can realistically maintain at least a six-foot distance during the work day. Some employers should use Plexiglas, tables or other barriers to ensure minimum distances between coworkers and/or customers. In enclosed spaces, employers should consider establishing one-way directional flow of movement. Coworkers should not share property, such as phones, computers or desks in the workplace. Employers should conduct deep cleanings of entire workplaces frequently, conduct regular disinfecting of high-touch surfaces and shared equipment, and consider increasing ventilation of their workplaces. If industrial cleaning solutions will be used to clean workspaces, employees using and storing such solutions should be trained on their use and the proper protective equipment that should be worn during such use. The necessary protective equipment to administer the cleaning solutions (e.g., masks and gloves) should be provided by the employer.

    Access to nonessential shared spaces, such as large meetings rooms, should be restricted. For essential shared spaces, such as restrooms, elevators, office printers and perhaps pantries, employers should adopt policies that limit the number of individuals permitted in such areas. These policies may include posting signage to inform employees to limit the number of individuals in these shared areas to a “safe” number, closing off sections of the shared areas, or raising temporary barriers in such areas to reduce the number of employees able to contemporaneously access those areas. Close contact between employees should be avoided as much as practicable. Food deliveries to the workplace should be prohibited. Likewise, access to joint refrigerators and kitchen areas should be restricted. To the extent applicable, employees should be required to bring their own food and utensils to work.

    Personal hygiene items, such as hand soap, hand sanitizer containing at least 60% alcohol, disinfectant wipes, sanitizer and tissues, should be made readily available and distributed throughout the workplace. Employers should consider providing single-use tools to employees to limit direct contact with high-touch surfaces.

    Preparing the Workforce

    Employees should be apprised of new safety and workplace policies before returning to work. Social distancing in the workplace should be required and enforced. Not all employees need be recalled to the workplace at the same time. Employers should consider gradually recalling employees to reduce density in the workplace, beginning with those employees or departments that are the most “essential.” In addition, work hours or work days can be staggered so that not all recalled employees are physically present in the workplace at the same time. All nonessential business travel should be prohibited. The number of customers or clients permitted into an employer’s facilities should be restricted. In-person meetings, if required, should have limited attendees with required physical distancing and be of short duration.

    Some employers successfully operated various departments or businesses by telework. These businesses should determine whether employees can and should continue to work from home. Many predict that telework is here to stay and that the future of work has been permanently altered, and employers should develop and publicize policies on teleworking. An employer’s teleworking policy should clarify that it is temporary (e.g., lasting only for the duration of the COVID-19 pandemic) and that it can be terminated by the employer, in its sole discretion, at any time. Such policies may, if appropriate, further clarify that employees’ physical attendance is still considered an essential job function.

    Employers should consider providing personal protective equipment, including masks and gloves, to all employees and require the donning of all such PPE in the workplace at all times. Masks must be utilized in all close-contact settings. Employers should also require employees to follow certain hygiene protocols, such as periodic hand washing or sanitizing, and the use and disposal of tissues. Signage reflecting these protocols should be strategically posted to boost employee compliance.

    Employers have a responsibility to reduce and address workplace harassment that may arise as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”) has recommended that employers explicitly communicate to their workforce that “fear of the COVID-19 pandemic should not be misdirected against individuals because of a protected characteristic, including their national origin, race, or other prohibited bases.”[6] They note that it may be helpful for employers to advise supervisors and managers of their roles in “watching for, stopping and reporting any harassment or other discrimination.”[7]

    Responding to Employee COVID-19 Concerns

    Communication during this period of uncertainty is critical. Employers should develop policies and procedures to deal with COVID-19 issues and concerns. Managers should be trained and point persons assigned to answer any questions and record comments and concerns. Employers must be sensitive to employee concerns and deal with each employee on an individualized basis. Employers should adapt or create systems to receive feedback. For example, some employees may refuse to return to work out of fear of contracting COVID-19. While employers do not necessarily need to comply with an employee’s desire to continue teleworking, employers should have personal discussions with such employees to address their concerns and reach a resolution. If an employee has a reasonable belief that he or she is under imminent threat of death or serious physical harm, OSHA permits such an employee to refuse to work.[8] This, however, is a high standard and will be a steep hurdle for employees to clear. Employers should be creative in developing policies to put employees at ease and increase employee participation in reopening. For example, in the early days of reopening, an employer may permit employees to telework for a certain number of days per week or make coming to the workplace voluntary for all employees.

    Employers should also be aware of what options their employees have to commute to work. Certain locations and forms of commuting may put employees at increased risk to contract the virus. Some employers are considering offering private shuttles to employees or giving employees a stipend to cover private cars or rental cars for their commutes.

    In addition to considering applicability of the employer’s existing leave policies and the Family and Medical Leave Act (“FMLA”) and state and city leave requirements, such as New York’s new paid sick leave laws, employers should be aware that the federal Families First Coronavirus Response Act and the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act have added additional legal requirements concerning employee leave. Employers with fewer than 500 employees are required to provide certain paid childcare leave and paid sick leave through Dec. 31, 2020.[9] Of most concern to employers seeking to have employees return to the workplace is the acts’ temporary amendment of FMLA to include a new entitlement of up to 12 weeks of paid leave to employees that are unable to work (in person or remotely) due to a need to care for a child because the child’s physical school or child care is unavailable due to a public health emergency.[10] Caring for a child in this circumstance is a qualifying reason for both emergency paid sick leave and emergency FMLA leave. Paid sick leave (limited to $200 per day or $2,000 total) is available for the first 10 work days of expanded FMLA leave, which are otherwise unpaid.[11] After the 10 work days elapse, the employee would receive two-thirds of the employee’s regular rate of pay for the hours the employee would have been scheduled to work in the ensuing 10 weeks (capped at $200 per day or $10,000 total).[12] Employers with fewer than 50 employees are exempt from this new FMLA requirement if they can establish that leave would jeopardize the viability of their business according to criteria set by the U.S. Department of Labor.[13]

    Screening Employees

    The EEOC has issued guidance concerning monitoring COVID-19 symptoms and making medical inquiries. Before permitting employees to repopulate the workplace, employers should consider asking their employees to answer questions on their symptoms, exposure and any previous diagnosis related to COVID-19. Questions concerning whether an employee tested positive or has been experiencing

    COVID-19 symptoms, or whether the employee has been exposed to anyone who has been diagnosed with COVID-19 or who has displayed symptoms associated with COVID-19, are permissible.[14]

    The EEOC has clarified that even if an employer knows that an employee has a medical condition that might place the employee at high risk of severe illness if he or she becomes infected with COVID-19, the employer is not allowed to exclude the employee — or take any other adverse action solely because the employee has a disability that the CDC identifies as potentially placing the employee at high risk.[15] If the employee does not request a reasonable accommodation, the law does not mandate that the employer take action. Such action is only allowed if the employee’s disability poses a “direct threat” to their health that cannot be eliminated or reduced by reasonable accommodation.[16] The direct threat requirement is a high standard and is not satisfied based solely on the condition being on the CDC’s list — “the determination must be an individualized assessment based on a reasonable medical judgment [using the most current medical knowledge and/or best available objective evidence] about the employee’s disability.”[17] In making this determination, employers may ask an employee to submit to a medical examination if the employer has “a reasonable belief, based on objective evidence,” that the employee will pose a “direct threat” due to their medical condition.[18] Even if an employer determines that the disability constitutes a direct threat to the employee’s health, the employer can only exclude the employee from the workplace if there is no way to provide a reasonable accommodation that would eliminate or reduce the risk so that it would be safe for the employee to return to the workplace.[19]

    The EEOC noted that accommodation may include:

    • Additional or enhanced protective gowns, masks, gloves or other gear.
    • Additional or enhanced protective measures, for example, erecting a barrier that provides separation or increasing the space between an employee with a disability and others.
    • Elimination of marginal job duties — i.e., duties that can be reassigned as a reasonable accommodation without causing an undue burden or hardship.
    • Temporary modification of work schedules.
    • Moving the location of where the employee performs work.[20]

    The EEOC has stated that disability-related inquiries and conducting medical exams are permitted if job-related and consistent with business necessity and that inquiries and reliable medical exams meet this standard, if necessary, to exclude employees with a medical condition that would pose a direct threat to their health and safety.[21] Accordingly, during the pandemic, employers are permitted to conduct COVID-19 tests on employees, including taking employee body temperatures, before permitting employees to enter their worksite.[22] Employers should ensure that their tests are accurate and reliable using available guidance from the CDC or other public health authorities. All tests must be administered in a non-discriminatory manner. Further, such tests should be, when possible, conducted by a health care professional. Tests and screenings should be done privately and the results of such tests and screenings are confidential and should be maintained by employers as confidential medical records. With respect to antibody testing, the EEOC has not yet issued guidance on the legality of administering such testing.

    Moreover, the antibody tests in their current form may have reliability and accuracy issues and the EEOC warns employers to be cautious of relying on inaccurate testing. Finally, there have been extensive discussions about utilizing technologies that track the movement of individuals for purposes of limiting the spread of COVID-19. These contact tracing technologies in the workplace raise serious privacy concerns.

    The COVID-19 Consumer Data Protection Act was recently introduced in the U.S. Senate and aims to “provide all Americans with more transparency, choice, and control over the collection and use of their personal health, geolocation and proximity data” by entities working to track and limit the spread of COVID-19. A second bill, the Public Health Emergency Privacy Act introduced in the U.S. Senate and U.S. House of Representatives on May 14, also aims to regulate the use of contact tracking technologies.

    Employees who become ill with symptoms of COVID-19 should be directed to stay home. Employees who become symptomatic at work should be immediately sent home and all potentially exposed employees quarantined. Employees can be required to obtain a doctor’s note certifying fitness for duty in order for an employee to be permitted to return to work. The EEOC, however, has stated that doctors may be too busy during the pandemic to provide such documentation. They note that new approaches may be necessary such as an email to certify that an individual does not have COVID-19.[23]

    Employers should be aware that their employees may request accommodations for religious or disability reasons. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (“Title VII”) and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (“ADA”) require employers to engage in the “interactive process” to determine a suitable accommodation that does not pose a hardship for the employer under Title VII[24] or an undue burden for the employer under the ADA.[25] Local laws, such as New York City’s Human Rights Law, also require employers to provide reasonable accommodations to certain employees unless doing so would create an undue hardship for the employer.[26] The employer may ask questions or request medical documentation to determine whether the employee has a “disability,” and whether the disability necessitates an accommodation.

    What’s Next?

    As noted by the EEOC, “[e]mployers should remember that guidance from public health authorities is likely to change as the COVID-19 pandemic evolves. Therefore, employers should continue to follow the most current information on maintaining workplace safety.” As more guidance and rules are published, employers will be equipped with more practical measures for preparing their worksites. In the meantime, employers must enforce the rules they establish to protect the health and safety of their employees.

    Future mandated closures may be on the horizon. Employers should monitor and update their business continuity and safety communication plans accordingly. In the event another round of mandatory closures takes place, employers should have an emergency plan in place detailing how the employer and its employees will navigate that challenge.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Max Garfield, Scott A. Gold and Abdulrahman Alwattar.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Workplaces During the COVID-19 Pandemic, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

    [2] Regional Guidelines for Reopening New York State.

    [3] Id.

    [4] Id.

    [5] 29 U.S.C. § 654 (1970).

    [6] What You Should Know About COVID-19 and the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act and Other EEO Laws, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

    [7] Id.

    [8] 29 U.S.C. § 662(a).

    [9] Families First Coronavirus Response Act, Pub. L. No. 116-127, § 3102, 134 Stat. 189-92 (2020).

    [10] Id. at § 110(a)(2)(A), 134 Stat. 189-90.

    [11] Id. at § 5110(5)(A)(i)-(ii), 134 Stat. 200.

    [12] Id. at § 110(b)(2)(B)(i)-(ii), 134 Stat. 190-91.

    [13] Id. at § 110(a)(3)(B), 134 Stat. 190.

    [14] What You Should Know About COVID-19 and the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act and Other EEO Laws, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

    [15] Id.

    [16] Id.

    [17] Id.

    [18] Enforcement Guidance on Disability-Related Inquiries and Medical Examinations of Employees under the ADA, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

    [19] What You Should Know About COVID-19 and the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act and Other EEO Laws, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

    [20] Id.

    [21] Id.

    [22] Id.

    [23] Id.

    [24] 29 C.F.R. § 1605.2(e).

    [25] 42 U.S.C. § 12111(10).

    [26] See generally N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 8-107.


    This is a fast-moving topic and the information contained in this Alert is current as of the date it was published.

    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Max Garfield

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Abdulrahman Alwattar

    Associate

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • European Regulators Suspend Short-Selling Bans

    European Regulators Suspend Short-Selling Bans

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    European Regulators Suspend Short-Selling Bans

    18 May 2020

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In a coordinated action, the financial regulators of Austria, Belgium, France, Greece, Italy and Spain have announced that their short-selling bans will expire at the end of the day (local time) on 18 May 2020. The bans will not be renewed on the grounds that the market conditions justifying the bans are no longer present.

    The lower initial threshold of 0.1% for reporting net short positions announced by ESMA as a temporary emergency measure in March 2020 remains in effect.

    Authored by Anna Maleva-Otto and Brian T. Daly.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This is a fast-moving topic and the information contained in this Alert is current as of the date it was published.

    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Legal Aid Needs Law Firm Support Now More Than Ever

    Legal Aid Needs Law Firm Support Now More Than Ever

    ARTICLE

    Legal Aid Needs Law Firm Support Now More Than Ever

    May 17, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Jeffrey E. Stone

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Reassessing Executive Compensation and Benefits in Tax-Exempt Organizations as the COVID-19 Crisis Deepens

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Reassessing Executive Compensation and Benefits in Tax-Exempt Organizations as the COVID-19 Crisis Deepens

    May 15, 2020

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hospitals, health systems and other tax-exempt organizations are responding to a longer and deeper economic crisis by making or considering significant changes to their executive compensation and executive benefit programs. The economic crisis, and these executive compensation and benefit changes, have far-reaching implications for the ongoing work of the board’s compensation committee. We want to provide this review of what we see happening “on the ground” as the crisis continues.

    In depth

    Changes to Pay Structures

    Here are the executive compensation and executive benefit changes that many larger and more complex exempt organizations have made or are considering:

    • Current and upcoming annual incentive plan performance cycles are being revised. The strategies being deployed include:
      • Suspending executive incentive award payments, even if already earned, until the crisis abates. Organizations will have to be mindful of the contractual claims that could be made, and of the tax consequences of delaying or canceling payments that have been earned and approved.
      • Cancelling the current performance period, and considering only discretionary awards for crisis leadership performance.
      • Reducing the amount of incentive pay potentially available to an executive, such as capping awards at 100% of base salary.
      • Moving to more frequent performance periods (such as two or three periods per year), with a smaller set of crisis-response and post-crisis planning goals.
      • Leaving the current incentive structure in place, but agreeing to evaluate performance more broadly at the end of the incentive plan year and to use discretion to adjust awards appropriately.
    • Salary increases are being delayed … for now. Approved adjustments to executive salaries have been delayed at some organizations, until the crisis abates.
    • For other organizations that may have relied heavily on incentive compensation that now is out of reach, salary adjustments are being selectively or broadly considered to make up for the loss of incentive opportunity and to keep compensation somewhat competitive.
    • Across-the-board salary decreases have become more prevalent as the economic crisis has deepened. Some CEOs have voluntarily decreased their base salaries by a larger percentage than has applied to other executives. In these situations, compensation committees should be addressing these implications:
      • Is the decrease temporary, and should there be a date as of which it will be revisited?
      • Is the decrease actually a deferral, or is it gone for good?
      • Does the decrease violate any existing employment agreement or policy (and if so, should it be amended)?
      • Is there a retention risk? Could the salary decrease make some executives vulnerable to receiving and considering an offer from another organization?
      • Will the salary decrease have an unintended adverse effect on benefit coverages?
      • If the media ask about executive pay during this crisis, is the organization prepared to respond appropriately?
      • To soften the adverse effect of the salary decrease, could or should the committee signal flexibility in the manner in which it will consider discretionary incentive compensation awards when the crisis abates?
    • Supplemental executive retirement plans (SERPs) are undergoing a careful cost review. Organizations are reviewing these cost structures (which may not have been reviewed in recent years) and considering these potential options:
      • Eliminating or reducing contributions for a specified period
      • Delaying contributions
      • Crediting contributions to book accounts without making actual contribution deposits
      • Reducing, eliminating or suspending earnings or interest credits on accounts.

    Note that, for all these potential changes, contractual limitations have to be considered. These limitations may be in employment agreements, incentive plan documents, SERP plans, or in other agreements or plans. The incidental effect of these changes should also be considered, such as whether compensation decreases, suspension or delays could trigger an executive’s right to terminate employment voluntarily for “good reason” and receive severance pay.

    Evaluating and Securing Key Leadership Talent

    Complex tax-exempt organizations need their best leaders more than ever. A key challenge in this crisis is identifying and retaining key leaders, particularly when the compensation tools (most notably performance-driven salary adjustments, incentive compensation awards and additional discretionary incentive payments) are much more limited. CEOs and compensation committees should work together closely to identify key leaders and make sure that sufficient retention approaches are in place or considered. Here are some of the approaches that organizations may wish to consider:

    • Providing leadership talent development and promotion opportunities (preferably as part of an executive succession plan regularly reviewed with the compensation committee)
    • Entering into a retention incentive arrangement
    • Providing an additional long-term incentive opportunity for additional leadership responsibilities
    • Adding to the executive’s portfolio with a more highly visible set of crisis-related duties and responsibilities.

    Expanded Role of the Compensation Committee

    In light of these changes, what are the key governance issues for the compensation committee right now?

    First, the committee should receive regular COVID-19 updates from the CEO on issues falling under the oversight jurisdiction of the committee.

    Second, the committee should stay current on the organization’s executive succession planning and consider the impact of the health and economic crisis on the succession plan. The plan may need to be made more robust in light of the COVID-19-related challenges.

    Third, the committee should not lose sight of the normal activities of executive compensation review and approval, such as supporting total compensation as reasonable, securing the rebuttable presumption of reasonableness for all compensation decisions, receiving regular updates on rapidly evolving pay practices of its market peers and reviewing Form 990 disclosure of executive compensation.

    Fourth, the committee should be in frequent dialogue with the CEO to make sure that the organization’s key leaders have been identified and retained.

    Fifth, the committee should consider the longer view in assessing near-term compensation changes. For example, if compensation or benefits are delayed until after the crisis, will that cause a bunching of pay that is likely to trigger the 21% excise tax on compensation over one million dollars for covered employees?

    Sixth, the committee should work with the CEO to consider what kind of performance metrics are of increased importance in this crisis. These could include various measures of financial stability, workforce health and workplace safety, capital structures and liquidity, workforce sustainability (maintaining current payroll), effective use of voluntary retirement or separation programs, effective mobile operations, planning for post-crisis revitalization, and similar crisis-oriented metrics.

    The committee’s most important function during this time, while the CEO is steering the organization through the crisis, is to look carefully and dispassionately at the broader and longer view on executive compensation, looking for unintended consequences, leadership stability, reputational impact, the evolving relationship of pay to performance, and the long-term best interests of the organization and its tax-exempt mission.

    Authors
    More insights