Content Type: Article

  • August 13, 2020, Deadline for Healthcare Providers and Life Sciences Federal Contractors: Ban on Use of Certain Chinese Telecommunications Equipment and Services

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    August 13, 2020, Deadline for Healthcare Providers and Life Sciences Federal Contractors: Ban on Use of Certain Chinese Telecommunications Equipment and Services

    July 29, 2020

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Effective August 13, 2020, an Interim Rule jointly issued by the Department of Defense (DoD), the General Services Administration (GSA), and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) that amends the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) and implements Section 889(a)(1)(B) of the FY 2019 NDAA, that will apply to all organizations making an offer for a federal contract, including medical device manufacturers, pharmaceutical manufacturers, and healthcare providers. The Interim Rule bars certain technology, including telecommunications and video surveillance products, equipment and services, manufactured or provided by specific list of companies and/or their subsidiaries.

    In depth

    Key Takeaways

    1. Medical device and pharmaceutical manufacturers (including manufacturers of covered outpatient drugs that participate in the Medicaid Drug Rebate Program), as well as healthcare providers should be aware of an upcoming compliance obligation.
    2. A new Interim Rule applies broadly to any entity making an offer for a federal contract, not just those operating in the telecommunications space (including commercial items) as soon as August 13, 2020.
      • The Interim Rule includes contracts with the Department of Veterans Affairs as well as the Defense Health Agency/TRICARE
    3. The Interim Rule bars certain technology (including Huawei, ZTE and all subsidiaries and affiliates of these entities, as well as others) as a substantial or essential component of any system, or as critical technology as part of any system (not just those used in contract performance).
      • The Interim Rule requires covered entities to conduct “a reasonable inquiry,” which may include training, changes to policies and procedures, and possible disclosure/remedial action.
      • The US government is considering expanding the certification requirement to extend to “affiliates, parents, and subsidiaries of the offeror that are domestic concerns”

    Background

    In 2018, Congress passed, and President Trump signed into law, the John S. McCain National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for Fiscal Year 2019 (P.L. 115-232) (FY 2019 NDAA), which includes a provision (Sec. 889 (a)(1)(B)) prohibiting federal agencies from entering into a contract (or extending or renewing a contract) with entities that use any equipment, system, or service that uses certain covered telecommunications equipment or services as a substantial or essential component of any system, or as critical technology as part of any system.

    On July 14, 2020, the Federal Register officially published an interim rule (Interim Rule) jointly issued by the Department of Defense (DoD), the General Services Administration (GSA), and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) that amends the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) and implements Section 889(a)(1)(B) of the FY 2019 NDAA.

    The rule will go into effect on August 13, 2020—new solicitations as well as contracts awarded after this date will require compliance.

    Which Telecommunication Equipment and Services Are Covered?

    The Interim Rule applies to “covered telecommunications equipment or services” as defined in FAR subpart 4.2101, which includes:

    1. Telecommunications equipment produced by Huawei Technologies Company or ZTE Corporation, (or any subsidiary or affiliate of such entities)
    2. For the purpose of public safety, security of government facilities, physical security surveillance of critical infrastructure, and other national security purposes, video surveillance and telecommunications equipment produced by Hytera Communications Corporation, Hangzhou Hikvision Digital Technology Company, or Dahua Technology Company (or any subsidiary or affiliate of such entities)
    3. Telecommunications or video surveillance services provided by such entities or using such equipment
    4. Telecommunications or video surveillance equipment or services produced or provided by an entity that the Secretary of Defense, in consultation with the Director of National Intelligence or the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, reasonably believes to be an entity owned or controlled by, or otherwise connected to, the government of a covered foreign country.

    The statute is not limited to contracting with entities that use end products produced by these companies, but also extends to the use of any equipment or services as a substantial or essential component of any system, or as critical technology as part of any system.
    “Critical technology,” as defined in FAR subpart 4.2101, means:

    1. Defense articles or defense services included on the United States Munitions List set forth in the International Traffic in Arms Regulations under subchapter M of chapter I of title 22, Code of Federal Regulations
    2. Items included on the Commerce Control List set forth in Supplement No. 1 to part 774 of the Export Administration Regulations under subchapter C of chapter VII of title 15, Code of Federal Regulations, and controlled under either of the following:
      • Pursuant to multilateral regimes, including for reasons relating to national security, chemical and biological weapons proliferation, nuclear nonproliferation, or missile technology
      • For reasons relating to regional stability or surreptitious listening
    3. Specially designed and prepared nuclear equipment, parts and components, materials, software, and technology covered by part 810 of title 10, Code of Federal Regulations (relating to assistance to foreign atomic energy activities)
    4. Nuclear facilities, equipment and material covered by part 110 of title 10, Code of Federal Regulations (relating to export and import of nuclear equipment and material)
    5. Select agents and toxins covered by part 331 of title 7, Code of Federal Regulations, part 121 of title 9 of such Code, or part 73 of title 42 of such Code
    6. Emerging and foundational technologies controlled pursuant to section 1758 of the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 (50 U.S.C. 4817).

    “Substantial or essential component,” as defined in FAR subpart 4.2101, means “any component necessary for the proper function or performance of a piece of equipment, system, or service.”

    To Whom Does the Interim Rule Apply?

    The Interim Rule applies to almost all entities making an offer for a prime federal contract, not just those operating in the telecommunications space, including contracts below the simplified acquisition threshold (micro-purchases) and commercial items contracts—putting many organizations that operate a small portion of their activities related to federal procurement at significant potential risk.

    Of particular concern are those organizations that operate principally in non-federal procurement activity but are nonetheless dependent on federal contracts for a material portion of revenues, such as healthcare and life sciences organizations.

    For covered entities, the Interim Rule’s prohibition covers any equipment, system or service that itself uses covered telecommunications equipment or services as a substantial or essential component of any system, or as critical technology as part of any system, regardless of whether that usage is in performance of work under a federal contract.

    In accordance with the statutory language of Sec. 889(a)(1)(B), the Interim Rule’s prohibition does not, however, flow down to subcontractors as a regulatory obligation, because the prime contractor is the only “entity” that a federal agency “enters into a contract with.” Nevertheless, a prime contractor may be held responsible for the incorporation of covered telecommunications equipment or services by a subcontractor in support of a federal prime contract and should consider whether “a reasonable inquiry” (as discussed below) requires consideration of subcontractors.

    As part of the finalization process for the Interim Rule, the FAR Council is considering expanding “the scope to require that the prohibition at 52.204-24(b)(2) and 52.204-25(b)(2) applies to the offeror and any affiliates, parents, and subsidiaries of the offeror that are domestic concerns, and expand the representation at 52.204-24(d)(2) so that the offeror represents on behalf of itself and any affiliates, parents, and subsidiaries of the offeror that are domestic concerns, as to whether they use covered telecommunications equipment or services.”

    If the definition of a contractor covered by the requirement is broadly interpreted, a large number of contractors will have to immediately begin conducting “reasonable inquiries,” implement compliance policies, conduct appropriate training, implement tracking programs for future technology purchases, and undertake remedial action as needed in order to meet the deadline with regard to all of its systems, whether or not related to performance of a federal contract.

    Comments regarding the Interim Rule may be submitted through September 14, 2020.

    Key Action Items for Federal Contractors (including Healthcare/Life Sciences Organizations)

    1. Prepare for Affirmative Representation of Compliance with Prime Contract Offers
      • The Interim Rule will require that all contractors/offerors represent with each offer for a covered contract, after conducting “a reasonable inquiry,” whether covered telecommunications equipment or services are used by the contractor/offeror. The System for Award Management (SAM) will be updated to allow offerors to make the representation annually, and contractors will be required to alert the government if use of covered telecommunications equipment or services is discovered during contract performance.
    2. Conduct a “Reasonable Inquiry”
      • The Interim Rule adds new definitions, including for “reasonable inquiry,” which is defined as “an inquiry designed to uncover any information in the entity’s possession about the identity of the producer or provider of covered telecommunications equipment or services used by the entity that excludes the need to include an internal or third-party audit.”
      • A reasonable inquiry will vary by organization, but the Interim Rule explains that it includes “examining relationships with any subcontractor or supplier for which the prime contact has a Federal contract and uses the supplier or subcontractor’s ‘covered telecommunications’ equipment or services as a substantial or essential component of any system,” and is “designed to uncover any information in the [contractor’s] possession—primarily documentation or other records—about the identity of the producer or provider of covered telecommunications equipment or services used by the [contractor].”
        Every covered entity will be required to conduct a reasonable inquiry as defined by the organization’s circumstances, which may be conducted under legal privilege in certain circumstances.
    3. Review, Disclose and Mitigate
      • If a contractor represents that it does use covered telecommunications equipment or services, the disclosing contractor will be required to provide additional detailed information, including the entity that produced the equipment, a description of the equipment offered, and an explanation of the proposed use of the equipment and any factors relevant to determining if such use would be permissible under the Interim Rule’s prohibition. With respect to services, the contractor will be required to provide a description of the services offered or, if not associated with maintenance, the product service code of the service and an explanation of the proposed use of the services and any factors relevant to determining if such use would be permissible under the Interim Rule’s prohibition.
      • In some cases, agency contracting officers will be permitted to grant, on a case-by-case basis, one-time waivers that will expire no later than August 13, 2022. In addition, the Director of National Intelligence (DNI) may also provide a separate waiver if the director determines that doing so is in the national security interests of the United States. Even when a waiver is granted, continued monitoring is still required—the contractor will still be required to report any additional uses discovered or identified during contract performance in accordance with 52.204-25(d), which requires reports to be made within one business day.
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Issues Final Rule Regulating Proxy Voting Advice

    SEC Issues Final Rule Regulating Proxy Voting Advice

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Issues Final Rule Regulating Proxy Voting Advice

    July 28, 2020

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 22, 2020, the SEC adopted a final rule confirming its position that proxy voting advice is a solicitation under the proxy rules subject to antifraud provisions and imposing certain new disclosure requirements on proxy advisory firms who wish to avoid the information and filing requirements applicable to proxy solicitations.  

    Proxy Advice a Solicitation Under the Proxy Rules. The SEC amended Rule 14a-1(l) to codify its view that proxy voting advice constitutes a “solicitation” under Section 14(a) of the Exchange Act. Specifically, the SEC added a paragraph to make clear that the terms “solicit” and “solicitation” include any proxy voting advice that makes a recommendation to a shareholder as to its vote, consent or authorization on a specific matter for which shareholder approval is solicited, and that is furnished by a person who markets its expertise as a provider of such advice, separately from other forms of investment advice, and sells such advice for a fee. The SEC has excluded proxy voting advice in response to an unprompted request. The SEC noted that one-off advice or services by investment advisers or broker-dealers to their clients, which may include proxy voting advice, do not pose risks as they are not marketing their expertise as a provider of such proxy voting advice, separately from other forms of investment advice, and selling such proxy voting advice for a fee.

    While this general position is not new, the SEC introduced certain disclosure requirements that must be satisfied in order for proxy advisory firms to be able to avail themselves of the exemptions they had traditionally relied on. In the past, proxy advisory firms, such as ISS, Glass Lewis and Egan-Jones, had taken the position that they are exempt under Rule 14a-2(b)(1) and Rule 14a-2(b)(3) from the information and filing requirements otherwise applicable to non-exempt solicitations. With the new SEC rules, in order to use those existing exemptions, the proxy advisory firms will need to adopt policies that provide certain new disclosures.

    Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest. The SEC’s new rule conditions the exemptions in Rules 14a-2(b)(1) and 14a-2(b)(3) on providing disclosure of material conflicts of interest. Proxy advisers must include in their voting advice, or in any electronic medium used to deliver the advice, such as a client voting platform, prominent disclosure of:

    • Any information regarding an interest, transaction or relationship of the proxy adviser (or its affiliates) that is material to assessing the objectivity of the proxy voting advice in light of the circumstances of the particular interest, transaction or relationship; and
    • Any policies and procedures used to identify, as well as the steps taken to address, any such material conflicts of interest arising from such interest, transaction or relationship.

    Company Review and Feedback to Proxy Voting Advice in Uncontested and M&A Situations. The SEC further conditioned the availability of the exemptions in Rules 14a-2(b)(1) and 14a-2(b)(3) on proxy advisory firms adopting and publicly disclosing certain written policies.

    First, the SEC’s new rules require a proxy advisory firm to adopt policies and procedures to ensure that their proxy voting advice is made available to the companies subject to it simultaneously with or prior to providing it to their clients. Importantly, the proxy advisory firms are not required to provide an opportunity for a preview to the companies in advance of the issuance of the report. Instead their policies can provide that they will distribute their voting recommendations contemporaneously to their clients and to the subject company.

    The SEC has provided a non-exclusive safe harbor provision that, if followed, will give assurance to a proxy adviser that it has met the requirements of the new rule. Under the safe harbor, a proxy advisory firm can adopt policies and procedures that are reasonably designed to provide companies with a copy of its proxy voting advice, at no charge, no later than the time it is disseminated to the business’ clients. Such policies and procedures may include conditions requiring that such companies have (A) filed their definitive proxy statement at least 40 calendar days before the shareholder meeting; and (B) expressly acknowledged that they will only use the proxy voting advice for their internal purposes and/or in connection with the solicitation and it will not be published or otherwise shared except with the company’s employees or advisers. A proxy adviser is not required to provide copies of any revised or supplemented advice to the subject company.

    Second, a proxy voting advisory firm must adopt policies to provide its clients with a mechanism by which they can reasonably be expected to become aware of any written statements regarding its proxy voting advice by companies that are the subject of such advice, in a timely manner before the shareholder meeting (or, if no meeting, before the votes, consents or authorizations may be used to effect the proposed action).

    Here again the SEC provided a non-exclusive safe harbor pursuant to which proxy advisers will be deemed to satisfy the new requirement. To satisfy this safe harbor, a proxy adviser must have written policies and procedures reasonably designed to inform clients who have received proxy voting advice about a particular company in the event that such company notifies the proxy adviser that the company either intends to file or has filed additional soliciting materials with the SEC setting forth its views regarding such advice. The safe harbor sets forth two methods by which the proxy adviser may provide such notice to its clients. It may either (A) provide notice on its electronic client platform that the company has filed, or has informed the proxy adviser that it intends to file, additional soliciting materials (and include an active hyperlink to those materials on EDGAR when available); or (B) provide notice through email or other electronic means that the company has filed, or has informed the proxy adviser that it intends to file, additional soliciting materials (and include an active hyperlink to those materials on EDGAR when available).

    These review and feedback requirements are not applicable where the proxy adviser is providing advice based on custom voting policies that are proprietary to a proxy adviser’s client.

    Importantly, the review and feedback requirements are also not applicable to non-exempt solicitations for the approval of an M&A transaction or contested director elections. The Commission rightfully recognized that the time constraints and frequent changes in contested elections and M&A situations would make compliance with the review and feedback requirements impractical and disruptive.

    Antifraud Provisions. The SEC amended Rule 14a-9, the antifraud provision of the federal proxy rules, to add an example that clarifies that, depending upon the particular facts and circumstances at issue, the failure to disclose certain information in proxy voting advice may be considered materially misleading within the meaning of the rule. Specifically the Note to Rule 14a-9 will include new paragraph (e) to provide that the failure to disclose material information regarding proxy voting advice, “such as the proxy voting advice business’s methodology, sources of information, or conflicts of interest” could, depending upon particular facts and circumstances, be misleading within the meaning of the rule.

    Compliance Date. The SEC has provided for a transition period until Dec. 1, 2021 for proxy advisers to adopt review and feedback policies and otherwise bring themselves in compliance with the amendments to Rule 14a-2(b)(9). The amendments to Rule 14a-1(l) and 14a-9 which clarify that proxy voting advice is a solicitation subject to the proxy rules antifraud provisions are not viewed by the SEC as new law but merely a clarification of the SEC’s existing position and therefore the SEC does not believe a transition period is needed.

    Practical Implications for Investment Advisers, Institutional Investors and Activists. Investment advisers, institutional investors and activists count on proxy advisers for timely, independent and well-informed analyses and recommendations. Investment advisers are subject to fiduciary duties in voting on behalf of their clients. Because of the excessive cost of formulating a customized voting decision for each of the thousands of companies and situations where an adviser must vote the recommendations of proxy advisers to various degrees are incorporated in the voting guidelines and internal systems they follow in making voting decisions. In contested situations in particular, proxy advisers play an important role in bringing an independent third-party perspective on issues in dispute between the two competing sides. (A separate SRZ Alert on the SEC’s supplemental guidance regarding the proxy voting responsibilities of investment advisers will be forthcoming.)

    The new SEC rules have the potential to impose operating and compliance costs on proxy advisers that can strain their resources and jeopardize their ability to provide timely and well-researched advice. Disclosures of conflicts of interest or scrutiny of proxy advisers’ methodologies and sources of information may create pressure on investors to put less stock into the proxy advisers’ voting recommendations. The review and feedback mechanisms, even though only applicable in uncontested situations, can give undue advantage to subject companies and undermine the independent critical analysis of their performance and governance.

    In contested situations, activists would need to engage more deeply with fellow shareholders to understand whether there is a change to how they factor proxy advice into their voting decisions. Engagement with the proxy advisers in presentations of the activist’s platform will need to be tailored to be in step with any changes to the practices and approach of the proxy advisers as a result of the new regulations.

    Authored by Eleazer Klein and Aneliya S. Crawford.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Ele Klein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Baker Should Commute Prisoner’s Sentence

    ARTICLE

    Baker Should Commute Prisoner’s Sentence

    July 27, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • State Aid: The General Court Opens a Formidable Remedy

    ARTICLE

    State Aid: The General Court Opens a Formidable Remedy

    July 24, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • GILTI Losses

    ARTICLE

    GILTI Losses

    July 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Indemnification of ESOP Fiduciaries

    Indemnification of ESOP Fiduciaries

    ARTICLE

    Indemnification of ESOP Fiduciaries

    Summer 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • New York Announces One of the World’s Largest Procurements for Offshore Wind and Onshore Renewable Energy Projects

    New York Announces One of the World’s Largest Procurements for Offshore Wind and Onshore Renewable Energy Projects

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York Announces One of the World’s Largest Procurements for Offshore Wind and Onshore Renewable Energy Projects

    July 24, 2020

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 21, 2020, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo announced the largest combined clean energy solicitation ever issued in the United States, seeking up to 4 GW of renewable capacity. This capacity is broken up into 2500 MW of offshore wind and 1500 MW of onshore large-scale renewable energy projects.

    In depth

    Increasing Renewable Energy Investments in the United States

    The United States remains one of the most attractive jurisdictions for renewable energy investments. It is the world’s biggest consumer of electricity and is now increasingly transitioning to renewable energy sources. It is a growing market with a stable regulatory environment and a transparent legal system and access to low cost of capital. The size and diversity of the United States also create numerous opportunities for various types of renewable energy projects.

    The United States is ranked first in the EY’s 2020 Renewable Energy Country Attractiveness Index. According to Bloomberg New Energy Finance, a total of $55.5 billion was spent in the US renewables sector in 2019 alone (setting new investment records), an increase of 28%, second only to China and beating Europe.

    Offshore Wind Solicitation

    This is New York’s second offshore wind solicitation; last year’s solicitation resulted in awards for projects of nearly 1700 MW in total capacity. The solicitation this year requires offshore wind generators to partner with any of the 11 prequalified New York ports to stage, construct key components, manufacture and coordinate operations and maintenance activities. New York is seeking at least 1000 MW of offshore capacity and will be accepting bids of between 400 MW and 2500 MW. New York will be providing $400 million in private and public funding to upgrade the state’s port infrastructure.

    The timeline for the latest round of solicitations includes an online conference for bidders on August 12, 2020, followed by a September 23, 2020, deadline for notices of intent to propose and an October 20, 2020, deadline for the submission of proposals.

    Learn more about the Offshore Wind solicitation.

    Onshore Renewables Solicitation

    Governor Cuomo also announced that the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) and the Power Authority of the State of New York (NYPA) will be running a coordinated solicitation to procure over 1500 MW of renewable energy. Projects selected in these solicitations will be fast-tracked to construction by seeking permitting through the new Office of Renewable Energy Siting.

    NYSERDA Solicitation
    NYSERDA is seeking Tier 1 renewable energy projects with combined generation of 1.6 million MWh annually. Eligible projects must have entered operation after January 1, 2015, and must enter commercial operation by November 30, 2022 (or November 30, 2025 with extensions). NYSERDA will also allow proposers to leverage renewable energy credits (REC) via the Index REC contract structure for the first time.

    NYSERDA will open the Step One Eligibility Application on August 5, 2020.

    Learn more about the NYSERDA solicitation.

    NYPA Solicitation
    NYPA is seeking solar photovoltaic and wind projects (with an option to combine with energy storage) with combined generation of 2 million MWh annually. Eligible projects will be required to interconnect into New York state and have generation capacities of between 20 and 25 MW or 100 MW or larger. NYPA will be purchasing energy, capacity and RECs from the selected projects, which are expected to come online between 2021 and 2024. Winning bidders are expected to be notified in late 2020.

    Learn more about the NYPA solicitation.

    Our global team of more than 50 dedicated renewable energy project finance lawyers is closely monitoring market developments for our clients engaged in the acquisition, development, construction and financing of renewables projects. Our team has extensive experience working with offshore projects in both Europe and the United States and has acted as counsel on a broad range of NYSERDA and NYPA projects and solicitations. For any immediate questions, or to set up a complimentary virtual meeting, we invite you to reach out to the authors of this article.

    Authors

    Christopher Gladbach

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Jacob Hollinger

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Joel A. Hugenberger

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Supreme Court: BOOKING.COM Can be Registered as a Trademark

    Supreme Court: BOOKING.COM Can be Registered as a Trademark

    ARTICLE

    Supreme Court: BOOKING.COM Can be Registered as a Trademark

    July 24, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Robert W. Zelnick

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Burdensome Documentation Requirements Modified under the Final Section 250 Regulations

    Burdensome Documentation Requirements Modified under the Final Section 250 Regulations

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Burdensome Documentation Requirements Modified under the Final Section 250 Regulations

    July 24, 2020

    Read time: 13 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) have issued highly anticipated guidance (the Final Regulations) regarding the substantiation requirements necessary to claim a section 250 deduction with respect to foreign-derived intangible income. The Final Regulations significantly modified the proposed documentation requirements issued in March 2019 (the Proposed Regulations), generally allowing taxpayers more flexibility to substantiate their transactions as for foreign use. The Final Regulations also expanded the transition rule set forth under the Proposed Regulations, thereby allowing taxpayers to rely on the current taxpayer-friendly standard until the Final Regulations are effective.

    In depth

    On July 9, 2020, the Treasury and the IRS issued final section 250 regulations that address, among other items, the substantiation requirements that a taxpayer must satisfy to take a section 250 deduction on its foreign-derived intangible income (FDII).

    Generally, taxpayers must meet “foreign use” requirements to the satisfaction of the Secretary of the Treasury to claim a FDII benefit. A seller of property must establish that the property is sold to a foreign person for a foreign use; a renderer of services must establish that the services are provided to a person (or with respect to property) that is not located in the United States. The Final Regulations largely relaxed the rules that govern the documentation necessary to satisfy these requirements. Except for certain transactions, the Final Regulations generally do not require any specific documentation, instead allowing taxpayers to presume foreign person status and claim a FDII benefit so long as they can substantiate they are entitled to the section 250 deduction under section 6001 and its regulations. In the case of certain transactions, the Final Regulations still require specific substantiation, but are generally more flexible regarding the specificity and reliability of required documentation.

    Specific Substantiation Requirements

    The Final Regulations provide specific substantiation rules with respect to sales of general property to recipients other than end users (including property for resale and manufacturing), sales of intangible property and general services provided to business recipients. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–3(f).) The preamble to the Final Regulations (the Preamble) states that in these transactions, there is higher potential for mischaracterization regarding foreign use, because the facts needed to substantiate a deduction are typically held by a third party as opposed to the taxpayer. For example, the Preamble expresses concern that without specific substantiation requirements, taxpayers that sell finished goods to foreign resellers would not be able to confirm that the resellers did not immediately sell such property back into the United States, thereby frustrating the purpose of the statute. Similarly, the Preamble states that without specific substantiation requirements, taxpayers that provide services to multinational companies with operations inside and outside the United States would not be able to confirm that their services did not benefit the recipient’s US operations.

    As a result, Treasury and IRS determined that for these transactions, specific substantiation requirements were necessary to establish foreign use. However, these specific substantiation requirements as revised are generally more flexible regarding what types of corroborating evidence may be used, and in all cases allow for taxpayers to satisfy the substantiation requirement through: (i) a specific document; (ii) credible evidence obtained from the recipient in the ordinary course of business; or (iii) a written statement prepared by the taxpayer, so long as the statement is corroborated by sufficient supporting evidence of the taxpayer’s choice. Taxpayers’ ability to rely upon written statements based upon their own internal information, such as how much time they spend working with each of the recipient’s offices (in the case of general services to business recipients), will in some cases be a welcome relief.

    Sale of General Property for Resale
    Under Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–4(d)(3)(ii), a seller of general property for resale must maintain one or more of the following types of information to substantiate foreign use: (i) a binding contract expressly limiting subsequent sales to outside the United States; (ii) proof that property is specifically designed, labeled or adapted for foreign use; (iii) proof that shipping costs back into the United States are impractical; (iv) credible evidence obtained or created in the ordinary course of business from the recipient establishing that the property will be sold to an end user outside the United States; or (v) a written statement describing, among other things, how the seller determined that the property will ultimately be sold to an end user outside the United States.

    Sale of General Property for Further Manufacturing
    Sellers of general property for further manufacturing, assembly or processing outside the United States are limited to the following substantiating items: (i) credible evidence that the property has been sold to a foreign unrelated party that is a manufacturer, and that it cannot be sold to end users without undergoing physical and material change; (ii) credible evidence obtained or created in the ordinary course of business from the recipient that the property will be subject to manufacture, assembly or other processing outside the United States; or (iii) a written statement describing, among other things, how the seller determined that the general property was substantially transformed and, if applicable, that the general property does not exceed twenty percent of the fair market value of the finished goods. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–4(d)(3)(iii).)

    Sales and Licenses of Intangible Property
    To substantiate that intangible property is sold or licensed for foreign use, taxpayers must maintain one or more of the following substantiating items: (i) a binding contract expressly providing that the intangible property can be exploited solely outside the United States; (ii) credible evidence obtained or created in the ordinary course of business from the recipient establishing what portion of its revenue for the taxable year was derived from exploiting the intangible property outside the United States; or (iii) a written statement describing, among other things, how the seller determined (a) the non-US portion of the sale; (b) for periodic payments, the extent of foreign use based on actual revenue earned by the recipient or, if unavailable, an explanation of why such information was unavailable and how the seller determined the extent of foreign use based on estimated revenue; and (c) for lump sum payments, how the seller determined the net present value of expected revenue both inside and outside the United States. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–4(d)(3)(iv).)

    Rendering General Services to Business Recipients
    Finally, a renderer of general services to business recipients must maintain either: (i) credible evidence obtained or created in the ordinary course of business from the recipient establishing the extent to which the non-US operations of the business recipient benefit from the service; or (ii) a written statement explaining, among other things, how the renderer determined what portion of the service will benefit the recipient’s non-US operations, including by potentially relying upon information such as the amount of time that the taxpayer works with each of the recipient’s offices. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–5(e)(4).) Notably, the Preamble confirms that taxpayers that rely upon credible information provided by the recipient will not need the recipient to specify which of its locations benefit from the service—for example, whether the services benefit the recipient’s European operations or its Asian operations—so long as they specify the portion that benefits non-US operations more generally.

    Other Changes to the Substantiation Requirements

    The Final Regulations removed certain documentation requirements that practitioners found to be particularly onerous or otherwise unnecessary to furthering the purpose of the statute. Now, taxpayers no longer need specific documentation to establish foreign person status and can instead often rely on the Final Regulations’ new presumption of foreign person status, which applies where certain facts are met. For example, the Final Regulations provide that certain sales of property are assumed to have been made to a foreign person where the recipient’s billing address is outside the United States. In addition, taxpayers no longer need specific documentation to establish: (i) foreign use with respect to sales of general property directly to end users; and (ii) the location of a consumer of a general service. Instead, the Final Regulations simply set forth which facts must be established for the income to qualify for the deduction.

    As with any deduction, taxpayers that claim a deduction under section 250 bear the burden of demonstrating that they are entitled to their deduction. The Preamble makes clear that even in the absence of specific substantiation requirements, taxpayers must make returns, render statements and keep necessary records to comply with section 6001 and the regulations thereunder. Thus, unlike the Proposed Regulations, the Final Regulations will not impose additional requirements for specific documents or information for transactions that do not have specific substantiation requirements.

    The Final Regulations also provided much-needed clarity and relief regarding certain reliability requirements. For example, the Proposed Regulations contained a constructive knowledge standard under which a seller must not know or have reason to know that documentation was incorrect or unreliable, based on a reasonably prudent person standard. Understandably, practitioners requested further guidance regarding when the constructive knowledge standard applies. In response, under Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–4(c)(1), the Final Regulations clarify that a seller would have such constructive knowledge if it receives information—including an individual’s phone number or billing and shipping address or a business’s place of incorporation or management—indicating that the recipient is not a foreign person and if it fails to obtain evidence establishing otherwise. The Final Regulations apply this constructive knowledge standard to: (i) the treatment of certain loss transactions; (ii) the foreign person status presumption; (iii) sales of general property incorporated into a product as a component; (iv) sales of intangible property consisting of a manufacturing method or process to a foreign unrelated party; and (v) general services provided to consumers.

    Practitioners also objected to a particularly harsh bright-line rule in the Proposed Regulations that stated that taxpayers could not rely upon documents created more than a year prior to the applicable sale or service. These practitioners argued that as proposed, the regulations arguably required domestic businesses to renegotiate long-term contracts annually, thereby opening themselves up to potential economic changes in long-term relationships and putting them at a competitive disadvantage in the international arena. The Final Regulations no longer provide that taxpayers cannot rely upon long-term contracts created more than a year in advance of a sale. In all cases, though, substantiating documentation must be credible, and the age of substantiating documentation may affect its credibility. For example, the Preamble notes that use of long-term contracts will depend upon all facts and circumstances, and that long-term contracts will be more credible in later years than otherwise if taxpayers periodically confirm that both parties are adhering to the terms of the contract.

    The Final Regulations removed two additional bright-line rules that taxpayers had been able to rely upon under the Proposed Regulations, taking the view in each case that the Final Regulations’ more flexible documentation requirements rendered these inflexible rules inappropriate. Under the Proposed Regulations, certain methods used to determine foreign use from the sale of a fungible mass of general property—including market research, statistical sampling, economic modeling and other similar methods—were sufficient to substantiate foreign use. In addition, the Proposed Regulations explicitly allowed taxpayers that provided services to businesses to use publicly available information, including financial statements, to determine and substantiate the foreign use portion of such services. The Preamble states that given the Final Regulations’ approach, it is no longer necessary to prescribe that specific substantiation methods—including market research and publicly available information—are reliable sources of information for these purposes. To the contrary, the Preamble notes that these specific methods are now presumed to be unreliable sources of information for these purposes, based on a view that substantiation that relies upon statistical sampling, economic modeling or market data research based upon taxpayers’ own data will generally be more reliable. Especially given that the Final Regulations retained the rule that a business recipient includes all related parties (as defined in Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–(1)(c)(19)), taxpayers that had relied upon publicly available information to substantiate general services provided to business recipients may find themselves worse off than they had been under the Proposed Regulations.

    The Proposed Regulations included an exception that exempted small businesses—defined as taxpayers with less than $10 million USD of gross receipts per taxable year—from certain documentation requirements. Taxpayers requested that Treasury expand this exception to apply to larger companies. In response, the Final Regulations increased the threshold to $25 million USD of gross receipts. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–3(f)(2).) However, this change is not as far-reaching as taxpayers had hoped. This is especially true in light of the fact that the threshold calculation now includes not only gross receipts received by the taxpayer, but also gross receipts received by related parties (defined as any members of an affiliated group under section 1504(a), when modified to include a 50%, as opposed to 80%, threshold). (See: Treas. Reg. §§ 1.250(b)–1(c)(17) and –(1)(c)(19).) As a result, businesses that previously qualified for this benefit will need to confirm that the exception still applies. Small businesses that qualify will not need to satisfy any specific substantiation requirement, though they are still subject to the general substantiation rules under section 6001.

    As before, the Final Regulations maintain the rule that substantiating documentation must be in existence at the time the taxpayer files its tax return (including extensions). (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–3(f)(1).) The Final Regulations further provide that taxpayers must submit substantiating documentation to the IRS within 30 days of its request, unless otherwise agreed. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)–3(f)(1).)

    Effective Date and Transition Rule

    Taxpayers are provided some flexibility in determining which set of regulations to apply for taxable years beginning before January 1, 2021, when the entirety of the Final Regulations become mandatory. Until then, taxpayers may choose to apply either the Proposed Regulations or the Final Regulations in their entirety. However, acknowledging that taxpayers may not be able to substantiate their deductions with information already available to them, the Final Regulations provide that taxpayers that choose to rely on the Final Regulations in pre-2021 tax years do not need to comply with the specific substantiation rules described in the first part of this article during this interim period. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.250-1(b).)

    Taxpayers that choose to rely on the Proposed Regulations are entitled to rely upon the favorable “documentation transition rule” as previously set forth, under which a taxpayer may substantiate its FDII deduction by using any reasonable documentation maintained in its ordinary course of business. Though the Proposed Regulations limited this transition rule to taxable years beginning on or before March 4, 2019, the Preamble makes clear that taxpayers may rely on the transition rule for documentation for all taxable years beginning before January 1, 2021. When deciding which regulations to apply, taxpayers should thus carefully analyze both the substantive provisions and the documentation requirements set forth under each regime.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Government Releases Final Regulations on FDII and GILTI Deduction

    Government Releases Final Regulations on FDII and GILTI Deduction

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Government Releases Final Regulations on FDII and GILTI Deduction

    July 24, 2020

    Read time: 17 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 9, 2020, the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and Internal Revenue Service (IRS) released Final Regulations (Final Regulations) that provide guidance on the section 250 deduction for foreign-derived intangible income (FDII) and global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI). Enacted as part of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), section 250 currently provides a deduction for domestic corporations equal to the sum of 37.5% of their FDII and 50% of their GILTI and section 78 gross-up. Electing section 962 shareholders are entitled to claim the section 250 deduction with respect to GILTI. The Final Regulations finalize the proposed regulations (the Proposed Regulations) issued in March 2019 with significant modifications, but are generally taxpayer-friendly. Further, the preamble to the Final Regulations (the Preamble) provides temporary guidance on certain topics and notes the government’s reservations in several areas where further guidance is expected. The discussion set forth below summarizes the key highlights from the Final Regulations and Preamble.

    In depth

    More Flexible Documentation Rules

    As one of the most notable changes, the Final Regulations significantly modified the proposed documentation requirements, generally allowing taxpayers more flexibility to substantiate their transactions as for foreign use. For example, except for certain transactions that are subject to new specific substantiation requirements, the Final Regulations relax most documentation requirements, loosen prior reliability rules and generally allow taxpayers to presume foreign person status, such that taxpayers may claim a FDII benefit so long as they can substantiate that they are entitled to the section 250 deduction under section 6001 and its regulations. Further, the Final Regulations expanded the transition rule set forth under the Proposed Regulations, thereby allowing taxpayers to rely on the current taxpayer-friendly documentation standard until the Final Regulations are effective. Some of these points are discussed in the topics below. Read our previous client alert, “Burdensome documentation requirements modified under the Final Section 250 Regulations,”for a more comprehensive and specific summary of the FDII documentation rules.

    Notable Revisions to Deduction for FDII and GILTI

    The Final Regulations reserve on coordinating sections 163(j), 172(a) and other Internal Revenue Code provisions with respect to section 250, and remove an example in the Proposed Regulations that applied this rule. The prior ordering rule in the Proposed Regulations provided that a taxpayer’s taxable income for purposes of applying the taxable income limitation of section 250(a)(2) is determined after all of the corporation’s other deductions are taken into account. As a result, taxpayers with sizable net operating losses (NOLs) and business interest expense could receive a significantly lower section 250 deduction, if any.

    The Preamble allows taxpayers to use any “reasonable method” to determine how allowed deductions are taken into account in determining the section 250(a)(2) taxable income limitation, provided it is applied consistently for all taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2021. Given that there is no carryback or carryforward of a taxpayer’s FDII deduction in excess of their taxable income limitation, taxpayers should consider employing methods that afford priority to section 250 deductions over NOLs or business interest expense, each of which can be carried forward.

    Notable Revisions to Computation of FDII (Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)-1)

    Cost of Goods Sold Allocation
    In the Final Regulations, IRS retained the rule that for purposes of determining gross income included in gross deduction-eligible income (DEI) and gross foreign-derived deduction-eligible income (FDDEI), cost of goods sold is attributed to gross receipts with respect to gross DEI or gross FDDEI under any reasonable method. Although the rule was retained, the Final Regulations clarified that the cost of goods sold allocation method selected by a taxpayer must be consistently applied. Taxpayers cannot segregate cost of goods sold associated with activities undertaken in an earlier tax year (including a tax year before the effective date of the Final Regulations) into component costs and attribute them disproportionately to amounts excluded from gross FDDEI or to amounts excluded from gross DEI.

    Expense Allocation
    Section 250(b)(3) generally requires taxpayers to determine deductions that are “properly allocable” to gross DEI, but for that purpose, the statute does not specify an allocation method. The proposed section 250 regulations provided that reg. sections 1.861-8 through 1.861-14T and 1.861-17 were to be applied for purposes of allocating deductions to gross DEI and gross FDDEI by treating section 250(b) as an operative section described in reg. section 1.861-8(f). For purposes of allocating expenses under those specific section 861 regulations, the Proposed Regulations treated: (a) gross FDDEI and gross non-FDDEI as separate statutory groupings; and (b) excluded gross income as the residual grouping. Moreover, the Proposed Regulations did not take into account the exclusive apportionment rule contained in reg. section 1.861-17(b).

    The Final Regulations eliminated the provision that excluded the exclusive apportionment rule contained in reg. section 1.861-17(b). The IRS explained the removal of such provision was in view of the proposed section 1.861-17 regulations it issued in December 2019.

    Treasury and IRS also adopted and expanded the taxpayer recommendation that pre-2018 NOLs (i.e., NOLs incurred before the effective date of the Proposed Regulations or, in certain cases, NOLs incurred before the effective date of the TCJA) be disregarded when allocating expenses to gross DEI and gross FDDEI. Namely, the Final Regulations provide that sections 163(j), 170(b)(2), 172, 246(b) and 250 are inapplicable when allocating and apportioning deductions to gross DEI or gross FDDEI of a taxpayer for a given tax year.

    Foreign-Derived Ratio
    Treasury and IRS adopted a rule in the Final Regulations indicating that the foreign-derived ratio (FDDEI to DEI) cannot exceed 1. By mechanically applying the definitions and rules in the statute and Proposed Regulations, the preamble to the Proposed Regulations noted that it could be possible that the foreign-derived ratio could exceed 1 in certain factual situations, and several comments to the Proposed Regulations argued for that to be permitted. However, Treasury and IRS took the position that permitted the foreign-derived ratio to exceed 1 would be inconsistent with section 250.

    Foreign Branch Income for FDII Purposes
    The Final Regulations include a definition of “foreign branch income” for FDII purposes that is fully consistent with the definition in the final foreign tax credit regulations issued in 2019. The Proposed Regulations had defined foreign branch income for FDII purposes by cross-reference to the foreign tax regulations but had also treated as foreign branch income any income or gain from the disposition of an asset that gives rise to foreign branch income. The Proposed Regulations’ expanded definition created the possibility of foreign branch income when disposing of a disregarded entity holding a foreign branch or when disposing of an asset that had been transferred from a foreign branch to its owner. This is significant because foreign branch income cannot be gross FDDEI. By making the foreign branch income definition for FDII purposes consistent with the foreign tax credit regulations, the Final Regulations allow for a FDII deduction with respect to income from disposition of a disregarded entity or an asset formerly on the books of a foreign branch.

    Revisions to the Determination of Qualified Business Asset Investment

    The Final Regulations revise the Proposed Regulations’ rules for determining qualified business asset investment (QBAI) with respect to dual-use property. Consistent with earlier revisions made with respect to analogous GILTI provisions, the Final Regulations remove the concept of “directly identifiable income” and generally provide that the basis of dual-use property is included in QBAI for FDII purposes in proportion to the extent that depreciation deductions with respect to such property would be allocable to gross DEI. Also, the Final Regulations include a relief provision providing that the sale/leaseback anti-avoidance rule of Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)-2(h) does not apply to transfers of property occurring before March 4, 2019.

    FDDEI Transactions

    Reliability of Documentation
    The Final Regulations replace the documentation requirements contained in the Proposed Regulations with more flexible substantiation rules, where different types of corroborating evidence may be used in that regard. The “reason to know” standard was retained: A taxpayer has a “reason to know” that a transaction fails to satisfy a substantive requirement if the information received by a taxpayer contains information indicating the substantive requirement is not met and, after making reasonable efforts, the taxpayer cannot establish the substantive requirement is met.

    Sales or Services to a Partnership
    In the partnership context, questions requiring clarification were: (i) whether a domestic corporation may deduct its share of a partnership’s FDII; and (ii) whether FDII be computed based on the entity approach (at the partnership level and the approach suggested in the Proposed Regulations) or based on the aggregate approach (computed at the partner level). The Final Regulations retained the rule in the Proposed Regulations that domestic corporate partners in a partnership are permitted to include their share of such partnership’s items of gross DEI, gross FDDEI and related deductions for purposes of calculating their FDII amount—thus, an aggregate approach is applied.

    Conversely, for purposes of determining whether a sale or service is a FDDEI transaction, Treasury and IRS require the application of the entity approach. Because sales to a domestic partnership do not qualify as a FDDEI sale because such partnership is not a “foreign person,” taxpayers recommended alternatives to the entity approach; namely, to treat a sale to a partnership as a FDDEI sale: (i) to the extent the partnership predominantly engages in a foreign business; or (ii) to the extent of its ownership by direct and indirect foreign partners. Those approaches were not adopted, which gives rise to a curious result that a sale to a foreign partnership owned by US persons can qualify as a FDDEI sale.

    Treatment of Certain Loss Transactions
    The Final Regulations generally retained the rule set forth in the Proposed Regulations that if a taxpayer knows or has reason to know that property is sold to a foreign person for a foreign use or a general service is provided to a person located outside the United States, but the taxpayer does not satisfy the documentation requirements applicable to such sale or service, the sale of property or provision of a service is nonetheless deemed a FDDEI transaction if treating the sale or service as a FDDEI transaction would reduce a taxpayer’s FDDEI. The rule contained in the Proposed Regulations was also modified by causing the loss transaction rules to only apply to transactions for which there is a specific documentation requirement.

    Predominant Character of a Transaction
    The Final Regulations retained the rule set forth in the Proposed Regulations that the predominant character of a transaction will prevail in determining whether such transaction is governed under the FDDEI sales rules or the FDDEI services rules. Taxpayers suggested including an election based on generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) that would permit taxpayers to elect whether a transaction was a sale or a service transaction. However, Treasury and IRS declined to adopt such a rule, citing, among other things, complexity and administrability issues.

    FDDEI Sales

    Presumptions Regarding Foreign Person Status and Foreign Use
    The Proposed Regulations had required specific documentation to establish that a sale was made to a foreign person and was for a foreign use. In contrast, the Final Regulations generally provide presumptions that eliminate the need for taxpayers to collect specific documents from third-party purchasers. In particular, under the Final Regulations, foreign person status generally can be presumed if property is sold in a foreign retail sale, or based on a shipping address or a billing address. Additionally, foreign use generally can be presumed for sales to end users, while sales to other recipients are subject to substantiation requirements (which may be satisfied by statements prepared by the seller).

    Sales for Further Manufacturing or Assembly
    The Proposed Regulations provided that general property may be considered used outside the United States if: (1) there is a physical and material change to the property; or (2) the property is incorporated as a component into a second product. To satisfy the component test, the value of the property received by the recipient could not be more than 20% of the value of the property into which it was incorporated. In contrast, under the Final Regulations, general property may be considered used outside the United States if: (1) it is substantially transformed and is distinguishable from, and cannot be returned to, its original state; or (2) it is incorporated as a component into another product by way or activities that are substantial in nature and generally considered manufacturing, assembly or processing (not just packaging, or minor assembly). Additionally, the 20% requirement in the Proposed Regulations is merely a safe harbor in the Final Regulations.

    Manufacturing Method or Process Intangibles
    Under the Proposed Regulations, in contrast to the rule for general property, intangible property that is used in manufacturing is considered used where the manufactured product is used. In response to comments requesting that such intangible property be considered used where manufacturing occurs, the Final Regulations include a narrow rule that an unrelated purchaser of a manufacturing method or process intangible is treated as an end user of the intangible. The Final Regulations otherwise follow the approach of the Proposed Regulations.

    Establishing Foreign Use of Intangible Property
    The Final Regulations clarify the rules for determining the extent to which intangible property is treated as used outside the United States. With regard to intangible property transferred in exchange for periodic payments, foreign use is determined annually based on actual revenue in that year. Significantly, if there is a periodic payment in a year when the intangible property does not actually produce revenue, no portion of the intangible property is treated as having a foreign use in that year. In contrast, where intangible property is transferred in exchange for a lump sum, foreign use is determined based on projections of the net present value of income the seller would have earned from exploiting the intangible property outside the United States.

    FDDEI Services

    The Proposed Regulations divided FDDEI services into five mutually exclusive categories, each of which have their own rules for determining FDDEI eligibility. The Final Regulations retain the five categories, but make a number of changes, which include the following:

    • Add two net subcategories of general services for “electronically supplied services” and “advertising services.” Electronically supplied services are general services that are delivered primarily over the internet or an electronic network, but exclude advertising services. Advertising services are general services that consist primarily of transmitting or displaying content (including via the internet) to consumers to generate revenue based on promotion of a product or a service. Each subcategory provides special rules for determining where a service is accessed, with varying rules for recipients that are consumers (individuals) or businesses. For example, for electronically supplied services to consumers, the Final Regulations provide that a customer is deemed to reside at the location of the device used to receive the service, which may be based on the location of an IP address, if available. And if the location of the device cannot be determined after reasonable efforts, the general rule based on billing address applies, subject to not knowing or having reason to know standard. For electronically supplied services to businesses, the Final Regulations provide that a business is deemed to reside where the service is accessed by the business recipient, which includes its employees, contractors or agents.
    • Adopt a more flexible approach to documentation requirements for general services provided to consumers by not including a finite list of specific documentation. Further, if a provider does not have consumer’s location of residence, the consumer is treated as residing outside the United States if the consumer has a foreign billing address, subject to a “knows or reason to know” standard.
    • For determining location of a business recipient (other than those that receive advertising or electronically supplied services), taxpayers are allowed to make “reliable assumptions” based upon available information. Further, the Final Regulations remove the provision stating that if the renderer cannot obtain “reliable information” regarding which specific locations of a business are conferred a benefit, then the gross income is allocated ratably to all business locations. In line with more flexible documentation regime, the Final Regulations remove the Proposed Regulations’ bright-line rule wherein “market research” would establish foreign use.
    • Expand definition of a “property service” to include circumstances where services are provided with respect to tangible property that is “temporarily” located in the United States, but requires several conditions to be satisfied.

    Related-Party Transactions

    The Final Regulations make several changes to the Proposed Regulations’ rules for determining the circumstances in which the sale of property by a domestic corporation to a foreign related party (related-party sales) could constitute FDDEI sales.

    Most prominently, in situations where a foreign related party purchases property in a related-party sale and then sells the property to an unrelated party in a FDDEI transaction (unrelated sale), the Proposed Regulations provided that the domestic corporation could not treat the related-party sale as a FDDEI sale until the unrelated sale occurred. In particular, if the unrelated sale did not occur until after the FDII filing date with respect to the related-party sale, then the domestic corporation would have to file an amended return to claim any additional FDII benefit resulting from treating the related-party sale as a FDDEI sale.

    Recognizing the administrative burdens (and possible statute of limitations issues) associated with filing amended returns, the Final Regulations remove the “amended return requirement” and provide that the domestic corporation can treat a related-party sale as a FDDEI sale if it can substantiate that an unrelated sale “will occur” with respect to the property sold in the related-party sale. The Final Regulations provide examples of information that can provide substantiation, such as contractual terms that restrict the foreign related party to sell the property to foreign unrelated parties.

    In situations where a foreign related party purchases property in a related-party sale and then uses the property to produce other property sold to unrelated parties or to provide services to unrelated parties in FDDEI transactions (unrelated transactions), the Proposed Regulations provided that the related-party sale could be treated as a FDDEI sale only if more than 80% of the foreign related party’s revenue with respect to the property purchased will be earned from unrelated transactions.

    Recognizing the potential for a cliff effect, the Final Regulations remove the 80% threshold and provide that such a related-party sale can be treated as a FDDEI sale to the extent that the domestic corporation “reasonably expects” the revenue with respect to the property purchased to be earned from unrelated transactions.

    The Final Regulations also expand Treas. Reg. § 1.250(b)-6(c)(3) to provide that a related-party sale can generally be treated as a FDDEI sale despite the presence of a US intermediary in the later supply chain. Under the Proposed Regulations, such sales could be treated as FDDEI sales only if the later supply chain consisted exclusively of foreign entities.

    Electing Section 962 Shareholders

    The Final Regulations retain the rule in the Proposed Regulations that allows section 962-electing taxpayers to take into account the section 250 deduction for GILTI. The Preamble notes uncertainty regarding situations in which individuals may make a section 962 election on an amended return, and states that the Treasury and IRS are considering issuing further guidance under section 962. Further, the Preamble provides that until further guidance is published on this issue, individuals are permitted to make a section 962 election on an amended return for the 2018 tax year and subsequent years, provided the interests of the government are not prejudiced by the delay and the Preamble provides further explanation in this regard.

    Non-corporate US taxpayers with controlled foreign corporation (CFC) structures should examine their US federal income tax reporting to determine if a section 962 election might benefit them in prior years 2018 or 2019, or thereafter. For example, to the extent a non-corporate US taxpayer has recently discovered that the repeal of section 958(b)(4) has caused CFC implications to a closely held structure, a section 962 election might be a favorable solution to minimizing the adverse tax consequences of CFC status. Read the article from Tax Notes, “A guide to managing downward attribution for determining CFC status,” for more information on the repeal of section 958(b)(4).

    Authors

    Michael J. Bruno

    Partner

    Miami

    Brian H. Jenn

    Partner

    Washington, DC, Chicago

    Gregory Weigand

    Counsel

    Miami, New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights