Content Type: Article

  • White House Revamps Chinese Securities Trading Ban

    White House Revamps Chinese Securities Trading Ban

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    White House Revamps Chinese Securities Trading Ban

    June 8, 2021

    Read time: 17 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 3, 2021, the Biden administration announced significant revisions to the sanctions program directed at Chinese publicly traded securities originally established by President Donald Trump’s Executive Order issued on Nov. 12, 2020. These changes take the form of an amended Executive Order[1] and several new and updated Frequently Asked Questions (“FAQs”) issued by the U.S. Department of Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”).[2] Taken together, these actions expand the scope of the China sanctions program in certain respects, ease the restrictions in other respects, clarify certain issues important to private investment funds and other market participants, and create new uncertainties as to other issues. This Alert summarizes the key changes made on June 3, 2021; for background on the Chinese securities trading ban, please see our prior Alerts dated Nov. 13, 2020, Dec. 31, 2020 and Jan. 19, 2021.[3]

    List of Covered Companies: Additions and Subtractions

    Executive Order 14032 issued on June 3, 2021 (“New E.O.”) “replace[s] and supersede[s]” key provisions of Executive Order 13959 issued on Nov. 12, 2020 (“2020 E.O.”). An Annex to the New E.O. lists the names of 59 publicly traded Chinese companies whose securities are subject to the trading restrictions set forth in the New E.O. Under the New E.O., U.S. persons are prohibited from engaging in “the purchase or sale of any publicly traded securities, or any publicly traded securities that are derivative of such securities or are designed to provide investment exposure to such securities,” of these 59 companies effective Aug. 2, 2021 (except for divestment transactions as discussed below).

    The list of 59 companies overlaps in part with the 44 companies designated during the Trump administration. A little over half of the 59 companies listed in the Annex were previously designated pursuant to the 2020 E.O. or are linked to previously designated companies. The remaining companies listed in the Annex, however, have been identified for the first time. OFAC has published a list of the companies, including ISIN and equity ticker information, on OFAC’s website.[4]

    Notably, many of the 44 companies designated during the Trump administration are not included in the Annex to the New E.O. Among the companies omitted from the Annex are all nine companies identified as Tranche 5 published by the U.S. Department of Defense on Jan. 14, 2021. The Defense Department’s Tranche 5 included Xiaomi Corp. and Luokung Technology Corp., both of which subsequently obtained preliminary injunctions from the U.S. District Court in the District Columbia preventing the trading ban from taking effect. It thus appears that at least for now, the Biden administration has abandoned any effort to re-impose trading sanctions against Xiaomi or Luokung.

    As the New E.O. replaces and supersedes the prohibitions set forth in the 2020 E.O., it appears that U.S. persons are now free to engage in transactions (including purchases) of the publicly traded securities of companies that were previously designated during the Trump administration but do not appear in the Annex to the New E.O.

    Timing and Effectiveness

    The New E.O.’s prohibitions on trading in the public securities of the 59 listed companies will take effect on 12:01 am ET on Aug. 2, 2021, 2021.[5] This 60-day window period parallels the similar 60-day window provided for in the 2020 E.O. However, the 12:01 am start time is different: the 2020 E.O.’s trading ban took effect at 9:30 am on the 60th day post-designation.

    Significantly, it appears that the Aug. 2, 2021 effective date for the trading ban applies to all 59 companies named in the New E.O., including the companies previously sanctioned under the Trump administration. The language of the New E.O. indicates that the trading restrictions previously imposed under the 2020 Order have now come to an end and that, to the extent the same companies are now subject to the trading restrictions in the New E.O., those restrictions do not take effect until Aug. 2, 2021. In other words, the new E.O. appears to create a window between June 3, 2021 and Aug. 2, 2021 in which purchases and sales of these companies’ securities is permissible.

    Legal Rationale for Imposition of Sanctions

    The New E.O. also reformulates the legal basis for this sanctions program. The 2020 E.O. was tied to Section 1237 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 1999 (“NDAA”), which empowers the Secretary of Defense to designate “Communist Chinese military companies” operating directly or indirectly in the United States in support of People’s Liberation Army of China. Under the 2020 E.O., the trading ban applied to publicly traded securities of all Communist Chinese military companies designated by the Secretary of Defense pursuant to Section 1237 of the NDAA, or determined by the Secretary of Treasury to meet the criteria in Section 1237.

    Under the New E.O., designation under Section 1237 is no longer a prerequisite to imposition of the trading restrictions, nor can the Secretary of Defense decide which companies are designated. Rather, the sanctions may be imposed against the securities of any company determined by the Secretary of Treasury (in consultation with the Secretary of State and, as appropriate, the Secretary of Defense) either (i) “to operate or have operated in the defense and related materiel sector or the surveillance technology sector of the economy of the PRC”; or (ii) “to own or control, or to be owned or controlled by, directly or indirectly,” such a company.

    Moreover, the New E.O. finds that, in addition to the threat posed by China’s military-industrial complex identified in the 2020 E.O., “the use of Chinese surveillance technology” both outside the PRC and to facilitate human rights abuses within the PRC constitutes a threat to United States interests, and expands the scope of the national emergency declared in the 2020 E.O. to address those threats. Newly issued OFAC FAQ 900 states that OFAC “expects to use its discretion to target” companies whose operations have included or supported “surveillance of persons by Chinese technology companies that occurs outside of the PRC,” as well as “the development, marketing, sale, or export of Chinese surveillance technology” that is, was, or can be used for surveillance of religious or ethnic minorities or otherwise facilitate repression or serious human rights abuses.[6]

    By placing the sanctions regime on this different legal footing, it may be easier for the Biden administration to defend against court challenges by Chinese companies that have already been sanctioned or may be sanctioned in the future. In their successful legal challenges, Xiaomi and Luokung were able to persuade the court that the government had failed to establish that the companies met the criteria for a “Communist Chinese military company” as defined in Section 1237 of the NDAA.[7]

    Reflecting this change in approach, sanctioned Chinese companies will no longer be referred to as “Communist Chinese Military Companies,” or “CCMCs” for short, as was previously the case. Henceforth, sanctioned companies will be referred to as “Chinese Military-Industrial Complex Companies,” or “CMICs.” OFAC has replaced the list of CCMCs previously published on its website with a “Non-SDN Chinese Military-Industrial Complex Companies List,” or “NS-CMIC List.”[8]

    Divestment of Sanctioned Securities

    In parallel to the 2020 E.O., the New E.O. provides an exception that allows U.S. persons ten months from the effective date of the trading prohibitions, or until 12:01 am ET on June 3, 2022, to engage in purchases or sales of sanctioned securities made “solely to effect the divestment, in whole or in part,” of positions held in such securities as of Aug. 2, 2021.[9]

    But the divestment provisions in the New E.O. differ in another respect. The Trump administration had issued an Executive Order (E.O. 13974) amending the 2020 E.O. and explicitly banning “possession” of sanctioned securities following the expiration of the ten-month divestment period. This amendment made clear, as OFAC explained in FAQ 872, that U.S. persons were not simply permitted to divest sanctioned securities during the divestment period but were in fact required to do so. The New E.O., however, revokes E.O. 13974 in its entirety, and FAQ 872 has now also been repealed. Therefore, it appears that U.S. persons now are no longer required to divest any sanctioned securities they hold as of Aug. 2, 2021. However, once the divestment period expires on June 3, 2022, U.S. persons will not be permitted to engage in any further transactions (either purchases or sales) involving these securities.

    In addition, it appears that U.S. persons now have additional time to divest themselves of sanctioned securities of entities designated as CCMCs pursuant to the 2020 E.O. and as CMICs pursuant to the New E.O. Under the 2020 E.O., divestment of CCMC securities was required within ten months of when the trading prohibitions went into effect. But the elimination of the divestment provisions contained in the 2020 E.O. appears to mean that, even if the particular CCMC is also named as a CMIC under the New E.O., U.S. persons now have until June 3, 2022 to divest any securities they still hold in the name. In the case of securities of CCMCs that are not named as CMICs under the New E.O., it appears that U.S. persons are no longer obligated to divest themselves of such securities.

    Definition of ‘Publicly Traded Securities’

    The 2020 E.O. applied to “any transaction in publicly traded securities, or any securities that are derivative of, or are designed to provide investment exposure to such securities,” of CCMCs. The 2020 E.O. (as amended) also defined the term “transaction” to mean “the purchase for value, or sale, of any publicly traded security.” Tracking the language of its predecessor, the New E.O. applies to “the purchase or sale of any publicly traded securities, or any publicly traded securities that are derivative of such securities or are designed to provide investment exposure to such securities,” of CMICs.

    The 2020 E.O. did not contain a definition of the term “publicly traded securities.” It did, however, define the terms “security” and “securities” to include any “security” as defined in Section 3(a)(10) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. The definition also encompassed currency and notes, drafts, bills of exchange and banker’s acceptances with a maturity not exceeding nine months. By contrast, the New E.O. instead contains a definition of the term “publicly traded securities,” which states that the term includes any “security” as defined in Section 3(a)(10) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 “denominated in any currency that trades on a securities exchange or through the method of trading that is commonly referred to as ‘over-the-counter,’ in any jurisdiction.” The New E.O. omits any reference to currency and notes and similar instruments with a maturity not exceeding nine months.

    Under the 2020 E.O., OFAC issued FAQ 860, which listed, as examples of financial instruments covered by the trading ban, “derivatives (e.g., futures, options, swaps), warrants, American depositary receipts (ADRs), global depositary receipts (GDRs), exchange-traded funds (ETFs), index funds, and mutual funds,” to the extent such instruments also meet the definition of a “security” under the Securities Exchange Act. As part of the updated FAQs issued on June 3, 2021, OFAC has reissued FAQ 860, listing the same financial instruments as examples of those covered by the trading ban in the New E.O., “to the extent such instruments also meet the definition of ‘publicly traded security’” in the New E.O.[10]  

    It thus appears that the scope of transactions in “publicly traded securities” affected by the New E.O. is largely co-extensive with the scope of the 2020 E.O. Fundamentally, the definition remains tied to the Securities Exchange Act’s definition of “security.” Therefore, to the extent that particular instruments do not meet the Exchange Act definition of a “security” — as is the case with futures and swaps on so-called broad-based market indices — such instruments should remain outside the scope of the New E.O.

    ‘Close Matches’ and Subsidiaries

    Significant confusion was created by FAQ 858 issued by OFAC under the 2020 E.O. That FAQ stated that the prohibitions in the 2020 E.O. applied with respect to publicly traded securities of a company with a name that either exactly matches or “closely matches” the name of a designated company. Responding to concerns that such a vague standard left market participants uncertain as to what securities were prohibited, OFAC subsequently issued a series of temporary General Licenses, before the “closely matches” standard ever became effective, that authorized transactions with respect to companies whose name “closely matches” that of a designated company, so long as it was not a designated company itself. The last of these General Licenses was due to expire on June 11.

    OFAC has now issued FAQ 899, which states: “Only entities whose names exactly match the names of the entities on the NS-CMIC List are subject to the prohibitions in [the New E.O.].”[11] FAQ 858 has been repealed. Accordingly, at least at this juncture, OFAC no longer intends to extend the trading restrictions to companies that have not themselves been designated but whose name “closely matches” that of a designated company.

    Similarly, OFAC FAQ 857, issued under the 2020 E.O., stated that OFAC intended to designate as CCMCs any publicly traded subsidiaries of existing CCMCs (i.e., entities that were either owned 50% or more by a CCMC or controlled by a CCMC). In the updated FAQ 857 issued on June 3, 2021, OFAC has eliminated that language and has instead stated that the prohibitions in the New E.O. apply to subsidiaries of CMICs “only if such subsidiary itself is publicly listed on the NS-CMIC List” published by OFAC.[12] New FAQ 857 further notes that OFAC’s so-called 50% rule, pursuant to which any entity owned 50% or more by a Specially Designated National (“SDN”) is itself considered an SDN even if has not been identified as an SDN, “does not apply to entities listed solely pursuant to [the New E.O.].”[13] CMICs are not SDNs and U.S. persons remain free to engage in other transactions with these companies that are unrelated to their publicly held securities, such as the purchase or sale of goods or services.[14]

    Affected Persons

    Like the 2020 E.O., the New E.O. only prohibits activities by any “United States person.” This term is defined in the same fashion as under the 2020 E.O.: It encompasses “any United States citizen, lawful permanent resident, entity organized under the laws of the United States or any jurisdiction within the United States (including foreign branches), or any person in the United States.” Therefore, as a general matter, the New E.O. does not restrict the activities of non-U.S. persons.

    It should be noted, however, that the New E.O. (like the 2020 E.O.) includes a broad and customary anti-evasion provision prohibiting “any transaction that evades or avoids, has the purpose of evading or avoiding, causes a violation of, or attempts to violate any of the prohibitions set forth in this order[.]” The New E.O. also prohibits “[a]ny conspiracy formed to violate any of the prohibitions set forth in this order[.]” In the context of other sanctions programs, OFAC has taken the position that non-U.S. persons can be deemed to have violated the applicable sanctions by taking actions that “cause” a U.S. person to engage in a prohibited transaction.

    Investment Advisory and Management Services to Non-US Funds

    Private fund managers organized or operating in the United States will generally be covered by the New E.O., as would funds organized in the United States. Newly issued OFAC FAQ 902 has, however, clarified that U.S. persons may provide investment advisory, investment management and similar services to non-U.S. persons (such as a foreign fund) in connection with the non-U.S. person’s purchase or sale of a sanctioned security, so long as the underlying purchase or sale would not otherwise violate the Order (such as in the case that the purchase or sale is ultimately for the benefit of a U.S. person, or otherwise an attempt to willfully evade the New E.O.).[15]

    At the same time, OFAC has reissued FAQ 861 in substantially identical form. FAQ 861 states that the New E.O. “prohibit[] U.S. persons from investing in U.S. or foreign funds, such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or other mutual funds, that hold publicly traded securities of” CMICs. As with the prior version of FAQ 861, this remains true “regardless of such securities’ share of the underlying index fund, ETF or derivative thereof.”[16] Therefore, restrictions remain on the ability of U.S. investors to invest in funds that continue to trade sanctioned securities.

    OFAC has, however, retained the guidance in FAQ 865 that allows U.S. persons to invest in investment funds that hold sanctioned securities but are “seeking to divest” those securities during the relevant wind-down periods. Specifically, as updated, FAQ 865 states: “Purchase or sales by U.S. persons (including investors and intermediaries) involving investment funds that are seeking to divest during the relevant wind-down periods are permitted.”[17]

    US Employees of Non-US Companies

    The impact of the 2020 E.O. on the activities of U.S. citizens who work for non-U.S. firms was unclear. Caution was warranted because OFAC sanctions often are considered to restrict the activities of U.S. citizens even when they live and work abroad. However, OFAC FAQ 903 now clarifies that U.S. persons employed by non-U.S. firms are not prohibited from being involved in, or otherwise facilitating, purchases or sales related to securities covered by the New E.O. on behalf of their non-U.S. employer, if those activities fall within the ordinary course of their employment and the purchase or sale in question would not otherwise violate the New E.O. (such as being for the ultimate benefit of U.S. persons or as part of a scheme of circumventing the Order).[18]

    Market Makers and Market Intermediaries

    Newly issued OFAC FAQ 904 clarifies that U.S. market makers, as well as non-U.S. market makers who employ U.S. persons, are permitted to engage in activities necessary to effect divestiture of sanctioned securities during the applicable wind-down period.[19] OFAC has also reissued that portion of FAQ 865 that allows market intermediaries, including market makers, to engage in ancillary or intermediary activities that are necessary to effect divestiture during the relevant wind-down periods.[20]

    OFAC FAQ 901 specifies that for purposes of conducting due diligence as to whether a particular purchase or sale is permissible under the New E.O., U.S. persons, including financial institutions, registered broker-dealers, securities exchanges, and other market intermediaries and participants, “may rely upon the information available to them in the ordinary course of business.”[21]  

    As in our previous Alerts on this topic, we note that the operation of the Chinese public securities trading ban is complex and questions will inevitably arise involving its impact on both U.S. and non-U.S. fund managers as well as other market participants. The actions taken by the Biden administration on June 3, 2021 demonstrate that, for the foreseeable future, this sanctions program is here to stay and may well be expanded. Firms are advised to carefully consider how the revised sanctions affect their trading and investment activities and to monitor for future developments.

    Authored by Gary Stein, Betty Santangelo, Melissa G.R. Goldstein, Hannah M. Thibideau and Joshua B. Wright.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See Executive Order: Addressing The Threat From Securities Investments That Finance Certain Companies Of The People’s Republic Of China (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [2] For entities subsequently subject to a sanctions determination, the safe harbor will extend to 12:01 am ET on the date that is 365 days after the date of the determination.

    [3] See White House Bans Trading in 31 Chinese Companies (Nov. 13, 2020), available here; OFAC Provides Guidance on Trading Ban in Chinese Companies (Dec. 31, 2020), available here; US Sanctions on Chinese Company Securities: Further Developments (January 19, 2021), available here.

    [4] See OFAC, “Non-SDN Chinese Military-Industrial Complex Companies List,” available here.

    [5] For entities subsequently sanctioned under the New E.O., restrictions on trading will apply beginning at 12:01 am ET on the date that is 60 days after the date of the sanctions determination.

    [6] See FAQ No. 900, available here.

    [7] See Xiaomi Corp. v. Dep’t of Defense, 2021 WL 950144 (D.D.C. Mar. 12, 2021); Luokung Technology Corp. v. Dep’t of Defense, 2021 WL 1820265 (D.D.C. May 5, 2021).

    [8] See FAQ No. 898, available here; and FAQ No. 899, available here.

    [9] For persons subsequently subject to a sanctions determination, the safe harbor will extend to 12:01 am ET on the date that is 365 days after the date of the determination.

    [10] See FAQ No. 860 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [11] See FAQ No. 899 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [12] See FAQ No. 857 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [13] See FAQ No. 857 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [14] See FAQ No. 905 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [15] See FAQ No. 902 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [16] See FAQ No. 861 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [17] See FAQ No. 865 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [18] See FAQ No. 903 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [19] See FAQ No. 904 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [20] See FAQ No. 865 (June 3, 2021), available here.

    [21] See FAQ No. 901 (June 3, 2021), available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2021 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • President Biden Elevates Anticorruption Enforcement

    President Biden Elevates Anticorruption Enforcement

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    President Biden Elevates Anticorruption Enforcement

    June 7, 2021

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Last week, President Biden issued a memorandum on Establishing the Fight Against Corruption as a Core United States National Security Interest. The memorandum ushers in a new era of collaboration between federal agencies and establishes a whole-of-government approach to fighting global corruption in furtherance of the national security interests of the United States.

    The memorandum establishes countering corruption as a “core United States national security interest.” It directs White House officials to coordinate a 200-day interagency review process and develop a strategy to strengthen the United States’ ability to achieve 10 objectives centered on building a more robust global anticorruption infrastructure. The interagency review process will include representatives of 15 federal agencies and culminate in a report to the president articulating how the United States can more effectively combat domestic and international corruption, curb illicit finance, hold corrupt individuals accountable for their behavior, build international partnerships and strengthen foreign assistance.

    In depth

    The memorandum sends a strong message to the international community about President Biden’s commitment to combatting corruption.

    We anticipate that the specific designation of corruption as a national security issue may trigger, among other things, increased information sharing across a broad spectrum of federal agencies; more funding allocated to DOJ components responsible for domestic and international corruption prosecutions; the potential realignment of personnel and resources within key enforcement agencies; and an overall increase in anticorruption enforcement activity.

    While the precise means by which the administration will carry out the president’s mandate are still unclear, companies—especially those with an international footprint—should take heed of the clear message the administration is communicating to the private sector and position themselves appropriately by strengthening compliance programs. In this regard, companies should focus on the following areas of compliance.

    ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING COMPLIANCE

    Companies should consider strengthening their anti-money laundering compliance programs and infrastructure. The Biden administration clearly views enhanced anti-money laundering enforcement as a key component of its anticorruption platform. The memorandum addresses the use of “[a]nonymous shell companies, opaque financial systems, and professional service providers” in enabling the “movement and laundering of illicit wealth,” and specifically directs federal officials to develop a strategy to combat “illicit finance in the United States and international financial systems.”

    As part of its focus on anti-money laundering, the memorandum directs the government to “robustly” implement federal law that requires companies to disclose their beneficial ownership to federal authorities. This is a direct reference to the requirements set forth in the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA)—a component of the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020 (AMLA 2020), which was signed into law earlier this year as part of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA).

    The CTA requires certain US companies and foreign companies registered to do business in the United States to report detailed information about their beneficial owners. The new beneficial ownership reporting requirements, described in detail in our previous client alert, are designed to, among other things, “better enable critical national security, intelligence, and law enforcement efforts to counter money laundering, the financing of terrorism, and other illicit activity.” The US Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) is currently in the process of issuing implementing regulations for the beneficial ownership reporting requirements. In light of the memorandum’s directives, one can expect that FinCEN will propose regulations reflecting an expansive view of the CTA’s reporting requirements.

    The memorandum’s call for federal officials to potentially identify “the need for new reforms” is also notable. This directive suggests that the Biden administration may believe there is more legislative or regulatory work to be done to combat illicit finance, beyond the requirements set forth in the recently-enacted CTA. Among the new reforms contemplated by at least some on Capitol Hill are calls for the administration to promulgate a rule requiring investment advisors to comply with anti-money laundering rules. The Treasury Department is also proposing enhanced financial reporting requirements for domestic and foreign financial institutions, including a specific cryptocurrency reporting requirement, as part of its tax plan.

    Companies should take proactive steps now to prepare for increased anti-money laundering enforcement activities and enhanced regulatory requirements by reviewing and strengthening their existing compliance programs. Companies should also begin preparing for the implementation of the CTA’s beneficial ownership reporting requirements and evaluate what impact those requirements may have on their businesses. Investment advisors may want to proactively prepare for increased scrutiny of illicit finance and the prospect that new regulations could subject them to existing anti-money laundering rules.

    IMPROVED DATA ANALYTICS AND DATA RESOURCES FOR INVESTIGATIONS

    Companies should also consider improving their use of data analytics to strengthen compliance infrastructure.

    It is well-known that the DOJ and other federal law enforcement agencies are increasingly using data analytics to identify and prosecute criminal conduct. While the use of data analytics is not new, recent technological advancements and improved data sets enhance the government’s ability to identify suspicious and fraudulent conduct, and we anticipate that this enhanced capability will be integral to law enforcement efforts to fight global corruption. Notably, the first “strategy” identified in the White House fact sheet published in connection with the memorandum is a call to “modernize, increase, coordinate, resource, and otherwise improve the ability” of agencies to prevent and combat corruption and “where appropriate establish new structures and staffing, improve intelligence collection and analysis.” We anticipate that improved information/data sharing between federal agencies and enhanced data analytics are likely to lead to increased criminal and civil enforcement activity.

    Companies are rapidly accumulating data from their workforces, with over 300 billion emails sent and received per day in 2020 (not to mention increased use of chat and messaging applications in the workplace). As the memorandum seeks to address for the federal government, companies should incorporate data analytics into their own audit and compliance programs in an effort to proactively identify errors, monitor risk areas and address any potential misconduct. The use of data in compliance programs was a key component of the DOJ’s changes to their corporate compliance guidance issued in June 2020. The DOJ now expects companies to engage in continuous, data-driven risk assessments when designing a compliance program responsive to their operational risks in real-time. The DOJ noted it will consider in its assessment of a compliance program whether the company mines “operational data” to identify and anticipate risks and also whether compliance personnel have access to relevant data so as to conduct ongoing monitoring and review of the compliance program.

    MORE ROBUST FCPA ENFORCEMENT TOOLS

    The Biden administration’s memorandum suggests that additional resources may soon be available to tackle Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) investigations and violations with vigor. Making good on a campaign promise,the memorandum builds upon recent new FCPA tools, including those incorporated into the NDAA, and specifically seeks to “[b]olster the capacity of domestic and international institutions and multilateral bodies focused on establishing global anticorruption norms,” including “combating money laundering, illicit finance, and bribery, including, where possible, addressing the demand side of bribery.”

    The memorandum also seeks to support and strengthen the “capacity of civil society, media, and other oversight and accountability actors” in their investigating and uncovering corruption. These provisions will facilitate the investigation and prosecutions of those companies and individuals causing and aiding in the corruption of foreign governments or foreign government officials. Companies should be prepared for an increase in FCPA and anticorruption scrutiny by private actors and whistleblowers, in addition to the US government. We anticipate that the report to be issued following the administration’s interagency review will further clarify how this national security designation will affect FCPA enforcement.

    ENHANCED COOPERATION WITH INTERNATIONAL LAW ENFORCEMENT

    Although US agencies maintain cooperative relationships with their international law enforcement counterparts, during the global COVID-19 pandemic the strengthening of such relationships became a priority. The Biden administration seeks to build on these partnerships even further, calling for the improvement of foreign assistance programs and working with other international bodies, including the United Nations (UN), the Group of Seven (G7) and Financial Action Task Force (FATF). Improved collaboration to combat corruption will result in more efficient information sharing between international regulators. This is a trend that will continue, and companies should expect an increase in multi-jurisdiction investigations and resolutions, including with foreign authorities that the United States may not have previously coordinated with.

    KEY TAKEAWAYS

    • Anticorruption has been elevated from a DOJ enforcement priority to a whole-of-government national security policy priority.
    • Companies can expect a comprehensive and multifaceted approach by the Biden administration focused on both sides of foreign government corruption, bolstered by increased funding and manpower.
    • Improved coordination and communication between agencies, and agencies’ utilization of improved technological capabilities, will undoubtedly increase the federal government’s ability to detect illegal conduct in these priority areas.
    • After the administration’s interim review, we will see how these goals will specifically be advanced. Companies can take this time as an opportunity to assess whether their compliance programs can stand up to this shift in the enforcement landscape.
    Authors

    Julian L. André

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Paul M. Thompson

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Benton Curtis

    Partner

    Miami

    More insights

  • SCOTUS: User’s Authorized Access to Obtain Digital Information Even if Done with “Improper Motives” Does Not Violate the CFAA

    SCOTUS: User’s Authorized Access to Obtain Digital Information Even if Done with “Improper Motives” Does Not Violate the CFAA

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SCOTUS: User’s Authorized Access to Obtain Digital Information Even if Done with “Improper Motives” Does Not Violate the CFAA

    June 7, 2021

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In November 2020, the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) heard oral arguments from the United States and an individual police sergeant. The US Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit held that the sergeant violated the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act of 1986 (CFAA, Act), employing an interpretation of the Act that differs from the Second, Fourth and Ninth Circuits. On June 3, 2021, SCOTUS issued a 6-3 decision in Van Buren v. United Sates, Case, No. 19-783 (Supr. Ct. June 3, 2021) (Barrett, Justice)(Thomas, Justice, dissenting) reversing the sergeant’s conviction, based largely on the Court’s interpretation of the CFAA’s language.

    In depth

    BACKGROUND

    Nathan Van Buren was a police sergeant in Georgia. He accepted $5,000 from an acquaintance in exchange for running a license plate search using his patrol car computer. Van Buren was authorized to run such searches but knew from police department trainings that searches could not be conducted for personal use. Unaware the acquaintance was working with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Van Buren ran the search and was subsequently charged with a felony violation of the CFAA for computer fraud (as well as a bribery charge, not at issue in this case), tried by a jury and sentenced to 18 months in prison.

    While Van Buren clearly violated police department policies, it was less clear whether he also violated the CFAA, an act designed to combat computer hacking. Circuits have previously split on the issue of just how far the CFAA extends.

    Following Van Buren’s unsuccessful appeal to the 11th Circuit, SCOTUS accepted certiorari to address the breadth of the Act and determine whether authorized computer access for improper purposes constitutes­­­ a violation of the CFAA. The majority has now held that it does not.

    OPINION OF THE COURT

    Justice Amy Coney Barrett, writing for a majority made up of Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, focused on the language of the CFAA but also addressed the CFAA’s structure, case precedent and statutory history and policy arguments.

    First, the Court addressed the CFAA’s text. The CFAA makes it a crime to obtain information by “intentionally access[ing] a computer without authorization or exceed[ing] authorized access.” 18 U.S.C. § 1030(a)(2). The Act defines “exceeds authorized access” as “to access a computer with authorization and to use such access to obtain … information on the computer that the accesser is not entitled so to obtain . . .” § 1030(e)(6) (emphasis added). The parties did not dispute that Van Buren was authorized to access the license plate database or that he obtained information from it. They disputed whether he exceeded his authorized access in obtaining such information. Van Buren maintained that the “exceeds authorized access” clause of the CFAA applies only to those who obtain information to which their computer access does not extend and does not apply to a person who misuses computer access that they otherwise have.

    Also invoking the specific language of the CFAA, the government argued that the use of “so” in “…is not entitled so to obtain…” suggests the Act prohibits access to “information one was not allowed to obtain in the particular manner or circumstances in which he obtained it” (emphasis in original). Justice Barrett explained the government’s proposed construction by example: An employee may have access to information in Folder Y and properly access it in the morning to prepare for a meeting, yet improperly access that same Folder Y in the afternoon to prepare his resume to apply for a job with a competitor.

    On the other side, Van Buren argued that the use of “so” in “…is not entitled so to obtain…” refers to information that a person is not entitled to obtain via a computer, which is a computer that the person is otherwise authorized to use. Extending her metaphor, Justice Barrett summarized Van Buren’s argument with an example in which an employee may be authorized to access Folder Y on a computer but may be prohibited from accessing Folder X. Under this construction, the employee is always authorized to access Folder Y and never “entitled so to obtain” information in Folder X; the CFAA does not contemplate the purpose (even if improper) for which the employee accesses Folder Y so long as the employee has been granted access. The Court agreed with Van Buren’s interpretation of “so.”

    Second, the Court’s opinion addressed the structure of the CFAA, specifically, the impact and meaning created by the interplay between two clauses of subsection (a)(2), which specifies two distinct means of obtaining information unlawfully: Namely, “without authorization” and “exceeds authorized access.” The Court agreed with Van Buren’s construction of “exceeding authorized access,” meaning that the Act protects the computer itself from unauthorized users and also provides protection for specific files within the computer from users who are not authorized to access those specific files. The Court contrasted this with what it deemed to be the government’s inconsistent reading of subsection (a)(2), in that examining the particular manner or circumstances in which information is obtained thereby imposes “purpose-based limits” only when information is obtained by a means of exceeding authority but not when obtained through means of unauthorized access. Therefore, due to its stronger internal consistency, the majority again favored Van Buren’s construction and interpretation of the Act.

    Third, the Court quickly dispensed of the government’s precedent and statutory history arguments. The government raised Musacchio v. United States, a 2016 SCOTUS case that also addressed the CFAA but as to the standard of review for instructional error. Justice Barrett therefore explained that Musacchio did not address the issue at hand and that the Court is not bound by its dicta. The government also argued that an early draft of the CFAA had criminalized computer access for improper purposes, suggesting that Congress intended the CFAA to encompass authorized access for improper uses. The majority was not convinced and found that the government “[got] things precisely backward,” noting that Congress’ choice to amend its draft and specifically remove such improper purpose language cuts against the government’s interpretation of Congress’ intent.

    Finally, the Court addressed policy implications. Justice Barrett clarified that Van Buren’s construction was persuasive in terms of the CFAA’s text and structure, thereby making policy arguments superfluous. Nonetheless, the Court found that the government’s construction of the Act “would attach criminal penalties to a breathtaking amount of commonplace computer activity” (such as sending a personal email or reading the news from a work computer) and “inject arbitrariness into the assessment of criminal liability.”

    According to the majority, Van Buren’s actions, though problematic, were not the type of computer activity contemplated by the CFAA, so the Court reversed the judgment of the 11th Circuit and remanded for further proceedings.

    DISSENT

    Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito, issued a dissent that would have held Van Buren clearly “exceeded the scope of his authority,” within the plain meaning of the phrase. Interpreting the “not entitled so to obtain” language, the dissent focused on the word “entitled,” not “so,” and explained that the inclusion of “entitled” necessarily requires an analysis of surrounding circumstances. Under the dissent’s interpretation of the Act, Van Buren was not given authority to access the license plate database for personal use, so he was not “entitled” to access it for his acquaintance. Additionally, the dissenters argued that the majority’s construction ran afoul of principles of property law, which hold that “a person’s authority to use his access to property is circumstance dependent.”

    The dissent also agreed with the government that the congressional record that referenced purpose-based factors suggested Congress intended the CFAA to criminalize improper use. Finally, the dissent took issue with the majority’s lengthy policy-based concerns about the breadth of the government’s construction since much of US law “criminalizes common activity” and violating the CFAA typically results only in a misdemeanor.

    Kat Lynch, a summer associate in the Chicago office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors

    Sarah Bro

    Partner

    Orange County, Los Angeles

    More insights

  • EEOC Issues New Guidance for Mandatory and Voluntary COVID-19 Vaccine Programs

    EEOC Issues New Guidance for Mandatory and Voluntary COVID-19 Vaccine Programs

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    EEOC Issues New Guidance for Mandatory and Voluntary COVID-19 Vaccine Programs

    June 7, 2021

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Can an employer mandate or incentivize a COVID-19 vaccination? If so, what exceptions or exclusions apply? As COVID-19 vaccines have become increasingly available in the United States, and with new Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidance that permits fully vaccinated individuals to dispense with certain safety precautions, employers have been grappling with these questions.

    The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act each impose obligations on employers and bestow rights to employees that intersect with an employer’s desire to require or encourage a COVID-19 vaccination. Initial Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) guidance on COVID-19 vaccinations issued in December 2020 left many employer questions unresolved.

    In depth

    On May 28, 2021, the EEOC issued long-awaited additional guidance to address these complicated questions and confirm the following:

    • Federal law permits vaccine mandates. Federal equal employment opportunity laws do not prevent an employer from requiring a COVID-19 vaccination for all employees who physically enter the workplace, subject to the reasonable accommodation provisions of the ADA and Title VII.
    • Employers must watch for disparate impact. The EEOC cautions employers who have a mandatory vaccine requirement to consider how such a requirement may disparately impact certain employees based on characteristics protected under federal law, as some individuals or demographic groups may face greater barriers to receiving a COVID-19 vaccine than others.
    • Employers can ask employees about their vaccination status and require proof but such information is confidential. Employers may require written documentation and confirmation that an employee received the vaccine from a third party, but must ensure that such information is kept in an employee’s confidential medical file.
    • The EEOC provides examples of potential reasonable accommodations. Examples of a “reasonable accommodation” for employees who cannot comply with a vaccine mandate because of a disability; religious belief, practice or observance; or pregnancy include requiring the unvaccinated employee to:
      • Wear a face mask at work
      • Work at a social distance from co-workers or non-employees
      • Work a modified shift
      • Get periodic COVID-19 tests
      • Work via a provided telework arrangement
      • Accept a reassignment

    These are examples only and may not work or be reasonable in all cases. An interactive process is required to determine what accommodations are reasonable and sufficient to mitigate any direct threat to the workplace.

    • Pregnant employees may be entitled to accommodation. Employees who are not vaccinated because of pregnancy may be entitled to accommodations to keep working if an employer makes workplace modifications or exceptions for other individuals.
    • Employers can provide vaccination information. The EEOC encourages employers to provide information to employees about how they and their families can get vaccinated, including providing them with transportation to vaccination sites.
    • Manager training is encouraged. As a best practice, an employer introducing a COVID-19 vaccination policy and requiring documentation or other confirmation of vaccination should train managers on reasonable accommodation policies prior to rolling out the policy. All employees should also be notified that the employer will consider requests for reasonable accommodation based on disability on an individualized basis. Manager training may include reminders to direct employees with accommodation requests to the appropriate human resources professional.

    MANDATORY VACCINATION PROGRAMS

    The EEOC guidance also tackles several questions about mandatory vaccinations. The guidance confirms that mandatory vaccination programs are permissible as long as they comply with the requirements of the ADA and Title VII.

    Specifically, for employers who have mandatory vaccination policies, the guidance provides:

    • Employers may not require a vaccine for an employee whose disability prevents the employee from becoming vaccinated unless the employer is able to establish a “direct threat” (defined as a “significant risk of substantial harm” that cannot be eliminated or reduced by reasonable accommodation). The guidance emphasizes an employer’s obligation to make an individualized assessment of the employee’s ability to perform the essential functions of the job.
    • In analyzing whether an employee is a “direct threat,” the guidance directs an employer to consider:
      • The type of work environment, such as whether the employee works alone or with others, and whether the employee works inside or outside
      • The available ventilation
      • The frequency and duration of the direct interaction the employee typically has with other employees and/or non-employees
      • The number of partially or fully vaccinated individuals already in the workplace
      • Whether other employees are wearing masks or undergoing routine screening testing
    • The space available for social distancing.
    • If the “direct threat” assessment demonstrates that an employee with a disability who is not vaccinated would pose a direct threat to themselves or others, the employer must consider whether providing a reasonable accommodation, absent undue hardship, would reduce or eliminate that threat.
    • Employers must attempt to accommodate employees who cannot get a COVID-19 vaccine because of a disability. The guidance reiterates that employees need not use the specific term “reasonable accommodation” in their request in order to trigger an employer’s obligations under the ADA.

    ADMINISTERING THE VACCINE TO EMPLOYEES

    Employers who administer the COVID-19 vaccine to employees (directly or through a third-party contract), whether on a mandatory or voluntary basis, have been seeking guidance regarding what pre-vaccination questions are permissible under the ADA. Generally, the ADA restricts the circumstances in which employers may require medical examinations (procedures or tests that seek information about an individual’s physical or mental impairments or health) or make disability-related inquiries (questions that are likely to elicit information about an individual’s disability). The EEOC’s guidance distinguishes between a mandatory employer-administered vaccination program and a voluntary program.

    For employers who require employees to receive a COVID-19 vaccination from the employer or its agent, the EEOC confirms that the ADA’s restrictions apply to the screening questions that must be asked immediately prior to administering the vaccine if the vaccine is administered by the employer or its agent. Because the pre-vaccination screening questions are likely to elicit information about a disability, the ADA requires that they be “job related and consistent with business necessity” when an employer or its agent administers the COVID-19 vaccine. To meet this standard, an employer would need to have a reasonable belief, based on objective evidence, that an employee who does not answer the questions and therefore cannot be vaccinated will pose a direct threat to the employee’s own health or safety or to the health and safety of others in the workplace. Therefore, when an employer requires that employees be vaccinated by the employer or its agent, the employer should be aware that an employee may challenge the mandatory pre-vaccination inquiries, and that the employer would have to justify them under the ADA.

    For employers who administer a COVID-19 vaccine on a voluntary basis, the EEOC clarifies that an employer may ask disability-related screening questions before administering the COVID-19 vaccine without needing to satisfy the “job-related and consistent with business necessity” standard.

    VOLUNTARY COVID-19 VACCINATIONS, THE ADA AND THE GINA

    The EEOC provides additional guidance for employers who offer voluntary vaccinations in compliance with the ADA and the GINA. The guidance confirms:

    • An employer may offer an incentive to employees for providing information about their vaccination received by a third-party provider.
    • Under the ADA, an employer may offer an incentive to employees for voluntarily receiving a
      vaccination administered by the employer or its agent as long as the incentive is voluntary and is not so substantial as to be coercive.
    • Under the GINA, an employer may offer an incentive to employees for providing
      documentation or other confirmation from a third party not acting on the employer’s behalf, such as a pharmacy or health department, that employees or their family members have been vaccinated. The EEOC also confirms that under the GINA, an employer may ask employees to show documentation or other confirmation that the employee or a family member has been vaccinated.
    • Under the GINA, an employer may offer an incentive to employees in exchange for an
      employee receiving a vaccination administered by the employer or its agent, but may not offer any incentives to an employee in exchange for a family member’s receipt of a vaccination from an employer or its agent.
    • Under the GINA, an employer may offer vaccinations to an employee’s family members if the
      employer takes certain steps to comply with the GINA. Specifically, employers:

      • Must not require employees to have their family members get vaccinated
      • Must not penalize employees if their family members decide not to get vaccinated
      • Must ensure that all medical information obtained from family members during the screening process is only used for the purpose of providing the vaccination; is kept confidential; and is not provided to any managers, supervisors or others who make employment decisions for the employees
      • Must obtain prior, knowing, voluntary and written authorization from the family member before the family member is asked any questions about her
        medical conditions.

    The EEOC appears to be working on additional guidance. Right before the EEOC’s guidance was issued, the CDC issued new guidance for unvaccinated individuals in the workplace. The EEOC is currently considering the CDC’s guidance, and we expect additional guidance in the near future.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Cal/OSHA Makes First Revision to the Temporary COVID-19 Prevention Requirements

    Cal/OSHA Makes First Revision to the Temporary COVID-19 Prevention Requirements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Cal/OSHA Makes First Revision to the Temporary COVID-19 Prevention Requirements

    June 4, 2021

    Read time: 13 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    UPDATE:

    The Cal/OSHA Board convened a special meeting on June 9, 2021, at which they voted 7-0 to withdraw the revised Emergency Temporary Standards (ETS); these standards were scheduled to go into effect on June 15, 2021. The Board will reconvene on June 17, 2021, to vote on a new proposal, which is expected to go into effect on June 28, 2021.

    The new standard is expected to align with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) guidance and new California Department of Public Health (CDPH) Guidance for the Use of Face Coverings that was issued on June 9, 2021, effective June 15, 2021. (Note: the CDPH guidance does not create standards for employers; that role is still with Cal/OSHA.) Cal/OSHA is now set to vote on adopting a revised ETS proposal at its June 17, 2021, meeting, with the revised proposal expected to be released in the next few days. The effect of the withdrawal of the June 3, 2021, ETS is that employers will need to continue to follow the rules under the original November 2020 ETS until the new proposal goes into effect on the expected June 28, 2021, date. Relatedly, the Department of Labor’s (DOL) Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) on June 10, 2021, issued its own healthcare Emergency Temporary Standard that sets workplace safety rules for employers in the healthcare sectors. 

    All California employers should continue to closely follow these ever-changing developments as they navigate their return-to-work plans and protocols. Employers should consult with counsel prior to finalizing their plans.

    On May 28, 2021, California’s Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) published a revised proposed COVID-19 Emergency Temporary Standards (ETS). The proposed regulations contain notable changes from the original ETS adopted on November 19, 2020, which we covered here.

    On June 3, 2021, the Cal/OSHA board voted 4-3 against the proposed ETS. Then, moments later, the seven-person board voted unanimously to adopt the revised regulations. The board now plans to put together a three-person subcommittee to further refine the standard. The regulations are expected to go into effect on June 15, 2021, and will apply to most employers in California. Therefore, employers will want to thoroughly review these rules and apply them to their workplaces.

    Many elements of the existing ETS remain in place:

    • Employees who are fully vaccinated are still required to wear face coverings indoors in the company of those who are not fully vaccinated.
    • Employers are still required to have a written COVID-19 prevention program. They will need to continue to identify and evaluate COVID-19 hazards; implement a process for screening employees; conduct workplace-specific identification of areas, activities, processes that can potentially expose employees to COVID-19 hazards; and implement effective policies for correcting unsafe or unhealthy conditions, work practices, policies and procedures.
    • Employers still need to provide training and instruction to employees, although now employers will need to include information on accessing COVID-19 testing and vaccination.

    There are also notable changes from the current requirements:

    • Employers will not have to enforce physical distancing and face covering requirements as long as all persons in the room are fully vaccinated.
    • Employers may provide those employees who are not fully vaccinated with respirators for voluntary use so that they do not have to enforce six-feet physical distancing.
    • The existing notice requirement for employers to notify employees of a close contact with a COVID-19 case are now supplemented to include that employers must inform employees when they should have known of a COVID-19 case (previous requirement was only when the employer knew of a close contact).
    • Starting July 31, 2021, employers will need to provide respirators for voluntary use to all employees who are not fully vaccinated.
    • Employers must make COVID-19 testing available at no cost to unvaccinated employees displaying COVID-19 symptoms during the employee’s paid time. Currently, employers are required to offer testing to employees when they have a potential COVID-19 workplace-related exposure.

    Of importance, Cal/OSHA is still not fully discarding the requirements for physical distancing and face coverings for fully vaccinated individuals to align with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and California state guidance. If all persons in a room are not fully vaccinated, employees will still need to wear face coverings.

    The proposed revisions will now be submitted to the Office of Administrative Law (OAL). After the proposed ETS is received, the OAL will have 10 calendar days for review before these regulations become effective this month. The revised standards are expected to go into effect no later than June 15 if approved by the OAL.

    Below, we address notable requirements from the now-adopted ETS.

    In depth

    FACE COVERINGS

    Face covering requirements still remain in place. Employers will have to provide and ensure that employees wear face coverings indoors, unless all persons in a room are fully vaccinated and do not have COVID-19 symptoms. Employers must provide face coverings and ensure that they are worn by employees when indoors, when outdoors and less than six feet away from another person, and where required by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) and local health orders.

    The new ETS also provides for the additional following exceptions to the face covering requirements:

    • When an employee is alone in a room, or when all persons in the room are fully vaccinated and do not have symptoms;
    • While eating or drinking at the workplace, provided that employees are at least six feet apart and outside air has been maximized to the extent possible (if indoors);
    • Employees wearing respirators required by the employer;
    • Employees who cannot wear face coverings due to a medical condition or mental health condition or disability, or who are hearing-impaired or communicating with a hearing-impaired person;
    • During the performance of specific tasks which cannot be performed with a face covering, but only for the duration of that task; and
    • Employees who are fully vaccinated, when they are outdoors and do not have symptoms.

    PHYSICAL DISTANCING

    Physical distancing requirements will stay in place until July 31, 2021, regardless of an employee’s vaccination status. Until July 31, 2021, employers must comply with either of the two options identified below for all employees who work indoors or at an outdoor mega event:

    • All employees must be separated from other persons by at least six feet, except for (1) employees wearing respirators required by the employer and used in compliance with section 5144; (2) where an employer can show that six feet of separation is not feasible; and (3) momentary exposure while persons are in movement.
    • All employees who are not fully vaccinated must be provided respirators for voluntary use in compliance with section 5144(c)(2).

    In effect, employers can eliminate physical distancing and partitions/barriers for employees working indoors and at outdoor mega events if they provide respirators to unvaccinated employees for their voluntary use. After July 31, however, physical distancing and barriers will no longer be required (except during an outbreak), but employers will be required to provide all unvaccinated employees with respirators for voluntary use (see below).

    CONTROLS, PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT AND TESTING

    The new ETS also provides for rules about engineering controls, administrative controls and personal protective equipment:

    • Until July 31, 2021, for all employees working indoors or outdoors at a mega event, if the employer is not providing employees who are not fully vaccinated with respirators for voluntary use, at their work stations where the employee is assigned to work for an extended period (such as cash registers, desks and production line stations) and where physical distancing cannot be maintained at all times, the employer must install a cleanable solid partition that reduces the transmission between the employee and other persons. While requirements for partitions have been in place, this requirement will go away on July 31, 2021.
    • Beginning July 31, 2021, employers must provide respirators for voluntary use to all employees who are working indoors or at an outdoor mega event who are not fully vaccinated. This is a new requirement which employers are required to abide by.

    Employers must continue to implement cleaning and disinfection protocols as specified and must evaluate their handwashing facilities to determine if they need more. Employers must also encourage and allow time for handwashing and provide employees with effective hand sanitizers. As a new requirement, employers must also make COVID-19 testing available at no cost to employees with COVID-19 symptoms who are not fully vaccinated, during the employee’s paid time. Employers are not required to provide testing if the employee who had a close contact was fully vaccinated or was previously infected within the prior 90 days.

    IDENTIFYING AND EVALUATING COVID-19 HAZARDS

    Employers are still required to implement a process for screening employees for and responding to employees with COVID-19 symptoms (such as by asking employees to evaluate their symptoms before reporting to work or through workplace screenings). Employers must also develop COVID-19 policies and procedures to respond to individuals at the workplace who are a COVID-19 case. In addition, employers are required to conduct workplace-specific identification of all interactions, areas, activities, processes, equipment, and materials that could potentially expose employees to COVID-19 hazards; employers must also treat all persons as potentially infectious (regardless of their symptoms or negative results).

    Employers with indoor worksites are also required to maximize ventilation with outdoor air and evaluate whether the use of certain filtration or air cleaning systems would reduce the risk of COVID-19 transmission.

    At the same time, employers are required to (1) review applicable orders and guidance from the state and local health departments about COVID-19 hazards and information specific to the employer’s industry, location and operations; (2) evaluate whether their existing COVID-19 prevention controls require an update; and (3) conduct periodic inspections to identify unhealthy conditions, workplace practices and workplace procedures related to COVID-19, and ensure compliance with the COVID-19 policies.

    INVESTIGATING AND RESPONDING TO COVID-19 CASES IN THE WORKPLACE

    Employers are still required to have a procedure in place for investigating COVID-19 cases. Employers must also have procedures for gathering information from employees about COVID-19 cases and close contacts, test results, the onset of symptoms and identifying and recording COVID-19 cases.

    When there is a COVID-19 case in the workplace, employers are required to:

    • Determine the day and time the COVID-19 case was last present, and to the extent feasible, the date of the COVID-19 test/diagnosis, and the date the COVID-19 case first had symptoms (if any).
    • Determine who had a close contact and follow exclusion requirements for employees after a close contact (see below).
    • Give written notice to employees that people at the workplace may have been exposed to COVID-19 within one business day of the time the employer knew or should have known of the COVID-19 case (without revealing personal information). Under the previous ETS, employers were only required to give notice if they knew of a COVID-19 case. The notice must include certain specific information.
    • Provide notice as required by Labor Code 6409.6(a)(2) and (c) to the authorized representative of any employee at the worksite during the high risk exposure within one business day of the time the employer knew or should have known of the COVID-19 case.
    • Make COVID-19 testing available at no cost, during paid time, to all employees who had a close contact in the workplace and provide them information on benefits. However, this requirement does not apply to the following:
      • Those who were fully vaccinated before the close contact and who do not have COVID-19 symptoms, and
      • Those with COVID-19 cases who returned to work and are free from symptoms for 90 days after the initial onset of symptoms (or with cases for those who never developed symptoms for 90 days after the first positive test).
    • Keep records confidential. For personal identifying information of COVID-19 cases or persons with symptoms, and any other records required by the draft rule, the records must be kept confidential unless disclosure is required by law. The ETS defines the term “fully –vaccinated” to mean that the employer has documentation establishing that the person received their full dose of a vaccine at least 14 days prior. The ETS does not however state what kind of documentation is required.

    EXCLUDING COVID-19 CASES AND EMPLOYEES WITH CLOSE CONTACTS

    Cal/OSHA has also updated the ETS to reflect that fully-vaccinated employees and those individuals who have had COVID-19 in the past 90 days do not need to be excluded from the workplace if they are asymptomatic.

    Employers must exclude (1) COVID-19 cases from the workplace until the return-to-work criteria is met (see below), and (2) those who had a close contact until they meet the return-to-work criteria (see below). The exceptions to the exclusion rule are those employees who were fully vaccinated before the close contact and who do not develop symptoms, and those who have recovered from COVID-19 in the last 90 days.

    Employees who are excluded must continue to maintain their wages, earnings, seniority and all other employee rights and benefits, as if they had not been removed. This does not, however, apply when the close contact is not work-related, or where the employee receives disability payments, was covered by worker’s compensation or received temporary disability.

    Return-to-Work Criteria

    The return-to-work is broken down by employees with COVID-19 who are symptomatic and asymptomatic:

    • Symptomatic COVID-19 cases: These employees must not return to work until (1) 24 hours pass since a fever of 100.4 degrees or higher is resolved without the use of fever reducing medication; (2) COVID-19 symptoms have improved; and (3) at least 10 days have passed since the first COVID-19 symptoms appeared.
    • Asymptomatic COVID-19 cases: These employees must not return to work until at least 10 days pass since the date of the first COVID-19 test.

    After the COVID-19 case meets the criteria above, a negative COVID-19 test is not required for an employee to return to work.

    Those employees who have a close contact can return to work under the following conditions:

    • Employees with a close contact who do not develop symptoms can return to work when 10 days have passed since the last known close contact.
    • Those who had a close contact and developed any COVID-19 symptoms cannot return to work until the requirements identified above for those with symptoms are met, unless:
      • The person tested negative for COVID-19 using a PCR test with the testing done after the onset of symptoms;
      • At least 10 days have passed since the last known close contact; or
      • The person has been symptom-free for at least 24 hours, without using fever-reducing medication.
    • If there are staffing shortages, when there aren’t enough staff to provide patient care, essential critical infrastructure workers in certain specified categories can return after Day 7 from the date of last exposure (if they receive a negative test after Day 5).

    OTHER REQUIREMENTS

    The new ETS still requires employers to maintain a written COVID-19 prevention program; to have a system in place for communicating with employees about COVID-19 exposure, symptoms and hazards, etc.; and to continue to provide training and instruction, although employers now need to include information about accessing testing and vaccination and proper use of respirators as part of the training program. Likewise, employers are still required to report information about COVID-19 cases and outbreaks and maintain records about steps taken to implement their COVID-19 prevention program.

    We are here to help. Our McDermott Will & Emery employment team of lawyers are tracking the latest state and local developments and are here to assist you with practical and protective guidance for navigating these complex workplace and business issues.

    Authors

    Pankit J. Doshi

    Partner

    San Francisco, Silicon Valley

    More insights

  • How to Apply the IRS’s COBRA Premium Subsidy Guidance

    How to Apply the IRS’s COBRA Premium Subsidy Guidance

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    How to Apply the IRS’s COBRA Premium Subsidy Guidance

    June 3, 2021

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On May 18, 2021, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued much-anticipated Notice 2021-31 (the Notice) regarding the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) premium subsidy provisions of the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (ARPA). Under ARPA, a 100% COBRA premium subsidy and additional COBRA enrollment rights are available to certain assistance eligible individuals (AEIs) during the period beginning on April 1, 2021, and ending on September 30, 2021. The US Department of Labor (DOL) has previously issued model notices and a set of FAQs regarding the COBRA premium subsidy. The IRS has now issued additional FAQs in the Notice. Below is a summary of the provisions of the Notice most relevant to employers and plan sponsors.

    In depth

    WHO IS ELIGIBLE?

    An AEI is defined as anyone who is eligible for COBRA from April 1, 2021 to September 30, 2021, due to a reduction in hours or involuntary termination (explained below). The subsidy is available until an AEI is eligible for other group health plan coverage—including Medicare. An individual may become an AEI more than once (e.g., due to successive losses of coverage under the individual’s or a spouse’s plan). A reduction of hours or involuntary termination of employment that follows an earlier qualifying event (such as a divorce) does not make a qualified beneficiary from the first qualifying event an AEI.

    WHAT CONSTITUTES A REDUCTION IN HOURS OR INVOLUNTARY TERMINATION?

    A furlough is considered a reduction of hours, so long as the employer and employee intend to maintain the employment relationship; this is true regardless of whether the employer initiated the furlough or the individual participated in a “window” arrangement. (A window program could include, for example, a voluntary severance program pursuant to which an employee with an impending termination could make an election to terminate employment within a specified period of time.) A work stoppage due to a strike or lockout is also considered a reduction of hours, so long as the intent is to continue the employment relationship.

    TIP: Check with employee benefits counsel as to what constitutes a “window program.” Not every voluntary window arrangement will qualify.

    Under the ARPA and the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, a severance from employment caused by the exercise of unilateral authority of the employer where the employee was willing and able to continue working constitutes an involuntary termination. In addition, if an employee terminates employment for good reason—due to “employer action that results in a material negative change in the employment relationship” or constructive discharge—then that is also an involuntary termination. Termination due to retirement, concerns about workplace safety due to a health condition, lack of childcare or death generally do not constitute an involuntary termination. Termination for cause can be involuntary, unless for gross misconduct.* A decision by an employer not to renew an employee’s contract or an employee’s decision to participate in a “window program” under a severance offer is still involuntary.

    *TIP: Be careful about using the “gross misconduct” exception as a reason to avoid offering COBRA. This exception to COBRA eligibility has been much-litigated. The standard for gross misconduct is inconsistent across states and represents a high bar for employers.

    WHICH COVERAGE MUST BE OFFERED?

    COBRA premium assistance is available for COBRA continuation of any group health plan except a health Flexible Spending Account (FSA) (under §106(c) offered under a 125 cafeteria plan) or a Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement (QSEHRA) (under §9831(d)). Coverage under a vision-only or dental-only plan or a health reimbursement account (HRA) (unless integrated with Medicare) is included under the subsidy. Retiree health coverage is also eligible coverage as long as it is offered under the same group health plan as the coverage made available to similarly situated active employees.

    A plan sponsor can allow AEIs to enroll in coverage different than the coverage the individual was enrolled in at the time of the qualifying event, but the different coverage cannot exceed the premium of the coverage of the AEI at the time of the qualifying event. The DOL clarified that the COBRA premium assistance cannot be used as a credit toward coverage with a greater premium amount, either. Coverage with a premium greater than the premium of the coverage the individual was enrolled in at the time of the qualifying event is not eligible. If an employer no longer offers the health plan that previously covered the AEI, then the individual must be offered the opportunity to elect the plan that a similarly situated active employee would have been offered.

    WHEN DOES THE AEI’S COBRA PREMIUM ASSISTANCE PERIOD BEGIN?

    An AEI is first entitled to receive COBRA premium assistance as of the first applicable period of coverage beginning on or after April 1, 2021. COBRA premium assistance is available for periods of coverage from April 1, 2021, through September 30, 2021, if the election for COBRA continuation coverage is made after September 30, 2021, but during the applicable 60-day election period. In that case, the AEI is entitled to COBRA premium assistance through the earlier of the last period of coverage beginning on or after September 30, 2021, or the date that COBRA continuation coverage expires.

    WHEN DOES THE SUBSIDY END?

    AEIs may receive COBRA premium assistance until the earliest of (1) the first date the AEI becomes eligible for other group health plan coverage (with limited exceptions) or Medicare coverage; (2) the date the AEI ceases to be eligible for COBRA continuation coverage or (3) the end of the last period of coverage beginning on or before September 30, 2021 (even if such period extends past September 30, 2021).

    The death of an AEI does not end the eligibility for COBRA premium assistance for the deceased AEI’s qualified beneficiary spouse and dependent children. Once subsidized COBRA continuation coverage ends with the last period of coverage beginning on or before September 30, 2021, coverage for an individual who was an AEI automatically continues with unsubsidized COBRA; the payment for the first subsequent period of coverage should be timely paid according to the terms of the plan (taking into account any applicable COVID-19 relief extensions).

    WHEN DO AEIS HAVE TO ELECT COBRA?

    The Notice clarifies that the following individuals are entitled to an extended election period to elect COBRA continuation coverage:

    • A potential AEI if the qualifying event occurred before April 1, 2021, and the individual has not yet elected COBRA continuation coverage (including for an individual who has an open COBRA election period as of April 1, 2021). Such individuals may elect retroactive COBRA continuation coverage under the original COBRA election period available prior to the ARPA extended election period; however, COBRA premium assistance does not apply to periods of coverage prior to the first period of coverage beginning on or after April 1, 2021.
    • A qualified beneficiary (spouse or dependent child) who did not elect COBRA continuation coverage by April 1, 2021, but who would have been an AEI if the election were in effect, even if the employee previously elected self-only COBRA continuation coverage.
    • In addition, a qualified beneficiary whose qualifying event was a reduction in hours or an involuntary termination must be offered the extended election period with respect to any health coverage the qualified beneficiary was enrolled in prior to the qualifying event and for which the individual does not have a COBRA election in effect on April 1, 2021, even if the qualified beneficiary previously elected COBRA continuation coverage with respect to other coverage in which the qualified beneficiary was previously enrolled.

    HOW DOES ALL THIS WORK WITH THE OUTBREAK PERIOD EXTENSIONS?

    The notice of an extended election period must have been furnished by May 31, 2021. An individual who receives the notice must elect COBRA continuation coverage no later than 60 days after the notice is provided in order to receive COBRA premium assistance starting on or after April 1, 2021. Although the outbreak period extensions do not apply to the COBRA premium subsidy’s notice or election deadlines, the extensions apply to premium payments for any retroactive periods of coverage prior to the subsidy period that an AEI elects. However, an AEI who elects the COBRA subsidy but declines to elect retroactive COBRA coverage may not elect retroactive coverage after the end of the 60-day extended election period.

    HOW DO WE GET REIMBURSED?

    In a divergence from the Obama administration’s American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) COBRA subsidy, the amount of the credit is the premium that would have been charged to an AEI (including a possible 2% administrative cost), but does not include the amount of any subsidy the employer would have otherwise provided.*

    However, if a plan that previously charged less than the maximum premium allowed under COBRA increases the premiums for similarly situated covered employees and qualified beneficiaries, the subsidy applies to the increased premium amount. For individual HRA coverage, the credit is limited to 102% of the amount actually reimbursed to the AEI. Details are provided on who is eligible to claim the credit (in most cases, the employer); when it is available (generally, at the beginning of a coverage period for which an AEI does not pay a premium) and how to claim it. Employers must maintain records substantiating eligibility for the credit; however, they generally need not refund credits received for AEIs who failed to report their ineligibility for the subsidy.

    *TIP: Employers are allowed to revise the subsidy they have offered to employees in order to get reimbursed for the entire ARPA subsidy amount; however, if the employer has contractually agreed to subsidize COBRA, such a change may require an amendment to the severance plan or other agreements. Such amendments may result in procuring new waivers.

    HOW DO WE FILE FOR THE CREDITS?

    In the case of a group health plan (other than a multiemployer plan) that is either subject to federal COBRA or is self-funded, the common law employer maintaining the plan is entitled to the premium assistance credit. In the case of a multiemployer plan, the plan is also entitled to the premium assistance credit. In the case of a fully insured group health plan, the insurer is entitled to the premium assistance credit if the insurer is collecting the premiums. Employers or other entities entitled to the credit can claim the credit by reporting the credit on Form 941, reducing its deposits of federal employment taxes by the anticipated credit and/or requesting an advance of the anticipated credit. The Notice also provides detailed guidance for employers that use third party payers to report and pay employment taxes to the IRS.

    Employers and plan sponsors should review their COBRA procedures, both internally and with their COBRA administrators, to ensure they are complying with the current guidance regarding COBRA premium subsidies. Because the IRS notes that it may release future guidance on additional issues related to the COBRA premium subsidy, employers and plan sponsors should stay tuned to any updates or changes to the guidance. For information about how to comply with the COBRA premium subsidy guidance, contact one of the authors or another McDermott Employee Benefits lawyer.

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sarah G. Raaii

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • DOJ and HHS-OIG Ramp Up COVID-Related Healthcare Fraud Enforcement Activity

    DOJ and HHS-OIG Ramp Up COVID-Related Healthcare Fraud Enforcement Activity

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOJ and HHS-OIG Ramp Up COVID-Related Healthcare Fraud Enforcement Activity

    June 1, 2021

    Read time: 17 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Since the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) has prioritized identifying and prosecuting COVID-related fraudulent conduct, including healthcare fraud. Most of the DOJ’s enforcement activity to date has focused on criminal prosecutions relating to the Paycheck Protection Program, Economic Injury Disaster Loans and unemployment insurance benefit claims. There has been relatively limited enforcement activity in specific to the healthcare arena—until now. A series of new healthcare fraud criminal indictments and the creation of the COVID-19 Fraud Enforcement Task Force demonstrate that healthcare fraud enforcement activity is ramping up and will continue to increase over the course of the next year. Providers can take a number of proactive steps now to prepare for and mitigate risks associated with the increased COVID-related enforcement activity.

    In depth

    2021 NATIONAL COVID-19 HEALTHCARE FRAUD TAKEDOWN

    On May 26, 2021, the DOJ and US Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General (HHS-OIG) announced new criminal healthcare fraud charges against 14 defendants in nine different cases as part of a coordinated nationwide “takedown.” The 14 defendants are, collectively, alleged to have caused over $143 million in false Medicare and Medicaid billings.

    In announcing these new charges, US Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco reaffirmed the DOJ’s commitment to investigating healthcare fraud schemes relating to the COVID-19 pandemic, stating:

    • These medical professionals, corporate executives, and others allegedly took advantage of the COVID-19 pandemic to line their own pockets instead of providing needed health care services during this unprecedented time in our country. We are committed to protecting the American people and the critical health care benefits programs created to assist them during this national emergency, and we are determined to hold those who exploit such programs accountable to the fullest extent of the law.

    The DOJ also announced that the Center for Program Integrity at the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS/CPI) has separately taken “adverse administrative actions against over 50 medical providers for their involvement in health care fraud schemes relating to COVID-19 or abuse of CMS programs that were designed to encourage access to medical care during the pandemic.”

    These new criminal charges and the 50 CMS/CPI administrative actions constitute a significant escalation in COVID-related healthcare enforcement activity. Crucially, the charges also provide further insight into the DOJ’s current healthcare fraud priorities. The newly announced charges demonstrate that the DOJ remains focused on the following areas relating to the pandemic:

    • Provider Relief Fund: The takedown included the third criminal case in the country involving the Provider Relief Fund, which was created as part of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act to provide direct payments to “eligible health care providers for health care-related expenses [and] lost revenues that are attributable to coronavirus.” The DOJ alleges that the owner of a home health agency misappropriated Provider Relief Fund monies and used them for his own benefit. Although all three criminal cases filed to date have involved similar misappropriation allegations, the DOJ has indicated that it also will pursue civil Provider Relief Fund cases under the False Claims Act (FCA), likely under the FCA’s reverse false claims provision.
    • Telehealth Waivers: As part of the response to the COVID-19 pandemic, US Secretary of Health and Human Services temporarily waived statutory and regulatory requirements related to telehealth to allow Medicare beneficiaries to obtain expanded telehealth services. The takedown included the first cases in the country involving the fraudulent use of temporary telehealth waivers to bill for services that were either medically unnecessary or never provided. Although telehealth was already a DOJ priority area, the DOJ’s scrutiny of telehealth is expected to further increase in the wake of the significant expansion in telehealth services during the pandemic associated with the waivers.
    • Bundling COVID-19 Tests: Many of the newly-filed criminal cases involve allegations that defendants bundled COVID-19 testing claims with Medicare claims for other, more expensive, laboratory tests, such as genetic testing, allergy testing and respiratory pathogen panel tests, that were not medically necessary and often not even provided. HHS-OIG and the DOJ prioritized such bundling schemes at the outset of the pandemic and will likely continue to scrutinize healthcare providers that billed Medicare for COVID-19 testing and other tests or services.
    • COVID-19 Emergency Override Billings: The DOJ also brought additional charges in a case alleging that pharmacy owners used COVID-19 “emergency override” billing codes to circumvent preauthorization requirements and bill Medicare for expensive cancer medication that was never purchased, prescribed or dispensed to patients. Providers who relied significantly upon such emergency override billing codes during the pandemic can likely expect additional scrutiny from the DOJ and HHS-OIG going forward.

    One can also expect a significant increase in civil healthcare fraud actions under the FCA relating to COVID-19. While criminal prosecutions will continue to target the most egregious conduct, civil and administrative actions will be used to pursue cases that turn on lower mens rea requirements or involve more complex regulatory issues. These civil actions will include qui tam actions filed by whistleblowers, as well as FCA cases initiated directly by the DOJ. Such civil enforcement activity typically trails criminal prosecutions and will inevitably impact a much broader range of healthcare providers.

    These healthcare fraud prosecutions are a sign of things to come. Similar healthcare fraud prosecutions, investigations and other enforcement activity will increase in scope and frequency over the course of the next year, particularly as the economy and health systems recover from the pandemic.

    COVID-19 FRAUD ENFORCEMENT TASK FORCE AND INTER-GOVERNMENTAL COLLABORATION

    On May 17, 2021, the DOJ also announced the formation of the COVID-19 Fraud Enforcement Task Force (Task Force). In announcing the Task Force, US Attorney General Merrick B. Garland reiterated that the DOJ “will use every available tool—including criminal, civil, and administrative actions—to combat and prevent COVID-19 related fraud.” The Task Force, which includes the DOJ, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and HHS-OIG, is designed to “augment and incorporate” the existing “whole-of-government” COVID-19 enforcement efforts that are already underway. The creation of the Task Force will ensure that the DOJ, HHS-OIG and other federal agencies remain focused on and have the resources necessary to pursue further criminal and civil COVID-related enforcement actions.

    Additionally, HHS-OIG’s Principal Deputy Inspector General Christi Grimm has made clear that audits, evaluations and investigations examining COVID-19 relief will remain an HHS-OIG priority for several years to come. As it focuses on COVID-related fraud, HHS-OIG is coordinating with the Pandemic Response Accountability Committee (PRAC) and collaborating with other law enforcement and oversight agencies, “using every tool in [its] arsenal, pursuing criminal or civil charges, seeking exclusion or referring for suspension and debarment from programs to recover ill-gotten gains.” Presently, HHS-OIG has received more than 2,400 COVID-related fraud complaints to its hotline and has more than 50 COVID-related audits/evaluations underway, including the Provider Relief Fund audits on eligibility, supporting documentation and overpayments that were added to the HHS-OIG work plan on May 17, 2021.

    PRACTICE POINTERS TO MITIGATE COVID-RELATED FRAUD RISK

    There are a number of proactive steps healthcare providers can take now to prepare for potential government enforcement activity:

    1. Incorporate Data Analysis into Audit and Compliance Programs
      • The DOJ and HHS-OIG are using increasingly “sophisticated data analytics” to identify trends and outliers and pursue healthcare fraud cases. The PRAC also recently formed a fraud task force that will use data analytics to support law enforcement investigations. Providers should incorporate data analytics into their own audit and compliance programs in an effort to proactively identify errors, monitor risk areas and address any potential misconduct.
    2. Monitor Provider Relief Fund Guidance Updates and Evaluate Corresponding Compliance Infrastructure, Audit Readiness and Supporting Documentation
      • The Health Resources & Services Administration (HRSA) administers the Provider Relief Fund through the issuance of Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) and other sub-regulatory guidance. The FAQs are the primary source of HRSA’s guidance to recipients on compliance with the Provider Relief Fund terms and conditions and are updated periodically. Recipients can reduce their enforcement risk by monitoring revisions to the FAQs and reporting guidance, assessing whether business changes may be appropriate and how to further document their good faith compliance efforts. While HRSA historically has not notified recipients of these updates, an easy way to stay ahead of the curve is to subscribe for free updates from McDermott+ Consulting and to updates from us.
      • Providers should work with legal and financial advisors to evaluate how guidance changes may impact prior data submissions and their interpretations or other assumptions regarding eligibility and use of funds. In preparation for upcoming reports and audits, providers also should reevaluate the controls implemented over relief program funds and the scope of their documentation supporting permissible uses, calculations and eligibility. Consider bolstering documentation related to higher-risk areas (e.g., transactions and complex organizational structures) and evaluate whether disclosures may be warranted to demonstrate compliance and transparency and mitigate FCA risk.
    3. Assess Telehealth System for Risks
      • Improper marketing strategies (e.g., cold calls), illegitimate physician-patient relationships and improper bundling of services have all prompted telehealth enforcement. Regardless of the role you play in any telehealth system, look at the design of the system and conduct of other participants with the goal of reducing the risk of entanglement with unlawful actors. Providers should also review their existing telehealth relationships, contracts and marketing materials to ensure total transparency and compliance (both historic and prospective) with applicable state and federal anti-kickback statutes.
    4. Monitor Regulatory Changes on Telehealth
    5. Proactively Review Coding and Billing Practices
      • Providers should immediately review and revisit their coding and billing practices to determine whether their practices involved bundling COVID-19 testing claims with other claims or the use of emergency override billing codes. To the extent providers have engaged in such practices, they should confirm the propriety of their billing and coding practices with in-house or external counsel. There is a strong likelihood that the DOJ will be reviewing the claims data for any providers with statistically significant use of these billing and coding practices, particularly when the providers are located in geographical areas where the DOJ’s Healthcare Fraud Strike Force and HHS-OIG’s Medicare Fraud Strike Force operate.
    Authors

    Julian L. André

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Benton Curtis

    Partner

    Miami

    More insights

  • Energy Future Holdings: Third Circuit Authorizes Potential Administrative Claim for Losing Stalking Horse Bidder

    Energy Future Holdings: Third Circuit Authorizes Potential Administrative Claim for Losing Stalking Horse Bidder

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Energy Future Holdings: Third Circuit Authorizes Potential Administrative Claim for Losing Stalking Horse Bidder

    June 1, 2021

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Third Circuit recently held, in a case from the Energy Future Holdings bankruptcy, that a losing stalking horse bidder can provide sufficient value to the debtor’s estate to receive an administrative claim for a break-up fee and expenses. In re Energy Future Holdings Corp., 990 F.3d 728, 748 (3rd Cir. 2021). This represents an expansive view of potential administrative claims related to those costs, providing bidders significant potential protections for their bids. The Third Circuit ruling ensures the enforcement of breakup fees and enables debtors to rely on their ability to attract stalking horse bids. The Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware will decide on remand whether the bidder’s work conferred an actual benefit on the estate that would entitle the bidder to payment. Id.

    Key Points

    • A stalking horse bidder can benefit the estate and potentially recover termination fees and out-of-pocket expenses with administrative expense priority — even when the ultimate winning bid is lower than the stalking horse bid.
    • Courts will consider the terms and conditions in the various proposals, along with the final purchase price, to determine whether the estate benefitted from the stalking horse’s efforts.
    • Stalking horse bidders should argue that expenses incurred in a bid ultimately stymied by regulatory concerns still benefit the estate — and thus may be entitled to administrative priority.

    Facts and Procedural History

    Energy Future Holdings filed for Chapter 11 relief in April 2014. EFH entered into merger negotiations with NextEra, culminating in the Bankruptcy Court’s approval of a Merger Agreement providing for NextEra’s acquisition of the Oncor power facility in exchange for paying EFH’s debt.

    NextEra made consummation of the Merger Agreement subject to the removal of a regulatory “ring fence” in place around Oncor. The ring fence prohibited NextEra from appointing or replacing Oncor board members and prevented Oncor from making distributions to NextEra.

    On April 13, 2017, the Public Utility Commission of Texas denied NextEra’s request to remove the ring fence. The Merger Agreement provided for a $275-million Termination Fee that would be payable to NextEra if EFH terminated the Agreement. NextEra appealed the PUCT decision to a Texas state court, and EFH terminated the Merger Agreement while NextEra’s appeal was pending.

    Upon a creditor’s motion for reconsideration, the Bankruptcy Court modified the Termination Fee provision in the NextEra Merger Agreement after noting “that under no foreseeable circumstances would NextEra terminate the Merger Agreement if the PUCT declined to approve the NextEra Transaction.” The Bankruptcy Court entered an order modifying the Termination Fee provisions and denying recovery of a Termination Fee.

    The Bankruptcy Court eventually approved a merger between EFH and Sempra Energy for several hundred million dollars less than what NextEra had agreed to pay. The Sempra Merger allowed the ring fence to stay in place.  

    Subsequently, NextEra filed an Expense Application under Section 503(b)(1)(A) to recover costs “incurred in its efforts to complete the transaction, obtain the requisite regulatory approvals, and complete the acquisition of [EFH’s] Oncor assets from the time the Merger Agreement was executed until [EFH] gave notice of termination.” One of EFH’s creditors, along with the indentured trustee, opposed NextEra’s Expense Application.

    The Bankruptcy Court did not permit payment of NextEra’s costs. The court emphasized the absence of a “competitive bidding process,” noting that EFH “eventually closed a transaction with Sempra for substantially less value.” The court also rejected NextEra’s argument that its efforts provided a “roadmap” for the Sempra deal, concluding that, because EFH “[was] forced … to find an alternative transaction at far less value,” there was no benefit to the estate.

    The Bankruptcy Court also denied payment based on language in the Merger Agreement providing that each party pays its own expenses, except for those fees recounted in “specifically enumerated sections of the Merger Agreement or are administrative expenses addressed in [EFH’s] bankruptcy plan.” The Delaware District Court affirmed the Bankruptcy Court, and NextEra appealed from this decision to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals.

    Analysis

    The Third Circuit addressed two issues on appeal: (1) whether the Merger Agreement barred NextEra from recovering expenses and (2) whether NextEra “plausibly alleged” that its expenses conferred an actual benefit on the estate.

    1. Section 6.7 of the Agreement’s Did Not Bar Payment of Fees

    The Third Circuit first addressed whether Section 6.7 of the Merger Agreement precluded NextEra from recovering general administrative fees, holding that it did not and reversing the Bankruptcy Court’s granting of summary judgment. Section 6.7 of the Merger Agreement provided that: “Except … any administrative expenses of the Debtors’ estates addressed in the Plan of Reorganization, whether or not the Merger is consummated, all costs and expenses incurred in connection with this Agreement and the Closing Date Transactions and the other transactions contemplated by this Agreement shall be paid by the party incurring such expense.” (emphasis added).

    The Third Circuit found that the “unambiguous meaning of Section 6.7 … is that administrative expenses of the Debtors’ estates are allowed under the Plan of Reorganization … if determined by the Bankruptcy Court to be expenses that were “actual and necessary” to preserving the Debtors’ estates.” Because the Plan allowed for payment of valid administrative expenses, the Third Circuit “enforce[d] the plain text of the Merger Agreement and the Plan” by reviewing the merits of NextEra’s administrative expense claims.

    1. NextEra Plausibly Alleged that it Benefitted the Estate

    The Third Circuit held that NextEra plausibly alleged that it benefitted the estate “by providing valuable information, and accepting certain risks, that paved the way for the later Sempra deal.” In reversing the Bankruptcy Court, the Third Circuit noted that, at the motion to dismiss stage, the inquiry “is not whether NextEra actually benefitted the estate, but whether it plausibly alleged that it did so.” Id. at 747 (emphasis added).  

    Defining and Determining “Benefit” to the Estate

    The Third Circuit emphasized that the benefit “does not have to be substantial” and that “less readily calculable benefits, such as the ability to conduct business as usual, can qualify.” The Court found that promoting more competitive bidding by inducing an initial bid, along with encouraging prospective bidders to do their due diligence and “research[ing] the value of the debtor and convert[ing] that value to a dollar figure on which other bidders can rely” can qualify as a “benefit.”

    The Plausibility of NextEra’s Alleged Benefits

    NextEra articulated two arguments that it benefitted the bankruptcy estate: (1) it acted as a “stalking horse” whose bid encouraged later, higher bidders; and (2) it created “a roadmap” that “assisted in and sped up the approval of the Sempra merger.” 

    Stalking Horse Theory. The Third Circuit noted that “NextEra was not a prototypical stalking horse” because its bid was the sole offer. Additionally, NextEra’s alleged stalking horse bid did not attract higher offers, because EFH agreed to the Sempra Merger with a significant price deduction. Id.  For this reason, the Court gave more consideration to NextEra’s “roadmap” theory. Id. 

    Roadmap Theory. The Third Circuit agreed that NextEra plausibly alleged that its labor in drafting the Merger Agreement and Plan (which were relied on in the later Sempra deal), settling creditor objections to the proposed merger, and “proving to future bidders that Debtor’s interest would necessarily have the [ring fence] attached saved Debtors from reinventing the wheel even after the deal with NextEra fell through.”

    Notwithstanding EFH’s acceptance of a substantially lower price, the Third Circuit observed that the Sempra bid “was for Oncor with the undesirable ring fence intact and was, therefore, a bid on a different bag of goods.” NextEra’s unsuccessful efforts towards consummating the merger without the ring fence “provided future bidders with the necessary information to place informed bids, with the understanding that the ring fence would remain.” Therefore, NextEra plausibly alleged that it benefited the estate through its “due diligence” in pursuing PUCT approval of the sale without the ring fence attached, since this “increase[d] the likelihood that the price at which the debtor[‘s asset] is sold will reflect its true worth.”

    Next Steps

    The Bankruptcy Court will consider whether NextEra’s efforts “actually benefitted” the estate. The court will ascertain the value of the benefits NextEra conferred, as well as any costs NextEra allegedly imposed, on the estate during merger negotiations. To minimize alleged costs, bidders would be wise to avoid pursuing expensive regulatory appeals that a court, in hindsight, may consider detrimental to the estate.

    The Bankruptcy Court “ought to consider in its balancing, the fairness — or lack thereof — of NextEra being induced by the assurance of a Termination Fee to make the substantial outlays it did, only, when all was said and done, to lose out not only on the deal but also on the Termination Fee.” Id. at n. 8. However, because Termination Fees are “meant to account for the risk of mergers rather than be an accurate valuation of merger-related services,” bidders should not rely on the Termination Fee alone as evidence of the value of the benefit to the estate. Id. at n. 13.

    The Third Circuit made clear that NextEra is not estopped from arguing that pursuing PUCT approval of a merger without the ring fence benefitted the estate, although a different panel on the Third Circuit affirmed a determination that the Termination Fee did not benefit the estate. Id. at n. 9. The question of “whether [a] Termination Fee, if correctly understood at the time it was approved, produced a benefit to the estate” is wholly independent from the inquiry on remand — whether NextEra’s efforts taken to consummate the merger “provided a benefit worthy of administrative expense reimbursement wholly apart from any Termination Fee.” Id. (emphasis added).

    Authored by Douglas Mintz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2021 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Climate Change and State Insurance Regulation: What Could Change After President Biden’s May 20 Executive Order

    Climate Change and State Insurance Regulation: What Could Change After President Biden’s May 20 Executive Order

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Climate Change and State Insurance Regulation: What Could Change After President Biden’s May 20 Executive Order

    May 27, 2021

    Read time: 16 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    US President Joe Biden’s May 20, 2021, executive order laid out an aggressive, whole-of-government plan to address climate change risk, including a set of directives that will have a major impact on the operations of the federal government and on the regulation of financial markets participants. While the effects on regulation of banks and financial services companies are somewhat clearer, state-regulated insurance companies face a murkier, less well-defined future. This On the Subject reviews recent developments in climate change risk management in the United States and in Europe, and outlines some of the challenges that lie ahead.

    In depth

    MAY 20 EXECUTIVE ORDER

    On May 20, 2021, US President Joe Biden issued his Executive Order on Climate-Related Financial Risk (EO) that sketched out a whole-of-government approach to addressing climate change risk, both for federal government operations and also for the regulation of many financial markets participants, including insurers. The EO sets deadlines for submission of two major reports: first, within 120 days from the date of the EO, a plan to develop a comprehensive strategy with respect to government programs (e.g., the underperforming federal flood insurance program), assets and liabilities; and second, a late-November 2021 deadline for the Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC) to submit to the president a comprehensive climate change risk assessment and progress reports from federal regulatory agencies on integration of climate change-related risk into banking, securities and asset-management regulatory frameworks.

    The initial focus of the EO is on disclosure. It seeks to promote “consistent, clear, intelligible, comparable and accurate” disclosure of climate-related financial risk, including physical and transition risks, by the federal government as a whole and by financial entities regulated by the government—and apparently also for insurers. As many readers will appreciate, insurer solvency and market conduct are most definitely not directly regulated by federal government regulators. But as those who know the history of the passage of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 will also recall, the creation of the Federal Insurance Office by that legislation positioned the proverbial camel’s nose very close to, if not under, state insurance regulators’ tents. (See more on the FIO and climate change, below.)

    The EO also seeks to advance two other Biden administration climate change aims: correcting environmental inequities imposed on many communities, and creating well-paying jobs. And for those fortunate enough to have pensions or retirement savings, the EO tasks the US Secretary of Labor to consider threats to them from climate change.

    The EO addresses federal lending, underwriting and procurement activities, seeking to ensure that climate change-related risks are considered in government financial management and financial reporting. Future budgets will include assessments of the government’s own climate risk exposure. “Major” federal government suppliers will need to begin disclosing greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs), climate change-related financial risks and “science-based” reduction targets for GHGs.

    As to federally regulated financial institutions—and mindful of systemic risk/stability issues—the EO assigns to the FSOC under the direction of Treasury Secretary Yellen (who also chairs the FSOC), the task of ensuring that every federal financial services regulatory body has integrated climate change-related risks into its regulatory and supervisory activities. Here again, the focus is on disclosure enhancements by regulated entities, but emphasis is also placed on examining approaches to improving mitigation with new or revised regulatory standards.

    As to the insurance industry in particular, the EO instructs Secretary Yellen to:

    “(i) direct the Federal Insurance Office to assess climate-related issues or gaps in the supervision and regulation of insurers, including as part of the FSOC’s analysis of financial stability, and to further assess, in consultation with States, the potential for major disruptions of private insurance coverage in regions of the country particularly vulnerable to climate change impacts; and

    (ii) direct the Office of Financial Research to assist the Secretary of the Treasury and the FSOC in assessing and identifying climate-related financial risk to financial stability, including the collection of data, as appropriate, and the development of research on climate-related financial risk to the U.S. financial system.”

    THE BACKDROP

    The development and publication of the EO come at a fascinating moment in the evolution of climate change-related financial risk analysis and planning in America and globally. As the “Fact Sheet” that accompanied the May 20 EO put it:

    “Today, President Biden took action to address the serious threat that the climate crisis poses to our economy. Extreme weather related to climate change can disrupt entire supply chains and deprive communities of food, water, or emergency supplies. Snowstorms can offline entire power grids. Floods made worse by rising sea levels destroy homes and businesses. As the United States builds a modern and equitable clean energy future that creates millions of good-paying jobs and advances environmental justice, the agency actions spurred by the President’s directive today will help safeguard the financial security of America’s families, businesses, and workers from the climate-related financial risks they are already facing.”

    The International Energy Agency (IEA), an entity that for almost half a century has focused on fossil fuels, has just published what some commentators have termed a “stunning” report entitled “Net Zero by 2050.” The IEA’s lengthy take on what will be required to move the global energy sector to net zero by 2050, the narrow pathway that policymakers and participants in the world economy will need to travel, the hundreds of milestones to reduce and then eliminate investment in oil, gas and coal-fired plants and projects that the IEA believes will need to happen, is sobering to consider.

    Among other global milestones in the IEA’s pathway:

    • Starting now, no more approvals of unabated coal fired power plants and no approvals for new oil or gas fields, or coal mines or extensions of existing mines
    • By 2030, spending $820 billion per year on electric grid upgrades (up from $260 billion per year today)
    • By 2030, spending $90 billion per year to reach an installed base of 40 million electric vehicle (EV) charging stations
    • By 2030, boosting annual EV battery production from 160 gigawatt hours today to 6,600—i.e., building the equivalent of 20 lithium-ion battery gigafactories each year
    • By 2030, 60% of passenger cars sold are electric; by 2035, 50% of heavy-truck sales are electric
    • By 2050, coal falls to 10% of power production, with 20% of that in plants with carbon-capture technology.

    Translating these global milestones into country-specific achievements and company-specific mandates will likely be a complex, expensive and messy exercise, particularly in countries still building coal-fired generation capacity with 40- or 50-year operating lives and in developing economies that will struggle to finance investment in green technology. Deploying (and financing the deployment of) new clean technology that will not have a positive environmental impact for some time also will be a huge challenge.

    Indeed, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has estimated that in the near-term (up to 2030) annual investment of $6.9 trillion (approximately 8% of global gross domestic product in 2020) will be required just to keep global warming to 2° C. above pre-industrial levels. The IEA’s own estimate of necessary energy-sector investment is $5 trillion by 2030, up from an annual average of $2.3 trillion in recent years.

    In the United States, an even bigger challenge is political, hence (in part) the Biden administration’s climate change mantra (reasserted in the EO) about the positive job creation aspects of setting out on this multi-decade crusade. But like it or not, the United States is beginning the journey. It is fascinating to observe the US government’s climate change about-face, now in progress and visible on a daily basis. (See, for example, https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators, now updated for the first time in four years.) Given this history, it is uncertain whether the United States will continue on the journey and at what pace.

    Not surprisingly, the IEA’s report has already been criticized or rejected, at least in part, by multiple countries and non-governmental organizations (e.g., OPEC), and there will certainly be continuing reverberations in the weeks and months ahead. Such dissents from the prevailing climate change orthodoxy in Europe and now in Washington, DC, are to be expected. In the United States, apart from climate-change skeptics in Congress, we may see state-by-state opposition as well. Recent press reports forecast that state Republican attorneys general in Arizona, Kentucky, Louisiana, Missouri and West Virginia could be expected to file suits seeking to challenge aspects of the Biden administration’s developing climate change policies. Indeed, state treasurers from 15 states wrote to John Kerry, the US Special Presidential Envoy for Climate, this week to decry the Biden administration’s “bullying” of banks and other financial institutions to curtail lending and investment in fossil fuel companies and projects. The treasurers threatened to withdraw funds from banks that cave to the Biden administration’s pressure tactics.

    IS “CONSISTENT, CLEAR, INTELLIGIBLE, COMPARABLE AND ACCURATE” DISCLOSURE OF CLIMATE-RELATED FINANCIAL RISK POSSIBLE?

    When it comes to climate-related financial risks, the world today is filled with multiple, proliferating, climate change regulatory frameworks and models, metrics, data sources and stress-testing scenarios. During the six weeks leading to the release of the EO, following months of climate change regulatory announcements by government officials in Washington, DC, and in capitals around the world, news cycles were inundated with press releases from financial institutions, fund managers and others discussing sustainability plans, new targets to reduce GHG emissions, claims about green investment funds, green investment commitments, green investment measurement tools and the like. Developers of climate change frameworks, purveyors of environmental and climate change data and metrics, scenario experts and others have continued to bombard the public all with their new and improved products.

    In one recent article, discussing which of 33 sustainability certifications might be right for a young graduate, Trish Kenlon, founder of Sustainable Career Pathways, observed:

    “The world of corporate sustainability reporting is not for the faint of heart. The organizations that comprise the infamous alphabet soup of reporting frameworks and standards each provide their own approach to the reporting of sustainable value creation and disclosure of climate-related risks, which makes deciding what reporting-related certification to pursue incredibly difficult.”

    Ms. Kenlon concluded that “we’re not likely to have one single framework that everyone uses anytime soon (if ever)” and offered the following advice to the graduate on which certification to pursue: the one that your future employer uses!

    CLIMATE CHANGE DATA

    As a noted asset manager put it last month in announcing its new sustainability scoring approach:

    “As demand for ESG-driven investing has accelerated, so too has the number of data providers–each with varying information, reporting components and levels of transparency. This has created significant confusion and subjectivity for investors to assess the magnitude and direction of individual companies’ ESG-related issues. Concerned by the numerous ESG methodologies and data sets available, investors have expressed the need for a more transparent and disciplined framework that focuses only on the ESG-related business issues that could impact the financial condition of a company–and ultimately their portfolio’s investment return.”

    Leaders within financial and other institutions are well aware of this surfeit of information. The head of sustainable finance at a leading investment bank, speaking to the proliferation of climate metrics, was quoted earlier this month as follows:

    “My mantra tends to be: if we could have better data on fewer things that matter more […] Companies feel like they’re asked for too many different things by too many different people, and that the list is changing […] investors feel, to some degree, that they get a lot of noise and not a lot of signal.”

    Central bankers apparently get it, as well. In early May 2020, in a speech delivered at the Delphi Forum, Benoît Coeuré, head of the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Innovation Hub, reviewed the Innovation Hub’s 2021 initiative, which involved teaming up with the international G-20 forum on a TechSprint addressing green/sustainable finance generally and how to help financial institutions and investors “better collect, verify, and analyse data to understand whether their loan decisions and investments improve (or worsen) environmental outcomes.” He continued:

    “This is a topical theme. Data and information availability has been highlighted as a major impediment to addressing climate change in recent years. The large number of standards and disclosure frameworks for corporate sustainability and climate-related issues, as well as different definitions and taxonomies, make it difficult to compare climate-related, green and sustainability information available to market participants. When firms make information public, they often do so across different reports, making such information difficult to locate, collate and analyse.”

    AFTER THE MAY 20 EXECUTIVE ORDER

    Federal government activity in line with the EO should lead to centralized and standardized US financial regulatory efforts to make sense of the many competing frameworks for climate change risk analysis, sources of information about climate change, the data that is analyzed, and the metrics that should be used by everyone, regulators and regulated entities alike. Indeed, in commenting on the EO, Secretary Yellen promised that:

    “FSOC will work with Council members to improve climate-related financial disclosures and other sources of data to better measure potential exposures… [and] will work with regulators to share perspectives, identify common impediments, and find solutions to those impediments. A critical task is pulling together individual agency perspectives to assess how climate risks may impact the stability of the entire financial system.”

    Presumably, Secretary Yellen will look to her staff, perhaps principally to John Morton, Treasury’s “climate counselor” appointed in April 2020 to lead the coordination efforts. What remains unclear, however, is exactly what this new structure and lineup of largely federal players may mean for the future of climate change regulation for insurers at the state level.

    Keep in mind that US insurance regulators have exactly one non-voting representative on the FSOC (although there is a legislation pending to enable the representative to vote). At the same time, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) is moving slowly to develop a position on climate change regulation and the New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) remains the only US financial services industry regulator, state or federal, that has developed a more or less comprehensive climate change regulatory framework.

    It is a leap, however, from having a framework, to guiding regulated entities in making sense of the existing jumble of climate change data and metrics—a jumble soon to be augmented with competing climate change models being developed by modelling companies and perhaps also by others, including possible state and federal agencies.

    Although there are many uncertainties, this new initiative probably also means that the odds have improved for greater convergence between US regulatory standards and processes, on the one hand, and the rest of the world on the other. Such alignment could help avoid an outcome in which differing approaches—with each country or region pursuing its own favored goals, methods and requirements—create gaps and inconsistencies and increase risk.

    In fact, Secretary Yellen committed Treasury to “engage fully with our global partners through the G-7, G-20, and Financial Stability Board [to] promote a strong and consistent global approach.” How quickly this happens and how far any such convergence might extend is of course subject to a host of factors and variables, including US political developments. While it would appear that the Network of Central Banks and Supervisors for Greening the Financial System (NGFS), along with others, may be well placed to help guide US regulators, even experienced central bankers understand how much work banks have yet to do.

    Recently, a task force co-chaired by senior regulators from the European Central Bank (ECB) and the Federal Reserve concluded:

    “[T]hat [bank regulators] still need an enhanced toolbox that can better measure climate risks. This is why the ECB is encouraging banks to enhance both the quantity and the quality of their climate-related disclosures, and to become more transparent about their overall exposures to climate-related risks. Banks are still in the early stages of incorporating climate change into their risk frameworks; risk identification and risk limits around climate-related goals do not yet actually feature in their risk management processes. This needs to change. Euro area banks need to drastically improve their capacity to manage climate-related and environmental risks and start acknowledging how these risks can drive others, including credit, market, operational and liquidity risks.”

    Clearly, US bank regulators are playing catch-up, but the distance between them and European bank regulators should shorten considerably as 2021 progresses. That said, the picture for US insurers is less clear.

    STATE REGULATORS AND CLIMATE CHANGE

    In late May 2021, the International Association of Insurance Supervisors, working with the UN-sponsored Sustainable Insurance Forum, published its revised “Application Paper on the Supervision of Climate-Related Risks in the Insurance Sector” that offers insurance regulators worldwide a mix of advice, illustrations, examples and recommendations with respect to constructing or upgrading a climate change insurance regulatory framework. However, apart from the New York DFS, it is not apparent that any state that has sought to develop a climate risk regulatory framework for insurers.

    The DFS’ work on its framework continues; industry and interested-party comments on New York’s proposed framework are due by June 23, 2021. There is one state—Connecticut—with legislation pending (S.B. 1047) that would require insurers to report to the state Insurance Department on fossil fuel-related investments and premium income, and would in turn require the Insurance Department to prepare an annual climate change report for the state legislature. It is unclear, however, whether this bill will advance over insurer opposition in the few weeks remaining in the state’s 2021 legislative session.

    In addition, submission of climate change disclosures by insurers will be required again in 2021 by a number of states (California, New York and Washington State, among others). What’s more, the NAIC’s Climate and Resiliency Task Force recently decided not to make any changes in the NAIC’s disclosure survey. Insurers again have the option of submitting the FSB’s Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) survey in place of the NAIC survey.

    CONCLUSION

    With a little more than 150 days until the start of the biggest climate change summit of the year (the United Nations Climate Change Conference of the Parties, or COP26) in Glasgow, Scotland, on November 1, 2021, there’s an old joke about how few working days (70? 80?) will be left to delegates to prepare after eliminating weekends, national and religious holidays, vacations (allowing for national differences), a sick day or two, preparing for and attending other conferences, etc. For US government officials engaged in the US whole-of-government climate change assessment exercise called for by the EO, there will be even fewer days to prepare for COP 26. Meanwhile, many US insurers will be engaged in the same climate change disclosure process as in years past, while also monitoring the final steps in the New York DFS process to adopt a climate change regulatory framework. Whether there will be any progress to report from the NAIC on climate change remains to be seen.

    Authors

    Thomas M. Dawson

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Texas Citizens Participation Act does not protect communications about private transactions

    Texas Citizens Participation Act does not protect communications about private transactions

    ARTICLE

    Texas Citizens Participation Act does not protect communications about private transactions

    May 27, 2021

    Read time: 5 min

    The Texas Court of Appeals in the 14th Circuit denied an interlocutory appeal from the trial court’s denial of a motion to dismiss under the Texas Citizens Participation Act (TCPA), holding that TCPA does not protect communications concerning a private transaction between private parties. Post Acute Medical, LLC v. Meridian Hospital Systems Corporation, No. 14-19-00546-CV (Tex. App. – Houston [14th Distr.], May 18, 2021) (Wise, J.)

    Meridian Hospital Systems developed and licensed web-based medical software to Post Acute Medical, PAM Physician Enterprise and Clear Lake Institute for Rehabilitation (collectively, PAM). Under the license, Meridian retained ownership of the software and reverse-engineering, as well as providing login information to third parties, were both prohibited. Meridian filed a complaint against PAM, alleging that PAM misappropriated Meridian’s trade secrets by entering into a contract with a third party to develop new software, and more specifically, by providing log-in information to the third party and “documenting” Meridian’s software to replicate its features. PAM moved to dismiss under the TCPA, but the trial court denied the motion. PAM filed an interlocutory appeal.

    The Court of Appeals cited several cases to the effect that TCPA does not apply if the defendants’ communications concern a private transaction between private parties. The Court characterized PAM’s communications (among PAM entities and with the third party) as misappropriating Meridian’s software and breaching its contract with Meridian. Thus, it reasoned that the communications related to PAM’s entities reflected only a “common business interest,” not to “common interests” under TCPA, which are limited to public interests that relate to the community at large. Because Meridian could not meet its burden to show by a preponderance of the evidence that TCPA applied to Meridian’s claims, the court affirmed the denial of the motion to dismiss.

    Practice note: In this case, PAM advanced the same legal theory (i.e., that “common business interests” qualify as “common interests” under TCPA) that the same Texas appeals court had embraced in prior cases. It’s also a legal theory that a panel of the Texas Court of Appeals [1st Dist.] had embraced in the Gaskamp opinion that was subsequently vacated en banc (the Court here agreed with the en banc opinion in Gaskamp). The issue may still be appealed (whether in this case or another) to the Texas Supreme Court.

    Authors

    Paul Devinsky

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights