ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
PhRMA Code Revisions to Go Into Effect January 2022
October 12, 2021
Read time: 8 min
In keeping with — and in response to — HHS-OIG’s November 2020 Special Fraud Alert on industry speaker programs, the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America has updated its Code on Interactions with Health Care Professionals, which will take effect on January 1, 2022. Given the Code changes and government attention to speaker programs, companies should review their policies and practices to determine whether changes should be made or enhanced controls should be implemented.
Likely inspired by recent government enforcement activity and guidance on industry speaker programs, the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA) announced revisions to its Code on Interactions with Health Care Professionals (Code), which will go into effect on January 1, 2022. These changes focus on the “suspect characteristics” of speaker programs that the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (OIG) discussed in its Special Fraud Alert: Speaker Programs (SFA) published November 16, 2020. Our client alert on the SFA is available here. PhRMA also made other updates to the sections covering meals offered by company personnel during informational presentations, healthcare professional (HCPs) consulting arrangements and company support for third-party educational or professional meetings.
Speaker programs are a standard way for pharmaceutical manufacturers to educate and inform HCPs about the risks, benefits and expected clinical outcomes of FDA-regulated products. FDA has long recognized certain so-called “bona fide scientific exchanges” among HCPs as beyond the purview of traditional advertising and promotion restrictions when certain guardrails are in place. Nonetheless, these programs have long been the target of Department of Justice (DOJ) and OIG investigations. In its November 2020 SFA, OIG went so far as to say it is “skeptical about the educational value of such programs.” PhRMA appeared to respond to this view in its August 6, 2021, press statement, reiterating that a “fundamental principle” behind the Code’s guidance on speaker programs is that it has “long recognized that company-sponsored speaker programs provide important substantive educational information about the benefits, risks and appropriate uses of company medicines and related disease states.”
Summary of Code Changes
HCP Speaker Programs
Key updates to the Code include:
- Program purpose: The Code emphasizes that speaker programs should be used to present substantive educational information designed to help address bona fide educational needs, taking into account recent developments or changes (e.g., new medical or scientific information; benefits, risks, and appropriate uses of company medicines and related disease states) or the availability of such educational programming.
- Speaker selection: The revised Code adds an express statement that HCPs should not be selected to serve as a speaker “based on past revenue that the speaker has generated or potential future revenue that the speaker could generate by prescribing or ordering a company’s products.” OIG cautioned more broadly that company sales or marketing business unit influence on speaker selection is a suspect characteristic.
- Attendance:
- The Code now states that repeat attendance at a speaker program on the same or substantially similar topic where a meal is provided to the attendee is generally not appropriate, unless the attendee has a bona fide educational need to receive the information presented.
- Building on existing Code guidance, PhRMA states that attendance by the family members, friends, or significant others or other guests of HCPs is not appropriate unless these individuals have an independent, bona fide educational need to receive the information presented.
- Another new Code provision states that attendance by speakers at programs after speaking on the same or substantially the same topic is generally not appropriate.
- Meals and Venue:
- The Code reiterates longstanding guidance that the speaker program should occur in a venue and manner conducive to informational communication, and a company representative should be physically present; and meals offered as an incidental business courtesy to attendees of speaker programs should be modest, as judged by local standards.
- While the OIG found the availability of alcohol as a “suspect” feature, PhRMA went farther to expressly state that companies should not pay for or provide alcohol in connection with speaker programs.
- In contrast to the OIG’s broad characterization of restaurants as a suspect characteristic, the Code merely cautions against “high-end” restaurants. The Code retains the position that many restaurants have private dining rooms that can be conductive to an educational presentation and focuses instead on whether the venue selected by the company is “extravagant or the main attraction of the event or perceived as such.” Luxury resorts, high-end restaurants, and entertainment, sporting, or other recreational venues or events are not appropriate.
Company Informational Programs and Meals
- PhRMA updates the section on company informational programs and accompanying meals by company representatives, which typically present information during the HCP’s working day, including mealtimes.
- The Code states that occasional, incidental meals can be offered, in connection with these meetings, to the HCP, as well as members of their staff attending presentations, so long as the presentation provides scientific or educational value, and the meal provided is: (a) modest as judged by local standards; (b) not part of an entertainment or recreational event; and (c) provided in a manner conducive to informational communication.
- Any such incidental meals and meetings should be limited to in-office or in-hospital settings and “only where there is a reasonable expectation, and reasonable steps are taken to confirm, that each attendee has a substantive interaction or discussion with the company representative.”
- Finally, the Code confirms that “offering ‘grab-and-go’ meals is not appropriate.”
HCP Consulting
Carrying over the revisions to the speaker program section, PhRMA updated the consulting section to also contain an express statement that consultant selection “should not take into account the volume or value of past business that may have been or potential business that could be generated for the company by the HCP consultant.” This section also states that high-end restaurants and entertainment, sporting, or other recreational venues or events are not appropriate venues for consultant/advisor meetings.
Virtual Third-Party and Company Meetings
The revised Code includes a brief mention that the principles articulated for company support of continuing medical education and third-party meetings apply to virtual events as well as in-person. However, the Code lacks further guidance and does not incorporate PhRMA’s Statement on Application of PhRMA Code Section 2 During Emergency Periods (Statement) issued on June 30, 2020, that addressed how to shift company informational and other programs to a virtual environment due to the pandemic. The Statement’s guidance is time-limited to the existence of the national public health emergency. Thus, it may be possible that PhRMA does not intend to continue supporting virtual company meetings with incidental meals following the end of the national emergency, or is still considering the issue.
Analysis and Implications
Given the Code changes and government attention to HCP speaker programs, companies should review their policies and practices to determine whether changes should be made or enhanced controls should be implemented. As noted above, there are details in which the Code and the SFA differ, such as having restaurants as venues and having alcohol available, that companies should consider as they re-evaluate their speaker programs.
More fundamentally, it is important to note that OIG suggests that companies should broadly assess the need for in-person programs and related remuneration to HCPs altogether, even after the ongoing COVID-19 public health emergency ends, citing in-person programs as inherently higher-risk activities under applicable fraud and abuse laws. The Code does not necessarily share this view, but it also did not expand its discussion of virtual programming beyond stating that its guidance regarding company support for continuing medical education programs and third-party educational and professional meetings applies to virtual and in-person meetings. As a result, companies should thoughtfully consider the contours of their speaker program activities in light of the Code’s changes and with the understanding of OIG’s perspective.
We also note that some jurisdictions, such as California, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, and Nevada, have requirements for companies and their representatives to follow the Code. Thus, companies should take steps to ensure compliance with the Code in those jurisdictions if policies vary from the Code in certain respects.
Recent Developments in Tax Law: Reform of the Real Estate Transfer Tax
ARTICLE
Recent Developments in Tax Law: Reform of the Real Estate Transfer Tax
October 2021
Read time: 2 min
Dr. Gero Burwitz authored the article “Recent Development in Tax Law: Reform of the Real Estate Transfer Tax”, featured in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), p. 1299-1301 in October, 2021.

Mexican Federal Government Submits Proposed 2022 Economic Plan
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Mexican Federal Government Submits Proposed 2022 Economic Plan
October 8, 2021
Read time: 12 min
Last month, the Mexican federal government sent the proposed 2022 Economic Plan (the Proposal) to the Congress of the Union, which includes the 2022 Federal Budget, as well as the 2022 Revenue Law (Ley de Ingresos) and proposed amendments to the Income Tax Law (Ley del Impuesto Sobre la Renta), the Value Added Tax Law (Ley del Impuesto al Valor Agregado) and the Federal Fiscal Code (Codigo Fiscal de la Federacion), among others.
While the proposed changes are not substantive in nature (in the sense that they do not create new taxes or increase applicable rates), they are intended to close certain loopholes available in some areas, increase the taxing authorities’ (Servicio de Administracion Tributaria or SAT) oversight and review rights and impose harsher penalties on taxpayers in violation of tax laws.
The Proposal is currently pending debate in the House of Deputies (Camara de Diputados) and the Senate of the Republic (Senado de la Republica). Many interest groups have also begun to lobby the SAT and Congress, seeking modifications to certain items of the Proposal, therefore, the final bill may differ from the specifics outlined in this article. The Proposal must be voted on no later than November 15, 2021, and the final bill will go into effect on January 1, 2022.
Below is a detailed summary of the more relevant items in the Proposal.
INCOME TAX
Intercompany Financing
If approved, the Proposal would expand the definition of back-to-back loans to include any related party debt that lacks business purpose. As such, interest payments on any related party loan or transaction would be recharacterized as dividends if the financing transaction were deemed to lack a business purpose. Mexican legislation does not define the term “business purpose,” however, the Federal Fiscal Code does provide some guidance in that sense. Specifically, it provides that the tax benefit derived from a specific transaction cannot exceed the value of the transaction itself.
Thin Capitalization Rules
Mexico currently has a three-to-one debt-to-equity ratio limitation for determining related party interest deductibles paid to nonresidents. Taxpayers have the option to use either the book value or tax equity to calculate the limitation on the interest deduction. The Proposal would modify the thin capitalization rules to make these two calculations more consistent. Specifically, the Proposal would require taxpayers to include net operating losses (NOLs) in addition to paid-in capital and previously taxed earnings when the tax equity option is elected to calculate their limitation on interest deductions. Losses are not currently included in the tax equity calculation. If the book value and tax equity differ by more than 20% for purposes of the thin capitalization rules, the Proposal would only allow taxpayers to use the tax equity option if there is a business purpose for the difference and other requirements are met.
Domestic Restructuring, Spin-Offs and Mergers
Currently, domestic restructurings, spin-offs and mergers are treated as tax free to the extent that certain formal requirements are met. In addition to the current requirements, the Proposal would require taxpayers to have a valid business purpose for these transactions to be treated as tax free.
Mergers and spin-offs would also be subject to additional reporting and scrutiny by the SAT if a relevant transaction (as defined in the Proposal) occurs within five years, before or after, the reorganization. Relevant transactions include the following:
- The transaction involves a transfer of stock ownership or the use or enjoyment of the voting rights or veto rights of shares for the merged entity (or entities) involved in a spin-off, as applicable.
- Rights are granted for the assets or profits of one of the reorganization parties for reductions of capital or liquidations.
- The value of the shareholders’ equity in any of the reorganization parties (survivors) increases or decreases by more than 30% compared to the value determined at the date of the reorganization.
- The capital stock (capital social) of the shares increases or decreases compared to the value at the date of reorganization.
- A shareholder’s participation in the company increases or decreases, resulting in an increase or decrease of another shareholder’s interest as compared to the date of the reorganization.
- One of the shareholders of the reorganization parties changes its residence.
- One of the reorganization parties sells a line of business.
Additionally, the Proposal would change the definition of a spin-off to refer to the transfer of capital stock instead of capital equity (capital contable). This provision aligns with other changes that disallow the creation of capital accounts because of a split-up.
The Proposal would also expand the current limitations for the allocation of NOLs resulting from a spin-off to require that the losses may only be transferred between entities that carry on the same business activity.
Regarding the existing restrictions on the use of NOLs when there is a change in control, the Proposal would expand on the current assumptions for determining when there is a direct or indirect change in the control of a company. Under the Proposal, a direct or indirect change in control would occur when (1) there is a change in the holders of the direct or indirect rights to make decisions in shareholders’ assemblies or to change members of the Board of Directors, or (2) a company and its shareholders stop consolidating their financial statements after a merger.
Nonresident Capital Gains
The Proposal would modify certain provisions related to the authorization to defer income tax for capital gains in corporate reorganizations carried out by nonresidents. Under current provisions, nonresident shareholders may request a ruling to approve the transfer of shares in a Mexican entity with the payment of the deferred income tax due when the shares leave the group. This ruling is an indefinite gain recognition agreement. The Proposal would allow the SAT to cancel the deferral authorization if, based on the information provided, it is concluded that the reorganization lacks a business purpose or that the exchange of the shares related to the reorganization resulted in income subject to a preferential tax regime. Once the deferral authorization is cancelled, the capital gains tax would be triggered.
When it comes to shares, the Proposal would deem them subject to the deferral ruling to be transferred out of the corporate group. Payment of the corresponding capital gains tax would be triggered if the issuer entity and the acquiring entity stop consolidating their financial statements.
In addition, the Proposal would include information regarding reporting provisions for relevant transactions carried out by the taxpayers within five years, before or after, the authorized date of the corporate reorganization.
The Proposal would also modify the requirements nonresidents must satisfy for electing to be taxed on capital gains on a net gain basis at a 35% rate. Specifically, it would require nonresidents to show that they have complied with the transfer pricing rules. For these purposes, the registered public accountant would have to include the transfer pricing supporting documentation in the tax audit report.
One requirement of the Proposal: The Mexican entity (issuer of the shares being transferred) must notify the SAT about transfers of its shares between foreign residents. Failure to do so could result in the Mexican entity becoming jointly liable for any tax due by the foreign residents.
The Proposal would include additional obligations for Mexican legal representatives of nonresidents appointed for specific compliance related to Mexican-sourced income. For example, the Proposal would require a legal representative to voluntarily assume joint and several liability up to the amount of any tax liability due by the nonresidents and must demonstrate that it has sufficient assets to cover possible assessments. This provision is not exclusive to capital gains income.
Maquiladora Transfer Pricing Rules
The Proposal would eliminate the option for maquiladoras (aka, a factory in Mexico run by a foreign company) to request an advanced pricing agreement (APA) in order to comply with maquiladora transfer pricing rules. The Proposal would also repeal the APA option for nonresidents operating through “shelter” companies.
Without this alternative, as of 2022, maquiladoras would only be able to apply the “safe harbor” methodology, which requires taxable income in Mexico to be the greater of 6.5% of total costs incurred by the maquiladora or 6.9% of the total value of the assets used in the maquiladora operation (including the average value of inventory, machinery and equipment owned by the maquiladora’s principal).
Additionally, the Proposal would eliminate the need to file an annual notice informing the SAT of the application of the safe harbor methodology (which was considered an administrative burden) as this information should already be disclosed in the annual maquiladora information tax return.
Given the size, relevance and strength of the maquiladora industry alliance and the consequential nature of this proposed reform, it is expected that the final bill will restore the ability for maquiladoras to seek APAs, however, in a more limited fashion.
VALUE-ADDED TAX
VAT Credit on the Importation of Goods
The Proposal would clarify that value-added tax (VAT) credits for the importation of goods would only apply if the import documentation (pedimentos) is issued in the name of the taxpayer claiming the credit, thereby making it more costly for the taxpayer to use a third party for importing goods into Mexico.
Disallowance of VAT Credits for Activities Carried Out Outside of Mexico
The Proposal includes provisions regarding the allocation of activities between taxable and non-taxable activities, including those performed outside of Mexico, for purposes of calculating the amount of credits that may be taken for input VAT. These rules would eliminate a taxpayer’s ability to credit any VAT paid on the acquisition of goods, services, imports, etc. related to activities carried out abroad.
Compliance for Nonresidents Rendering Digital Services in Mexico
The Proposal would require foreign digital service providers to submit VAT information returns monthly, instead of quarterly. This provision is consistent with the monthly return form. The Proposal would also sanction foreign digital service providers that fail to file information returns and pay taxes for three or more consecutive months.
VAT on the Leasing of Goods
The Proposal would subject the leasing of goods to Mexican VAT, regardless of the place where the goods are delivered (i.e., Mexico or abroad). Currently, leasing transactions are subject to VAT in Mexico only when the leased goods are delivered within the Mexican territory.
OTHER AMENDMENTS ON COMPLIANCE AND AUDIT PROCEDURES
Tax Residence
The Proposal would establish that taxpayers may not lose their Mexican tax resident status for five years, unless tax residency can be demonstrated in another country not considered a preferential tax regime. If Mexico has entered into an information exchange agreement with the relevant country and that agreement allows for assistance in the collection and remittance of taxes, this provision would not apply.
Cancellation and Restriction of Digital Stamp Certificates
The Proposal would modify the current procedure to cancel digital stamp certificates (CSDs) required to issue invoices. The Proposal would also clarify the procedure for rebooting a cancelled CSD or obtaining a new one. The cancellation of a CSD is an enforcement tool typically applied by the SAT in cases of deemed incompliance by Mexican taxpayers (i.e., missed tax returns, transactions with blacklisted companies, a mismatch in records or non-locatable tax domicile).
Joint and Several Liability
Currently, joint and several liability applies to the acquirers of going concerns. The Proposal would create several assumptions for deeming a going concern as acquired, even if the title is not formally transferred. Specifically, the Proposal would deem a going concern as acquired when there is an identical continuation of certain elements (i.e., assets, liabilities, members of the Board, shareholders, suppliers, tax domicile, employees and copyright).
The Proposal would also impose joint and several liability for up to the amount of the tax liability on any Mexican legal representatives appointed by foreign residents.
The Obligation for Certain Taxpayers to File an Annual Tax Report
The Proposal would reinstate the requirement that taxpayers have their financial statements audited by a registered public accountant and file an annual tax report (Dictamen Fiscal) if they recorded gross income of at least $876,171,996.50 Mex$ (approximately $45 million USD) on their tax returns or if the company is publicly traded in Mexico. Taxpayers have been relieved of this obligation in recent years.
The Obligation of CPAs to Report on Potential Tax Criminal Offenses
The Proposal would require certified public accountants (CPAs) to report any conduct by the audited taxpayer, identified because of the preparation of the annual tax report that may constitute the commission of a tax criminal offense, to the SAT. It would also hold CPAs who fail to report these situations criminally liable for concealing the potential tax offense.
Common Reporting Standard/Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act
The Proposal would (1) incorporate into Mexico’s domestic legislation the international covenants assumed by Mexico regarding the exchange of information, (2) strengthen compliance and (3) provide enforcement tools for financial institution reporting obligations.
In addition, the Proposal would require companies, trustees, other entities and legal vehicles (e.g., partnerships) to obtain and keep information on their ultimate beneficial owner in an accurate and updated manner. It would also grant new verification powers to the SAT for auditing these persons.
Simulation of Legal Acts for Tax Purposes
The Proposal would authorize the SAT to determine the simulation of legal acts in related party transactions exclusively for tax purposes and determine upon audit the outstanding tax liability amount according to the true nature of the transaction. While the process for determining the simulation of related party transactions is already contained in the Mexican Income Tax Law, the Proposal would allow the SAT to determine simulation from a procedural perspective at the Federal Fiscal Code level. This provision would close the loophole for certain challenges to this process that have been raised in the past.
Tax Offense for Simulating Employment Relationships
In line with the recent Mexican outsourcing reform under which the subcontracting of employees is restricted or forbidden, the Proposal would add, as an aggravating circumstance to the committing of tax fraud, the false treatment of employees as independent contractors for tax purposes. The Proposal would also add obtaining any tax benefit from payments that violate anti-corruption laws as an aggravating circumstance to tax fraud.
The McDermott Will & Emery Tax Practice Group look forward to any questions or comments regarding the content in this article.

NFA Excludes Certain Remote Work Arrangements From Its Branch Office Definition
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
NFA Excludes Certain Remote Work Arrangements From Its Branch Office Definition
October 7, 2021
Read time: 6 min
On September 23, 2021, National Futures Association (“NFA”) rule amendments became effective that will permit NFA-member managers to authorize certain “work from home” and “flex work” arrangements for their Associated Persons (“APs”) without incurring an obligation to register the AP’s remote work location as a branch office. The NFA’s updated rules will allow many — but not all — COVID-19-related remote working accommodations adopted under managers’ business continuity policies to become ordinary course operations. Managers who are not NFA members (such as unregistered commodity pool operators or unregistered commodity trading advisors who manage funds under Rule 4.13(a)(3) relief) are unaffected by the NFA’s branch office rules and their recent amendments.
How Have the NFA’s Branch Office Registration Requirements Changed?
Prior to the NFA’s recent rule amendments, NFA-member managers, such as Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”)-registered commodity pool operators and commodity trading advisors, were generally required to register any location aside from the manager’s main business address as a branch office if activities requiring registration as an AP (such as marketing and solicitation) were being conducted there. Subsequent COVID-19-related relief clarified that this requirement would not apply to temporary remote-working accommodations adopted pursuant to activation of a member’s business continuity policy in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, provided that sufficient, documented supervisory and recordkeeping contingencies were adopted.[1]
The NFA’s September 23 amendments to Interpretive Notice 9002, governing branch office registration, have formalized a general exclusion to the prior branch office definition for, in essence, APs’ personal home (or flex-work) offices, provided that in-person customer meetings or physical handling of customer funds does not occur at the work site, all records associated with the remote work location are available at the manager’s main business address, and the location is not otherwise held out to the public as the firm’s office.[2] Specifically, the branch office definition now excludes:
[A]ny location where one or more APs from the same household live or rent/lease provided the location is not held out to the public as an office of the Member; the AP(s) does not meet in-person with customers or physically handle customer funds at the location; and any CFTC or NFA required records created at the non-branch office location are accessible for inspection at the Member firm’s main or applicable listed branch office as required under CFTC Regulation 1.31 and NFA Compliance Rule 2-10.
What Remote Work Arrangements Are Covered by the New Exclusion?
Notably, the NFA’s branch office exclusion only applies to locations “where one or more APs from the same household live or rent/lease.” The NFA has advised that its new branch office definition is “designed to capture both work from home arrangements as well as flexible shared workspace arrangements.”[3] Based on the NFA’s guidance and new branch office definition:
- A typical home office, or “flex-work” space (such as a WeWork™ cubicle), mortgaged or rented by one or more cohabiting Associated Persons for personal work use will not be deemed a branch office (provided that the other requirements of the new branch office exclusion are satisfied); but
- A firm satellite office, serving multiple APs who would not be deemed part of the same household, or that is leased or mortgaged by the firm itself (for the use of one or more APs), would remain liable to branch office registration, even if no in-person investor meetings are conducted at the site.
Action Steps
NFA-member managers with registered branch offices, as well as managers with unregistered remote work arrangements adopted pursuant to the NFA’s prior COVID-19-related relief, and managers who are considering adopting a remote work policy going forward, should carefully review the NFA’s updated branch office definition and guidance.
- Managers may immediately update their NFA registration documents to delist locations that are presently identified as branch offices if those locations fall outside of the NFA’s amended branch office definition.
- Managers relying on the NFA’s COVID-19-related relief to avoid branch office registration should note the new branch office exclusion is more particular, and, therefore, less extensive, than the NFA’s COVID-19-related relief.
- Managers should seek counsel before relying on the NFA’s new branch office rule amendments to avoid registering any remote work site that that is not clearly excluded under the revised definition.
- Finally, Managers should be reminded that APs utilizing remote work arrangements that are eligible for the NFA’s branch office exclusion remain subject to all applicable supervisory requirements of the NFA’s bylaws and interpretive notices, including NFA Rule 2-9 (“Supervision”)[4] and Interpretive Notice 9074 (“CPO Internal Controls System”)[5]. Managers should have documented policies and procedures that ensure APs using “work from home” and similar accommodations remain in compliance with NFA rules.
Authored by Marc E. Elovitz, Heather N. Wyckoff and Joshua B. Wright.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
[1] See NFA Notice I-20-12 (March 13, 2020), available here.
[2] See NFA Interpretive Notice 9002: Registration Requirements; Branch Offices (amended Sept. 23, 2021), available here.
[3] See NFA Proposed Amendments: 9002 – Registration Requirements: Branch Offices (Aug. 23, 2021), p.4, available here.
[4] See NFA Rule 2-9, available here.
[5] See NFA Interpretive Notice 9074: CPO Internal Controls System, available here.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2021 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
State Aid & Taxation: An Overview of EU and National Case Law
ARTICLE
State Aid & Taxation: An Overview of EU and National Case Law
October 2021
Read time: 2 min
Hendrik Viaene explores State aid and taxation, reviewing the existing European Commissions decisional practice and case law of the European Courts.
To read the full article, please click here.

The Legal 500: Merger Control Country Comparative Guide | Belgium
ARTICLE
The Legal 500: Merger Control Country Comparative Guide | Belgium
October 2021
Read time: 2 min
Hendrik Viaene and Karolien Van der Putten have contributed to the latest Legal 500 Guide, which aims to provide its readers with a pragmatic overview of merger control laws and regulations across a variety of jurisdictions.
Their Belgium chapter provides information about jurisdictional thresholds, the substantive test, process, remedies, penalties, appeals, as well as analysis on planned future reforms of the merger control regime.
Click here to read the full chapter.

A Flurry of CFTC Actions Shock the Cryptocurrency Industry
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
A Flurry of CFTC Actions Shock the Cryptocurrency Industry
October 1, 2021
Read time: 9 min
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) sent shockwaves across the cryptocurrency industry when it issued a $1.25 million settlement order with Kraken, one of the industry’s largest market participants. The next day, the CFTC announced that it had charged each of 14 entities for offering cryptocurrency derivatives and margin trading without registering as a futures commission merchant (FCM). While the CFTC has issued regulatory guidance in the past and engaged in some regulatory enforcement activities, it has now established itself as a key regulator of the industry along with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the US Department of Justice (DOJ) and the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury). Market participants should be aware that the CFTC will continue to take a more active role in regulation and enforcement of commodities and derivatives transactions moving forward.
The CFTC alleged that each of the defendants were acting as an unregistered FCM. Under Section 1a(28)(a) of the Commodity Exchange Act (the Act), 7 U.S.C. § 1(a)(28)(A), an FCM is any “individual, association, partnership, or trust that is engaged in soliciting or accepting orders for the purchase or sale of a commodity for future delivery; a security futures product; a swap . . . any commodity option authorized under section 6c of this title; or any leverage transaction authorized under section 23 of this title.” In order to be considered an FCM, that entity must also “accept[] money, securities, or property (or extends credit in lieu thereof) to margin, guarantee, or secure any trades or contracts that result or may result therefrom.” (See: 7 U.S.C. § 1(a)(28)(A)(II).) 7 U.S.C. § 6d(1), requires FCMs to be registered with the CFTC.
THE KRAKEN SETTLEMENT
On September 28, 2021, the CFTC issued an order, filing and settling charges against respondent Payward Ventures, Inc. d/b/a Kraken for offering margined retail commodity transactions in cryptocurrency—including Bitcoin—and failing to register as an FCM. Kraken is required to pay a $1.25 million civil monetary penalty and to cease and desist from further violations of the Act. The CFTC stated that, “This action is part of the CFTC’s broader effort to protect U.S. customers.”
The CFTC’s order finds that from approximately June 2020 to July 2021, Kraken violated Section 4(a) of the Act, 7 U.S.C. § 6(a)(2018) by offering to enter into, entering into, executing and/or confirming the execution of off-exchange retail commodity transactions with US customers who were not eligible contract participants or eligible commercial entities. The CFTC also found that Kraken operated as an unregistered FCM in violation of Section 4d(a)(1) of the Act, 7 U.S.C. § 6d(a)(1) (2018). According to the order, Kraken served as the sole margin provider and maintained physical and/or constructive custody of all assets purchased using margins for the duration of a customer’s open margined position.
Margined transactions worked as follows: The customer opened an individual account at Kraken and deposited cryptocurrency or fiat currency into the account. The customer then initiated a trade by selecting (1) the trading pair they wished to trade, (2) a purchase or sale transaction and (3) a margin option. All trades were placed on Kraken’s central limit order book and executed individually for each customer. If a customer purchased an asset using margin, Kraken supplied the cryptocurrency or national currency to pay the seller for the asset. If a customer sold an asset using margin, Kraken supplied the cryptocurrency or national currency due to the buyer. Trading on margin allowed the customer to establish a position but also created an obligation for the customer to repay Kraken at the time the margined position was closed. The customer’s position remained open until they submitted a closing trade, they repaid the margin or Kraken initiated a forced liquidation based on the occurrence of certain triggering events, including limitations on the duration of an open margin position and pre-set margin thresholds. Kraken required customers to exit their positions and repay the assets received to trade on margin within 28 days, however, customers could not transfer assets away from Kraken until satisfying their repayment obligation. If repayment was not made within 28 days, Kraken could unilaterally force the margin position to be liquidated or could also initiate a forced liquidation if the value of the collateral dipped below a certain threshold percentage of the total outstanding margin. As a result, actual delivery of the purchased assets failed to occur.
The CFTC asserted that these transactions were unlawful because they were required to take place on a designated contract market. Additionally, by soliciting and accepting orders for, and entering into, retail commodity transactions with customers and accepting money or property (or extending credit in lieu thereof) to margin these transactions, Kraken was operating as an unregistered FCM.
Coinciding with the release of the enforcement action against Kraken, CFTC Commissioner Dawn D. Sump issued a “concurring statement.” In it, she appeared to be calling upon the CFTC to adopt more specific rules governing the products that are the subject of the enforcement action. Commissioner Sump seemed to indicate that it would be helpful to cryptocurrency market participants if the CFTC clarified its position on the applicability of the Act, as well as registration requirements. The CFTC will likely issue guidance or rules to clarify its position on which cryptocurrency-related products trigger registration requirements.
CFTC CHARGES 14 CRYPTOCURRENCY ENTITIES
On September 29, 2021, the CFTC issued a press release and 14 complaints against cryptocurrency trading platforms. The CFTC is seeking a sanction “directing [the cryptocurrency platforms] to cease and desist from violating the provisions of the Act set forth herein.” Each of the platforms have 20 days to respond.
All of the complaints are somewhat similar in that the CFTC alleges that each of the cryptocurrency platforms “from at least May 2021 and through the present” have offered services to the public “including soliciting or accepting orders for binary options that are based off the value of a variety of assets including commodities such as foreign currencies and cryptocurrencies including Bitcoin, and accepting and holding customer money in connection with those purchases of binary options.”
The CFTC has taken the position that “binary options that are based on the price of an underlying commodity like forex or cryptocurrency are swaps and commodity options as used in the definition of an FCM.” (The CFTC has previously taken the position that Bitcoin and Ethereum constitute “commodities,” doing so in public statements and enforcement actions.) In a prominent enforcement action previously filed by the CFTC in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York, the court held that “virtual currency may be regulated by the CFTC as a commodity” and that it “falls well-within the common definition of ‘commodity’ as well as the CEA’s definition of commodities.” (See: CFTC v. McDonnell, et al., 287 F. Supp. 3d 213, 228 (E.D.N.Y. Mar. 6, 2018); CFTC v. McDonnell, et al., No. 18-cv-461, ECF No. 172 (E.D.N.Y. Aug. 23, 2018).) In the action the CFTC filed against BitMEX in October of 2020, it alleged that “digital assets, such as bitcoin, ether, and litecoin are ‘commodities’ as defined under Section 1a(9) of the Act, 7 U.S.C. § 1a(9). (See: CFTC v. HDR Global Trading Limited, et al., No. 20-cv-8132, ECF 1, ¶ 23 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 1, 2020).)
The CFTC has previously taken the position that Bitcoin, Ethereum and Litecoin are considered commodities. However, in these recently filed complaints, the CFTC did not appear to limit the cryptocurrencies that would be considered “commodities” to just Bitcoin, Ethereum and Litecoin. Instead, the CFTC broadly referred to “commodities such as foreign currencies and cryptocurrencies including Bitcoin.” It remains to be seen which of the hundreds of cryptocurrencies on the market will be considered “commodities,” but it appears that the CFTC is not limiting its jurisdiction to just three. It is also an open question as to whether there are certain cryptocurrencies or cryptocurrency referencing financial products that the SEC and CFTC will determine are subject to the overlapping jurisdiction of both regulators, similar to mixed swaps under the derivatives rules.
The CFTC also singled out two of these cryptocurrency platforms, alleging that they issued false statements to the effect that it “is a registered FCM and RFED with the CFTC and member of the NFA.” The CFTC noted that neither of these entities were ever registered with the National Futures Association (NFA) and one of the NFA ID numbers listed “identifies an individual who was once registered with the CFTC but has been deceased since 2009.”
WHAT’S NEXT
While the SEC, Treasury and DOJ are often considered the most prominent federal regulators in the cryptocurrency space, this recent sweep by the CFTC is not the first time it has flexed its muscles. The CFTC went to trial and won in 2018, accusing an individual of operating a boiler room. In October 2020, the CFTC filed a case against popular cryptocurrency exchange BitMEX for failing to register as an FCM, among other counts. However, unlike those one-off enforcement actions, the recent actions targeting multiple market participants within two days is a big step forward for the CFTC. Cryptocurrency derivative trading has been rising in popularity over the last few years and it is unsurprising that the CFTC is taking a more active enforcement role.
It is expected that regulatory activity within the cryptocurrency space will increase from all US regulators, including the CFTC, SEC, Treasury and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, especially as cryptocurrency products are increasingly classified as financial products subject to regulation. While the CFTC and other regulators have issued some regulatory guidance, regulators appear to be taking a “regulatory guidance by enforcement action” strategy.Market participants will need to thoughtfully consider all relevant regulatory regimes in order to determine what compliance activities are necessary. As we describe, multiple classifications are possible.


