Content Type: Article

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 5

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 5

    October, 2003

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HOT TOPICS

    1. The Community Patent

    Duncan Curley of McDermott Will & Emery’s London office gives an overview of the proposed European Community Patent which businesses should be able to apply for within five years.

    2. Second Medical Use Claims & The Harmonisation of Patent Law in Europe

    For pharmaceutical companies inconsistencies in the interpretation of second medical use patent claims by the European Patent Office and the national courts of the European Member States may give rise to complications regarding the validity of patent claims. Simone Blakeney of McDermott Will & Emery’s London office discusses the implications of these idiosyncrasies and their elimination by the proposed Community Patent Court.

    3. OHIM Publishes Details Of Its New E-Filing Service For Design Protection

    The Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Community Trade Marks and Designs Registry) (OHIM) has published on its website details of how to file for design protection electronically.

    4. Moscow Arbitration Court To Rule Over Sale Of Soviet-Era Films

    A Russian film studio has applied to obtain a ruling annulling the sale of 1,200 classic Soviet-era cartoons to a US film company.


    COPYRIGHT

    5. Licensing Digital Information

    The Copyright Licensing Authority and the United Kingdom Media Monitoring Association have developed terms of a generic licence that will facilitate the delivery of press cuttings by cutting agencies to their clients, while respecting the interests of copyright owners.

    6. Unauthorised Use Of Elvis Costello Photograph

    In Gabrin v Universal Music Operations [2003] EWHC 1335 (Ch), Universal Music used a silk-screen print within an album booklet, without authorisation from copyright owner of photograph.

    7. Masthead Copyright Infringement

    Scottish Universal Newspaper v Mack (2003) ScotCS 167

    The Scottish Outer House Court of Session has confirmed the well established principle that, if a substantial part of a copyright work is copied, it is irrelevant whether a new work in which copyright subsists has been created.


    PATENTS

    8. Celltech Appeal Allowed

    Celltech Chiroscience v MedImmune Inc  [2003] EWCA Civ 1008

    The Court of Appeal, on appeal from the first instance decision of Mr Justice Jacob, were required to assess the doctrine of equivalents and file wrapper estoppel under post-Festo 2 US law. In doing so they partially overturned first instance decision, finding both amendment based estoppel and argument based estoppel, albeit with one of the three judges dissenting.

    9.  BASF And SmithKline Cross Appeals Dismissed

    BASF AG v SmithKline Beecham [2003] EWCA Civ 872

    This case concerned an appeal by SmithKline Beecham Plc against a judgment of Pumfrey J of 12 July 2002 and a cross appeal by BASF AG. Both appeals were dismissed on 25 June 2003.

    10.  Add A Hint Of Paroxetine Salt

    The decision handed down by the Court of Appeal on 25 June in Synthon BV v SmithKline Beecham [2003] EWCA Civ 861 emboldens the position of patentees facing revocation orders for want of novelty.

    11.  Ajinomoto Sweetener Patent Upheld

    In Daesang Corporation v Ajinomoto Co Inc [2003] EWHC 973 (Ch), the Patents Court upheld the validity of a patent under attack of the respondent whose revocation was sought by the claimants on grounds of obviousness, insufficiency and anticipation.


    TRADE MARKS

    12.  Three’s company, Two’s A crowd

    In Adidas-Salomon AG and Adidas Benelux BV v Fitnessworld Trading Ltd, Case C-408/01, Advocate General Jacobs considered whether Article 5(2) of the Trade Mark Directive applies to use by a defendant of his sign on similar or identical goods. He also turned his attention to the precise meaning of the types of harms identified in Article 5(2) and whether trade mark use is necessary for infringement under that article.

    13.  Interaction Between The Elements Of A Mark: CFI Upholds OHIM On Its Examination Methodology

    In Best Buy Concepts v OHMI (BEST BUY) CFI T-122/01, the Court of First Instance has upheld the decision of the OHIM Third Board of Appeal in rejecting the application for a figurative trade mark incorporating the word element BEST BUY. In doing so the CFI approved the method of first examining the separate elements of the mark applied for.

    14.  Ansul To The Question Of Genuine Use

    In Laboratories Goemar SA & La Mer Technology Inc[2003] EWHC 1382 (Ch), Jacob, J. was unclear how much use is too little within the meaning of the directive to revoke the registration of Laboratories Goemar SA (hereafter Goemar) trade marks. He requested the ECJ formulate a de minimis test for national court to distinguish genuine from covetous use in cases involving small scale enterprises. The ECJ ruled that national court should apply the decision in Ansul BV(C40/01), when assessing the genuineness of use.

    15.  Russia Claims Geographical Protection For Russian Vodka

    In June Russia’s Patent Office ruled that “Russian Vodka” can only be labelled as such if it is distilled in the country itself and if it tastes like the genuine article.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by the following individuals at Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute:

    Abigail Browne, Alan Cunningham, Alison Firth, Malcolm Langley, Florian Leverve, James Mitchiner, Aditya Nagarsheth, Mike Rhys-Thomas, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Negotiating the Perils of European Patent Litigation

    ARTICLE

    Negotiating the Perils of European Patent Litigation

    October, 2003

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Distribution of Broadband Content Pursuant to the New Telecommunications Law

    ARTICLE

    Distribution of Broadband Content Pursuant to the New Telecommunications Law

    October 1, 2003

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Ralf Weisser discusses the distribution of broadband content pursuant to the new telecommunications law.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 4

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 4

    August/September 2003

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HOT TOPICS

    1. Have a Break – The House of Lords refers to the ECJ in the Kit Kat Case

    Rohan Massey of the London Office reports on the latest ruling in the long running Kit Kat case. On 25 July the House of Lords in Société des Produits Nestlé S.A. and Mars UK Limited referred a question to the ECJ regarding whether the distinctive character of a trade mark may be acquired following the use of that mark in conjunction with another mark.

    2. Adoption of New Copyright Bill in Germany

    Kathrin Tauber of the Munich Office discusses the changes to German copyright law brought about by the Bill on Copyright in the Information Society. The provisions of the Bill see a number of changes to the current German Copyright Act (Urheberrechtsgesetz), most of which address the need to adapt copyright law for the digital era.

    3. House Of Lords Comments On Need For Trade Mark Use

    In R v Johnstone [2003] UKHL 28, the House of Lords decided whether the fact that the defendant’s activities do not amount to civil trade mark infringement is a defence to criminal trade mark infringement under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1994.

    4. The Trials Of Trade Mark Use

    The Court of Appeal handed down judgment in Arsenal Football Club Plc v Matthew Reed [2003] EWCA Civ 96 on 21 May, following an appeal by the claimants against the decision of the High Court of 12 December 2002.

    5. Report Of The Commission On Intellectual Property Rights: The UK Government Response

    The UK Governments has given its official response to the final report of the Commission on Intellectual Property Rights.


    GENERAL IP

    6. Protected Designation Of Origin: Parma Ham And Grana Padano Cheese

    Maintaining the quality and reputation of Grana Padano cheese and Parma ham justifies the rule that the product must be grated or sliced and packaged in the region of production.

    7. Swedish Crackerbread To Be Re-Branded 27 Years After It Was Launched

    Wasa, a subsidiary of the Italian bakery group Barilla, was ordered by a Swedish court to re-brand one of its most famous products, Moraknaecke, almost three decades after it was first launched.

    8. Third Country Agreement Is Permissible

    In Budejovický Budvar v Rudolf Ammersin Gmbh, C-216/01, Opinion of the Advocate General, following an action between a Czech brewery and an Austrian beer distribution company, the European Court of Justice is examining the protection of a mere geographical indication ‘Bud’. Precisely it has to consider if an international agreement between a Member State and a third country falls under Art. 307 EC. The Advocate General proposes that such agreement is permissible.

    9. The European Commission Selects Eurid To Manage The .EU

    The European Commission has taken steps towards the establishment of the .eu Top Level Domain (TLD) by selecting EURID (the European Registry for Internet Domains) as the official Registry for the .eu domain.

    10. Data Protection Notification – Scam Update

    Rohan Massey of the London Office reviews an interim hearing showing the Office of Fair Trading continuing to crack down on fraudsters holding themselves out as official organisations administering the Data Projection Act.

    11. Withdrawal Of Marketing Authorisation May Not Entail Automatic Withdrawal Of Parallel Import License

    Paranova Oy v Lakemedelsverket, C-113/01, ECJ [reference by supreme administrative court, Finland]


    COPYRIGHT

    12. Court Order Made Against Unknown Person

    In Bloomsbury Publishing Plc and JK Rowling v Newsgroup Newspapers Limited [2003] EWHC 1087 Ch, Laddie J held that court orders can be made against a person whose name is unknown where he can be identified by some other means.


    PATENTS

    13. Soya Patent Restricted By The EPO

    The Opposition Division of the EPO has decided to limit the scope of the so called “Soya” patent, bearing number EP 301 749 B1, after conducting a public hearing in the opposition proceedings.


    TRADE MARKS

    14. ECJ Rules Colours Per Se Are Registrable In Limited Circumstances

    In Libertel Groep BV v Benelux-Merkenbureau, C-104/01, the European Court of Justice held that colours per se that are not applied for by reference to a specific surface can be registered as trade marks, but only in limited circumstances.

    15. ECJ Rules Sounds Are Registrable

    In Shield Mark BV v Joost Kist, C-283/01, Opinion of the Advocate General, sounds are registrable as long as their representation is “clear, precise, self-contained, easily accessible, intelligible, durable and objective”. In the AG’s opinion, this is clearly fulfilled if a sound is represented on a score but generally not if it is represented by onomatopoeia or a nominative succession of musical notes. This determination however always belongs to the national court.

    16. Doublemint Refused By Advocate General

    In OHIM v Wrigley Jr Co., C-191/01, Opinion of the Advocate General. After an application for a CTM for the mark “doublemint” was refused by OHIM, but then allowed by the CFI, OHIM appealed to the ECJ. The Advocate General has now issued his opinions suggesting the application should be dismissed.

    17. Registrar’s Objections Upheld

    In Dyson Ltd v Registrar of Trade Marks, [2003] EWHC 1062 (Ch), Dyson appealed to the High Court against the decision of the hearing officer in an ex parte hearing not to grant a trade mark on grounds of acquired distinctiveness against an examiner’s objection under ss.3(1)(a)-(c) and s.3(2)(b).


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by the following individuals at the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute: Andrew Bennett, Alan Cunningham, Estelle Derclaye, Alison Firth, Malcolm Langley, Florian Leverve, Aditya Nagarsheth, Anthony Robinson, Ilanah Simon, Daphne Zografos.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Cable Distribution and the Obligation to Contract under German Copyright Law

    ARTICLE

    Cable Distribution and the Obligation to Contract under German Copyright Law

    August 1, 2003

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Ralf Weisser discusses cable distribution and the obligation to contract under German copyright law

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 3

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 3

    July, 2003

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HOT TOPICS 

    1. The Directive on Privacy and Electronic Communications (2002/58/EC)

    Clare Sellars of the London office provides an overview of the new legislation to be implemented by 31 October 2003 which will affect businesses using email or text messaging systems to market themselves to clients. The aim of the Directive is to harmonise the legal requirement of privacy protection in relation to the processing of personal data in electronic communications throughout the EU.

    2. German Ministry of Justice Proposes Bill Reforming Act on Unfair Competition

    Kathrin Tauber of the Munich office deals with the legal changes arising out of the proposed bill to modernise the current Act on Unfair Competition, especially the suggested modifications to the rules of sales promotion.

    3. Third World Intellectual Property Day

    Following a call of the Director General of the World Intellectual Property Organisation for society to be more involved in matters relating to intellectual property, the theme of this year’s Word Intellectual Property Day on 26 April 2003 was: “Making Intellectual Property Your Business”.

    4. Royal Society report on the effect of intellectual property rights on research

    The Royal Society report “Keeping science open: the effects of intellectual property policy on the conduct of science” has been published. It studied the effect of several intellectual property rights, i.e.patent, copyright, and database legislation and concluded that the current intellectual property system needs to be tightened up for the sake of both science and society.

    5. How can the public sector provide people with information on, and build confidence in, the way it handles their personal details?

    The Lord Chancellor’s Department has launched a consultation paper on personal information and the way the public sector is handling it. It is concerned with the understanding of the public as ‘customer’ of such service to a paper made by the Lord Chancellor’s Department. This paper aims at providing information to the public about why they should provide their personal data to the public sector, the protection of such data, and the legal safeguards.


    COPYRIGHT & DESIGNS

    6. Linux creator speaks out on Digital Rights Management

    Although Digital Rights Management (DRM) is thought of as a means by which rights owners can control the authenticity of works and monitor their use and ensure payment for use is made, the creator of Linux, the open-source operating, system says that some DRM systems may be compatible with open source policies.

    7. Breach of confidence, alternatively copyright infringement?

    In Cray Valley Limited v Deltech Europe Ltd., John Scanlan & Cristopher Riley, [2003] EWHC 728, it was alleged that on the sale of a business where information was left behind on abandoned computers. The information did not have the necessary character of confidential information, however, an assignment of “all assets” was wide enough to cover the copyright works by which the information was recorded, and this copyright was infringed by the defendants’ downloading the information.

    8. EasyInternet café settles over music rights

    EasyInternet has paid £80,000 in damages (down from £1 million requested) and legal costs to the UK record industry in an out-of-court settlement for running unlicensed CD-burning of music downloads in its stores. The court held that EasyInternet was liable for its customers downloads and that the recording industry’s umbrella organisation, BPI, had title to sue.

    9. Dutch court blocks Harry Potter-like books

    A Dutch court has found in favour of J.K. Rowling, the author of the Harry Potter series and prohibited the distribution of 7000 copies of a book by Russian author Dimitry Yemets entitled “Tanya Grotter and the Magic Double Bass”. The court held that the defendant’s book was not a parody but an adaptation and thus infringed J.K. Rowling’s copyright.

    10. Registered Community Designs come on stream as of 1 April 2003

    The Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Community Trade Marks and Designs Registry) has begun processing applications to register Community designs and has issued draft examining guidelines for consultation.

    11. New German design law proposed

    The council of German Federal ministers have approved and published a bill for the reform of German design law. Harmonisation of EU law will result in the lowering of thresholds for design registration in Germany and a shift from a copyright approach (albeit copying may be presumed if a design has been made available to the public) to full exclusive rights for registered designs. Examination as to certain substantive requirements will be introduced. A 12-month general grace period will be available. Protection will be available for a broader range of subject-matter.

    12. UK amends Registered Designs Act to accommodate Registered Community Designs

    The Registered Designs Regulations came into effect in 1 April 2003. The main change is to allow refusal or invalidation of a national registered design on the ground of a prior Community registration (Art 11 of the Design Directive 98/71/EC), with appropriate transitional provisions.


    PATENTS

    13. Rockwater win on infringement and invalidity

    Rockwater Limited v Coflexip S.A. & Technip, [2003] EWHC 812 (Ch).

    An action was brought by Rockwater before the Patent Court, Chancery Division, High Court of Justice for revocation of a European Patent. Rockwater succeeded on both grounds of infringement and invalidity. Claims 3 to 9 failed for anticipation from prior art, while claim 1 to 9 failed for obviousness. This patent had previously been found valid and infringed, so the second action succeeded in overturning the result of the first.

    14. Obligation of farmers to provide information to Holders of Community Plant Variety Rights

    Schulin v Saatgut-Treuhandverwaltungs GmbH, C-305/00, ECJ.

    The ECJ in this case, while interpreting the sixth indent of Art. 14(3) of Council Regulation (EC) No. 2100/94 on Community Plant Variety Rights and Art. 8 of Commission Regulation (EC) No. 1768/95 implementing rules on agricultural exemption as provided in Art. 14(3), has held that the obligation of farmers to provide information to right holders only extends to those who have derogated from such rights under Art. 14 and not to all farmers as such. The right holders must demonstrate some indication that the farmer has used or would use their variety for any purposes stated in Art. 13(2) of the Council Regulation.

    15. Refusal of Supplementary Protection Certificate to combination drugs

    Takeda Chemical Industries Ltd v Comptroller General of the Patent Office, [2003] EWHC 649 (Pat).

    The subject matter of this appeal pertains to the second ‘Swiss form’ patent, relating to Lansoprazole, which showed particular uses of prevention and treatment of certain diseases when taken with some antibiotics. Takeda was granted an amendment of product license to include the combination by the Medicines Control Agency (MCA). Takeda had sought SPC for this amended product license. The Patents Court dismissed the appeal, stating that the prerequisite of ‘basic patent’ under Art. 3(a) of the Regulation was not fulfilled as Takeda owned a patent only for Lansoprazole and other antibiotics in the combination could not be identified with the invention of Lansoprazole as such


    TRADE MARKS

    16. The Court of First Instance dismiss the appeal over the ‘NU-TRIDE’ mark

    Durferrit GMBH v. Office of Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade mark and Designs) (“OHIM”) and Kolene Corporation], ECFI, T-224/01, 2003.

    The Court of First Instance dismissed the appeal brought by Durferrit GMBH against the decision of the First Board of Appeal of the OHIM, relating to trade mark opposition proceedings between Duferrit and Kolene Corporation, holding word marks ‘NU-TRIDE’ and ‘TUFFTRIDE’ not to be confusingly similar.

    17. Burden of proof in parallel import cases

    In Van Doren + Q.GmbH v Lifestyle sports and sportswear Handelsgesellschaft mbH and Michael Orth, C-244/00, the ECJ ruled on the burden of proof to be applied by Member States’ courts when hearing exhaustion cases. While it is permissible in principle for a Member State to require the defendant to prove that the claimant’s trade mark rights have been exhausted, in some cases the need to preserve the free movement of goods may mean that this rule has to be qualified. The ECJ said that where there is a real risk that placing the burden of proof on the defendant would allow the trade mark owner to partition the national markets, maintaining any price differentials between the Member States, the burden of proof remains with the trademark owner.

    18. ECJ rules on registrability of shapes

    In Linde AG, Winward Industries Inc. and Rado Uhren AG the ECJ considered how Articles 3(1) (b) to (d) of Directive 89/104/EEC of 21 December 1988 to Approximate the Laws of the Member States Relating to Trade Marks should apply to applications to register shape marks. In doing so, the Court employed two of the central concepts behind the absolute grounds for the refusal of registration of trade marks: the capability of the sign in question to distinguish the applicant’s goods from the goods of other undertakings; and the need to keep certain signs free for competitors to use.

    19. Registration of band name by ex-members in bad faith

    This was an appeal by one of the members of 80’s rock band SAXON, who was claiming that the registration of the band’s name as a trade mark by other former members of the band constituted bad faith.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by the following individuals at Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute:

    Andrew Bennett, Abigail A. Browne, John Cahir, Alan Cunningham, Professor, Mike Dowler, Alison Firth, Alexandra George, Celeste Hanley, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Chris Lee, Florian Leverve, Judy McCullagh, Jane Molyneaux, Aditya Nagarsheth, Chiew Geik Ooi, Prabhuram Otharam, Barbara Shao-I Chen, Ilanah Simon, Matthew Smith and Sunethra Wimalasundera.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 2

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 2

    May/June 2003

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HOT TOPICS

    1. PRIVACY AND PERSONALITY, POLITICIANS AND STARS

    An article by Rohan Massey and Kathrin Tauber

    2. DATA PROTECTION – CALIFORNIA’S LONG ARM OF THE LAW GETS LONGER

    An article by Rohan Massey

    3. THE eEUROPE 2002 FINAL REPORT

    Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, the Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions.

    4. AMENDMENTS TO THE PROPOSED EUROPEAN DIRECTIVE ON RE-USE & COMMERCIAL EXPLOITATION OF PUBLIC SECTOR INFORMATION

    A number of amendments to the draft directive on re-use and commercial exploitation of public sector information (2002/0123(COD)) have been suggested by the European Parliament.

    5. THE CIVIL PROCEDURE (AMENDMENT NO. 2) RULES 2002 (SI 2002/3219 (L.18))

    An Amendment to the Civil Procedure Rules 1998 has come into force on the 1 April 2003 providing a new Part 63 that will govern the Court’s procedures related to intellectual property rights.

    6. CREAM HOLDINGS LTD V BANERJEE & THE LIVERPOOL DAILY POST & ECHO [2003] EWCA CIV 103

    This case centres on Section 12(3) of the Human Rights Act 1998, which provides that no relief is to be granted to restrain publication before trial unless the court is satisfied that the applicant is likely to establish that publication should not be allowed


    COPYRIGHT

    7. IFPI TURNS IT EYES TO ACADEMIA

    The International Federation of the Phonographic Industry has released a Copyright Use and Security Guide for Academic Institutions as part of a two pronged copyright education campaign which saw business and government targeted last month.

    8. REPRESENTATIVE ACTIONS – COMMON INTERESTS AND GRIEVANCES

    In Independiente Ltd & Ors v Music Trading On-Line (Hk) Ltd, [2003] EWHC 470 (Ch), the Court held the claimants were entitled, as the owners or exclusive licensees of the UK copyright in various sound recordings, to bring an action for alleged breach of copyright in a representative capacity on behalf of all other members of the British Phonographic Industry Ltd and Phonographic Performance Ltd in relation to sound recordings which, although lawfully made and released on the market by the defendants outside the European Economic Area, had subsequently been supplied by them to buyers within the UK.


    PATENTS

    9. AMENDMENT: THE PATENTS ACT 1977 (ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATIONS) ORDER, 2003

    The UK has amended the Patents Act, 1977 (“the Act”) by SI 2003 No. 512 made under the Electronic Communications Act, 2000 and Tribunals and Inquiries Act, 1992 with effect from 1st April, 2003.

    10. SIGNIFICANCE OF DATE OF WITHDRAWAL OF PATENT APPLICATIONS

    Haberman v Comptroller General of the Patent Office, [2003] EWHC 430 (Pat)

    11. COFLEXIP SA AND COFLEXIP STENA OFFSHORE LTD V STOLT OFFSHORE MS LTD., [2003] EWCA CIV 296

    On the 13 March 2003, the Court of Appeal (Chancery Division) held that Coflexip would be required to re-plead its claim for damages for economic loss that were associated with a previous successful patent infringement litigation.


    TRADE MARKS

    12. GOULBOURN V OHMI – REDCATS (SILK COCOON), T-174/01, ECJ

    The CFI overruled the decision of the Board of Appeal annulling the Opposition Division’s earlier decision concerning the application to have ‘Silk Cocoon’ registered as a Community Trade Mark.

    13. ANSUL BV V AJAX BRANDBEVEILIGING BV, C-40/01, ECJ

    The ECJ held that “put to genuine use” within the meaning of Art.12(1) of the Trade Marks Directive (89/104/EEC) meant “actual use” of the mark and did not include “token use” of a mark merely to maintain the right to the mark.

    14. CFI APPLIES GENERICITY TEST

    In Alcon Inc. v OHIM, Dr Robert Winzer Pharma GmbH (BSS), T-237/01, ECJ (5 March 2003), the CFI applied the genericity test formulated by the ECJ in Merz & Krell [2001] C-517/99. Additionally, in considering whether the mark in question had acquired distinctiveness, the CFI looked for real evidence that the mark was now perceived as an indication of origin.

    15. ECJ DEFINES IDENTICAL MARKS

    In LTJ Diffusion SA v Sadas Vertbaudet SA (Case C-291/00, 20 March 2003), the ECJ responded to a French Article 234 reference calling for clarification of what is meant by an identical trade mark in Directive 89/104, which approximates the trade mark laws of the EU Member States. The restrictive definition given is relevant to registrability, infringement and invalidity under both Directive 89/104 and the Community Trade Mark Regulation.

    16. THIRD PARTY LIABILITY UNDER INJUNCTIONS

    The Court of Appeal held that where an injunction had been granted to prevent the defendant using the initials “WWF”, a third party licensee of intellectual property rights from the defendant was entitled to a suitable declaration to protect its position in relation to use of the initials which it was not practical to discontinue.

    17. DAIMLERCHRYSTLER CORPORATION V OFFICE FOR HARMONISATION IN THE INTERNAL MARKET (TRADE MARKS AND DESIGNS) (OHIM), T-128/01, CFI

    The CFI annulled a decision of OHIM’s Second Board of Appeal refusing the registration of a figurative mark representing a vehicle grille as a Community trade mark on the grounds that the mark had insufficient distinctive character.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by the following individuals at Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute:

    Andrew Bennett, Abigail A. Browne, John Cahir, Alan Cunningham, Professor, Mike Dowler, Alison Firth, Alexandra George, Celeste Hanley, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Chris Lee, Florian Leverve, Judy McCullagh, Jane Molyneaux, Aditya Nagarsheth, Chiew Geik Ooi, Prabhuram Otharam,Barbara Shao-I Chen, Ilanah Simon, Matthew Smith and Sunethra Wimalasundera.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 1

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 1

    April, 2003

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HOT TOPICS

    1. The Right to Privacy in the Context of CCTV Surveillance- Peck v The United Kingdom (ECtHR, Application No.44647/98 of 28 January, 2003) [The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR)]

    The unauthorised disclosure of CCTV footage by a public authority may constitute a violation of an individual’s right to privacy under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

    2. UK Courts Allow Service Out of Jurisdiction in Douglas v Hello! [2003] EWCA Civ 139

    This case raises interesting issues about whether acts committed in a foreign jurisdiction can give rise to liability in England under the doctrine of joint tortfeasance. Long arm jurisdiction was established and permission was granted by the Court of Appeal to join a photographer who was alleged to have breached confidence and statutory duty under data protection legislation. The allegation that transmitting a photograph over telephone lines was held to be an actionable breach of data protection legislation.

    3. European Commission Proposes the Establishment of a European Network and Information Security Agency

    4. Vitamins Cartel – Fines Imposed by EC Commission

    The Commission decision of 21 November 2001 concerns the infringement of Article 81(1) of the EC Treaty (Article 85 of the Treaty of Rome) and Article 53 of the EEA Agreement due to unlawful concerted practices of 13 different producers of 12 types of vitamins across Europe and the Far East. The cartel operation centred on the preparation and implementation of an annual “budget” to stabilise the world market share for each producer, compensation arrangements, target and minimum prices and meeting structures. Fines were reduced (in one case by 100%) for those who co-operated with the EC Commission.

    5. Can GM Crops Be Commercially Grown

    There is considerable debate within the EU as to whether genetically modified (GM) crops can be grown, or whether they will be banned forever. On the horizon for 2003 are two important steps that will precede any announcement from the British government on whether it will allow the commercial cultivation of GM in the UK. First is the publication of the first set of the results from the Farm Scale Evaluations (FSEs). Second is the public debate on broader issues surrounding GM technology.

    6. “Equitable Remuneration” Under the Rental and Lending Rights Directive (92/100/EC)

    Where a broadcast includes a performance embodied in commercial phonogram, Article 8(2) of the EU Directive on Rental and Lending Rights (92/100/EEC) requires a single ‘equitable remuneration’ to be paid for the use by the broadcaster, to be shared between phonogram producer and artists. The highest Court of Appeal of the Netherlands referred Stichting ter Exploitatie van Naburige Rechten [SENA] v Nederlandse Omroep Stichting [NOS] to the ECJ under Article 234 EC for a preliminary ruling on the interpretation of the undefined term ‘equitable remuneration’. The ECJ held that this term falls to be interpreted by national courts.

    7. EC Proposes Harmonising IP Directive to Fight Piracy and Counterfeiting

    The European Commission has presented a proposal for a Directive on the enforcement of intellectual property rights. The proposed Directive is intended to harmonise national laws on the means of enforcing intellectual property rights, and to establish a general framework for the exchange of information between responsible national authorities. It is particularly aimed at reducing counterfeiting and piracy by reducing differences in member states’ legislation concerning the enforcement of intellectual property rights, reinforcing measures against offenders, and acting as a deterrent to those engaged in counterfeiting and piracy.


    COPYRIGHT

    8. ‘Young at Heart’ Copyright Claim Upheld

    The Court of Appeal in Beckingham v Hodgens, Court of Appeal, 19 February 2003 upheld a successful claim by session violinist ‘Bobby Valentino’ to be joint author of the song ‘Young at Heart’, performed and recorded by the Bluebells in 1984. The case looked at joint authorship and estoppel.

    9. Sony Music Entertainment (UK) Limited v. Easyinternetcafe Limited [2003] EWHC 62 (Ch) 28 January 2003, Chancery Division

    The CD copying service offered by Easyinternetcafe Limited, an Easyjet affiliated Internet café company, assisted infringement of copyright under section 17(1) and section 18(1) of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA 1988). The judgment also considered a defence under section 70 CDPA (time shifting).

    10. Norwegian Copy Protection Case – Circumvention of Copy Protection Devices Held Not Criminally Unlawful

    On January 9 2003, a Norwegian Criminal Court acquitted John Lech Johansen of charges under the Norwegian Criminal Code relating to circumventing technical control measures that protect data, after he had succeeded in circumventing a copy protection system employed by the motion picture industry to protect DVD’s.

    11. IFPI Address Copyright Infringement

    The International Federation for the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) has published a Copyright Use and Security Guide for business and government. Addressing the problem of copyright theft in the corporate and government environment, the publication proposes certain best practice and policy considerations.

    12. Lego Co v Coko Toy Co. – Industrial Copyright Decision in the People’s Republic of China

    The Lego Co., the Danish toy manufacturer, won a copyright infringement proceeding on applied art (or industrial design) initiated in 1999 in the China High People’s Court whereby the defendant, Coko Toy Co., a Chinese company, was held liable for the unauthorised use of 33 out of 50 copyright elements owned by Lego Co., though with slight modification. The Defendant was ordered to destroy the relevant moulding equipment, to print a formal apology and to pay compensation.

    13. Finnish Update on Copyright Issues

    Three issues are reported, unauthorised sub-titles for films, the rejection of proposed of domestic legislation relating to copyright infringement based on the EC Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC) and a law governing ISP’s on the internet.


    PATENTS

    14. Case Comment on C-131/01 Commission v Italy [2002] Place of Establishment for Patent Agents Practising in Italy

    Italian legislation states that to provide services before the Italian Patent Office, patent agents established in other Member States must be enrolled on the register of patent agents and have a residence or place of business in Italy. Patent agents are required to pass a professional aptitude test to be eligible for entry onto the register. This was held unlawful by the ECJ.

    15. Appeal Dismissed in the Stena v Irish Ferries Case [2003] EWCA (Civ) 66

    Ships (and aircraft) registered in other countries of the World Trade Organisation or Paris Union on industrial property may visit British territorial waters without fear of infringing local patents (section 60(5)(d) of the Patents Act 1977).

    16. General Electric Co. v Enercon GmbH Ch.D Patents Court (Laddie J) 17/2/2003 [Unreported]

    This case concerned an application for a stay of infringement proceedings pending conclusion of EPO opposition proceedings. The judge set out some helpful comments on some factors which would be taken into account in considering whether to order a stay, including whether an injunction would ever be ordered to stop on-going projects.

    17. Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd v (1) Istituto Gentili SpA (2) Merck & Co Inc [2003] EWHC 5 (Pat)

    Patent found invalid, but with judicial “regret”. The failure of a patent to accurately describe the state of the prior art made it particularly susceptible to an attack of obviousness, since there was then little evidence of improvement over the prior art.

    18. Agreement on Community Patent

    Since 1999 the EU has been debating the regulations to bring a community patent into effect, and thus cut costs. The last road blocks have now been removed. It is now likely that the first community patents will be granted soon, as the EPO is the granting authority, and provided all member states of the EU are designated, it should be possible to covert on grant a European Patent to a Community Patent. Enforcement will be through national courts until 2010. It was this last issue which formed the final major bottleneck.

    19. Implementation of the Biotech Directive: Commission Applies Pressure on Member States and Establishes Expert Group

    20. SKB Plc & Anor v Apotex & 2 Ors Ch.D Patent Court, Laddie J, 4/2/2003 [Unreported]

    Should experiments on samples provided in a patent action be subject to confidentiality undertakings, and if so to what extent.

    21. Smithkline Beecham Plc (2) Glaxosmithkline UK Ltd v (1) Apotex Europe Ltd (2) Neolab Ltd (3) Waymade Healthcare Plc [2003] EWCA CIV. 137

    This case deals with the dynamics of granting or refusing interim injunctions in the pharmaceutical field, where there has been a recent history of granting interim injunctions because price depression would be irrecoverable by a final injunction and an award of damages. The patent in question was only partly valid, and the issues arising out of that finding (in other proceedings) were also discussed.


    TRADE MARKS

    22. High Court Applies ECJ Repackaging Rules

    In Glaxo Group Ltd. and The Welcome Foundation Ltd. v Dowelhurst Ltd. [2003] EWHC 110(Ch), Laddie J applied the preliminary ruling of the ECJ (Case C-143/00, [2003] Ch 27, [2002] ETMR 78) on the repackaging issues raised by this case. The judge discussed the conditions on which the re-packager can use the originator’s trade marks on repacked pharmaceuticals. Such use must be proportionate to the need to achieve market penetration, and must not lead to brand association.

    23. Summary Judgment Refused in Repackaging Case Glaxo Group Ltd & The Welcome Foundation Ltd v Europharm of Worthing Ltd & Eurochem Ltd [2003] EWHC 116 (Ch)

    Following the Glaxo v Dowelhurst case (above, “Dowelhurst“), the defendants applied for summary judgment under CPR rule 24.2. The defendants argued that, because the claimants had lost on the necessity to repackage issue in Dowelhurst, they had no reasonable prospect of success here and there was no compelling reason for the case to be tried. Laddie J in the High Court disagreed. The necessity for repacking will be examined on a case by case basis. The judge made some comments on the procedure adopted by the defendant in its application.

    24. Court of Appeal Dismisses Appeal and Cross Appeal in the Registered Trade Mark Case of West (trading as Eastenders) v Fuller Smith & Turner plc [2003] EWHC Civ 48; 2003 WL 116973

    The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and cross appeal by the parties and affirmed the earlier decision in David West (t/a Eastenders) v Fuller Smith & Turner PLC, [2002] EWHC 122; [2002] FSR 55; 2002 WL 346991 (Ch D), which dismissed West’s challenge to the validity of Fuller’s trade mark ESB (holding it was not devoid of distinctive character) and ordered a partial revocation of the mark in respect of all goods except bitter beers, the latter being the only goods for which the mark had been used. This case has a bearing on partial revocation for non-use, and its effect.

    25. A New-look Community Trade Mark System?

    The European Commission has recently presented a proposal for a Regulation which aims to modify existing procedures for the granting of Community Trade Marks (CTMs) by the Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM). The Regulation would abolish the system of searches, amend the regime for professional representation before the OHIM and expand the current system to include means by which the Boards of Appeal can further improve the way they function. The proposal also includes the abolition of the nationality and reciprocity conditions for allowing an application of a CTM thereby removing the nationality and residential restrictions on access to the system.

    26. Spain’s Cidesport Loses to Nike in Chinese Trade Mark Case

    A trade mark is unfringed where it is applied, even if all of the goods are for export to a country where the impersonation of the goods bearing the mark is not an infringement. The trademark NIKE is split, with different owners in Spain and China, the owner of the latter being the well-known US company. It succeeded in obtaining an injunction to prevent the Chinese manufacturer applying the NIKE trade mark in China for goods destined for the Spanish market.

    27. Bud Trade Mark Battle Ends in Stalemate Budejovicky Budvar Narodni Podnik v Anheuser Busch Inc. [2002] EWCA Civ 1534

    This case concerns the BUD trade mark, which was split between Czech and US owner, neither of whom was able to oust the other. The judgment deals with what constitutes genuine use of a trade mark, for the purpose of revocation for non use.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to this Bulletin made by the following individuals at Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute:

    Andrew Bennett, Abigail A. Browne, John Cahir, Alan Cunningham, Professor, Mike Dowler, Alison Firth, Alexandra George, Celeste Hanley, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Chris Lee, Florian Leverve, Judy McCullagh, Jane Molyneaux, Aditya Nagarsheth, Chiew Geik Ooi, Prabhuram Otharam,Barbara Shao-I Chen, Ilanah Simon, Matthew Smith and Jon Bing of the EFF for his translation of the Norwegian.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • IP Review

    ARTICLE

    IP Review

    Spring, 2003

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Summary

    IP Review is a biannual publication that contains insights into the various topics of IP while incorporating the authors points of view.

    In this issue:

    • A Less Expensive Alternative to Litigation
    • Crafting Business Method Patents
    • Brand Leveraging
    • Forum Shopping in Europe
    • Patenting Biotechnology Tools
    • IP Valuation in Transactions
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Film Rights Trading with Companies in Crisis – Risks and Solutions

    ARTICLE

    Film Rights Trading with Companies in Crisis – Risks and Solutions

    March 3, 2003

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights