ARTICLE
Professional Football and Labor – Two Worlds Collide
October 9, 2015
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
October 9, 2015
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
October 8, 2015
Read time: 8 min
An insolvent corporate subsidiary’s payment of its parent’s contractual obligations was not a fraudulent transfer when “the [subsidiary] Debtor received reasonably equivalent value in exchange for [its cash] transfers,” held the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit on Sept. 4, 2015. In re PSN USA, Inc., 2015 WL 5167803, at *7 (11th Cir. Sept. 4, 2015) (per curiam). Affirming the bankruptcy court’s dismissal of the Chapter 11 liquidation trust’s complaint, the Eleventh Circuit reasoned that “an insolvent debtor’s payment on behalf of [its] third party [parent] is not avoidable if the transfer ‘confers an economic benefit upon the debtor [subsidiary], either directly or indirectly.’” Id., quoting Rubin v. Mfrs. Hanover Trust Co., 661 F.2d 979, 991 (2d Cir. 1981). In short, the defendant provided services to the debtor subsidiary, those services constituted property, and the debtor paid for and used those services.
The Eleventh Circuit avoided defining “value” three years ago in a major fraudulent transfer case. See In re TOUSA, Inc., 680 F.3d 1298, 1311 (11th Cir. 2012). It reasoned there that “even if all of the purported benefits of the transaction were legally cognizable [as value], they did not confer reasonably equivalent value,” relying on the bankruptcy court’s factual findings after trial. Id. (emphasis added). In the view of the Eleventh Circuit at the time, the bankruptcy court’s fact findings in TOUSA as to the inadequacy of value were supported by the record, were not “clearly erroneous,” and should not have been reversed by the district court. Id. at 1310-13. PSN, however, squarely deals with the “value” issue, for the plaintiff trust had conceded “that the payments to [the defendant] were reasonably equivalent in value to the … services” provided by the defendant. 2015 WL 5167803, at *6.
Other appellate courts have recently wrestled with the definition of value. See, e.g., In re Positive Health Management, 769 F.3d 899, 904-05, 909 (5th Cir. 2014) (reversing lower courts, Fifth Circuit narrowed their holding that debtor had “received reasonably equivalent value in exchange for [its] cash transfers”; in effect, Fifth Circuit disregarded value of indirect economic benefits that had been provided to debtor by good faith lender, instead focusing on “the value that the transferee [defendant] gave up as its side of the bargain”); Janvey v. The Golf Channel, Inc., 780 F.3d 64 (5th Cir. 2015) (reversing district court, held that defendant’s “services furthering a debtor’s Ponzi scheme provided no value to the debtor’s creditors”), petition for rehearing granted to extent of vacating earlier decision and certifying “value” issue to Texas Supreme Court, 2015 WL 3972216 (5th Cir. June 30, 2015).
The corporate parent of the subsidiary debtor in PSN had only contracted with the defendant for satellite services. Although the subsidiary was not obligated on its parent’s contract, it actually used the services for which it paid. 2015 WL 5167803, at *6. “In exchange for its payments, the Debtor [subsidiary] received from [the defendant] the … services that were necessary for the Debtor’s business [operations]. For [its operations], the Debtor earned a service fee from its parent company … . As a non-operating holding company, … [the parent] could not have used the satellite services [obtained by the Debtor].” Id. The parent, in fact, had no offices, no employees and no operations, and it was not authorized to do business in the United States.
According to the plaintiff trustee, “the Debtor’s receipt and use of the satellite services, and its [business] operation … were solely for the benefit of [the parent].” Despite the debtor’s paying $3 million to the defendant, the trust argued that the debtor’s payment did not “preserve [the debtor’s] net worth, and [its] staying in business ultimately worsened [its] condition and made its creditors worse off.” Id.
The bankruptcy court, granting the defendant’s motion for summary judgment, held that the debtor had received “reasonably equivalent value” for two reasons: “(1) [It] received and used the satellite services; and (2) [the corporate parent] and the Debtor shared an identity of interests, such that any benefit [the parent] received under the contract also indirectly benefited the Debtor.” Id. at *2. The district court affirmed.
The Eleventh Circuit applied the constructive fraudulent transfer provisions of the Bankruptcy Code (the “Code”), Section 548(a)(1)(B), and the relevant section of the Florida Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act. Under both provisions, “a transfer of the debtor’s property … can be avoided if the debtor ‘received less than a reasonably equivalent value in exchange for such transfer’ and the debtor was insolvent at the time of the transfer.” 2015 WL 5167803, at *3, citing Code § 548(a)(1)(B)(i) & (ii)(I) and Fla. Stat. § 726.105(1)(b).
The parties stipulated as to the debtor’s insolvency, leaving only the issue of whether the debtor had received “reasonably equivalent value.” In particular, the court focused on the meaning of “value,” defined by Code Section 548(d)(2)(A) as “property, or satisfaction or securing of a present or antecedent debt of the debtor.” Id.
Courts generally hold that a debtor’s “payment of a third party’s obligation does not constitute value” when it receives nothing in return. In re Good Time Charley’s, Inc., 854 B.R. 157, 161 (Bankr. N.J. 1984) (“Any benefit to a third party is not factored into the fair consideration equation.”). “Thus, when a debtor transfers its property but the transferee gives the consideration to a third party, the debtor will not have received fair consideration in exchange for its property.” H.B.E. Leasing Corp. v. Frank, 48 F.3d 623, 638 (2d Cir. 1995). When the debtor does receive value, however, it may receive that value through a benefit conferred upon a third party. In re Image Worldwide, Ltd, 139 F.3d 574, 579-82 (7th Cir. 1998) (indirect benefits to debtor may be considered when determining whether it received reasonably equivalent value for guarantee); H.B.E. Leasing Corp., 48 F.3d at 639 (judgment debtor received fair consideration for its payments to attorneys for its co-defendants in RICO action; “multiple codefendants … threatened with joint and several liability … mounted a common defense, and one defendant paid the legal fees of the others”); Rubin, 661 F.2d at 991 (benefit to debtor may come indirectly through benefit to third party; key inquiry is whether net effect of transaction resulted in value to debtor’s estate); In re Abatement Envtl. Res. Inc., 102 Fed. Appx. 272, 277 (4th Cir. 2004) (fair consideration may exist when “the consideration given to the third person has ultimately landed in the debtor’s hands, or if the giving of the consideration to the third person otherwise confers an economic benefit upon the debtor”).
The Eleventh Circuit rejected the plaintiff trust’s argument that the debtor had not received value. First, the court construed “the term ‘value’ broadly … .”2015 WL 5167803,at *4, quoting In re Am. Hous. Found., 785 F.3d 143, 163 (5th Cir. 2015). Consistent with this broad understanding of value, courts have considered “whether the transfer confers an economic benefit upon the debtor, either directly or indirectly.’” Id. at *5, citing In re Rodriguez, 895 F.2d 725, 727 (11th Cir. 1990). In doing so, the Eleventh Circuit rejected the liquidation trust’s argument that had focused on whether the debtor received property rights or whether it was a party to the contract at issue. Id., citing In re N. Merch., Inc., 371 F.3d 1056, 1059 (9th Cir. 2004) (“Although Debtor was not a party to the … loan, it clearly received a benefit from that loan.”).
According to the Eleventh Circuit, its prior decision in Rodriguez “recognizes that a party may have received an ‘economic benefit’ for purposes of determining ‘reasonably equivalent value’ if it ‘share[s] in the enjoyment of or use[s] a good or service’. Id. at *6. Here, the debtor “was able to use the satellite services for which it paid, despite the fact that it was not obligated on” the contracts. Id. Also, because the debtor was able to “receive and use the full value of the satellite services” provided by the defendant, “the evidence shows that the Debtor indirectly benefited … by using these services it received.” Id. at *7.
The Eleventh Circuit in PSN was correct, for it closely reviewed the stipulated facts to focus on the economic reality, not the formal corporate structure. As the court recognized, the debtor received the benefits of its parent’s contract with the defendant, regardless of the transaction’s form.
Authored by Michael L. Cook .
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.
This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.
ARTICLE
October 7, 2015
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
October 7, 2015
Read time: 2 min
Dr. Thomas Gennert wrote this bylined article to examine a European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruling which held that a “safe harbor” rule governing safety of data transfer to the US was invalid, and that national data protection authorities must examine independently the extent to which the transfer of personal data to a third country complies with European data protection requirements. The Court’s ruling, Dr. Gennert wrote, “can have far reaching consequences for many cross-border businesses.
ARTICLE
October 7, 2015
Read time: 2 min
Tony Maida and T. Reed Stephens wrote this bylined article regarding two recent Justice Department settlements with healthcare systems that reflect the government’s Stark Law victory in the Tuomey case. The authors wrote that, in light of that case and the two other settlements, “The DOJ appears to advance an interpretation of the Stark Law that puts at risk vertically integrated health systems that treat a physician as a professional component cost of delivering a bundle of professional and facility/technical component services to patients and payors.” Read the full article.

ARTICLE
October 2015
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE
October 2015
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE
October 1, 2015
Read time: 2 min
Michael Peregrine and Joshua Buchman wrote this bylined article on the new Justice Department corporate conduct guidelines, noting that “these guidelines demonstrate a substantially increased government focus on individual accountability for corporate misconduct, and on corporate eligibility for cooperation credit in the context of government investigations,” and will impact the healthcare sector because “they extend to both criminal AND civil matters—an important consideration given the amount of False Claims Act enforcement activity in health care.”
ARTICLE
September/October 2015
Read time: 2 min
Todd Welty, Mark Thomas, and Kevin Spencer were authors of this bylined article assessing greater IRS efforts to seek documents or information revealing the tax advice given to a taxpayer, thus rejecting taxpayer privilege claims – whether attorney-client, tax practitioner, or work product. “With an increased demand for transparency, we expect more pressure to be placed upon whether information and documents are considered privileged,” the authors wrote. Read the full article.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
September 21, 2015
Read time: 8 min
As the end of 2015 approaches, financial regulators continue to emphasize the risk that poor cybersecurity poses to market integrity and financial stability, and to elaborate on the policies, procedures and controls they expect investment advisers, commodity pool operators and registered investment companies to have in place.
In January 2015, the Security and Exchange Commission’s Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations (“OCIE”) announced that cybersecurity compliance and controls would be a focus of its examinations in 2015. On Sept. 15, 2015, OCIE issued a Risk Alert providing additional information on its focus and noting that OCIE would be “testing to assess implementation of firm procedures and controls” for cybersecurity.[1] The Risk Alert also includes an appendix with a “sample list of information that [OCIE] may review” in examinations on cybersecurity matters.
Similarly, Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) Chairman Timothy Massad noted in his recent keynote speeches that cybersecurity has become “perhaps the single most important new risk to market integrity and financial stability”[2] and that the CFTC was working on a rule proposal related to cybersecurity.[3] On Aug. 28, 2015, the National Futures Association (“NFA”), the self-regulatory organization for the futures industry, submitted to the CFTC a proposed interpretive notice (the “NFA’s Proposal”) that would apply to NFA Compliance Rules 2-9, 2-36 and 2-49, which generally require firms to diligently supervise their employees and agents or their businesses.[4] The NFA’s Proposal provides cybersecurity guidance and focuses on areas similar to those in OCIE’s Risk Alert.
These recent pronouncements are largely extensions of past alerts and guidance,[5] and so will not surprise most registrants. Yet they provide additional detail on particular examples of reasonable security measures. The legal, compliance and information security officers of private and registered fund managers should review this guidance and determine whether additional measures within their organization are warranted.
The OCIE and the NFA guidance, read broadly and taken together, should force managers to — at a minimum — ensure that they are taking the following steps:
Compliance Tip: Managers without a written policy should act quickly to adopt a robust program, employing outside consultants if necessary. However, managers should be wary of wholesale adoption of an outside consultant’s cybersecurity program, as it may not be sufficiently tailored to the manager’s business and risks; active involvement in developing the program is needed to have an effective set of policies and procedures. To the extent that the SEC, the CFTC or the NFA have provided examples of specific elements that they expect to see in a Cybersecurity Policy (e.g., multifactor authentication, dynamic updating of personnel access rights, patch management practices, vulnerability scans and penetration testing), they should be carefully considered.
Compliance Tip: Meaningful involvement in oversight is likely to be expected by examiners; managers should be encouraging and documenting — in real time — a more active oversight role by senior personnel of the manager and fund directors. This may mean more briefings and meetings, and more costs, but managers should focus on fostering a culture of active involvement in and oversight of the cybersecurity program.
Compliance Tip: Many managers adopt policies that are well-designed to combat the risks facing the business on the date of adoption. Risk assessment (and responses), however, should be a continual interdisciplinary process; managers should not wait for the annual compliance review to reassess cybersecurity risks. Also, identified and prioritized threats and vulnerabilities should be matched to specific Cybersecurity Policy elements.
Compliance Tip: Managers should perform an information transfer channel inventory and analysis on a periodic basis and compare the volume of data transmitted (by channel) on a relative basis and over time. Corrective action should be taken to limit or close transmission channels that present an unnecessary or unacceptable risk of theft or loss.
Compliance Tip: Managers should be performing due diligence of vendors when they are selected, negotiating protections into vendor contracts related to access to firm networks or data, and monitoring vendors after they are on-boarded; this process should be documented. Managers should also ensure that they have “written contingency plans [with vendors] concerning … issues that might put the vendor out of business or in financial difficulty.”
Compliance Tip: Because examiners will be expecting to discuss incident responses, it is important to contemporaneously document each incident and the manager’s response. As this can be challenging for compliance personnel without extensive technical training or experience, it underscores the need to partner with the information security staff from as early a point in time as possible.
Compliance Tip: Managers should be aggressive in scheduling training sessions and in documenting their use and effectiveness. Thought should also be given to tailoring training by employee function and classification.
Authored by Brian T. Daly , Marc E. Elovitz , Robert R. Kiesel , Holly H. Weiss , Jacob Preiserowicz and Michael L. Yaeger .
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
[1] Securities and Exchange Commission, OCIE, “OCIE’s 2015 Cybersecurity Examination Initiative,” Vol. IV, Issue 8 (Sept. 15, 2015) (“Risk Alert”).
[2] Timothy Massad, Chairman, CFTC, Keynote Address Before the Futures Industry Association Boca Conference (March 11, 2015).
[3] Timothy Massad, Chairman, CFTC, Keynote Address Before the Beer Institute Annual Meeting (Sept. 9, 2015). Another CFTC commissioner, Sharon Bowen, suggested that bigger changes may lie ahead when she described “ideas that I think are worth considering if and when we propose a rule on improving system safeguards.” These ideas included: (1) requiring each registrant to designate a Chief Information Security Officer; (2) requiring registrants to file annual or quarterly reports on the state of their cybersecurity program; (3) requiring that registrants report any material cybersecurity event to the CFTC promptly (with an example of reports being made “within minutes of a significant breach”); and (4) requiring an independent audit or annual penetration testing for all registrants. Sharon Y. Bowen, Commissioner, CFTC, Keynote Address Before ISDA North America Conference (Sept. 17, 2015). While some of these proposals are consistent with current best practices, the reporting of any material event “within minutes” would be a new requirement for fund managers.
[4] NFA, National Futures Association: Information Systems Security Programs — Proposed Adoption of the Interpretive Notice to NFA Compliance Rules 2-9, 2-36 and 2-49: Information Systems Security Programs (Aug. 28, 2015) (the “NFA’s Proposal”).
[5] See, e.g., Securities and Exchange Commission, OCIE, Risk Alert: OCIE Cybersecurity Initiative (April 15, 2014), Appendix; SEC, Division of Investment Management, IM Guidance Update (April 2015), No. 2015-02.
This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.