Content Type: Article

  • Short Selling Update: New Disclosure Rules in Norway

    Short Selling Update: New Disclosure Rules in Norway

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Short Selling Update: New Disclosure Rules in Norway

    December 22, 2016

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Fund managers and investors should be aware that new Norwegian short selling rules are expected to come into force on 1 Jan. 2017 (the ‘New Rules’). The New Rules are Norway’s implementation of European Union (‘EU’) Regulation No 236/2012 on short selling and certain aspects of credit default swaps (the ‘Short Selling Regulation’).[1] This Alert provides a summary of the new short selling disclosure rules that fund managers and investors need to consider. Fund managers should be aware that EU regulators have, over the past two years, taken a number of enforcement actions against buy-side firms for breaches of disclosure obligations under the Short Selling Regulation (including in the case of missed or late filings).

    New Disclosure Obligations in Respect of Net Short Positions

    The New Rules will require an investor to notify the Norwegian Financial Supervisory Authority (‘NFSA’) privately when its net short position in a listed company’s shares crosses an initial threshold of 0.2 per cent of the share capital of the issuer. Additional notifications must be made when the position changes by 0.1 per cent in either direction. Reporting obligations will also apply in respect of net short positions in Norwegian sovereign debt. The European Commission has published detailed rules on the calculation of net short positions[2] under the Short Selling Regulation.

    Investors will also be required to make a public disclosure once their net short position in shares reaches an initial threshold of 0.5 per cent. Additional public disclosures must be made at each position change of 0.1 per cent, in either direction, until the position drops beneath the 0.5 per cent threshold.

    The New Rules require investors to calculate their net short position at midnight on the relevant trading day. Any notification or disclosure (as per the above) must be made, via an online Short Sale Register maintained by the NFSA, available at https://ssr.finanstilsynet.no (website active from 2 Jan. 2017), by no later than 15:30 local time on the following trading day after a change in net short position.

    Authored by Anna Maleva-Otto and Anthony Lombardi.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See our 5 Oct. 2012 Alert, ‘New European Rules on Short Selling — Effective 1 November 2012’.

    [2] Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 918/2012. See also our 5 Oct. 2012 Alert, ‘New European Rules on Short Selling — Effective 1 November 2012’.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Whistleblower Update: New Enforcement Actions for ‘Chilling’ Language in Severance Agreements

    SEC Whistleblower Update: New Enforcement Actions for ‘Chilling’ Language in Severance Agreements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / US POLICY

    SEC Whistleblower Update: New Enforcement Actions for ‘Chilling’ Language in Severance Agreements

    December 22, 2016

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) continues to actively enforce Rule 21F-17 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, which provides that “no person may take any action to impede an individual from communicating directly with the Commission staff about a possible securities law violation, including enforcing, or threatening to enforce, a confidentiality agreement … with respect to such communications.”[1] In its most recent actions, the SEC charged companies with violating Rule 21F-17 by including language in severance agreements that specifically prohibited former employees from communicating disparaging information about the company to the SEC and that prohibited former employees from voluntarily communicating with or contacting any governmental agency in connection with a complaint or investigation.

    On Dec. 19, 2016, the SEC announced an enforcement action against NeuStar, Inc., a Virginia-based technology company.[2] NeuStar entered into severance agreements with former employees containing a non-disparagement provision which prohibited former employees from engaging “in any communication that disparages, denigrates, maligns or impugns” the company. The language at issue specifically stated that such communications could not be made to “regulators” including the SEC. When the SEC began its investigation, NeuStar, on its own accord, removed the reference to “regulators” including the SEC, and added language specifying that nothing in the agreement prohibited the former employee from “communicating, without notice to or approval by NeuStar, with any federal government agency” about a potential violation of a federal law or regulation. These amendments were apparently sufficient to satisfy the SEC. NeuStar agreed to make reasonable efforts to inform former employees who signed the severance agreements between Aug. 12, 2011 (the date Rule 21F-17 became effective) and the date of the amendments. NeuStar also agreed to pay a civil monetary penalty of $180,000.

    On Dec. 20, 2016, the SEC announced a settlement in an enforcement action against SandRidge Energy, Inc., an oil and natural gas exploration and production company headquartered in Oklahoma City.[3] As with NeuStar, SandRidge entered into severance agreements with former employees that contained non-disparagement provisions that prohibited former employees from making any disparaging remarks or statements to any “governmental or regulatory agency.” In addition, SandRidge’s form severance agreement prohibited employees from disclosing confidential or proprietary information to governmental agencies without SandRidge’s consent and from assisting or contacting any governmental agency in connection with a complaint or investigation. The SEC determined that these provisions violated Rule 21F-17. In response to the SEC’s investigation, SandRidge revised its form agreement and advised former employees that the problematic provisions were no longer in effect. SandRidge also added a provision to its form agreement stating that nothing in the agreement was intended to prohibit employees from reporting violations of law to governmental agencies.

    In light of the SEC’s actions, employers should review employment and separation agreements, as well as employment and compliance policies and codes of conduct and ensure that they do not contain any contractual or policy provisions that may be interpreted to run afoul of Rule 21F-17, without express carve-outs. Any prohibition or restriction on communications with individuals outside a firm, whether concerning confidential information, disparaging information or general communications with third parties, which does not include a specific carve-out for communications with the SEC without prior notice to the employer, may violate Rule 21F-17.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Holly H. Weiss, Aaron S. Farovitch, and Adam B. Gartner.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Holly H. Weiss

    Retired Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam B. Gartner

    Special Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • CMS Releases Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice Form

    CMS Releases Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice Form

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Releases Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice Form

    December 21, 2016

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    On December 8, 2016, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) published the Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice (MOON), which educates Medicare beneficiaries on the effect of outpatient status, particularly as it pertains to cost-sharing requirements and skilled nursing facility (SNF) eligibility. The MOON was published by CMS to implement the Notice of Observation Treatment and Implication for Care Eligibility Act (the NOTICE Act), which was enacted on August 6, 2015. The NOTICE Act seeks to eliminate any surprises Medicare beneficiaries might experience after (1) receiving large out-of-pocket costs for a hospital stay in which they received outpatient observation services but were not admitted as inpatients, and (2) learning that time spent under observation does not count toward their eligibility for SNF coverage.

    Beginning on March 8, 2017, hospitals and critical access hospitals must provide the MOON to Medicare beneficiaries receiving observation services as an outpatient for more than 24 hours. The MOON must be provided no later than 36 hours from the time the beneficiary begins receiving outpatient observation services (or, if sooner, upon release). The MOON must be accompanied by an oral explanation of the information in the form and must be signed by the beneficiary or the beneficiary’s representative. Failure to provide the MOON to applicable beneficiaries is considered a violation of the hospital’s Medicare provider agreement and could result in termination of the hospital’s Medicare provider agreement.

    Hospitals should ensure they understand the NOTICE Act requirements and implement applicable policies and procedures for MOON compliance prior to March 8, 2017.

    A copy of the MOON is available from CMS’s website.

    Authors

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Monica Wallace

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Recent CFTC Rule Changes That Affect Hedge and Private Equity Fund Managers

    Recent CFTC Rule Changes That Affect Hedge and Private Equity Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Recent CFTC Rule Changes That Affect Hedge and Private Equity Fund Managers

    December 21, 2016

    Read time: 18 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In recent weeks, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission has issued several final rules and rule proposals that directly affect hedge fund managers that trade in futures contracts (and in other commodity interests) and private equity fund managers with portfolio companies that may, as part of a hedging or raw materials acquisition effort, engage in commodity interest transactions. All fund managers should review these changes to determine if they present limitations on their business or require regulatory relief filings; registered commodity pool operators and commodity trading advisors, of course, should review all of the developments discussed in this Alert.

    Expanded Position Limits

    On Dec. 5, 2016, the CFTC reproposed rules that would, if adopted, expand the scope of the existing federal position limits regime for exchange-traded futures contracts (the “Reproposal”).[1]

    CFTC rules currently impose position limits for nine futures and commodity options contracts (the “Legacy Contracts”). In 2011, the CFTC adopted rules to expand the position limits regime beyond the Legacy Contracts, but these rules were quickly vacated — on technical grounds — by a federal district court. In 2013, the CFTC again put forth a proposal for expanded position limits and most recently supplemented that proposal in May 2016. No final rule was adopted, however, and the CFTC issued the Reproposal earlier this month based on public comment and related reviews by the CFTC Staff.

    The Reproposal, if adopted, would:

    • Establish federal limits on speculative positions in 25 core physical commodity futures contracts (the actual numerical limits were set by the CFTC based on statistical analyses of the normal trading levels for futures and other referenced contracts in actual trading);
    • Require their economically equivalent “referenced contracts” (i.e., options and swaps) to count towards such limits; and
    • Clarify and, in some ways, expand the use of the “bona-fide hedging” position limits exemption.

    The Reproposal also requested comments on the possibility of delaying the compliance date of any final rule to Jan. 3, 2018 (which would align CFTC position limits rules with new EU position limits rules scheduled to go into effect on that date).

    While the Reproposal could represent an important expansion of the CFTC’s direct role in the markets, it will fall to the CFTC commissioners, and especially the new chairman, who are appointed by the new presidential administration to finalize these changes. While it is quite possible that the CFTC will revisit, modify or even abandon the Reproposal, in the interim, all fund managers that trade in the futures markets should review the new position limits to determine whether they, if adopted, would negatively affect their trading and investment program. Of course, any fund manager that seeks to rely on the hedging exemption should also review the changes to that exemption contained in the Reproposal.

    Fund managers should also be cognizant of the fact that the U.S. futures exchanges maintain their own position limits on non-Legacy Contracts pursuant to CFTC Rule 150, which are and will remain effective no matter what happens to the Reproposal.

    New Aggregation Rules Effective Feb. 14, 2017

    On Dec. 5, 2016, the CFTC did finalize rules concerning position limits aggregation, i.e., rules determining which positions and accounts must be aggregated when determining compliance with position limit rules. While all fund managers that trade futures contracts should be aware of the upcoming changes, this change may also affect fund managers that do not trade commodity interests but hold 10-percent or greater ownership interests in portfolio companies that themselves engage in commodity interests transactions (such as private equity fund managers, activist investors and high-conviction hedge fund managers).

    Background on the Aggregation Rules Amendment

    CFTC Rule 150.4 has traditionally required several categories of related entities to aggregate their Legacy Contract holdings for purposes of calculating compliance with CFTC position limits. In 2012, the CFTC, as part of its overall position limits rulemaking efforts, amended and expanded its aggregation rules,[2] but those new rules were quashed by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association district court case referenced above in the position limits discussion. In 2013[3] and in 2015,[4] the CFTC re-proposed amendments to its aggregation rules and, on Dec. 5, 2016, adopted new final rules on aggregation (the “New Aggregation Rule”).[5]

    Overall Impact of the New Aggregation Rule

    The New Aggregation Rule will have several impacts on the futures markets, including the following:

    • A “control” relationship that requires aggregation now will be deemed to exist where there is “substantially similar” trading;
    • The introduction of several new aggregation exemptions and the issuance of additional guidance on certain existing exemptions; and
    • New aggregation exemption notice requirements.

    Because, as discussed above, the new position limits rules were not finalized, the New Aggregation Rule currently only applies to Legacy Contracts (although it would extend to new limits and new instruments if and when adopted). The New Aggregation Rule is, however, likely to be adopted in some form by the various exchanges, which — among other things — could cause the new federal notice requirement to be replicated on the exchange level.[6]

    Extension of the Control Concept to “Substantially Identical” Trading

    Rule 150.4 has historically required aggregation where a control relationship exists and, in the adopting release for the New Aggregation Rule, the CFTC reiterated its historical position: (i) that a “control” relationship generally will still require aggregation, and (ii) that control can be evidenced by a 10-percent or greater ownership position.

    Under the New Aggregation Rule, however, the CFTC now will also require aggregation on the basis of “substantially identical” trading. Under the rule, a person (the “aggregating person”) will now need to aggregate with its own commodity interest positions all commodity interest positions:

    • Held by another person but that are deemed to be controlled by the aggregating person (e.g., where the aggregating person makes trading decisions for another person);
    • Held by another person acting pursuant to an express or implied agreement with the aggregating person;
    • Held in an account (other than a fund) in which the aggregating person has a 10-percent or greater ownership interest;
    • Held by a fund: (i) in which the aggregating person is a 25-percent or larger investor, and (ii) that is managed by a commodity pool operator that is exempt from registration pursuant to CFTC Rule 4.13; and
    • That another person directly or indirectly (e.g., through an investment in a fund operated by an unaffiliated commodity pool operator) holds within a trading strategy that is “substantially identical” to a trading strategy overseen by the aggregating person.

    In addition, the New Aggregation Rule expressly provides that the “substantially identical trading” provision will override the various aggregation exemptions discussed below.

    New Aggregation Exemptions and Notice Requirements

    Following the adoption of the New Aggregation Rule, there are five CFTC aggregation exemptions available to fund managers.[7] Three of these predated and were preserved by the New Aggregation Rule, i.e., (i) the “independent account controller” exemption (which would still require some aggregation during the “spot month” ),[8] (ii) the “fund investor” exemption,[9] and (iii) the “insider” fund investor exemption,[10] while these two are new:

    • The owned-entity exemption, and
    • The information sharing exemption.

    Under the New Aggregation Rule, to claim any of these exemptions (other than the “fund investor” exemption) a manager is required to make a filing with the CFTC. This is a departure from prior practice and one that all fund managers should consider as soon as possible.

    Managers should also note that a CFTC filing is not necessarily sufficient for an exemption at the futures exchange level and that a filing with or approval from each applicable exchange may be required.

    The new “owned-entity exemption” is available for a 10-percent or greater owner of a subsidiary, so long as certain physical and informational barriers are in place between the subsidiary and the parent. The CFTC also provided a new exemption from aggregation (the “information sharing exemption “) in situations where there is an inference of control, but the parties involved can reasonably assert (in a memorandum of law provided to the CFTC) that: (i) sharing such information would create a “reasonable risk” of a violation of law, and (ii) there is no actual sharing of futures trading or position information.

    Independent Account Controller Exemption

    The CFTC independent account controller exemption (the “IAC”) permits a firm to disaggregate trading units within the same firm from each other, provided that certain conditions are met and that the firm continues to aggregate during the spot month. This CFTC exemption is relevant to Legacy Contracts and to non-Legacy Contracts traded on futures exchanges whose own IAC exemption mirrors that of the CFTC.

    To claim an IAC exemption, a manager must be able to demonstrate that:

    • There are appropriate physical and informational barriers between trading units;[11] and
    • Certain definitional requirements must be met: i.e., the firm seeking the exemption must be an “eligible entity” (e.g., a commodity trading advisor) and each trading unit must have an “independent account controller” (i.e., certain categories of CFTC registrants and their registered associated persons). Nevertheless, the IAC exemption still does not extend to all categories of traders; for example, proprietary trading firms and non-CFTC registrants may not be able to utilize an IAC. Funds of funds and multi-manager funds should also consider whether it is necessary or even possible to rely on this exemption.

    Fund managers relying on IACs will need to make formal notice filings with the CFTC by Feb. 14, 2017 (the “Effective Date”). They will also need to inquire with each of the futures exchanges that they trade on to ascertain what, if any, filings are required to perfect an exchange-level IAC.

    While the CFTC did not make any substantive changes to the IAC in the New Aggregation Rule, it did make some technical revisions that expand its application slightly.[12]

    Owned-Entity Exemption

    The owned-entity exemption may be a useful exemption for some fund managers, especially for fund managers that do not traditionally trade futures. In particular, private equity funds that invest in operating entities that trade or hedge with futures contracts may be able to establish an aggregation exemption under the owned-entity exemption.

    Aggregation Exemption Filings

    The CFTC confirmed that the owner of an entity that files an exemption (i.e., the “higher-tier” entity) will be able to rely on the aggregation exemption filing of that entity without having to make its own filing and without needing to be mentioned in the filing. For example, if a fund makes a notice filing to rely on the owned-entity exemption with respect to the fund’s acquisition of an entity, an investor in the fund that is required to aggregate the positions of that fund (i.e., a 25-percent investor in a Rule 4.13 fund), will not need to make a separate filing to disaggregate the positions of that entity. The CFTC also clarified that “sister affiliates” under common control generally are not required to aggregate.[13]

    CFTC Form 40 Changes

    In November 2013, the CFTC finalized rules that made significant changes to many of its “large trader” reporting forms. While these rules made changes to several CFTC forms, buy-side firms are primarily affected by changes to the Form 40. The Form 40 is only required to be filed upon request by the CFTC; when a trader crosses certain reportable thresholds (which may differ contract by contract), the CFTC may choose to send a Form 40 request to the trader. Historically, such thresholds were only in place for futures contracts and were only quantity thresholds. The Form 40 has added “volume” thresholds and is now also applicable to swaps. These changes have already been in effect for a while. The most significant aspect of the November 2013 rule only went into effect in November; the Form 40: (i) has now been modified to require additional information, (ii) must be filed electronically, and (iii) requires a filer to update the form should information change after filing.

    While a Form 40 is only required upon request, traders should be prepared in advance to file the new form; once the CFTC sends a request, a filing will need to be made by the deadline requested by the CFTC. Potential filers should also be prepared to answer many of the new questions relating to ownership structure (i.e., parent companies and subsidiaries), accounts controlled by the trader, as well as the names of specific individuals that have authority to trade or authority to oversee traders. The new questions with respect to ownership structure also align with the CFTC rules concerning aggregation of accounts for purposes of position limits (as discussed in “New Aggregation Rules Effective Feb. 14, 2017” above); these are questions that were historically not asked by the CFTC. Thus, traders who are not familiar with the CFTC requirements concerning which accounts to aggregate should refocus on this requirement before being required to file to ensure that the correct calculations are being done. To the extent possible, traders should also try to familiarize themselves with the CFTC portal so that they are prepared for the electronic filing.

    Registered Commodity Pool Operator Reporting Requirements

    “Long” First Fiscal Year Financial Statement Relief

    On Nov. 21, 2016 the CFTC issued final rules[14] allowing registered CPOs to defer the annual financial statement filing requirement for a new fund to the end of the first full calendar year of operation (the “Final Rule”). Historically, fund managers have been able to obtain relief allowing for up to an 18-month extended first fiscal year, generally with no restriction on the size of the fund. The November relief allows funds, without the need for an individual request, to utilize an extended first fiscal year so long as:

    • The extended fiscal year is no longer than 16 months (i.e., the fund launches no earlier than Sept. 1);
    • During the stub year (i.e., the first one to four months), the fund receives investments from “non-insiders” of no more than $3 million from no more than 15 investors; and
    • The CPO receives unanimous consent to an extended fiscal year from all non-insider investors in the form of a separate waiver signature page that contains specific language provided by the CFTC.Fund managers looking to rely on the Final Rule should be aware of the specific consent requirements of the Final Rule so that an additional signature page that complies with the Final Rule can be included with fund subscription documents.

    While this relief may be utilized by certain managers, the new restrictions of this rule that were historically not required by CFTC staff, particularly, the $3 million restriction, will severely limit the usefulness of this new rule. Furthermore, extended fiscal year relief has primarily been utilized by non-U.S.-based managers that are not SEC-registered investment advisers. Fund managers that are also registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission and that seek to comply with the “audit exception” under the Custody Rule will need to consider whether this relief is compatible with the fund manager’s Custody Rule compliance.

    In addition, in the event that a fund relying on this relief does not complete its first fiscal year, the CPO will nonetheless be required to file final audited financials with the NFA.

    CPO-PQR Changes

    Parallel Managed Accounts (February 2017)

    CPOs should also be aware of changes to the CPO-PQR going into effect for the fourth quarter 2016 filing (due in February or March 2017). As a general rule, managed accounts are not reported on the CPO-PQR; they are only reported by registered CTAs in the Form CTA-PR. In November 2015, the CFTC provided additional guidance regarding when “parallel managed accounts” nonetheless need to be reported on CPO-PQR as part of its parallel fund.[15] At that time, CFTC staff provided temporary relief from the requirement,[16] but that relief has expired; a CPO’s next filing will require it to aggregate any parallel managed accounts and consider it part of the parallel fund. While the requirement is not applicable for “relationship” questions (i.e., pool custodians, brokers), it is required for most of the rest of the form.

    CPOs should be considering whether they are impacted, particularly since the CFTC’s approach with parallel managed accounts differs from the SEC’s Form PF approach. First, the CFTC does not make a distinction between dependent parallel managed accounts and other managed accounts; all parallel managed accounts are affected. Second, the Form PF only requires counting managed accounts for purposes of the threshold asset under management questions to determine how much of the Form PF must be completed. Conversely, the CFTC requires parallel managed accounts to be considered for all (non-relationship) questions, not just the threshold asset under management questions. Thus, a CPO will be required to answer the CPO-PQR questions as if the pool is the size of the assets of the pool and the managed account(s) combined. This may be somewhat difficult for fund managers, particularly in situations where there is a different administrator for the fund and any parallel managed accounts.

    It is also worth noting that the different methods of calculating assets under management may result in different levels of reporting on the CPO-PQR from the Form PF. For example, a CPO with a parallel managed account that is not dependent would be required to count such account for CPO-PQR purposes, but not for Form PF. This could result in such a CPO being considered a “large filer” for CPO-PQR, but not for Form PF.

    Financial Ratios Reporting for CPO and CTA Entities (August 2017)

    Starting with the CPO-PQR and CTA-PR second quarter 2017 filings (due in August 2017), the NFA will, for the first time, require firms to provide certain financial information at the management company level (as opposed to client-level information typically asked for in those forms). Starting with that filing, the NFA will require firms to provide two ratios: (i) current assets/current liabilities as of quarter-end; and (ii) total revenue/total expenses for the prior 12 months. Filers will be able to elect to report the ratios at a parent company level. The NFA also clarified that this does not mean they are imposing any minimum financial ratio requirements; rather, the NFA will use these ratios as part of its regulatory oversight program of CPOs and CTAs.

    Use of Alternative Accounting Standards

    The CFTC generally requires use of U.S. GAAP for purposes of the audited financial statements and the CPO-PQR, although CFTC Rule 4.22(d)(2) permits the CPO of a pool organized outside the U.S. to use IFRS. The CFTC has now expanded this rule to codify previous CFTC staff relief and to permit a fund organized outside of the U.S. to use the accounting principles, standards or practices followed in the United Kingdom, Ireland, Luxembourg or Canada.[17] This will also be permitted for CPO-PQR.

    The CFTC’s approach regarding the use of IFRS has historically differed from the SEC’s approach with respect to the custody rule audit requirement; while the SEC relief is based on the location of the fund manager, the CFTC relief is based on the location of the fund. The CFTC’s approach can be problematic for a non-U.S. fund manager with a U.S-based fund. For example, a “master-feeder” structure that includes a U.S.-based feeder fund would be unable to utilize IFRS (or any of the other non-U.S. accounting standards now permitted by the CFTC) for the U.S. feeder fund. While we have previously been granted relief for clients to use IFRS for a U.S.-based fund (provided that it included a reconciliation to U.S. GAAP), the Final Rule did not codify this relief. Fund managers wishing to take this approach would continue to be required to request such relief from CFTC staff.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Jacob Preiserowicz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Position Limits for Derivatives: Reproposal (Dec. 5, 2016).

    [2] Aggregation, Position Limits for Futures and Swaps, 77 Fed. Reg. 31767 (May 30, 2012).

    [3] Aggregation of Positions; Proposed Rule, 78 Fed. Reg. 68946 (Nov. 15, 2013).

    [4] Aggregation of Positions, 80 Fed. Reg. 58365 (Sept. 29, 2015).

    [5] Aggregation of Positions, 81 Fed. Reg. 91454 (Dec. 16, 2016).

    [6] While the futures exchanges have some flexibility with respect to implementing aggregation rules and exemptions that apply to contracts traded on each respective exchange (that are not Legacy Contracts), they tend to generally track the CFTC rules, with some exceptions, as discussed below.

    [7] The CFTC also provides aggregation exemptions not applicable to fund managers, such as exemptions for broker-dealers and futures commission merchants.

    [8] The independent account controller exemption permits a firm to disaggregate trading units within the same firm from each other, provided that certain conditions are met.

    [9] As a general rule, passive fund investors that are not affiliated with the fund manager are not required to aggregate the positions of the fund, even when above 10 percent, but this exemption is not available where: (i) the investor holds more than 25 percent of a fund for which the CPO relies on a Rule 4.13 exemption from registration, and (ii) where the new “substantially identical” aggregation requirement applies.

    [10] This exemption is available where the fund investor is also an “insider” (e.g., a principal or affiliate of the commodity pool operator) but certain physical and informational barriers are erected.

    [11] These criteria did not change significantly. A firm that is disaggregating affiliated trading units will need to demonstrate that there are written procedures precluding access to information across trading units, and that each trading unit has a separately developed trading system and is marketed separately.

    [12] The CFTC added general partner, managing member or manager of an exempt or excluded CPO to the definition of “Eligible Entity.” It also now only requires aggregation during the spot month for physically settled contracts, a change that will only impact the IAC exemptions of futures exchanges that reference the CFTC rules.

    [13] However, their parent company may still need to utilize the owned-entity exemption.

    [14] Commodity Pool Operator Financial Reports, 81 FR 85147 (Nov. 25, 2016).

    [15] CFTC Division of Swap Dealer and Intermediary Oversight Responds to Frequently Asked Questions Regarding Commission Form CPO-PQR.

    [16] CFTC Letter No. 16-22 (Feb. 26, 2016).

    [17] See Commodity Pool Operator Financial Reports at note 17.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • FAA 20153301F’s Unfounded Recharacterization of Services Income as Sales Income for Subpart F Purposes

    ARTICLE

    FAA 20153301F’s Unfounded Recharacterization of Services Income as Sales Income for Subpart F Purposes

    December 20, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Lowell Yoder wrote this bylined article on IRS Field Attorney Advice which recharacterized referral fees earned by a controlled foreign corporation (CFC) as Subpart F sales income rather than services income. Mr. Yoder asserted that “the IRS’s analysis is untethered from the governing statute and regulations and as such is fundamentally flawed.”

    In depth
    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Don’t Ignore IRS Formal Document Requests

    ARTICLE

    Don’t Ignore IRS Formal Document Requests

    December 20, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Andrew Roberson and Joshua McConkey wrote this bylined article on the Formal Document Request (FDR) procedures used by the IRS in business audits. The authors cautioned that “taxpayers receiving an FDR should formulate a response within the FDR response period to avoid any potential exclusionary rule effects over foreign-based taxpayer material that might damages their case in a later litigation.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Tenth Circuit Quashes Fraudulent Transfer Suit Against Asset Buyer

    Tenth Circuit Quashes Fraudulent Transfer Suit Against Asset Buyer

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Tenth Circuit Quashes Fraudulent Transfer Suit Against Asset Buyer

    December 19, 2016

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    An undersecured mortgagee’s “release of [its entire underlying claim] was value obtained ‘in exchange for’ the [pre-bankruptcy] sale of the [debtor’s] property,” held the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit on Dec. 6, 2016. In re Expert South Tulsa LLC, 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 21704, at *11 (10th Cir. Dec. 6, 2016). The Tenth Circuit flatly rejected the debtor’s attempt “to set aside as a fraudulent transfer its own sale of real estate that was encumbered by a mortgage far exceeding the sale price.” Id. at *1. Affirming the lower courts, the court stressed the extraordinary value to the debtor of the undersecured lender’s “dismiss[al] with prejudice [of] its claims under the mortgage and the mortgage note.” Id. at *9.

    Relevance

    A number of appellate courts have, within the past year, analyzed “value” in the fraudulent transfer context. See, e.g., In re PSN USA, Inc., 615 F. App’x 925 (11th Cir. 2015) (insolvent corporate subsidiary’s payment of parent’s contractual obligations not a fraudulent transfer when “the [subsidiary] Debtor received reasonably equivalent value in exchange for [its cash] transfers.”); Janvey v. Golf Channel, Inc., 487 S.W. 3d 560 (Tex. 2016) (“reasonably equivalent value” as defense to fraudulent transfer suit “can be satisfied with evidence that the transferee (1) fully performed under a lawful, arm’s-length contract for fair market value, (2) provided consideration that had objective value at the time of the transaction, and (3) made the exchange in the ordinary course of the transferee’s business … . [V]alue is value regardless of whether the debtor is insolvent … .”); Janvey v. Golf Channel, Inc., 834 F.3d 570, 573 (5th Cir. 2016) (affirmed dismissal of receiver’s fraudulent transfer suit against advertising firm for $5.9 million received in good faith from Ponzi scheme debtor; district court found debtor had received market value of advertising services and that defendant “looks more like an innocent trade creditor  …  .”).

    “Value,” for purposes of Bankruptcy Code (“Code”) § 548, “means property, or satisfaction or securing of a present or antecedent debt of the debtor … .” A trial court’s finding of value is a factual matter. In re Fruehauf Trailer, 444 F.3d 203, 214 (3rd Cir. 2006) (plaintiff must prove that value of intangible benefit is zero); 1756 W. Lake St LLC v. Am. Chartered Bank, 787 F.3d 383, 387 (7th Cir. 2015) (court approximated value of benefit); Creditors’ Comm. of Jumer’s Castle Dodge v. Jumer, 472 F.3d 943, 947 (7th Cir. 2007) (court must “determine the value of what was transferred and … compare it to what was received.”). When the transferee is a creditor, the debtor receives value for the transfer only if it satisfies part or all of the transferee-creditor’s claim against the debtor. Id.

    Facts

    The debtor owned a parcel of real estate subject to a $7.75-million mortgage and other liens totaling roughly $500,000. After defaulting on the mortgage loan, the debtor chose to find a buyer for the property rather than defend a foreclosure action brought by the mortgagee. It eventually found a buyer, C, who paid $3 million “contingent on delivery of free and clear title.” At the closing, the purchase price was distributed as follows: $1.74 million to the mortgagee; $115,000 to other lienholders; $686,000 to the debtor’s unsecured creditors; and $261,000 to the debtor. C then sold the property “for $4.4 million only eleven days after closing,” a troubling fact for the debtor. 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 21704, Id. at *3.

    An unpaid creditor later forced the debtor into bankruptcy involuntarily, but the debtor promptly converted the case to Chapter 11 and sued C to avoid the property sale, alleging a fraudulent transfer because it had “not receive[d] reasonably equivalent value for the property.” Id. at *4. The bankruptcy court granted summary judgment dismissing the debtor’s suit and the Tenth Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel affirmed.

    Tenth Circuit Analysis

    The debtor asserted “two claims of fraudulent or constructively fraudulent transfer against” C under federal and state law. Id. at *4. Both claims “require that a transfer of property by [the debtor] have been for less than reasonably equivalent value.” Id. See Code § 548(a)(1)(B) (transfer voidable if made “within two years before the filing of the bankruptcy petition” and the debtor “received less than a ‘reasonably equivalent value’ in exchange for the transfer” while insolvent).

    Test for Determining Value

    Noting that “fraudulent-transfer statutes are for the protection of unsecured creditors,” the court “measure[d] the value received in terms of the effect on those creditors.” Id. at *5. Significantly, “value” includes more than the exchange of cash, but also includes “satisfaction … of a present or antecedent debt of the debtor.” Id. at *6, citing Code § 548(d)(2)(A) and Oklahoma’s Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act. When a debt is extinguished, reasoned the court, “the remaining creditors benefit because the satisfied creditor is no longer competing for the debtor’s property.” Id.

    Application of Law to Facts

    The debtor here not only received part of the $3-million purchase price from the sale, but also obtained the “release of the more than $6 million it would still owe on the mortgage loan.” Id. at *7. According to the Tenth Circuit, “it is obvious that Debtor received at least reasonably equivalent value for the property if the obligation was released (the amount due on the note, $7.75 million, is more than reasonably equivalent to $4.99 million [the property’s asserted value]) … .” Id. Nor could there be any question that the debtor had been released. “The mortgagee ended the litigation by filing a dismissal with prejudice, stating that it ‘hereby dismisses all claims or counterclaims, against all other parties, with prejudice.’” Id. The dismissal thus released the debtor from all of its obligations on the mortgage. Id. at *8. When the mortgagee “dismissed its claims with prejudice, it … was barred from litigating them later.” Id. at *9-*10.

    The court also dismissed the debtor’s argument that the mortgagee’s release of its debt was not “‘in exchange for’ the property it sold,” and, therefore, not value received as “part of the deal.” Id. at *10. Finding that “extinguishment of the debt” was simultaneous with the rest of the deal and no reasonable factfinder could find that the extinguishment was an act of generosity divorced from the overall deal, the court concluded “[s]imply put, the sale was undoubtedly a but-for cause of the extinguishment of the debt.” Id. at *10-11.

    Comment

    The debtor’s suit was based on envy. The debtor may have regretted the sale of its property for $3 million when the buyer promptly resold it for almost a 50-percent profit, but it overlooked what it received — the release of a $7.75-million claim plus $261,000 in cash. That was enough and more than “reasonably equivalent.”

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Twilight of the Deferred Fees: Planning for 2017

    Twilight of the Deferred Fees: Planning for 2017

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Twilight of the Deferred Fees: Planning for 2017

    December 19, 2016

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In 2008, President George W. Bush signed into law the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 (H.R. 1424), which, among other things, effectively ended the ability of most investment fund managers to defer fees they earned from the offshore funds they managed by virtue of the introduction of Section 457A into the U.S. Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the “Code”). That legislation, however, grandfathered deferred fees earned for services rendered prior to 2009, provided that such amounts were included in the managers’ income no later than calendar year 2017.[1]

    Eight years later, many managers still have significant amounts of pre-2009 deferred fees owing to them that are payable in the next 12-13 months. Below are certain tax and other considerations of which managers should take note as they plan for the inevitable end of the deferral era.

    Section 409A

    Pre-2009 fees that have been deferred by managers using the cash method of tax accounting (i.e., almost all such deferred fees) are still subject to Section 409A of the Code. Managers should review their deferral elections and make sure that payment is made at the times provided for in their plans and elections or discuss with their advisers as to whether any modifications are permissible.[2] Failure to comply with Section 409A of the Code can lead to an additional tax equal to 20 percent of the entire amount deferred, as well as additional interest on the amount deferred going back to the tax return due date for the initial year of deferral. Moreover, any deferred fee agreements that are part of a “back-to-back” arrangement need to be operated such that both the payment by the fund to the manager and the related distribution or payment by the manager to its partners and employees comply with Section 409A of the Code.

    Side Pockets

    Deferred fees that are indexed to the performance of a fund may be partially indexed to side pockets. While an investor in the fund generally cannot voluntarily redeem from a side pocket, the manager still must be paid the value of the deferral that is indexed to the side pocket, i.e., the manager cannot treat itself from a payment timing standpoint the way it would a shareholder. The manager should be prepared to: (i) be paid such amounts in kind, including in the form of shares of the fund that track the side pocket (see also “Payment in Kind” below), and (ii) pay full U.S. federal, state and local income tax on that value even though the manager is not being paid in cash.

    Size of Deferral/Portfolio Management

    Managers should start planning now, if they have not already done so, how to pay the deferred fees on time. The fund will generally need to liquidate assets or use available cash to pay out the deferred fees, so consideration should be given to what impact that will have on the fund’s portfolio. If the deferred fees represent a significant portion of the fund, for example, the manager may want to consider gradually changing how the deferred fees are indexed. Many deferred fee agreements allow the manager, with the fund’s consent and at predetermined times, to elect to have its fees indexed to other assets.

    For example, if as of Dec. 1, 2016, the deferred fees represented 25 percent of the fund’s gross assets, the fund’s cash accounts were generally de minimis and the fees were due to be paid on Dec. 31, 2017, the manager might consider electing to index a portion of those fees to treasury bills or other cash-equivalent assets over time (e.g., 5 percent on each of Jan. 1, 2017, April 1, 2017, July 1, 2017 and Oct. 1, 2017, or use some other pre-set formula) rather than cashing out 25 percent of the fund’s managed portfolio at the end of 2017.

    Another situation certain managers should consider addressing is what to do with the indexing of the deferred fees if the fund is in liquidation. As an example, assume that a manager had previously elected Dec. 1, 2017 as the payment date for its deferred fees, but that the fund is in liquidation as of Jan. 1, 2017 and is paying out its investors as and when it monetizes its remaining positions. Under the deferral agreement and Section 409A of the Code, the manager generally may not be paid until the earlier of Dec. 1, 2017 and the termination of the manager’s services to the fund (e.g., if the liquidation were complete).[3] If no change to the indexing were made, the deferral may automatically become indexed to a smaller number of remaining, presumably illiquid assets. Instead, the manager may desire to elect, with the fund’s consent, to have the portion of its deferred fees that would otherwise have been paid to it had the manager been a shareholder of the fund indexed to treasury bills as and when shareholders are paid.

    In addition, as payment is not considered late under Section 409A of the Code if it is paid by the end of the calendar year in which the elected distribution date occurs, a manager may agree with the fund to delay a 2017 scheduled payment date to later in 2017[4] in order to give the fund more time to liquidate positions or for other reasons.

    Payment in Kind

    A payment in kind may be a desirable approach for a fund where the manager either does not wish to liquidate substantial assets or is not able to monetize particular positions to pay the deferred fees out in cash. As a result, a payment in the form of shares of the fund may be necessary to satisfy the requirement that the fees be paid in a timely manner under Section 409A of the Code, in which case the manager should consider whether a “qualified electing fund” election is available and, if so, desirable.[5] If the fund is part of a master-feeder structure (including a “mini-master” structure), where the master fund is treated as a partnership for U.S. tax purposes, the fund may be able to pay the manager some or all of its deferred fees in the form of an interest in the master fund. Given that the manager will be taxed on the full value of the fees due, if the master fund has unrealized appreciation in its assets at the time of the payment of the deferred fees, the manager would be taxed in the year(s) when the master fund realizes gains on those assets even if there has been no subsequent increase in the value of the master fund’s assets. Managers who are in this situation may want to consider whether it would be feasible to make an election under Section 754 of the Code at the master fund level, which would avoid the manager’s picking up additional tax in that situation.

    Investor Relations

    The partners and employees of the managers will be taxed on the payment of the deferred fees, which could exceed 50 percent of the deferred fees paid depending on where the individual is resident. However, managers should be prepared to answer investor inquiries regarding what they plan to do with the remainder of such amounts. Managers who had treated their deferred compensation as a way of aligning their interests in the fund with those of their investors may wish to continue doing so through investing such after-tax amounts in a parallel fund or, if applicable, receiving payment of a portion of the deferred fees in kind in the form of master fund interests (as described in “Payment in Kind” above). Moreover, each manager should consider whether the payment of the deferred fees and corresponding reduction in the offshore fund’s gross assets (assuming incoming subscriptions do not offset such reduction) is something to address in an investor communication, e.g., a periodic investor letter.

    Authored by Philippe Benedict, Shlomo C. Twerski and David S. Griffel.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] In the rare circumstance where a manager had subjected itself to a substantial risk of forfeiture that required its continued provision of substantial services to receive the fee, the deferral could have lasted through such later year beyond 2017 if such risk still existed at such later time.

    [2] For example, if a payment had previously been elected to be made on Jan. 1, 2017, a violation of Section 409A of the Code generally would not occur if the payment were instead made on July 1, 2017. However, a payment that was previously elected to be made on July 1, 2017 would generally violate Section 409A of the Code if it were made on Jan. 1, 2017.

    [3] If there were a “back-to-back arrangement” and a partner or employee of the manager left the management firm, payment of such person’s share of the deferral also generally gets accelerated.

    [4] For a manager who had elected to be paid its deferred fees in January 2018 (with the tax liability still owing for 2017), a delay could be agreed to with the fund to later in 2018.

    [5] In most cases, an offshore hedge fund that is classified as a corporation for U.S. tax purposes will be considered a “passive foreign investment company” (“PFIC”). A taxable U.S. shareholder faces several adverse consequences as a result of holding shares of such a PFIC, some of which are ameliorated by making a “qualified electing fund” election.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Philippe Benedict

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    David S. Griffel

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Bankruptcy Judge Requires Investment Funds to Disclose Major Investors

    Bankruptcy Judge Requires Investment Funds to Disclose Major Investors

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Bankruptcy Judge Requires Investment Funds to Disclose Major Investors

    December 16, 2016

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure (“Bankruptcy Rules”) require each corporate party in an adversary proceeding (i.e., a bankruptcy court suit) to file a statement identifying the holders of “10% or more” of the party’s equity interests. Fed. R. Bankr. P. 7007.1(a). Bankruptcy Judge Martin Glenn, relying on another local Bankruptcy Rule (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. R. 7007.1-1), recently held that investment funds that are partnerships or joint ventures must also file their statements “in the public record without redactions.” In re Motors Liquidation Co., 2016 WL 7187298, at *1 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Dec. 9, 2016). In so holding, Judge Glenn denied the motion of a group of hedge fund lenders to seal their corporate ownership statements. According to the court, its ruling follows the “strong presumption and public policy favoring open access” to court records in the Second Circuit. Id. at *4.

    Relevance

    Parties in bankruptcy adversary proceedings regularly have relied on sealing motions to seek to protect confidential information. Investment funds ordinarily treat as confidential information the identities of their underlying investors. The Motors Liquidation decision, however, creates uncertainty regarding the ability of investment funds to protect the identities of their investors in the future. Indeed, as the court recognized, “[i]t is far from clear that the identities of the owners of 10% or more of the equity interests of a party in an adversary proceeding can ever be confidential commercial information” requiring protection from public disclosure. Id. at *6.

    Motors Liquidation did not create a hard and fast rule. Rather, it merely applied the rules and existing case law to the particular facts before it. Significantly, the moving lenders submitted “[n]o evidence” to support their “arguments.” Id. at *3. As the court stressed, “[e]vidence — not just argument — is required to support the extraordinary remedy of sealing.” Id. at *5.

    Facts

    Bankruptcy Rule 7007.1 requires a corporate party in an adversary proceeding (other than the debtor or a governmental unit) to file a corporate ownership statement identifying any corporation that directly or indirectly owns 10 percent or more of the corporation’s equity interests. “Corporation” includes “limited liability companies and similar entities that fall under the definition of a corporation in Bankruptcy Code § 101.” Fed. R. Bankr. P. 7007.1 & Comm. Notes (2003); In re McGraw, 2007 WL 1076690, at *6 (Bankr. N.D. Ala. Apr. 5, 2007). The Southern District of New York Local Bankruptcy Rules expand the federal rule even further by including any “general or limited partnership or joint venture.” Bankr. S.D.N.Y. R. 7007.1-1. An investment fund partnership thus falls within the purview of the local rule.[1]

    These disclosure requirements led a group of investment funds as defendants in a suit in Motors Liquidation to move to redact from their corporate ownership statements the names of the holders of 10 percent or more of their equity interests. They also sought to “file unredacted statements under seal, and provide the Court with unredacted statements for in camera review.” Motors Liquidation, 2016 WL 7187298, at *2. No objection to the sealing motion was filed, but the court denied the motion, then reconsidered, and asked the U.S. Trustee to brief the issue.

    On reconsideration, the court denied the investment funds’ motion to redact. The court stressed that “[n]o evidence was submitted in support of the Movants’ arguments,” and that “[m]ovants have failed to file a declaration supporting their confidentiality arguments.” Id. at *3.

    The court also distinguished between “confidential information” and “commercial information.” “[J]ust because information may be ‘confidential’ does not mean it is ‘commercial information’ entitled to the extraordinary procedure of sealing.” Id. at *7. The movants, according to the court, failed to meet their evidentiary burden of proving that the investors’ identities were “commercial information,” for they provided only “conclusory statements regarding the information’s commercial importance.” Id. Rather, to prove that information is commercial, it must be “so critical to the operations of the entity seeking the protective order that its disclosure will unfairly benefit the entity’s competitors.” Id. at *5. Moreover, Section 107(b) of the Bankruptcy Code (which protects a party’s commercial information) requires “an extraordinary circumstance or compelling need,” which the movants failed to show. Id. at *4 (citations omitted).

    Finally, the court relied on a “strong [federal] policy” of “transparent proceedings” as a primary consideration for the denial of the requested relief. Id. at *6. “While enabling the judge to determine whether he or she has a disqualifying conflict of interest is most certainly one of the goals of Rule 7007.1, it is not the only goal.” Id. (emphasis in original). Indeed, “transparent proceedings” and “public confidence in the integrity of the federal courts,” reasoned the court, are additional goals of Rule 7007.1 and the Bankruptcy Code generally.

    Comments

    Counsel to plaintiffs or defendants in an adversary proceeding should present evidence (e.g., tangible proof of benefit to the party’s competitors) if their clients seek to redact or seal the identities of their investors. Conclusory arguments by counsel regarding confidentiality may not be sufficient. Even with this evidence, however, it is unclear whether, and to what extent, a court will permit redaction or sealing. As the court noted in Motors Liquidation, it is accountable to the public and must “advance the goal of transparent proceedings.” Id. at *6.

    There are subtle differences between Bankruptcy Rule 7007.1, applicable in adversary proceedings, and the similarly worded Fed. R. Civ. P. 7.1, applicable in other federal courts and on appeals from bankruptcy courts. The former requires disclosure of “any corporation … that directly or indirectly owns 10% or more” of a party’s equity interests. Outside the bankruptcy court, a party need only disclose “any parent corporation and any publicly held corporation owning 10% or more of its stock.” The disclosure requirement under the Bankruptcy Rules is broader, for it encompasses any corporation (not just a parent or a publicly held corporation) that owns, directly or indirectly, 10 percent or more of the party’s equity interests. Thus, parties to bankruptcy adversary proceedings are subject to greater disclosure requirements than parties to non-bankruptcy federal court actions.

    Authored by Michael L. Cook, David M. Hillman, Lawrence V. Gelber and Parker J. Milender.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The disclosure requirement in Bankruptcy Rule 7007.1 does not apply to contested matters (i.e., most garden-variety bankruptcy disputes, such as objections to debtor-in-possession financing or plan confirmation), although bankruptcy judges can make the rule applicable under Bankruptcy Rule 9014(c). Groups or committees that consist of or represent multiple creditors or equity security holders do have to disclose certain facts under Bankruptcy Rule 2019, but unlike Bankruptcy Rule 7007.1, it does not require the disclosure of direct or indirect ownership of 10 percent or more of a corporate party’s equity interests.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • OIG Revises Safe Harbors under the Anti-Kickback Statute and Civil Monetary Penalty Rules Regarding Beneficiary Inducements

    OIG Revises Safe Harbors under the Anti-Kickback Statute and Civil Monetary Penalty Rules Regarding Beneficiary Inducements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    OIG Revises Safe Harbors under the Anti-Kickback Statute and Civil Monetary Penalty Rules Regarding Beneficiary Inducements

    December 14, 2016

    Read time: 12 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On December 7, 2016, the Office of Inspector General of the US Department of Health and Human Services published a final rule containing revisions to both the federal Anti-Kickback Statute safe harbors and the beneficiary inducement prohibition in the civil monetary penalty rules. Effective January 6, 2017, the Final Rule modifies certain existing safe harbors and adds additional safe harbors to the Anti-Kickback Statute and incorporates Affordable Care Act-mandated exceptions into the definition of remuneration under the civil monetary penalty rules.

    In depth

    On December 7, 2016, the Office of Inspector General of the US Department of Health and Human Services (OIG) published a final rule containing revisions to both the federal Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) safe harbors and the beneficiary inducement prohibition in the civil monetary penalty rules (CMP Law) (Final Rule). The Final Rule follows the proposed rule that was published on October 2, 2014. The Final Rule is effective January 6, 2017.

    Anti-Kickback Statute

    The Final Rule modifies certain existing safe harbors to the AKS and added additional safe harbors that provide new protections or codify certain existing protections. Overall, the Final Rule adopts all of the AKS safe harbors previously proposed, with certain modifications suggested by commenters. Following is a brief summary of each safe harbor and change.

    Referral Services: The OIG finalized a technical correction to the safe harbor for referral services. The OIG explained there was an inadvertent error in a 2002 revision, such that the regulation prohibited basing a participant’s fee on the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated by either party for the referral service. The Final Rule returns the safe harbor to the prior language stating that any payment to the referral service by participants must not be based on the volume or value of any referrals to or business otherwise generated by either party for the other party.

    Cost-Sharing Waivers by Pharmacies: A new subsection to the safe harbor relating to waiver of beneficiary coinsurance/deductible amounts (42 C.F.R. § 1001.952(k)) implements Section 1128B(b)(3)(G) of the Social Security Act (Act)—as added by the Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act of 2003 (MMA)—to protect waivers or reductions by pharmacies of Medicare Part D cost-sharing obligations. To meet the safe harbor, pharmacies are required to satisfy the following criteria: (1) the waiver/reduction is not advertised or part of a solicitation; (2) the pharmacy does not routinely waive cost-sharing; and (3) before waiving a cost-sharing obligation, the pharmacy determines in good faith that either the beneficiary has a financial need or the pharmacy fails to collect cost-sharing amounts after making a reasonable effort to do so. Only the first criterion would apply if the reduction/waiver is made on behalf of a “subsidy-eligible” individuals, since such individuals would have already been deemed to satisfy financial need criteria for purposes of subsidy of their Part D premiums. In response to public comment, the OIG also extended the entire safe harbor (not just the section on Part D cost-sharing waivers) to all Federal health care programs, as the safe harbor had applied only to Medicare and state health care programs. However, the OIG cautioned that the waiver is still only applicable to pharmacies and does not protect, for example, waivers by physicians for copayments of Part B drugs.

    Cost-Sharing Waivers for Emergency Ambulance Services: The Final Rule finalized the OIG’s proposal to create another new section of the safe harbor relating to waiver of beneficiary coinsurance/deductible amounts to protect waivers and reductions for “emergency ambulance services” furnished by a Medicare Part B ambulance provider or supplier owned or operated by a state, a political subdivision of a state or a tribal health program. Under the Final Rule, ambulance providers are required to offer the reduction/waiver on a uniform basis, and the waivers should not be based on patient-specific factors, which include anything other than residency in the municipality or other government unit providing ambulance services. Further, providers are prohibited from claiming the reduction or waiver amount as bad debt. The OIG had previously proposed including an additional requirement that the reduction or waiver not be considered the furnishing of free services paid for directly or indirectly by a government entity. However, the OIG removed this requirement, stating that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) policy adequately addresses the issue. The OIG also expanded the cost-sharing under this part of the safe harbor to all Federal health care programs.

    Federally Qualified Health Centers and Medicare Advantage Organizations: The Final Rule adds a new safe harbor to implement Section 237 of the MMA, which created a statutory exception to the AKS for any remuneration between a federally qualified health center and a Medicare Advantage organization (MAO) pursuant to a written agreement.

    Medicare Coverage Gap Discount Program: Section 3301(d) of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, as amended by the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 (ACA) amended the AKS to create a statutory exception for discounts under the Medicare Coverage Gap Discount Program, which provides beneficiaries with discounts on covered Part D drugs while they are in the coverage gap or “donut hole.” The new safe harbor protects discounts for “applicable drugs” furnished to an “applicable beneficiary,” as those terms are defined in the Medicare Coverage Gap Discount Program statute.

    Local Transportation: The most highly anticipated AKS provision in the Final Rule is the new safe harbor to protect free or discounted local transportation services provided to Federal health care program beneficiaries in order to obtain medically necessary items or services. In finalizing the rule, the OIG addressed multiple issues raised by commenters, including clarifying that the safe harbor protects transportation to a provider or supplier of services and back to a patient’s home, as long as all conditions of the safe harbor are met, and that the transportation does not need to be planned in advance and can be accessed through use of vouchers rather than directly by the eligible provider or supplier.

    The final safe harbor includes numerous elements, requiring that services be provided by “eligible entities” (which excludes entities that primarily supply health care items such as durable medical equipment and pharmaceutical companies), and otherwise meet various safeguards, including prohibitions on air, luxury or ambulance transportation, marketing the services, and transports in excess of 25 miles or 50 miles if the patient resides in a rural area. The OIG believes that signage designating the source of the transportation on vehicles used to transport patients is an important safety feature and would not be “marketing,” for purposes of the safe harbor. However, providers that give patients pamphlets or other marketing or informational materials during transport would not be protected by the safe harbor.

    The Final Rule also permits shuttle service (a vehicle that runs on a set route, on a set schedule and that may include stops at locations that do not relate to a particular patient’s medical care). Non-shuttle local transportation services must be provided pursuant to a policy which the eligible entity applies uniformly and consistently (individualized documentation for each patient whom transportation is provided is not required), and the services may be provided only to “established patients.”

    The proposed rule defined “established patients” to include only patients who had selected a provider or supplier and had attended an appointment with the provider or supplier. However, in the Final Rule, the OIG acknowledged that due to the marketing restriction, providing services to new patients who contact the provider or supplier on their own initiative is sufficiently low risk to also warrant safe harbor protection. As a result, under the Final Rule, a patient is considered “established” once he or she selects and initiates contact with a provider or supplier to schedule an appointment.

    Civil Monetary Penalty Law

    Under the beneficiary inducement provisions of the CMP Law, a person who offers or provides any remuneration to a Medicare or Medicaid beneficiary that the person knows or should know is likely to influence the beneficiary’s selection of a particular provider, practitioner or supplier of Medicare or Medicaid payable items or services may be liable for civil money penalties, subject to a limited number of exceptions. The Final Rule excepts certain practices from the definition of “remuneration” for purposes of the CMP rules in an effort to establish a balance between preserving restrictions against fraud and abuse and facilitating activities that incentivize beneficiaries to comply with their wellness or treatment regimens and seek coordinated care.

    Copayment Reductions for Outpatient Department Services as an Exception to the Definition of “Remuneration”: The Final Rule codifies the exception to the definition of “remuneration” added by Section 4523 of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 concerning reductions in copayment amounts for covered hospital outpatient department services pursuant to Section 1833(t)(8)(b) to the Act.

    ACA-Mandated Exceptions to the Definition of “Remuneration” into the CMP Laws: The Final Rule incorporates ACA-mandated exceptions into the definition of “remuneration” by including the following:

    • Promotes Access to Care and Low Risk of Harm. The Final Rule exempts “items or services that improve a beneficiary’s ability to obtain items and services payable by Medicare or Medicaid, and pose a low risk of harm to Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries and the Medicare and Medicaid programs” from the definition of remuneration. The OIG maintained its interpretation of “low risk of harm,” categorizing such items or services as those that are: “(i) unlikely to interfere with, or skew, clinical decision making; (ii) unlikely to increase costs to Federal health care programs or beneficiaries through overutilization or inappropriate utilization; and (iii) not raising patient safety or quality-of-care concerns.” While “items or services that support or help patients to access care, or make access to care more convenient than it otherwise would be” would often fall under this exception, “inducements to comply with treatment or rewards for compliance with treatment” would not fall under this exception.This section of the Final Rule was a highly anticipated regulatory implementation of one of the ACA’s CMP exceptions. While other exceptions require a determination of financial need or are narrowly tailored to specific circumstances (e.g., the retailer rewards programs described below), this exception potentially covers a broader array of programs, which is very helpful. However, this flexibility also means that the exception does not include explicit guidelines for specific arrangements, so evaluation of arrangements under the Final Rule still requires a facts and circumstances analysis. The preamble to the Final Rule includes a fairly lengthy discussion of this section that should be reviewed when evaluating the facts and circumstances of a particular program or practice under the exception.
    • Retailer Rewards Program. The Final Rule retains language and interpretation of the proposed exception, exempting “items or services for free or less than fair market value by a person if: (i) the items or services consist of coupons, rebates, or other rewards from a retailer; (ii) the items or services are offered or transferred on equal terms available to the general public, regardless of health insurance status; and (iii) the offer or transfer of the items is not tied to the provision of other items or services reimbursed in whole or in part by the program under” Medicare or a State health care program. The term “retailer” is interpreted to exclude entities that primarily provide services, such as hospitals and physicians. As a result, this exception is primarily of use to pharmacies and other retailers that also include a pharmacy, as opposed to most health care providers.
    • Financial-Need-Based Exemption. The Final Rule maintains the language and interpretation of this proposed exception, exempting offers or transfers of items or services (excluding cash or instruments that can be converted into cash) for free or less than fair market value if: (i) the items or services are not offered through advertising or solicitation; (ii) the offer or transfer is not tied to other reimbursable services and (iii) are “reasonabl[y] connected” to the individual’s medical care from both medical and financial perspectives; and (iv) the offeror or transferor of the items or services “determines in good faith” that the individual has financial need.
    • Waivers of Cost-Sharing for the First Fill of a Generic Drug. The Final Rule retains the text of the proposed exception, allowing Part D Plan sponsors or Medicare Advantage (MA) organizations to waive copayments for the first fill of a covered Part D “generic drug,” as defined in Part D regulations. Sponsors aiming to offer these waivers to enrollees must disclose such waivers in the benefit design packets that they are required to submit to CMS. As a result, this exception will not be available until January 1, 2018.

    The OIG notes in the Final Rule that non-cash or cash equivalent payments that are nominal in value are not inducements and therefore do not require an exception to the beneficiary inducement prohibition. As noted in our On the Subject, ‘‘Tis the Season for Giving: OIG Updates Policy on Gifts of Nominal Value to Medicare and Medicaid Beneficiaries,’ concurrently with issuance of the Final Rule, the OIG announced an increase in its guidelines for “nominal value” from $10 to $15 for an individual gift and from $50 to $75 in value in the aggregate annually per patient.

    Finally, the OIG previously proposed to adopt a regulation implementing the gainsharing CMP, which prohibits a hospital from knowingly paying a physician to induce the physician to reduce or limit the services provided to Medicare or Medicaid beneficiaries under the physician’s direct care. Approximately six months after the proposed rule was published, Congress passed the Medicare and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 (MACRA) in April 2015, which amended the language so that only payments to reduce or limit medically necessary services are prohibited by the law. Because of the amendment to the statute, OIG did not finalize the regulation.

    Authors

    Monica Wallace

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights