Content Type: Article

  • Third Circuit Allows Repossessing Secured Lender to Hold Collateral Pending Bankruptcy Stay

    Third Circuit Allows Repossessing Secured Lender to Hold Collateral Pending Bankruptcy Stay

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Third Circuit Allows Repossessing Secured Lender to Hold Collateral Pending Bankruptcy Stay

    October 31, 2019

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    “[A] secured creditor [has no] affirmative obligation under the automatic stay to return a debtor’s [repossessed] collateral to the bankruptcy estate immediately upon notice of the debtor’s bankruptcy,” held the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on Oct. 28, 2019. In re Denby-Peterson, 2019 WL 5538570, *1 (3d Cir. Oct. 28, 2019). Affirming the lower courts, the Third Circuit joined “the minority of our sister courts – the Tenth and D.C. Circuits” with its holding. According to the court, it was “[g]uided by the plain language of the Bankruptcy Code’s automatic stay and turnover provisions, the legislative purpose and policy goals of the automatic stay, and the reasoning of the Supreme Court and our two sister circuits….” Id. at *13. In sum, because “a secured creditor [need not] return the [repossessed] collateral to the debtor until the debtor obtains a [bankruptcy] court order… requiring the creditor to do so,” it does “not violate the automatic stay” of Bankruptcy Code (“Code”) § 362(a)(3) (creditors stayed from “any act to obtain possession of property of the debtor… or to exercise control over property of the estate.”). Id. at *5 – *6.

    Relevance

    The Third Circuit followed the holdings of the Tenth and D.C. Circuits “that a creditor does not violate the stay in regard to property of the estate if it merely maintains the status quo.” Id. at *3, citing In re Cowen, 849 F.3d 943 (10th Cir. 2017); United States v. Inslaw, Inc., 932 F.2d 1467 (D.C. Cir. 1991). In contrast, the “Second, Seventh, Eighth, and Ninth Circuits… have held that the Bankruptcy Code’s turnover provision requires immediate turnover of estate property that was seized [prior to bankruptcy] and that failure to do so violates the automatic stay.” Id., citing In re Fulton, 926 F.3d 916 (7th Cir. 2019); In re Weber, 719 F.3d 72 (2d Cir. 2013); In re Del Mission Ltd., 98 F.3d 1147 (9th Cir. 1996); In re Knaus, 889 F.2d 773 (8th Cir. 1989); also see In re Rozier, 376 F.3d 1323, 1324 (11th Cir. 2004) (creditor held “in willful contempt of the automatic stay… by refusing to return the vehicle).”

    The Supreme Court should resolve this circuit split. It did so 24 years ago in Citizens Bank of Maryland v. Strumpf, 516 U.S. 16 (1995), when it “considered the interplay between the automatic stay and the turnover provision in [Code §] 542(b).” 2019 WL 5538570, at *12. In Strumpf, the court held “that a bank’s temporary withholding of funds in a debtor’s bank account, pending resolution of the bank’s setoff right… did not violate the automatic stay,” reasoning “among other things, that [to] interpret… [§] 542(b)’s turnover provision as self-executing would ‘eviscerate’ the provision’s exceptions to the duty to pay.” Id. at *12. 

    Facts

    The individual debtor bought a used Chevrolet Corvette in July 2016. After making several installment payments on her financing agreement, the secured lenders repossessed the car when the debtor later defaulted on her car payments. The debtor then filed a Chapter 13 petition notifying the secured lenders of the bankruptcy filing and demanding that they return the car to her.

    The lenders rejected the debtor’s demand. She then moved for a turnover order in the bankruptcy court under Code § 542(a) (creditor “shall deliver” debtor’s property to debtor), seeking not only the return of the car, but also sanctions under Code § 363(k) for the lenders’ alleged “willful violation” of the Code’s automatic stay.

    The Lower Courts

    The bankruptcy court ordered the turnover of the car but denied the debtor’s request for sanctions, reasoning that the lenders had not violated the stay by failing to return the car after receiving notice of the bankruptcy filing. The district court affirmed.

    The Third Circuit

    The Third Circuit noted the “twofold” purpose of the automatic stay in Code § 362(a). Not only does it protect the debtor “by stopping all collection efforts, harassment, and foreclosure actions,” but it also protects creditors by “preventing particular creditors from acting unilaterally in self-interest to obtain payment from a debtor to the detriment of other creditors.” Id. at *5. The stay thus “prevent[s] dismemberment of the estate,” enabling an “orderly” distribution of the debtor’s assets. Id., citing Taggart v. Lorenzen, 139 S.Ct. 1795, 1804 (2019) (automatic stay “aims to prevent damaging disruptions to the administration of a bankruptcy case in the short run.”).

    An “individual injured by any willful violation” of the automatic stay may seek “actual damages, including costs and attorneys’ fees, and, in appropriate circumstances, may recover punitive damages.” Id. at *5, quoting Code § 362(k). Here, the debtor sought sanctions because of the lenders’ refusal to turn over the debtor’s car.

    Plain Language of Code. The court rejected the debtor’s assertion that the lenders violated the stay by failing to return her car. “… § 362(a)(3) prohibits creditors from taking any affirmative act to exercise control over property of the estate.” Id. at *7. Because the statutory language “is prospective in nature … the exercise of control is not stayed, but the act to exercise control is stayed.” Id. In short, the language “requires a post petition affirmative act to exercise control over property of the estate.” Id.

    No Affirmative Act. The lenders here had “possession and control of the” car, but “merely passively retained that same possession and control.” Id. at *8. They never violated the automatic stay because they never did anything “to exercise control over” the car. Id. When learning of the debtor’s bankruptcy filing, they merely “preserved the pre-petition status quo.” Id. Congress never intended “passive retention to qualify as ‘an act to exercise control over property of the estate.’” Id., quoting Code § 362(a)(3).

    No Need to Resort to Unhelpful Legislative History. The court rejected the debtor’s reliance on the legislative history because of the “unambiguous text” of § 362(a)(3). Id. at *8. In any event, as the court noted, “Congress … ‘gave no explanation of its intent’” when it amended § 362(a)(3) by adding “to exercise control over property of the estate.” Id. Indeed, said the court, “Congress did not express any intent, much less an intent to include creditors’ passive retention of property that was seized pre-petition.” Id. *9.

    Code § 542(a) Turnover Provision Not Self Effectuating. Rejecting the debtor’s argument that Code § 542(a) is “self-executing,” the court found that “a creditor’s obligation to turn over estate property to the debtor is not automatic.” Id. *10. Instead, the debtor or trustee must sue in the bankruptcy court to give that court a chance to determine whether the property is subject to turnover. Both the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure and § 542(a) itself govern.

    The debtor or trustee, after a bankruptcy filing, “must . . . initiate a turnover proceeding by (1) filing a complaint in Bankruptcy Court, and (2) serving a creditor with a copy of the complaint” under Bankruptcy Rule 7001(1). Id. *10. Also, Code § 542(a) “explicitly limits the right to turnover [of] estate property that (1) is in the possession, custody or control of a creditor, and (2) is not ‘of inconsequential value or benefit to the estate.’” Id. *11. Thus, “explicit conditions . . . must be satisfied before property is subject to turnover.” Id. There is no “automatic duty on creditors to turn over collateral to the debtor upon learning of a bankruptcy petition” and Code § 542(a) is not “self-effectuating.” Id. The bankruptcy court, after a debtor or trustee sues, “must ultimately decide whether certain property must be turned over to the debtor.” Id. Although Code § 542(a) contains the phrase “shall deliver to the [debtor],” it only happens when the bankruptcy court “says so in the context of an adversary proceeding brought under Rule 7001(1).” Id. at *12.

    Supreme Court Guidelines. The Supreme Court’s Strumpf decision supports the holding in Denby-Peterson: “interpreting § 542(b)’s turnover provision as self-executing would ‘eviscerate’ the provision’s exceptions to the duty to pay.” Id., citing Strumpf, 516 U.S. at 20. Neither the “automatic stay provision [nor] the turnover provision … refer to each other.” Id. Accordingly, “they should not be read together, [meaning that] violation of the turnover provision would not warrant sanctions for violation of the automatic stay provision.” Id.

    Comments

    1. The Third Circuit reached a sensible, practical result in Denby-Peterson. The well-reasoned opinion maintained the right balance between debtors’ and creditors’ rights. By preserving the status quo and the debtor’s right to reclaim its property, it also relieves secured lenders from the threat of sanctions.
    2. The turnover remedy was also never viewed as self-effectuating under pre-Code practice. A secured lender who repossessed collateral prior to bankruptcy was able to retain possession pending the bankruptcy court’s entry of a turnover. Ralph Brubaker, “Turnover, Adequate Protection and the Automatic Stay (Part I): Origins and Evolution of the Turnover Power,” 33 Bnkr. L. Letter No. 8, at 4 — 7 (Aug. 2013). According to the Supreme Court, moreover, when a debtor sought a turnover order, “[n]othing in the legislative history evinces a congressional intent to depart from that [pre-Code] practice.” United States v. Whiting Pools, Inc., 462 U.S. 198, 208 (1983).

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • DOL Issues New Proposed Rule for Electronic Disclosures of Retirement Plan Notices

    DOL Issues New Proposed Rule for Electronic Disclosures of Retirement Plan Notices

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOL Issues New Proposed Rule for Electronic Disclosures of Retirement Plan Notices

    October 30, 2019

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Department of Labor (DOL) issued a proposed rule that, if finalized, would expand its existing guidance and liberalize rules for electronic disclosure of retirement plan notices under ERISA. The proposed rule, which sets forth a notice and access safe harbor, would permit electronic disclosure as the default method of delivery while permitting participants to opt out and continue to receive paper disclosures.

    In depth

    On October 22, 2019, the Department of Labor (DOL) issued a proposed rule that would expand its prior safe harbor guidance for electronic disclosures to allow posting of retirement plan disclosures on a designated website. The proposed rule, which the DOL refers to as the “notice and access” safe harbor, is intended to reflect modern internet technology while easing the administrative burden on plan sponsors. The proposed rule would not apply to notices for health and welfare benefit plans.

    Under ERISA, plan administrators must use delivery methods for required disclosures that are reasonably calculated to ensure actual receipt of information by participants, beneficiaries, and other individuals. The DOL has previously issued rules and guidance regarding electronic delivery of disclosures required under Title I of ERISA, including, for example, summary plan descriptions (SPDs), summaries of material modifications (SMMs) and summary annual reports (SARs), as well as Section 404(c) disclosures for participant-directed individual accounts, qualified default investment alternative (QDIA) notices, disclosures regarding investment advice and blackout notices. Under current DOL rules, acceptable delivery methods include hand delivery, first-class mail or electronic delivery under a 2002 safe harbor for participants who have access to electronic media at work, or participants who affirmatively consent to receive electronic documentation.

    The proposed rule leaves in place the existing 2002 safe harbor and would introduce an additional safe harbor for retirement plan notices. Those notices could be posted on a website rather than sent by paper or electronic mail. The new safe harbor would be optional for plan sponsors and could be used to communicate to plan participants who either provide an electronic address (which could include a phone number for a smartphone) to the plan sponsor or have an electronic address assigned by an employer. Under the proposed rule, plan participants would need to receive both:

    1. a one-time paper disclosure stating that some or all disclosure documents will be furnished electronically, and
    2. for each required disclosure, an electronic notice of internet availability with a brief description of the document(s) and instructions on how to access information on the website.

    Participants must also be notified of their right to receive paper copies of some or all plan notices. The website hosting the disclosures must also meet certain requirements.

    In light of the proposed rule, plan sponsors should evaluate the new safe harbor proposal, as it may be an efficient way to deliver retirement plan disclosures while reducing the cost of mailing notices to individual participants and beneficiaries. Plan sponsors should pay special attention to obtaining updated contact information for former employees who continue to participate in the retirement plans.

    Both ERISA and the Internal Revenue Code (IRS) require a number of participant notices, disclosures, elections, and consents. The IRS and the DOL have each promulgated regulations that permit the documents over which they have authority to be disseminated electronically under certain conditions. The electronic disclosure rules of the IRS do not govern communications regulated by the DOL, and vice versa. In addition, although the DOL stated in its Fact Sheet that the new safe harbor is meant to align with IRS rules about delivering retirement plan disclosures electronically, the DOL rules do not govern disclosures regulated by the IRS.

    Plan sponsors are not entitled to rely on the proposed rule before it is finalized. Under the proposed rule, the applicability date for retirement plans would be the first day of the first calendar year after the final rule is published. Any comments on the proposed rule and on the specific questions posed by the DOL must be submitted on or before November 22, 2019.

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    Alan D. Nesburg

    Counsel

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Reducing the Effects of GILTI to Individuals and Trusts Through the High-Tax Exception to GILTI, Code Sec. 962 Elections and Corporate Contributions

    ARTICLE

    Reducing the Effects of GILTI to Individuals and Trusts Through the High-Tax Exception to GILTI, Code Sec. 962 Elections and Corporate Contributions

    October 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • A Guide to Managing Downward Attribution for Determining CFC Status

    A Guide to Managing Downward Attribution for Determining CFC Status

    ARTICLE

    A Guide to Managing Downward Attribution for Determining CFC Status

    October 28, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • California’s New IoT Cybersecurity Law: A Guide for Business

    ARTICLE

    California’s New IoT Cybersecurity Law: A Guide for Business

    October 28, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Reproduced with permission from Copyright 2019.The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc. (800-372-1033)www.bloombergindustry.com.

    In depth
    Authors

    Shawn C. Helms

    Partner

    Dallas

    Michael G. Morgan

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Silicon Valley

    Jason D. Krieser

    Partner

    Dallas

    Brian Long

    Associate

    Dallas

    More insights

  • The US-China Trade War: The War of the Lists and How It Could Affect Your Company

    The US-China Trade War: The War of the Lists and How It Could Affect Your Company

    ARTICLE / OTHER

    The US-China Trade War: The War of the Lists and How It Could Affect Your Company

    October 28, 2019

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Authored by David J. Levine (Washington, DC)

    Since the Trump Administration announced its tariffs on Chinese goods, the US-China trade war has continued to escalate and create uncertainty for many US, Chinese and other international companies. The Trump Administration’s move on October 7, 2019, to blacklist eight major Chinese technology companies marks yet another flare-up in the long-running tensions. This move also highlights a critical strategy deployed by both the US and Chinese governments: utilizing administrative powers to “blacklist” companies, create trade barriers and restrict market access. With the escalation of the trade war, US, Chinese, and international companies face new challenges in the market, making it critical to strategize accordingly in order to reduce risks and maximize success.

    In depth

    US-China Trade War Background

    The US-China trade war has had global economic impact and has created anxiety for US and international companies operating in China and Chinese companies operating in the United States. Although not prominently reported compared to tariffs, the use of administrative powers and “blacklisting” has been a frequent and powerful tool of the US and Chinese governments.

    Since the beginning of the Trump Administration, the US government has implemented several policies to increase pressure on China to open its markets, reduce intellectual property theft and create an even playing field in trade. These policies include tariffs on items such as steel, agriculture and consumer goods as well as use of legal and administrative tools such as congressional, criminal and civil investigations, including enforcement actions under the US export control laws, the US Export Administration Regulations (EAR) and US trade sanctions regulations administered by the US Treasury Department Office of Foreign Assets Control. For example, the US Department of Commerce Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) has used the Entity List under the EAR to impose very restrictive US export licensing requirements on specified Chinese companies. The Chinese government responded to these policies in kind, enacting its own tariffs, trade and market restrictions, and other measures.

    In May 2019, the US government added Huawei and 68 of its subsidiaries to the BIS Entity List. In response, the Chinese government announced the creation of its own entity list, the “Unreliable Entities List,” and placed several companies under investigation in connection with the list. The list takes aim at non-Chinese companies accused of harming the interests of China, and can lead to a range of actions, including government investigations, sanctions and even criminal liability.

    The use and impact of these lists continues, with the most recent action being on October 7, 2019, when the Trump Administration added eight Chinese high-tech companies to the BIS Entity List for allegations in connection with matters in China’s Xinjiang province. The Chinese government has stated that it will respond.

    War of the Lists

    In order to survive the turbulence brought on by the US-China trade war and the so-called “war of the lists,” it is critical to have at least a basic understanding of these two lists.

    US BIS Entity List
    Under the EAR, BIS administers the Entity List, on which it identifies specified persons (legal and natural), including businesses, individuals, governments, research institutes and private organizations, that have engaged in activities that have been deemed contrary to US national security and/or foreign policy interests. The EAR imposes very restrictive license requirements and limits the availability of most license exceptions for exports, re-exports and transfers to listed persons/entities. Specific license restrictions vary for listed parties but, as a practical matter, a listing on the Entity List greatly restricts a listed party from engaging in any transactions that require the exportation of US goods or technology subject to the EAR. If a listed entity violates these restrictions or a company sells products to a listed entity without proper licensing, it can result in civil and even criminal liability under US law.

    China’s Unreliable Entities List
    On June 1, 2019, the Chinese Ministry of Commerce (MOFCOM) announced the creation of the Unreliable Entities List. This list is largely perceived as retaliation for the United States’ use of the BIS Entity List. China’s list is designed to identify foreign entities, organizations or individuals that have “harmed the interests of Chinese consumers.” The Chinese government has published four elements that it will consider when determining whether to add a foreign company, organization or individual to the list:

    • Whether the entity has blocked, cut off the supply or otherwise engaged in discriminatory behavior towards a Chinese entity
    • Whether the entity’s actions are for a non-commercial purpose and violate the rules and principles of the market economy
    • Whether the entity has caused serious damage/harm to a Chinese company or related industry
    • Whether the entity’s actions have created any real or perceived threat to Chinese national security.

    If a foreign company, organization or individual meets one of these elements and is placed on the list (or if MOFCOM is considering placing them on the list), they may be targeted for legal and administrative actions, including investigations; market restrictions; and civil, administrative and criminal liability pursuant to the PRC Foreign Trade Law, Anti-Monopoly Law and National Security Law.

    How Your Company May Be Affected
    The restrictions and uncertainty created by the US and Chinese lists can have significant impact on Chinese companies doing business in the United States as well as US and international companies doing business in China.

    Chinese Companies in the United States
    If listed on the BIS Entity List, practical impacts for Chinese companies include market restrictions and prohibition from purchasing US goods, which can significantly affect a company’s supply chain and business operations. These impacts could even go beyond the US market and extend globally, as non-US companies will also need to consider liability and compliance for conducting business with a listed entity where the sale of US-sourced goods is involved. Additionally, since listing is premised on a company’s actions being contrary to US national security or foreign policy interests, being placed on the BIS Entity List, consideration for inclusion into the list, or even reports of prior business dealings with prominent entities on or under consideration for the list might occur concurrently with other investigative actions by the US government. To date, companies listed include high-tech companies such as Huawei and Hikvision, and reasons for listing often include accusations of national security risks or human rights violations. Therefore, companies in the high-tech space, companies that have (or have had) operations in high-risk locations, or companies that have a cooperation history with any of the listed companies may wish to review their operations in the United States and their dealings with listed entities. They should also seek to understand the true reason behind any scrutiny from the US government, and prepare a strategy to address any practical impacts or obligations imposed by the BIS Entity List.

    US and International Companies in China
    Although no specific public documents have been released detailing the exact impact of inclusion on the Unreliable Entities List, based on public reporting and official statements from MOFCOM, some consequences have come to light. First, as stated by MOFCOM, inclusion on the list can warrant liability under the PRC Foreign Trade Law, Anti-Monopoly Law and National Security Law, which includes fines, revocation of business licenses and even criminal liability.

    Second, companies on or considered for inclusion on the list may be targeted for government investigations by various administrative and law enforcement agencies. Companies such as FedEx, Flex and HSBC have been placed under investigation for activities related to inclusion on the Unreliable Entities List, particularly for actions with Chinese companies on the BIS Entity List, such as Huawei.

    Third, companies may face extralegal barriers, including increased scrutiny from the Chinese public, social media and government that could cause consequences in the Chinese market. Companies such as Qualcomm, Intel and Google have experienced this when they were summoned by the Chinese government and warned about cutting ties to Chinese companies on the BIS Entity List, in particular Huawei.

    For these reasons, companies that have been affected in China generally include high-tech companies or companies that have had dealings with Chinese companies on the BIS Entity List, especially Huawei. In order to minimize risks and impact to a company’s China operations, companies with connections to blacklisted Chinese entities and/or operating in a similar industry may wish to review their activities in China, determine any new compliance obligations with respect to Chinese entities on the BIS Entity List, and ascertain and prepare a preemptive strategy to address a response by the Chinese government.

    US, Chinese and other multinational companies have faced significant commercial, regulatory and legal challenges due to the US-China trade war and the “war of the lists.” Navigating this new landscape can be complex, and companies must plan accordingly to survive in the US, Chinese and global markets.

    Authors

    David J. Levine

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Nonprofit Health Care, Social Responsibility, and the Accountable Capitalism Act

    Nonprofit Health Care, Social Responsibility, and the Accountable Capitalism Act

    ARTICLE

    Nonprofit Health Care, Social Responsibility, and the Accountable Capitalism Act

    October 25, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Robert C. Louthian , III

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Due Diligence for Collaborative Ventures

    ARTICLE

    Due Diligence for Collaborative Ventures

    October 23, 2019

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hospitals and health systems (HHS) are increasingly acting as the catalyst for growth and expansion through technology and data innovations. Through their centralized initiatives, HHSs not only drive internal innovation, but also allow HHSs to explore external investment opportunities and collaborations with third parties. As an HHS considers these funding opportunities, it must also ensure that it is conducting appropriate and thorough due diligence. Particularly when investing in start-up companies to develop and commercialize innovative products, HHSs need to tackle due diligence through a fresh lens. In the fifth installment of our Focus on Innovation Centers series, Kerrin Slattery and Kristian Werling explore the need for specialized due diligence for Innovation Centers and three key areas to focus on to maximize the value of such investments.

    In depth
    Authors

    Kerrin B. Slattery

    Partner

    Chicago

    Kristian A. Werling

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • What Fund Managers Need to Know About Recent Proposed CFIUS Regulations

    What Fund Managers Need to Know About Recent Proposed CFIUS Regulations

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    What Fund Managers Need to Know About Recent Proposed CFIUS Regulations

    October 23, 2019

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act of 2018 (“FIRRMA”) has made compliance with increasingly complex Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (“CFIUS”) rules an important part of a fund manager’s job if any of its funds have foreign investors. Before FIRRMA, CFIUS jurisdiction only applied to transactions where a foreign entity acquired control over a U.S. business (defined as “any entity engaged in interstate commerce in the United States”) and all CFIUS filings were voluntary. This meant that both U.S. funds with foreign investors and foreign investment funds whose U.S. investments were limited to real estate and minority investments in public and private companies had no reason to worry about CFIUS compliance.

    FIRRMA has changed that. FIRRMA now extends CFIUS jurisdiction for the first time to cover certain minority investment in U.S. businesses and U.S. real estate acquisitions by or made on behalf of foreign investors, and in some instances, as explained below, to require mandatory reporting prior to closing. On Sept. 17, 2019, the U.S. Department of the Treasury issued over 300 pages of additional proposed rules to implement FIRRMA, which will take effect when made final sometime before the Feb. 13, 2020 statutory deadline. We summarize below the takeaways fund managers should know about the new proposed regulations.

    1. The New Rules Leave the Pilot Program Mandatory Filing Unchanged, Along with the Safe Harbor for U.S.-Managed Funds Not Controlled by Foreign Investors

    CFIUS has not proposed any changes to the current mandatory filing FIRRMA Pilot Program that became effective last November. The Pilot Program requires that certain foreign investments in U.S. critical technology businesses be reported to CFIUS. There have also been no changes proposed to the Pilot Program investment fund “safe harbor” rule (explained below) that exempts certain U.S.-managed funds from the mandatory filing requirement even if they have significant foreign investors.

    The existing Pilot Program requires mandatory reporting for:

    • All foreign persons;
    • Making non-controlling investments;
    • That provide board representation or board observer rights, access to non-public technical information or involvement in substantive decision making of a U.S. business;
    • That produces, designs, tests, manufactures, fabricates or develops one or more “critical technologies” (which include items subject to export controls, items related to nuclear energy and select agents and toxins); and
    • Such technologies are used in one of 27 named industries.[1]

    Mandatory reporting is not required if the investment fund safe harbor requirements are met. Investment funds organized as limited partnerships with foreign investors are not subject to the Pilot Program mandatory reporting requirements if the fund is (a) managed by a U.S. general partner and (b) foreign limited partners do not have certain types of control over the fund’s management or investment decisions, or access to certain types of technical information. Since the Pilot Program became effective, many investment funds have reviewed, and in some instances, revised, their fund governance to ensure that they fall within this safe harbor.

    2. The New Rules Require Additional Mandatory Reporting for Certain Foreign Government Acquisitions of U.S. Businesses

    Under the proposed regulations, certain foreign government-controlled investments in a newly defined term, “TID (Technology, Infrastructure, Data) U.S. Business,” will be also subject to mandatory CFIUS filing. A “TID U.S. Business” is defined as a U.S. business that:

    • Deals with critical technology as defined under the Pilot Program; as well as U.S. businesses that own, operate, manufacture, supply or service critical infrastructure as defined; or that maintain or collect sensitive personal data of U.S. persons that may be exploited in a manner that threatens U.S. national security.[2]

    A mandatory filing will be required for transactions in which a foreign government holds a 49% or greater direct or indirect voting interest in any foreign person, including a fund, that obtains a 25% or greater direct or indirect voting interest in a TID U.S. Business.

    This new mandatory reporting requirement likely will apply most often to foreign government sovereign wealth funds and foreign state owned-enterprises that make direct investments of 25% or more in a U.S. TID Business. For fund managers who oversee multi-investor funds that have no 49% or greater investors, this new regulation will not affect their investment activity. However, fund managers should be aware that this new rule would likely apply to managed accounts, single investor funds (“funds of one”) or any co-investment or sidecar fund held 49% or more by a foreign government investor if they invest in 25% or more of a U.S. TID Business.

    3. The New Rules May Except Certain Foreign Countries and Certain Foreign Entities From Reporting Acquisitions of U.S. Real Estate and Non-Controlling Investments in U.S. Businesses

    Under pre-FIRRMA law, all foreign investors were subject to CFIUS jurisdiction and reporting requirements and procedures; there has been no formal “white list” of favored countries or “black list” of disfavored countries.[3] FIRRMA for the first time allowed CFIUS to treat buyers and investors from certain foreign countries more favorably than others in terms of formal process.

    The proposed regulations implement this new authority and provide that CFIUS may exempt individuals and entities from particular foreign countries from the scope of its jurisdiction when they make certain real estate acquisitions or non-controlling investments in a U.S. business. (All acquisitions of control of a U.S. Business by foreign buyers/investors will continue to be subject to CFIUS jurisdiction without respect to the home country of the buyer/investor.) The establishment of a so-called “white list” of what will be called “Excepted Foreign Countries” will be accomplished by CFIUS selecting specific countries to exempt based on a super-majority vote of CFIUS member agencies. The criteria for qualification will include the establishment by the foreign country of a foreign investment review process of its own and coordination and cooperation with the United States on security matters. It is expected that the initial list will be very narrow, possibly only including America’s closest allies, Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia and New Zealand. The prospects of further inclusion of additional favored foreign countries will likely be used by the U.S. government to leverage other countries to increase their level of security cooperation with the United States.

    Investors from Excepted Foreign Countries who meet specified requirements related to prior legal compliance will automatically be considered “Excepted Foreign Investors” so long as they maintain specified ties with an Excepted Foreign Country.

    Note that under the proposed rules, a fund operating in an Excepted Foreign Country will not qualify as an “Excepted Foreign Investor” if any of its 5% or more economic owners (investors) are foreign nationals or entities from a country that is not an Excepted Foreign Country.

    Note that in such a situation, a foreign fund that does not qualify as a Excepted Foreign Investor may still take advantage of the Pilot Program safe harbor and avoid mandatory reporting if none of its foreign investors have the kinds of participation rights that would disqualify the application of the safe harbor. This would be an important point to keep in mind if the list of Excepted Foreign Countries is drawn narrowly.

    4. The New Regulations Provide Greater Specificity as to the Types of Transaction for Which Parties May Be Advised to Make Voluntary Filings

    As was the case prior to FIRRMA, most CFIUS compliance and enforcement activity will continue to be based on voluntary notification of covered transactions. The new regulations provide significant help in determining which types of transactions CFIUS is likely to be most concerned with. In the past, parties often were left to guess or rely on their CFIUS counsel to piece together clues from prior non-published CFIUS enforcement actions. While that may still be the case in some circumstances, the new regulations provide very specific lists of the types of infrastructure, personal data and geographic locations that are of greatest interest to CFIUS:

    1. Critical Infrastructure. The new rules specify that CFIUS has authority to review non-controlling investments in U.S. Businesses that own, operate, manufacture, supply or service certain critical infrastructure identified in a detailed Annex to the proposed regulations.[4]
    2. Sensitive Personal Data. Recent CFIUS enforcement has focused on the foreign acquisition of U.S. businesses that maintain or collect sensitive personal data of U.S. citizens that could be exploited in a manner that threatens national security, but until now the extent of information of concern has not been publicly detailed. The proposed regulations describe the specific types of information CFIUS will consider sensitive, such as consumer credit reports, health and genetic data, biometric data and financial data tied to specific identifiable individuals. The proposed rules also describe types of data that are not of significant concern, such as the personal data typically collected and maintained by businesses with respect to their own customers and employees. The new rules emphasize that CFIUS’s focus in this area is on companies whose primary business model depends on the collection or usage of large amounts of data on identifiable individuals.
    3. Real Estate. The regulations provide a new stand-alone section of rules related to the acquisition of U.S. real estate by foreign investors. For the first time, CFIUS has defined the types of facilities and the proximity areas around them that will be considered to raise security concerns. An appendix to the proposed rules provides a detailed list of military installations. Although no list is provided, the new rules also apply to real estate located near airports, maritime ports and U.S. government facilities or properties other than listed military installations that are sensitive for reasons of national security. These rules apply specifically to real estate acquisitions, but foreign acquirers of U.S. businesses that operate at sites located near such facilities may also be advised to make voluntary CFIUS filings.

    Conclusion

    As the Department of the Treasury continues to issue new and more complex rules to implement FIRRMA, fund managers should continue to (a) consult with qualified CFIUS counsel; (b) monitor their fund governance/documentation, positions of their foreign investors and fund portfolio investments in order to ensure they comply with mandatory CFIUS filing requirements; and (c) be aware of any risks of CFIUS enforcement where mandatory filings are not required but where CFIUS has jurisdiction to require mitigation or divestment if it finds national security concerns are raised by a particular transaction.

    Fund managers should also expect that the U.S. businesses in which they make significant investments, lenders, co-investors and other counterparties may increasingly ask about the CFIUS status of their funds in due diligence, and should be prepared to make representations in transaction documents as to whether particular funds or investors are not (or are) subject to mandatory CFIUS filing requirements and/or CFIUS jurisdiction.

    More rules implementing FIRRMA are expected in the coming months related to the establishment of filing fees for both mandatory and voluntary CFIUS filings, and the expansion of the mandatory Pilot Program reporting requirements related to critical technologies considered to be “emerging” or “foundational.” If you have any questions regarding FIRRMA regulations or CFIUS compliance, please reach out to the contacts provided below.

    Authored by Peter Jonathan Halasz and Gregory L. Kinzelman.

    If you have any questions regarding FIRRMA regulations or CFIUS compliance, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] 31 CFR § 801.101 et seq.

    [2] To be codified at 31 CFR § 800.248.

    [3] The proposed regulations relate only to procedural and jurisdictional benefits to parties from favored countries. Under current and prior law, CFIUS may assign greater potential national security risk to investors and buyers from certain foreign countries when evaluating particular transactions.

    [4] To be codified at 31 CFR § 800.214.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Peter Jonathan Halasz

    Of Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Still Tax, Even Without the Distributed Cash

    Still Tax, Even Without the Distributed Cash

    ARTICLE

    Still Tax, Even Without the Distributed Cash

    October 22, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights