ARTICLE
A Primer on Exporting and Importing Distilled Spirits
Spring 2020
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
Spring 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
March 6, 2020
Read time: 6 min
The new priorities for tax-exempt organization compensation committees in 2020 primarily fall into four key areas: remaining market competitive for key leaders, succession planning, evolution of the compensation committee to a more strategic role, and examining the bigger picture of executive pay costs and results. This article offers an overview of these emerging topics and trends.
An appointment to the board-level compensation committee of a large tax-exempt organization is a major time commitment, involving complex issues, huge agenda books and challenging oversight matters. And just as one year ends and its challenges are met, a new year begins, and the priorities and focus of the compensation committee continue to shift and grow. The year 2020 is no exception.
The new priorities for compensation committees in 2020 primarily fall into four key areas. Read on for an overview of these emerging topics and trends.
How to Remain Competitive with Regard to Key Leaders
Larger organizations, particularly those that have grown through acquisitions and affiliations, are moving away from lockstep compensation approaches and toward those that help to identify and retain the most critically important leaders. Even though base salary and incentive programs remain uniformly structured and administered, many organizations are considering special compensation approaches for their “superstars,” such as the following:
When special compensation arrangements are considered for select leaders, the compensation committee has a greater burden to show that total compensation remains reasonable under federal tax law standards, and to provide the appropriate supporting rationale. The committee should also take into consideration the disclosure implications on the Form 990 annual tax return, and the tax implications under the still-new Section 4960 excise tax (on annual remuneration over $1 million to any member of the five highest paid employees of the organization), which first applied to fiscal years beginning in 2018.
Succession Planning for the Top Executive Leadership Tier
Compensation committees are grappling with the effects of retirements in top leadership. Although many leaders delayed their retirements during and after the 2008–2009 recession, many have recently retired or are about to retire, and compensation committees find that they have to be prepared for the next wave. Committees are working with the CEO to make sure that emergency successors are identified, and that the next generation of leaders for key executive positions is being identified, assessed and developed with appropriate leadership opportunities. Increasingly, these succession planning efforts are integrated with the focus mentioned above on keeping compensation competitive, as organizations identify the next cohort of top leaders and use long-term incentive plans to challenge, reward and retain those leaders.
When succession planning involves the CEO position in particular, compensation committees face a new set of challenges. Committees are working with the CEO to assess “ready now” and “ready later” candidates for the CEO position, and to ensure that top candidates are being developed. Committees are using compensation mechanisms to retain top succession candidates (to ensure they are not poached and do not grow tired of waiting for the CEO opportunity) and to protect those who ultimately are not chosen. Committees are also working with the CEO to make sure that the timing of search and succession is sufficient for the board but does not lead to a breach in the confidentiality of the process. Compensation committees may find that an advisor experienced in the succession planning process can help them navigate these delicate and difficult issues.
Evolution of the Compensation Committee’s Role
Increasingly, compensation committees are becoming less transactional and more strategic. This shift involves moving away from tasks such as reviewing and approving the compensation of a large number of executive leaders for the organization, and toward strategic priorities such as vetting and approving new approaches to compensation that will help to identify and retain critical current and future leadership, and using compensation to guide where the organization wants or needs to be in five to 10 years.
This change in focus does not mean that review and approval of compensation is no longer an important function of the compensation committee—after all, the “rebuttable presumption of reasonableness” (a principal procedural underpinning of the committee’s work) is still the most important legal protection available to a tax-exempt organization in paying executive compensation. Rather, committees are recognizing that their oversight role may be more effective if they spend less time on the granular review of compensation market data for the fourth tier of executives, for example, and more time on how compensation approaches can be used to ensure appropriate leadership succession, provide greater community access to affordable healthcare, or meet the organization’s long-term strategic objectives.
Looking at the Bigger Picture of Cost and Results
As compensation committees step back from an intense transactional role of reviewing and approving compensation for multiple levels of executive leadership, they more frequently look at the bigger picture of total cost of executive pay and how the organization is performing in its local or regional market, or nationally, on a wide variety of metrics. The cost analysis increasingly includes the long-term cost of retirement supplements, the full potential variation in annual and long-term incentive awards, and the cost of the new Section 4960 excise tax. The performance metrics increasingly include quality and safety dashboards, the relationship of executive pay to operating revenue and other financial indicators, diversity and inclusion, and other indicators of the organization’s reputation and industry stature.
Conclusions
The changing landscape of healthcare, and the growth and increased complexity of hospital systems, are causing compensation committees to adapt their priorities and approaches. These fresh areas of focus for 2020 show that compensation committees are increasingly thinking about how to position their organizations for long-term success through retention of key leaders, succession planning for long-term leadership stability, and broader measurement of competitiveness through a wide variety of external metrics.
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
March 5, 2020
Read time: 4 min
On March 4, 2020, the House passed the Coronavirus Preparedness and Response Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2020, a bipartisan bill to aid in COVID-19 preparedness and response. The bill includes, among other things, provisions that waive certain telehealth requirements during the COVID-19 public health emergency to ensure Medicare beneficiaries can receive telehealth services at home to avoid placing themselves at greater risk of the virus.
Generally, Medicare beneficiaries may only receive telehealth services as a Medicare covered service if:
The bill gives the secretary of the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) the authority to waive the originating site requirement for telehealth services provided to Medicare beneficiaries located in any identified emergency area during emergency periods by a qualified provider. An “emergency area” is a geographical area in which, and an “emergency period” is the period during which, there exists: (a) an emergency or disaster declared by the president pursuant to the National Emergencies Act or the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act; and (b) a public health emergency declared by the secretary. The bill also allows telehealth services to be provided to Medicare beneficiaries via phone, but only if the phone allows for audio-video interaction between the provider and the beneficiary.
The bill takes important steps to allow healthcare providers to deploy telehealth resources in response to COVID-19 and other public health emergencies, and allows Medicare beneficiaries to receive telehealth services from the comfort of their home (even via their smart phone) without risk of exposure. While the bill represents a further step in the expansion of the availability of telehealth services, we should be careful not to overstate its impact. The waiver of the originating site requirement and expansion of telemedicine modalities is limited to emergency areas identified by the president and secretary during emergency periods. Accordingly, as a practical matter, this expansion of availability of telehealth reimbursement is very limited. In addition, healthcare providers must still comply with state laws and regulations that govern telehealth, including, but not limited to, professional licensure, scope of practice, standard of care, patient consent and other reimbursement requirements for non-Medicare beneficiaries.
The bill offers a welcome relaxation of the rigid Medicare requirements for telehealth reimbursement during a time of stress within the healthcare industry. It also represents another, albeit small, step in the gradual acceptance of telehealth within the healthcare reimbursement sector.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
March 5, 2020
Read time: 4 min
CMS issued three Quality, Safety & Oversight memoranda addressed to state survey agencies and state survey agency directors identifying wide-ranging modifications to the survey and certification process in relation to the growing COVID-19 crisis in the United States. This article outlines the guidance provided by the three memoranda.
CMS issued three (3) Quality, Safety & Oversight memoranda (each a QSO Memo) addressed to state survey agencies and state survey agency directors on March 4, 2020, identifying wide-ranging modifications to the survey and certification process in relation to the growing COVID-19 crisis in the United States. The focus of the modifications is described as a “call to action” to healthcare providers to focus on infection control and prevention in light of the spread of COVID-19, and provides mechanisms for CMS and state agency inspectors to focus their efforts, personnel and related resources on addressing COVID-19 spread and containment.
CMS Administrator Seema Verma cautioned that providers “must immediately review their procedures to ensure compliance with CMS infection control requirements, as well as the guidelines from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).” CMS joins the CDC and NIH in shifting their focus to COVID-19 and its impact on the population as the number of cases grows.
The first QSO Memo, entitled Suspension of Survey Activities (QSO-20-12-All), announces the limitation of survey activity to (in order of priority):
Survey protocols for facilities with complaints alleging infection control concerns and/or COVID-19 or other respiratory illness are provided in an attachment to QSO-20-12. CMS also released and will update in “real time” FAQs related to QSO-20-12.
The second QSO Memo, Guidance for Infection Control and Prevention Concerning Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19): FAQs and Considerations for Patient Triage, Placement and Hospital Discharge (QSO-20-13-Hospitals), focuses on hospitals and provides detailed guidance on screening visitors and patients and monitoring and restricting healthcare facility staff from working in case of exposure. QSO020-13 further addresses appropriate actions for hospitals to take in relation to patient placement, evaluating patients with known or suspected COVID-19, precautions in caring for patients requiring diagnostic or therapeutic interventions, and discharge and visitation matters.
The third QSO Memo, Guidance for Infection Control and Prevention of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Nursing Homes, similarly provides guidance designed to help nursing homes limit the transmission of COVID-19, including guidance for monitoring or restricting staff and managing transfers and admissions of patients with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 infection.
Updates to these memoranda are expected as the situation evolves.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
March 4, 2020
Read time: 4 min
Following the recent outbreak of the coronavirus (COVID-19), companies are becoming increasingly concerned about the related financial and commercial implications, including problematic supply chain disruption, workforce disruption and sweeping travel restrictions on both goods and people. Because the potential scope of COVID-19 remains largely unknown, companies must be aptly equipped to deal with these and any other challenges that may arise, particularly those that could result in unforeseen financial distress. Being proactive in the coming months can help companies preserve value and prevent additional harm.
To successfully navigate this uncertainty, management should be prepared to evaluate modifications to current business plans to address changes in operations, potential covenant defaults and other possible contract breaches or defaults; regularly update their requisite cash flow forecasts; and monitor their ability to pay upcoming debt maturities or obtain additional financing, as needed.
The subsequent chart outlines considerations that will help companies proactively and successfully navigate the potential impacts of the spread of COVID-19:
Considerations for Successfully Navigating COVID-19
| Mitigate Supply Chain Disruptions | Identify and mitigate any potential supply chain disruption caused by factory closures, travel restrictions or employee shortages due to illness or quarantine.
Consider short-term changes to supply chain model to avoid disruption (e.g., replacement suppliers or vendors, other production alternatives). Evaluate and consider impact on vendors’ ability to deliver and customers’ ability to pay on time. Review material contracts for any cross-default issues. |
|---|---|
| Contemplate Impending EOD’s or Maturities | Critically review existing debt service obligations to identify possible events of default (e.g., missed interest payments) and assess probable consequences.
Critically review potential covenant defaults resulting from operational disruption. Consider whether there are any upcoming debt maturities in the near future (e.g., next nine months to a year) and assess ability to address them. Consider impact of decreasing loan bids and falling bond prices in the secondary loan market on traded debt. Engage with lenders and other company stakeholders to encourage proactive discussions regarding potential rescheduling of debt or obtaining alternative financing sources. |
| Consider Potential Financial Obstacles | Regularly review actual cash flow status and accurately forecast cash on a regular and rolling basis (e.g., daily) to mitigate potential deficiencies due to supply chain disruption, decreased sales, and extended travel restrictions.
Consider implications of missed targets on ability to achieve overall projections outlined in current business plan and update business plan accordingly. Assess implications for the potential delay of business expansion or consolidation and ability to obtain subsequent rounds of financing. Consider impact on working capital of disruption to supply chain and replacement of existing company vendors. Consider cost of significant workforce disruption and its impact on continued operation of business. Consider cost of implementing programs to protect employee health. Carefully review insurance policies to assess potential recoveries for any business disruption and clarify need for additional coverage as situation develops. |

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / US POLICY
March 4, 2020
Read time: 5 min
Federal courts should “turn to state law to resolve” a “fight over a tax refund,” held a unanimous U.S. Supreme Court on Feb. 25, 2020. Rodriguez v. FDIC (In re United W Bancorp., Inc.), 589 U.S. ___, 2020 WL 889191 (Feb. 25, 2020). Vacating a Tenth Circuit decision, the Supreme Court remanded the case for the lower court to apply state law in resolving “the distribution of a consolidated corporate tax refund.” The bankruptcy trustee of a bank holding company was litigating against the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (“FDIC”), as receiver for the subsidiary bank that had incurred losses generating the refund. According to the Supreme Court, it was not deciding “[w]ho is right about all this … .” Id. at *4. Instead, the court rejected the Tenth Circuit’s application of the Ninth Circuit’s so‑called Bob Richards rule. In re Bob Richards Chrysler‑Plymouth Corp., 473 F.2d 262, 265 (9th Cir. 1973) (in absence of tax allocation agreement, refund belongs to group member responsible for losses that led to it). In so doing, the court rejected the Bob Richards rule as inappropriate federal “common lawmaking.”
The court granted certiorari in Rodriguez not only to resolve a split among the circuits, but also “to decide Bob Richards’ fate.” Id. *3. As it evolved over time, Bob Richards supplied a federal common law rule that, absent a clear agreement to the contrary, tax refunds belong to a taxpayer group member responsible for the losses that led to the refund.
The Internal Revenue Service in Rodriguez paid a tax refund to the bank holding company, although the tax refund had resulted from losses incurred by its bank subsidiary. The bankruptcy trustee of the holding company sued the FDIC, as receiver for the bank, claiming ownership of the refund. The Tenth Circuit, applying Bob Richards, affirmed the district court’s judgment that the tax refund belonged to the FDIC, finding that the parties’ tax allocation agreement was “ambiguous.” Nevertheless, the Tenth Circuit relied on the terms of the document providing that any “ambiguity … shall be resolved … in favor of any insured depository institution.” The parent holding company had an agency relationship “with respect to federal tax refunds” and had agreed to an “equitable allocation of tax liability.” According to the agreement, tax benefits would be computed “on a separate‑entity basis for each” member of the affiliated corporate group.
The court explained how federal courts should resolve a dispute when “the group members dispute the meanings of the terms found in their agreement … . State law is replete with rules readymade for such tasks — rules for interpreting contracts, creating equitable trusts, avoiding unjust enrichment, and much more.” Id. at *2.
Limited Federal Common Law. The court stressed that “there is ‘no federal general common law.’” Id. at *3, quoting Erie R. Co., v. Tompkins, 304 U.S. 64, 78 (1938). Federal judges “may appropriately craft the rules of decision” in such limited areas as admiralty disputes and “certain controversies” between states. But unless Congress authorizes it, “common lawmaking must be ‘necessary to protect uniquely federal interests.’” Id., quoting Texas Industries, Inc. v. Radcliff Materials, Inc., 451 U.S. 630, 640 (1981).
Federal Government’s Indifference to Distribution of Refunds. The federal government regulates how it receives and “also may have an interest in regulating a delivery of any tax refund due a corporate group.” Id. at *3. But it has no “unique interest … in determining how a consolidated corporate tax refund, once paid to a designated agent, is distributed among group members.” Id.
State Law Dispositive. “ … [S]tate law is well equipped to handle disputes involving corporate property rights … like the one” in Rodriguez. Id. Although this dispute arose in a bankruptcy case, “the determination of property rights” in a debtor’s assets is governed by state law. Butner v. United States, 440 U.S. 48, 54 (1979).
The court rejected the Bob Richards rule because it “made the mistake of moving too quickly past important threshold questions at the heart of our separation of powers.” Id. at *4. Emphasizing the “care federal courts should exercise before taking up an invitation to try their hands at common law making,” the court reasoned that the Bob Richards rule tipped the scales in favor of one party. Instead of a judge-made rule presuming that entities responsible for losses get the resulting tax refund in the absence of a clear agreement to the contrary, the issue must be resolved under applicable state law on remand to the Tenth Circuit. Id.
Authored by William H. Gussman, Jr., Alan R. Glickman, and Michael L. Cook.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney or one of the authors.

ARTICLE / REPORT
March 3, 2020
Read time: 10 min
Artificial intelligence (AI) systems have raised concerns in the public—some speculative and some based in contemporary experience. Some of these concerns overlap with concerns about privacy of data, some relate to the effectiveness of AI systems and some relate to the possibility of the misapplication of the technology. At the same time, the development of AI technology is seen as a matter of national priority, and fears of losing the “AI technology race” fuel national efforts to support its development.
The healthcare and life sciences sectors are highly influenced by US government policy; accordingly, these industry sectors should monitor carefully US government policy pronouncements on AI. This special report is the first of two that will review the US government’s overarching national policy on AI, as articulated in Executive Order 13,859, “Maintaining American Leadership in Artificial Intelligence” (Executive Order), and the related draft Office of Management and Budget memorandum entitled “Guidance for Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Applications” (Draft Memo). While these two special reports will provide a high-level review of these documents, they will also highlight certain aspects and other recent developments that may be related to the Executive Order and the Draft Memo.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
March 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Updated: March 17, 2022
Read time: 2 min
To account for higher rates of short- and long-term absences from the workplace, employers may offer current employees additional work or overtime opportunities, or may consider retaining temporary workers in the interim. Employers who utilize temporary workers should understand that in many jurisdictions, the company may be considered a joint employer with the temporary services provider. We recommend contacting counsel to address joint employment considerations when contracting with a temporary services provider.

ARTICLE
March 3, 2020
Read time: 1 min