Content Type: Article

  • CMS Completes Sprint to Modernize the Stark Law—Part I

    ARTICLE

    CMS Completes Sprint to Modernize the Stark Law—Part I

    January 1, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Top Ten Issues in Health Law 2021

    ARTICLE

    Top Ten Issues in Health Law 2021

    January 1, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Eric Zimmerman

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Tony Maida

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Key Takeaways from the AKS Final Rule

    ARTICLE

    Key Takeaways from the AKS Final Rule

    January 1, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Tony Maida

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    James A. Cannatti III

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • OFAC Provides Guidance on Trading Ban in Chinese Companies

    OFAC Provides Guidance on Trading Ban in Chinese Companies

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    OFAC Provides Guidance on Trading Ban in Chinese Companies

    December 31, 2020

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Dec. 28, 2020, the U.S. Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”) issued guidance clarifying the scope of the Trump Administration’s recent Executive Order banning trading in the public securities of certain companies deemed to be supporting the People’s Liberation Army of China (each, a “Covered Company”). The guidance takes the form of five Frequently Asked Questions (“FAQs”) available on OFAC’s website.

    OFAC’s guidance focuses on three issues of particular importance to U.S. investors and to private investment fund managers in the United States and abroad: (1) whether subsidiaries of the Covered Companies are included in the trading ban; (2) what types of securities and financial instruments are covered by the ban; and (3) how the ban affects U.S. investors who invest in funds that hold prohibited securities.

    Background

    On Nov. 12, 2020, President Trump signed Executive Order No. 13959 (“Executive Order”), which, effective Jan. 11, 2021, will impose restrictions on trading by U.S. persons in the securities (and derivatives thereof) of 31 Covered Companies.[1] On Dec. 3, 2020, four other entities were added to the list, bringing the total to 35.[2]

    In general, the Executive Order applies to transactions in “publicly traded securities [of Covered Companies], or any securities that are derivative of, or are designed to provide investment exposure to such securities.”[3] Beginning on Jan. 11, 2021, U.S. persons are prohibited from engaging in “transactions”[4] in the affected securities of the 31 companies, except that U.S. persons may, up until Nov. 11, 2021, engage in transactions “solely to divest” from securities held as of Jan. 11.[5] The Executive Order’s trading ban is described more fully in a prior client alert.[6]

    The effect of the Executive Order as drafted was unclear in a number of respects. As a result, it had been expected that OFAC, which is responsible for administering and enforcing most U.S. economic sanctions programs, would provide clarification as to the scope of the Executive Order. The guidance issued by OFAC yesterday represents at least a first step in that direction.

    >Subsidiaries of Covered Companies

    FAQ 857 addresses a question that, according to press reports,[7] had caused some tension between OFAC and the Department of Defense: Does the trading ban apply to subsidiaries of Covered Companies? A number of the Covered Companies have subsidiaries that are themselves publicly traded.

    OFAC confirms in FAQ 857 that the Executive Order does not cover subsidiaries of Covered Companies unless and until the subsidiary is itself publicly listed by OFAC (pursuant to section 4(a)(iii) of the Executive Order) or designated by the Defense Department under Section 1237 of the National Defense Authorization Act (pursuant to section 4(a)(ii) of the Executive Order).[8]

    However, the FAQ announces that OFAC “intends to publicly list as subsidiaries” subject to the Executive Order any entity that issues publicly traded securities and that is (1) 50% or more owned by one or more Covered Companies or (2) determined to be controlled by one or more Covered Companies.[9] It is not clear when OFAC will publicly list these subsidiaries. The prohibitions on trading in the publicly traded securities of the subsidiaries (or in securities derivative of, or intended to provide investment exposure to, such securities) will take effect 60 days after the subsidiaries are listed by OFAC.

    Securities Encompassed by the Executive Order

    FAQ 858 notes that in some cases, the names of the Covered Companies, as identified pursuant to the Executive Order, do not “match” the names of issuers of publicly traded securities.[10] The FAQ clarifies that the Executive Order’s trading ban applies to entities “with a name that exactly or closely matches” the name of an identified Covered Company.[11]

    To assist investors, OFAC has published a list on its website containing the names of the 35 Covered Companies along with additional identifying information including “a/k/a” names for the entities, issuer names and equity ticker symbols.[12]

    FAQ 859 provides guidance on how OFAC will interpret the term “publicly traded securities” as used in the Executive Order.[13] It explains that OFAC “intends to interpret the term ‘publicly traded securities’ to include securities (as defined in section 4(d) of [the Executive Order]) denominated in any currency that trade on a securities exchange or through the method of trading that is commonly referred to as ‘over-the-counter,’ in any jurisdiction.”[14] The Executive Order does not contain any definition of the term “publicly traded securities,” and merely defines (in section 4(d)) the term “securities” to include the definition found in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.[15]

    FAQ 860 provides “examples” of financial instruments covered by the other parts of the trading ban — “securities that are derivative of, or are designed to provide investment exposure to,” publicly traded securities of Covered Companies.[16] According to the FAQ, such financial instruments include — “but are not limited to” — the following instruments, “to the extent such instruments also meet the definition of “security” as defined in section 4(d)” of the Executive Order:

    • Derivatives (e.g., futures, options, swaps)
    • Warrants
    • ADRs
    • GDRs
    • ETFs
    • Index funds
    • Mutual funds[17]

    Application to Investments by US Persons in Funds Holding Prohibited Securities

    OFAC FAQ 861 gives a broad sweep to the Executive Order’s impact on U.S. investors.[18] It provides, in full:

    Does Executive Order (E.O.) 13959 prohibit U.S. persons from investing in U.S. or foreign funds, such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or other mutual funds, that hold publicly traded securities of a Communist Chinese military company?

    Yes. Under E.O. 13959, any transaction in publicly traded securities, or any securities that are derivative of, or are designed to provide investment exposure to such securities, of any Communist Chinese military company is prohibited regardless of such securities’ share of the underlying index fund, ETF, or derivative thereof.[19]

    Under this FAQ, a U.S. person (beginning on Jan. 11, 2020) cannot make an investment in any “U.S. or foreign fund,” including a foreign fund that is not itself subject to the Executive Order’s trading ban, if the fund holds securities of one (or more) of the Covered Companies. There is no de minimis exception to this ban, as it applies “regardless of” how small a percentage those securities comprise of the fund’s overall portfolio.

    Shortly after OFAC’s publication of the FAQs, U.S. Secretary of State Michael R. Pompeo issued a statement, entitled “Protecting U.S. Investors from Financing Communist Chinese Military Companies,” highlighting the impact of the Executive Order on U.S. investors:

    The Executive Order applies to all transactions by U.S. persons, including individuals, institutional investors, pension funds, university endowments, banks, bond issuers, venture capital firms, private equity firms, index firms, and other U.S. entities, including those operating overseas. This should allay concerns that U.S. investors might unknowingly support CCMCs via direct, indirect, or other passive investments including those linked to educational, ETFs, venture funds, private equity, Real Estate Investment Trusts, commodities, endowments, pensions, or any other investment funds tracking bonds, loans, lease lines, debt or equity indices that include securities of CCMCs or subsidiaries publicly listed by the U.S. government.[20]

    How the FAQ and the Executive Order would apply to hedge funds and private equity funds that are domiciled outside the U.S. and managed by a non-U.S. manager, but that receive investments from U.S. investors, merits careful consideration by both investors and fund managers.


    Authored by Betty Santangelo, Gary Stein, Brian T. Daly, Melissa G.R. Goldstein, and  Hannah M. Thibideau.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your lawyer or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • 5 Takeaways from Vineyard Wind

    5 Takeaways from Vineyard Wind

    ARTICLE

    5 Takeaways from Vineyard Wind

    December 28, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

     

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Jacob Hollinger

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Edward Zaelke

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Christopher Gladbach

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • London’s Status as Disputes Hub in ‘Serious Jeopardy’ Despite Impending Brexit Deal

    London’s Status as Disputes Hub in ‘Serious Jeopardy’ Despite Impending Brexit Deal

    ARTICLE

    London’s Status as Disputes Hub in ‘Serious Jeopardy’ Despite Impending Brexit Deal

    December 24, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • COVID Relief Bill: Key PPP Eligibility Issues Loom Large for New and Second Draw Loans

    COVID Relief Bill: Key PPP Eligibility Issues Loom Large for New and Second Draw Loans

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    COVID Relief Bill: Key PPP Eligibility Issues Loom Large for New and Second Draw Loans

    December 24, 2020

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The COVID-19 relief bill opens the door to new aid for small businesses under the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP). This is welcome news to small businesses throughout the country, but—as detailed below—there are significant issues and uncertainties looming large over the PPP that could render many small businesses ineligible for new or second draw loans.

    In depth

    On December 27, 2020, President Donald Trump signed into law a new $900 billion stimulus bill, which includes $284 billion in funding for PPP loans for small businesses. The $284 billion includes funding for businesses that already received a PPP loan under the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act (referred to as “second draw loans”) and businesses that did not apply for a PPP loan in the first round or are only now eligible under the new expanded eligibility criteria (“new borrowers” or “new loans”). The bill also clarifies that borrowers’ PPP loan expenses are deductible, overriding prior Internal Revenue Service (IRS) guidance on this issue.

    A comprehensive overview of the bill is available here. Below is an overview of certain issues and uncertainties that loom large over new PPP borrowers and borrowers seeking second draw loans. New borrowers considering applying for the first time and those interested in obtaining a second draw loan should pay attention to these provisions when conducting an analysis of whether they are eligible for a loan. As always, we will have to wait for the US Small Business Association (SBA) and Department of the Treasury to issue guidance and rules to carry out the program. As we saw during the first round of the PPP, this guidance may not always be entirely consistent with the legislation or previous administrative rules and guidance.

    Will borrowers need to certify that the loan is “necessary” to maintain ongoing operations?

    • Under the CARES Act, borrowers were required to certify in good faith at the time of loan application that, due to then-current economic uncertainty, the loan was necessary to support the borrower’s ongoing operations.
    • For second draw loans, borrowers will have to meet a new revenue reduction requirement. This requirement provides that eligible borrowers must have “had gross receipts during the first, second, third, or, only with respect to an application submitted on or after January 1, 2021, fourth quarter in 2020 that demonstrate not less than a 25 percent reduction from the gross receipts of the entity during the same quarter in 2019.” It is unclear whether this revenue reduction test will replace or merely supplement the CARES Act’s subjective necessity certification.
    • While second draw loans will have to meet the revenue reduction requirement, the bill does not appear to apply the revenue reduction test to new borrowers. However, it appears that new borrowers will still need to meet the CARES Act’s subjective necessity certification.

    What size test applies for new and second draw loans?

    • Under the CARES Act, businesses could qualify for a PPP loan under any of the following size tests: having no more than 500 employees; the size standard applicable to its North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) code; or the “alternative size standard” found in the Small Business Act.
    • For second draw loans, the bill appears to eliminate the NAICS code and alternative size standard qualification pathways, and it reduces the 500-employee cap to 300.
    • For new borrowers, it does not appear that the bill applies the 300-employee cap across the board to new borrowers that did not obtain a PPP loan between April and August. Instead, the original 500-employee cap from the CARES Act appears to still be in effect for new borrowers.
    • However, specific size limits are specified in the bill for newly eligible entities, such as certain housing cooperatives (300 employees), 501(c)(6) organizations (300 employees) and news/media organizations (500 employees).

    Can businesses that previously qualified for a PPP loan as a “small business concern” under the Small Business Act’s “alternative size standard” or the size standard applicable to their NAICS Code apply for a second draw loan or new loan?

    • For second draw loans, the bill appears to exclude from eligibility borrowers that previously qualified as a “small business concern” under the “alternative size standard” or the borrower’s NAICS Code. It appears to limit second draw loans to businesses that have no more than 300 employees.
    • However, the bill does not appear to extend this limitation to new borrowers.

    What should NAICS Code 72 businesses and franchisees keep in mind when considering a second draw loan?

    • For second draw loans, the bill once again waives the SBA’s affiliation rules for NAICS Code 72 businesses (i.e., restaurant and lodging), franchisees and businesses that receive assistance from a Small Business Investment Company (SBIC).
    • When calculating the maximum loan amount for second draw loans, NAICS Code 72 businesses should take the average monthly payment for payroll costs incurred or paid during either the one-year period before the loan date or calendar year 2019 and multiplying that number by 5. The business will then be eligible to receive the lesser of this figure or $2 million.
    • NAICS Code 72 businesses that employ no more than 300 employees per physical location appear to be eligible even if they employ more than 300 employees across different locations.

    Does the SBA rule implementing an aggregate $20 million cap on loans to borrowers that are part of a “single corporate group” apply to second draw loans?

    • On April 30, 2020, the SBA issued a rule providing that businesses that are part of a single corporate group could not receive more than $20 million of PPP loans in the aggregate after April 30. The SBA defined single corporate group as businesses that are “majority owned, directly or indirectly, by a common parent.” This $20 million cap applied even where the affiliation rules had been waived for specific borrowers in the corporate group (e.g., NAICS 72 and franchisees). The SBA reasoned that this limitation, which was not part of the CARES Act, was necessary to “preserve finite appropriations for PPP loans and ensure broad access for eligible borrowers.”
    • The bill does not include any reference to a cap on loans received across a single corporate group. However, it remains uncertain whether the SBA will again exercise its discretion to implement a cap on the second draw or new loan amounts received across a single corporate group.

    When can a business apply for a new loan or second draw loan?

    • After sending mixed signals for nearly a week after the bill passed Congress, President Trump signed the bill into law on December 27, 2020.
    • Congress provided the SBA 10 days to issue regulations to implement this new bill after it is enacted.
    • Members have Congress have issued statements indicating that they expect the SBA to work over the holidays to enable businesses to apply for new or second draw loans before the end of 2020. This is probably unrealistic, but we expect a fast rollout.

    How will the bill impact the SBA’s audit process?

    • The bill provides the SBA with $50 million to carry out its audit process—which has recently begun for borrowers with loans of $2 million or more—and requires the SBA to submit a “forgiveness audit plan” to Congress within 45 days of the bill’s enactment. Borrowers should keep an eye out for this plan as it will hint at the level of review SBA is conducting or intends to conduct.

    Our team at McDermott has extensive experience advising clients on issues relating to the SBA’s affiliation rules, PPP loan eligibility, PPP loan forgiveness, mergers and acquisitions involving PPP loans, and government investigations and audits. Please let us know if we can assist you and your business.

    Authors

    Llewelyn M. Engel

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • French Supreme Tax Court Upholds Broad Interpretation of Permanent Establishment, Partially Overturns Protective Google Case Precedents on Dependent Agents

    French Supreme Tax Court Upholds Broad Interpretation of Permanent Establishment, Partially Overturns Protective Google Case Precedents on Dependent Agents

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    French Supreme Tax Court Upholds Broad Interpretation of Permanent Establishment, Partially Overturns Protective Google Case Precedents on Dependent Agents

    December 22, 2020

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In a landmark decision of 11 December 2020 involving digital player Conversant (fka Valueclick), the French Supreme Tax Court (Conseil d’État) ruled that a French company can qualify as a dependent agent, and thus as a French permanent establishment, of an Irish affiliate if the French company habitually exercises the authority to conclude contracts in the name of the Irish affiliate, even though formal consent to these contracts can only be given by the Irish affiliate.

    In depth

    This is the first time that the French Supreme Tax Court has ruled on the characterisation of a permanent establishment for a digital player rendering services in France through a non-French entity (Conseil d’État, 11 December 2020, n° 420174, Conversant International Ltd). In doing so, the Court partially overturned the all-or-nothing precedents that the Paris Court of Appeal rendered in a similar and widely publicised tax controversy involving Google Ireland and Google France.

    Like the Google case, the Conversant case involves a digital player that structured its French operations through a French subsidiary (Valueclick France) acting as a marketing and promotional services provider for an Irish affiliate (Valueclick Ireland) that entered into transactions with French clients and carried out the business of the Conversant group on the French market.

    Unlike in the Google case, however, the legal relationships between the French company and its Irish affiliate, and their respective human and material resources, did not reflect their respective involvement in the transactions carried out on the French market.

    Thus, while being a landmark case, this decision also has the hallmarks of a fact-based case.

    Grounds for the Tax Assessments

    Valueclick is a US group that offers online advertising services such as “marketing affiliation services” or “media services”:

    Marketing affiliation services consist of a digital platform that connects advertisers wishing to promote their products with publishers willing to display these advertisements on their site (the publisher receives commission on sales generated by the advertising or information acquired on potential customers). The role of the digital platform, managed by Valueclick, is to act as an intermediary between publisher and advertiser and to calculate the commissions due to the publisher.

    Media services consist of carrying out advertising campaigns on behalf of advertisers by buying targeted space on publishers’ websites.

    All of these online advertising services are the responsibility of Valueclick Ireland on the global market, except for North America.

    For the French market, Valueclick Ireland receives administrative and marketing assistance from Valueclick France. Valueclick France receives compensation for its services on a cost plus 8% basis in accordance with an intragroup services agreement with Valueclick Ireland.

    According to the French tax authorities, Valueclick France negotiated the terms of the contracts concluded by Valueclick Ireland with clients and was involved in drafting certain contractual clauses. The French employees also acted as employees of the Irish company, and clients did not distinguish between the Irish and the French company. Therefore, while not formally empowered to do so, Valueclick France was actually concluding online advertising services agreements on behalf of Valueclick Ireland. On this basis, Valueclick France should be viewed as the dependent agent and thus the permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland. Alternatively, the French tax authorities argued that Valueclick Ireland should be viewed as having a fixed place of business in France through Valueclick France because the services agreement between Valueclick France and Valueclick Ireland was drafted in such broad terms that no distinction was made between Valueclick France’s marketing and promotional services business and Valueclick Ireland’s online advertising business.

    For similar reasons, Valueclick France should also be considered as the permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland for VAT purposes under Article 259 of the French tax code and the VAT directive.

    French Supreme Tax Court Opinion

    The first point of contention was whether Valueclick France could be viewed as the French permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland for corporate income tax purposes within the meaning of Article 2 of the France-Ireland tax treaty (which is consistent with the OECD Model Tax Convention).

    In this respect, the Paris Court of Appeal had ruled that Valueclick France could not qualify as the permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland. First, Valueclick France’s services remained in the scope of the services agreement with Valueclick Ireland; therefore, Valueclick Ireland could not be regarded as having access to Valueclick France’s human and material resources to carry out its own business and thus as having a fixed place of business in France. Second, while Valueclick Ireland merely ratified the contracts prepared and negotiated by the employees of Valueclick France, Valueclick France did not exercise the authority to conclude contracts in the name of Valueclick Ireland; therefore, Valueclick Ireland could not be regarded as having a dependent agent in France.

    While the French Supreme Tax Court did not assess the merits of the characterisation of a fixed place of business of Valueclick Ireland, it did overrule the decision of the Paris Court of Appeal on the qualification of Valueclick France as a dependent agent of Valueclick Ireland.

    Under Article 2(9)(c) of the France-Ireland tax treaty, a dependent agent constitutes the permanent establishment of the principal if that dependent agent has, and habitually exercises, the authority to conclude contracts in the name of the principal.

    According to the French Supreme Tax Court, a French company can qualify as the dependent agent and thus as the French permanent establishment of an Irish affiliate within the meaning of Article 2(9)(c) if that French company habitually makes all the necessary preparations and the actual decision to enter into contracts with clients on behalf of the Irish affiliate, which merely ratifies such contracts on a routine basis and is then legally bound by these transactions. This position is consistent with par. 32.1 and 33 of the OECD commentaries on the articles of the model tax convention.

    In ruling so, the French Supreme Tax Court departed from the formal, all-or-nothing approach of the Paris Court of Appeal set by its Google precedents, whereby the conclusion of contracts is materialised only by the signature of the parties, and thus the French company could never qualify as the dependent agent of its Irish affiliate as long as only the Irish affiliate could formally sign the contracts. This new approach is processual and looks at who, in practice, makes the decision to conclude the contracts. In this case, the contracts were prepared and negotiated by the French company and routinely ratified without modifications by the Irish affiliate. Therefore, the French company was the one concluding the contracts for purposes of Article 2(9)(c) of the tax treaty.

    The second point of contention was whether Valueclick France could be viewed as the French permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland for VAT purposes within the meaning of Article 259 and the VAT directive.

    In this respect, the Paris Court of Appeal had ruled that Valueclick France could not be regarded as having in France the human resources required to autonomously carry out the marketing services because (i) Valueclick France did not have the authority to conclude contracts in the name of Valueclick Ireland, and (ii) the digital platform required to deliver the media and affiliate marketing services was hosted by data centres in the United States, the Netherlands and Sweden.

    The French Supreme Tax Court overruled this decision.

    Under Article 259 of the French tax code and the VAT directive, a permanent establishment for VAT purposes is characterised by a sufficient degree of permanence and a suitable structure in terms of human and technical resources to enable it to provide services or receive services for its own needs.

    According to the French Supreme Tax Court, Valueclick France was able to conclude contracts with clients and had access to the digital platform required to perform the services provided under these contracts, even though the data centres hosting this digital platform were located outside France (and outside Ireland). Valueclick France’s employees had regular exchanges with French clients and could also create and set all the parameters of clients’ accounts on the digital platform without any employees of Valueclick Ireland ever intervening. Therefore, Valueclick Ireland could be regarded as having in France the human resources required to autonomously carry out the marketing services, and consequently could be regarded as a French permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland for VAT purposes. The fact that Valueclick France had more than 50 employees to cover the French market, compared to Valueclick Ireland’s five to seven employees for the entire global market excluding North America, is likely to have weighed significantly in the French Supreme Tax Court’s decision to recognise a French permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland.

    The Permanent Establishment Conundrum

    Subsidiaries are legally distinct from foreign related companies and in general cannot be considered as their permanent establishments. However, case law has found that subsidiaries can qualify under certain conditions as the permanent establishment of a foreign related company (Conseil d’État, 20 June 2003, No. 224407, Interhome AG). This bifurcation applies primarily in cases where a French subsidiary is a dependent agent of the foreign related company, requiring a legal and economic dependence between both companies. A permanent establishment may thereafter be so characterised only if the dependent agent has the authority to conclude, or actually concludes, contracts in the name of the foreign related company, and only if such contracts relate to the foreign related company’s operations (Conseil d’État, 31 March 2010, No. 304715, Zimmer Ltd.) A French subsidiary may also be considered as the permanent establishment of a foreign related company if that foreign related company operates a business through its French subsidiary’s premises and thus has a fixed place of business in France. However, French courts have been restrictive in their approach to this matter, as in all cases where a French subsidiary was recognised as the permanent establishment of a foreign related company, the French subsidiary carried out virtually all of the business of the foreign related company, which itself had little or no substance.

    Indeed, the difficulty for tax authorities to identify permanent establishments in similar contexts – such as limited risk distributor, commissionaire or marketing office arrangements – led to the adoption of the Multilateral Convention, which simultaneously amended the permanent establishment definition of multiple tax treaties through a cross-election mechanism. Under Article 12(1) of the Multilateral Convention, a dependent agent will be considered as the permanent establishment of its principal if the agent habitually concludes contracts on behalf of the principal or plays the primary role leading to the conclusion of contracts routinely concluded without any material modification by the principal.

    In the Conversant case, however, Valueclick France was found to be a permanent establishment of Valueclick Ireland based on a traditional definition of a permanent establishment, not the new definition provided by the Multilateral Convention. Thus, the French Supreme Tax Court brought its interpretation of a dependent agent somewhat closer to the new definition of a permanent establishment. The same reasoning should therefore apply to cases involving companies located in jurisdictions that elected not to include the new definition of a permanent establishment provided by the Multilateral Convention to their tax treaty with France (such as Ireland), or which elected not to apply the Multilateral Convention to their tax treaty with France (such as Switzerland or the United States).

    This ruling also shows that tax structures frequently used among digital players (such as double Irish with a Dutch sandwich structures) are no longer impervious to challenge by the French tax authorities, especially when the human and material resources of the Irish affiliates are disproportionate to those of the French company.

    Going forward, multinational groups of companies that structured their French operations through a French subsidiary acting as a marketing or promotional services provider for a non-French affiliate carrying the legal relationship with clients should review their structure, especially their client onboarding and contract formation process. In order to mitigate the risk of a French permanent establishment, the non-French affiliate should be involved in the negotiation and drafting of contracts with clients, and its role should not be limited to the signature (or “rubber stamping”) of such contract.

    Although the French Supreme Tax Court did not address the issue of the fixed place of business, the French tax authorities raised it, and the opinion of the advocate general points to a potential evolution of case law. Traditionally, if a French subsidiary provides services that remain strictly within the scope of the intercompany services agreement with its non-French affiliate, the French subsidiary should not qualify as a fixed place of business of the non-French affiliate. However, if the intercompany services agreement is drafted in such broad terms that the French subsidiary can in practice carry out all the business of the non-French affiliate, the subsidiary could qualify as a fixed place of business of the non-French affiliate. Therefore, non-French companies should make sure that intercompany services agreement with a French affiliate have a well-defined and limited scope, so that the French company cannot be regarded as carrying out the business of the non-French company.

    Finally, this decision raises the question of the portion of the profit that should be allocated to the permanent establishment. In light of the fact that the activities performed on the French market heavily rely on technological tools developed and owned by entities located abroad, this transfer pricing issue remains unanswered.

    Authors

    Antoine Vergnat

    Partner

    Paris

    Romain Desmonts

    Partner

    Paris

    More insights

  • Proposed Regulations Provide New Rules for Allocating and Apportioning Foreign Income Taxes Relating to Disregarded Payments

    Proposed Regulations Provide New Rules for Allocating and Apportioning Foreign Income Taxes Relating to Disregarded Payments

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Proposed Regulations Provide New Rules for Allocating and Apportioning Foreign Income Taxes Relating to Disregarded Payments

    December 23, 2020

    Read time: 13 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On November 12, 2020, the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) published proposed regulations (REG-101657-20) (the “2020 Proposed Regulations”) in the Federal Register that contain a new comprehensive set of rules addressing the allocation and apportionment of foreign income taxes relating to foreign gross income generated under foreign law by disregarded payments. Also on the same day, Treasury and the IRS published final regulations (TD 9922) (the “2020 Final Regulations”), which address foreign tax credits and related matters, but reserve on the allocation and apportionment of foreign income taxes on disregarded payments.

    In depth

    The rules provided in the 2020 Proposed Regulations would apply for purposes of assigning foreign taxes paid on disregarded payments to or from a foreign branch of a domestic corporation to a section 904 category (i.e., foreign branch category, section 951A category, passive category or general category). They also would apply for purposes of assigning foreign taxes paid by a controlled foreign corporation (CFC) on a payment to or from its disregarded entity to a section 904 category and an income group (e.g., a tested income group, a Subpart F income group or a residual income group) within the section 904 category. The income group to which a tax paid by a CFC is assigned determines whether, and to what extent, a US shareholder of the CFC may claim a deemed paid foreign tax credit.

    The 2020 Proposed Regulations represent a significant departure from the approach taken in the prior proposed regulations published in the Federal Register on December 17, 2019 (REG-105495-19) (the “2019 Proposed Regulations”), as well as from 2019 final regulations (TD 9882) (the “2019 Final Regulations”) that generally apply a “timing difference” rule (described below) to determine how taxes on certain types of disregarded transactions are categorized. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.904-6(a)(1)(iv) (2019 Final Regulations).)

    As a result, the 2020 Proposed Regulations may provide for significantly different availability of foreign tax credits than under the 2019 Final Regulations or the 2019 Proposed Regulations.

    Allocation of Taxes Generally

    In general, taxpayers are required to allocate and apportion foreign income taxes to or among the statutory and residual groupings (e.g., section 904 categories or a CFC’s income groups within a section 904 category) under the following steps: (i) first, assign foreign gross income items to statutory and residual groupings; (ii) second, allocate and apportion foreign law tax deductions to the foreign gross income in such statutory and residual groupings; and (iii) third, allocate and apportion the foreign income tax among such statutory and residual groupings. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.861-20(c) (TD 9922).)

    The most substantive and detailed rules for allocating and apportioning foreign taxes relate to the first step of assigning foreign gross income items to statutory and residual groupings. Foreign gross income items are items of income recognized for foreign law purposes, which may or may not correspond to items of income for US federal income tax purposes. Where there is a US gross income item corresponding to a foreign gross income item, the item of foreign gross income is categorized based on the categorization of the corresponding item of US gross income. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(2)(ii)(A).) Where there is no US gross income item corresponding to a foreign gross income item, the 2020 Final Regulations and the 2020 Proposed Regulations provide various rules for addressing the allocation and apportionment of foreign taxes associated with such foreign income items.

    Foreign taxes imposed on disregarded payments are one category of transactions in which there is a foreign gross income item with no corresponding US item. Under the 2019 Final Regulations and prior regulations, a timing difference rule generally applied to categorize such foreign taxes based on the category to which the item would be allocated if it were recognized for US purposes in the year the tax was imposed (essentially by treating the payment as between regarded entities for foreign tax credit purposes). (A “timing difference” generally arises where there is an item of income that constitutes income under US tax principles but is not recognized for US tax purposes in the current year.) Being very general, this rule was subject to uncertainty in its application to many common fact patterns.

    The 2019 Proposed Regulations provided special rules for categorizing foreign gross income items included because of a taxpayer’s receipt of a disregarded payment. Broadly, the 2019 Proposed Regulations assigned foreign taxes associated with foreign gross income included by reason of a “northbound” disregarded payment (i.e., a payment from a disregarded entity to its regarded owner) to the statutory and residual groupings based on the tax book value of the branch’s assets, and foreign taxes associated with foreign gross income included by reason of a “southbound” disregarded payment (i.e. a payment from a regarded owner to its disregarded entity) to the residual grouping. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(ii)(A) and (B) (2019 Proposed Regulations).) As described above, taxes imposed on foreign gross income assigned to a CFC’s residual income group may not be credited under section 960 or otherwise.

    New Tracing Regime

    In response to comments on the 2019 Proposed Regulations, including a number of comments criticizing the denial of foreign tax credits for “southbound” payments, the 2020 Proposed Regulations introduce a detailed new tracing regime. At a high level, the new rules seek to assign foreign gross income items resulting from disregarded payments based on the category of US gross income items out of which the disregarded payments may be considered to be paid.

    To determine the US gross income to which disregarded payments are considered attributable, the 2020 Proposed Regulations incorporate the foreign branch category income rules of Treas. Reg. § 1.904-4(f) (which apply to assign gross income to the foreign branch category or general category) for allocating foreign taxes of domestic corporations. For allocating foreign taxes of CFCs, the 2020 Proposed Regulations determine the US gross income to which disregarded payments are considered attributable based on the section 954(b)(4) high-tax exception proposed rules, which assign income to “tested units” of a CFC for purposes of applying the high-tax exception (see our prior coverage of the section 954(b)(4) high-tax exception proposed regulations).

    The 2020 Proposed Regulations include specific rules for disregarded “reattribution payments,” disregarded sales or exchanges of property, disregarded remittances and disregarded contributions. Each is discussed in turn below.

    Reattribution Payments

    Reattribution payments generally mean disregarded payments to the extent they result in the reattribution of income from one “taxable unit” to another. Generally, a disregarded payment causes gross income to be attributed from one taxable unit to another to the extent that a deduction for the payment, if regarded, would be allocated against the payor tested unit’s US gross income.

    Statutory or residual groupings to which foreign gross income of a taxable unit is assigned is determined without regard to any reattribution payments made by the taxable unit. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(B)(3).) As a result, foreign taxes that are imposed on foreign gross income that is subject to these reattribution provisions will not be reattributed on account of the reattribution payment.

    With respect to a domestic corporation, a foreign branch and a foreign branch owner are separate taxable units, and Treas. Reg. § 1.904-4(f) provides rules for reattributing income between a foreign branch owner and a foreign branch. Special rules apply in the case of payments to or from “non-branch taxable units” (which include, inter alia, disregarded entities that are not foreign branches). With respect to a foreign corporation, a taxable unit means a tested unit as such term is defined in the high-tax exception proposed regulations.

    For “reattribution payments” (i.e., the portion of a disregarded payment that results in a reattribution of US gross income from the payor taxable unit to the recipient taxable unit), foreign gross income is assigned to the statutory and residual groupings to which the amount of US gross income that is reattributed (i.e., a “reattribution amount”) is initially assigned upon receipt of a disregarded payment by the taxable unit, before taking into account any reattribution payments made by the recipient taxable unit. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(B)(1).)

    Once reattributed, such amounts are subject to certain attribution rules to assign foreign gross income items arising from the reattribution payment to the relevant statutory and residual groupings. For domestic corporations, the attribution rules relating to gross income attributable to the foreign branch category apply, and for foreign corporations, the attribution rules in the high-tax exception proposed regulations apply. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(B)(2); Treas. Reg. § 1.904-4(f)(2) and Prop. Reg. § 1.954-1(d)(1)(iii).)

    The foreign branch category rules generally reattribute US gross income between the general category and foreign branch category for disregarded payments between a foreign branch and its regarded owner that, if regarded for US tax purposes, would be deductible against either general category or foreign branch category income. (See: Treas. Reg. § 1.904-4(f)(2).)

    The high-tax exception proposed regulations adopt the attribution rules relating to gross income attributable to the foreign branch category, but with certain adjustments (e.g., treating disregarded interest payments as reattribution payments to the extent they are deductible in the country where the payor taxable unit is a tax resident). (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.954-1(d)(1)(iii)(B).)

    The 2020 Proposed Regulations also include instructive examples of regarded payments made by one domestic corporation to the foreign branch of another affiliated domestic corporation. In one example, where the domestic affiliate does not file a consolidated return with the payor corporation, the intercompany payment is fully regarded for purposes of determining US and foreign source income of the two corporations. In the other example, the two corporations file a consolidated return; in this scenario, the example illustrates how the consolidated return rules apply to the intercompany payment (i.e., the payment is still regarded, but, under a single entity analysis provided for in the matching rule of Treas. Reg. § 1.1502-13(c), the overall US sourcing result for the consolidated group is the same as if the payment were made directly by a single domestic corporation to its foreign branch). (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.904-4(f)(4)(xv), Example 15.)

    Finally, the Preamble to the 2020 Proposed Regulations notes that taxpayers are not required to apply these reattribution provisions to foreign gross basis taxes (e.g., withholding taxes) imposed on foreign gross income of a taxable unit if such foreign gross basis taxes are not otherwise reassigned pursuant to the above reattribution provisions. Treasury stated that the application of these rules could distort the effective foreign tax rate of the payor taxable unit, and that reattributing foreign gross basis taxes among taxable units by reason of reattribution payments would require complex ordering rules that would be unduly burdensome for taxpayers to apply.

    Disregarded Sales or Exchanges of Property

    The 2020 Proposed Regulations also have specific rules for disregarded sales or exchanges of property. Pursuant thereto, foreign gross income attributable to gain on a disregarded property sale is treated as a timing difference, and associated foreign taxes are assigned to the statutory and residual grouping to which the item of gross income would be assigned if it were included in US gross income. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(D); Treas. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(2)(ii)(A).) Any foreign income resulting from gain recognized on a future regarded disposition of such property, however, must be assigned to a statutory or residual grouping in the same manner as the item of US gross income (or loss), if any, that arises from the same transaction or other realization event from which an item of foreign gross income also arises. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(D); Treas. Reg. §§ 1.861-20(d)(1); -20(b)(2) (“corresponding U.S. item”).)

    Remittances

    The 2020 Proposed Regulations treat a “northbound” disregarded payment that is not a reattribution payment as a remittance for US tax purposes, and include certain provisions addressing foreign gross income arising from such remittances. Pursuant thereto, foreign gross income is assigned to the statutory and residual groupings based on the asset apportionment percentages of the payor taxable unit. This apportionment is based on the asset method as provided by the interest expense apportionment rules, but with modifications to (i) treat stock owned by the taxable unit as an asset of the remitting taxable unit; and (ii) reallocate assets from a payor taxable unit that gives rise to US gross income that is assigned to a recipient taxable unit pursuant to the reattribution rules described above. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(C)(1)(i) and (ii); Treas. Reg. § 1.861-9.) If the payor taxable unit has no assets, the foreign gross income associated with the remittance is allocated to the residual category, and no foreign tax credit is available. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(C)(1)(i).)

    Contributions

    Contributions to disregarded entities must also be taken into account for purposes of allocating and apportioning foreign income taxes under the 2020 Proposed Regulations. Pursuant thereto, foreign gross income and the associated foreign tax resulting from the receipt of a contribution (i.e., a “southbound” payment that is not a reattribution payment) must be assigned to the residual category. Thus, if such taxes are paid by a CFC, such taxes are not eligible to be claimed as a deemed paid foreign tax credit under section 960ry. (See Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(C)(2) and (3); Treas. Reg. § 1.960-1(e).) Treasury believes, according to the Preamble to the 2020 Proposed Regulations, that the rule allocating foreign taxes to the residual grouping will have limited application, since contributions are rarely subject to foreign tax. Regardless, given that a “contribution” includes the portion of a disregarded payment in excess of a reattribution payment, taxpayers should review any “southbound” disregarded payments made by CFCs in their structures (e.g., disregarded interest or royalty payments) to confirm if such payments could be captured by the contribution rules.

    Certain ordering rules require that, in the case of foreign gross income and associated foreign taxes arising from a disregarded payment that includes both a reattribution and a remittance or contribution, taxpayers must first attribute such amounts to the reattribution payment, and any excess thereof is attributed to the remittance or contribution. (See: Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(v)(E)(2); -20(d)(3)(v)(C)(2).) Although the Preamble to the 2020 Proposed Regulations does not offer an explanation, the application of these ordering rules may be limited to situations in which a deductible payment is disallowed under foreign tax law.

    Conclusion

    Treasury’s pivot to the tracing approach in the 2020 Proposed Regulations may, in many instances, yield a more favorable result than the 2019 Proposed Regulations. That said, the complexity of the provisions in the 2020 Proposed Regulations, and the expansive record-keeping requirements arising therefrom, no doubt add to the growing list of taxpayer administrative burdens deriving from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act.

    If finalized, the 2020 Proposed Regulations relating to disregarded payments will apply to taxable years that begin after December 31, 2019, and end after the date on which the regulations become finalized.

    Authors

    Brian H. Jenn

    Partner

    Washington, DC, Chicago

    Bradford E. LaBonte

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Michael J. Wilder

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • FinCEN Releases Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and FAQs Concerning Convertible Virtual Currency and Legal Tender Digital Asset Transactions

    FinCEN Releases Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and FAQs Concerning Convertible Virtual Currency and Legal Tender Digital Asset Transactions

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FinCEN Releases Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and FAQs Concerning Convertible Virtual Currency and Legal Tender Digital Asset Transactions

    December 23, 2020

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Dec. 18, 2020, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) of the U.S. Department of the Treasury issued for public comment a notice of proposed rulemaking (the “NPRM“ or “Proposed Rule”) that would require banks and money services businesses (“MSBs”) to (1) submit reports for transactions exceeding $10,000 USD involving convertible virtual currency (“CVC”) or digital assets with legal tender status (“legal tender digital asset,” or “LTDA”); (2) maintain records of customers’ CVC and LTDA transactions exceeding $3,000 USD; and (3) verify the identity of those customers engaging in CVC or LTDA transactions exceeding $3,000 USD with counterparties using wallets that are either (i) not hosted by a financial institution (“Unhosted Wallets”) or (ii) hosted by a financial institution, but located in a jurisdiction listed on FinCEN’s Foreign Jurisdictions List, which FinCEN is proposing to establish (“High-Risk Jurisdiction Wallet”).[1] The NPRM specifically requests feedback from financial institutions to 24 questions and prompts. Comments may be submitted to FinCEN by Jan. 4, 2021. The shortened notice-and-comment period is due to the Proposed Rule’s close bearing on issues of foreign affairs.

    FinCEN concurrently released a set of Frequently Asked Questions (“FAQs“) providing high-level supplementary guidance as to how the Proposed Rule would impact financial institutions and combat illicit criminal activity. For example, wallets are classified as either “hosted” or “unhosted”; and the rules proposed are similar to those already established for transactions in currency and wire transfers. The FAQs define a hosted wallet as “a digital account hosted by a third-party financial institution, which allows the account-holder (the user) to store, send, and receive cryptocurrency,” and define an unhosted wallet as a wallet that is “not hosted by a third-party financial system […] similar to an anonymous bank account, because the only identifier of the holder is a code. “

    Reporting Requirements for CVC and LTDA Transactions Exceeding $10,000 USD

    The Proposed Rule would require banks and MSBs to file a report for transactions in excess of $10,000 USD initiated between their own customers’ CVC and LTDA hosted wallets and Unhosted Wallets or High-Risk Jurisdiction Wallets. The requirement would apply to both those customers that are senders of CVC or LTDA and those that are recipients of CVC or LTDA, including when customers transfer such CVC or LTDA to themselves. The NPRM further notes that foreign-located MSBs would be required to comply with the Proposed Rule’s CVC and LTDA reporting requirement, but the requirement would apply only to those activities within the United States.

    Similar to the existing currency transaction report (“CTR”) filing requirement, the Proposed Rule would require banks and MSBs to verify and record the identity of the individual presenting the CVC or LTDA transaction, as well as record the identity, account number, and the social security or taxpayer identification number, if any, of any person or entity on whose behalf such transaction is to be effected. Verification of identity must occur through examination of a document (e.g., a driver’s license). The Proposed Rule also provides banks and MSBs 15 days from the date of the reportable transaction to file the CTR, and for purposes of determining whether the $10,000 USD threshold is reached, the NPRM explains that “only CVC or LTDA transactions would need to be aggregated together.” It further notes, “a report would not be required when the total value of a person’s CVC or LTDA transactions plus the person’s currency transactions in a 24-hour period is greater than $10,000 in value, … but the total value of the person’s CVC or LTDA transactions alone is not greater than $10,000 in value.”

    FinCEN is proposing exemptions to this reporting requirement that would make this requirement inapplicable to CVC or LTDA transactions either between hosted wallets held by Bank Secrecy Act —regulated financial institutions or where the counterparty wallet is hosted by a foreign financial institution, except where that foreign financial institution is located in a jurisdiction listed on FinCEN’s Foreign Jurisdictions List.

    Additionally, the Proposed Rule would also modify the prohibition on structuring to capture transactions conducted in CVC or LTDA.

    Recordkeeping Requirements for Customers’ CVC and LTDA Transactions Exceeding $3,000 USD

    The Proposed Rule provides that banks and MSBs would be required to collect and keep the following information related to a CVC or LTDA transaction involving the withdrawal, exchange or other payment or transfer, by, through or to such bank or MSB where (i) a counterparty uses an Unhosted Wallet or High-Risk Jurisdiction Wallet; and (ii) the transaction exceeds $3,000 USD:

    1. Name and physical address of the financial institution’s customer;
    2. Type of CVC or LTDA used in the transaction;
    3. Amount of CVC or LTDA in the transaction;
    4. Time of the transaction;
    5. Assessed value of the transaction in USD, based on the exchange rate circulating at the time of the transaction;
    6. Payment instructions received from the financial institution’s customer, if applicable;
    7. Name and physical address of each counterparty;
    8. Other counterparty information the Secretary of the Treasury may prescribe as mandatory on the reporting form for transactions subject to reporting under 31 CFR § 1010.316;
    9. Any other information that uniquely identifies the transaction, the accounts and the parties involved; and
    10. Any form relating to the transaction that is completed or signed by the customer.

    The Proposed Rule would not require banks and MSBs to aggregate multiple transactions for the purpose of determining whether the $3,000 USD threshold has been met. It further provides that a bank or MSB would be expected to “follow risk-based procedures, consistent with their AML/CFT program, to determine whether to obtain additional information about their customer’s counterparties or take steps to confirm the accuracy of counterparty information.”

    Identity Verification Requirements for Customers Engaging in CVC and LTDA Transactions Exceeding $3,000 USD

    The Proposed Rule would require banks and MSBs to verify the identity of their hosted wallet customers when those customers engage in transactions exceeding $3,000 USD with Unhosted Wallets or High-Risk Jurisdiction Wallets. To that end, the Proposed Rule calls for banks and MSBs to establish risk-based procedures for verifying a hosted wallet customer’s identity — procedures sufficient to allow a bank or MSB to reasonably believe that it knows the customer’s true identity. The NPRM explains that these risk-based procedures would be predicated on “the bank’s or MSB’s assessment of the relevant risks, including those presented by the nature of their relationship with their hosted wallet customer, the transaction activity, and other activity associated with each counterparty and the CVC or LTDA assets.” The NPRM further notes that this verification requirement would include verifying the identity of a person accessing a customer’s account who is not the customer, but who may be initiating a transaction on the customer’s behalf.

    Request for Feedback

    FinCEN also requests feedback in response to 24 questions that it poses to the public. The questions, some of which are reproduced below, concern an array of issues related to the Proposed Rule.

    • For purposes of the Proposed Rule’s CVC/LTDA transaction reporting requirement with respect to High-Risk Jurisdiction Wallets, FinCEN currently includes Burma, Iran and North Korea on its Foreign Jurisdictions List. FinCEN asks which additional jurisdictions, if any, should be added to the Foreign Jurisdictions List, and whether there are particular considerations that should be taken into account when adding or removing jurisdictions to this list.
    • FinCEN has proposed to apply the CVC or LTDA transaction reporting requirement only to banks and MSBs. FinCEN requests feedback as to whether it should extend the obligation to file reports under the Proposed Rule’s CVC or LTDA transaction reporting requirement to financial institutions other than banks and MSBs, such as brokers-dealers, futures commission merchants and mutual funds.
    • While FinCEN believes that those financial institutions already providing CVC or LTDA wallet hosting services are likely capable of handling the implementation of the Proposed Rule’s requirements, FinCEN acknowledges that the initial costs of implementation may be non-trivial. Accordingly, FinCEN asks for input as to what the technical challenges to implementation could be and what might impact a financial institution’s reasonable ability to implement these requirements.

    Banks and MSBs engaging in such transactions are encouraged to review the Proposed Rule and any final rule that is issued and modify their existing internal controls, policies and procedures accordingly.

    Authored by Kara A. Kuchar, Donald J. Mosher, Betty Santangelo, Melissa G.R. Goldstein and Nicholas Zlevor.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The NPRM provides that the list of high-risk jurisdictions would initially be comprised of “jurisdictions of primary money laundering concern (i.e., Burma, Iran and North Korea), but could in the future be expanded to include jurisdictions that are identified to have significant deficiencies in their regulation of CVC or LTDA such that the application of this proposed rule’s recordkeeping and reporting requirements would be appropriate.”


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights