ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Update 2.0: Future Financing Act – Focus on Employee Participation
September 12, 2023
Read time: 6 min
In the latest Financing for the Future Act (Zukunftsfinanzierungsgesetz) draft, the German government made significant adjustments to the intended tax relief for employee share ownership plans (employee shares).
In this article, we explore the main differences between the original draft bill and the current government draft and provide a summary of the proposed improvements to the tax framework for employee shares.
Under the government draft, improvements to the tax framework for employee shares are intended to make asset formation more attractive to employees. In addition to increasing the tax allowance, the adjustments aim to alleviate the problem of so-called “dry” income taxation in connection with employee shares.
THE GOVERNMENT DRAFT VS. THE ORIGINAL DRAFT
- In Section 3 no. 39 EStG, there are plans to raise the tax allowance for employee shares from €1,440 to €5,000. In a departure from the original draft bill, the government draft includes a tax benefit of up to €2,000 that may be granted by means of deferred compensation. A tax benefit exceeding this amount would still have to be granted in addition to the salary owed.
- Under Section 19a EStG, the company-related employee threshold for claiming tax deferral will increase to 1,000 employees, which is four times the current threshold for small- to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). For the annual turnover and balance sheet total, the government draft retains the original draft bill’s increase of two times the SME threshold.
- The government draft eliminates the option to tax the tax benefit from the discounted transfer of employee shares at a flat wage rate of 25% in cases covered by Section 19a EStG.
- The government draft allows for the tax-neutral repurchase of granted employee shares (e.g., in a leaver case) provided for in Section 19a (4) sentence 4 EStG—not only by the employer or an affiliated company of the employer but also in the case of an acquisition by a shareholder of the employer.
OVERVIEW OF THE LEGISLATIVE PROPOSAL
Tax Allowance Increase for Employee Shares
As previously mentioned, the tax exemption (Section 3 no. 39 sentence 1 EStG) for employee shares will increase to €5,000 annually per employee.
To limit windfall gains from targeted deferred compensation and to promote long-term participation in the employer company, the government draft includes the following supplementary provisions:
- If the tax benefit exceeds €2,000 per calendar year, the benefit must be in addition to the salary already owed (i.e., limit the ability to defer compensation).
- In the event of a sale or transfer of the employee shares, the non-cash benefit, which is tax-exempt under Section 3 no. 39 EStG, is to be considered as acquisition costs only after a period of three years.
If the employee shares are sold before the minimum holding period of three years, there would be no subsequent wage taxation. However, the original tax-exempt amount would be indirectly subject to the final withholding tax (25% plus solidarity surcharge and, if applicable, withholding tax) due to the higher capital gain.
The increase in the tax-free amount would make the granting of employee shares notably more attractive for both employers and employees. The requirement for a partial sale of shares to cover the payroll tax (so-called “sell-to-cover”) would only be necessary for individual grants of more than €5,000. This would benefit companies for which a sell-to-cover has previously only been possible with considerable effort due to the low trading volume of their shares.
The possibility of a limited deferred compensation of up to €2,000 per year would also allow so-called “matching models”—in which parts of the cash income are converted into company shares—to benefit from the tax exemption.
Tax Deferral Relief When Granting Employee Shares
The government draft is also intended to facilitate the possibility of tax deferral when granting employee shares under Section 19a EStG. This section, introduced in 2021, is intended to make it possible for employees of startups and growth companies to receive employee shares through tax deferral without dry income taxation. From the perspective of the employer company, this will also have a liquidity-saving effect.
The government draft would also significantly expand the scope of Section 19a EStG:
- In addition to shares granted by the employer, the government draft addresses shares in the employer company granted by a shareholder of the employer. This takes into account the fact that employee shares are often not granted by the employer company itself but by the founding shareholders.
- The government draft extends the deferral option to include the granting of shares in affiliated companies of the employer as defined in Section 18 AktG. The granting of shares to employees in multilevel group structures would also be included.
The government draft raises the thresholds for classification as a beneficiary employer as defined in Section 19a (3) EStG:
- The employer company may not exceed twice the value of the SME threshold in terms of annual sales and annual balance sheet total (maximum €100 million and €86 million, respectively). As for the number of employees, the fourfold increase of the SME threshold to a maximum of 1,000) would replace the existing SME threshold.
- The observation period for exceeding the threshold will increase from two to seven years.
- The company may not have been founded more than 20 years ago (previously 12 years).
The maximum deferral period will be extended from the current 12 years to 20 years from the transfer of the asset interest (Section 19a (4) sentence 1 no. 2 EStG-E). This also applies to shares that were or will be transferred before 2024. However, taxation will continue to apply automatically if the employment relationship with the previous employer is terminated (especially in leaver scenarios).
If employee shares are repurchased by the employer, an affiliated company of the employer or a shareholder of the employer, the remuneration granted by the employer (not the fair market value of the shares) will be used to determine the tax basis (Section 19a (4) sentence 4 second half EStG). Here as well, the common practice is taken into account according to which leaver regulations regularly provide a repurchase value that deviates from the fair market value.
OUTLOOK
Following the issuance of the government draft, the parliamentary legislative process can now begin. We expect the Financing for the Future Act to become law before the end of this year.

Distribution of closed-end funds – On the necessity of revocation instructions under the German Civil Code (BGB)
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Distribution of closed-end funds – On the necessity of revocation instructions under the German Civil Code (BGB)
12. September, 2023
Read time: 6 min
When distributing investment funds and designing the fund documentation, information on revocation rights must be observed. This applies not only to mutual funds, but also to special funds if they are sold to “consumers” as defined by the German Civil Code. In addition to small investors, this may also include semi-professional investors. While the KAGB contains a special regulation in the area of open-end funds, the general regulations of the BGB apply to closed-end funds – which, however, do not apply to investments in closed-end funds. The following article shows which special features have to be observed in the context of revocation rights for closed-end funds and which risks are threatening in case of missing or incorrect information.
Regelungen im KAGB gelten nur für offene Fonds
Das KAGB regelt Widerrufsrechte nur bei offenen Fonds. §305 KAGB gewährt dem Käufer von Anteilen oder Aktien eines offenen Investmentvermögens ein Widerrufsrecht binnen zwei Wochen, wenn der Kauf aufgrund mündlicher Verhandlungen außerhalb der Geschäftsräume des Verkäufers bzw. Vermittlers erfolgt ist. Die Frist beginnt erst mit der ordnungsgemäßen Belehrung über das Widerrufsrecht. Gemäß 305 Abs. 4 KAGB erfolgt die Rückabwicklung jedoch zu dem Anteilpreis am Tag nach Eingang des Widerrufs, so dass zwischenzeitliche Wertveränderungen zu Gunsten bzw. zu Lasten des Anlegers gehen. Das gilt auch dann, wenn der Widerruf wegen einer versäumten Belehrung noch lange nach dem Anteilkauf erfolgen durfte. Zudem besteht das Widerrufsrecht nur für Verbraucher i.S.d. §13 BGB. Hierunter können insbesondere auch semi-professionelle Anleger fallen, sofern sie natürliche Personen sind, so dass die Vorschrift auch im Spezialfondsbereich beachtet werden sollte.
Für geschlossene Investmentvermögen verweist §305 Abs. 7 KAGB hingegen auf die (allgemeinen) Regelungen des BGB.
Informationspflichten und Verbraucher-Widerrufsrecht bei Beteiligung an geschlossenen Fonds
(Auch) die Zeichnung von Anteilen an geschlossenen Fonds wird mitunter im Wege des sog. „Fernabsatzes“ vereinbart. Hierunter fällt beispielsweise der Vertrieb von Fonds per Telefon oder E-Mail. Erfolgt die Zeichnung eines Fonds durch einen Verbraucher im Wege des Fernabsatzes oder auch außerhalb von Geschäftsräumen, ist der Verkäufer bzw. Vermittler verpflichtet, bestimmte Informationspflichten nach §§ 312d Abs. 2 BGB i.V.m. Art. 246b EGBGB zu erfüllen.
Die Informationspflichten nach Art. 246b §§ 1,2 EGBGB bei Finanzdienstleistungen sind umfangreich. Hierzu gehören u.a. die Identität und die Hauptgeschäftstätigkeit des Unternehmers, wesentliche Merkmale der Finanzdienstleistung, Informationen über das Zustandekommen des Vertrages und den Gesamtpreis der Finanzdienstleistung. Hinzu kommen Information über das Bestehen oder Nichtbestehen eines Widerrufsrechts sowie die Bedingungen und Einzelheiten der Ausübung. Der Verkäufer/Vermittler ist verpflichtet, diese dem Verbraucher rechtzeitig vor Abgabe von dessen Vertragserklärung klar und verständlich und unter Angabe des geschäftlichen Zwecks zur Verfügung zu stellen.
Werden die Informationspflichten erfüllt, so steht dem Erwerber der Fondsanteile ein 14tägiges Widerrufsrecht zu. Die Widerrufsfrist beginnt nach Abschluss des Vertrages, der in diesem Kontext regelmäßig mit Aufnahme des Verbrauchers in den Fonds durch Annahme der Zeichnungsunterlagen vorliegt. Dies gilt jedoch nur dann, wenn dem Erwerber der Fondsanteile zu diesem Zeitpunkt alle Informationen gem. Art. 246b §§1,2 EGBGB auf einem dauerhaften Datenträger (z.B. Brief, E-Mail, Telefax, USB-Stick) zur Verfügung gestellt worden sind. Werden die Informationspflichten hingegen nicht oder nicht vollständig erfüllt, so beginnt die Widerrufsfrist nicht zu laufen, mit der Folge, dass ein „ewiges Widerrufsrecht“ besteht, welches u. U. auch nach Jahren noch wirksam ausgeübt werden kann.
Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung nicht passend für geschlossene Fonds
Mit Anlage 3 zu Artikel 246b §2 Abs. 3 Satz 1 EGBGB stellt der Gesetzgeber eine Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung zur Verfügung. Unternehmern (Fondsinitiatoren) steht es frei, die Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung zu verwenden oder andere Widerrufsbelehrungen zu nutzen. Sie tragen jedoch auch bei Verwendung der Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung das Risiko, dass diese Belehrung nicht den gesetzlichen Anforderungen entspricht bzw. von einem Gericht nicht akzeptiert werden wird, sodass die Widerrufsfrist nicht in Gang gesetzt wird und das „ewige Widerrufsrecht“ besteht.
Die Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung klärt u.a. über die Widerrufsfolgen auf: „Im Fall eines wirksamen Widerrufs sind die beiderseits empfangenen Leistungen zurückzugewähren.“ Die Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung bezieht sich also grundsätzlich auf vollständige Rückabwicklung bzw. Rückgewähr der empfangenen Leistungen und passt somit nicht zu den Widerrufsfolgen beim Erwerb von Anteilen geschlossener Fonds in Gesellschaftsform. Dort richtet sich nämlich die Rückabwicklung nach den sog. Grundsätzen der fehlerhaften Gesellschaft.
Tritt der Anleger, wie bei einem geschlossenen Fonds üblich, als Gesellschafter (zB Kommanditist, „Limited Partner“) einer Gesellschaft bei, so kann die Beteiligung an dieser nicht rückwirkend aufgelöst bzw. rückgängig gemacht werden kann. Einem Anleger, der seinen Beitritt wirksam widerruft, steht damit nicht – wie durch die Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung angedeutet – die Rückgewähr seiner Einlage in der geleisteten Höhe zu. Vielmehr steht ihm nur ein Recht auf (außerordentliche) Kündigung des Gesellschaftsvertrags mit Wirkung für die Zukunft zu und damit auch nur ein Anspruch auf das Auseinandersetzungsguthaben im Zeitpunkt seines Ausscheidens. Der widerrufende Gesellschafter ist also bis zum Zeitpunkt des Wirksamwerdens der Kündigung ein Gesellschafter mit allen damit verbundenen Rechten und Pflichten. Er partizipiert bis zum Zeitpunkt seines Ausscheidens an den Gewinnen und Verlusten der Gesellschaft.
Diese Grundsätze können zur Folge haben, dass der widerrufende Verbraucher betragsmäßig deutlich schlechter steht als er stünde, wenn ihm tatsächlich seine geleistete Einlage zurückgezahlt werden müsste. Die gesetzliche Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung macht diesen Umstand nicht deutlich. Der Gesetzgeber hat eine Klarstellung für den Erwerb von Fondsanteilen der genannten Art bisher nicht vorgenommen. Die gesetzliche Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung ist also hinsichtlich der Rechtsfolgen bei Widerruf einer Beteiligung an einem geschlossenen Fonds in Gesellschaftsform unrichtig.
Empfehlung für die Ausgestaltung der Fondsdokumentation geschlossener Fonds
Wird bei der Fondsdokumentation geschlossener Fonds die gesetzliche Muster-Widerrufsbelehrung verwendet, sollte demnach zur Minimierung von Risiken eine Abänderung erfolgen bzw. eine zusätzliche Erklärung eingefügt werden, die auf die besonderen Rechtsfolgen bei Fonds in Gesellschaftsform verweist. Vor allem sollte über das Risiko informiert werden, dass der Anleger im Falle des Widerrufs schlechter stehen kann, als dies der Fall wäre, wenn ihm seine geleistete Einlage zurückgezahlt würde. Andernfalls besteht das Risiko einer fehlerhaften Widerrufsbelehrung mit der Folge des Bestehens eines „ewigen Widerrufsrechts“ für den Fondsanleger.

Employment Law Updates
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Employment Law Updates
September 12, 2023
Read time: 4 min
The NLRB Flip-Flops Again on Work Rules and Handbook Policies
On Aug. 2, 2023, the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB”) adopted a new standard for assessing the legality of workplace rules and handbook policies that affect employees’ rights under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (“NLRA”). The NLRA applies to both unionized and non-unionized employees, and protects employees’ rights to engage in protected concerted activities.
The NLRB’s decision in Stericycle overrules its prior 2017 decision in Boeing, which had provided employers greater flexibility in establishing workplace rules and handbook policies. The NLRB reasoned in Stericycle that this previous standard gave too much weight to employer interests and condoned overbroad work rules. Over the past 25 years, the NLRB has issued conflicting decisions on the applicable test for assessing facially neutral work rules. Under the new standard, facially neutral rules and policies are presumptively unlawful if they have a “reasonable tendency” to chill employees’ exercise of section 7 rights, which include the right to engage in activity for mutual aid or protection. This presumption is interpreted from the perspective of the employee, taking into account the employee’s economic dependence on an employer. The NLRB held that an employer’s intent in maintaining the rule is immaterial, and if an employee could reasonably interpret the rule to have a coercive meaning, the rule is presumptively unlawful. The employer may rebut this presumption by proving the rule advances a legitimate and substantial business interest and the employer is unable to advance that interest with a more narrowly tailored rule. If the employer proves its defense, then the work rule will be found lawful to maintain.
The new standard set forth by the NLRB will be applied retroactively. The decision adopted a case-by-case analysis and rejected prior decisions holding that certain rules and policies are lawful, such as confidentiality during ongoing investigations, no recording policies and rules prohibiting outside employment.
All workplace rules and handbook policies can be subject to legal challenge under the new standard. Employers should review their handbooks and try to narrowly tailor their rules and policies to support their business interests.
New Form I-9
US Citizenship and Immigration Services has issued a revised version of Form 1-9 for Employment Eligibility Verification. The revised form is ready for use now and is available here. Employers may use the current Form I-9 through Oct. 31, 2023. Starting Nov. 1, 2023, failure to use the new Form I-9 may result in penalties. The revised form, among other changes, includes a checkbox allowing employers to indicate they examined Form I-9 documentation remotely under a new alternate procedure, available only to employers enrolled in E-Verify.
Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Martin L. Schmelkin and Scott A. Gold.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

NLRB Abandons Primacy of Secret Ballot Elections: Employers Should Reassess Labor Relations Risk and Develop New Action Plans
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
NLRB Abandons Primacy of Secret Ballot Elections: Employers Should Reassess Labor Relations Risk and Develop New Action Plans
September 11, 2023
Read time: 8 min
In its recent Cemex Construction decision, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) abandoned two fundamental rules enshrined in Supreme Court case law. Both of those Supreme Court decisions prioritized secret ballot elections to determine if employees desired union representation or not and if employers had a duty to bargain with unions.
- In Linden Lumber v. NLRB, 419 U.S. 301 (1974), the Supreme Court held that unions may be validly refused voluntary recognition based on authorization cards or other evidence purporting to show majority status and that unions alone have the burden of invoking the NLRB’s election procedure. No more: now, employers must invoke the NLRB’s election procedure or else employees will not be able to vote in a secret ballot election on whether they want a union or not.
- In NLRB v. Gissel Packing, 395 U.S. 575 (1969), the Supreme Court held that election results may be overridden with a bargaining order instead of a new election only in “exceptional” cases where the possibility of ensuring a rerun election with traditional remedies is slight. No more: now, bargaining orders will be issued to overturn election results (or preclude an election entirely) based on virtually any violation.
The net result is that rules to protect employee choice are being replaced with rules to facilitate unionization without letting the affected employees make that choice in a secret ballot election. This is a radical shift in priority in the administration of the National Labor Relations Act by the current members of the NLRB requiring employers to immediately reassess risk profiles, action plans and employee relations strategies.
ANALYSIS
NLRB Election Petitions
Pre-Cemex, unions seeking to represent employees had to:
- Request and receive voluntary recognition from the employer or
- File an election petition with the NLRB and obtain a majority employee vote in the NLRB-conducted secret ballot election.
Post-Cemex, employers receiving a demand for recognition from a union must promptly file an NLRB election petition or forfeit their employees’ right to a secret ballot election. For employers who fail to do so, the consequences are significant because the NLRB will certify the union based on employee signatures on union authorization cards without an election and order the employer to bargain for a contract. The only defenses for an employer are difficult: proving that the cards are inauthentic or proving that the union’s proposed bargaining unit is fatally flawed.
NLRB Bargaining Orders
Pre-Cemex, the remedy for all but the most outrageous and unfair labor practices has been to order traditional remedies (cease and desist orders, reinstatement of union supporters who were disciplined, notice posting to all employees, etc.) and then hold a new election. Bargaining orders were the exception, not the rule.
Post-Cemex, the exception is now the rule. The NLRB will set aside an election “based on [any] violation…unless the violations…are so minimal or isolated that it is virtually impossible to conclude that the misconduct could have affected the election results.” The employer’s burden of proving what is “virtually impossible” is indeed daunting.
WHAT’S NEXT
While many employers will challenge these NLRB attempts to undermine secret ballot elections as the primary basis for determining union representation, such challenges in the federal appellate courts will take time. Meanwhile, employers must operate under the new rules for the foreseeable future.
And, worse, employers will face retroactive liability because the NLRB announced in its holding that it will apply the Cemex rules retroactively. This has already come to pass: one national grocery store chain received an unfair labor practice charge the very next day which asks the NLRB to (i) set aside an election a union lost in April 2023 and (ii) issue a mandatary bargaining order.
What’s next is troubling for employers. Plus, this danger is amplified by other changes being made by the NLRB, which not only has concurrently issued regulations to speed up election procedures but also issued decisions to expand the scope of what constitutes an unfair labor practice (and thus a basis for a bargaining order).
Employers should consider the following action items to protect their workforces and employee rights:
- Assemble and empower a working group team to evaluate and respond to rapid demands for recognition, including evaluating a demand for recognition, whether the bargaining unit is valid, and whether to pursue a secret ballot election for employees to decide whether they want a union or not.
- Focus on strengthening employee relations in order to hear and respond to employee concerns in real-time. Strong employee relations can further open communication and improve workplace morale.
- Focus on education in advance. This would include providing information about what union authorization cards are and what it means to sign one (including the potential loss of any right to a secret ballot election). Inform employees about their rights and potential tactics third parties may use to target or use them for their own agenda and gains.
- Focus on being prepared. Employers should have an action plan tailored to the unique needs of their workplace including education for managers and supervisors regarding their legal obligations and their rights to truthfully communicate concerning the pros and cons of union representation.
ANALYSIS
NLRB Election Petitions
Pre-Cemex, unions seeking to represent employees had to:
- Request and receive voluntary recognition from the employer or
- File an election petition with the NLRB and obtain a majority employee vote in the NLRB-conducted secret ballot election.
Post-Cemex, employers receiving a demand for recognition from a union must promptly file an NLRB election petition or forfeit their employees’ right to a secret ballot election. For employers who fail to do so, the consequences are significant because the NLRB will certify the union based on employee signatures on union authorization cards without an election and order the employer to bargain for a contract. The only defenses for an employer are difficult: proving that the cards are inauthentic or proving that the union’s proposed bargaining unit is fatally flawed.
NLRB Bargaining Orders
Pre-Cemex, the remedy for all but the most outrageous and unfair labor practices has been to order traditional remedies (cease and desist orders, reinstatement of union supporters who were disciplined, notice posting to all employees, etc.) and then hold a new election. Bargaining orders were the exception, not the rule.
Post-Cemex, the exception is now the rule. The NLRB will set aside an election “based on [any] violation…unless the violations…are so minimal or isolated that it is virtually impossible to conclude that the misconduct could have affected the election results.” The employer’s burden of proving what is “virtually impossible” is indeed daunting.
WHAT’S NEXT
While many employers will challenge these NLRB attempts to undermine secret ballot elections as the primary basis for determining union representation, such challenges in the federal appellate courts will take time. Meanwhile, employers must operate under the new rules for the foreseeable future.
And, worse, employers will face retroactive liability because the NLRB announced in its holding that it will apply the Cemex rules retroactively. This has already come to pass: one national grocery store chain received an unfair labor practice charge the very next day which asks the NLRB to (i) set aside an election a union lost in April 2023 and (ii) issue a mandatary bargaining order.
What’s next is troubling for employers. Plus, this danger is amplified by other changes being made by the NLRB, which not only has concurrently issued regulations to speed up election procedures but also issued decisions to expand the scope of what constitutes an unfair labor practice (and thus a basis for a bargaining order).
Employers should consider the following action items to protect their workforces and employee rights:
- Assemble and empower a working group team to evaluate and respond to rapid demands for recognition, including evaluating a demand for recognition, whether the bargaining unit is valid, and whether to pursue a secret ballot election for employees to decide whether they want a union or not.
- Focus on strengthening employee relations in order to hear and respond to employee concerns in real-time. Strong employee relations can further open communication and improve workplace morale.
- Focus on education in advance. This would include providing information about what union authorization cards are and what it means to sign one (including the potential loss of any right to a secret ballot election). Inform employees about their rights and potential tactics third parties may use to target or use them for their own agenda and gains.
- Focus on being prepared. Employers should have an action plan tailored to the unique needs of their workplace including education for managers and supervisors regarding their legal obligations and their rights to truthfully communicate concerning the pros and cons of union representation.

Proposed Regulations From the IRS Outline Reporting Requirements for Cryptocurrency “Brokers”
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Proposed Regulations From the IRS Outline Reporting Requirements for Cryptocurrency “Brokers”
September 11, 2023
Read time: 14 min
On August 29, 2023, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) published new proposed regulations on tax reporting requirements for cryptocurrency brokers. The proposed regulations build on efforts to expand IRS regulation over cryptocurrency reporting in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (PL 117-58) and modify the existing broker reporting regime to account for the rapidly growing digital asset ecosystem. A broadened definition of “broker” under these rules may increase the number of actors in the crypto space who are required to report.
The proposed regulations also expand the tax rules governing the determination of amount realized and adjusted basis to now cover digital assets. Under the proposed rules, the amount realized by a taxpayer in a digital asset disposition will be equal to the consideration received, reduced by allocable digital asset transaction costs. The basis of a digital asset will be equal to the cost paid, increased by allocable digital asset transaction costs.
These regulations do not take effect immediately. Regulations regarding the computation of gain or loss and the basis of digital assets under Sections 1001 and 1012 will not apply until these rules are adopted as final regulations. The proposed rules for broker reporting on gross proceeds will not apply until January 1, 2025. Similarly, the proposed rules for broker reporting of adjusted basis and the character of gain or loss will not apply until January 1, 2026. The US Department of the Treasury and the IRS are accepting written comments on the proposed regulations until October 30, 2023.
In this article, we outline several of the tax reporting rules for brokers discussed in the proposed regulations with respect to cryptocurrency transactions.
BACKGROUND: DIGITAL ASSETS, EXISTING REPORTING RULES AND THE INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT AND JOBS ACT
Cryptocurrency is here to stay. The total implied market value of digital assets currently exceeds $1 trillion, with an all-time high of $3 trillion. Both Congress and the IRS have turned their attention to the governance of this ecosystem, acknowledging the need for comprehensive guidance as taxpayers continue to participate in digital asset transactions. The IRS’s proposed regulations aim to increase transparency in this market.
Digital Assets Generally
Digital assets are defined as any virtual representation of value that is recorded on a cryptographically secured distributed ledger or any similar technology. Rather than existing in physical form, digital assets are stored in wallets in the form of public and private keys that allow owners to access, control and dispose of them. They are used in a broad range of transactions and may be exchanged for goods, services, real estate, other property and even other digital assets. To facilitate digital asset transactions, trading platforms offer a range of services, including wallet hosting, buy/sell matching, market making, valuation and recordkeeping, often in exchange for transaction fees. The number and complexity of these transactions has steadily grown, raising concerns about the tax gap in digital asset taxation. Ambiguity regarding the proper classification of digital assets (as currency, property, commodity, security or otherwise) has contributed to uncertainty regarding the application of existing tax rules to these assets.
Existing Broker Reporting Rules
Existing rules already govern the tax reporting obligations of brokers, though they do not specifically address digital assets. Under the existing regulations, a broker is defined as a dealer, barter exchange or any other person who (for consideration) regularly acts as a middleman with respect to property or services. Generally, any person who effects sales made by others as a dealer or an agent is a broker. Under the existing reporting rules, any person doing business as a broker must file information returns and furnish payee statements. For example, for each customer for whom a broker has sold stocks, commodities or other specified assets in exchange for cash, the broker must include in their payee statements the customer’s name and address, gross proceeds details and the adjusted basis of certain categories of assets. This information allows US tax authorities to more effectively monitor and tax these transactions. Similar information reporting rules apply to persons transferring securities to a broker, securities issuers who engage in certain actions that affect the basis of their securities, barter exchanges and real estate reporting persons. While these rules implicate a wider range of potential reporting parties, this article will generally focus on the reporting requirements applicable to brokers.
The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act
Passed in 2021, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act clarified several rules regarding how digital assets should be reported by brokers under the existing reporting rules. This was intended to provide the IRS and individual taxpayers with easier access to information on gross proceeds and adjusted basis. The Infrastructure Act clarified the definition of a “broker” to include any person who, for consideration, is responsible for regularly providing any service effectuating transfers of digital assets on behalf of another person. Other definitions such as “specified security” were similarly expanded to apply to the concept of digital assets. Because specified securities are treated as “covered securities” for purposes of basis reporting if acquired on or after January 1, 2023, the effect of this change is that brokers must report on the tax basis of digital assets transferred in sales that they effectuate. The Infrastructure Act also introduced new provisions for broker reporting on non-sale transfers of digital assets that are covered securities, provided that the transfer is not to another broker.
RELEVANT ACTORS: WHO IS A BROKER FOR REPORTING PURPOSES?
The proposed regulations further expand and clarify the definition of a broker for reporting purposes as “any person that stands ready to effect sales to be made by others in the ordinary course of a trade or business.” This generally appears to align with the existing statutory definition of a broker as “any person who (for consideration) is responsible for regularly providing any service effectuating transfers of digital assets on behalf of another person.” Ostensibly a simple definition, the meaning of various terms including “effect,” “person” and “sale,” as well as other rules and exceptions, create a complex architecture for taxpayers to navigate in determining whether they are a broker for reporting purposes. For example, by defining “effect” more broadly and therefore expanding the definition of a broker, the IRS exposes additional actors involved in digital asset transactions to these reporting rules.
Defining “Effect”
The IRS lists several examples of online brokers, including trading platforms that hold custody of their customers’ digital assets and operators with sufficient control or influence over certain noncustodial trading platforms. Some may be surprised to find operators of noncustodial trading platforms are classified as brokers under the new rules. These operators do not necessarily know the identity of their customers or the gross proceeds of their sales, and it therefore may be difficult under their existing infrastructure to report this information. Based on the meaning of “effect,” however, the IRS generally considers persons providing facilitative services that directly or indirectly effectuate the sale of digital assets to be brokers and subject to the new reporting requirements. The IRS considers the ability to require that customers provide this information sufficient to qualify such noncustodial trading platforms as brokers.
Defining “Person”
Based on an expansive definition of “person,” brokers may also be individuals, legal entities, and unincorporated groups or organizations through which any business, financial operation or venture is carried on. This definition also encompasses decentralized groups or organizations that share fees from a trading platform. The IRS specifically contemplates the classification of a decentralized autonomous organization as a person that could be treated as a broker. As a result, owners of governance tokens or taxpayers who otherwise participate in the control of platforms engaging in broker activities may find themselves classified as brokers and subject to the new reporting requirements.
Common Categories of Brokers
Common parties to digital asset transactions that may be considered brokers subject to the reporting rules include digital asset trading platforms that also provide custodial services, operators of noncustodial trading platforms, digital asset payment processors, operators and owners of digital asset kiosks, wallet hosting service providers (to the extent that they function in certain roles or provide certain additional transaction services) and real estate reporting persons with respect to digital assets used as consideration for real estate transactions. In contrast, merchants who merely accept digital assets directly from customers as payment for the provision of goods or services, cryptocurrency miners and other persons solely engaged in validating distributed ledger transactions through proof-of-work or proof-of-stake, and persons solely engaged in selling wallet hardware or licensing wallet software without providing other services are generally not considered brokers.
Non-US Brokers
The proposed rules governing sales effected at an office outside the United States or on behalf of exempt foreign persons are quite complex. Under the proposed regulations, the determination of whether a sale is effected inside or outside the United States will not depend on the physical location of the acts undertaken but on the classification of the broker. A broker may be classified as a US digital asset broker, a controlled foreign corporation digital asset broker or a non-US digital asset broker. Rules for determining the location of a digital asset may depend on the type of broker. Under these rules, it may be possible for a non-US actor to be considered a broker for purposes of these reporting rules.
PROPOSED REGULATIONS: ADAPTING THE BROKER REPORTING RULES FOR DIGITAL ASSETS
Sales Subject to Broker Reporting
The proposed regulations under Section 6045 generally incorporate the concept of digital assets into the existing reporting rules, expanding the definition of a “sale” subject to reporting. Under the proposed regulations, sales include certain dispositions of digital assets for cash and services, property, securities, real estate and other digital assets. The delivery of digital assets pursuant to derivatives or other financial contracts are also sales. Notably, both stablecoins and non-fungible tokens are treated as digital assets for purposes of reporting. However, the IRS explicitly excludes hard fork transactions, airdrops and the receipt of digital assets by broker customers in return for services, such as taking surveys, from the definition of a sale.
Reporting on Gross Proceeds
For each reportable sale, brokers generally must report gross proceeds by following specific rules for computing the amount realized. For example, a broker for a digital asset sale must calculate gross proceeds by taking into account the US dollars or other currency credited to the customer’s account, the fair market value of any property received or the issue price of debt instruments received by the customer, the fair market value of services received by the customer and the allocable digital asset transaction cost (which reduces gross proceeds). Similarly, a digital asset payment processor effecting a sale on behalf of a party must report gross proceeds by considering the amount paid in cash, the fair market value of digital assets received, the digital asset transaction costs withheld and the allocable digital asset transaction cost (which reduces gross proceeds). These calculations depend on the details of each transaction because the fair market value determination may be made by reference to the valuation of the consideration received in exchange for the digital asset.
Reporting on Adjusted Basis
Broker reporting on adjusted basis will also be mandatory for certain digital assets. Specifically, under the proposed regulations, brokers who are otherwise required to make a return with respect to a covered security must report the adjusted basis with respect to those securities. Generally, a covered security is any specified security, including digital assets acquired on or after January 1, 2023, but only if the broker has received a Section 6045A transfer statement with respect to that security. Because Section 6045A rulemaking is still ongoing, for purposes of basis reporting, a “covered security” is currently limited to digital assets acquired in a customer’s account by a broker providing hosted wallet services. Brokers must also report the date and time that the digital asset was purchased and whether any gain or loss with respect to the digital asset is long-term or short-term.
Calculating Amount Realized and Basis for Digital Asset Transactions
The proposed regulations also modify the general rules in Sections 1001 and 1012 for determining the adjusted basis and initial basis for securities to accommodate digital assets. These rules generally apply to property subject to the broker reporting rules even if they are not a security. The initial basis for digital assets will generally be determined based on the cost of the digital asset, increased by any allocable digital asset transaction costs. The amount realized from a disposition involving digital assets generally will be the value of any cash, property, or services received, reduced by any allocable digital asset transaction costs. Special rules for determining the fair market value of such property or services and for allocating digital asset transaction costs to digital assets also apply, depending on the transaction type.
While the proposed regulations under Sections 1001 and 1012 generally refer to a “taxpayer,” the proposed regulations under Section 6045 refer to a “customer” instead. Under the proposed regulations for Section 6045, brokers will be required to report on transactions engaged in by their customers. A customer (within the definition of Section 6045) may not mean the same thing as taxpayer under historic tax ownership principles.
Backup Withholding
Under the existing rules governing withholding for reportable payments, payors must deduct and withhold tax on reportable payments at the statutory backup withholding rate (currently 24%) if the payee fails to provide a taxpayer identification number (TIN) or provides an incorrect TIN. Any reportable payment by a broker is subject to the backup withholding, based on gross proceed amounts. While these rules are already broad enough to cover digital asset transactions, the IRS modified these regulations to specifically include digital asset transactions.
Effective Date
The regulations regarding the computation of gain or loss and the basis of digital assets are proposed to apply to taxable years for all sales and acquisitions of digital assets after the adoption of these rules as final regulations. However, taxpayers may rely on these proposed rules for dispositions in taxable years ending on or after August 29, 2023, so long as they consistently follow the proposed regulations in their entirety and in a consistent manner for all taxable years through the applicability date of the final regulations.
The proposed rules on broker reporting for gross proceeds from the sale of digital assets are applicable if the sale is effected on or after January 1, 2025. Similarly, the proposed rules on broker reporting of adjusted basis and the character of gain or loss with respect to a sale of digital assets are applicable if the sale or exchange is effected on or after January 1, 2026.
CONCLUSION
The proposed regulations on broker reporting do not immediately take effect and are generally not effective until January 1, 2025 (or later). This will allow taxpayers time to interpret and respond to the IRS’s request for comments on these rules. The impact of these rules will likely soon be felt in the digital asset ecosystem. They may require significant changes to the existing infrastructure of digital asset services providers falling within the expanded broker definition. These changes may conflict with anonymity and decentralization, two major characteristics of digital assets that draw taxpayers to transact with them in the first place. On the other hand, clearer reporting standards may provide welcome transparency and additional clarity for taxpayers seeking more secure compliance with US tax laws.
These proposed regulations represent only a portion of the ongoing guidance the IRS plans to release on crypto reporting. The IRS is still considering the regulation of transfer statement reporting, which the current proposed regulations take into account (providing certain exceptions until additional guidance is released). The IRS has requested comments on these proposed regulations, as there are many open questions it is still considering in connection with these rules. Until these regulations are finalized, they are still subject to change and may be modified to more effectively address the tax administration challenges presented by digital assets and related technologies.
While the discussion above provides a broad overview of the broker reporting rules modified by the proposed regulations, many issues are not discussed in this article. Voluntary reporting, coordination rules, ordering rules, foreign sales reporting, barter exchange reporting, real estate transaction reporting and numerous other tax issues are addressed in greater detail in the regulations. The potential consequences these rules merit additional attention. We plan to address several of these issues in a follow-up article.
If you have questions about the tax implications of digital asset transactions or other broker activities, please do not hesitate to contact the authors of this article or your regular McDermott lawyer(s).

UPDATE FUTURE FINANCING LAW – FOCUS ON STOCK CORPORATION AND CAPITAL MARKET LAW
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
UPDATE FUTURE FINANCING LAW – FOCUS ON STOCK CORPORATION AND CAPITAL MARKET LAW
September 11, 2023
Read time: 10 min
With the ambitious goal of strengthening the performance of the German capital market and increasing the attractiveness of Germany as a financial location in the European financial center, the draft bill for a law on the financing of future-proof investments (“draft bill”) was published by the German Federal Ministry of Finance and the German Federal Ministry of Justice on April 12, 2023. The Draft Referendum contained a large number of proposed amendments under corporate, financial market and tax law (see our update Future Financing Act – Focus on Stock Corporation and Capital Market Law).
This was followed on August 17, 2023 by the publication of the draft law on the financing of future-proof investments (Future Financing Act – “ZuFinG-E” and “Government Draft”) by the German government.
In the following, we provide an overview of the key changes under stock corporation law as well as the concretizations and new provisions of the government draft.
I. Einführung der elektronischen Aktie
Bereits im Koalitionsvertrag angelegt und im Eckpunktepapier zum Zukunftsfinanzierungsgesetz angekündigt, soll der Anwendungsbereich des Gesetzes über elektronische Wertpapiere (“eWpG”) auf elektronische Aktien ausgeweitet werden. Bislang konnten im Rahmen des eWpG lediglich Inhaberschuldverschreibungen und Investmentfonds-Anteilscheine elektronisch begeben werden. Durch die vorgeschlagenen Änderungen im eWpG und AktG soll dies zukünftig auch für Aktien möglich sein.
Aktiengesellschaften haben dann die Wahl, ob sie ihre Anteile als herkömmlich verbriefte oder als elektronische Aktien ausgeben. Dabei sollen Namensaktien künftig in beiden Formen elektronischer Wertpapiere nach dem eWpG begeben werden können, d.h. als Zentralregisterwertpapiere und als Kryptowertpapiere (§ 10 Abs. 6 AktG-E).
Inhaberaktien sollen in Fortschreibung der bestehenden Einschränkungen lediglich als Zentralregisterwertpapiere elektronisch begeben werden können (§ 10 Abs. 1 Satz 2 Nr. 3 AktG-E), da der Gesetzgeber für Inhaberaktien bei fehlendem Zentralregister eine Vielzahl gesellschafts- als auch geldwäscherechtlicher Fragestellungen befürchtet.
Der Regierungsentwurf konkretisiert und verschärft die vorgeschlagenen Änderungen des Referentenwurfes nun in einigen Punkten:
- So soll bspw. die Begebung von Krypto-Aktien § 10 Abs. 6 Satz 2 AktG-RegE nur zulässig sein, wenn die Satzung die Eintragung in ein Kryptowertpapierregister gem. § 16 eWpG ausdrücklich zulässt. Die neuen Technologien seien zumindest derzeit vielen Menschen noch nicht hinreichend vertraut und es könnten ggf. Vorbehalte gegenüber Kryptoaktien bestehen. Sieht die Satzung nur allgemein die Zulassung einer Eintragung in das elektronische Register vor, könne damit nur ein zentrales Register gemeint sein.
- Der Regierungsentwurf hält zwar an der Entscheidung fest, die elektronische Inhaberaktie – anders als die elektronische Namensaktie – nur als Zentralregisteraktie und nicht als Kryptoaktie Die Begründung verweist nunmehr jedoch darauf, dass eine etwaige Öffnung für mittels Blockchain-Technologie oder vergleichbarer Technologien begebenen Inhaberaktien zu einem späteren Zeitpunkt diskutiert werden sollen, wenn die Verhandlungen zu der EU-Verordnung zur Verhinderung der Nutzung des Finanzsystems für Zwecke der Geldwäsche oder der Terrorismusfinanzierung abgeschlossen sind.
- Im Hinblick auf die Änderungsvorschläge im eWpG stellt der Regierungsentwurf in einem neuen Absatz 5 klar, dass bei elektronischen Aktien die Satzung der Aktiengesellschaft nicht bei der registerführenden Stelle niederzulegen ist. Diese ist bei Aktiengesellschaften bereits für jedermann aus dem Handelsregister abrufbar. Zudem sieht der Regierungsentwurf Folgeanpassungen der Regelungen vor, die auf die Niederlegung der Emissionsbedingungen Bezug nehmen, da es bei Aktien in der Regel keine begleitenden Emissionsbedingungen gibt.
- Weitere Anpassungen durch den Regierungsentwurf betreffen die Zurechnung des Verschuldens der registerführenden Stelle (§ 21 eWpG-E), Veröffentlichungen von Kryptowertpapieren durch die Aufsichtsbehörde (§ 20 eWpG-E) und ein fristloses Kündigungsrecht des Emittenten für den Fall, dass er eingetragene Wertpapiere auf ein anderes Wertpapierregister überträgt und somit die Führung des Wertpapierregisters und die Führung des Aktienregisters auseinanderfallen würden (§ 30a eWpG-E).
II. Einführung von Mehrstimmrechtsaktien
Durch Streichung des bisherigen Verbots von Mehrstimmrechten in § 12 Abs. 2 AktG sollen zukünftig Mehrstimmrechtsaktien die Beschaffung von Eigenkapital über den Kapitalmarkt attraktiver machen. Insbesondere Start-ups und Wachstumsunternehmen soll durch die Sicherung von Einfluss und Kontrolle über die strategische Ausrichtung des Unternehmens somit die Scheu vor einem Börsengang genommen werden.
Die Modalitäten der Mehrstimmrechte sollen durch Einführung eines neuen § 135a AktG-E geregelt werden, der unter anderem die Begrenzung der Mehrstimmrechte auf höchstens das Zehnfache des Stimmrechts nach § 134 Abs. 1 Satz 1 AktG und ein Erlöschen der Mehrstimmrechte nach spätestens zehn Jahren nach Börsennotierung der Gesellschaft („Sunset Clause“) vorsieht. Dabei soll jedoch – eine qualifizierte Kapitalmehrheit vorausgesetzt – eine satzungsmäßige Verlängerung von weiteren zehn Jahren möglich sein (§ 135a Abs. 2 Satz 3 und 4 AktG-E).
Der Regierungsentwurf ergänzt nun, dass die Verlängerung nur wirksam sein soll, wenn die Aktionäre jeder stimmberechtigten Gattung in Form eines Sonderbeschlusses zugestimmt haben (§ 135a Abs. 2 Satz 6 bis 8 AktG-E).
Zudem sieht der Regierungsentwurf gegenüber dem Referentenentwurf weitere Verschärfungen vor:
- Das Erlöschen der Mehrstimmrechte soll weiterhin nach Aktienübertragung oder zehn Jahren nach Börsennotierung der Gesellschaft erfolgen. Die Mehrstimmrechte sollen nunmehr aber auch nach zehnjähriger Einbeziehung der Aktien in den Freiverkehr erlöschen (§ 135a Abs. 2 Satz 1 und 2 AktG-E).
- Da sich beim Erlöschen von Mehrstimmrechte die Gesamtzahl der Stimmrechte an der betroffenen Gesellschaft reduziert, was zu einer Verschiebung des Stimmgewichts führt, kann es zu einem Überschreiten der Kontrollschwelle nach § 29 Abs. 2 WpÜG kommen. Der Regierungsentwurf verweist daher in seiner Begründung ausdrücklich auf die Möglichkeit einer Befreiung des betroffenen Aktionärs von den übernahmerechtlichen Pflichten nach § 35 WpÜG (Kontrollerwerbsmitteilung, Pflichtangebot) gemäß § 37 WpÜG i.V.m. § 9 Satz 1 Nummer 5 WpÜG-Angebots-VO.
- Im Verhältnis zum Referentenentwurf enthält der Regierungsentwurf zudem für Mehrstimmrechtsaktien die Einschränkung, dass diese bei Beschlüssen über die Bestellung von Abschluss- und Sonderprüfern nur zu einer Stimme berechtigen (§ 135a Abs. 4 AktG-E).
III. Erleichterung von Kapitalerhöhungen
Darüber hinaus soll die Eigenkapitalgewinnung durch eine gesellschaftsrechtliche Erleichterung von Kapitalerhöhungen einfacher werden. Hierzu sieht das ZuFinG-E eine Erhöhung der Grenze für den vereinfachten Bezugsrechtsausschluss von bisher 10 Prozent des Grundkapitals auf 20 Prozent vor (§ 186 Abs. 3 Satz 4 AktG-E).
Zudem sollen die Grenzen des bedingten Kapitals bei Unternehmenszusammenschlüssen sowie für Bezugsrechte von Arbeitnehmern und Mitgliedern der Geschäftsführung erhöht werden:
- Bedingtes Kapital soll zukünftig bei Unternehmenszusammenschlüssen bis zu einer Grenze von 60 Prozent des Grundkapitals statt der bisherigen 50 Prozent möglich sein (§ 192 Abs. 3 Satz 1 AktG-E).
- Die Grenze für Bezugsrechte von Arbeitnehmern und Mitgliedern der Geschäftsführung soll von 10 Prozent auf 20 Prozent erhöht werden (§ 192 Abs. 3 Satz 1 Nr. 2 AktG-E).
Die Neuregelung zum Ausgabebetrag werden zudem um einen Absatz zur Wertbestimmung für börsennotierte Gesellschaften ergänzt, wobei der Wert – einen durchgehenden und funktionierenden Preismechanismus vorausgesetzt – zukünftig ausdrücklich durch den durchschnittlichen Börsenkurs bestimmt wird (§ 255 Abs. 5 AktG-E). Der Regierungsentwurf ergänzt den Referentenentwurf hier um eine Sonderregelung: Ist der Börsenkurs zum Ablauf des der Entscheidung über die Ausgabe neuer Aktien vorausgehenden Tages niedriger als der ermittelte Durchschnittskurs, ist der niedrigere Börsenkurs für die Untergrenze des Ausgabebetrages maßgeblich (§ 255 Abs. 5 AktG-E).
Sah der Referentenentwurf noch generell vor, dass Streitigkeiten über die Angemessenheit der Höhe des Ausgabebetrages bei Kapitalmaßnahmen gemäß § 255 AktG zukünftig nicht mehr im Rahmen eines Anfechtungsverfahrens zuzulassen und stattdessen im Spruchverfahren zu entscheiden sein sollen, modifiziert der Regierungsentwurf nun das im Referentenentwurf angelegte Rechtsschutzsystem:
- Das Anfechtungsverfahren soll weiterhin möglich sein, wenn ein vereinfachter Bezugsrechtsausschluss § 186 Abs. 3 Satz 4 AktG vorliegt, denn in vielen Fällen würde hier bereits eine Entscheidung im Freigabeverfahren gemäß § 246a AktG das Verfahren beschleunigen, weil es sich hier nicht um schwierige Bewertungsfragen handeln wird.
- Demgegenüber sollen Streitigkeiten über die Angemessenheit der Höhe des Ausgabebetrages im Rahmen einer Kapitalerhöhung mit nicht vereinfachtem Bezugsrechtsausschluss dem Anfechtungsverfahren entzogen und dem Spruchverfahren zugewiesen werden (§ 255 Abs. 4 AktG-E).
- Neu hinzugekommen sind zudem die § 255a, 255b AktG-E, nach denen im Kapitalerhöhungsbeschluss für den Ausgleichsanspruch bestimmt werden kann, dass anstelle einer Barleistung zusätzliche Aktien gewährt werden. Durch die Einfügung der Möglichkeit des Ausgleichs durch Aktien soll laut Begründung des Regierungsentwurfs der Kritik Rechnung getragen werden, dass die bislang lediglich vorgesehene bare Ausgleichszahlung nicht als der sachgerechte Schutzmechanismus angesehen wurde.
IV. Einführung von SPACs
Um Unternehmen den Zugang zum Kapitalmarkt zu erleichtern, soll in einem neuen Abschnitt 4a-E des Börsengesetzes (“BörsG“) zukünftig die Special Purpose Acquisition Company (“SPAC“) als eine besondere Rechtsform der Aktiengesellschaft eingeführt werden. Die SPAC bezeichnet eine Mantelgesellschaft ohne eigenes operatives Geschäft, die gegründet wird, um mittels eines Börsengangs Kapital einzusammeln und hiermit ein – vor dem Börsengang unbestimmtes – nicht-börsennotiertes Unternehmen zu übernehmen und so mittelbar an die Börse zu bringen. Vor diesem Hintergrund schlägt das ZuFinG-E als zukünftige Rechtsformbezeichnung den Begriff der Börsenmantelaktiengesellschaft (BMAG) vor.
In dem neuen Abschnitt 4a BörsG-E sieht das ZuFinG-E zahlreiche Sonderregelungen für die neue Rechtsform vor, die dem Aktienrecht gem. § 44 Abs. 7 BörsG-E vorgehen sollen. Davon umfasst sind beispielsweise die zwingende Voraussetzung, virtuelle Hauptversammlungen durch Satzungsregelung zu ermöglichen (§ 44 Abs. 4 Nr. 3 BörsG-E) und die zwingende Auflösung der Gesellschaft, wenn innerhalb einer satzungsmäßig bestimmten Frist keine Zieltransaktion erfolgt (§ 47b Abs. 1 BörsG-E).
Ergänzend regelt der Regierungsentwurf nun, dass für die Verhinderung des Auflösungsgrunds die Zieltransaktion von wesentlichem Umfang sein muss, d.h. das Volumen mindestens 20 Prozent des Werts der Einlagen einschließlich eines etwaigen Aufgelds erreichen muss (§ 47b Abs. 1 BörsG-E).
Der Regierungsentwurf sieht ferner ergänzend vor, dass anstelle einer Aktiengesellschaft auch eine Europäische Gesellschaft (SE) als BMAG verwendet werden kann:
- Das Verhandlungsverfahren über die Beteiligung der Arbeitnehmer in der SE soll nach §§ 4 bis 20 SEBG regulär im Rahmen der Gründung der Europäischen BMAG durchzuführen sein, sofern die an der Gründung beteiligten Gesellschaften allein oder gemeinsam mit ihren betroffenen Tochtergesellschaften zumindest zehn Arbeitnehmer beschäftigen.
- Sofern das Verhandlungsverfahren im Rahmen einer arbeitnehmerlosen Gründung nicht durchgeführt werden konnte, ist das Verfahren nachzuholen, sobald die BMAG allein oder gemeinsam mit ihren Tochtergesellschaften – insbesondere nach Durchführung der Zieltransaktion – eine hinreichende Zahl von Arbeitnehmern beschäftigt.
V. Angleichung des Nachweisstichtages
Für die Hauptversammlungspraxis erfreulich ist ferner der Vorschlag zur Angleichung der Definition des in § 123 Abs. 4 Satz 2 AktG normierten Nachweisstichtages an die Durchführungsverordnung (EU) 2018/1212. Ein materieller Unterschied der Frist bestand durch den abweichenden Wortlaut bislang zwar nicht; die vorgeschlagene Anknüpfung an den „Geschäftsschluss des 22. Tages“ (statt bisher den „Beginn des 21. Tages“) vor der Hauptversammlung beseitigt jedoch die Gefahr von Missverständnissen und Erschwerungen bei den im Einklang mit den EU-Vorschriften anzugebenden Informationen im Rahmen der Mitteilung der Einberufung.
Die vom Referentenentwurf vorgeschlagene Angleichung blieb durch den Regierungsentwurf unverändert.
VI. Erleichterungen bei Börsengängen
Schließlich schlug der Referentenentwurf vereinzelt Erleichterungen bei Börsengängen vor, die der Regierungsentwurf ebenfalls beibehalten hat:
- Zur Stärkung der Wettbewerbsfähigkeit des Kapitalmarktes soll der Mindestbetrag für die voraussichtliche Marktliquidität von 1,25 Mio. Euro auf 1 Mio. Euro herabgesetzt werden (§ 2 Abs. 1 Satz 1 BörsZulVO-E).
- Daneben sollen Börsen zur Senkung der Zulassungskosten für Emittenten in der Börsenordnung zukünftig vorsehen können, dass die Zulassung in gewissen Segmenten auch vom Emittenten allein beantragt werden kann (§ 32 Abs. 2a BörsG-E).
VII. Ausblick
Der Regierungsentwurf wird zeitnah das Gesetzgebungsverfahren durchlaufen, dessen Abschluss ist für den Herbst oder den Winter diesen Jahres beabsichtigt. Während der Großteil der Regelungen bereits am Tag nach der Verkündung des Zukunftsfinanzierungsgesetzes im Bundesgesetzblatt in Kraft treten soll, ist dies für einige andere Regelungen für den 1. Januar 2024 anberaumt. Wir freuen uns, Sie auch weiterhin über die Entwicklungen des geplanten Zukunftsfinanzierungsgesetzes auf dem Laufenden zu halten!

Investing in Healthcare & Life Sciences 2023
ARTICLE / REPORT
Investing in Healthcare & Life Sciences 2023
September 2023
Read time: 2 min
In the ever-changing landscape of global M&A and deal-making, health and life sciences remain top priorities, offering both growth potential and defensive strategies. In these markets, understanding regulatory and policy shifts is crucial. McDermott’s international health and life sciences team excels in working with our clients to anticipate the impact of changing regulatory, reimbursement and strategic issues on their deals.
Dive into our international Guide, where we reveal insights on forthcoming legal and regulatory risk, changes to drug approvals and device certification, upcoming AI regulation, telemedicine, merger control and more. This is your roadmap to navigating the complex regulations and seizing opportunities.

CMS Announces New GUIDE Model for People Living with Dementia and Their Caregivers
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
CMS Announces New GUIDE Model for People Living with Dementia and Their Caregivers
September 8, 2023
Read time: 5 min
The US Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently announced a new, voluntary and nationwide test model designed to support two rapidly growing demographic groups: people living with dementia, and their unpaid caregivers. The Guiding an Improved Dementia Experience (GUIDE) Model will focus on dementia-care management and aims to improve the quality of life for people living with dementia. The model will offer care coordination and care management for individuals living with dementia, while providing education, support and respite services for their caregivers.
Approximately 6.7 million Americans currently live with Alzheimer’s disease or another form of dementia, and that number is expected to more than double by 2060. To address the needs of the growing dementia population and their caregivers, the GUIDE Model seeks to bridge the gaps in care for people with dementia.
Some key components of the model include:
- Model design and purpose: The model will be voluntary and run for eight years (through July 1, 2032) and will be offered nationwide. In this model, Medicare Part B providers (participants) will establish dementia-care programs (DCPs) to provide longitudinal care and support to Medicare beneficiaries living with dementia (beneficiaries), as well as to their family members and other individuals who provide significant amounts of assistance to the beneficiaries (caregivers). The model will be person-centered in its delivery approach and will require participants to provide a defined standardized set of services for beneficiaries and their unpaid caregivers (such services are likely to be defined in the request for applications (RFA) described below, but which has not yet been released). Furthermore, participants are required to form an interdisciplinary care team that must include a care navigator who has received requisite training in dementia, assessment and care planning, as well as a clinician with dementia proficiency.
- Beneficiary eligibility criteria: Beneficiaries are eligible to receive services under the GUIDE Model if they (i) have dementia (as confirmed by a clinician practicing within the model), (ii) are enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B and have Medicare as their primary payer, (iii) are not enrolled in the Medicare hospice benefit and (iv) do not reside in a nursing home. Beneficiaries will be placed in one of five “tiers” based on their disease stage and level of caregiver strain. Each additional tier represents increased beneficiary needs, care intensity and payment.
- Provider participation: Medicare Part B enrolled providers/suppliers that are eligible to bill for Medicare physician fee schedule services are eligible to participate in the GUIDE Model. It should be noted, however, that durable medical equipment and laboratory suppliers are not eligible to participate. To improve the recruitment of diverse beneficiaries, CMS will recruit organizations that do not offer comprehensive dementia care or have experience with alternative payment models. CMS will provide technical assistance and other support to these organizations to prepare them for participation in the model.
- Tracks: The GUIDE model will consist of two tracks, one for established programs and one for new programs. To qualify as an established program, the participant program must (i) have an interdisciplinary care team, (ii) use an electronic health record platform that meets the standards for certified electronic health record technology and (iii) meet care-delivery requirements to be outlined in the RFA. A new program is a program that is not operating a comprehensive, community-based dementia-care program at the time of the model’s announcement. New programs will have a one-year pre-implementation period to establish their programs and will have a performance period that starts on July 1, 2025. The performance period for established programs will begin on July 1, 2024.
- Payment methodology: The model encompasses three types of potential payments: an infrastructure payment, a per-beneficiary-per-month payment and a respite-care payment.
- The infrastructure payment is a one-time, lump-sum amount given to participants in the new-program track to support activities related to program development.
- CMS will make a per-beneficiary-per-month payment, also known as a dementia care management payment (DCMP), to all participants regardless of track. This payment is intended for providing care management and coordination as well as caregiver education and support services. It is not yet clear if the DCMP applies to new programs during their implementation period. The DCMP rates will be adjusted by two factors: a health equity adjustment (HEA) and a performance-based adjustment, both of which aim to incentivize high-quality care.
- Finally, participants can also bill for respite services, which are temporary services provided to a beneficiary in order to give the unpaid caregiver temporary breaks from caregiving. Coverage for respite services is limited to beneficiaries with moderate to severe dementia and who have a caregiver. These respite services are subject to an annual cap.
- Compatibility with other models: Since the GUIDE Model is a condition-specific longitudinal care model, CMS has stated that it is designed to be compatible with other CMS accountable care models and programs (e.g., accountable care organizations (ACO)s and advanced primary care models).
The GUIDE model will launch on July 1, 2024. CMS is currently accepting letters of interest (LOI) for the model through September 15, 2023, and will release an RFA for the model in fall 2023. Further information regarding the model will become available upon the release of the RFA.
Please contact the authors with any questions you may have regarding the GUIDE Model.

New York Proposes Regulations Expanding State’s Ability to Regulate PBMs
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
New York Proposes Regulations Expanding State’s Ability to Regulate PBMs
September 7, 2023
Read time: 9 min
The New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS) recently announced the publication of proposed regulations that would increase the state’s oversight of pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs). According to DFS, the proposed regulations would be “the most comprehensive set of market conduct rules for pharmacy benefit managers in the country.” If enacted, the regulations would govern a wide range of PBM activities. They would regulate contracting with network pharmacies; prohibit preferential treatment of pharmacies owned or affiliated with PBMs; require prior approval for acquisitions of PBMs; and impose consumer protection requirements such as prohibiting market conduct practices deemed unfair, deceptive or abusive, and requiring network adequacy standards.
Comments on the proposed regulations are due October 16, 2023. If adopted following the comment period, the regulations would require compliance by January 1, 2024.
The proposed regulations are lengthy and intricate, but the key provisions are summarized below. Access the complete text.
Applicability
The proposed regulations would impact almost all PBMs operating in New York state. PBMs providing services only to a Medicare prescription drug plan would be exempt from complying with some, but not all, of the proposed regulations. To the extent that a PBM provides services to another health plan in addition to a Medicare prescription drug plan, the requirements would apply. Neither the proposed regulations nor DFS guidance addresses whether the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) would preempt application of the proposed regulations to PBMs that provide services only to self-funded plans. ERISA preemption of state PBM regulation remains a hot topic, as demonstrated in the US Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit’s recent decision in Pharmaceutical Care Management Association v. Mulready.
Contracting with Network Pharmacies
The proposed regulations would regulate PBMs’ contracts with network pharmacies, including prohibiting PBMs from the following:
- Charging pharmacies a fee related to enrollment or participation in a pharmacy network
- Charging pharmacies a fee related to adjudication of claims
- Reimbursing a pharmacy less than what the PBM reimburses a pharmacy that is owned by or affiliated with the PBM
- Retroactively denying or reducing reimbursement for a claim unless the claim was submitted fraudulently, the denial or reduction was made to correct errors identified in an audit, or the pharmacy agreed to an adjustment prior to the denial or reduction
- Prohibiting a pharmacy from engaging in certain discussions or disclosures to covered individuals, selling more affordable alternatives to covered individuals, providing individuals with the option of paying cash, or offering and providing mail or delivery services.
PBMs also would be required to do the following:
- Make unilateral changes or updates to pharmacy contracts only at the time of contract renewal and upon 60 days’ notice
- Disclose in pharmacy contracts the sources used to calculate reimbursement
- Adhere to certain requirements when denying a pharmacy’s application for enrollment or participation in a pharmacy network
- Provide 60 days’ notice when exercising a right of non-renewal for a pharmacy contract, and provide an explanation of the reason for non-renewal.
Credentialing
PBMs would be prohibited from requiring a network pharmacy to renew credentialing more frequently than every three years.
Terminating Pharmacies from Network
PBMs would be prohibited from immediately terminating network pharmacies except in limited specified circumstances, such as bankruptcy or insolvency, fraud, change of pharmacy ownership or where the pharmacy submits no claims for at least 90 days. Otherwise, a pharmacy could not be terminated with less than 60 days prior written notice. PBMs would be required to provide pharmacies with a detailed explanation for the termination, and termination would not release a PBM from its obligation to make payments due to the terminated pharmacy for services properly rendered prior to termination.
Maximum Allowable Cost Pricing Lists and Appeals
The proposed regulations would regulate PBMs using maximum allowable cost (MAC) pricing, including detailing requirements for placing a drug on a MAC price list, reviewing and adjusting MAC lists, and making disclosures to pharmacies regarding MAC lists. The proposed regulations also include several requirements regarding pharmacies’ rights to appeal MAC pricing. PBMs would be prohibited from charging a pharmacy a fee related to re-adjudication of claims resulting from a MAC pricing appeal, regardless of whether such appeal was denied or upheld.
Pricing Models
PBMs would be prohibited from reimbursing a pharmacy or pharmacist for a prescription drug or pharmacy service in an amount less than the national average drug acquisition cost for the prescription drug or pharmacy service at the time the drug is administered or dispensed, plus a professional dispensing fee of $10.18. If the average drug acquisition cost is not available, PBMs would be prohibited from reimbursing in an amount that is less than the wholesale acquisition cost of the drug plus a professional dispensing fee of $10.18.
PBMs would be required to offer a health plan the option of paying the PBM the same price for a prescription drug as the PBM pays a pharmacy for the prescription drug.
PBMs would be prohibited from restricting a pharmacy from dispensing drugs to covered individuals based on volume of claims, therapeutic categories or dispensing rates of other pharmacies. However, the regulations propose an application process whereby a PBM could apply to DFS for permission to restrict a pharmacy from dispensing a prescription drug covered by the covered individual’s health plan on the basis of the above categories.
These requirements would apply to any contract issued, assigned, renewed, recredentialed, extended, amended or otherwise modified on or after January 1, 2024. Any provision in a contract between a PBM and a pharmacy that conflicts with the proposed requirements would be deemed void and unenforceable as of January 1, 2025.
Acquisition of PBMs
The proposed regulations would require DFS’s prior approval for acquiring control of a PBM licensed in New York. A proposed acquisition could be disapproved if such disapproval was “reasonably necessary to protect the interests of [New Yorkers].” The regulations detail factors that DFS may consider in making such a determination, including the following:
- The financial condition of the acquiring person and the PBM
- The trustworthiness of the acquiring person or any of its officers or directors
- The plan for the proper and effective conduct of the PBM’s operations
- The source of the funds or assets for the acquisition
- The fairness of any exchange of shares, assets, cash or other consideration for the shares or assets to be received
- Whether the effect of the acquisition may contribute to excessive concentration and vertical integration of markets
- Whether the acquisition is likely to be hazardous or prejudicial to health plans, covered individuals, pharmacies or any other stakeholders in the pharmaceutical supply chain.
Consumer Protection
The proposed regulations also contain several consumer protection requirements. PBMs would be prohibited from engaging in a variety of conduct, including the following:
- Marketing to individuals or providers to gain dispensing opportunities at pharmacies owned by or affiliated with the PBM
- Including the name of pharmacies in marketing materials (other than lists of all pharmacies in a network)
- Transferring or sharing certain prescription records to a pharmacy owned by or affiliated with the PBM for commercial purposes
- Requiring covered individuals to purchase prescription drugs exclusively through a mail-order pharmacy, except as required by a health plan
- Penalizing covered individuals for not using a pharmacy owned by or affiliated with the PBM, or incentivizing covered individuals to use a pharmacy owned by or affiliated with the PBM
- Removing a drug from a formulary or denying coverage of a drug for the purpose of incentivizing covered individuals to seek coverage from a different health plan
- Charging a shipping fee for use of an in-network pharmacy that provides shipping for prescription drugs
- Prohibiting or limiting covered individuals from selecting an in-network pharmacy of their choice, unless in accordance with a health plan’s requirements.
Maximum Out-of-Pocket Costs
PBMs would be prohibited from requiring a covered person purchasing a covered prescription drug to pay an amount greater than the lesser of the cost-sharing amount under the health plan, the MAC or the cash price for the drug.
Consumer Resources
PBMs that provide clinical, formulary or preferred drug list development or management on behalf of health plans would be required to publish complete lists of covered prescription drugs on each health plan’s formulary drug list. They also would be required to notify covered individuals of any intent to remove a prescription drug from a formulary or to alter cost-sharing requirements. PBMs that perform retail network management or contract with network pharmacies on behalf of health plans would be required to publish a list for each health plan identifying pharmacies with which the PBM contracts.
Network Adequacy
PBMs would be required to have pharmacy networks that meet access requirements within specified distances and with specified hours, do not use pharmacies that only provide mail-order services to meet access standards, and do not require covered individuals to use only pharmacies that are directly or indirectly owned by the PBM, including for all regular prescriptions, refills or specialty drugs regardless of number of days’ supply.
Other Requirements
The proposed regulations touch on a variety of other PBM conduct, including credentialing and accreditation requirements imposed by PBMs on network pharmacies, confidentiality provisions in contracts with network pharmacies, consumer-facing resources, investigations of complaints, and PBM audits and investigations of network pharmacies.
Timeline and Next Steps
The proposed regulations will be open to public comment until October 16, 2023. Any party interested in participating in the rulemaking process must submit comments to the DFS in writing to kristina.magne@dfs.ny.gov. Although the proposed regulations do not have a timeline for formal adoption, since several provisions in the proposed regulations require compliance as of January 1, 2024, the release of a notice of adoption marking the effective date of the proposed regulations could fall anywhere in the last months of 2023.
DFS’s objectives for the proposed regulations are to ensure fairness in contracting between PBMs and pharmacies, increase state oversight of transactions involving pharmacies to “protect the interests of the people of [New York],” and to guarantee that New Yorkers have the information and access they need with regard to pharmacy services. The proposed regulations, if adopted, would create significant requirements for PBMs and would require prompt compliance. Interested parties should submit comments to DFS by October 16, 2023.

The NLRB Sets Forth A New Standard for Recognition of Unions
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
The NLRB Sets Forth A New Standard for Recognition of Unions
September 7, 2023
Read time: 3 min
On Aug. 25, 2023, the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB”) released its decision in Cemex, setting forth a new standard that shifts the burden of union recognition procedures from unions to employers. Under the new standard, when faced with a union demand for recognition based on a majority support of employee-signed cards, employers are obligated to either voluntarily recognize and bargain with the union, or promptly (generally, within two weeks) file a petition with the NLRB seeking an election. Under the new standard, if the employer commits any unfair labor practice(s) that would warrant setting aside the election, the petition will be dismissed and the employer will be subject to a remedial bargaining order. This order will require the employer to bargain with the union without an election verifying that a majority of the employees have designated the union as their bargaining representative. The NLRB stated that its focus is on a “free, fair, and timely representation election,” and that conducting a new election after an employer’s unfair labor practices have been fully adjudicated can never be a truly adequate remedy. “Simply put, an employer cannot have it both ways. It may not insist on an election by refusing to recognize and bargain with the designated majority representative, and then violate the Act in a way that prevents employees from exercising free choice in a timely way.”
In addition to the Cemex decision, the NLRB also announced a new Representation-Case Procedures rule that will fast-track the timeline for election procedures. This rule is set to take effect on Dec. 26, 2023.
The new Cemex standard will likely be subject to legal challenges. In his dissenting opinion, the only Republican member of the NLRB argued that the new standard conflicts with well-established Supreme Court precedent, and is non-binding because the employer in Cemex had committed such egregious unfair labor practices that the violation and remedy would have been the same under the prior standard. Employers will now be required to abide by the new standard and should be prepared for increased union organizing efforts.
Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Martin L. Schmelkin and Scott A. Gold.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
