Content Type: Article

  • Swap Market Regulation: New Rules for Dealers and Major Participants Proposed by CFTC and SEC

    Swap Market Regulation: New Rules for Dealers and Major Participants Proposed by CFTC and SEC

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Swap Market Regulation: New Rules for Dealers and Major Participants Proposed by CFTC and SEC

    January 7, 2011

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (the “CFTC”) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC” and, collectively with the CFTC, the “Commissions”) have jointly proposed rules to define key terms in the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (the “Dodd-Frank Act”) relating to swaps and security-based swaps (“SBSs”). Private investment funds and their managers seem unlikely to be captured within the proposed definition of “swap dealer” or “security-based swap dealer” (each, a “dealer”) though some may have to monitor whether a fund’s swap exposure could classify them as a “major swap participant” or “major security-based swap participant” (each, a “major participant” or “MSP”), which would subject them to significant additional oversight.

    In depth
    Authors

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin – Issue 76

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 76

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 76

    January, 2011

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    COPYRIGHT

    Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 (Amendment): PPL Licence Exemptions Abolished

    The Copyright Designs and Patents Act (CDPA) 1988 (Amendment) Regulations 2010/2694 has abolished, as of 1 January 2011, exemptions in the CDPA that allowed charitable and not-for-profit organisations to play recorded or broadcast music in public without obtaining a PPL licence.

    The Newspaper Licensing Agency Ltd v Meltwater Holding BV: Online Commercial Media Monitoring Services and The End User Licence Debate

    This ruling from Mrs Justice Proudman confirms that businesses using an online commercial media monitoring service require a licence from the Newspaper Licensing Agency Ltd. This is because, when they receive email alerts containing headlines and extracts from newspaper articles, they effectively make copies of such headlines and extracts on their computers.

    ITV Broadcasting Ltd v TV Catch Up Ltd: Communication to The Public of a Broadcast

    Refusing the Defendant’s application for summary judgment in ITV Broadcasting Ltd v TV Catch Up Ltd [2010] EWHC 3063 (Ch), Mr Justice Kitchin has held that, as regards broadcasts, the meaning of communication to the public within Section 20 of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 is not limited to broadcasts but extends to all communications by electronic means, whether one-to-one or one-to-many. As such, ITV, Channel 4 and Channel 5 had a real prospect of proving at trial that the Defendant’s “catch-up TV” service infringed the copyrights in broadcasts of television programmes by converting them to a flash stream accessible to members signed up to receive the stream through the Defendant’s website.

    TRADE MARKS

    La Chemise Lacoste SA and Baker Street Clothing Ltd (ALLIGATOR): Word and Device Marks, Conceptual Similarity and Likelihood of Confusion

    The application for ALLIGATOR was opposed by Lacoste SA in La Chemise Lacoste SA and Baker Street Clothing Ltd (ALLIGATOR) BL 0 333 10 on the basis of its earlier Community and UK registered device marks featuring the well-known Lacoste crocodilian image. The opposition succeeded on the ground of likelihood of confusion arising between the earlier device marks and the ALLIGATOR word mark. Mr Landau considered that “the average relevant consumer will believe that goods and services sold under the respective trade marks emanate from the same or an economically linked undertaking”. On appeal, Mr Hobbs QC overturned that decision, finding that the marks were not linkable by any conceptual similarity and, accordingly, there was no likelihood of confusion between them.

    National Guild of Removers & Storers Ltd v Christopher Silveria: Damages Assessed on The “User” Principle

    In National Guild of Removers & Storers Ltd v Christopher Silveria [2010] EWPCC 15, His Honour Judge Birss QC, sitting in the Patents County Court, has found that damages assessed on the “user” principle are available in cases of trade mark infringement and passing off in the same way as in patent infringement cases. In other words, there is no need for any lost sales to have occurred, damages can be assessed by reference to the amount the infringer would have had to pay in fees to the trade mark proprietor had the infringer acquired the rights to use the name or trade mark in question lawfully (i.e., a reasonable royalty basis).

    Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB v OHIM: Movement Mark and Graphic Representation

    In an application concerning a movement mark (Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications AB v OHIM R443/2010-2), the Second Board of Appeal has annulled the refusal by the Office for Harmonization in the Internal Market (OHIM) to register a mark on behalf of Sony Ericsson, holding that the mark in conjunction with its description met the criteria set out in Article 4 of the Community Trade Mark Regulation (207/09/EC).

    Codorniu Napa Inc v OHIM: Figurative Marks, Wine and Likelihood of Confusion

    In Codorniu Napa Inc v OHIM T-35/08 23 November 2010 (unreported). The EU General Court has found a likelihood of confusion between two figurative marks on the basis of the strong phonetic similarity of the word components ARTESA and ARTESO and the fact that the marks related to identical goods, namely wine, which would commonly be referred to by the average consumer verbally.

    Specsavers International Healthcare Ltd v Asda Stores Ltd: Asda “Rides on The Coat-Tails” of Specsavers’ Reputation

    In October 2009, Asda re-launched its optician services. The logo and straplines used by Asda were alleged by Specsavers to infringe its SPECSAVERS trade marks (word and device) under Articles 9(1)(b) and 9(1)(c) of the Community Trade Mark Regulation

    PATENTS

    Long v Comptroller General of Patents: Insufficiency and Ambiguity

    On appeal in the High Court of England and Wales, it was noted that while it is sometimes permissible to describe an invention by reference to the result to be achieved, it was not permissible in this case because there was a lack of information regarding how the result was to be achieved.

    Unilever plc v Ian Alexander Shanks: Calculating Employee Compensation

    Lord Justice Jacob has clarified the mechanism by which an inventor’s compensation is calculated, specifically where an “outstanding invention” is assigned between companies within the same group. Jacob LJ held that the disposal in Section 41 of the Patents Act 1977 referred to a real disposal and to a real person

    DOMAIN NAMES

    Nominet Opens Registration of Short .uk Domains: Registered Rights Sunrise

    The initial sunrise period for registration of “short” domain names in the United Kingdom was opened by Nominet, the registry for .uk domain names, on 1 December 2010 and closed on 17 January 2011. “Short” domain names include two letter domain names and those which consist of a current second level domain, such as gov.co.uk.

    COMMERCIAL

    OFT Report on Price Framing: Common Pricing Practices and The CPRs

    On 3 December 2010 the Office of Fair Trading published a much anticipated Report on Price Framing in which it sets out its findings on how the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 (CPRs) impact on specific pricing practices identified by psychological and economic studies as being potentially detrimental to consumers

    Eminence Property Developments Ltd v Kevin Heaney:  – “… A Mere Honest Misapprehension… Will Not Justify a Charge of Repudiation”

    A mistake in calculating the number of days (counting “days” rather than “working” days) in a contract’s completion timing led to a dispute (Eminence Property Developments Ltd v Kevin Heaney [2010] EWCA Civ 1168) as to whether it had been repudiated properly and thus terminated validly.

    EDI Central Ltd v National Car Parks Ltd: All Reasonable Endeavours and Utmost Good Faith

    In EDI Central Ltd v National Car Parks Ltd [2010] CSOH 141, Lord Glennie found that EDI Central Ltd had not breached a contractual obligation to pursue, “with all reasonable endeavours and as would be expected of a normal prudent commercial developer experienced in developments of that nature”, the development of an NCP car park. In so finding, Lord Glennie, discussed the differences between “all reasonable endeavours”, “reasonable endeavours” and “best endeavours”.

    Rooney v CSE Bournemouth Ltd: “Terms and Conditions Available Upon Request”

    In Rooney v CSE Bournemouth Ltd [2010] EWCA Civ 1364, the Court of Appeal of England and Wales has held that “terms and conditions available upon request” could be interpreted as incorporating a contractor’s standard terms.

    Mediaprint Zeitungs- und Zeitschriftenverlag GmbH & Co KG v Österreich-Zeitungsverlag GmbH: Prize Promotions and Unfair Commercial Practices

    The European Court of Justice inMediaprint Zeitungs- und Zeitschriftenverlag GmbH & Co KG v Österreich-Zeitungsverlag GmbHC-540/08has held that the possibility of participating in a prize competition, linked to the purchase of a newspaper, does not constitute an unfair commercial practice within the meaning of Article 5(2) of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC), simply on the ground that that is what induced some of the consumers concerned to buy the newspaper in the first place.

    ADVERTISING AND MARKETING

    Lidl SNC v Vierzon Distribution SA: Comparative Advertising and Products Sold in Supermarkets

    The fact that there are differences in the extent to which you might like to eat certain food products depending on their place of production, the ingredients and who produced them, does not, the European Court of Justice has said in Lidl SNC v Vierzon Distribution SA C-159/09, preclude the possibility that an advertisement comparing such products (by reference to price alone, as opposed by reference to any of their other attributes) will fall within the boundaries of permitted comparative advertising, provided the advertisement is not misleading.

    ENTERTAINMENT AND MEDIA

    Spiller v Joseph: Defamation and “Honest Comment”

    The Supreme Court of England and Wales in Spiller v Joseph [2010] UKSC 53 (1 December 2010) has declined to alter radically the defence of “fair comment” in libel claims. However, Lord Phillips renamed the defence “honest comment” and amended it to reduce slightly the burden on claimants when identifying on which facts the comment is based.

    JIH v News Group Newspapers Ltd: Privacy, Interim Injunction, Open Justice and Refusal to Grant Anonymity

    In JIH v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2010] EWHC 2818 (QB), the High Court of England and Wales refused to continue an anonymity order, despite the parties having agreed thereto, but agreed to continue an order to withhold all information concerning the subject matter of the case.

    DATA PROTECTION

    ICO Imposes First Financial Penalties for Serious Data Protection Breaches

    The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has imposed its first financial penalties for serious data protection breaches under Section 55A of the Data Protection Act 1998. Stopping well short of the maximum that the ICO can impose, the penalties—£100,000 on Hertfordshire County Council for two separate incidents involving highly sensitive information faxed to the wrong recipients and £60,000 on employment services company A4e Ltd after it lost an unencrypted laptop containing sensitive personal data—are nevertheless substantial and a clear warning to data controllers in all sectors against insufficient data security controls and internal procedures.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Know-How in Corporate Acquisition

    ARTICLE

    Know-How in Corporate Acquisition

    December 5, 2010

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In this article Dr. Ralf Weisser and Dr. Vera Glas discuss all you need to know in Corporate Acquisitions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin – Issue 75

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 75

    November, 2010

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY (GENERAL)

    IPO Consultation: Setting The Limit on The Value of Claims Heard in The UK Patents County Court

    The UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) has launched a consultation, which closes on 3 December 2010, to determine whether a cap of £500,000 should be put on the value of claims to be heard at the Patents County Court.

    PATENTS

    Persons Skilled in the Art: Obviousness and Sufficiency

    Reversing a High Court decision on the invalidity of two patents Lord Justice Jacob has held that the person skilled in the art can differ, depending on whether the test is used to determine obviousness or in relation to sufficiency and claim interpretation.

    Tate & Lyle Technology Ltd v Roquette Freres: Claim Construction Destroys Novelty

    The Court of Appeal of England and Wales has held that, on the basis of the facts presented, the construction of a patent claim destroyed its novelty.

    Grimme Maschinenfabrik GmbH & Co KG v Derek Scott (t/a Scotts Potato Machinery): Contributory Infringement and “Means Essential”

    The Court of Appeal of England and Wales has held that the supply of an entire and non-infringing machine, which could be modified by the removal of a part and substitution of another part so as to infringe a patent, constituted contributory infringement under Section 60(2) of the Patents Act 1977

    COPYRIGHT

    Harry Potter v Willy the Wizard

    In Paul Gregory Allen (acting as trustee of Adrian Jacobs (deceased)) v Bloomsbury Publishing plc [2010] EWHC 2560 (Ch)  Mr Justice Kitchin denied a summary judgment application against claims that Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire infringed the copyright in Willy the Wizard.

    TRADE MARKS

    Socks World International Ltd and Beko Plc: Intention and Unfair Advantage

    Taking into account the judgment of the European Court of Justice in L’Oréal v Bellure C-487/07, Daniel Alexander QC overturned the hearing officer’s decision rejecting an opposition by Beko against Socks World’s application for the stylised trade mark BEKO SPORT, finding that use in the United Kingdom of the mark would take unfair advantage of the distinctive character or repute of Beko’s earlier BEKO mark under Section 5(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1994.

    DHL Express (France) v Chronopost SA (Opinion of Advocate General Pedro Cruz Villalón): Injunction Effective Throughout the European Union

    On a reference to the European Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling from the Cour de Cassation in France in DHL Express (France) v Chronopost SA [2010] C-235/09, Advocate General Pedro Cruz Villalón has opined that an injunction prohibiting an infringer of a Community Trade Mark from continuing to infringe has effect throughout the whole of the European Union.

    DESIGNS

    Dyson Ltd v Vax Ltd: Overall Impression, Design Corpus and Design Freedom

    Mr Justice Arnold held that Vax Ltd had not infringed a UK registered design—owned by Dyson Ltd in relation to the latter’s Dual Cyclone vacuum cleaner—by importing and marketing the Mach Zen C-91 MZ vacuum cleaner. Although there were some similarities between the designs, there were also some significant differences, making the overall impression produced by the two designs different.

    DATABASES

    Beechwood House Publishing Ltd v Guardian Products Ltd: Sui Generis Right and Extraction of Substantial Part

    An application for summary judgment with respect to a claim for database right infringement was dismissed on the grounds that the applicant Claimant had failed to show that the Defendant had extracted a substantial part of its database.

    COMMERCIAL

    European Parliament’s Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection Briefing Paper on the Proposed Consumer Rights Directive: Disharmony Over Full Harmonisation

    The Briefing Paper analyses a number of different models of harmonisation and the impact of full harmonisation on Member States’ substantive laws and on the workload of the European Court of Justice.

    Gary Fearns (trading as Autopaint International) v Anglo-Dutch Paint & Chemical Ltd: Operative Date for Set-Off of Damages in Different Currencies

    The date when the Claimant’s damages and the sum he owed to one of the Defendants was to be converted into a common currency and set off to derive a net liability, was the date of final determination of liabilities (i.e., the date of judgment), not the date the claim arose.

    Oceanbulk Shipping & Trading SA v TMT Asia Ltd: Without Prejudice Negotiations and The Interpretation Exception

    The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom has reversed a decision of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales and added a further exception to the general inadmissability of without privilege communications—the “interpretation exception”—which brings without prejudice negotiations in line with the approach to pre-contract negotiations.

    DATA PROTECTION

    Information Commissioner’s Office Data Sharing Code of Practice Consultation: Draft Code on Lawful and Effective Data Sharing

    On 7 October 2010, the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) published a draft statutory Code of conduct for the sharing of personal data under its powers under Sections 52A and 52D of the Data Protection Act 1998. The ICO is conducting a consultation on the content of the proposed Code. The Code will have statutory effect and, whilst it does not impose additional legal obligations and is not intended to be an authoritative statement of the law, it is designed to be used in evidence in legal proceedings and this is not limited to proceedings under the Data Protection Act.

    SPORT

    Giedo Van der Garde BV v Force India Formula One Team Ltd: Breach of Service Agreement, Restitution and “Wrotham Park” Damages

    In a detailed judgment, Mr Justice Stadlen has found that Force India Formula One Team Ltd was in breach of its contract with Formula One aspirant Giedo Van der Garde by not providing him with the minimum number of driving kilometres for which Mr Van der Garde had paid US$3 million in the hope of gaining enough experience to win a Formula One driving seat. Undertaking a thorough review of the law of restitution and total failure of consideration, Stadlen J held that restitution did not apply as the failure of consideration had not been total.

    Olympics, Paralympics and London Olympics Association Rights: Remedies for Infringement

    Regulations, which take effect from 8 November 2010, have been published setting out the orders a court can make to protect the right of association with the London Olympics.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin – Issue 74

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 74

    October, 2010

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    COPYRIGHT

    Robin Meakin v BBC: Television Programme Proposals, Format Rights and Conspiracy Theories

    In a UK copyright case concerning TV game-show formats, Arnold J granted the Defendants summary judgment and provided an overview of the approach the court will take in relation to the protection of TV formats. Essentially, the question was whether there was derivation—assessed on the basis of any similarities with and access to Mr Meakin’s proposals—and whether there was reproduction of a substantial part thereof. The court concluded that there was neither.

    TRADE MARKS 

    Companhia Muller de Bebidas v The Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market: Numerical Elements and Likelihood of Confusion

    Following a detailed analysis of the distinctive and dominant elements of the Applicant’s figurative mark “61 a nossa alegria” and a number of the Opponent’s earlier trade marks incorporating the words “cachaça 51”, the General Court overruled a decision of the Board of Appeal of the Office The Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market in finding some visual, conceptual and phonetic similarities between the numbers “51” and “61”. Despite rather different figurative elements, taking into account the identity of the goods to which the marks related, the Court held that there was a real likelihood of confusion between the marks.

    Lego Juris A/S v The Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market: Three-Dimensional Mark and “Essential Characteristics Which Perform a Technical Result”

    Confirming that a shape cannot be registered as a trade mark if all of its essential characteristics merely perform a technical function, the European Court of Justice held that Lego’s iconic three-dimensional trade mark for a red Lego brick was invalid under Article 7(1)(e)(ii) of Community Trade Mark Regulation 40/94 EEC (now 207/2009/EC) because its shape is necessary to obtain a technical result.

    PARALLEL IMPORTS

    Oracle America Inc (formerly Sun Microsystems Inc) v M-Tech Data Ltd: “Euro-Defences” at Least Arguable

    The Court of Appeal has overturned Mr Justice Kitchin’s decision to grant summary judgment to Oracle America Inc in respect of its claim for registered trade mark infringement in relation to certain parallel imports made by M-Tech Data Ltd.

    COMMUNICATIONS AND NEW MEDIA

    BIS Consultation on Implementing the Revised EU Electronic Communications Framework

    The UK Department for Business Innovation and Skills has launched a consultation on its proposals for implementing the revised EU Electronic Communications Framework.

    Online Infringement of Copyright Cost Sharing: UK Government Decision

    Internet service providers will share 25 per cent of the costs of running the new anti-piracy notification scheme under the Digital Economy Act, with copyright holders bearing the remaining 75 per cent.

    E-COMMERCE, IT AND BANKING TECHNOLOGY

    European Commission Consultation on the Future of Electronic Commerce 

    The European Commission has launched a public consultation on the future of electronic commerce in the internal market and the implementation of the Directive on electronic commerce (2000/31/EC) aimed at identifying obstacles to the development of e-commerce and evaluating the impact of the E-commerce Directive. Taking into account the responses received, the Commission intends to issue a Communication on e-commerce in the first half of 2011

    ENTERTAINMENT AND MEDIA

    Experience Hendrix Llc v Times Newspapers Ltd: Damages and The IP Enforcement Directive

    Damages have been awarded to Experience Hendrix Ltd under the IP Enforcement Directive (2004/48/EC) in respect of a covermounted CD on the Sunday Times newspaper containing bootlegged recordings of Jimi Hendrix’s last concert. Damages were based upon loss suffered on a worldwide basis.

    LEGAL PROFESSIONAL PRIVILEGE

    Akzo Nobel Chemicals Ltd v European Commission: Exchanges Between In-House Lawyers and Their Employers

    The European Court of Justice has dismissed an appeal by Akzo Nobel Chemicals Ltd and Akcros Chemicals Ltd against the decision of the General Court in 2007 that advice given by an in-house lawyer is not protected by legal privilege in EU competition cases.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin – Issue 73

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 73

    August/September 2010

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    COMMERCIAL

    CPC Group Ltd v Qatari Diar Real Estate Inv Co.:  “Reasonable” and “Best” Endeavours

    The case provides a useful review of the meaning of “reasonable endeavours” and “best endeavours”, as well as the meaning of acting in good faith.

    CONFIDENTIALITY

    Robert Andrew Jones v Ricoh UK Ltd: Scope of Confidentiality Agreements

    The High Court of England and Wales has ruled that a clause to protect confidential information was so wide that it went “far beyond any possible view of what could be needed for that purpose”. It was found to be in breach of Article 101 of the Treaty of the Functioning of the European Union and was an unreasonable restraint of trade.

    DESIGNS

    Shenzhen Taiden Industrial Co Ltd v Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market: Individual Character and Degree of Freedom of The Designer

    The General Court has dismissed an appeal by Shenzhen Taiden Industrial Co Ltd in relation to the validity of its Community design for a “conference unit” on the grounds that Shenzhen’s design did not produce a different overall impression on the informed user when compared with an earlier design owned by Bosch Security Systems BV. As a result, it lacked individual character within the meaning of Article 6 of the Community Design Regulation (6/2002/EC).

    TRADE MARKS

    FreemantleMedia Ltd and 19 TV Ltd (MODEL IDOL and POP IDOL): Moderately Similar Marks and Likelihood of Confusion

    Freemantle and 19 TV filed an opposition against the sign MODEL IDOL. The Opposition was based on three trade mark registrations for POP IDOL, word marks and figurative marks, in various classes. The opposition succeeded in respect of the Section 5(2) claim, but only in respect of “advertising services”. The opposition failed on the other claims.

    O2 Holdings Ltd’s Application for WE’RE BETTER, CONNECTED: Registrability of Slogans

    The trade mark application by O2 Holdings Ltd for WE’RE BETTER, CONNECTED was partially refused registration due to the lack of distinctive character. The recent judgment of the European Court of Justice in Audi v Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market C-398/08 was considered carefully and followed when assessing whether the phrase was capable of denoting origin.

    European Court of Justice Reference on Class Headings in Trade Mark Specification

    Questions have been referred to the European Court of Justice as to as to the degree of clarity and precision required in a specification of goods and services in a trade mark application.

    Best Buy Co Inc v Worldwide Sales Corporation España SL:  Threats, Community Trade Marks and Without Prejudice Correspondence

    Mr Justice Floyd has held that for a threat to be actionable in the UK under the Trade marks Act 1994, a threat must relate to proceedings in the United Kingdom. The case also explores the scope of the without prejudice rule in the context of correspondence relating to settlement negotiations

    PATENTS

    Marathon Oil Company’s Patent Application: Computer-Related Inventions and the Contribution Approach

    Despite the attempt of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales in Symbian Ltd v Comptroller General of Patents to reconcile the approaches of the United Kingdom Intellectual Property Office (UK IPO) and the European Patent Office (EPO) to inherent patentability, they are again at odds as the UK IPO applies the “Aerotel/Macrossan” test, while a recent opinion of the EPO’s Enlarged Board of Appeal (G_0003/08) confirmed that, for the EPO, novelty has no place in such an assessment.

    Occlutech GmbH v AGA Medical Corp: Claim Construction

    Dismissing an appeal from a decision of Mr Justice Mann, the Court of Appeal of England and Wales has decided that, although in a suitable context, the word “clamp” could be understood to carry an extended meaning, in the context of the patent in suit, a “clamp” meant a “clamp” in the everyday sense of the word and not an all-inclusive term for means of securing things together.

    The Community/European Union Patent: Where Does it Now Stand?

    On 2 July 2010, the Advocates-General of the Court of Justice of the European Union released their preliminary opinion on the legality of the proposed European Union Patent (EUP). They stated that the draft Agreement for the patent system did not guarantee the full application and observance of the pre-eminence of European Union law and did not provide for sufficient protection of litigants if the Court itself had failed to observe European Union law. In addition, the language regime did not protect sufficiently against discrimination of litigators from certain member states and the draft Agreement did not allow for effective control of the European Patent Office’s administrative functions in respect of the granting of the EUP.

    COMMUNICATIONS AND NEW MEDIA

    Ryanair Ltd v Billigfluege.de GmbH: Enforceability of Exclusive Jurisdiction Clauses in Website Terms and Conditions

    The Irish High Court has held that an exclusive jurisdiction clause in the terms and conditions of a website was binding on the user of the website, despite the user disputing the validity of the terms and conditions.

    SPORT

    Proactive Sports Management Ltd v Wayne Rooney: Image Rights Representation Agreement and Restraint of Trade

    The High Court of England and Wales has held that an Image Rights Representation Agreement made between Proactive Sports Management Ltd and Stoneygate 48 Ltd, the company to which Wayne Rooney had assigned his image rights, was unenforceable as it was in restraint of trade.

    ADVERTISING AND MARKETING

    Advertising Standards Authority Adjudication on Orange Personal Communications Services Ltd: Comparative Advertising and Statistical Substantiation

    Ambiguous claims based on statistics that were not directly comparable with those of competitors because of differing data-gathering methodologies have been found in breach of the CAP Code.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin – Issue 72

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 72

    July, 2010

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    PATENTS

    UK Patent Office Decision: Ignorance Not a Valid Defence in “Unintentional” Failure to File

    The UK Patent Office has refused to restore the right to claim priority from an earlier British patent in the case of an application for a patent under the Patent Cooperation Treaty, even though an entitlement action relating to the earlier patent was only resolved in the Applicant’s favour after the deadline for claiming priority had expired.

    Nampak Cartons Ltd v Rapid Action Packaging Ltd: “Pozzoli” Test and a Measure of Flexibility

    In Nampak Cartons Ltd v Rapid Action Packaging Ltd [2010] EWHC 1458 (Pat), Mr Justice Floyd concluded that the attack on inventiveness by Nampak Cartons Ltd could only be sustained with the benefit of hindsight and that a failure to adhere rigidly to the “Pozzoli” test was not necessarily an error of principle by the hearing officer.

    UK Intellectual Property Office Practice Notice on Second Medical Use Claims: “Swiss-type” Claims Objectionable

    On 26 May 2010, the UK Intellectual Property Office issued a Practice Notice on second medical use claims, stating that it will no longer accept “Swiss-type” claims for pharmaceutical products, following the recent decision of the European Patent Office’s Enlarged Board of Appeal in G 02/08 Abbott Respiratory/Dosage regime.

    DESIGNS

    Victor Ifejika v Charles Ifejika: Equitable Assignment of Design

    The Court of Appeal of England and Wales has held that an assignment of a registered design does not have to be in writing and can be effected by equitable assignment or by operation of law.

    Crocs Inc v Holey Soles Holdings Ltd: Individual Character and Novelty

    A registered design was found to be invalid as the design had been disclosed at a trade exhibition and online and had been sold through a US registration prior to the grace period afforded to the design.

    TRADE MARKS

    UK Intellectual Property Office Practice Amendment Notice Applying the ECJ Ruling in American Clothing

    The UK Intellectual Property Office has issued a Practice Amendment Notice (PAN 01/10) on trade mark applications for protected symbols, setting out how it will assess applications to register marks that incorporate or resemble national symbols, protected under Article 6terof the Paris Convention. The practice has been updated in light of the decision of the European Court of Justice in Joined Cases C-202/09 and C-208/08 American Clothing NV v The Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market.

    PASSING OFF

    Numatic International Ltd v Qualtex UK Ltd: Pyrrhic Victory for HENRY?

    The High Court of England and Wales has held that the threat by Numatic to market and sell a vacuum cleaner in the shape of a tub, with a domed black lid, amounted to passing off in the sense that the consumer would be deceived into thinking that the product was one of the well known HENRY vacuum cleaners.

    COMMERCIAL

    Financial Services Authority Statement: Consumer Declarations and The Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999

    In a June 2010 statement, the Financial Services Authority has warned financial services firms to review and amend their retail terms and conditions, stating that terms to the effect that the customer has “read and understood this contract” are unfair under the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999. Firms must provide a clear warning to consumers that they should read and understand terms before signing them and that they should ask questions if they do not understand any terms.

    Dominion Corporate Trustees Ltd v Debenhams Properties Ltd: Termination, Time of the Essence and Repudiatory Breach

    A recent decision of the High Court of England and Wales has held that the late payment of a reverse premium by Dominion (as landlord) to Debenhams (the UK retailer, as tenant) did not constitute a repudiatory breach and so did not entitle Debenhams to terminate.

    City of Westminster v Urban Wimax Ltd: Clarification of “On Completion of This Agreement”

    On appeal, it has been found that the phrase “oncompletion of this agreement”, when interpreted in its context, reading the document as a whole and having regard to the expressly stated objectives, could not mean “on execution or signing”, but instead on the completion of what is envisaged to be done by the agreement.

    E-COMMERCE, IT & BANKING TECHNOLOGY

    Financial Services Authority Update: Financial Promotions and Non-Promotional Communications on New Media

    In June 2010, the Financial Services Authority (FSA) published an update on financial promotions using new media, following its review of the use of new media channels, such as Twitter and Fecebook by those in the financial services sector. In its review, the FSA looked at approximately 30 new media pages of small and larger firms that offered a wide range of products such as financial advice and investments. The FSA also visited a variety of forums to gain an insight into the posts and comments being made on the subject.

    SPORT

    Future Investments SA v Fédération Internationale De Football Association (FIFA): Licensing of World Cup Rights, Jurisdiction and Causing Harm by Unlawful Means

    The claim that Future Investments sought to bring in England concerned the scope of FIFA’s rights to licence footage of the 1998 World Cup to IMG. Future alleged and FIFA denied, that Future had exclusive rights which FIFA and IMG had infringed, since IMG should have obtained a license from Future to use the footage. Future claimed against FIFA under the tort of causing damage by unlawful means.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • “Communication to the public and cable retransmission via joint antenna and the relation between license fees and fees paid to cable operators…”

    ARTICLE

    “Communication to the public and cable retransmission via joint antenna and the relation between license fees and fees paid to cable operators…”

    June, 2010

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin – Issue 71

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 71

    June, 2010

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    DATA PROTECTION

    Social Networking Sites Challenged Over Privacy Standards

    The Article 29 Working Party, the EU advisory body on data protection and privacy, has sent letters to 20 social networking service (SNS) providers that signed up to the Safer Social Networking Principles for the European Union, raising issues concerning privacy standards on social networking platforms. The letters from the Working Party are a follow up to its Opinion on online social networking (5/2009) adopted in June 2009 and a subsequent hearing with three major SNS operators at the Working Party’s plenary meeting in November last year.

    E-COMMERCE, IT AND BANKING TECHNOLOGY

    Vertical Restraints Block Exemption Regulation (330/2010/EC) and Guidelines: Online Sales, Exclusive and Selective Distribution

    The Vertical Restraints Block Exemption Regulation (2970/1999/EC) expired on 31 May 2010 and the European Commission has adopted a new Vertical Restraints Block Exemption Regulation (330/2010/EC) which came into force on 1 June 2010.

    COMMERCIAL

    The Trademark Licensing Company Ltd and Lonsdale Sports Ltd v Leofelis SA: Anatomy of an International Licensing Deal Gone Bad

    On an application for summary judgment, the High Court of England and Wales held that where a defence to a claim might succeed, but probably would not, it was appropriate to make a conditional order requiring that the defendant make a payment into court.

    COPYRIGHT

    Football Dataco Ltd v Brittens Pools Ltd: Database Copyright in Football Fixture Lists.

    In a significant database decision, Mr Justice Floyd has determined that the Claimants’ football fixture lists are protected by the harmonised form of copyright provided for by Article 3 of the Database Directive, but has confirmed that the sui generis database right under Article 7 of the Directive does not apply to databases if the investment involved in their creation is limited to time and resources dedicated to the creation of the data themselves, as opposed to their collection into a database.

    DESIGNS

    Beifa Group Co Ltd v the Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market: Opposing Trade Mark Rights and Genuine Use

    Beifa registered as a Community design various designs in relation to “instruments of writing”. In 2006, Schwan-Stabilo Schwanhaü GmbH & Co KG applied to the Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market to have the registration declared invalid on the basis of its earlier German trade mark registration.

    TRADE MARKS

    Transport for London: Domain Name Use and Genuine Use

    The Appointed Person rejected Transport for London’s opposition to an application by Jason Wright to register “tfl” (in lower case) as a trade mark for search engine and domain name management services in Classes 42 and 45. Transport for London relied on its earlier registration for “TFL” (upper case) and produced evidence of the mark in use, but in the forms “tfl” as part of a domain name and “TfL”.

    L’Oréal SA v Bellure NV: Comparative Advertising, Unfair Advantage and Imitations

    L’Oréal sued for trade mark infringement of various word marks under Section 10(1) and infringement of bottle and box marks under Section 10(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1994. The Court of Appeal of England and Wales referred questions to the European Court of Justice (ECJ).

    PATENTS

    Fabio Perini SPA v LPC Group plc: Invalidity for Disclosure to Customer 

    The Court of Appeal of England and Wales, in a judgment by Lords Justice Neuberger, Hughes and Jackson, has upheld a decision of Mr Justice Floyd that a patent (the 929 Patent) owned by Perini for sealing the tail ends of paper rolls was valid and infringed by their competitor PCMC. In relation to a second patent owned by Perini (the 168 Patent), which related to an improvement of the method of the 929 Patent, the Court of Appeal upheld Floyd J’s finding in relation to prior disclosure and held that the patent was invalid.

    SPORT

    UEFA v Euroview Sport Ltd: Extra Time for Football Broadcasts?

    Mr Justice Kitchin has made another reference to the European Court of Justice in a dispute over the sale in the United Kingdom of foreign decoder cards used to access foreign transmissions of football matches, this time UEFA Champions League and Europa League matches. As in FAPL v QC Leisure and Murphy v MPS (Joined Cases C-403/08 and C-429/08), Kitchin J asked if parallel imported decoder cards are “illicit devices” as defined by the Conditional Access Directive (98/84/EC). What sets this latest reference apart, however, is that guidance is also sought on whether encryption amounts to a “technological measure” for the purposes of Article 6 of the Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC) and whether the use without consent of decoder cards issued pursuant to a subscription agreement in a foreign country amounts to “circumvention” of these measures.

    DOMAIN NAMES

    LOCOG v H&S Media Ltd: London Olympics Association Right and mylondon2012.com

    The London Organising Committee of the Olympic Games and Paralympic Games Ltd v H&S Media Ltd World Intellectual Property Organization Case No. D2010-0415 (29 April 2010), is a cyber-squatting case grounded in trade mark rights and the London Olympics Association Right created by the London Olympic Games and Paralympic Games Act 2006.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin – Issue 70

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin – Issue 70

    May, 2010

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    COMMERCIAL

    MGB Printing and Design Ltd v Kall Kwik UK Ltd[2010] EWHC 624 (QB)

    This case highlights that a franchisor may owe its franchisee a duty of care that exists separately from its contractual obligations under the franchise agreement. In such a situation, exclusion and limitation of liability clauses in respect of pre-contractual statements and discussions, designed to prevent claims in misrepresentation, will not be of use. Care must thus be taken by franchisors when advising any potential franchisee, before entering into agreements.

    Handelsgesellschaft Heinrich Heine GmbH v Verbraucherzentrale Nordrhein-Westfalen eVC-511/08 (Unreported)

    This case was referred to the European Court of Justice in relation to Articles 6(1) and (2) of the Distance Selling Directive (DSD) regarding reimbursement of delivery costs. The outcome of the reference was that the DSD obliges online retailers to refund the original cost of delivery to consumers who withdraw from the contract; the only permissible cost that retailers can pass on to consumers is the cost of returning the goods This is in line with the approach already adopted by the UK Office of Fair Trading.

    TRADE MARKS AND PASSING OFF

    Pavel Maslyukov v Diageo Distilling Ltd and Diageo Scotland Ltd[2010] EWHC 443 (Ch): Bad Faith and Residual Goodwill

    Arnold J’s judgment in this case provides a useful assessment of residual goodwill. The key point is whether a positive step has been taken to abandon the goodwill. Each case will turn on its own facts, but what is more difficult to assess is what happens to the goodwill if trading ceases: no actual abandonment of the goodwill takes place, but no further use is made of the marks in question.

    Weldebräu v The Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market[2010] T-24/08

    The General Court of the European Union has upheld an appeal from the Fourth Board of Appeal of The Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market rejecting an opposition to an application to register the three-dimensional shape of a bottle as a Community trade mark, based on an earlier Community registration for a bottle shape in respect of identical and similar goods.

    COUNTERFEITING AND PIRACY

    Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation v Newzbin Ltd[2010] EWHC 608 (Ch): Major Victory for Film Industry Against Online Piracy

    Mr Justice Kitchin’s judgment in this case represents a major victory for the film industry against online piracy. The uncompromising judgment determined that a Usenet search service infringed film studios’ copyright when it provided the means by which its “premium members” could, with the click of a mouse, sweep the Usenet platform and retrieve binary component film files to reconstitute whole movies that could then be burned to DVD.

    European Commission Review of EU legislation on Customs Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights

    Following its review of Council Regulation (EC) No 1383/2003 of 22 July 2003 (the Regulation) concerning customs action against goods suspected of infringing certain intellectual property rights and the measures to be taken against goods found to have infringed such rights, the European Commission has published a Consultation Paper entitled Review of EU Legislation on Customs Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights. If, following the public consultation procedure, it is considered appropriate, the Commission will prepare a proposal to replace the Regulation.

    PATENTS

    Red Spider Technology v Omega Completions Technology [2010] EWHC 59 (Pat): Insufficiency, Obviousness, Anticipation and Design Right

    Mr Justice Mann has held that a patent for a water injection valve was invalid for insufficiency, obviousness and anticipation. A further claim for design right infringement was also thrown out as Mann J held that Omega had used only the drawings from the patent, which pre-dated the design of Red Spider’s valve. The case highlights a number of pitfalls for the unwary inventor.

    Les Laboratoires Servier v Apotex Inc[2010] EWCA Civ 279: Enforcement of Cross-Undertaking in Damages and Set-Off for Unlawful Manufacture

    The Court of Appeal of England and Wales has reversed the decision of Mr Justice Norris in which he refused Servier permission to amend its pleadings post-trial to take account of a Canadian decision upholding the validity of a key patent and awarded Apotex millions of pounds in damages.

    COMMUNICATIONS AND NEW MEDIA

    Kaschke v Gray[2010] EWHC 690 (QB): Online Blogs and the Hosting Safe Harbour

    This appeal raises important questions relating to Regulation 19 of the Electronic Commerce (EC Directive) Regulations 2002 (Section I 2002 No 2013). The judgment appears to accept the proposition that the operation of a chat room should fall within the definition of the provision of an information society service consisting of the storage of information, making it eligible for protection under the hosting safe harbour in Article 14 of the E-Commerce Directive (2000/31/EC).

    ENTERTAINMENT AND MEDIA

    The Digital Economy Act 2010

    The UK Digital Economy Act 2010 (DEA) was enacted on 8 April 2010 as a result of the recommendations in the Digital Britain Report.

    DOMAIN NAMES

    New Powers to regulate Domain Name Registries

    The Digital Economy Act 2010 (DEA) introduces new powers in relation to domain name registries to prevent potential abuses in light of the liberalisation by ICANN (the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers) of the generic top-level domain (gTLD) market.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights