Content Type: Article

  • Four Considerations When Moving to Value-Based Payment

    ARTICLE

    Four Considerations When Moving to Value-Based Payment

    December 16, 2015

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Jeremy Earl wrote this bylined article on the shift from fee-based to value-based payment models, spurred by the Affordable Care Act. Value-based payment aims “to re-align provider incentives away from simply providing more services to effectively managing the cost and quality of care for a defined population or for a defined episode of care,” Mr. Earl wrote, adding that “these payment models hold great promise, but they raise a host of legal issues and strategic considerations that require managed care organizations to think outside of the fee-for-service box.”

    Authors

    Jeremy Earl

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • ‘The End Result Test’ Revisited, Part 2

    ARTICLE

    ‘The End Result Test’ Revisited, Part 2

    December 15, 2015

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Philip Levine and Britt Haxton wrote this bylined article, part two of their assessment on using the end result test in corporate stock transactions. “There probably never will be one answer for all situations in which the step transaction doctrine might apply, nor should there be,” the authors wrote, adding: “Different congressional policies underlie different [tax code] provisions … but not every formal difference should be sufficient to alter the tax result, and particular policies might require extra protection from overly artful tax planning.” Read the full article.

    Authors
    More insights

  • The CFTC Brings (and Settles) Its First Insider-Trading Case: Implications for All Private Fund Managers

    The CFTC Brings (and Settles) Its First Insider-Trading Case: Implications for All Private Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The CFTC Brings (and Settles) Its First Insider-Trading Case: Implications for All Private Fund Managers

    December 15, 2015

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission recently settled its first-ever insider-trading case, relying on new powers granted to it under the Dodd-Frank Act and embodied in CFTC Regulation § 180.1 (“Rule 180.1”).

    This development should be examined closely by all private fund managers that trade or engage in transactions that include “commodity interests” (i.e., futures, options on futures and related swaps), irrespective of whether they are registered with the CFTC and irrespective of whether they are trading for their own account or for clients. Among other things, managers should consider extending the scope of their current insider-trading protection efforts to commodities interest trading and broadening their personal trading disclosure requirements and review practices to cover commodity interest trading.

    CFTC Sanctions

    The CFTC brought this action against Arya Motazedi, a proprietary gasoline and energy trader at an unnamed public company in Chicago. According to the CFTC, Motazedi had access to confidential, proprietary information concerning his employer’s proprietary trading in energy commodities (e.g., timing, amounts and prices) and he used that knowledge:

    • To enter “opposite side” orders that matched with his employer’s orders at least 34 times (causing the employer’s account to buy energy futures at higher prices and sell at lower prices, profiting Motazedi and harming his employer), at least some of which were designed as “round trip” transactions (where both sides bought and sold with the other and neither party experienced a net change in its positions); and
    • To “front run,” on at least 12 occasions, his employer’s orders (allowing Motazedi to benefit from any subsequent price movement caused by the subsequent execution of the employer’s oil and gas futures orders).

    The CFTC noted that, of the two accounts that Motazedi controlled and utilized in these activities, he only owned one of them.

    The Motazedi matter was resolved in a settlement order (the “Order”)[1] in which the CFTC:

    • Issued a “cease and desist” order against Motazedi relating to the statutory provisions and CFTC regulations implicated in the Order;
    • Required Motazedi to pay $216,955.80 in restitution;
    • Required Motazedi to pay a civil monetary penalty of $100,000; 
    • Permanently banned Motazedi from trading commodity interests; and
    • Permanently banned Motazedi from registering with the CFTC as a futures professional in any capacity.

    Rule 180.1 Liability

    Motazedi is noteworthy because it is a “plant the flag” case for the use of Rule 180.1 as a source of liability in general and for insider trading in particular.[2] In the Order, the CFTC reiterated its intent to interpret CEA Section 6(c)(1), which permits the CFTC to prosecute fraud in connection with any contract of sale of any commodity for future delivery, as a “broad, catch-all provision reaching fraud in all its forms — that is, intentional or reckless conduct that deceives or defrauds market participants.” Rule 180.1, which is the means for carrying out this interpretation, was promulgated under Section 6(c)(1) and demonstrates the extent of the CFTC’s efforts to extend its antifraud powers. Prior to the promulgation of Rule 180.1, CFTC enforcement efforts generally were subject to a requirement that the CFTC show actual price manipulation, which historically has been difficult to prove; the use of Rule 180.1 in the Motazedi case may make it possible for the CFTC to bring, and win, more cases.

    Taken together, Section 6(c)(1) and Rule 180.1 establish a CFTC prohibition on deceptive or manipulative conduct that is expressly modelled on the SEC’s use of Securities Exchange Act Rule 10b-5.[3] Both regimes are utilized to sanction insider-trading activity under a “misappropriation theory,” that is, “trading on the basis of material nonpublic information in breach of a pre-existing duty (established by another law or rule, or agreement, understanding or some other source), or by trading on the basis of material nonpublic information that was obtained through fraud or deception.”

    The Motazedi case also confirms that the CFTC and the SEC insider-trading regimes share a mental state requirement: While Section 6(c)(1) is silent with respect to scienter, Rule 180.1 allows the CFTC to pursue traders who act “recklessly,” defined as an act or omission that “departs so far from the standards of ordinary care that it is very difficult to believe the actor was not aware of what he was doing.” Applying Rule 180.1 to Motazedi’s alleged conduct, the Order highlights several facts that demonstrate Motazedi’s recklessness:

    • He was privy to material, nonpublic information regarding his employer’s intended trading, including the timing, contracts, prices and volume of its orders.
    • Motazedi owed a duty (to his employer) based on an understanding: He held a relationship of trust and confidence with his employer and owed a duty not to misuse proprietary or confidential information.
    • Motazedi also owed a duty (to his employer) based on an agreement: Under the company’s personal trading and conflict of interest policies, he was prohibited from trading energy commodities in his personal accounts and engaging in personal transactions that created an actual or potential conflict of interest.
    • Despite this policy, he used his employer’s trading information to trade for his own benefit and failed to disclose those plans to his employer.

    Thus, the CFTC found that Motazedi’s misappropriation and misuse of his employer’s material nonpublic trading information was “knowing or reckless” and that he breached his duty to his employer, violating both Section 6(c)(1) and Rule 180.1.[4] However, it appears from the Order that the CFTC would have found a violation of Rule 180.1 even without a company policy prohibiting personal trading, based on the duties inherent in the employment relationship.

    Implications of Motazedi for Managers

    Motazedi has several clear and direct implications for private fund managers:

    1. A precedent has been set on CFTC insider-trading enforcement actions. The CFTC has demonstrated a willingness to pursue these cases and can be expected to vigorously pursue additional actions in the future. 2. The CFTC has aligned its theory and standards of liability in a manner consistent with its sister regulators (i.e., the SEC and the Department of Justice). There is now a consistent fraud and misappropriation theory that underpins insider-trading actions in all three regulatory regimes.

    3. The penalties for insider trading in the futures markets will be stiff. In addition to financial penalties, Motazedi has a lifetime industry bar and a lifetime bar on trading for his personal account in the futures markets. This sanction is clearly intended to send a message.

    Motazedi shows that the franchise risk posed by an insider-trading allegation is not limited to managers that are registered with the CFTC and the National Futures Association (as, e.g., commodity pool operators or commodity trading advisors); any individual or entity can be sued under Section 6(c)(1) and Rule 180.1.

    Therefore, all private fund managers that trade commodity interests (in any quantity) should consider taking steps to expand the insider-trading protections on the securities side of their businesses to trading in futures commodity options and swaps markets. These measures should include specific policies, targeted training and surveillance. Managers that do not request records of personal trading (including records of accounts that are controlled, but not owned, by firm personnel) in futures and options and that do not surveil those trading records to the same degree as equity trading should begin doing so.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly, Jacob Preiserowicz and Seetha Ramachandran.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] In the Matter of Arya Motazedi, CFTC Docket No. 16-02 (Dec. 2, 2015).

    [2] In addition to the Rule 180.1 allegations, the CFTC also deemed Motazedi’s alleged conduct to be a violation of multiple other provisions of the Commodities Exchange Act and CFTC regulations, including the CEA’s anti-fraud provision (Section 4b), the CEA’s prohibitions on illegitimate, prearranged trading (Section 4c(a)), and the CFTC rule against non-competitive trades (Regulation § 1.38(a)).

    [3] In the final rule adopting new Rule 180.1, the CFTC stated that “[t]o account for the differences between the securities markets and the derivatives markets, the Commission will be guided, but not controlled, by the substantial body of judicial precedent applying the comparable language of SEC Rule 10b-5.” Prohibition on the Employment, or Attempted Employment, of Manipulative and Deceptive Devices and Prohibition on Price Manipulation, 76 Fed. Reg. 41398, 41399 (July 14, 2011).

    [4] Separately, the CME entered an order against Motazedi based upon the same conduct. The order was based on a violation of CME’s anti-fraud provision (NYMEX Rule 432.B) and the prohibition on prearranged execution of transactions for the purpose of transferring equity between accounts (NYMEX Rule 432.G).


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • “German as Mother Tongue” – Discriminatory Requirements in an Employment Ad

    ARTICLE

    “German as Mother Tongue” – Discriminatory Requirements in an Employment Ad

    December 11, 2015

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Thomas Gennert

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Update on Insider Litigation

    Update on Insider Litigation

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Update on Insider Litigation

    December 10, 2015

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Illinois ordered the “equitable subordination” of insider secured claims against a Chapter 11 debtor on Nov. 30, 2015 because the insiders left “the company and its unsecured creditors unprotected against a sharp market decline” in the debtor’s business; failed to make an equity infusion “when a sharp market decline [in the debtor’s business operations] did in fact occur … immediately after [the insiders received a cash] distribution”; caused the debtor to lose its “equity cushion” with the distribution they received and “replaced” it with their secured loans, thereby “diminishing the funds available to support the trade creditors”; and kept the debtor’s finances “completely confidential from its trade creditors,” making it “impossible for any … trade creditors to know about its shareholder distributions … or its decision to substitute secured debt.” In re SGK Ventures, LLC, 2015 WL 7755525, at *22 (Bankr. N.D. Ill. Nov. 30, 2015). Because of the trustee’s broad attack on the debtor’s insiders here, the court’s decision provides a helpful update to the current state of insider litigation.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Comments on Proposed Treasury Regulations Section 1.170A-13(f)(18) (IRS REG-138344-13)

    ARTICLE

    Comments on Proposed Treasury Regulations Section 1.170A-13(f)(18) (IRS REG-138344-13)

    December 9, 2015

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Ellen Harrison, on behalf of the ABA Section’s Committee on Governmental Submissions, reviewed this letter to the IRS. It contained comments drafted by Toni Ann Kruse as part of the Section’s Charitable Planning and Organizations Group on privacy concerns over a proposed regulation for more taxpayer identification on contemporaneous written acknowledgements of charitable donations.

    In depth
    Authors

    Ellen K. Harrison

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Toni Ann Kruse

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Firm Offers Alternative for Manufacturing Deduction Eligibility

    ARTICLE

    Firm Offers Alternative for Manufacturing Deduction Eligibility

    December 9, 2015

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Robin Greenhouse and Kevin Spencer were authors of a comment letter to the Internal Revenue Service, asserting that proposed manufacturing deduction regulations which eliminate the benefits and burdens of ownership rule conflict with Section 199 and are inconsistent with congressional intent. The letter recommended instead an alternative test that already exists in the context of Section 263A. Read the full article.

    Authors
    More insights

  • The Agricultural Commodities Exception to Foreign Base Company Sales Income

    ARTICLE

    The Agricultural Commodities Exception to Foreign Base Company Sales Income

    December 9, 2015

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Lowell Yoder wrote this bylined article about a recent Chief Counsel Advice (CCA) regarding an exception for processed or manufactured agricultural products from the definition of foreign base company sales income. Mr. Yoder wrote that the CCA addressed whether a 2009 amendment to the foreign base company sales income regulations eliminated that limitation, and concluded that the limitation still applies. Read the full article.

    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • FTC Publicizes Change in Policy Regarding Valuation of Publicly Traded Securities Under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act

    FTC Publicizes Change in Policy Regarding Valuation of Publicly Traded Securities Under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FTC Publicizes Change in Policy Regarding Valuation of Publicly Traded Securities Under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act

    December 9, 2015

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Premerger Notification Office (“PNO”) of the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) recently published a blog post regarding a policy change relating to valuations under the Hart-Scott-Rodino (“HSR”) Act that affects certain categories of acquisitions, in particular the acquisition of voting securities on a national securities exchange or through an interdealer quotation system registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Previously, the PNO advised that parties seeking to acquire additional shares of an issuer could “lock in” the value of any shares previously held at the lowest per share closing price within 45 days prior to an HSR filing. The PNO now takes the position that, for valuation purposes, the share price should not be “locked in” but should be re-valued at the time of each acquisition (using the actual acquisition date, rather than the filing date, for the 45-day lookback), even when an HSR filing has already been made.

    The HSR Act requires parties to acquisitions of voting securities, assets or non-corporate interests meeting certain annually adjusted thresholds to make a premerger notification to the FTC and the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice, and to observe a waiting period, prior to consummating such acquisitions. The various thresholds, which are to include the aggregate of current and anticipated holdings, are currently set at:

    • $76.3 million; 
    • $152.5 million;
    • $762.7 million;
    • 25 percent of outstanding voting securities (if valued greater than $1.5253 billion); and
    • 50 percent of outstanding voting securities or non-corporate interests (if valued greater than $76.3 million).

    The value of an acquisition of voting securities held as a result of the transaction includes the value of the voting securities already held by the acquiring person prior to the acquisition plus the value of the voting securities to be acquired. With respect to publicly traded voting securities, the voting securities already held are valued at the “Market Price,” which is generally defined as “the lowest closing quotation, or, in an interdealer quotation system, the lowest closing bid price, within the 45 calendar days prior to” a certain reference date. The value of the publicly traded voting securities to be acquired is the greater of the acquisition price or the Market Price. The reference date depends on the nature of the acquisition, but for open market purchases and other specific categories of transactions,[1] the HSR Act rules specify that the applicable reference date for the the Market Price is either the date of receipt of the notice required by 16 C.F.R. Section 803.5(a) (typically, on or immediately prior to the filing date) or the date the acquisition is consummated.

    Once an HSR Act filing has been made, the acquiring person has one year from the date the statutory waiting period ends or early termination has been granted to make an acquisition that crosses the threshold indicated in the filing. If an acquisition is made within that time and the threshold is crossed, whether through an acquisition or by an appreciation in value during the first year,[2] the acquiring person is exempt from filing for subsequent acquisitions of the same issuer’s voting securities for a period of five years from the date the statutory waiting period ends or early termination has been granted, so long as a higher threshold is not crossed. If the filed-for threshold is not crossed within the first year, then the five-year exemption is only available for subsequent acquisitions up to the limit of the highest threshold that was crossed within the first year.

    Based on the PNO’s prior interpretation regarding the determination of Market Price, where parties have made an HSR filing, the “Market Price” of their current holdings could be locked in as of the filing date for many transactions (including open market purchases), for up to one year after the filing. Therefore, if, prior to the consummation of the acquisition, the stock price rose, this allowed parties filing at a certain threshold to be able to buy more shares because the value of their current holdings would be locked in at the lower Market Price. Conversely, if the stock price dropped, the locked-in Market Price meant that parties would not have to acquire as many shares to ensure that the filed-for threshold was crossed within the first year.

    The PNO has now changed its view in a manner that does away with the locked-in Market Price. Therefore, in order to assess whether a particular transaction has crossed an HSR Act threshold, the appropriate reference date for the Market Price should be the date of each planned acquisition, whether or not an HSR filing has been made. It appears then that the date of the receipt of the required notice that is mentioned in the HSR Act rule is only relevant for purposes of making the initial determination as to whether to file, and for stating the value of the acquiring person’s holdings in their HSR filing.

    There are many complex and technical coverage requirements and exemptions under the HSR Act. Accordingly, the advice of counsel must be sought to determine the applicability of the HSR Act’s filing requirements to particular situations.

    Authored by Peter Jonathan Halasz and Beverly J. Ang.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] In addition to acquisitions made on securities exchanges, these categories include acquisitions of acquirer stock by offerees in non-cash tender offers, tender offers, indirect non-controlling acquisitions of voting securities of an issuer through a change of control of the entity holding such voting securities (so-called “secondary acquisitions”), conversions and the exercise of options or warrants that are the subject of a currently effective registration statement.

    [2] Note, however, that an appreciation in value alone, without any further acquisition, will not require any HSR filing.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Peter Jonathan Halasz

    Of Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Recent Developments in Tax Law: Tax Law Changes at the Turn of the Year

    ARTICLE

    Recent Developments in Tax Law: Tax Law Changes at the Turn of the Year

    December 2015

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Gero Burwitz authored the article “Recent Developments in Tax Law: Tax Law Changes at the Turn of the Year”, featured in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), p. 144-146 in December, 2015.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    More insights