Content Type: Article

  • More Paid Sick Leave — the New Trend Sweeping California

    ARTICLE

    More Paid Sick Leave — the New Trend Sweeping California

    July 19, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Chris Scheithauer and Michael Graham wrote this bylined article on how California employers face an ever-changing patchwork of local ordinances that go beyond statewide sick leave benefit requirements. The authors urged employers to “create an organized and thought-out plan to satisfy all of these local and statewide legal requirements,” by “developing an overall policy that complies with the variances in local laws and ordinances that may impact the employer’s overall benefit scheme.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • ANDA Update

    ANDA Update

    ARTICLE / OTHER

    ANDA Update

    July 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Corporate Acquisition Agreements: A SALT Perspective

    ARTICLE

    Corporate Acquisition Agreements: A SALT Perspective

    July 18, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Peter Faber wrote this bylined article discussing state and local tax (SALT) issues that arise in drafting corporate acquisition agreements. Mr. Faber urged tax practitioners to “get involved in planning the structure of the transaction from the outset. State and local taxes can often be saved by advance planning, and potential disasters can often be avoided by simple restructurings that do not upset the parties’ business objectives. If the SALT practitioners are not part of the planning team from day one, this cannot be done.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • First Circuit Affirms Conversion of Reorganization Case to Liquidation

    First Circuit Affirms Conversion of Reorganization Case to Liquidation

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    First Circuit Affirms Conversion of Reorganization Case to Liquidation

    July 13, 2016

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    An individual Chapter 11 debtor’s “estate was diminishing” with no “reasonable likelihood of rehabilitation,” held the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit on July 5, 2016. In re Hoover, 2016 WL 3606918, *2 (1st Cir. July 5, 2016), affirming the bankruptcy court’s conversion of the case to a Chapter 7 liquidation. In a rare appellate decision on the conversion issue, the First Circuit affirmed the finding that the debtor had sold “inventory without replacing it with new inventory or retaining cash sufficient to offset the diminution.” Id. at *3. As for the debtor’s plan to “generat[e] more income,” the court dismissed it as “speculation” based on the debtor’s “internet search” and a third party’s renting of a competitor store’s premises. Id. at *3n. 4. In short, reasoned the court, aside from prior losses and his failure to pay “anything to secured creditors,” the debtor had insufficient “business prospects.” Id. at *3.

    Facts

    The bankruptcy court granted the conversion motion of the U.S. Trustee (“Trustee”) under Bankruptcy Code (“Code”) §1112(b)(4) (“substantial or continuing loss to or diminution of the estate and the absence of a reasonable likelihood of rehabilitation”). Given these findings, the court did not have to consider the Trustee’s alternative grounds for the motion (“unauthorized use of cash collateral”; and unexcused failure to file timely reports).

    Cause for Conversion. The debtor had “conceded that he was selling inventory without replacing it, and his monthly operating reports … showed insufficient profit to account for or replace the sold inventory.” In addition, the debtor’s monthly operating reports showed insufficient cash to pay “costs and debts.” Id. at *2.

    The court rejected the debtor’s argument that he was continuing “to conduct business.” Id. at *3. Operating a business at a loss and not paying ongoing creditors was hardly persuasive.

    The court also rejected the debtor’s argument that state tax authorities would “hopefully … write off much” of their claims. The debtor’s profits during the ongoing Chapter 11 case were “only minimal” and he had insufficient “funds and income to pay monthly expenses under” any Chapter 11 reorganization plan. His proposals for “generating more income” were “speculative and optimistic.” Although the debtor “need not have a confirmed reorganization plan in place to avoid conversion … , the debtor still must have ‘sufficient business prospects’ … to ‘justify continuance of [a] reorganization effort.’” Id.

    Interests of Creditors. Because of the bankruptcy court’s detailed findings of losses and inability to reorganize, the court found “conversion [to be] in the interest of creditors … .” Id. at *4. The court rejected the debtor’s argument that “even a long shot at making a go of it under Chapter 11 is worth it for the creditors” when they would “mostly get nothing on liquidation … .” Aside from the debtor’s failure to make this argument in the court below, the lower courts had ample grounds to find “that a prompt conversion rather than further diminution was in the best interest of creditors, especially [when] no creditor opposed conversion as hostile to its interests.” Id.

    Comments

    1. Hoover’s indisputable facts support the validity of the court’s opinion. The court did not have to mention another important obstacle for every individual Chapter 11 debtor: the absolute priority rule, which makes it practically impossible for most individuals to prosecute a Chapter 11 reorganization plan. In re Cardin, 751 F. 3d 734, 740 (6th Cir. 2014) (“… an individual Chapter 11 [debtor] is hit by a double whammy: he must dedicate at least five years’ disposable income to the payment of unsecured creditors and … is also subject to the absolute-priority rule (and thus cannot retain any pre-petition property) if he does not pay those creditors in full.”); Accord, In re Lively, 717 F. 3d 406, 410 (5th Cir. 2013); In re Stephens, 704 F. 3d 1279, 1287 (10th Cir. 2013); and In re Maharaj, 681 F. 3d. 558, 565 (4th Cir. 2012).
    2. Some courts, however, give Chapter 11 debtors every opportunity to propose a reorganization plan. See, e.g., In re Brown, 951 F. 2d 564, 566, 572, 573 (3d Cir. 1991) (reversing district court’s dismissal of individual’s Chapter 11 petition, court remanded “case [for bankruptcy court] to determine if a reorganization is possible”; debtor had no “existing business,” no “assets other than … mortgaged properties”; “record lack[ed] the certainty needed … ”; no proof of “continuing loss or diminution of the estate.”); In re New Rochelle Tel. Corp., 397 B.R. 633, 641-42 (Bankr. E.D.N.Y. 2008) (delayed conversion so long as debtor paid utility creditor, other post-bankruptcy creditors, utility security deposits and obtained good faith offer from buyer for customer base); In re Daniels, 362 B.R. 428, 435-36 (Bankr. S.D. Iowa 2007) (delayed conversion so that debtor could establish debtor-in-possession bank account, obtain malpractice insurance, file delinquent monthly financial reports and amend schedules of assets).

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (‘SRZ’) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Brexit: What Alternative Asset Managers Can Expect

    Brexit: What Alternative Asset Managers Can Expect

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Brexit: What Alternative Asset Managers Can Expect

    July 13, 2016

    Read time: 16 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On 23 June 2016, the British public voted to leave the European Union after 43 years of membership. Although the results of the referendum are not binding in law and there remains a possibility of a constitutional challenge, the early indications from Prime Minister Theresa May and leading figures within the ruling Conservative Party are that the United Kingdom will proceed with the so-called Brexit. This Alert considers how Brexit might affect alternative asset managers in the United Kingdom and the United States.

    Article 50 Procedure

    The process for a member state exiting the EU is set out in Article 50 of the Treaty of the European Union. Article 50 prescribes that a member state that decides to withdraw must first formally notify the European Council [1] (‘Article 50 Notice’). Following the Article 50 Notice, the European Council will draw up the guidelines for the negotiations of the withdrawal agreement between the EU and the United Kingdom. Once negotiated, the withdrawal agreement must be adopted by a qualified majority of government ministers representing the remaining EU member states after obtaining consent of the European Parliament. The Article 50 Notice also sets a two-year period running, so that an eventual Brexit will occur at the earlier of: (1) the conclusion of the withdrawal agreement; or (2) two years following the Article 50 Notice.

    If no agreement has been reached by the end of the two-year period, the negotiations can be extended for a further two years, but only with the unanimous consent of the remaining member states. Alternatively, the United Kingdom will leave the EU with no separation terms in place. The United Kingdom has not yet given the Article 50 Notice, but EU officials have indicated that 1 Jan. 2019 should be the target date for Brexit.

    Future Financial Services Regulation

    Much of the UK financial services legislation, including the regulatory regime for asset managers, is derived from EU Directives. As an EU member state, the United Kingdom is also subject to a number of EU Regulations which have a direct effect in all member states. During the negotiation process, the United Kingdom will remain a member state of the EU and will continue to be bound by EU law (including the domestic legislation incorporating EU Directives). To this end, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (‘FCA’) has emphasised that it expects FCA-regulated firms to abide by their obligations derived from EU law and continue with their implementation plans for EU legislation that is not yet in effect. Such implementation plans would include, for example, compliance with the revised Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (‘MiFID’) framework known as MiFID II, due to take effect from January 2018.

    Exactly how the future UK legal and regulatory landscape might be impacted by Brexit will only become clear once a formal approach to exit negotiations has been drawn up and the nature of the relationship that the United Kingdom will seek to maintain with the EU post-Brexit is known. If, as some commentators suggest, the United Kingdom were to opt to become a member of the European Free Trade Association (‘EFTA’) and part of the European Economic Area (‘EEA’), similar to Norway, it would be required to comply with any existing and future EU financial services legislation (without the ability to formally influence such legislation) in return for the right to benefit from the access to the common market for financial services.

    Another alternative might be some form of ‘equivalence’ status for the purposes of certain aspects of EU financial services legislation. In this scenario, the United Kingdom would likely retain the overwhelming majority of existing EU-derived legislation and implement the key elements of any relevant future EU legislation.

    As a major financial centre, the UK has historically contributed significantly to the shaping of EU financial services legislation. Moreover, a large proportion of recent EU financial legislation originates from G20 commitments made in the wake of the financial crisis. Accordingly, it is doubtful that the United Kingdom would rush to repeal material portions of existing EU-derived legislation regardless of what relationship (if any) it negotiates with the EU. At the same time, a full separation or a new relationship with the EU might present the United Kingdom with both an opportunity to repeal or replace unwanted legislation and greater flexibility to tailor current regulations to the interests of the UK financial services industry post-Brexit.

    Impact on UK Asset Managers

    Two key EU Directives shape the regulatory regime applicable to UK alternative asset managers: Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (‘AIFMD’) and MiFID. Both Directives contain a passporting regime for cross-border services within the EU and establishment of branches in other member states based on the principle of common market access embedded in EU legislation. The AIFMD and, from 2018, MiFID II also include a so-called ‘third country’ regime which gives access to EU markets to non-EU firms on the basis of an equivalence determination (that is, where such firms are subject to equivalent regulatory supervision in a non-EU jurisdiction).

    Position of UK AIFMs

    The AIFMD contains two types of passporting regimes: a management passport and a marketing passport. A UK manager may currently utilise the management passport to act as the alternative investment fund manager (‘AIFM’) of, for example, an Irish or Luxembourg fund. The marketing passport is currently only available in respect of EU-domiciled funds managed by an EU manager and has not been used widely by the alternative management community, as most alternative investment funds (‘AIFs’) are established outside the EU (e.g., Cayman Islands). The European Securities and Markets Authority (‘ESMA’) has been charged with advising the European Commission on the possible extension of the marketing passport to third countries. To this end, ESMA continues to work on its equivalence assessments of various third countries and is expected to produce further advice on a number of key fund jurisdictions (including the Cayman Islands) this year.

    If the Brexit negotiations result in the United Kingdom having continued access to the common market (and, accordingly, retention of the passporting rights), there will be no post-separation change for alternative investment managers. If UK managers lose passport rights as a result of Brexit, the United Kingdom should be in the position to secure a third country equivalence status for the purposes of both management and marketing passports. Specifically, if the Commission chooses to extend the marketing passport to AIFs established in the Cayman Islands and also agrees to grant UK (as the domicile of the AIFM) equivalence status, UK AIFMs will have access to the third country marketing passport for their Cayman AIFs in the same way as managers from other non-EU jurisdictions which may be deemed ‘equivalent’ by the Commission (e.g., US managers marketing Cayman funds). Equally, if UK AIFMs are deemed subject to equivalent supervision, they will be able to continue acting as AIFMs of Irish and Luxembourg AIFs.

    The third country regime under AIFMD would effectively put UK managers in the same position as now, including compliance with the whole of AIFMD. To benefit from the third country regime, a UK manager will also need to register with a regulator of another EU member state (e.g., Ireland) as its ‘member state of reference’. It is unlikely that other aspects of the third country regime, including the appointment of a full depositary for the Cayman AIF, would present a significant challenge given that both UK AIFMs and depositaries are currently subject to the UK law implementing the provisions of AIFMD.

    MiFID Investment Services

    UK managers authorised to provide MiFID services (e.g., portfolio management, and reception and transmission of orders) typically utilise the MiFID cross-border passport to offer managed account services to institutional investors in those EU member states where the local regime does not exclude activities of overseas firms from the scope of the licensing requirements. Some MiFID authorised firms also utilise the MiFID passport to provide distribution services in respect of UCITS and AIFs in countries where such passport is required as an alternative to local licensing as a broker or placement agent.

    As with AIFMD, there would be no change to MiFID passporting rights if the United Kingdom were to retain access to the common market post-Brexit (e.g., as an EEA member). If the United Kingdom loses its passporting rights following the withdrawal, UK managers may be able to provide MiFID services to professional clients in the EEA based on an equivalence determination made by the Commission and subject to a requirement to register with ESMA. As noted above, the United Kingdom will be required to implement MiFID II during the withdrawal negotiation period and, accordingly, the regulatory regime applicable to investment firms in the United Kingdom will be the same as in the remaining EU member states.

    UCITS and AIFM Platforms

    Post-Brexit, it is likely that UK managers will also be able to continue providing portfolio management services to UCITS and AIFM platforms based in Ireland and Luxembourg, even if the United Kingdom does not become an EEA member and does not benefit from equivalence status under the third country provisions. Such platforms are typically structured as either an Irish or Luxembourg self-managed fund (e.g., an Irish ICAV) or a fund with a regulated Irish or Luxembourg management company.

    Both jurisdictions currently allow non-EU managers to provide such services, subject to the approval of the local regulator. Continued access to such platforms will also secure the ability of UK managers to distribute UCITS funds and AIFs to EU investors under the passporting provisions contained in the UCITS Directive and AIFMD.

    Impact on US Managers

    It is unlikely that Brexit will have a direct impact on US managers that do not have UK-based affiliates. US managers who have registered their AIFs under the national private placement regime in the United Kingdom will be required to continue complying with its conditions, such as initial investor disclosures (e.g., an AIFMD disclosure supplement to the private placement memorandum), periodic reporting (including annual reports with remuneration disclosures), and Annex IV reporting. Depending on the terms of Brexit (i.e., whether it retains access to the common market), the United Kingdom may be in the position to relax its marketing restrictions in the future and revert to the pre-AIFMD marketing regime.

    The ability of US managers to provide portfolio management services to UCITS and AIFM platforms established in the remaining EU member states will depend, as now, on the local regulatory regime of the relevant EU member state, as described above (i.e., there will be no change).

    Impact on UK and US CLO Managers

    Potential Brexit has also raised concerns about the continued ability to offer CLOs to investors in the EU. Under the current EU securitisation framework, certain EU-regulated investors (such as banks, fund managers and insurance companies) are unable to invest in CLOs unless the risk retention requirements contained in the relevant EU Directives have been met.

    There are two permissible options for a compliant risk retention vehicle in the context of CLOs. The first option is the ‘originator’ model which has been utilised widely by UK and US CLO managers. For these purposes, an originator of a CLO structure is a person that acquires credit exposures from a third party and then securitises them, subject to certain conditions being met.

    The second option is the ‘sponsor’ model. A sponsor is, broadly, an investment firm established in the EU and authorised under MiFID to conduct certain types of investment activities. Although the ‘sponsor’ model has been utilised widely by European financial institutions, the applicable MiFID authorisation and regulatory capital requirements have made this structure less feasible for US managers and UK managers not affiliated with large financial institutions.

    Unless the withdrawal negotiations result in the United Kingdom remaining a member of the EEA, UK collateral managers will no longer be eligible to act as ‘sponsors’. Conversely, the ‘originator’ does not need to be an entity established in the EU and, as such, the ‘originator’ model would continue to be available to UK and US CLO managers under the current EU securitisation regime.

    That being said, the EU securitisation framework is being revised. The current legislative proposals tighten the eligibility conditions applicable to originators, including a possible requirement for the originator to be an EU entity subject to some form of regulatory oversight. If implemented, these changes will have a significant impact on the structuring of future CLO transactions and may also affect existing deals sold to EU investors.

    Derivatives Documentation

    Until further details of the post-Brexit regulatory framework are known, it would be difficult to predict the impact on the ISDA Master Agreement and OTC derivatives trades. It is unlikely that Brexit would directly trigger an Event of Default in the standard 1992 or 2002 versions of the ISDA Master Agreement. At the time of writing, we are not aware of any Brexit termination events being negotiated into ISDA Master Agreements. However, the likely economic ripple effect of Brexit (e.g., credit downgrade termination events in relation to rated institutions, such as prime brokers) could trigger termination events.

    The Governing Law and Jurisdiction provisions of the now more common 2002 version of the ISDA Master Agreement provides an exclusive jurisdiction clause to English-law-governed agreements entered into between EU counterparties and the reciprocal recognition of judgments handed down by a court in an EU member, including UK court judgments, across the EU. This position is unlikely to change in the event of Brexit, even if the United Kingdom does not become an EFTA/EEA member. EU courts will continue to give effect to the contractual parties’ choice of law in accordance with the Rome Regulations. English courts have historically respected contractual choice of law and jurisdiction, and this approach is not likely to change in the future.

    OTC derivatives regulation emanated from a global G20 initiative and has been implemented in the United States under Dodd-Frank and the EU under the European Market Infrastructure Regulation (‘EMIR’). As an EU Regulation, EMIR takes direct effect in the United Kingdom. Post-Brexit, it is uncertain what elements of this regulation would remain applicable or adopted as UK law. As with other EU legislation, parts of EMIR rely on cross-border recognition and authorise the European Commission to recognise the arrangements and legal framework of non-EU countries as being ‘equivalent’. Given the global regulatory initiative and the nature of the derivatives market which relies on cross-border recognition, it is expected that such recognition would be a part of EU and UK exit negotiations, as both sides would be keen to address regulatory inconsistency and potential jurisdictional arbitrage.

    Taxation

    Membership of the EU has had a substantial influence on the development of UK tax law. EU Directives and Regulations have been incorporated into UK domestic law and so become part of the UK tax system, most notably in the case of the United Kingdom’s participation in a common European VAT regime for cross-border supplies of goods and services. The United Kingdom has also transposed a number of EU Directives related to cross-border payments and the provision of financial information, such as the Interest and Royalties Directive, the Parent/Subsidiary Directive and the EU Savings Directive.

    Decisions of the European Court of Justice have also brought about changes in UK tax law to ensure its compliance with EU fundamental freedoms, such as the free movement of workers and capital and freedom of establishment. UK law in the areas of group loss relief, double tax relief and controlled foreign companies (‘CFCs’) has been significantly altered by the need to ensure its compatibility with these fundamental principles of the EU.

    In considering the impact of Brexit, however, it should be recognised that rules derived from EU tax law are only a part of the UK tax system. The UK has an extensive network of bilateral double tax treaties (including with those countries that remain EU member states) and is also subject to other international agreements in the area of tax information reporting, such as FATCA and the OECD Common Reporting Standard.

    The immediate UK tax impact of Brexit is therefore likely to be limited. In principle, the non-applicability of the Interest and Royalties Directive and the Parent/Subsidiary Directive might lead to the imposition of withholding taxes on cross-border payments made to or by UK companies, but this will remain dependent on the terms of any applicable double tax treaty.

    What may be more significant is the flexibility that Brexit will give for the United Kingdom to diverge from EU tax law in the future. For example, whilst the United Kingdom will clearly need to maintain a UK VAT system (or at least an equivalent sales tax), Brexit will give the United Kingdom the freedom to set its own VAT rates and determine which supplies should be treated as exempt or zero-rated. Brexit should also permit the United Kingdom to adopt its own rules in areas such as transfer-pricing and CFCs in ways that might have been struck down as discriminatory and contrary to the fundamental freedoms had the United Kingdom remained subject to the jurisdiction of the EU.

    The fact that the United Kingdom will now have a much diminished role in the development of EU tax law and policy should also not be forgotten. In the past the United Kingdom has been very active in seeking to influence EU tax measures in defence of the United Kingdom’s interests — one notable instance being the negotiations on the proposals for an EU financial transactions tax — and will lose that influence following Brexit.

    Conclusion

    The full impact of the potential Brexit on the UK legal and regulatory regime will remain unknown until the terms of the United Kingdom’s future relationship with the EU have been defined. What is clear is that there will be no overnight changes. Once the negotiations on the separation have commenced, it is likely to be a slowly evolving process. This will allow asset managers sufficient time to plan, mitigate any risks and adapt to the forthcoming changes well before they come into effect. The negotiation process is also likely to present asset managers with unparalleled opportunities to engage with trade bodies and UK policy makers and to contribute to the shaping of the future legal and regulatory environment in which the alternative asset manager community operates.

    Authored by Christopher Hilditch and Anna Maleva-Otto.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The European Council consists of heads of state or government of EU member states together with its president (currently, Donald Tusk) and the president of the European Commission (currently, Jean-Claude Juncker).


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (‘SRZ’) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Christopher Hilditch

    Partner

    London – One Eagle Place

    More insights

  • Insolvency Law – The Entire Insolvency Law in One Volume! – Comments

    ARTICLE

    Insolvency Law – The Entire Insolvency Law in One Volume! – Comments

    2016

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Sandra Urban-Crell has worked as an editor of the labor law representation.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Recent Developments in Tax Law: Commercial Partnerships: Application of § 50 i EStG

    ARTICLE

    Recent Developments in Tax Law: Commercial Partnerships: Application of § 50 i EStG

    July 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Gero Burwitz authored the article “Recent Developments in Tax Law: Commercial Partnerships: Application of § 50 i EStG”, featured in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), p. 777-779 in July, 2016.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    More insights

  • CMS Proposed Rule Implements Limitations on Medicare Payments for Off-Campus Outpatient Hospital Departments

    CMS Proposed Rule Implements Limitations on Medicare Payments for Off-Campus Outpatient Hospital Departments

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Proposed Rule Implements Limitations on Medicare Payments for Off-Campus Outpatient Hospital Departments

    July 11, 2016

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 6, 2016, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services released the CY 2017 Outpatient Prospective Payment System (OPPS) Proposed Rule, which includes proposed regulations to implement Section 603 of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015. Effective January 1, 2017, Section 603 bars Medicare payments under the OPPS for items or services (other than services furnished by a dedicated emergency department) furnished at an off-campus provider-based department, unless the location was billing as an outpatient department of a hospital prior to November 2, 2015.

    In depth

    Background

    On July 6, 2016, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released the CY 2017 Outpatient Prospective Payment System (OPPS) Proposed Rule, which includes proposed regulations to implement Section 603 of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015. Effective January 1, 2017, Section 603 bars Medicare payments under the OPPS for items or services (other than services furnished by a dedicated emergency department) furnished at an off-campus provider-based department (PBD), unless the location was billing as an outpatient department of a hospital prior to November 2, 2015. Further discussion of Section 603 is available here and here.

    The Proposed Rule comes shortly after the House Ways and Means Committee approved new legislation that would create broader exceptions under Section 603. Under the bill, which the Senate has not yet approved, an off-campus PBD could continue to be eligible for higher OPPS payments in 2017 if the host hospital submitted a voluntary provider-based attestation to CMS pursuant to 42 CFR § 413.65(b)(3) before December 2, 2015.

    Effective January 1, 2017, Medicare will pay for such items and services under the applicable fee schedule rather than the OPPS. Payment under the OPPS can be considerably higher than payment under the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) or the Ambulatory Surgical Center (ASC) fee schedule, for example, for the same services, which has been a concern of Congress and the US Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (OIG), which last month released a report recommending elimination of the provider-based distinction (discussion of the OIG report is available here).

    CMS estimates that the proposed implementation of Section 603 will reduce net OPPS payments by $500 million in 2017 and increase payments to physicians under the MPFS by $170 million, resulting in a reduction of Part B expenditures by $330 million.

    Services and Locations Subject to Section 603

    Section 603 excludes from payment under the OPPS “applicable items and services” furnished by an off-campus PBD on or after January 1, 2017, with the exception of items and services furnished (1) by a dedicated emergency department (defined at 42 CFR 489.24(b)); (2) at “remote locations of a hospital” (i.e., a location where hospital inpatient services are furnished) and locations that are within 250 yards (measured by a straight line from any point of a remote location) of a “remote location of a hospital”; and (3) at a location that was billing as an outpatient department of a hospital prior to November 2, 2015.

    CMS proposes to apply the statutory exception for services furnished at dedicated emergency departments broadly and would permit payment under the OPPS for all services furnished at a dedicated emergency department, not just emergency services.

    Prohibition on Service Expansion

    CMS proposes to limit OPPS payment to services furnished and billed for at an off-campus PBD prior to November 2, 2015. Services will be identified as part of a “clinical family of services,” which is a new term, to group Ambulatory Payment Classifications by 19 specialty areas. Services within a clinical family of services that were furnished and billed for at an off-campus PBD prior to November 2, 2015, would be deemed “excepted services” and would remain eligible for OPPS payment. Services within a clinical family of services that were not furnished and billed for at an off-campus PBD prior to November 2, 2015—i.e., services that were not billed at that location as of the grandfather date—would be deemed “non-excepted services” and would not be eligible for payment under the OPPS.

    CMS acknowledges that its current enrollment and billing systems do not accommodate identification of the specific location where off-campus PBD services are furnished or whether a particular location was billing for services within a particular clinical family of services prior to November 2, 2015, and seeks comments on how it might collect appropriate data to identify such services. However, CMS expects hospitals to maintain documentation showing what lines of service were provided at each off-campus PBD prior to November 2, 2015, and to make such documentation available upon request.

    CMS is not proposing to limit the volume of services furnished within a clinical family of services that the hospital was billing prior to November 2, 2015. That is, an excepted facility can increase the number of services furnished at the excepted off-campus PBD beyond those furnished on the grandfather date, as long as the increased services are within the same clinical family as the services furnished as of the grandfather date. Additionally, CMS is not proposing at this time but is considering specifying a timeframe in which service lines had to be furnished and billed under the OPPS prior to November 2, 2015, e.g., CY 2013 to November 1, 2015, in order for the services to be excepted services.

    Prohibition on Facility Relocation and Expansion

    CMS proposes to limit OPPS payment to off-campus PBDs that were identified on the hospital’s Medicare enrollment forms (CMS Form 855A) as of November 1, 2015. CMS would identify each off-campus PBD by the enrolled street address, including suite number. Such locations would be considered “excepted locations” and would be eligible for continued OPPS payment after January 1, 2017, for excepted services.

    CMS proposes to limit the ability of excepted locations to relocate or expand. Specifically, an excepted location that relocates would become a non-excepted location and no longer be eligible for OPPS payment. CMS seeks comments on whether to add disaster/extraordinary circumstances exceptions to accommodate relocations that are outside of the hospital’s control. Excepted locations can expand if the expansion takes place at the same enrolled street address. If, however, an excepted location expanded into a separate suite at the same address, CMS would consider the expanded location to be a non-excepted location.

    CMS would permit excepted locations to retain their excepted status following a change of ownership (CHOW) if the CHOW also involved the main hospital entity (not just the excepted location) and the new owner accepted assignment of the former owner’s Medicare provider agreement.

    Payment Methodology

    Under existing Medicare rules, Medicare generally makes two types of payments for most items and services furnished in an off-campus PBD: (1) payment for the items and services furnished by the facility under the OPPS, and (2) payment for the physician’s professional services under the MPFS. Under the Proposed Rule, CMS states that there is “no straightforward way” for CMS to implement, by January 1, 2017, the payment changes under which an off-campus PBD could bill and receive payment for furnishing non-excepted items and services—those services that do not meet the Proposed Rule’s exceptions to bill under the OPPS—under a payment system that is not the OPPS.

    Therefore, CMS proposes to pay the majority of non-excepted items and services under the MPFS for a one-year transitional period starting January 1, 2017. CMS would pay physicians furnishing services in off-campus PBDs based on the professional claim and at the non-facility rate. CMS acknowledges that the proposal to pay non-excepted items and services under the MPFS may result in hospitals needing to establish business arrangements with physicians or non-physician practitioners to share reimbursement for the service, and that such arrangements could confront billing and claims submission rules, the fraud and abuse laws, and other statutory and regulatory provisions affecting the Proposed Rule.

    For services not payable under the MPFS, CMS proposes that hospitals enroll as a provider or supplier type that is eligible to receive payment for the service at issue under a non-OPPS payment methodology. For example, to receive payment for the technical component of certain diagnostic tests, the hospital could enroll as a physician group or independent diagnostic testing facility.

    CMS is “actively exploring” options to allow off-campus PBDs to bill for non-excepted items and services under another payment system beginning in calendar year 2018 and seeks comments on what the methodology and process should look like.

    The Proposed Rule does not address Medicare cost reporting treatment for services that it would require to be billed under the MPFS at the non-facility rate, but that would continue to be provided in space that is considered by Medicare to be part of the hospital.

    340B Impact

    Although not directly acknowledged in the Section 603 language or in the Proposed Rule, the method of implementation for Section 603 has the potential to significantly affect hospitals that participate in the 340B Drug Discount Program. The 340B Program is administered by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) and allows participating hospitals to access reduced pricing for outpatient drugs dispensed to hospital patients. Under current 340B Program policy, off-campus locations of a 340B-participating hospital are eligible to dispense and prescribe 340B drugs only if the Medicare cost report for the hospital reflects Medicare-covered outpatient costs and charges at the location. To the extent that the Proposed Rule would result in Medicare costs and charges for non-excepted locations and services being removed from the Medicare cost report, under current 340B Program policy it is likely that non-excepted locations and services would lose access to 340B pricing. Further, under current 340B Program policy, if a 340B-participating hospital opts to remove certain off-campus PBDs from its Medicare enrollment and convert such locations to non-hospital entities, such non-hospital entities would not be eligible to participate in the 340B program. HRSA likely will not provide further guidance regarding the impact of CMS implementation of Section 603 on 340B Program eligibility until after CMS issues final rules later this year.

    Commentary and Next Steps

    Hospitals concerned about the implications of Section 603 as enacted should be even more concerned about the manner in which CMS proposes to implement that legislation. Since enactment of Section 603 and leading up to release of this proposed rule, hospitals and hospital associations have peppered CMS and Congress with suggestions about how to interpret and implement the legislation. With respect to just about every major decision point, CMS rejected hospital recommendations and opted for the most restrictive interpretations.

    Perhaps most significant for hospitals is how CMS proposes to determine payment for non-excepted services in 2017 using MPFS rates. As proposed, Medicare payment would not only be substantially cut, but also directed to the physician furnishing the services. This aspect of the proposed rule should be particularly troubling for ASCs that converted to provider-based hospital status in recent years, because services furnished at this rate would go not from OPPS back to original ASC rates, but from OPPS to much lower MPFS rates. This proposal alone is likely to inspire many former ASCs to consider conversion back to ASC status.

    The Proposed Rule’s limitation on service line expansion and facility relocation and expansion further affects hospitals that are already grappling with the prohibitions imposed by Section 603. If finalized as proposed, the Proposed Rule also has the potential to create significant operational burdens on hospitals, which may need to disclose items and services furnished by each off-campus PBD, work closely with physicians—and likely enter written agreements—in order to obtain payment for off-campus PBD services until CMS identifies a new payment methodology for non-excepted items and services, and assess whether the organization satisfies the requirements to enroll in Medicare as a different provider or supplier type in order to receive payment for exempted services. Hospitals should also evaluate whether the proposal to use Medicare enrollment data as of November 2, 2015, may result in certain locations that a hospital currently treats as off-campus PBDs no longer being viewed as such by CMS, and whether review and updates to the hospital enrollment records may be warranted.

    In light of the significant changes to payment and operations that will result if the Proposed Rule is finalized as currently proposed, hospitals should strongly consider providing comments to the Proposed Rule. Hospitals that participate in the 340B Program should also evaluate submission of comments that incorporate alternative approaches to Section 603 implementation that would preserve 340B eligibility for non-excepted services and locations under current 340B Program policies. Comments must be submitted no later than 5 pm EDT on September 6, 2016, and may be submitted electronically via www.regulations.gov.

    Authors

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Monica Wallace

    Partner

    Chicago

    Eric Zimmerman

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Lender’s Derivative Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claim Not Time-Barred Because of Its Knowledge

    Lender’s Derivative Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claim Not Time-Barred Because of Its Knowledge

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Lender’s Derivative Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claim Not Time-Barred Because of Its Knowledge

    July 8, 2016

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    A lender’s (“Lender”) derivative breach of fiduciary duty claims on behalf of Chapter 7 guarantor-Debtors cannot be time-barred because of Lender’s knowledge of the “[d]efendants’ conduct,” held the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware on June 22, 2016. In re AMC Investors, LLC, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 80861, *16 (Del. June 22, 2016). Reversing the bankruptcy court’s dismissal of Lender’s derivative suit against officers and directors, the district court explained that the “inquiry should not have turned on [Lender’s] knowledge.” Id. Instead, “the relevant inquiry turns on plaintiff’s ability to discover the claim, and here, Debtors are the only plaintiffs with a breach of fiduciary duty claim against Defendants.” Id. Delaware law, said the district court, “required the bankruptcy court to evaluate when Debtors discovered facts constituting the basis for the … claims, or the existence of facts sufficient to put Debtors on inquiry notice.” Id. The decision underscores the difference between a lender’s direct action and a derivative action asserting a claim held by another entity.

    Facts

    Lending Relationship and Guarantees. Lender had advanced funds to the debtors’ affiliate (“Borrower”) under a 2003 Credit Agreement, obtaining a lien on Borrower’s working capital and a guaranty from the debtors (“Debtors”). By 2005, Borrower “became insolvent, and its board of directors voted to cease operations and to approve an assignment for the benefit of creditors.” Id. at *III. Lender called a default under its agreement, demanded immediate payment, and sued the guarantor-Debtors in New York State court, obtaining a $10.7-million judgment against them in 2007. Although the guarantor-Debtors appealed, Lender filed an involuntary Chapter 7 petition against them in Delaware in 2008 and a Chapter 7 trustee was appointed for them in 2009.

    Prior Non-Bankruptcy Litigation Related to Borrower. Lender brought additional “related, but unconsolidated” suits against the officers, directors and shareholders (“Defendants”) of Debtors in the Southern District of New York. It asserted direct and derivative claims on behalf of the Borrower for fraud and breaches of fiduciary duty in connection with its credit agreement defaults. Id. at *3. The New York District Court dismissed those suits and the Second Circuit affirmed. See In re Eugenia VI Venture Holdings, Ltd. Litigation, 649 F. Supp. 2d 105 (S.D.N.Y. 2008), aff’d, 370 F. App’x. 197 (2d Cir. 2010).

    Delaware Derivative Litigation Related to Guarantor-Debtors. The Delaware bankruptcy court granted Lender, “as Debtors’ sole creditor in the Chapter 7 cases, derivative standing to pursue causes of action against Defendants on behalf of Debtors” in 2011. 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 80861, at *4. (emphasis added). Lender then sued Defendants “on behalf of each Debtor,” alleging breaches of fiduciary duty (“good faith, due care, and loyalty to Debtors”) by “instituting, directing and/or failing to discover and prevent massive fraud by the board and management of” Borrower. Id. In their answer, the Defendants raised several affirmative defenses, but Lender moved for partial summary judgment only “as to Defendants’ timeliness defenses based on the statute of limitation and laches.” Id. at *5.

    The Bankruptcy Court

    The bankruptcy court found that “breach of fiduciary duty claims are equitable claims bearing close resemblance to legal claims,” making “a statute of limitations analysis … appropriate.” Id. at *7. Defendants argued that because Lender did not sue until 2011, its “claims [were] time-barred.” Id. at *8. The bankruptcy court agreed, reasoning that the record did not “justify tolling the statute of limitations.” Id. Under each of Delaware’s tolling doctrines, said the bankruptcy court, “the statute of limitations begins to run upon the discovery of facts constituting the basis of a cause of action or the existence of facts sufficient to put a person of ordinary intelligence and prudence on inquiry which, if pursued, would lead to the discovery of such facts.” Id. at *8. Because Lender “clearly knew about Defendants’ conduct” when it previously litigated in New York, the bankruptcy court denied Lender’s motion for summary judgment and held that the derivative claims were time-barred because “the tolling mechanisms recognized by Delaware courts do not apply.” Id.

    The District Court

    The only issue on appeal was Defendants’ timeliness defenses. According to the district court, in an “extremely limited holding,” the bankruptcy court erred in finding “none of Delaware’s tolling doctrines” to be “available to Debtors.” Id. at *17. The Lender’s “knowledge is not imputed to the Debtors for purposes of the statute of limitations analysis.” Id. Because “Debtors are the only plaintiffs with a breach of fiduciary duty claim against Defendants,” the key inquiry was “when Debtors discovered facts” supporting the breach of fiduciary duty claims, or when Debtors had “inquiry notice.” Id., at *16.

    Equally important, the court expressed “no opinion” as to the validity of other defenses that the Defendants asserted. The court therefore remanded “the case to the Bankruptcy Court for further proceedings … .” Id. at *17.

    Comment

    The AMC decision is limited in scope. Here, Lender sued derivatively on behalf of the guarantor-Debtors because a direct action by it would have been time-barred. AMC confirms that Lender’s derivative claims only sought to enforce the Debtors’ claims. It was not asserting its own direct claims.

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (‘SRZ’) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • HSR Act Update: 150-Percent Increase in Maximum Civil Penalties for Violations; Yearly Increases to Follow

    HSR Act Update: 150-Percent Increase in Maximum Civil Penalties for Violations; Yearly Increases to Follow

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    HSR Act Update: 150-Percent Increase in Maximum Civil Penalties for Violations; Yearly Increases to Follow

    July 7, 2016

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 29, 2016, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) announced that the maximum civil penalty that can be assessed for violations of the premerger notification requirement of the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976 (as amended, the “HSR Act”) will increase from $16,000 per day to $40,000 per day. The increase applies to all transactions covered by the HSR‎ Act, including securities purchases, mergers, and other acquisitions of voting securities, assets or non-corporate interests, and may be applied to any penalties assessed on or after the Aug. 1, 2016 effective date (including for violations that occurred prior to such date).

    The HSR Act requires parties to acquisitions meeting certain thresholds to: (1) make a premerger notification to the FTC and the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice (“DOJ” and, together with the FTC, the “Antitrust Agencies”); and (2) observe a waiting period prior to consummating such acquisitions. Failure to comply with any provision of the HSR Act subjects violators to penalties that may be recovered in a civil action brought by the United States.[1]

    The magnitude of the latest increase is unprecedented in the history of HSR Act civil penalties. To date, the maximum civil penalty provided for under the HSR Act has only been increased twice, from $10,000 per day to $11,000 per day in 1996, and from $11,000 per day to $16,000 per day in 2009. The new change is being made pursuant to legislation enacted last year, which requires federal agencies to adjust penalty amounts using a “catch-up” inflation adjustment. Going forward, the maximum penalty amount will be adjusted for inflation every January.

    Each day of non-compliance with the HSR Act is deemed to be a separate violation, which can cause substantial fines to accumulate over time (in some cases, undetected by the parties) until a corrective HSR Act filing is made with the Antitrust Agencies. It is, therefore, more crucial than ever that parties remain cognizant of their HSR Act reporting obligations. In the past, HSR Act enforcement actions have often been settled with penalties far below the maximum permitted by law. Mitigating factors that the courts (and, historically, the Antitrust Agencies) consider in determining the amount of the civil penalty to be imposed include: “the good or bad faith of the respondent; the injury to the public; the respondent’s ability to pay; the desire to eliminate the benefits derived from the violations; and the necessity of vindicating the [FTC]’s authority.”[2] In light of the increasingly active enforcement by the Antitrust Agencies in recent years,[3] and in light of the new maximum penalties, it is possible that we will soon see a marked increase in the fines actually imposed on parties that fail to comply with the HSR Act.

    There are many complex and technical coverage requirements and exemptions under the HSR Act. Accordingly, the advice of counsel must be sought to determine the applicability of the HSR Act’s filing requirements to particular situations.

    Authored by Peter Jonathan Halasz and Beverly J. Ang.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The FTC shares its enforcement authority under the HSR Act with DOJ. Although only the DOJ can seek civil penalties for HSR violations, investigations are often initiated by the FTC and then referred to DOJ for enforcement on the FTC’s behalf.

    [2] 81 Fed Reg. 42,476 (June 30, 2016).

    [3] See SRZ Client Alerts: “Activist Investing Update: DOJ’s HSR Action Against ValueAct Highlights Uncertainties Regarding the ‘Investment-Only’ Exemption;” “Hart-Scott-Rodino Filing Update: Recent Settlement Interprets ‘Investment-Only’ Exemption Narrowly;” “Hart-Scott-Rodino Act: US Levies $720K Civil Penalty for Failure to Re-File for Additional Stock Acquisitions;” “Investor Fined for Alleged Misuse of HSR Act Passive Investment Exemption.”


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (‘SRZ’) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Peter Jonathan Halasz

    Of Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights