Content Type: Article

  • Proposed IRS Regulations Would Increase Estate and Gift Taxes on Transfers of Family-Controlled Entities

    Proposed IRS Regulations Would Increase Estate and Gift Taxes on Transfers of Family-Controlled Entities

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Proposed IRS Regulations Would Increase Estate and Gift Taxes on Transfers of Family-Controlled Entities

    September 7, 2016

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In August, the Internal Revenue Service published proposed regulations that would have a significant impact on the estate and gift tax consequences of many transfers of certain family-controlled entities, such as corporations, partnerships and limited liability companies (regardless of whether the entity is a passive or active business). If adopted in their current form, the regulations will dramatically reduce the effectiveness of many common estate planning techniques involving these types of entities.

    The regulations relate to a provision (Section 2704) of the Internal Revenue Code that governs the valuation of certain property when transferred among family members. It is common for the transfer of interests in family-controlled entities to receive valuation discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability. The proposed regulations would, in many circumstances, significantly reduce or eliminate the valuation discounts that currently are allowed when a person transfers an interest in a family-controlled entity to another family member (or a trust for a family member) during life or at death. As a consequence of the potential loss of valuation discounts, the gift or estate tax consequences of such a transfer could increase significantly. The proposed regulations would also apply a so-called “look-back” rule to some transfers within three years of a transferor’s death in order to negate valuation discounts that otherwise would have been warranted. 

    In general, the provisions of the proposed regulations will not become effective until they are finalized. However, in certain circumstances, the “look-back” rule would have retroactive effect.

    A public hearing on the proposed regulations is currently scheduled for December 1, 2016. In the interim, we will continue to monitor the status of these proposed regulations. There are many uncertainties raised in the proposed regulations and it is not known whether, and the extent to which, any changes will be made prior to the issuance of the final regulations. While the proposed regulations need to go through a public hearing period, we recommend that if you are considering making any such transfers, you do so prior to December 1, 2016. (In order to take advantage of existing rules, you would need to make a transfer of an interest in a family-controlled entity prior to the effective date of the final regulations, though, under the “look-back” rule, certain transactions now may be brought back into a person’s estate if he or she dies within three years of the transfer.)

    Please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel if you wish to discuss how these proposed regulations may apply to your specific financial and personal situation.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • OIG Work Plan: A Roadmap to Identify Health Care Compliance Risk

    ARTICLE

    OIG Work Plan: A Roadmap to Identify Health Care Compliance Risk

    September 2, 2016

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The Crisis of Business Enterprises From a Shareholder’s Perspective

    ARTICLE

    The Crisis of Business Enterprises From a Shareholder’s Perspective

    2016

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Introduction to the New World of Global Tax Planning

    ARTICLE

    Introduction to the New World of Global Tax Planning

    September 1, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Cym Lowell wrote this bylined article on global implementation of a country-by-country (CbC) transfer pricing documentation regime. Mr. Lowell discussed creation of a CbC checklist for clients “to facilitate the process of developing profit split models. It reflects our overall approach to documentation, which is to develop a customized model for the unique circumstances of each client.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Representations & Warranties Insurance

    ARTICLE

    Representations & Warranties Insurance

    August 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Mark Collins and Michael Sartor wrote this bylined article on the timeline and process considerations for use of a representations and warranties insurance policy in transactions. “All policies require the insured to take reasonable steps to mitigate losses,” the authors wrote, adding, “It is possible to negotiate an express statement that mitigation steps against the seller are not a pre-condition to the buyer making a claim or receiving payment for a loss under the policy.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • LSTA Introduces New Rules for Application of Delayed Settlement Compensation

    LSTA Introduces New Rules for Application of Delayed Settlement Compensation

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    LSTA Introduces New Rules for Application of Delayed Settlement Compensation

    August 31, 2016

    Read time: 12 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Loan Syndications and Trading Association (‘LSTA’) is introducing new rules in connection with the application of delayed settlement compensation on par trades that will be implemented in two phases. The first and main phase will launch on Sept. 1, 2016, and the second phase will launch on Nov. 1, 2016.

    The new rules introduce a requirements-based model for delayed settlement compensation that will replace the current no-fault model, meaning the parties to a trade must now meet certain requirements in order to be eligible to receive delayed settlement compensation.[1] The purpose of the new rules is to create ‘urgency’ for the parties to close trades within the LSTA-suggested timelines, with the ultimate goal being improved liquidity.

    The requirements differ slightly depending on whether the trade is settling on paper or on an Electronic Settlement Platform (an ‘E-Platform’). The vast majority of par trades today settle on an E-Platform and the E-Platform rules described below will apply, unless the parties designate in the trade confirmation that they will settle the trade manually (i.e., via paper).

    The most important requirements under the new regime are highlighted below, but the list is not exhaustive.

    In the following scenarios, delayed settlement compensation always applies:

    • Any required consents under the Credit Agreement have not been obtained and the Buyer has satisfied its requirements described in this Alert.
    • ‘Participation’ has been selected as the form of settlement at the time of trade (if the trade was originally expected to settle by assignment, but ends up settling by participation, the requirements described in this Alert must still be met).
    • Seller has not provided Buyer the KYC information that Buyer has timely requested,[2] and due to that, Buyer has not satisfied its requirements described below.[3]

    Settlement on E-Platform of Trades with a Trade Date of Sept. 1 Through Oct. 31

    Delayed settlement compensation will apply to the transaction if the following requirements have been met:

    • On or before T+6[4] Buyer has to: (i) execute online or submit by email its signatures to the trade confirmation and assignment agreement and select a proposed settlement date of no later than T+7 and select ‘Persisted’;[5] and (ii) pay the purchase price on settlement (collectively, the ‘Buyer Platform Requirements’).
    • Dealer has to submit trade details to the E-Platform no later than T+1 so that the E-Platform can generate the transfer documents. If both Buyer and Seller are dealers, or if neither party is a dealer, Seller has the obligation to submit trade details to the E-Platform.
    • If Seller is the dealer, or neither party is a dealer, and trade details are not submitted to the E-Platform within T+1, delayed settlement compensation applies, regardless of whether Buyer has satisfied its own requirements.
    • If Buyer is the dealer and trade details are not submitted to the E-Platform by T+1, Seller must provide a notice with the Trade Date, Credit Agreement, Purchase Amount and Facility to Buyer within T+3.
    • If notice is timely provided by Seller, then Buyer must submit trade details within T+5[6] for delayed settlement compensation to apply and satisfy the Buyer Platform Requirements.
    • If Seller notice is not timely provided by Seller, delayed settlement compensation applies.

    Other scenarios where delayed settlement compensation shall apply:

    • Buyer has not paid the purchase price because it reasonably believes in good faith that the purchase price calculation on the E-Platform is incorrect, Buyer has timely notified Seller[7] and has complied with its other requirements.
    • Buyer hasn’t satisfied its requirements because it is unable to do so due to functionality issues of the E-Platform that the Buyer can’t control. Buyer needs to try and mitigate its inability to perform due to such issues.
    • There is a material error in the assignment agreement generated by the E-Platform that the Buyer needs to try and fix by T+3,[8] and if error is fixed by T+4,[9] Buyer needs to satisfy its requirements.

    Payment Timing

    For a trade confirmation with a Trade Date on or before Oct. 31, 2016, Buyer shall be obligated to pay the purchase price on the date when the assignment is made effective by the agent.

    New CLO Issuers on E-Platform Settlement

    • Prior to T+7, Buyer may indicate that it is a newly formed SPV formed to issue CLOs under an Indenture, then Buyer from T+7 through settlement may select a CLO Blackout Period during which the Agent will not make the assignment agreement effective and delayed settlement compensation shall continue to apply.
    • CLO Blackout Period means a period of not more than five consecutive business days preceding the effective date of the Indenture under which New CLO Issuer issues notes, provided such New CLO Issuer may designate only one such period before such effective date of the Indenture. The Blackout Period occurs when the CLO exits the warehousing stage, so that the CLO can issue the securities under its Indenture and go live. Before and after the Blackout Period, the CLO will settle trades in the normal course.

    Settlement on E-Platform of Trades with a Trade Date of Nov. 1 or Later

    Some market participants need a lead time to settle some trades (for instance, because their custodian is in Europe). Lead time is the time between when the administrative agent is ready to make the trade effective and Buyer is ready to fund. In order to accommodate that and, at the same time, stay within the T+7 timeline for settlement, on Nov. 1 the LSTA is changing the requirement for execution of the trade confirmation and assignment agreement from T+6 to T+5. That means that Buyers can only have either no lead time or one day of lead time.

    • By T+5[10] Buyer has to: (i) execute online or submit by email its signatures to the trade confirmation and assignment agreement; and (ii) select a proposed settlement date of no later than T+7 and select ‘Persisted’.

    Payment Timing

    • If the agent notifies the parties on or before 11 a.m. (Eastern time) that the agent can make the transfer effective on that day, Buyer: (i) with no lead time shall be obligated to pay the purchase price on the same date of such notification; and (ii) with lead time of one business day shall be obligated to pay the purchase price no later than the following business day.[11]
    • If the agent notifies the parties after 11 a.m. (Eastern time), but on or before 6 p.m. (Eastern time), Buyer shall be obligated to pay the purchase price no later than the following business day.
    • If the agent notifies the parties after 6 p.m. (Eastern time), Buyer: (i) with no lead time shall be obligated to pay the purchase price no later than the following business day; and (ii) with lead time of one business day shall be obligated to pay the purchase price no later than two business days following the date of such notification.[12]

    Notwithstanding the time frame requirements set forth in the three clauses above, as well as the payment timing for trades with a Trade Date on or before Oct. 31, 2016, Seller and Buyer may mutually agree to override such terms on the E-Platform and have the assignment agreement made effective on a different business day than contemplated above (the ‘Override Date’) and, to the extent the administrative agent makes the assignment agreement effective on the Override Date (the ‘Override Assignment Effective Date’), Buyer shall then be obligated to pay the purchase price no later than the Override Assignment Effective Date.

    Settlement on Paper (Manually) of Trades with a Trade Date of Sept. 1 Through Oct. 31

    Delayed settlement compensation will apply to the transaction if the following requirements have been met:

    Buyer obligations:

    • If Buyer is responsible for drafting the trade confirmation and the assignment agreement, Buyer needs to deliver to Seller the trade confirmation and the assignment agreement on or before T+1.
    • If Buyer fails to do so, Seller is obligated to notify Buyer on or before T+3 of such failure (if Seller fails to notify, then Buyer has satisfied its obligations and delayed settlement compensation applies).
    • If Seller’s notification is timely provided, Buyer needs to deliver signed trade confirmation and assignment agreement on or before T+5.[13]
    • When Buyer receives Seller’s signatures to the trade confirmation and the assignment agreement, Buyer has to deliver within one business day of such receipt its signature to the trade confirmation to Seller and the fully executed assignment agreement to the agent.

    Seller obligations:

    • If Seller is responsible for drafting the trade confirmation and the assignment agreement, Seller needs to deliver to Buyer on or before T+1 the trade confirmation and the assignment agreement.
    • Then Buyer needs to execute the trade confirmation and the assignment agreement by T+6;[14]
    • If Seller fails, delayed settlement compensation applies.
    • If Seller is responsible for obtaining consents and the transaction does not settle by T+7, Seller shall sign the assignment agreement and deliver copy of signature page to Buyer any time from T+7 through settlement, and notify Buyer of proposed delayed settlement date no later than 6 p.m. on the business day immediately preceding the proposed settlement date to the extent Seller determines in good faith all consents for settlement will have been satisfied.
      • If Seller does not timely provide Buyer with advanced notification of a proposed delayed settlement date, then Buyer shall be obligated to pay the purchase price no later than the business day immediately following the date Seller provides Buyer with notification that the transfer has been made effective.
      • If Seller timely provides Buyer with advanced notification of a proposed delayed settlement date and Seller further provides Buyer with notification that the transfer has been made effective: (i) on or prior to 11 a.m. (Eastern time), then Buyer shall be obligated to pay the purchase price on the same day; or (ii) after 11 a.m. (Eastern time), then Buyer shall be obligated to pay the purchase price no later than the following business day.
    • Where Buyer is the party responsible for obtaining any required consents and the transaction does not settle by T+7, to the extent Buyer receives notification that the transfer was made effective either: (i) on or prior to 11 a.m. (Eastern time), then Buyer shall be obligated to pay the purchase price on the same day; or (ii) after 11 a.m. (Eastern time), then Buyer shall be obligated to pay the purchase price not later than the following business day.

    Other scenarios where delayed settlement compensation shall apply:

    • Buyer has not paid the purchase price, because it reasonably believes in good faith that the purchase price calculation prepared by Seller is incorrect, and Buyer has timely[15] notified Seller and has complied with its other requirements.
    • There is a material error in the assignment agreement prepared by Seller, Buyer notifies Seller by T+3,[16] and if error is fixed by T+4,[17] Buyer needs to satisfy its requirements.

    New CLO Issuers

    • If Buyer has notified Seller on or before T+7[18] that it is a newly formed SPV formed to issue CLOs under an Indenture, and Seller is the party responsible for obtaining consents, Buyer may select at any time from T+7 through settlement a CLO Blackout Period during which Seller shall notify agent not to make the assignment agreement effective and delayed settlement compensation shall continue to apply. If Buyer is the party responsible to obtain consents, and Buyer has notified Seller that it is a new CLO issuer, Buyer shall notify agent not to make the assignment agreement effective per the above.

    Settlement on Paper (Manually) of Trades with a Trade Date of Nov. 1 or Later

    • Obligation of Buyer to execute and deliver to Seller the trade confirmation and assignment agreement on or before T+5 instead of T+6.

    Authored by David J. Karp and Alexia Petrou.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The current model provides that, if settlement occurs on a date after T+7, delayed settlement compensation always applies (unless the parties agree otherwise at the time of trade).

    [2] Prior to the date Buyer’s requirements are due.

    [3] Provided that Buyer has to promptly satisfy its requirements once Seller provides the requested KYC information. According to the LSTA best practices, any KYC documents should be delivered to the agent and the counterparty at least three business days prior to entering into or sub-allocating a trade.

    [4] Trigger Date +12 for early day trades. ‘Early day trade’ is a trade for which the Trade Date is a date on or before the sixth business day following the Trigger Date (i.e., the date of initial funding under the Credit Agreement) unless there is no funding of any facilities under the Credit Agreement when it becomes effective, in which case the Trigger Date is the date when the Credit Agreement becomes executed and delivered.

    [5] ‘Persisted’ means that Buyer is financially able to settle the trade without interruption until the settlement date.

    [6] Within Trigger Date +10 for early day trades. ‘Trigger Date’ for a trade is the date of initial funding under the Credit Agreement, unless there is no funding of any facilities under the Credit Agreement at or about the time it becomes effective, in which case the ‘Trigger Date’ is the date the Credit Agreement is executed and delivered.

    [7] On or prior to the business day on which payment of the purchase price is due.

    [8] T+6 for early day trades.

    [9] T+8 for early day trades.

    [10] Trigger Date +10 for early day trades.

    [11] In this case, Buyer forfeits one day of delayed settlement compensation.

    [12] In this case, Buyer forfeits one day of delayed settlement compensation.

    [13] On or before Trigger Date +10 for early day trades.

    [14] Trigger Date +12 for early day trades.

    [15] On or prior to the business day on which payment of the purchase price is due in accordance with the above.

    [16] T+6 for early day trades.

    [17] T+8 for early day trades.

    [18] Trigger Date +14 for early day trades.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Case in Which Disclosure of Technical Level of Person of Ordinary Skill in the Art Affected Determination of Whether Prior Art Is Enabling

    ARTICLE

    Case in Which Disclosure of Technical Level of Person of Ordinary Skill in the Art Affected Determination of Whether Prior Art Is Enabling

    August 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Takashi Saito wrote this bylined article on In re Steve Morsa, in which the Federal Circuit affirmed a Patent & Trademark Office finding that admissions made by a patent applicant in his submission to the PTO were sufficient to enable prior art for the patent. The Federal Circuit previously ruled the PTO had applied the incorrect prior-art-enablement procedure and remanded.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Can Transaction Parties Rely on the Common Interest Privilege?

    ARTICLE

    Can Transaction Parties Rely on the Common Interest Privilege?

    August 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Alison Nadel and Erika Pont wrote this bylined article on whether parties to a transaction should share legal advice among themselves to save money and time. “The question arises: Can they assume their communications are protected by the so-called ‘common interest privilege? The answer is ‘perhaps,’” wrote the authors.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Fifth Circuit Narrowly Accepts Texas Supreme Court’s Reading of Fraudulent Transfer Value Defense

    Fifth Circuit Narrowly Accepts Texas Supreme Court’s Reading of Fraudulent Transfer Value Defense

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Fifth Circuit Narrowly Accepts Texas Supreme Court’s Reading of Fraudulent Transfer Value Defense

    August 30, 2016

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit just affirmed the dismissal of an SEC receiver’s fraudulent transfer suit against an advertising firm for $5.9 million it had received in good faith from a Ponzi scheme debtor. Janvey v. Golf Channel Inc., 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 15407, *7 (5th Cir. Aug. 22, 2016) (“Golf Channel IV”). We predicted this outcome in our April 6, 2016 Alert after the Texas Supreme Court ruled that “Golf Channel’s media-advertising services had objective value and utility from a reasonable creditor’s perspective at the time of the transaction, regardless of [the debtor’s] financial solvency at the time.” Janvey v. Golf Channel Inc., 2016 Tex. LEXIS 241, 487 S.W.3d 560, 570 (Tex. 2016) (“Golf Channel III”). According to the Texas Supreme Court, the Texas version of the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act (“TUFTA”) should not be applied “in a way that would nullify a statutory affirmative defense [good faith receipt of funds in exchange for reasonably equivalent value] whenever the debtor was operating a Ponzi scheme.” Id. at *530.

    The Fifth Circuit begrudgingly accepted the Texas Supreme Court’s reading of the definition of “value” contained in TUFTA after certifying the question to that court on June 30, 2015, in response to a petition for rehearing. Janvey v. Golf Channel Inc., 792 F. 3d 539 (5th Cir. 2015) (“Golf Channel II”). On March 11, 2015, the Fifth Circuit had initially reversed the district court, holding the defendant advertising firm liable for its undisputed good faith receipt of cash from a Ponzi scheme debtor. Janvey v. Golf Channel Inc., 780 F.3d 641, 646-47 (5th Cir. 2015) (“Golf Channel I”) (advertising services had “no value” to Ponzi scheme debtor). The district court had dismissed the receiver’s complaint, relying on the defendant’s statutory “affirmative defense that it received the payments in good faith and in exchange for reasonably equivalent value (the market value of advertising on the Golf Channel),” reasoning that the defendant “looks more like an innocent trade creditor than a salesman perpetrating and extending the [debtor’s] Ponzi scheme.” In its initial 2015 holding in Golf Channel I, however, the Fifth Circuit stressed that this case is “different because [the debtor] was engaged in a Ponzi scheme.” It conceded, nevertheless, that the defendant’s services might have been “quite valuable” had the debtor been engaged in a legitimate business.

    Relevance

    The Fifth Circuit acquiesced in the Texas Supreme Court’s response. In its view, the Texas Court interpreted “the concept of ‘value’ under TUFTA differently than we have understood ‘value’ under other states’ fraudulent transfer laws and under Section 548(c) [of] the Bankruptcy Code.” 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 15407, at *5. It cited its own precedents to support this position. Warfield v. Byron, 436 F.3d 551, 560 (5th Cir. 2006) (applying Washington’s UFTA statute, held services that furthered a Ponzi scheme not “value” as a matter of law because the “primary consideration in analyzing the exchange of value for any transfer is the degree to which the transferor’s net worth is preserved”); In re Fairchild Aircraft Corp., 6 F.3d 1119, 1125-27 (5th Cir. 1993), abrogated on other grounds by In re Dunham, 110 F.3d 286, 288-89 (5th Cir. 1997) (under Bankruptcy Code §548(c), inquiry is whether consideration provided in exchange for transfer conferred a tangible economic benefit on debtor, not whether consideration had objective value in the abstract). The Fifth Circuit stressed that its “prior decisions” remain “unaffected” by Golf Channel III. 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 15407, at *7. In other words, if a Fifth Circuit trustee sues under Bankruptcy Code (“Code”) 548(a)(1), the outcome would be different from the result in Golf Channel III, where the receiver sued under applicable state law — TUFTA. A good faith creditor paid in the ordinary course of a Ponzi scheme debtor’s business will still be held liable, unable to raise the good-faith reasonably equivalent value defense contained in Code § 548 (c).

    Analysis

    The Fifth Circuit ignored the substantial body of case law in other circuits and other state courts, implying that Golf Channel III merely construes a specific provision of Texas law and that the opinion is aberrational. But the Texas Supreme Court in Golf Channel III detailed the statutory purpose behind the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act before discussing relevant decisions by other federal courts and the decisions of at least one other state Supreme Court.

    First, according to the Texas Legislature, TUFTA should be “applied and construed to effectuate its general purpose to make uniform the law with respect to [fraudulent transfers] among states enacting [the model] UFTA.” 2016 Tex. LEXIS 241, at *29. Second, the Texas Supreme Court considered other courts’ “construction [of] the pertinent terms in cases applying” Bankruptcy Code §548 “and similar provisions in UFTA statutes enacted by other states.” Id. at *30.

    Most important, the Texas Supreme Court rejected the Fifth Circuit’s view that a Ponzi scheme debtor failed to receive value when it paid for goods or services in good faith. Id. at *38-*39, citing In re Richards & Conover Steel Co., 267 B.R. 602, 612 (B.A.P. 8th Cir. 2001), quoting 2 Epstein, Nickels & White, Bankruptcy §6-49 at 23 (1992); 5 Collier, Bankruptcy ¶548.05[2][a] at 548-70 (16th ed. 2016) (value received by debtor need not be something “on which creditors can levy; … with respect to valuable services, such as legal or other similar professional services, courts will not factor in a lack of tangible increase in physical assets,” but will discount “intangible and transitory assets and rights that have value only to the debtor”). Moreover, reasoned the Texas Court, “TUFTA does not support a distinction based on the type of consideration exchanged, particularly when such a distinction would effectively negate a transferee’s good faith defense in certain categories and transactions — namely intangible services and consumable goods … .” 2016 Tex. LEXIS 24, at *41, citing, In re RML, Inc., 92 F.3d 139, 149 (3d Cir. 1996) (value exchanged when debtor obtains benefit from services performed, such as cleaning windows received in exchange for payment to a window-washer); In re Chomakos, 69 F.3d 769, 771 (6th Cir. 1995) (chance of winning bet placed at casino constituted value at time bet was placed).

    Nor did the Fifth Circuit in Golf Channel IV acknowledge the Eleventh Circuit’s holding in In re Fin. Federated Title & Trust, Inc., 309 F.3d 1325, 1332 (11th Cir. 2002) (evaluation of whether an employee of a Ponzi scheme debtor provided value “should focus on the value of the goods and services provided rather than on the impact the goods and services had on the bankrupt enterprise”; court “dismissed … cases in which courts had held that value was lacking as a matter of law in compensation transactions involving a Ponzi scheme”). In the words of the Texas Supreme Court, “value is value regardless of whether the debtor is insolvent or whether either party is acting in good faith.” 2016 Tex. LEXIS 241, at *50, citing Fin. Federated, 309 F. 3d at 1331-32.

    Finally, the Fifth Circuit in Golf Channel IV ignored the “only … state high court” decision that “has addressed the Ponzi-scheme presumptions and good faith defense under an UFTA-based statute.” Id. at *52, citing Finn v. Alliance Bank, 860 N.W. 2d 638, 647 (Minn. 2015) (construing Minnesota Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act, court declined to apply Ponzi-scheme presumptions; “if it were to presume the transfers from Ponzi-scheme operators were not for value, it would ‘effectively negate a transferee’s good-faith defense to an actual-fraud claim’”). Like the Minnesota Supreme Court, the Texas Supreme Court “refused to apply the statute in a way that would nullify a statutory affirmative defense whenever the debtor was operating a Ponzi scheme … .” Id. at *53.

    Comment

    The Fifth Circuit has now unnecessarily complicated fraudulent transfer litigation in its circuit. By adhering to an unsound judge-made presumption in Ponzi scheme cases, the Fifth Circuit has undermined its previously stated acknowledgment that Code § 548(c)’s “good faith” defense was meant to “protect … the [good faith] transferee from his unfortunate selection of business partners.” In re Hannover Corp., 310 F. 3d 796, 802 (5th Cir. 2002). See also In re Churchill Mortgage Inv. Corp., 264 B.R. 303, 308 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) (affirming bankruptcy court and applying Code § 548, held debtors “received ‘value’ in exchange for the commissions paid to the Brokers for performing in good faith a facially lawful and customary service … . There is neither an allegation of the Brokers’ knowledge of the Ponzi scheme nor of an unreasonably high or excessive commission paid to the Brokers.”); In re Universal Clearing House Co., 60 B.R. 985, 999 (D. Utah 1986) (reversing bankruptcy court, and applying Code §548, held Ponzi scheme debtor’s “sales agents’ … services … fall … squarely within the definition of value in [Section 548] … . [W]e do not think that the goods and services [provided by the debtor’s landlord, salaried employees, accountants and attorneys, and utility companies] were without value or their transfers to them could be set aside as fraudulent [transfers] … . The financial positions of the debtor need not necessarily be improved by a particular transaction in order for us to hold that value was given”).

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • IP Update, Vol. 19, No. 8

    IP Update, Vol. 19, No. 8

    ARTICLE

    IP Update, Vol. 19, No. 8

    August 2016

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Paul Devinsky

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights