Content Type: Article

  • A Tribute to John Mikesell

    ARTICLE

    A Tribute to John Mikesell

    September 26, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Dental Company’s Indemnification Claim “Bites”

    ARTICLE

    Dental Company’s Indemnification Claim “Bites”

    September 25, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Lender Primes Trustee in Seventh Circuit

    Lender Primes Trustee in Seventh Circuit

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Lender Primes Trustee in Seventh Circuit

    September 25, 2019

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    A bankruptcy trustee was “not entitled to avoid” a secured lender’s “lien under the Bankruptcy Code” (“Code”), held the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on Sept. 11, 2019. In re 180 Equipment, LLC, 2019 WL 4296751, *6 (7th Cir. Sept. 11, 2019). The court rejected the trustee’s argument that the lender’s “lien [was] avoidable because the [lender’s] financing statement failed to properly indicate the secured collateral.” Id., at 1. Reversing the bankruptcy court, the Seventh Circuit held that the lender had perfected its security interest under the Illinois version of the Uniform Commercial Code (“UCC”) when its financing statement incorporated “by reference…an unattached security agreement,” sufficiently indicating its collateral. Id. This decision is arguably inconsistent with In re Financial Oversight Management Board for Puerto Rico, 914 F.3d 694, 705-06, 711-713 (1st Cir. 2019) petition for cert. filed 2019 WL 1989185 (U.S. May 3, 2019) (No. 18-1389) (financing statements did not describe collateral but only referred “to an extrinsic document located outside the UCC filing office, and that document’s location is not listed in the financing statement”; notice in financing statement held insufficient under 2008 Puerto Rican version of UCC, but cured by later amendments under revised 2012 version of Puerto Rican UCC).

    Relevance

    Code § 544(a)(1) permits a bankruptcy trustee to avoid a security interest held by a lender if that interest would not have been enforceable against a subsequent lien creditor under applicable state law. This so-called “strong-arm clause” gives the trustee, as of the date of bankruptcy, the rights and powers of a judicial lien creditor, regardless of whether such a creditor exists. In other words, the trustee has the powers of a creditor who extended credit and obtained a lien on the date the debtor’s bankruptcy petition was filed.

    Courts applying Code § 544(a) consider, among other things, whether the secured lender satisfied state law public notice requirements as of the date of the bankruptcy filing. In the case of personal property, as in 180 Equipment, the issue is whether the lender had “perfected” its security interest in substantially all of the debtor’s assets, consistent with the parties’ security agreement. Outside of bankruptcy, § 9-301(i)(b) of Article 9 of the UCC gives a judicial lien creditor priority over an unperfected security interest. In a bankruptcy case, the trustee, with the status of a hypothetical lien creditor, may avoid a security interest that had not been properly perfected with a proper financing statement in accordance with Article 9. See, e.g., Kors, Inc. v. Howard Bank, 819 F.2d 19 (2d Cir. 1987) (“Section 544(a) of the Code, the ‘strong-arm’ clause, enables the trustee…to act as a hypothetical lien creditor as of the day the bankruptcy case is filed…. Pursuant to this section, the trustee…can avoid unperfected liens on property belonging to the bankruptcy estate…. Once the trustee has assumed the status of a hypothetical lien creditor under § 544(a)(1), state law is used to determine what the lien creditor’s priorities and rights are…. Hence, the bankruptcy court and the district court examined Vermont law to determine what rights the trustee had as a hypothetical lien creditor under § 544(a)(1)…. The [lower courts correctly] found…that under Vermont law the…Bank failed to perfect its security interest in the [debtor’s] equipment [because of a defective financing statement]…. Thus, at the commencement of the bankruptcy case, the Bank had an unperfected security interest in [the debtor’s] collateral.”) In sum, because an unperfected security interest is “subordinate” to a judicial lien creditor, the trustee primes the lender and may avoid the lender’s security interest.

    Facts

    The debtor in 180 Equipment had obtained a loan by granting the lender a security interest on “substantially all of [its] assets.” Id. at *1. The lender’s security agreement described the collateral in 26 categories, including accounts, cash, equipment, instruments, goods, inventory and all proceeds of those assets. The lender promptly filed a financing statement to perfect its security interest with the Illinois Secretary of State. According to the financing statement, the lender’s lien purported to cover “[a]ll Collateral described in First Amended Restated Security Agreement dated March 9, 2015 between Debtor and Secured Party.”

    The debtor later defaulted and filed a Chapter 7 petition. In response to the lender’s claims, the trustee asserted that the lender’s security interest was not properly perfected because its financing statement did not independently describe the underlying collateral, but instead incorporated the assets listed in the parties’ security agreement. Id. The bankruptcy court agreed with the trustee, but the Seventh Circuit granted the parties’ joint petition to review the bankruptcy court’s decision. The sole question on appeal was whether the lender’s lien was avoidable “because the financing statement failed to properly indicate the secured collateral ….” Id.

    The Seventh Circuit

    The UCC. The court first cited the relevant sections of the Illinois version of Article 9 of the UCC. “In relevant part, § 9-502 requires that a financing statement … (1) provide the name of the debtor; (2) provide the name of the secured party …; and (3) indicate the collateral covered by the financing statement.” (emphasis added). According to § 9-504 of the UCC, “[a] financing statement sufficiently indicates the collateral that it covers if the financing statement provides … (1) a description of the collateral pursuant to Section 9-108; or (2) an indication that the financing statement covers all assets or all personal property.” Section 9-108 “further explains that a description of the secured property does not need to be specific but must ‘reasonably identif[y]’ what is described. Section 9-108 gives six distinct methods by which a description of collateral reasonably identifies the secured property: (1) specific listing; (2) categories; (3) type; (4) quantities; (5) mathematical computation or allocation; or (6) any other method, if the identity of the collateral is objectively determinable.” Id. at *3 (emphasis added).

    Applying Law to Facts. The court then explained why the lender’s “incorporating … a description [of its collateral in a financing statement] by reference to a security agreement sufficiently ‘indicates’ the collateral.” Id. A lender can “indicate collateral in a financing statement – including by ‘any other method’ – so long as the identity of the collateral is ‘objectively determinable.’” Id.

    Prior to 2001, explained the court, a secured lender had to indicate in the financing statement “the types, or describ[e] the items, of collateral.” But, in 2001, Illinois revised its version of the UCC “to no longer require that the financing statement ‘contain’ a description of the collateral; after [this] revision the statement must only ‘indicate’ collateral.” According to the court, this “pared-down approach reflects the notice function of Article 9. . . . [T]he ordinary meaning of ‘indicate’ is to serve as a ‘signal’ that ‘point[s] out’ or ‘direct[s] attention to’ an underlying security interest.” Id. at *4, citing Webster’s New World College Dictionary (4th ed. 2001).

    Precedent. The Seventh Circuit had previously “recognized that Article 9 ensures ‘adequate public notice’ of liens and security interests, … and that ‘the goal of the filing system is to make known to the public whatever outstanding security interests exist in the property of debtors.” Id., quoting In re Blanchard, 819 F.3d 981, 986, 988 (7th Cir. 2016). The purpose of the financing statement is to put third parties “on notice that the secured party who filed it may have a perfected security interest in the collateral described, and that further inquiry into the extent of the security interest is prudent.” Helms v. Certified Packaging Corp., 551 F.3d 675, 679 (7th Cir. 2008). “The financing statement itself is an ‘abbreviation of the security agreement.’“ Helms, 551 F.3d at 679. “It is a streamlined paper to be filed for the purpose of giving notice to third parties of the essential contents of the security agreement.” Id.

    “The financing statement … need not particularize in detail the collateral secured under the security agreement because … a financing statement serves to give notice that the secured party who filed may have a security interest in the collateral and that further inquiry with respect to the security agreement will be necessary to disclose the complete state of affairs.” Id., quoting Helms, 551 F.3d at 680. The “prudent potential creditor would … request … a copy of the security agreement … and need look no further than the security agreement” to resolve questions about the adequacy of the collateral description.” Id., quoting Helms, 551 F.3d at 680-681. In short, “the financing statement provides notice of an underlying security interest, while the security agreement creates and specifically defines that interest.” Id.

    Lower courts in Illinois have repeatedly found “that incorporation by reference is permissible … as ‘any other method’ under § 9-108, so long as the identity of the collateral is objectively determinable.” Id. at *6. In 180 Equipment, the security agreement contained a detailed list of the collateral to which the financing statement referred. The financing statement also named both the debtor and lender, had not lapsed and “includes the date and precise title of the underlying document,” describing the lender’s security interest — “[a]ll [c]ollateral . . . as described in the underlying security agreement between the parties.” Id. Thus, “the financing statement … ‘notif[ied] subsequent creditors that a lien may exist and that further inquiry [was] necessary to disclose the complete state of affairs.’“ Id. The Seventh Circuit therefore reversed the bankruptcy court, finding that the lender’s security interest was properly perfected and unavoidable by the trustee under Code § 544(a)(1).

    Comments

    1. The holding in 180 Equipment is consistent with 2001 changes to the UCC:

    In a major change in the law that recognizes the broad concept of notice filing, UCC 9-504(2) states that a financing statement ‘sufficiently indicates the collateral that it covers’ if it provides ‘an indication that the financing statement covers all assets or all personal property.’ In other words, supergeneric collateral descriptions are okay in the financing statement, even though not allowed in the security agreement under 9 108(c). Regardless of its breadth, of course, the financing statement cannot perfect a security interest in collateral not covered by the security agreement. On a related point, a somewhat narrower description than ‘all assets,’ e.g., ‘all assets other than equipment,’ is sufficient for the financing statement even though it is not an adequate description of collateral in the security agreement. A supergeneric collateral description in the financing statement should be valid for notice-filing purposes even though the security agreement only covers limited categories of collateral.

    Barkley Clark, Secured Transactions, § 2.09[b][c], at 2-222 (2016 rev. ed.). See 180 Equipment, 2019 WL 4296751, at *3 (“In 2001, the Illinois version of the UCC was revised to no longer require that the financing statement ‘contain’ a description of the collateral; after revision the statement must only ‘indicate’ collateral.”).

    2. The Eighth Circuit has similarly held that supergeneric language in a financing statement suffices, stressing the statement’s notice filing function:

    The [Missouri version of the UCC] UCC gives two methods for identifying collateral in a financing statement: a description of the collateral, or an indication that the financial statement covers all of the debtor’s assets. It then provides that errors or omissions do not render the statements ineffective unless they are seriously misleading. The relevant question is whether the statements—judged in their entirety—are seriously misleading, not whether one alternative, and ultimately unnecessary, means of describing the collateral therein is seriously misleading. While Defendant’s specific descriptions of the annuity contracts contain errors, the statements themselves are not seriously misleading, because a subsequent creditor should reasonably understand that the financing statements may cover all of Hanson’s assets. It was then incumbent upon subsequent creditors to inquire whether specific collateral owned by Hanson is the subject of a prior security agreement.

    ProGrowth Bank, Inc. v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 558 F3d 809, 815 (8th Cir. 2009) (emphasis added).

    3. Some practitioners recommend filing the security agreement with the financing statement. See, e.g., Financial Oversight, 914 F.3d at 705-06, 710-711 (security agreement could have been attached to financing statement in 2008; later amended financing statements in 2015-16 did attach “a full definition of ‘Pledged Property’“).

    4. New York apparently follows the Seventh Circuit’s reasoning in 180 Equipment. See, e.g., In re Sterling United, Inc., 674 Fed Appx. 19, 20-21 (2d Cir. 2016) (“In New York, a financing statement perfects a security interest if it (a) states the name of the debtor and the name of the secured party, or a representative of the secured party, and (b) indicates the collateral covered by the financing statement, N.Y. U.C.C. § 9-502. The collateral requirement may be satisfied by an indication that the financing statement covers all assets or all personal property. Id. § 9-504, which is the minimum necessary to provide [ ] notice that a person may have a security interest in the collateral claimed, Id. § 9-504, cmt. 2. . . . We conclude that the description [here] is sufficient because it unambiguously refers to ‘[a]ll assets of the Debtor’ irrespective of their location.”).

    Authored by Michael L. Cook, James T. Bentley and Nathaniel J. Norman.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Expanded CFIUS Review over Non-Controlling Foreign Investments in US Businesses and Foreign Investments in Certain US Real Estate

    Expanded CFIUS Review over Non-Controlling Foreign Investments in US Businesses and Foreign Investments in Certain US Real Estate

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Expanded CFIUS Review over Non-Controlling Foreign Investments in US Businesses and Foreign Investments in Certain US Real Estate

    September 20, 2019

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Treasury Department issued proposed regulations that would “comprehensively” implement legislation passed last year, FIRRMA, to broaden the jurisdiction of CFIUS. Interested parties have until October 17 to file comments that could influence how Treasury finalizes the rules.

    In depth

    On September 17, 2019, the US Treasury Department (Treasury) issued proposed regulations that would “comprehensively” implement legislation passed last year, the Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act of 2018 (FIRRMA). This would broaden the jurisdiction of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) to review foreign investments in the United States to determine their impact on US national security. FIRRMA expanded the role of CFIUS to review non-controlling foreign investments in US businesses and foreign investments in certain US real estate. Interested parties have until October 17, 2019, to file comments that could influence how Treasury finalizes the rules, which FIRRMA requires be completed by February 13, 2020.

    Under prior legislation, CFIUS has had authority to review transactions that could result in control of a US business by a foreign person. FIRRMA expanded the authority of CFIUS to review certain foreign non-controlling investments and real estate transactions that previously fell outside its jurisdiction. A CFIUS review of any transaction may result in the transaction being cleared to proceed without revision, cleared to proceed with mitigating measures to address any national security issues, or blocked on account of unresolved national security issues. The new rules would provide important clarity and predictability for the business community concerning how CFIUS will treat foreign investment transactions.

    Although FIRRMA provided for CFIUS to establish a filing fee requirement for notifications and reviews, the new proposed rules do not impose a filing fee. Instead, Treasury has indicated that it will publish a separate proposed rule regarding fees at a later date.

    The proposed rules can be accessed here: Proposed-FIRRMA-Regulations-Part-800 and Proposed-FIRRMA-Regulations-Part-802. CFIUS guidance on the proposed rules can be accessed here: Proposed-FIRRMA-Regulations-FACT-SHEET and Proposed-FIRRMA-Regs-FAQs. Following is a summary of key provisions.

    Rules for ‘Covered Investments’

    Prior to FIRRMA, CFIUS had authority to review controlling investments (primarily acquisitions) in US businesses by foreign persons, called “covered transactions.” FIRRMA expanded CFIUS’s jurisdiction to authorize reviews of certain non-controlling investments by foreign persons in a US business if (1) such investment affords the foreign person

    • access to material nonpublic technical information;
    • membership, observer, or nomination rights for the board of directors or equivalent; or
    • involvement in substantive decision-making regarding
    • use, development, acquisition, safekeeping, or release of “sensitive personal data” of US citizens;
    • use, development, acquisition, or release of “critical technologies”; or
    • management, operation, manufacture, or supply of “critical infrastructure”;

    and (2) if the US business is one that

    • produces, designs, tests, manufactures, fabricates or develops one or more “critical technologies”;
    • owns, operates, manufactures, supplies or services “critical infrastructure”; or
    • maintains or collects “sensitive personal data” of US citizens that may be exploited in a manner that threatens US national security.

    In the first of two sets of proposed new rules, Treasury will amend its existing Title 31, Part 800 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) to define more clearly the highlighted terms above. The new rules would name such a non-controlling investment subject to CFIUS jurisdiction a “covered investment,” rename a foreign controlling investment in a US business a “covered control transaction” and retain the old term “covered transaction” to cover both of the foregoing as well as any transaction intended to evade or circumvent the CFIUS law.

    Under the new rules, CFIUS reviews of most covered investments would continue to be triggered by parties voluntarily notifying CFIUS of the transaction, by filing either a full notice or a short-form “declaration” on a five-page form. However, pursuant to FIRRMA, the rules will make declarations mandatory for certain covered transactions where a foreign government has a “substantial interest” or where the US business involves critical technologies. For the latter, Treasury already has established a “pilot program” mandating declarations or notices for such covered investments, and the new rules would not at this time modify the pilot program.

    Neither FIRRMA nor the proposed rules establish a “white list” or “black list” to treat distinctly any specified countries or nationals thereof. However, the new rules would create an exception from “covered investments” (but not from “covered control transactions”) for foreign persons that qualify as “excepted investors” (i.e., investors tied to a country that CFIUS determines to be an “excepted foreign state” based on that country’s maintenance and compliance with certain laws and practices in furtherance of national security protection).

    Rules for Certain Real Estate Transactions

    In a second set of proposed rules creating a new Part 802 of CFR Title 31, Treasury would implement the provisions of FIRRMA that authorize CFIUS to review certain real estate transactions. Specifically, FIRRMA subjected to CFIUS jurisdiction the lease by, or concession to, a foreign person of private or public real estate that:

    • is, is located within or will function as part of an air or maritime port;
    • is in “close proximity” to (i.e., within one mile of) a US military installation or other sensitive US government property;
    • could provide the foreign person the ability to collect intelligence on activities at such US government property; or
    • could expose national security activities at such US government property to foreign surveillance risk.

    An appendix to the proposed rules lists by name and location relevant military installations and incorporates lists of relevant airports and maritime ports published by the US Department of Transportation.

    The rules do not impose a mandatory filing with CFIUS for covered real estate transactions; rather, parties to covered real estate transactions may voluntarily file a notice or short-form declaration to seek review and clearance by CFIUS.

    As in the case of “covered investments,” the new CFIUS real estate rules create exceptions from coverage for certain foreign persons defined as “excepted real estate investors” if they have requisite ties to certain countries that CFIUS identifies as “excepted real estate foreign states” and if the persons are found to comply with certain national security-related laws of those countries. The new rules provide other exceptions from the scope of covered real estate transactions for single housing units, real estate in an “urbanized area” and office space in multi-unit commercial office buildings.

    Considerations for Parties to Covered Transactions and Covered Real Estate Transactions

    FIRRMA, which passed with large bipartisan congressional and executive branch support, leaves a wide range of discretion for CFIUS. Those contemplating transactions involving foreign investment in the United States should carefully consider the scope of the new CFIUS rules, in conjunction with the political and practical dimensions of US national security concerns, to determine if and/or how the new rules may apply. From these perspectives, interested parties should also consider submitting comments prior to the comment deadline of October 17 to influence how Treasury finalizes the rules.

    CFIUS will continue for now its pilot program mandating notification and CFIUS reviews for certain covered transactions involving US businesses with critical technologies in one of 27 specified industries. Accordingly, parties to such transactions will need to continue to adhere to the interim regulations issued by CFIUS for this program in October 2018 (see McDermott On the Subject on CFIUS Pilot Program).

    To help navigate these regulations, we invite you to access “CFIUS Review Flowcharts: Existing & Proposed Rules.”

    Authors

    David J. Levine

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Raymond Paretzky

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Patent Protection for Medical 3D Printing & Bioprinting Technologies

    ARTICLE

    Patent Protection for Medical 3D Printing & Bioprinting Technologies

    September 20, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • NFA Updates FAQs on Swaps Proficiency Requirements

    NFA Updates FAQs on Swaps Proficiency Requirements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    NFA Updates FAQs on Swaps Proficiency Requirements

    September 20, 2019

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Sept. 12, 2019, the National Futures Association updated its Frequently Asked Questions on the upcoming new swaps proficiency requirements for “associated persons” of NFA members that engage in swaps-related activities.[1]

    Hedge fund managers registered as commodity pool operators that have not yet determined whether their associated persons will be subject to these new requirements should do so as soon as possible. (Associated persons of a commodity pool operator, generally, are individuals that have an active role in soliciting investors.) To be clear, the new requirements will not apply to personnel of investment managers exempt from NFA membership under a Rule 4.13 or other exemption.

    As noted in a prior Alert,[2] the NFA’s swaps proficiency requirements will be structured as a set of online course modules that may be completed one at a time, at any time, and from any up-to-date computer. They will be more “tutorial-like” than a conventional exam (although responsive questions to the course material will be administered) Associated persons of commodity pool operators will only be required to complete modules relating to assessing their familiarity with swaps products and their applications, swaps market regulation, supervision requirements, and other compliance, anti-fraud and miscellaneous issues. The compliance deadline for these new requirements is Jan. 31, 2021 and the target date for initial access to the online training modules is Jan. 31, 2020.

    The NFA’s new FAQs provide information on several aspects of the new swaps proficiency requirements, notably:

    • How long will this take? The NFA estimates that the “short track” (which is the option applicable for most commodity pool operators) may be completed in as few as four hours.
    • How much will this cost? Nothing, for individuals already associated with a registered NFA member (the cost of enrollment is factored into annual NFA membership dues).
    • What are the computer system requirements? System requirements to access the online coursework are very modest. Virtually any internet-connected desktop computer should suffice. Both Macs and PCs are supported.
    • What happens if an associated person fails a module? A score of 70% will be a passing module grade. If an associated person fails a module, he or she may take it again after completing the remaining modules. There is no waiting period.
    • Can an associated person skip the tutorials and go right to the tests? The learning components must be completed first.
    • What will happen if an associated person switches employers? Swaps proficiency requirements will generally transfer with the associated person (subject, on a going-forward basis, to there being no two-year gap in the individual’s registration history as a swaps associated person).
    • How can an employer check completion status? NFA members can check whether their associated persons have successfully completed the NFA’s swaps proficiency requirements through the Online Registration System portal.

    Next Steps

    The NFA’s new swaps proficiency requirements are being provided with ample advance notice in a convenient format. The updated FAQs, which all NFA member managers should quickly review, reaffirm that members should find compliance straight-forward. To avert the possibility of a last minute rush, however, NFA member managers should (if they have not already):

    • Identify personnel who will need to complete the swaps proficiency requirements; and
    • Add Jan. 31, 2020 (the date of the swaps proficiency modules online availability) and Jan. 31, 2021 (the deadline for compliance) to their compliance calendars.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Joshua B. Wright.

    If you have any questions concerning advance notice bylaws, owning shares in record name or this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See NFA Swaps Proficiency Requirements FAQs, available here.

    [2] See New NFA Proficiency Requirements for Hedge Fund Managers (May 2, 2019), available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • CFTC Sanctions CCO for Participation in Fraud: Lessons for Private Fund Compliance Officers

    CFTC Sanctions CCO for Participation in Fraud: Lessons for Private Fund Compliance Officers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFTC Sanctions CCO for Participation in Fraud: Lessons for Private Fund Compliance Officers

    September 19, 2019

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Sept. 12, 2019, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) instituted and settled an action against the chief compliance officer of a private fund manager registered as a commodity pool operator.[1] The CCO was fined $125,000, received a cease and desist order and is subject to other ongoing sanctions.

    The Marconato Order

    The CFTC order [2] alleges that the CCO, Rafael Marconato, engaged in fraud alongside the manager’s chief executive officer. Marconato and the CEO are alleged to have engaged in solicitation activities involving the preparation and distribution of advertising documents that presented false positive performance, when, in fact, the manager, and the CEO himself, misappropriated participants’ funds for their own benefit.

    The National Futures Association (“NFA”) commenced an examination of the manager in November 2017, and Marconato is also alleged to have made knowing misstatements and to have provided false documents to the NFA. In addition, Marconato is alleged to have engaged in a redemption that was effectively funded by investments made on the basis of his misrepresentations.

    As a result of his actions, Marconato was ordered by the CFTC to make $125,000 in restitution payments and to pay a $25,000 civil penalty. Marconato is also permanently prohibited from trading commodity interests for himself or others, soliciting or accepting funds from others for the purpose of trading commodity interests, and from registering with the CFTC.

    Given the scope and nature of his alleged actions, Marconato’s sanctions were relatively light, which was the result of his ongoing cooperation in ongoing litigation against other parties.

    Lessons for Private Fund Managers

    While the actions alleged to have been carried out by Marconato, the manager and the manager’s CEO are clearly extreme, this action still contains a number of lessons and practice tips for the average private fund manager.

    One point to note, which we have mentioned in earlier Alerts, is that the CFTC is aggressively and effectively leveraging its relationships with the NFA and other regulators and self-regulatory organizations. All managerial personnel, and especially compliance and finance personnel, should be cognizant that any and all statements made or documents provided to the NFA, either on examination or in less formal situations, may be referred to the CFTC and its enforcement staff.

    A second point to consider is that the CFTC is willing to pursue cases (and defendants) that have ties to non-U.S. jurisdictions. In this case, the CFTC pursued Marconato from his original location of Miami to his current residence in Brazil. Indeed, the CFTC’s Director of Enforcement, James McDonald, was quoted as stating, “The reach of our enforcement efforts does not stop at our borders — we will root out fraud and misconduct in our markets no matter where it originates. I want to thank our U.S. and international law enforcement partners for their assistance in this matter.”

    A final aspect of this matter to note is that Marconato was acting as (and charged as) a chief compliance officer. While the allegations of personal involvement in fraud indicate that this is not a borderline case of “CCO liability” for failing to effectively administer a compliance program, actions like this could more generally color the views of examiners in assessing actions of CCOs and other control personnel. Also, while the facts here are far away from the normal course of business of a private fund manager, this case can also serve as a reminder that any CCO transaction with a fund or other client (e.g., a redemption) may deserve extra or independent scrutiny.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Joshua B. Wright.

    If you have any questions concerning advance notice bylaws, owning shares in record name or this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See CFTC Orders Chief Compliance Officer of Trading Firm to Pay $150,000 for Fraud and False Statements to a Self-Regulatory Organization (Sept. 12, 2019), available here.

    [2] See Order Instituting Proceedings Pursuant To Section 6(C) And (D) Of The Commodity Exchange Act, Making Findings, And Imposing Remedial Sanctions (Sept. 12, 2019), available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Recent Developments in Delaware Corporate Law

    Recent Developments in Delaware Corporate Law

    ARTICLE

    Recent Developments in Delaware Corporate Law

    October 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Ashley R. Altschuler

    Partner

    Wilmington

    Ethan H. Townsend

    Partner

    Wilmington

    More insights

  • To Defer or Not to Defer: Kisor’s Impact on Tax Controversies

    ARTICLE

    To Defer or Not to Defer: Kisor’s Impact on Tax Controversies

    September 13, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • PBGC’s Multiemployer Insurance Program Faces Insolvency, While Single-Employer Program Improves

    PBGC’s Multiemployer Insurance Program Faces Insolvency, While Single-Employer Program Improves

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    PBGC’s Multiemployer Insurance Program Faces Insolvency, While Single-Employer Program Improves

    September 17, 2019

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation’s Multiemployer Insurance Program is close to collapse, while its Single-Employer Insurance Program continues to improve. We discuss implications and predictions for both programs over the coming years.

    In depth

    The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) recently issued a press release announcing that the Multiemployer Insurance Program remains in a dire financial condition, nearing insolvency. The agency’s insurance program for multiemployer pensions, covering more than 10 million people, will likely run out of money by the end of fiscal year 2025, according to the FY 2018 Projections Report. On the other hand, the PBGC’s projection for the Single-Employer Program shows continued improvement. However, these positive projections are subject to a range of potential outcomes due to the Program’s sensitivity to economic conditions.

    Without changes in the law, the financial conditions of the PBGC’s Multiemployer Insurance Program will continue to worsen over the next 10 years. Approximately 125 multiemployer plans, covering 1.4 million people, are predicted to run out of money within the next 20 years. An increase of larger claims submitted to the Multiemployer Insurance Program will exhaust the program assets and lead to the program’s insolvency by the end of FY 2025. If the Multiemployer Program runs out of money, current law requires the PBGC to decrease guarantees to the amount that can be paid from the Multiemployer Program premium income. The PBGC’s guarantee is the amount of retirement benefits that the PBGC insures for each participant, which is capped by law. As a result, the guarantees would be reduced to a fraction of current values.

    The President’s FY 2020 Budget proposes to create a new variable rate premium and an exit premium for the Multiemployer Insurance Program, raising an additional $18 billion in premium revenue over the 10-year budget window. The proposal includes a provision that permits a waiver of the additional premium to avoid increasing the insolvency risk of the most troubled plans.

    The PBGC’s Single-Employer Insurance Program, covering approximately 26 million participants, continues to improve and last year arose from a deficit for the first time since 2001. Continued improvement is expected, although it is not certain because the program is vulnerable to a downturn in the economy. The Single-Employer Program is exposed to a substantial amount of underfunding in plans sponsored by employers who are financially weak. The average projected net position for FY 2028 is $37 billion in future dollars ($27 billion in today’s dollar). The PBGC’s projected improvements in the Program’s financial position result from better funding of pension plans and the projection that in the future PBGC premiums will exceed projected claims.

    Authors
    More insights