Content Type: Article

  • 5G Is Here: Get Ready for the Cybersecurity Battles of Tomorrow

    5G Is Here: Get Ready for the Cybersecurity Battles of Tomorrow

    ARTICLE

    5G Is Here: Get Ready for the Cybersecurity Battles of Tomorrow

    November 5, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

     

     

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The GILTI High-Tax Exclusion: An Additional Planning Tool for Noncorporate US Shareholders

    The GILTI High-Tax Exclusion: An Additional Planning Tool for Noncorporate US Shareholders

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The GILTI High-Tax Exclusion: An Additional Planning Tool for Noncorporate US Shareholders

    November 5, 2020

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    An individual or trust US shareholder of a controlled foreign corporation (CFC) faces harsh treatment under the global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI) regime. These tax implications have forced these taxpayers to pursue planning to mitigate their US tax liability. Now that the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) have finalized regulations permitting a US shareholder to elect the GILTI high-tax exclusion for its GILTI inclusion amount, noncorporate US shareholders should analyze the benefits and costs of using this additional planning tool.

    In depth

    Background

    The GILTI regime requires a US shareholder of a CFC to include a significant amount of the CFC’s income in its gross income on an annual basis. In so doing, a domestic C corporation shareholder can reduce its US tax liability associated with GILTI by claiming a deduction equal to 50% of its GILTI amount, and by also claiming a foreign tax credit equal to 80% of foreign taxes paid or accrued. As a result, a domestic C corporation shareholder generally has a US effective tax rate of 10.5% on its GILTI inclusion, which can be further reduced or even eliminated to the extent the US shareholder may claim a foreign tax credit to offset its US tax liability.

    By contrast, a noncorporate US shareholder cannot claim the 50% deduction or a foreign tax credit with respect to its GILTI inclusion amount, and such amounts are subject to US federal income tax at 37% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax. Thus, absent any planning, the GILTI rules apply significantly higher US tax rates on GILTI attributed to noncorporate US shareholders than to domestic C corporation shareholders.

    Noncorporate US shareholders have generally reduced the effect of GILTI by either making a section 962 election to be subject to corporate tax rates (thereby permitting a 50% deduction and a foreign tax credit), by contributing the shares of CFCs to a domestic C corporation, by engaging in check-the-box planning to treat each CFC as a transparent entity for US federal income tax purposes or as described in more detail below, by making an election to exclude certain high-taxed GILTI from its gross income under the GILTI high-tax exclusion.

    GILTI High-Tax Exclusion as an Additional Planning Tool

    Proposed Regulations

    In June 2019, Treasury and IRS issued proposed regulations (REG-101828-19) (the “Proposed Regulations”) providing US shareholders with the ability to exclude GILTI tested income subject to a foreign tax rate in excess of 18.9% from its GILTI determination (the “GILTI high-tax exclusion”).

    Many practitioners viewed the GILTI high-tax exclusion in the Proposed Regulations as having limited utility, since the GILTI high-tax exclusion applied for all future tax years once elected, and if revoked, US shareholders were prevented from re-electing the GILTI high-tax exclusion for 60 months. The Proposed Regulations also provided that the GILTI high-tax exclusion applied only for a CFC’s tax year beginning on or after the rules were finalized.

    Final Regulations

    On July 23, 2020, Treasury and the IRS published final regulations on the GILTI high-tax exclusion (85 FR 44620) (the “Final Regulations”). The Final Regulations include several similarities to the Proposed Regulations, including that the GILTI high-tax exclusion must be elected by a “controlling domestic shareholder” of a CFC (generally, US shareholders who own more than 50% of the vote), that the election is binding on all other US shareholders of the CFC and that the election applies to all CFCs in a “controlling domestic shareholder group” (despite several taxpayer comments requesting that the election be made on a CFC-by-CFC basis).

    Despite these similarities, the Final Regulations make several significant changes that may impact whether noncorporate US shareholders may consider electing the GILTI high-tax exclusion. In particular, the Final Regulations provide US shareholders with additional flexibility by permitting US shareholders to elect the GILTI high-tax exclusion on an annual basis without imposition of the 60-month limitation. The Final Regulations also permit US shareholders to choose to apply the GILTI high-tax exclusion retroactively to taxable years of CFCs that begin after December 31, 2017.

    Conformity with Subpart F High-Tax Exception

    On the same day as issuing the Final Regulations, Treasury and the IRS also issued proposed regulations on the Subpart F high-tax exception under section 954(b)(4) (REG-127732-19). These proposed regulations generally conform the Subpart F high-tax exception to the GILTI high-tax exclusion. As a result, a noncorporate US shareholder analyzing the benefits of electing the GILTI high-tax exclusion should include in its modeling any Subpart F income items that may so qualify for the Subpart F high-tax exception. See our On the Subject for a more complete description of the proposed regulations on the Subpart F high-tax exception.

    Benefits and Costs of the GILTI High-Tax Exclusion

    Opportunity for Deferral

    In many cases, noncorporate US shareholders have already reduced the effect of GILTI by either making a section 962 election or by contributing the shares of CFCs to a domestic C corporation. While these tools offer a substantial benefit for US shareholders, especially those with high-taxed CFCs (i.e., since the foreign tax credit mechanism generally results in no residual US taxation where the foreign effective tax rate exceeds 13.125%), noncorporate US shareholders should also consider the potential utility of the GILTI high-tax exclusion.

    The GILTI high-tax exclusion may provide noncorporate US shareholders the ability to defer US taxation on net tested income in certain cases, which may help improve short-term or medium-term cash flow requirements for noncorporate US shareholders as well as the businesses they operate. For example, a noncorporate US shareholder that made a section 962 election or that contributed the shares of CFCs to a domestic C corporation, could use the GILTI high-tax exclusion to mitigate any residual US taxation on GILTI where the application of the expense allocation and apportionment provisions results in a foreign tax credit limitation under section 904 principles, or where the utilization of losses adversely impacts the taxable income limitation under section 250.

    Because the GILTI high-tax exclusion may be made on an annual basis, noncorporate US shareholders have the ability to alternate between the GILTI high-tax exclusion and the section 962 election on an annual basis to the extent that may prove advantageous.

    Modeling the Tax Impact of the GILTI High-Tax Exclusion

    Since gross income earned by high-taxed CFCs is not included in the US shareholder’s GILTI amount, noncorporate US shareholders should model the impact of corresponding tax attributes on its overall GILTI tax liability. Specifically, each high-taxed CFC’s qualified business asset investment (QBAI) and foreign taxes paid or accrued can no longer be included in determining each US shareholder’s GILTI tax liability. This is especially important because GILTI tax liability is determined on a net basis, aggregating all CFCs a US shareholder owns. If some CFCs are subject to a high tax rate and others subject to a low tax rate, the high-tax exclusion will eliminate the benefit of the high-tax CFCs’ foreign tax credits being netted against the GILTI generated by the low-tax-rate CFCs. Similarly, to the extent that high-tax CFCs may have a large amount of QBAI, making the election will result in the loss of that QBAI, potentially increasing GILTI amounts generated by low-tax CFCs’ tested income.

    Noncorporate US shareholders should also take into account whether electing the GILTI high-tax exclusion may impact any investments in US property, since gross income earned by high-taxed CFCs will no longer generate previously taxed earnings and profits (PTEP), but instead, will generate untaxed earnings and profits (E&P) that may be included as part of the CFC’s “applicable earnings” that could be treated as a section 956 inclusion to the US shareholder.

    Moreover, a noncorporate US shareholder should consider whether distributions from its high-taxed CFCs may be eligible for the 20% qualified dividend income tax rate (i.e., if the CFC is incorporated in a jurisdiction that has entered into a tax treaty with the United States). A noncorporate US shareholder of a non-treaty jurisdiction CFC may be subject to lower tax rates on distributed income by not electing the GILTI high-tax exclusion or a section 962 election. Alternatively, such shareholder may consider converting the CFC into a transparent entity or by changing the place of incorporation of the CFC to a country that has entered a tax treaty with the United States.

    Weighing Complexities

    The GILTI high-tax exclusion offers a certain simplicity with respect to the US taxation of CFC operations, insofar as it avoids the complexity of applying the foreign tax credit limitation provisions, as well as tracking new classes of “section 962 earnings and profits.” Although certain noncorporate US shareholders could find this appealing, such shareholders should balance this simplicity with other kinds of complexity created by the Final Regulations.

    Whereas the Proposed Regulations applied a qualified business unit (QBU) approach to identify the relevant items of income that may be eligible for the GILTI high-tax exclusion, the Final Regulations replace the QBU-by-QBU approach in the Proposed Regulations with a new “tested unit” standard. By any measure, the tracking and reporting of “tested units” will create additional administrative burdens for taxpayers, especially for noncorporate US shareholders that may not have the internal tax and bookkeeping resources that large US multinationals do. A more robust summary of the key changes found in the Final Regulations is found in our On the Subject.

    Conclusion

    Noncorporate US shareholders now have another tool in their arsenal to mitigate the GILTI tax liability resulting from the harsh application of GILTI. In certain circumstances, the GILTI high-tax exclusion could prove useful for noncorporate US shareholders to mitigate their GILTI tax liability, even in conjunction with other planning tools. Noncorporate US shareholders should carefully analyze the merits of the GILTI high-tax exclusion and would be well advised to model the benefits of GILTI high-tax exclusion with, and against, other planning tools.

    Authors

    Sandra P. McGill

    Counsel

    Chicago

    More insights

  • The End of Intra-EU Investment Protection

    ARTICLE

    The End of Intra-EU Investment Protection

    November 2020

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Termination of intra-EU bilateral investment treaties

    What the agreement for the termination of bilateral investment treaties between the Member States of the European Union of 5 May 2020 entails for investors and how existing intra-EU investments can be protected in the future.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Public Disclosure of Sustainable Investment and Shareholder Engagement Policies

    Public Disclosure of Sustainable Investment and Shareholder Engagement Policies

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Public Disclosure of Sustainable Investment and Shareholder Engagement Policies

    5 November 2020

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The new sustainability-related disclosure obligations are due to come into effect on March 10, 2021 under the EU Regulation on Sustainability-Related Disclosures (“ESG Disclosure Regulation”).[1] When preparing their sustainable investment statements, FCA-regulated managers should also consider revisiting their shareholder engagement policies under the amended Shareholder Rights Directive (“SRD II”). The disclosure obligations under SRD II and the ESG Disclosure Regulation are linked, at least insofar as they relate to the manager’s approach to discharging its stewardship responsibilities and other forms of shareholder engagement aimed at promoting sustainability in portfolio companies. This may mean that some managers will find it helpful to combine those disclosures, as well as the Stewardship Code disclosure (required by the FCA rules), in a single policy statement.

    SRD II disclosure obligations came into effect in the United Kingdom on 10 June 2019, mandating publication of a shareholder engagement policy on the manager’s website. At the time, many managers published generic holding statements in anticipation of developing a more tailored policy over time. Annual disclosure obligations under SRD II apply in addition to the website policy statement disclosures. Some managers may have already been prompted to prepare and release annual updates on their shareholder engagement by requests from their insurance company and pension fund investors that are entitled to detailed reporting under the FCA rules.

    Shareholder Engagement Policy

    Under the FCA rules implementing SRD II, FCA-authorised managers, including alternative investment fund managers, UCITS management companies and MiFID firms are required to develop and disclose publicly a policy specifying how they integrate shareholder engagement in their investment strategy (“Engagement Policy”).

    The requirement to maintain an Engagement Policy applies on a “comply or explain basis” to all managers that invest in publicly traded equities regardless of their investment strategy. Managers who do not consider shareholder engagement relevant to their investment process are required to publish a clear and reasoned explanation of why they have chosen not to have an Engagement Policy. The disclosure must be made freely accessible on the manager’s website.

    The Engagement Policy must explain how the manager:

    • Monitors investee companies on matters, including their strategy, financial and nonfinancial performance and risk, capital structure, social and environmental impact, and corporate governance;
    • Conducts dialogue with investee companies;
    • Exercises voting rights and other rights attached to shares;
    • If applicable, cooperates with other shareholders and communicates with relevant stakeholders of investee companies; and
    • Manages actual and potential conflicts of interests in relation to shareholder engagement.

    Annual Public Disclosure

    On an annual basis, managers must disclose publicly how their Engagement Policy has been implemented during the relevant period. The timing for the annual disclosure is not specified in the rules, but managers should consider publishing their first annual disclosure before the end of 2020 given that the disclosure obligations have now been in effect for over a year.

    The annual disclosure must include general information on their voting during the prior year, including an explanation of the most significant votes and, if applicable, a report on the use of proxy advisers. The rules give managers discretion in determining what information to publish about their voting, as only the casting of “significant” votes needs to be disclosed. A manager may consider a vote insignificant for these purposes (and omit the disclosure) if the holding in the investee company was small or based on the subject matter of such votes.

    Reporting to Insurance Company and Pension Fund Investors

    Firms that manage assets of UK or EU life insurers, reinsurers and occupational pension schemes (“SRD Institutional Investors”), either on a separately managed account basis, or in their funds are subject to additional reporting obligations under SRD II.

    This reporting is more detailed than the annual public disclosure obligations and is designed to provide further detail of how the manager’s Engagement Policy was implemented and contributed to the longer-term performance of the assets of the SRD Institutional Investor. The report must cover at least the following:

    • The key material medium- to long-term risks associated with the investments;
    • Portfolio composition, turnover within the portfolio and turnover costs;
    • The use of proxy advisers;
    • If relevant, the manager’s policy on securities lending and how that policy is applied, particularly at the time of the general meetings of investee companies;
    • How the manager makes investment decisions based on evaluation of medium- to long-term performance of investee companies; and
    • A discussion of any specific conflicts of interests that have arisen in connection with shareholder engagement activities during the relevant period and how the manager has dealt with those conflicts.

    Authored by Anna Maleva-Otto and Olivia Cork.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See New ESG Disclosure Obligations to Take Effect in March 2021.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • NAIC – Innovation and Technology Task Force Letter

    NAIC – Innovation and Technology Task Force Letter

    ARTICLE

    NAIC – Innovation and Technology Task Force Letter

    November 4, 2020

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    This letter is McDermott’s response to the NAIC Innovation Team’s request for information to support making permanent various regulatory accommodations related to innovation and technology during the pandemic.

    In depth

    We are writing in response to the request for information from the Innovation and Technology (EX) Task Force and the Innovation and Technology State Contacts (the “NAIC Innovation Team”) to support making permanent various “regulatory relief” and “regulatory accommodations” related to innovation and technology granted during the pandemic. We believe making these measures permanent will benefit consumers and strengthen the competitive marketplace.

    By way of background, our firm represents a large and diverse client base in the industry that includes traditional and emerging/start-up re/insurers, agents, brokers, MGAs, TPAs, program administrators, investors, and other stakeholders. Our practice spans all lines of business.

    You may recall our correspondence and meeting in Kansas City in 2019 around these issues with you and your team and representatives from several InsurTech firms. Thank you for the opportunity to offer these comments and for your continuing engagement with the industry on these important matters.

    First, we appreciate the work of the NAIC and state insurance regulators to date in modernizing various legal requirements to facilitate innovation, such as in the rebating-related amendments to the Unfair Trade Practices Model Act. The focus and commitment needed to complete that work during the pandemic is not lost on us or our clients.

    Second, we support the comments submitted by the Wholesale & Specialty Insurance Association, and likely comments that we have not yet reviewed from other industry trade associations supporting such regulatory modernization efforts.

    Below is a high-level summary of the regulatory relief and accommodations we believe should be made permanent, in no particular order.

    1. Wet signatures, paper notices, and notarization. Many of these requirements would seem to have little benefit to consumers, provided the same verification and other substantive standards can be satisfied through other means. For example, it seems that regular mail, especially uncertified mail, may not be any more reliable than electronic mail; in our view, receipt of electronic mail would appear much easier to verify than paper mail. Notarization, if/when required to protect consumers and insurer solvency, should be able to be performed virtually. These requirements create extra compliance costs and can be especially burdensome to smaller regulated firms including start-ups. Consumers and the market as a whole would benefit greatly from modernization of these requirements in a uniform and consistent manner across the states that recognizes many consumers wish to transact electronically. Consumers that prefer paper such as payment by check should still be able to do so, but such individual needs should not prevent innovation efforts that benefit the broader industry and consumer base.
    2. Regulatory paper filings. Many a tree has suffered unnecessarily at the hands of state insurance regulatory filings, particularly requirements to file multiple copies of the yellow and blue books. We understand states, while having access to such filings electronically, do not wish to incur the cost to print financial statements and other materials when regulators wish to review away from the computer, in which we would suggest modernizing (i.e., increasing) filing fees to account for such cost. We respectfully suggest regulators accept as compliant any filing that can be made electronically by any regulated entity, for efficiency, public health and many other reasons.
    3. New products. Certain states have facilitated an expedited review process for new products. For example, one state expedited its review of a new no-cost guaranteed issue three-year term life insurance policy for front-line health workers. Consumers around the country would also benefit from the expedited review and approval of many other products currently being developed or awaiting regulatory approval, for example, life products incorporating health and wellness factors into underwriting and rating. Short of an expedited review/approval process, or in the meantime during such process, consumers interested in new products would also benefit from any combination of rate and form filing exemptions, file and use, and expansion of automatic surplus lines export, as applicable.
    4. Expedited filings. Expanding on Item 3 above, and further to our discussions in 2019, we respectfully request the NAIC Team consider the merits of a pre-filing (virtual) meeting, possibly with the participation of one or more insurance departments, to discuss new/novel products. The regulated entity would be able to provide greater transparency around the proposed new product, while receiving more transparency into the filing process and a potentially definitive (e.g., 30 day) timeline for resolution of a complete filing. Such pre-filing meetings could be facilitated through the members of the NAIC Team, using the SERFF platform to flag filings that go through this process. In the meantime, and in addition, companies may also wish to work with individual states, e.g., those that might have an interest in expediting approval of a particular product due to local need or specific innovation initiative.
    5. In-person/physical presence. States have waived requirements that would necessitate inperson presence as well as encouraged insurers to use remote options for functions such as adjusting or inspecting claims. In instances where a personal physical presence or office location is not necessary to protect consumers and the regulatory process, it seems appropriate to repeal all such requirements to avoid unnecessary gatherings and the cost of time and travel. These include physical office requirements (e.g., where a copy of a producer’s license must be displayed prominently for the hypothetical consumer who will never visit the office in person), in-person continuing education and licensing/proctored examinations, as well as in-person audits of MGAs and TPAs, though there will of course be instances where in-person audits and other meetings are warranted. A permanent repeal would avoid the need to issue new Orders/Notices re-instituting such accommodations in any next wave of COVID-19 or the next novel virus or other emergency such as natural catastrophes. In addition, many start-up producers would benefit from express regulatory permission to maintain a purely digital presence, as appropriate, including from outside the U.S. where a good amount of new investment in the industry originates. None of these measures would seem to us to impede regulators’ ability to regulate these entities.
    6. Real-time insurance transactions. Various states have indicated during the pandemic that certain activities will not be deemed unfair trade practices/methods of competition or otherwise in violation of existing state laws such as those governing policy cancellation and nonrenewal. These include (i) mid-term retroactive refunds and other premium adjustments; (ii) temporary termination of coverage; (iii) virtual and self-audits of premium; (iv) limited extensions of coverage in lieu of non-renewal or cancellation; and (v) mid-term coverage extensions (e.g., food delivery for commercial or charitable purposes). Beyond the pandemic, there are many uses for such accommodations, including on-demand, or episodic, insurance and products serving the gig economy. The availability of such real-time insurance products is especially important for small businesses, temporary workers, and the construction industry as the economy builds back. Such accommodations should also extend to real-time, live declinations by admitted insurers for purposes of state surplus lines diligent search requirements, which some states have sought to apply on a risk by risk basis for products widely known to be unavailable from admitted insurers.

    We believe the above accommodations are reasonable and intuitive. The past eight months have essentially served as a pilot program, or “sandbox”, in which these accommodations were tested in many states in one form or another, with no discernible effect on solvency regulation or consumer protection. We would of course appreciate any opportunity to discuss our comments and for other opportunities to collaborate with the NAIC Innovation Team. Thank you again for your consideration.

    Authors

    H. Michael Byrne

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Seeing Beyond the Wall of Capital

    Seeing Beyond the Wall of Capital

    ARTICLE

    Seeing Beyond the Wall of Capital

    November 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Reprinted with permission from Refinitiv Project Finance International

    In depth
    Authors

    Christopher Gladbach

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Seth B. Doughty

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Further Tightening of the German Investment Control Regime – a Critical Overview and Outlook

    ARTICLE

    Further Tightening of the German Investment Control Regime – a Critical Overview and Outlook

    November 3, 2020

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    With the First Amendment Act to the Foreign Trade and Payments Act, which came into force on 17 July 2020, and the Fifteenth Amendment of the Foreign Trade and Payments Regulation of 3 June 2020, which was hastily pushed forward in the light of the corona pandemic, more M&A transactions will in future fall within the scope of the German investment control regime than was previously the case.

    In his article, Dr. Germar Enders explains how the state’s powers of inspection and intervention are again being expanded and the regulatory regime is further tightened as a whole. The article analyses the material changes of the law and their effects on transaction practice.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Next-Generation Cybersecurity Disclosures for Publicly Traded Companies

    Next-Generation Cybersecurity Disclosures for Publicly Traded Companies

    ARTICLE

    Next-Generation Cybersecurity Disclosures for Publicly Traded Companies

    November 4, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Executive Order on Workplace Training for Federal Contractors and Federal Grant Recipients Released

    Executive Order on Workplace Training for Federal Contractors and Federal Grant Recipients Released

    ARTICLE

    Executive Order on Workplace Training for Federal Contractors and Federal Grant Recipients Released

    November 4, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Maria C. Rodriguez

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Government Revises Base Difference Rules in New Foreign Tax Credit Regulations

    Government Revises Base Difference Rules in New Foreign Tax Credit Regulations

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Government Revises Base Difference Rules in New Foreign Tax Credit Regulations

    November 3, 2020

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On September 29, 2020, the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued final regulations (TD 9922) (the 2020 Final Regulations) and related proposed regulations (REG-101657-20) (the 2020 Proposed Regulations) that address the treatment of “base differences” for purposes of allocating and apportioning foreign taxes. These regulations contain important and helpful changes to proposed regulations that were issued in 2019 (REG-105495-19) (the 2019 Proposed Regulations). In particular, these regulations limit the situations in which taxpayers are prevented from claiming foreign tax credits attributable to base difference items.

    In depth

    The 2019 Proposed Regulations

    The 2019 Proposed Regulations provided a detailed framework for allocating and apportioning foreign taxes that was generally consistent with existing law: Taxes are allocated and apportioned on the basis of the income as computed under foreign law on which the tax is imposed. In general, under the 2019 Proposed Regulations, foreign gross income is assigned to the grouping to which the corresponding US item is assigned. If an item of foreign gross income arises from the same transaction as an item of gross income under US tax law, the foreign gross income item is assigned to the same statutory or residual grouping as the related US item.

    If foreign tax is imposed on an amount that does not constitute income under US tax principles, the tax is attributable to a base difference*. The 2019 Proposed Regulations provided an exclusive list of seven items of foreign gross income that are attributable to a base difference. This list consisted of: (1) section 101 death benefits; (2) section 102 gifts and inheritances; (3) section 118 contributions to capital; (4) section 1032 receipts of money or other property in exchange for stock (including in a section 351(a) exchange); (5) section 721 receipts of money or other property in exchange for a partnership interest; (6) section 301(c)(2) distributions of property by a corporation as a return of basis; and (7) section 733 distributions to a partner.

    Under the 2019 Proposed Regulations, if an item of foreign gross income is attributable to a base difference, that foreign gross income was assigned to the residual grouping, and, as such, taxes associated with the foreign gross income paid by a controlled foreign corporation (CFC) would not have been creditable. As a result, foreign taxes on common transactions such as a partnership distribution to a CFC partner would not have been creditable. Foreign taxes that are paid by a domestic corporation and attributable to a base difference were assigned to the category described in section 904(d)(2)(H)(i). This section currently cross-references foreign branch income, though this cross-reference may reflect an inadvertent drafting error (with the intended cross-reference being general category income).

    *Note: Disregarded payments do not give rise to a base difference (even though they do not constitute income under US tax principles) and are instead subject to a highly complex set of rules in the 2020 Proposed Regulations that are beyond the scope of this On the Subject. These rules will be covered in a future On the Subject entry.

    Modifications to the Base Difference Rules in the 2020 Final Regulations and 2020 Proposed Regulations

    The 2020 Final Regulations generally retain the approach of the 2019 Proposed Regulations in allocating and apportioning foreign taxes, including the incorporation of an exclusive list of base differences. Thus, if a foreign tax is attributable to one of these base differences, it is generally assigned to a residual grouping (and, if paid by a CFC, is not creditable). However, in response to comments, Treasury and the IRS removed section 301(c)(2) distributions and section 733 distributions from the base difference list. The other five base difference items from the 2019 Proposed Regulations remain in the 2020 Final Regulations.

    In the preamble to the 2020 Final Regulations, Treasury and the IRS explained that, in most cases, a foreign tax imposed on distributions described in sections 301(c)(2) and 733 is likely to represent tax on earnings and profits of the distributing entity that are accounted for at different times under US and foreign tax law (such as earnings of a hybrid partnership, earnings that are accelerated and subsequently eliminated for US tax purposes by reason of a section 338 election, or earnings and profits of lower-tier entities) rather than amounts that are permanently excluded from the US tax base.

    As foreign taxes on section 301(c)(2) distributions are now treated as attributable to timing differences related to the distributing corporation’s earnings, under new Treas. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(i)(B)(2), such taxes are attributable to “hypothetical earnings” of the distributing corporation, measured based on the groupings to which the tax book value of the distributing corporation’s stock is assigned under the asset method in Treas. Reg. § 1.861-9. If, for example, CFC stock is categorized as a section 951A category asset in the hands of a US shareholder, foreign taxes paid on a section 301(c)(2) distribution received by the US shareholder would be assigned to the US shareholder’s section 951A category. If CFC stock is characterized as an asset in multiple groupings, including the section 951A category, the exempt income and asset rule under Treas. Reg. § 1.861-8(d)(2)(ii)(C) with respect to the section 250 deduction likely will apply to cause foreign taxes to be assigned to other non-section 951A categories. To the extent that a portion of the CFC stock is assigned to a section 245A subgroup under section 904(b)(4) and Treas. Reg. § 1.904(b)-3(c), a portion of the foreign taxes paid on return of capital amounts with respect to the CFC would appear to be assigned to the section 245A subgroup. The 2020 Proposed Regulations provide that in that case, neither a foreign tax credit nor a deduction would be allowed for such foreign taxes.

    The 2020 Proposed Regulations contain similar “hypothetical earnings” rules for the treatment of distributions from partnerships. The rule in Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(3)(ii)(B) uses the asset apportionment percentages of the tax book value of a partner’s distributive share of the partnership’s assets (or, in the case of a limited partner with less than a 10% interest, the tax book value of the partnership interest) as a surrogate for the partner’s distributive share of earnings of the partnership that are not recognized in the year in which the distribution is made for US tax purposes.

    The 2020 Proposed Regulations also contain rules that are intended to align the treatment of foreign taxes attributable to the return of capital distributions described above with foreign taxes attributable to amounts that essentially represent a return of capital on a disposition of stock or a partnership interest. For example, if a taxpayer sells stock and recognizes a greater amount of gain for foreign tax purposes than for US tax purposes (e.g., due to differences in determining stock basis), foreign taxes attributable to the excess of the foreign gain over US gain are allocated and apportioned based on the groupings to which the tax book value of the corporation’s stock is assigned under the asset method.

    Implications for Taxpayers

    The removal of return of capital distributions from the exclusive list of base differences is a welcome development for taxpayers, as foreign taxes that otherwise would have been assigned to a residual grouping (and therefore “lost,” if paid by a CFC) are more likely to be creditable under the 2020 Final Regulations.

    To apply the asset method to assign foreign taxes attributable to return of capital amounts, taxpayers will generally use data for interest expense apportionment to compute the tax book value of stock or partnership interests (or, in the case of partners that own 10% or more of a partnership, data on the underlying assets of the partnership) and apply the relevant section 861 expense allocation and apportionment rules. Much of this information might be readily available even if the CFC applies the modified gross income method for purposes of characterization, and additional administrative work could be worthwhile to avoid “losing” taxes on a base difference.

    Assigning foreign taxes based on the tax book value of CFC stock will likely result in a greater portion of foreign taxes (either paid directly or deemed paid) assigned to the section 951A category (rather than being assigned to a residual category under the approach of the 2019 Proposed Regulations). If not fully creditable in the current year, such taxes are “lost” and cannot be carried forward or back to other taxable years. A portion of the foreign taxes paid on return of capital amounts with respect to the CFC may be assigned to the section 245A subgroup if a portion of the CFC stock is assigned to a section 245A subgroup. In that case, the 2020 Proposed Regulations provide that neither a foreign tax credit nor a deduction would be allowed for such foreign taxes.

    Applicability Dates

    The 2020 Final Regulations addressing base differences are effective for taxable years that begin after December 31, 2019. The 2020 Proposed Regulations addressing base differences are proposed to apply for taxable years that begin after December 31, 2019, and end on or after the date on which the 2020 Proposed Regulations are filed in the Federal Register.

    Authors

    Bradford E. LaBonte

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Michael J. Wilder

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights