Content Type: Article

  • Captive Taxation 2015: The Year in Review

    ARTICLE

    Captive Taxation 2015: The Year in Review

    January 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Elizabeth Erickson and Kristen Hazel, working with Tom Jones, wrote in this bylined article that “2015 was an exciting year for captive insurance taxation, bringing with it important guidance with respect to what is, and what is not, insurance for federal tax purposes.” The authors reviewed major court cases and Treasury rulings which provided important insights on risk distribution and how it affects insurance characterization.

    Authors

    Kristen E. Hazel

    Partner & Deputy General Counsel

    Chicago

    More insights

  • SEC Proposes Rule Governing the Use of Derivatives and Short Sales by Registered Investment Companies and Business Development Companies

    SEC Proposes Rule Governing the Use of Derivatives and Short Sales by Registered Investment Companies and Business Development Companies

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Proposes Rule Governing the Use of Derivatives and Short Sales by Registered Investment Companies and Business Development Companies

    January 15, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Dec. 11, 2015, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) issued a release proposing the adoption of new Rule 18f-4 under the Investment Company Act of 1940 (the “1940 Act”). The proposed rule, if adopted as proposed, will establish new limitations on the use of derivatives by registered investment companies and business development companies (collectively, “regulated funds”). It will also regulate other trading practices of such funds (including short sales of securities) that are deemed to involve the issuance of “senior securities.” Hedge funds and other private investment funds will not be subject to the rule. The SEC is soliciting comment on the proposed rule. The deadline for submitting comments is March 28, 2016.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Compliance and M&A in Latin America: Some Practical Recommendations

    ARTICLE

    Compliance and M&A in Latin America: Some Practical Recommendations

    January 14, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Nicolas Lafont wrote this bylined article on the anti-corruption compliance risk for French companies in Latin American transactions. “While it should not be exaggerated, this risk is very real,” Mr. Lafont wrote, adding that “French investors who carry out M & A transactions in Latin America must adopt effective means of protection against the risk that the target has committed acts of corruption.” Read the full article.

    In depth

    Nicolas Lafont wrote this bylined article on the anti-corruption compliance risk for French companies in Latin American transactions. “While it should not be exaggerated, this risk is very real,” Mr. Lafont wrote, adding that “French investors who carry out M & A transactions in Latin America must adopt effective means of protection against the risk that the target has committed acts of corruption.” Read the full article.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Seventh Circuit Voids Lien Securing Rescue Loan but Rejects Equitable Subordination Claim

    Seventh Circuit Voids Lien Securing Rescue Loan but Rejects Equitable Subordination Claim

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Seventh Circuit Voids Lien Securing Rescue Loan but Rejects Equitable Subordination Claim

    January 14, 2016

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    A “bank [making a secured rescue loan] had information that should have created the requisite suspicion … to conduct a diligent search for possible dirt” — i.e., whether the debtor had the right to pledge $312 million of customer securities, held the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on Jan. 8, 2016. In re Sentinel Management Group, Inc., 2016 WL 98601, at *2 (7th Cir. Jan. 8, 2016) [“Sentinel V”]. The Seventh Circuit reversed the district court, voided the defendant bank’s lien as a fraudulent transfer, and rejected the bank’s good faith defense. Based on the district court’s detailed findings of inquiry notice, the Seventh Circuit stressed that “the bank had lent approximately $300 million to a company that had capital equal to roughly 1/150th of that amount” at a time when the debtor was mysteriously “able to secure the entire loan.” Id. at *3. Because the “obvious” source of the collateral “was the [debtor’s] customer accounts,” and because “the bank had … documents [showing] on even a casual perusal … that [the debtor] lacked authority to pledge” the assets, the bank “was on inquiry notice that the assets … had been fraudulently” pledged to it. Id. at *6. Nevertheless, the court of appeals affirmed the district court’s refusal to subordinate the bank’s unsecured claim because the bank’s “negligence” was not “an adequate basis for imposing equitable subordination.” Id. at *5. According to the court, “the trustee ha[d] not proved” that the bank knew the debtor “was securing the bank’s loans with customers’ money without their consent.” Id.

    Relevance

    Sentinel V provides lenders with helpful guidance in the making of rescue loans. It not only shows the importance of “inquiry notice” to a lender’s asserted “good faith” defense, but it also shows what constitutes “egregious and conscience shocking” conduct for a lender’s claim to be subordinated on equitable grounds. In re Sentinel Management Group, Inc., 2014 WL 6990322, at *1 (N.D. Ill. Dec. 10, 2014) (“Sentinel IV”). Sentinel V is the fifth reported decision on this dispute in eight years of litigation. The transfers under attack were made in 2007; the district court’s original decision came down in 2010; and the Seventh Circuit handed down two prior opinions in 2012 and 2013. Before rendering its 2010 decision, In re Sentinel Management Group, Inc., 441 B.R. 864 (N.D. Ill. 2010) (“Sentinel I”), the district court had “struggled with the issues following a seventeen day bench trial. After hearing from more than a dozen witnesses, listening to audio recordings between [the parties], and reviewing hundreds of exhibits,” it had initially dismissed the trustee’s claims six years ago. In re Sentinel Management Group, Inc., 728 F.3d 660, 666 (7th Cir. 2013) (“Sentinel III”).

    The Seventh Circuit In Sentinel III had held that the debtor investment manager’s “failure to keep client funds properly segregated” and its later pledge of those funds “to secure an overnight loan” from the defendant bank to stay in business may have constituted (1) a fraudulent transfer; and (2) grounds for equitably subordinating the bank’s $312-million secured claim. Id. at 668, 670-72. Reversing and remanding the case to the district court for further litigation over the bank’s asserted “good faith” defense because of “inconsistencies” in that court’s Sentinel I decision, the Seventh Circuit found that the debtor-manager’s “pledge of segregated funds as collateral for loans” was likely a fraudulent transfer based on its “actual intent to hinder, delay or defraud” creditors under Bankruptcy Code (“Code”) Section 548(a)(1)(A). Id. at 666. See M.L. Cook, “Seventh Circuit Reverses ‘Inconsistent’ District Court Fraudulent Transfer and Equitable Subordination Ruling,” 31 Bankr. Strategist, No. 1 (November 2013). When remanding, the Seventh Circuit stressed in Sentinel III that the bank’s good-faith-for-value defense on remand will be “very difficult” because it will have to prove “that it was not on inquiry notice of [the debtor’s] possible insolvency.” Id. at 668 n.2. The Seventh Circuit in Sentinel III directed the lower court, on remand, to “clarify … exactly” what the lender knew and whether its “failure to investigate” the debtor was “reckless” or “deliberately indifferent.” Id. at 672.

    The district court, in Sentinel IV, purportedly clarifying its prior Sentinel I opinion, held that the bank’s “good faith” insulated it under Code Section 548(c) from liability. It also held that the bank had not engaged in “egregious conduct” sufficient to subordinate its lien on equitable grounds. Conceding the debtor’s “actual intent to defraud [its creditors],” the district court in Sentinel IV still upheld the bank’s good faith defense in accepting the pledge of customer securities. Id. at *8.

    Facts

    The debtor investment manager (“Sentinel”) had “marketed itself to its customers as providing a safe place to put their excess capital, assuring solid short-term returns, but also promising ready access to the capital.” Sentinel further “represented that it would maintain customer funds in segregated accounts as required under the Commodity Exchange Act.” Thus, “at all times a customer’s accounts held assets equal to the amount [the debtor] owed the customer, and … [the debtor] treated and dealt with the assets ‘as belonging to such customer.’” 728 F.3d at 662-63. It “maintained segregated accounts [with] assets that could not be subject to any [lender’s] lien.” The bank agreed it had no lien and would “not assert” a “lien against securities held in a Segregated Account.” Although Sentinel was responsible “for keeping assets at appropriate levels of segregation,” the bank’s “main concern was ensuring that [the debtor] had sufficient collateral in the lienable accounts to keep its … loan secured.” Id. at 664.

    Sentinel went through a liquidity crunch during the summer of 2007. In a series of transactions, it moved securities from segregated accounts to “lienable accounts in a series of transactions.” Id. A lienable account, however, could contain only securities and other assets that belonged to Sentinel or that were not subject to segregation. When Sentinel’s “segregation deficit grew to $644 million, [the bank] became suspicious.” A managing director of the bank emailed colleagues involved with the debtor’s accounts, asking how the debtor had “so much collateral? With less than [$2 million] in capital I have to assume that most of this collateral is for somebody else’s benefit. Do we really have rights on the whole $300 MM?” The bank’s officials knew Sentinel “had an agreement that gave the [bank] a lien on any securities in clearing accounts.” By Aug. 13, 2007, Sentinel told its customers “that it was halting redemptions because of problems in the credit market,” causing the bank to cut the debtor’s “remote access to its systems, … [to send] its officials to [the debtor’s] offices, demand … full repayment of the loan and threaten … to liquidate the collateral.” Sentinel then filed a Chapter 11 petition, owing the bank $312 million. Id. at 665.

    The bankruptcy court ordered the appointment of a trustee who later became the post-plan confirmation liquidating trustee. When the bank filed a $312-million secured claim, the trustee sued it in the district court, alleging that Sentinel had “fraudulently used customer assets to finance the loan to cover its house trading activity”; the bank allegedly “knew about it, and, as a result, acted inequitably and unlawfully,” giving rise to fraudulent transfer and equitable subordination claims, including invalidation of the bank’s lien. Id.

    Sentinel V No Good Faith. The Seventh Circuit criticized the district court “on remand” for its failure to “conduct an evidentiary hearing” or make “additional findings.” 2016 WL 98601 at *2. More important, the district court misunderstood “the [bank’s] inquiry notice.” Id. As the Seventh Circuit explained, the bank could not have “been acting in good faith” because it had “inquiry notice.” Id. at *1. “The term signifies awareness of suspicious facts that would have led a reasonable firm, acting diligently, to investigate further and by doing so discover wrongdoing.” Id., citing In re M&L Business Machine Co., 84 F.3d 1330, 1335-38 (10th Cir. 1996); In re Sherman, 67 F.3d 1348, 1355 (8th Cir. 1995); and In re Agricultural Research & Technology Group, Inc., 916 F.2d 528, 535-36 (9th Cir. 1990). In other words, “inquiry notice is not knowledge of fraud or other wrongdoing, but merely knowledge that would lead a reasonable, law-abiding person to inquire further — would make him … suspicious enough to conduct a diligence search for possible dirt.” 2016 WL 98601, at *2.

    The defendant bank, had, as noted, documentary information (e.g., financials) “that should have created the requisite suspicion.” Id. The internal emails, mentioned above, placed “the bank on inquiry notice and thus require[d] it to conduct an investigation of what Sentinel was using to secure a $300 million debt when it had capital of no more than $3 million.” Id. According to the court, the bank had “more than enough” notice of a possible fraud so as to require it to “investigate.” Id. at *3. Indeed, “all that is required to trigger” the duty to investigate was “information that would cause a reasonable person to be suspicious enough to investigate.” Id. The Seventh Circuit stressed that the district court’s fact findings in its original 2010 opinion (Sentinel I) “actually prove inquiry notice.” Id. at *4.

    No Equitable Subordination. The court of appeals affirmed the district court’s holding that the trustee had not proved the defendant bank’s knowledge of Sentinel’s “securing the bank’s loans with customers’ money without their consent.” Id. at *6. “Even though the bank’s secured claim [went] down the drain because it was on inquiry notice of Sentinel’s fraud, it still has an unsecured claim in bankruptcy — a claim for the money it lost when Sentinel failed to repay the bank’s loan to it of $312 million.” Id. at *4-5. According to the court, “the defendant’s conduct must be not only ‘inequitable’ but seriously so (‘egregious,’ ‘tantamount to fraud,’ and ‘willful’ are the most common terms employed) and must harm other creditors.” Id. at *5, citing Carhart v. Carhart-Halaska Int’l, LLC, 788 F.3d 687, 692 (7th Cir. 2015). Although other creditors had been “harmed by the bank’s accepting the accounts of Sentinel’s customers as security for its loan,” that was not tantamount to fraud. The court agreed “with the district judge that the trustee has not satisfied that high standard. To suspect potential wrongdoing yet not bother to seek confirmation of one’s suspicion is negligent, and negligence has not been thought an adequate basis for imposing equitable subordination.” The bank had suspicions and should have followed up, but it was merely negligent.

    Bank Retains Unsecured Claim. Finally, the court rejected two other defenses raised by the bank “to losing its status as a secured creditor.” Although Code Section 550(b)(1) provides a defense to a lender who “gave value for the transfer in good faith,” that provision was inapplicable, for the trustee did not seek to recover assets, but only to avoid the bank’s lien. Nor was the trustee seeking “a double recovery,” for the bank was “still owed Sentinel’s debt to it. It has just lost its security interest.” Id. at *6.

    Comments

    • Rescue lending is still alive despite Sentinel V. The U.S. Supreme Court’s seminal Dean v. Davis decision, 242 U.S. 438, 444-45 (1917), confirms that an arm’s-length, good faith commercial loan will not be undone: Securing a loan to an insolvent debtor for payment of “a pre-existing debt does not necessarily imply an intent to hinder, delay or defraud creditors. The mortgage may be made in the expectation that thereby the debtor will extricate himself from a particular difficulty and be enabled to promote the interests of all other creditors by continuing his business. The lender … may be acting in perfect ‘good faith’ … . It is a question of fact in each case what the intent was with which the loan was sought and made.” The bank in Sentinel V lost its good faith defense because it had inquiry notice and failed to investigate, but still accepted a third party’s property as collateral.
    • The district court’s failure in Sentinel IV, after a 17-day trial, to conduct another “evidentiary hearing” or to make “additional findings” triggered the Seventh Circuit’s reversal. 2016 WL 98601, at *2. Nevertheless, “in fairness to the [district] judge,” the court of appeals conceded that the panel in Sentinel III could have reversed Sentinel I “outright.” Id. at *5. There had been “no need to remand,” it reasoned, due to the district court’s ample findings in Sentinel I that “the bank had … been on inquiry notice.” Id.
    • Another lender successfully relied on the “good faith” defense in the past two years. See Gold v. First Tennessee Bank, N.A., 743 F.3d 423 (4th Cir. 2014) (2-1) (applying “objective good-faith standard”; bank investigated debtor before lending; when debtor offered excuses for non-payment, bank visited collateral “properties,” reviewed records and understood market conditions, consistent with industry practice; bank had no “information” requiring it to “investigate further”).

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney or the author.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • LMA Revises EMEA Secondary Debt Trading Documents

    LMA Revises EMEA Secondary Debt Trading Documents

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    LMA Revises EMEA Secondary Debt Trading Documents

    14 January 2016

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Following recent court decisions, the Loan Market Association (‘LMA’) has updated its Standard Terms and Conditions for Par and Distressed Trade Transactions (Bank/Claims) (‘STC’) and relevant secondary trading documents. The revised documents ‘went live’ on and apply to trades agreed on or after 16 December 2015. The existing LMA secondary documents will continue to apply to all trades undertaken before 16 December 2015 that are subject to LMA terms.

    Allocation of Interest, Recurring Fees/Non-Recurring Fees and Other Fees

    Condition 15.9 of the STC has been updated to address allocations of interest, recurring fees and non-recurring fees between buyers and sellers, where the trade confirmation or the STC does not otherwise address them — for instance, if the parties haven’t chosen an interest treatment in Section 9 of the trade confirmation. In these cases, any accrued interest or recurring fees relating to the period before settlement will be allocated to the seller, and those relating to the period after settlement will be allocated to the buyer. Any non-recurring fees paid or capitalised on or after the trade date will be allocated to the buyer.

    If the buyer or seller receives a payment of interest, recurring fees or non-recurring fees that the other party should have received, it must forward such payment to the other party within two business days of receipt. However, these payments must be paid back to the original party if subsequently clawed back by the agent. Finally, if either party receives a non-cash distribution in satisfaction of an obligation of the debtor to pay interest, recurring fees or non-recurring fees that belongs to the other party pursuant to Condition 15.9, the receiving party shall, as soon as reasonably practicable following receipt of such non-cash distribution (but not before the settlement date), transfer the non-cash distribution to and register it in the name of the other party. (This process is also in line with the amendments to the STC’s non-cash distributions language, discussed below in the Turnover Provisions section.)

    If the parties want to allocate all or any part of the interest, recurring fees or non-recurring fees differently from the allocation in the STC or if the credit documentation includes unusual interest or fees that don’t readily fit within the STC’s relevant definitions, they must agree on how to allocate these amounts at the time of trade and expressly include their agreement in the ‘Other Terms of Trade’ section of the trade confirmation. The UK Supreme Court’s recent holding in Tael One Partners Limited v. Morgan Stanley & Co International PLC [2015] UKSC 12[1] that a loan prepayment premium paid after the settlement date is for the account of the buyer and not for the account of the seller or the seller’s predecessor-in-title underscores the importance of correctly allocating payments that don’t fit within the STC’s definitions.

    The LMA has also updated the definition of recurring fees to include ticking fees. As with other fees that fall under the term ‘Recurring Fees’ in the STC, the credit documentation must expressly refer to ticking fees. As a result, a ticking fee documented in the commitment letter will not fall under ‘Recurring Fees’.

    Turnover Provisions

    The market viewed previous provisions of the STC relating to non-cash distributions as ambiguous, as they could potentially have been interpreted to require the establishment of a trust structure. The new provisions clarify that if the seller receives a non-cash distribution that is for the account of the buyer, the seller must transfer it to and register it in the name of the buyer as soon as reasonably practicable after receiving it.

    The LMA has tried to ensure a consistent approach between trading instruments (i.e. bank debt and claims) by updating Clause 15 (‘Interest Payments and Fees’) as well as Clause 9 (‘Insolvency Proceedings’) regarding the turnover provisions. Now, if a seller receives a distribution that belongs to the buyer, the seller must turn it over within two business days.

    Notarial Fees/Notarial Perfection of Security and Collateral

    Prior to these changes, counterparties had argued that in certain jurisdictions it was unclear who was responsible for paying notarial fees or specific fees associated with loan transfers or collateral perfection. Most market participants believed that the buyer and seller should split such fees. However, the STC and the secondary documents now state which party is responsible for the for payment of these fees at time of trade, splitting them into contractual notarial fees[2] and any other notarial fees associated with the transfer of the Traded Portion. Each type of notarial fee is treated differently by the STC:

    Contractual Notarial Fees

    Contractual notarial fees will be split equally between the buyer and seller. However, each counterparty is only responsible for half of one notarial fee. Therefore if a counterparty is either selling or purchasing via multiple entities, that counterparty is responsible for all of the additional notarial fees due.

    Any Other Notarial Fees

    Any non-contractual notarial fees relating to the purchase or sale of the Traded Portion will be payable by the buyer. If the parties want a different arrangement, they need to agree so at time of trade and reflect the same in the trade confirmation.

    Jurisdictions where parties might encounter notarial fees or similar types of perfection fees for registering security for loans or for transferring claims include France,[3] Spain[4] and Germany.[5]

    Acting as Custodian

    The LMA’s updated documents also clarify that unless otherwise specified in the trade confirmation, a party does not act as a trustee, agent, custodian or fiduciary for the other party.

    Calculating Delayed Settlement Compensation

    Unless the parties agree otherwise at time of trade, delayed settlement compensation applies to trades. Delayed settlement compensation puts the parties in the economic position they would have been in had the trade settled within the LMA’s contemplated settlement timeframe (i.e. T+20 for distressed trades and T+10 for par trades). If the trade settles on a date that is after T+20 for distressed trades and T+10 for par trades (the ‘Delay Period Commencement Date’), the seller must pay the buyer accrued interest up to (but excluding) the settlement date. The buyer must pay the seller the cost of funding the traded portion past the Delay Period Commencement Date (also referred to as ‘Cost of Carry’).

    However, in some instances the seller is required to pay the Cost of Carry to the buyer — when, for example, the interbank offered rate used for the calculation of the Cost of Carry is negative. The LMA has also updated its user guide to explain how a negative interbank offered rate could impact payments of delayed settlement compensation. The guide now offers proposed drafting that parties can include in their trade confirmations to address the issue.

    Authored by David J. Karp, Alexia Petrou and Anthony Lombardi.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.

    We offer clients of the firm access to the SRZ Distressed Debt & Claims Trading Client Resource Center, which contains a frequently updated collection of U.S. and European distressed debt education and training materials. Please contact one of the authors to request access.


    [1] For a detailed account of the case, please see the SRZ Alerts ‘UK Supreme Court Clarifies Allocation of Prepayment Premiums for Debt Traders’ and ‘English High Court Clarifies Post-Settlement Treatment of Interest and Fees for Secondary Market Participants’.

    [2] ‘Contractual notarial fee’ is defined as any notarial fee which must be paid in connection with the purchase or sale of the Traded Portion as an express requirement in the credit agreement (including where such express requirement is exercised at the discretion of the Agent or any other party to the credit agreement). However, counterparties should note that contractual notarial fees exclude any other part of the Purchased Assets and Purchased Obligations or related Collateral posted.

    [3] In order to perfect a transfer of bank debt and/or security in France, the purchaser is required to notify the borrower of the transfer through a French huissier or bailiff. Non-compliance may result in the security being unenforceable against third parties.

    [4] In Spain, a borrower should be notified of a transfer of bank debt. The usual method of notification is to notarise the assignment, which usually allows a new lender to enforce its rights directly against the borrower. Also, in Spain, each piece of security granted over real estate will need to be perfected in accordance with individual local Spanish Public Registries. Where a security is granted in multiple local Spanish Public Registries, this can be very time consuming and costly for a buyer, as each registry may have different fee structures, time frames and local processes for finalising registration.

    [5] In Germany, if a claim is being purchased in an insolvent estate and the insolvency register has already been published, the purchaser will need to ask the court’s permission to update the register. This involves having an assignment agreement notarised (and in some cases apostilled) in order for the court to recognise the perfection of a valid assignment.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Gender Stereotypes and the Biases They Foster Against Women

    ARTICLE

    Gender Stereotypes and the Biases They Foster Against Women

    January 13, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Andrea Kramer was co-author of this bylined article on the gender stereotypes which ascribe to women and men different physical, mental and emotional characteristics. “The problem is that these traditional gender stereotypes operate in virtually all organizations — including law firms — to slow, obstruct and block women’s progress up the career ladder,” the authors wrote. Read the full article.

    Authors
    More insights

  • The SFT Regulation Comes into Effect on 12 January 2016

    The SFT Regulation Comes into Effect on 12 January 2016

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The SFT Regulation Comes into Effect on 12 January 2016

    12 January 2016

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Background and Timing

    Regulation (EU) 2015/2365 on Transparency of Securities Financing Transactions and of Reuse (the ‘SFT Regulation’) has been published in the EU Official Journal and applies from 12 January 2016. As an EU regulation, it applies directly in each EU Member State without the need for local implementing legislation.

    Scope

    The SFT Regulation applies to securities financing transactions (‘SFTs’) and total return swaps (‘TRSs’). An SFT, for these purposes, includes repo transactions, securities or commodities lending or borrowing, buy-sell back or sell-buy back transactions, and margin lending.  

    This Alert describes the provisions of the SFT Regulation that will be of particular relevance to alternative investment fund managers (‘AIFMs’) established in the EU, management companies of Undertakings for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities (‘UCITS’), and firms that provide investment management services to alternative investment funds (‘AIFs’) and UCITS on a delegated basis (collectively, ‘fund managers’).

    Record Keeping

    Article 4(4) of the SFT Regulation requires fund managers to keep a record of all SFTs entered into for their funds. The record-keeping requirements apply in respect of the conclusion, modification and termination of an SFT with effect from 12 January 2016. Fund managers should note that records must be kept for at least five years after an SFT transaction is terminated.

    Initial Investor Disclosure Obligations

    Article 14 of the SFT Regulation sets out certain disclosure requirements in relation to SFTs and TRSs to be included in ‘pre-contractual documents’, defined as prior investor disclosures under Article 23(1) and (3) of the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (‘AIFMD’), and the UCITS prospectus. The rationale for requiring these additional disclosures is to ensure that investors in AIFs and UCITS understand and appreciate the inherent risks of SFTs and TRSs before they invest. The reference to Article 23 of AIFMD indicates that these disclosure obligations will apply only in respect of EU AIFs or those non-EU AIFs that are marketed to EU investors. The prior disclosure obligations will apply to all UCITS funds.

    Funds launched on or after 12 January 2016 will be subject to these disclosure requirements (if applicable) with immediate effect or from the date when the AIFM makes a marketing notification. Funds lunched prior to the entry into force of the SFT Regulation will have until 13 July 2017 to comply with the new disclosure obligations.

    • Section B of the Annex to the SFT Regulation contains a detailed list of information to be disclosed, including:
    • General description of the SFT and TRS used and the rationale for their use;
    • Overall data for each type of SFT and total return swap, such as the type of assets that can be subject to them, and the maximum and expected proportion of the fund’s assets under management that will be subject to them;  
    • Selection criteria for SFT and TRS counterparties (including legal status, country of origin and minimum credit rating);
    • Description of acceptable collateral with regard to asset types, issuer, maturity, liquidity, diversification and correlation policies;
    • Collateral valuation methodology used and its rationale, and whether daily mark-to-market and daily variation margin is used;
    • Description of risks linked to SFTs and total return swaps and collateral management, including matters such as operational, liquidity, counterparty, custody and legal risks and, where applicable, the risks arising from the right of reuse of collateral;
    • Description of how assets subject to SFT and TRS, and collateral received are safe-kept (e.g. with fund custodian);
    • Description of any restrictions (regulatory or self-imposed) on the right of reuse of collateral; and
    • Policy on the sharing of any return generated by SFTs and TRSs, including proportion of revenue paid to the fund, and costs and fees assigned to the manager and third parties (e.g. lending agent).

    Article 14(3) empowers the European Securities and Markets Authority (‘ESMA’) to develop technical standards specifying the content of these disclosures in order to reflect any evolving market practices and to ensure uniform disclosure of data by fund managers. It is not clear when, if at all, such technical standards may be produced by ESMA.

    Fund managers should consider whether the description of the investment policy, risk factors, custody arrangements and the fund’s counterparties in the existing fund offer documentation include sufficient detail to address the new obligations and should prepare additional disclosures, as appropriate. It is not currently clear whether any changes to the above information could simply be disclosed to investors as an update to the fund offer documentation, or whether these changes would also need to be notified to the regulator, as in the case of the AIFMD leverage limits disclosure, for example.

    Periodic Investor Disclosure Obligations

    The following information, specified in Section A of the Annex to the SFT Regulation, will need to be included in the AIF annual reports and UCITS half-yearly and annual reports published after 13 January 2017:

    • Global data: (1) the amount of securities and commodities on loan as a proportion of total lendable assets; and (2) the amount of assets engaged in each type of SFT and TRS expressed both as an absolute amount and as a proportion of the fund’s assets under management;
    • Concentration data: (1) 10 largest collateral providers across all SFTs and TRSs (with a breakdown of volumes of the collateral received per provider); (2) top 10 counterparties for each type of SFT and TRS separately (name of counterparty and gross volume of outstanding transactions);
    • Aggregate transaction data for each type of SFT and TRS separately broken down by: (1) type and quality of collateral; (2) maturity tenor; (3) currency; (4) maturity tenor of the SFTs and TRSs; (5) country where the counterparty is established; and (6) settlement and clearing (e.g. central counterparty cleared or bilateral).
    • Data on reuse of collateral: (1) share of collateral received that is reused compared with the maximum limits specified in the initial disclosure made to investors; and (2) cash collateral reinvestment returns to the fund;
    • Safekeeping of collateral received as part of SFTs and TRSs (e.g. with the fund custodian);
    • Safekeeping of collateral granted as part of SFTs and TRSs (e.g. how the assets pledged as collateral will be treated by the prime broker or another counterparty); and
    • Data on return and cost for each type of SFT and TRS.

    As with the initial disclosure obligations above, ESMA may, in time, develop regulatory technical standards with further detail of the content of such reports. When preparing such regulatory technical standards, ESMA will be required to take account of the administrative burdens and the specific characteristics of the different types of SFT and TRS.

    Transaction Reporting

    The SFT Regulation imposes an obligation to report SFTs to trade repositories and specifies that, in the case of AIFs and UCITS, the obligation to report falls on the manager (rather than on the fund, as the counterparty to an SFT). Fund managers will be able to delegate reporting to their counterparties.

    Details of the information reported will be specified in the regulatory technical standards (‘Reporting RTS’) to be developed by ESMA in cooperation with the European Systemic Risk Board by 12 January 2017. The reporting start dates for each category of counterparty specified in the SFT Regulation will be dependent upon the date of the entry into force of the delegated act adopting the Reporting RTS. Fund managers will be subject to reporting 18 months following the entry into force of that delegated act.

    Authored by Anna Maleva-Otto and Ron Feldman.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • A Look at FTC Challenge of Chicago-Area Hospital Merger

    ARTICLE

    A Look at FTC Challenge of Chicago-Area Hospital Merger

    January 8, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Ashley Fischer and David Marx Jr. wrote this bylined article about the FTC’s administrative complaint challenging the proposed combination of Advocate Health Care Network and NorthShore University Health System in the Chicago area. “The complaint against Advocate and NorthShore generally follows the FTC’s playbook from prior complaints, but the parties’ alleged combined market share and the post-merger market concentration are the lowest of the hospital merger challenges brought by the FTC in recent years,” the authors wrote. Read the full article (subscription required).

    Authors

    Ashley M. Fischer

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Product Recalls

    ARTICLE

    Product Recalls

    Winter 2015-16

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Marc Sorini wrote this bylined article about product recall issues facing distillers. “Even the best companies cannot prevent every potential hazard, many of which may arise from circumstances (e.g., the purchase of defective bottles) entirely outside the distiller’s control,” Mr. Sorini wrote, but he added that distillers can “reduce the stress level and help navigate this ‘worst-case’ scenario by understanding the process and taking certain steps to prepare.” Read the full article.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Governance Challenges When Gatekeepers are “Chilled”

    Governance Challenges When Gatekeepers are “Chilled”

    ARTICLE

    Governance Challenges When Gatekeepers are “Chilled”

    January 7, 2016

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

     

    In depth

    Michael Peregrine wrote this bylined article on the governance challenges from new federal enforcement initiatives toward corporate officials. Mr. Peregrine warned that the risk from these initiatives “may cause some gatekeepers and other corporate officials to be much more self-protective in performing their corporate and fiduciary responsibilities, to the possible detriment of strategic implementation. Attentive boards will acknowledge this challenge and engage its gatekeepers in an appropriate resolution.” Read the full article.

    Authors
    More insights